• Nie Znaleziono Wyników

Comparison of clustering accuracy in ensemble approach based on co-occurence data

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Comparison of clustering accuracy in ensemble approach based on co-occurence data"

Copied!
8
0
0

Pełen tekst

(1)

/,+&! ,(",%,0&"! 1234 1565 !"!#$%&!'()*+%

!"#$%&'!()!*) +,'-.%&(/)$ ,%$ 0))

&().('."1+.)$##%!$ 2)1$'.3))

!() !4! ,%.( .)3$-$)

) )

$1'-%$ -5)(789:;<9 =>>?@=AB B=8 ;997 8CAA988DC<<E =>><F9G F7 HB9 A@7H9IH @D 8C>9?JF89G

<9=?7F7K H@ F7A?9=89 HB9 =AAC?=AE =7G 8H=;F<FHE @D A<=88FDFA=HF@7L )9A97H<E4 =7=<@K@C8 H9AB7FMC98 D@? A<C8H9? =7=<E8F8 B=J9 ;997 8CKK98H9GL )989=?AB B=8 >?@J9G HB=H4 ;E A@:;F7F7K = A@<<9AHF@7 @D GFDD9?97H A<C8H9?F7K84 =7 F:>?@J9G 8@<CHF@7 A=7 ;9 @;H=F79GL

&7 HB9 H?=GFHF@7=< N=E @D <9=?7F7K D?@: HB9 G=H= 89H HB9 A<=88FDF9?8 =?9 ;CF<H F7 = D9=HC?9 8>=A9L O@N9J9?4 =7 =<H9?7=HFJ9 N=E A=7 ;9 D@C7G ;E A@78H?CAHF7K G9AF8F@7 ?C<98 @7 GF88F:F<=?FHE ?9>?9897H=HF@78L &7 8CAB = ?9A@K7FHF@7 >?@A988 9=AB @;P9AH F8 G98A?F;9G ;E = :=H?FI 8B@NF7K HB9 8F:F<=?FHF98 @? GF8H=7A98 H@ HB9 ?98H @D H?=F7F7K 8=:><98L

#BF8 ?989=?AB B=8 D@AC89G @7 9I><@FHF7K HB9 =GGFHF@7=< F7D@?:=HF@7 >?@JFG9G ;E = A@<<9AHF@7 @D GFJ9?89 A<C8H9?F7K8 H@ K979?=H9 = A@Q=88@AF=HF@7 RA@Q@AAC??97A9S :=H?FI R/?9G =7G T=F74 1551SL #=UF7K HB9 A@Q@AAC??97A98 @D >=F?8 @D >=HH9?78 F7 HB9 8=:9 A<C8H9? =8 J@H98 D@? HB9F? =88@AF=HF@74 HB9 G=H= >=?HFHF@78 =?9 :=>>9G F7H@ = A@Q=88@AF=HF@7 :=H?FI @D >=HH9?78L #BF8 7 V 7 :=H?FI ?9>?9897H8 = 79N 8F:F<=?FHE :9=8C?9 ;9HN997 >=HH9?78L #B9 DF7=< G=H= >=?HFHF@7 F8 @;H=F79G ;E A<C8H9?F7K HBF8 :=H?FIL &7 HB9 9I>9?F:97H84 HB9 ;9B=JF@? @D >=?HFHF@78 ;CF<H @7 A@Q@AAC??97A9 G=H= NFHB GFDD9?97H A<C8H9?F7K :9HB@G8 F8 8HCGF9GL

678) 9:;<=> "<C8H9? =7=<E8F84 "<C8H9? 9789:;<94 "@Q=88@AF=HF@7 :=H?FI4 R-F8S8F:F<=?FHE

?9>?9897H=HF@7L

)

&5)&(-%!3, -&!()

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

(2)

-@?@H= )@^:C8

6_`

;9HH9? ?98C<H8L !:@7K HB9 :@8H >@>C<=? :9HB@G8 HB9?9 =?9 9KL /$00120 ;=89G @7 ;@@H8H?=> 8=:><98 RW?9F:=74 6XXYS =7G /!!*#120 ;=89G @7 KFJF7K BFKB9? N9FKBH8 H@ HB9 N?@7K A<=88FDF9G 9I=:><98 R/?9C7G4 6XX5SL

)9A97H<E4 9789:;<9 =>>?@=AB D@? A<C8H9? =7=<E8F8 B=8 ;997 8CKK98H9G F7 @?G9? H@ F7A?9=89 HB9 A<=88FDFA=HF@7 =AAC?=AE =7G ?@;C8H7988 @D HB9 A<C8H9?F7K 8@<CHF@78L #B9 :=F7 FG9= @D =KK?9K=HF@7 F8 H@ A@:;F79 @CH>CH8 @D 89J9?=< A<C8H9?F7K8L #B9 >?@;<9: @D A<C8H9?F7K DC8F@7 A=7 ;9 G9DF79G K979?=<<E =8 D@<<@N8Z KFJ97 :C<HF><9 >=?HFHF@78 @D HB9 G=H= 89H4 DF7G = A@:;F79G A<C8H9?F7K NFHB = ;9HH9? MC=<FHEL )9A97H<E 89J9?=< 8HCGF98 @7 A<C8H9?F7K A@:;F7=HF@7 :9HB@G8 B=J9 >F@799?9G = 79N =?9= F7 HB9 A@7J97HF@7=< H=I@7@:E R/?9G4 1551a /?9G =7G T=F74 1551a T=F7 ,#% $-L4 6XXXa *H?9B< =7G b@8B4 1551SL #B9?9 =?9 89J9?=< >@88F;<9 N=E8 H@ C89 HB9 FG9= @D 9789:;<9 =>>?@=AB F7 HB9 A@7H9IH @D C78C>9?JF89G <9=?7F7KZ R6S A@:;F79 ?98C<H8 @D GFDD9?97H A<C8H9?F7K =<K@?FHB:8a R1S >?@GCA9 GFDD9?97H >=?HFHF@78 ;E ?98=:><F7K HB9 G=H=4 8CAB =8 F7 ;@@H8H?=>>F7K H9AB7FMC984 9KL /$00120a R2S C89 GFDD9?97H 8C;89H8 @D D9=HC?98 RHB=H A=7 ;9 GF8P@F7H @? @J9?<=>>F7KSa RcS ?C7 = KFJ97 =<K@?FHB: :=7E HF:98 NFHB GFDD9?97H >=?=:9H9?8 @? F7FHF=<F^=HF@78L

) )

&&5)-2.)$+/!%&-2")

&7 HBF8 ?989=?AB HB9 <=8H =>>?@=AB F8 H=U97 H@ 8@:9 9IH97GL b979?=<<E4 HBF8 ?989=?AB B=8 HB?99 8@C?A98L #B9 DF?8H F8 >?@>@89G ;E \9U=<8U= =7G -CF7 R1555S GF88F:F<=?FHE ;=89G =>>?@=ABL &7 HB9 A@7J97HF@7=< N=E @D <9=?7F7K D?@: 9I=:><98 @D @;89?J=HF@78 HB9 A<=88FDF9? F8 ;CF<H F7 = D9=HC?9 8>=A9L O@N9J9?4 =7 =<H9?7=HFJ9 N=E A=7 ;9 D@C7G ;E A@78H?CAHF7K G9AF8F@7 ?C<98 @7 GF88F:F<=?FHE ?9>?9897H=HF@78L &7 8CAB = ?9A@K7FHF@7 >?@A988 9=AB @;P9AH F8 G98A?F;9G ;E FH8 GF8H=7A98 R@? 8F:F<=?FHF98S H@ HB9 ?98H @D H?=F7F7K 8=:><98L "<=88FDF9? F8 ;CF<H @7 HBF8 GF88F:F<=?FHE ?9>?9897H=HF@7 HB=H F8 @7 = :=H?FI G98A?F;F7K 8F:F<=?FHF98 ;9HN997 C89G 9I=:><98 @D @;P9AH8 D@? H?=F7F7KL #B9 89A@7G 8@C?A9 F8 >?@>@89G ;E /?9G =7G T=F7 R1551S HB9 FG9= @D A@:;F7=HF@7 @D A<C8H9?F7K ?98C<H8 >9?D@?:9G ;E H?=78D@?:F7K G=H= >=?HFHF@78 F7H@ = A@Q@AAC??97A9 :=H?FI NBFAB 8B@N8 A@B9?97H =88@AF=HF@78L #BF8 :=H?FI F8 HB97 C89G =8 = GF8H=7A9 :=H?FI H@ 9IH?=AH HB9 DF7=< >=?HFHF@78L #B9 HBF?G 8@C?A9 F8 >?@JFG9G ;E ]C7AB9J=4 O=GPFH@G@?@J =7G #@G@?@J= R155YS ?989=?AB NB9?9 HB9E K@H J9?E >?@:F8F7K ?98C<H8 NFHB GF88F:F<=?FHE ?9>?9897H=HF@7 H?9=H9G =8 = G=H= :=H?FIL O9?9 8F:F<=? 8><FH =7G :9?K9 =>>?@=AB F8 C89GL #B9 >=?HFAC<=? 8H9>8 @D HB9 =<K@?FHB: =?9 =8 D@<<@N8Z

*?;=@)=@7A)4)=AB?@L /@? = DFI9G 7C:;9? @D A<C8H9? 9789:;<9 :9:;9?8 3 A<C8H9? HB9 G=H= C8F7K 9KL HB9 4Q:9=78 =<K@?FHB:4 NFHB GFDD9?97H A<C8H9?F7K ?98C<H8 @;H=F79G ;E ?=7G@: F7FHF=<F^=HF@78 @D HB9 =<K@?FHB:L

'7C:D<)=@7A)4)C:EF?D7L #B9 C7G9?<EF7K =88C:>HF@7 F8 HB=H >=HH9?78 ;9<@7KF7K H@ = d7=HC?=<d A<C8H9? =?9 J9?E <FU9<E H@ ;9 A@Q<@A=H9G F7 HB9 8=:9 A<C8H9? =:@7K HB989

(3)

A<C8H9? =8 J@H98 D@? HB9F? =88@AF=HF@74 HB9 G=H= >=?HFHF@78 >?@GCA9G ;E 3 ?C78 @D 4Q :9=78 =?9 :=>>9G F7H@ = 2 2A@Q=88@AF=HF@7 :=H?FIZ $/ 5!#,* / $ $**!6 6!f R 4 S! 4 R6S NB9?9 5!#,* F8 HB9 7C:;9? @D HF:98 NB97 HB9 >=F? @D >=HH9?78 R=4 ;S F8 =88FK79G H@ $/ HB9 8=:9 A<C8H9? =:@7K HB9 3 A<C8H9?F7K8L

-G?;<) =@7A) 4) E7;H7L &7 @?G9? H@ ?9A@J9? DF7=< A<C8H9?84 =>><E =7E H=I@7@:FA =<K@?FHB: @J9? HBF8 A@Q=88@AF=HF@7 :=H?FI H?9=H9G =8 GF88F:F<=?FHE ?9>?9897H=HF@7 @D HB9 @?FKF7=< G=H=L

#B9 FG9= @D 9789:;<9 =>>?@=AB F8 B9?9 C89G F7 HB9 >B=89 @D >?9>=?F7K HB9 G=H= HB=H 8B@C<G ;9 A<C8H9?9G 7@H F7 A<C8H9?F7K F::9GF=H9<EL #B9?9 F8 >?9>=?9G = 8>9AF=< G=H= G98A?F>HF@7 ;E C8F7K =7 =KK?9K=H9G =>>?@=AB =7G HBF8 :=H?FI F8 HB97 A<C8H9?9G ;E 8F7K<9 ?C7 @D HB9 A<C8H9?F7K =<K@?FHB: RF<<C8H?=H9G @7 /FKC?96LSL ! ! ! ! ! " " " " " # # # # # $ $ $ $ $ % % % % %

& & & & &

! " # $ % & ! " # $ % & ! " # $ % & ! " # $ % & ! " # $ % & '()*+,-. '()*+,-.! '()*+,-." '()*+,-.# '/0/'')-,1',.23+-45 ! " # $ % & ! " # $ % & '/0/'')-,1',.23+-45

/FKL 6L "@78H?CAHF@7 @D HB9 A@Q@AAC?97A9 :=H?FI =7G HB9F? DF7=< >=?HFHF@7F7K

*@C?A9Z @N7 N@?UL

) )

&&&5)."#&%& $+)%.',+-')

#B9 =F: @D 9:>F?FA=< 9I>9?F:97H8 N=8 H@ A@:>=?9 HB9 =;F<FHE H@ ?9A@K7F^9 HB9 ?FKBH A<=88 8H?CAHC?9 @D HB9 >?@>@89G A<C8H9? 9789:;<9 =>>?@=AB NFHB C8F7K HN@ A<C8H9? =<K@?FHB:8 D@? HB9F? A@78H?CAHF@7 =7G HB9F? <=H9? >=?HFHF@7F7K NFHB GFDD9?97H =<K@?FHB:8L

&7 HB9 8H9> @D ;CF<GF7K HB9 A@Q@AAC??97A9 :=H?FI HB9?9 N9?9 C89G 4Q:9=78

=<K@?FHB: =7G G9J9<@>9G ;E W9^G9U R6X`6S 6Q:9=784 NBFAB F8 HB9 DC^^E J9?8F@7 @D

HB9 4Q:9=78 =<K@?FHB:L #B9 7C:;9? @D A<C8H9? 9789:;<9 :9:;9?8 3 N=8 89H H@ 9MC=< 654 =7G HB9 J=<C98 @D >=?=:9H9?8 6% =7G 4 N9?9 9MC=< H@ HB9 7C:;9? @D A<=88L 6()*+,-417. 3(7/-4+82. 9413(. :3-+4+4/1417.

(4)

-@?@H= )@^:C8 6`5 !88C:F7K HB9 ?FKBH 7C:;9? @D A<=8898 D@? 6 =7G 4%>=?=:9H9?8 F8 @DH97 C89G =>>?@=AB ;E HB9 ?989=?AB9?8 D?@: HB9 DF9<G @D H=I@7@:EL !:@7K C89G :9HB@G8 D@? DC?HB9? >=?HFHF@7F7K @D HB9 A@Q@AAC?97A9 :=H?FI HB9?9 N9?9Z 4Q:9=784 6Q:9=784 >=?HFHF@7 =:@7K :9G@FG8 R4Q:9G@FG8S4 NBFAB F8 = :@?9 ?@;C8H J9?8F@7 @D 4Q:9=78 R)@C8899CN =7G ]=CD:=774 6XX5S =7G A<=?=4 NBFAB

A@:>=?9G H@ @HB9? >=?HFHF@7F7K :9HB@G8 8CAB =8 4Q:9G@FG8 A=7 G9=< NFHB :CAB

<=?K9? G=H=89H8 R)@C8899CN =7G ]=CD:=746XX5SL !8 = :9=8C?9 @D A@??9AH7988 @D HB9 =<K@?FHB: = >@>C<=? )=7G &7G9I N=8 C89G R)=7G4 6X_6SL 0@8H A@:>CH=HF@78 N9?9 :=G9 F7 %6L !:@7K C89G =<K@?FHB:8 HB9?9 N9?9 U:9=78 D?@: <F;?=?E *#$#*4 A:9=78 D?@: <F;?=?E ,78974 >=: =7G A<=?= =<K@?FHB:8 D?@: <F;?=?E 6-)*#,"L

&7 HB9 ?989=?AB HB9?9 N9?9 C89G ?9=< =7G =?HFDFAF=< K979?=H9G G=H= 89H84 HB9F? 8B@?H AB=?=AH9?F8HFA8 =?9 8B@N7 F7 HB9 #=;<9 6L #=;L 6L -=H= 89H8 C89G F7 HB9 9I>9?F:97H8 -=H= 89H g @D @;P9AH8 g @D J=?F=;<98 g @D A<=88 :!*#!2% 35Y 62 c ;6!-1% 22Y ` ` <-$**% 16c 65 Y 3$**121% 355 1 2 3)/!1=*% 355 2 c >?$@,*% 355 1 c >(1-,A% 355 1 c *@C?A9Z @N7 N@?UL #B9 DF?8H HB?99 =?9 ?9=< G=H= =7G HB9 ?98H =?9 =?HFDFAF=< K979?=H9G 89H8L !:@7K HB9 ?9=< G=H= HB9?9 N9?9 C89G 89H8 HB=H =?9 C8C=<<E =>><F9G F7 A<=88FDFA=HF@7 D@? :@G9< ;CF<GF7K =7G FH8 9J=<C=HF@7L #B989 =?9 G=H= 89H8 NB9?9 HB9 @;P9AHh8 A<=88 =GB9?97A9 F8 U7@N7L #BF8 F7D@?:=HF@7 F8 H?9=H9G =8 =7 $%@"1!"1 F7D@?:=HF@7 =;@CH HB9 7C:;9? @D

A<C8H9?8L *CAB =7 =>>?@=AB F8 =<8@ @DH97 C89G ;E ?989=?AB98 D?@: HB9 DF9<G @D H=I@7@:EL #B9 >?9897H9G ?9=< G=H= 89H8 =?9 C8C=<<E C89G F7 ;97AB:=?UF7K ?989=?AB98 F7 A<=88FDFA=HF@74 =7G HB9E =?9 :=G9 =J=F<=;<9 ;E $"& )9>@8FH@?E RW<=U9 ,#% $-L4

6X``SL !:@7K =?HFDFAF=< K979?=H9G G=H=4 HB9?9 N9?9 89H8 HB=H =?9 C8C=<<E C89G F7 A@:>=?=HFJ9 8HCGF98 F7 H=I@7@:EL #B9F? 8H?CAHC?9 F8 >?9897H9G @7 /FKC?9 1L #B9

3$**121B%>?$@,*%=7G >(1-,A =?9 HN@ GF:978F@7=< G=H= 89H8 NFHB A<9=?<E 89>=?=H9G

A<=88984 HB9 3)/!1=* F8 = >?@;<9: NB9?9 HB9?9 =?9 C7FD@?:<E GF8H?F;CH9G @7

= 2QGF:978F@7=< 8>=A9 NFHBF7 2 AC;@FG8 =7G = 8:=<< AC;9 F7 HB9 :FGG<9 @D HB9:L

(5)

0 ;$ 0 ;< 0<;$ <;< <;$ ;< 0! 0 < ! =3-. <;<<;! <;#<;% <;> ;< < ;< < ;! < ;# < ;% < ;> ;< < ;< < ;! < ;# < ;% < ;> ;< =3-.! <;<<;! <;#<;%<;> ;< <;<<;! <;#<;%<;> ;< < ;< < ;! < ;# < ;% < ;> ;< =3-." 0 ;$ 0 ;< 0<;$ <;< <;$ ;< ;$ !;< 0! 0 < ! 0 ;< 0<;$ <;< <;$ ;< 0 ;< 0< ;$ < ;< < ;$ ;< /FKL 1L !?HFDFAF=< K979?=H9G G=H= 89H8a C>>9? j 3$**121%=7G%3)/!1=*4 ;@HH@: j >?$@,* =7G >(1-,A *@C?A9Z @N7 N@?UL

+@@UF7K =H HB9 9:>F?FA=< ?98C<H8 R#=;<9 1S FH A=7 ;9 7@HFA9G HB=H NB97 =8 = :9HB@G D@? A@Q@AAC??97A9 :=H?FI A@78H?CAHF@7 HB9 4Q:9=78 :9HB@G N=8 AB@8974

HB97 HB9 ;98H :9HB@G D@? HB9F? <=HH9? >=?HFHF@7F7K F8 4Q:9=78L kCFH9 K@@G ?98C<H8 A=7

;9 =<8@ @;H=F79G NFHB A<=?= =<K@?FHB:L &7 HC?7 6Q:9=78 F8 7@H ?9A@::97G9G F7 HBF8

A=89L

lB97 HB9 A@Q@AAC?97A9 :=H?FI N=8 A@78H?CAH9G ;E :9=78 @D 6Q:9=78 =<K@?FHB:4

HB97 F7 HB?99 A=898 HB9 ;98H :9HB@G D@? HB9 DF7=< >=?HFHF@7F7K F8 HB9 4C:9=78

=<K@?FHB:4 =7G F7 HB?99 A=898 j >=: =7G A<=?=L !K=F7 FH A=7 ;9 7@HFA9G HB=H 6Q:9=78

(6)

-@?@H= )@^:C8

6`1

#=;L 1L '=<C98 @D )=7G &7G9I

0=H?FI U:9=78 A:9=78 U:9=78 A:9=78 U:9=78 A:9=78 U:9=78 A:9=78

"<C8H9? =<K@?FHB: -=H= 89H

U:9=78 U:9=78 A:9=78 A:9=78 >=: >=: A<=?= A<=?=

3$**121 54_X6 54X_2 54_X6 54X_6 54_`c 54X_1 54_`c 54X_1

3)/!1=* 54X6` 54X2X 54X6Y 54`_c 54X63 54`_Y 54X63 54`_Y

>(1-,A 54Y_3 54X52 54`1c 54`_3 54X`6 54`_X 54X`6 54_`X

>?$@,* 54`c3 54XX_ 54XX` 54XX_ 54XX_ 54XX` 54XXX 54XX_

:!*#!2 54Y`5 54Y11 54Y62 54Y6_ 54Y33 54Y_3 54YY` 54Y_3

;6!-1 54`1c 54_`1 54_XX 54_`` 54_`` 54_XY 54`5X 54_XY

<-$** 54Y__ 54_5Y 54_6c 54_65 54_6` 54_1c 54_6` 54_1c

*@C?A9Z @N7 A@:>CH=HF@78L

+@@UF7K D?@: HB9 >@F7H @D JF9N @D AB@897 H=I@7@:FA =<K@?FHB: D@? HB9 DF7=< >=?HFHF@7F7K FH A=7 ;9 8997 HB=H D@? 4C:9=78 =7G 4Q:9G@FG8 =<K@?FHB:8 HB9 ;98H ?98C<H8

A=7 ;9 @;H=F79G NB97 HB9 A@Q@AAC??97A9 :=H?FI N=8 A@78H?CAH9G NFHB 6Q:9=78

:9HB@GL /@? 6Q:9=78 =7G A<=?= =<K@?FHB:8 =7 =:;FKCFHE @D HB9 ?98C<H8 A=7 ;9

7@HFA9GL

)

&I5)',""$%0)

#@ 8C: C> FH F8 N@?HB H@ 7@HFA9 HB=H AB@@8F7K = K@@G H=I@7@:FA :9HB@G F8 :CAB :@?9 GFDDFAC<H HB=7 AB@@8F7K = K@@G A<=88FDF9?L &H F8 8@ ;9A=C89 F7 GF8A?F:F7=HF@7 HB9?9 F8 = 8FHC=HF@7 NB9?9 A<=88 :9:;9?8BF> D@? HB9 @;89?J=HF@78 F8 U7@N7 F7 =GJ=7A9a HB9?9 F8 = >?@;<9: @D 8C>9?JF89G <9=?7F7KL &7 HB9 H=I@7@:E @7 HB9 @HB9? B=7G4 HB9 A<=88 =GB9?97A9 D@? @;P9AH8 F87hH U7@N7 8@ HB9 ?FKBH 8H?CAHC?9 HB=H 8B@C<G ;9 D@C7G ;E HB9 =<K@?FHB: F8 C7U7@N7L *@4 F7 @?G9? H@ @:FH HB9 ?F8U @D = N?@7K =<K@?FHB: 89<9AHF@74 HB9 9789:;<9 =>>?@=AB A=7 ;9 C89G F7 @?G9? H@ A@:;F79 8@:9 @D HB9:L *F7A9 9=AB @D GFDD9?97H A<C8H9?F7K :9HB@G8 B=8 GFDD9?97H 8H?97KHB8 =7G N9=U798898 FH A=7 ;9 9I>9AH9G HB=H HB9F? P@F7H A@7H?F;CHF@7 NF<< B=J9 = A@:>978=H@?E 9DD9AHL

#B9 79IH =GJ=7H=K9 @D HBF8 =>>?@=AB F8 HB9 >@88F;F<FHE H@ :=U9 HB9 ?98C<H8 F7G9>97G97H D?@: 89<9AH9G :9HB@G8 @? 8@:9 HB9F? >=?=:9H9?84 9KL HB9 F7FHF=< J=<C98 @D

HB9 4 >=?=:9H9? D@? 4Q:9=78 =<K@?FHB:L #BF8 :9=78 HB=H =KK?9K=HF@7 :=U9 FH >@88F;<9

H@ 8H=;F<F^9 HB9 ?98C<H8 @D A<C8H9?F7K 8@<CHF@78L

#B9 79IH 8H?97KHB @D =7 9789:;<9 =>>?@=AB F8 ?@;C8H7988a HBF8 :9=78 <@N9? 8978FHFJFHE H@ 7@F894 @CH<F9?8 =7G 8=:><F7K J=?F=;F<FHEL

!7G HB9 <=8H A@7A<C8F@78 HB=H D<@N8 D?@: HB9 9:>F?FA=< 9I>9?F:97H8 =?9 HB=H NB97 HB9 A@Q@AAC??97A9 :=H?FI F8 A@78H?CAH9G ;E :9=78 @D 4Q:9=78 =<K@?FHB: HB97

(7)

@AAC??97A9 :=H?FI >?9>=?9G ;E 6Q:9=78 HB9 ;98H :9HB@G8 =?9 4Q:9=784 >=: =7G

A<=?=L /?@: HB9 >@F7H @D JF9N @D AB@897 A<=88FDFA=HF@7 :9HB@G D@? 4C:9=78 =7G >=:

HB9 ;98H :9HB@G D@? A@Q@AAC??97A9 :=H?FI A@78H?CAHF@7 F8 6Q:9=784 F7 HC?7 D@? 6Q

:9=78 =7G A<=?= A<=88FDFA=HF@7 :9HB@G8 HB9 ?98C<H8 =?9 7@H 8H?=FKBHD@?N=?GL

) ) %.*.%.( .')

W9^G9U TL "L R6X`6S4 D$##,"2% &,6!021#1!2% E1#?% F)''A% G/H,6#15,% F)26#1!2% I-0!"1#?(*4 \<97C:4 %9N n@?UL

W<=U9 "L4 ]9@KB (L4 09?^ "L TL R6X``S4 J3K%&,@!*1#!"A%!L%M$6?12,%N,$"2120% $#$/$*,*B% -9>=?H:97H @D &7D@?:=HF@7 =7G "@:>CH9? *AF97A94 $7FJ9?8FHE @D "=<FD@?7F=4 &?JF79L

W?9F:=7 +L R6XXYS4 W=KKF7K \?9GFAH@?84 M$6?12,%N,$"21204 1Y R1SZ 612 j 6c5L

/?9G !L R1551S4 /F7GF7K "@78F8H97H "<C8H9?8 F7 -=H= \=?HFHF@784 F7 )@<F /L4 ]FHH<9? TL4 9GFH@?84 D"!6,,=120*% !L%#?,%K2#,"2$#1!2$-%O!"4*?!@%!2%M)-#1@-,%3-$**1L1,"%>A*#,(*4 >=K98Z 25X Q 26`4 +%"L

/?9G !L4 T=F7 !L ]L R1551S4 -=H= "<C8H9?F7K $8F7K (JFG97A9 !AAC:C<=HF@74 D"!6,,=120*%!L%#?,%>1P#,,2#?% K2#,"2$#1!2$-%3!2L,",26,%!2%D$##,"2%&,6!021#1!24 >=K98 1_YQ1`54 &"\)4 "=7=G=L

T=F7 !L4 0C?HE 0L % =7G /<E77 \L R6XXXS4 -=H= "<C8H9?F7KZ ! )9JF9N4%I3M%3!(@)#120%>)"5,A*B%26 R2SZ 1Yc j 212L

]=CD:=7 +L4 )@C8899CN \L TL R6XX5S4% F12=120% <"!)@*% 12% $#$Q% I2% K2#"!=)6#1!2% #!% 3-)*#,"% I2$-A*1*B lF<9E4 %9N n@?UL

/?9C7G nL R6XX5S4 W@@8HF7K = N9=U <9=?7F7K =<K@?FHB: ;E :=P@?FHEL D"!6,,=120*%!L%#?,%R?1"=%I22)$-% O!"4*?!@%!2%3!(@)#$#1!2$-%N,$"2120%R?,!"A4 >=K98Z 151 j 16YL

]C7AB9J= +L &L4 O=GPFH@G@?@J *L #L4 #@G@?@J= +L \L R155YS4 (I>9?F:97H=< "@:>=?F8@7 @D "<C8H9? (789:;<9 09HB@G84 S12,#,,2#?% K2#,"2$#1!2$-% 3!2L,",26,% !2% K2L!"($#1!2% F)*1!24 >=K98Z 6 Q _4 /<@?97A9L

\9U=<8U= (L4 -CF7 )L \L lL R1555S4 "<=88FDF9?8 D@? -F88F:F<=?FHEQ;=89G \=HH9?7 )9A@K7FHF@74 F7 *=7D9<FC !L4 'F<<=7C9J= TL T4 '=7?9<< 0L4 !<MC9^=? )L4 T=F7 !L ]L =7G ]FHH<9? TL4 9GFH@?84 D"!6,,=120*% !L% #?,% F1L#,,2#?% K2#,"2$#1!2$-% 3!2L,",26,% !2% D$##,"2% &,6!021#1!24 >=K98Z 61 Q 6Y4 &((( "@:>CH9? *@AF9HE \?9884 +@8 !<=:FH@8L

)=7G lL 0L R6X_6S4 ,;P9AHFJ9 A?FH9?F= D@? HB9 9J=<C=HF@7 @D A<C8H9?F7K :9HB@G84 T!)"2$-%!L%#?,% I(,"16$2%>#$#1*#16$-%I**!61$#1!24 YYZ `cY j `35L

*H?9B< !L4 bB@8B TL R1551S4 "<C8H9? (789:;<98 Q ! ]7@N<9GK9 )9C89 /?=:9N@?U D@? "@:;F7F7K 0C<HF><9 \=?HFHF@784 T!)"2$-%!L%M$6?12,%N,$"2120%&,*,$"6?4 2Z 3`2 Q Y6`L

#8E:;=< !L4 \9AB97F^UFE 0L4 "C77F7KB=: \L R1552S4 15,"*1#A% 12% ;2*,(/-,% F,$#)",% >,-,6#1!2B #9AB7FA=< )9>@?H4 #?F7FHE "@<<9K9 -C;<F7L

!"!#$%&!'()*%

#!%JK($(&.)3!6L$3(!M &)".-!3)-$6'!(!"& N(0 2)K)#!3.OM &,) K&.+!"!3.+!K0")!#$%-0")($)"$ &.%N0)K'#JLK0'-P#&.Q)

)

\@G9PoAF9 NF9<@:@G9<@N9 G@HEABA^=8 ^ GCpE: >@N@G^97F9: 8H@8@N=79 ;Eq@ N U<=8EDFU=APF F ?9K?98PF N A9<C >@G7F98F97F= G@Uq=G7@oAF >?9GEUAPFL l @8H=H7FAB <=H=AB =7=<@KFA^79 >?@>@^EAP9 >@P=NFqE 8Fr H=Up9 N H=U8@7@:FF4 = <FA^79 ;=G=7F= NEU=^=qE4 p9 =K?9K=AP= ?sp7FtAEAB 8Fr :FrG^E 8@;t NE7FUsN NF9<@U?@H79K@ K?C>@N=7F=4 >@^N=<= 7= >@>?=Nr G@Uq=G7@oAF U<=8EDFU=APFL

l ;=G=7FC CN=K= ^@8H=q= 8UC>F@7= 7= >@^E8U=7FC G@G=HU@N9P F7D@?:=APF G@8H=?A^=79P >?^9^ ^;Fs? NE7FUsN NF9<@U?@H7F9 G@U@7=79P U<=8EDFU=APF N A9<C U@78H?CUAPF H^NL :=AF9?^E N8>sqNE8Ht>F9uL WF@?tA >@G CN=Kr P9G7@A^9879 NE8Ht>F97F9 >=?E @;F9UHsN N H9P 8=:9P U<=8F9 P=U@ N8U=^sNUr F8H7F97F=

(8)

-@?@H= )@^:C8

6`c

^NFt^UC :FrG^E 7F:F4 >F9?N@H7E ^;Fs? @;89?N=APF >?^9U8^H=qA=7E P98H N 2 2 j NE:F=?@Nt :=AF9?^4 UHs?= @>F8CP9 >@G@;F9u8HN@ :FrG^E @;F9UH=:FL ,8H=H9A^79 K?C>@N=7F9 G@U@7EN=79 P98H 7= >@G8H=NF9 C^E8U=79P :=AF9?^E N8>sqNE8Ht>F9uL

"9<9: ?9D9?=HC P98H >@?sN7=7F9 G@Uq=G7@oAF ?@^>@^7=N=7F= >@>?=N79P 8H?CUHC?E U<=8 ^=>?@Q >@7@N=79K@ >@G9PoAF= NF9<@:@G9<@N9K@ ^ ^=8H@8@N=7F9: ?sp7EAB =<K@?EH:sN H=U8@7@:FA^7EAB G@ U@78H?CUAPF :=AF9?^E N8>sqNE8Ht>F9u @?=^ P9P >sv7F9P8^9K@ >@G^F=qC 7= U<=8E @;F9UHsN >@G@;7EAB G@ 8F9;F9L

Cytaty

Powiązane dokumenty

Pojęcie rodzaju literackiego jest wynikiem właśnie owego odsegregowania cech typowych od jednorazowych, tutaj indy­ widualnych, i zarazem pewną pozycją w próbie ich

W raporcie z 13 grudnia 1920 roku Józef Sramek informował o niepokojących doniesieniach z polskiej części Śląska Cieszyńskiego.. Według niego na tym terenie panował

It opens debate similar to the French debate around the famous text „I, Pierre Riviére, having slaughtered my mother, my sister, and my brother” (Foucault, 1975) with a foreword

Zrozumienie mechanizmów regulujących stosunki wodne w komórce wymaga wiedzy o procesach dyfuzji i  osmozy. Istniejące w  umysłach uczniów i  studentów koncepcje tych

The diversification of glaciofluvial and fluvial processes during the phase of stagnation and recession of uppervistulian ice-sheet in the vicinity of Piaski Pomorskie

Agresywne zachowanie Klausa, który na każdym kroku podkreśla swą przewagę, zdaje się dominować nad Helmutem i wzbudzać w nim poczucie niższości, jest dla bohatera niczym

Poruszono w nich problem interpreta- cji tekstu Martyrium Polycarpi jako świadectwa kultu relikwii, a także zagadnienia związane z początkami weneracji Krzyża Świętego,

For co-occurrence matrix with c-means used for its construction, similarly as before for Cuboids, Shapes, Threenorm and 2dnormals data sets, its further partitioning with