Same and Other: from Plato to Kierkegaard. A reading of a metaphysical thesis in an existencial key

-RXUQDORI(GXFDWLRQ&XOWXUHDQG6RFLHW\1RB

15

Same and other: from Plato

to Kierkegaard. A reading of

a metaphysical thesis

in an existential key

María J. Binetti

,QWHUGLVFLSOLQDU\,QVWLWXWHIRU*HQGHU6WXGLHV

)DFXOW\RI3KLORVRSK\DQG/LWHUDWXUH8QLYHUVLW\RI%XHQRV$LUHV

1DWLRQDO&RXQFLOIRU6FLHQWLÀFDQG7HFKQLFDO5HVHDUFK

3XDQ%XHQRV$LUHV$UJHQWLQD E-mail adress: mjbinetti@gmail.com ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1850-6408

Roman Králik

5XVVLDQ/DQJXDJH'HSDUWPHQW

0HGLFDO,QVWLWXWH3HRSOHV·)ULHQGVKLS8QLYHUVLW\RI5XVVLD

58'18QLYHUVLW\0LNOXNKR0DNOD\D6WUHHW0RVFRZ5XVVLD

(PDLODGUHVVURPDQNUDOLN#JPDLOFRPNLHUNHJDDDUG#FHQWUXPF]

ORCID ID: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1929-1894

Hedviga Tkáčová

'HSDUWPHQWRI3KLORVRSK\DQG5HOLJLRXV6WXGLHV )DFXOW\RI+XPDQLWLHV8QLYHUVLW\LQ=LOLQD 8QLYHU]LWQi=LOLQD6ORYDN5HSXEOLF E-mail adress: hedwiga.tkacova@gmail.com 25&,','KWWSRUFLGRUJ

Marie Roubalová

+XVVLWH7KHRORJLFDO)DFXOW\&KDUOHV8QLYHUVLW\LQ3UDJXH

3DFRYVND3UDJXH&]HFK5HSXEOLF E-mail adress: marie.roubalovahtf@cuni.cz ORCID ID: http://orcid.org/0000-0003-1484-1524

Abstract

Aim. ,QKLV.LHUNHJDDUGLDQVWXGLHV-HDQ:DKOVWDWHVWKDWWKHUHLVDIXQGDPHQWDO

FRQYHUJHQFHEHWZHHQ3ODWRDQG6¡UHQ.LHUNHJDDUGIRFXVHGRQWKHQRWLRQVRILGHQWLW\

doi: 10.15503/jecs2021.1.15.31

DQGGLIIHUHQFH:DKOVXJJHVWVDVRUWRIWUDQVSRVLWLRQRISODWRQLFPHWDSK\VLFVLQWRWKH

VSKHUH RI SHUVRQDO VXEMHFWLYLW\ 7KLV SDSHU LQWHQGV WR H[SODLQ WKLV SDVVDJH IURP WKH

VDPHWRWKHRWKHUIURP3ODWRWR.LHUNHJDDUG

Concept7KHDUWLFOHH[SODLQVWKHSDVVDJHIURPWKHVDPHWRWKHRWKHUIURP3ODWRWR

.LHUNHJDDUG,QERWKDXWKRUVWKHFDWHJRULHVRIEHLQJRUQRWEHLQJLGHQWLW\DQGGLIIH

UHQFHXQLW\DQGPXOWLSOLFLW\EHFRPLQJDQGUHVWH[SODLQWKHG\QDPLFQDWXUHRIWKHUHDO

Results and conclusion. ,QERWKDXWKRUVWKHFDWHJRULHVPHQVLRQHGDERYHH[SODLQ

WKHG\QDPLFQDWXUHRIWKHUHDO%XWZKLOH3ODWRDSSOLHVWKHVHFDWHJRULHVWRWKHLQWHOLJL

ELOHZRUG.LHUNHJDDUGDSSOLHVWKHPWRLQGLYLGXDOIUHHGRPZKLFKVXSSRUWVUHDOLW\DV

DZKROH

Cognitive value. %RWKVHDUFKHVOHDGWRDVLQJOHVSHFXODWLYHDQVZHUDQGFXOPLQDWH

LQWKHVDPHPHWDSK\VLFDOFDWHJRULVDWLRQZKLFKDSSOLHVDQDORJRXVO\WRHYHU\WKLQJUHDO

,QGHHGEHLQJDQGQRQEHLQJLGHQWLW\DQGGLIIHUHQFHRQHQHVVDQGRWKHUQHVVUHVWDQG

EHFRPLQJH[SODLQWKHGLDOHFWLFLQWHQVLYHDQGUHODWLRQDOG\QDPLVPRIHQWLD$WWKHVDPH

WLPHWKH\HVVHQWLDOO\GHWHUPLQHWKHSRZHURIKXPDQH[LVWHQFHLQÀQLWHO\SRVVLEOHDQG

IRUHYHUGHSHQGLQJRQWKHDEVROXWH

Key words: .LHUNHJDDUG3ODWRFDWHJRULHVIUHHGRPPHWDSK\VLFVKXPDQH[LVWHQFH

Introduction

T

EHHQSRLQWHGRXWLQ-HDQ:DKO·VKierkegaardian Studies7KH)UHQFKLQWHUSUH

WHUDUJXHVWKDWVLQLVDSRVLWLYHSRVLWLRQQRWDPHUHQHJDWLRQDQGWKLVFDQQRW

HYHQEHFRQFHLYHGLWLVWKHDIÀUPDWLRQRIWKHEHLQJRIQRQEHLQJVRQRWDQ

LPPHGLDWHEXWDPHGLDWHLQVWDQFH7KHH[LVWHQFHRIRWKHUQHVVRIQRQEHLQJ

DEVWUDFWO\VWDWHGE\3ODWRLQSophistLVKHUHFRQFUHWHO\DVVHUWHGDQGLQThe Sick- ness unto Death.LHUNHJDDUGZLOOVWDWHWKLVLGHDVWLOOPRUHDFFXUDWHO\E\VKRZLQJ

WKDWVLQWDNHVSODFHDQGLVDZDUHRILWVWDNLQJSODFHEHIRUH*RG´7KLVEHIRUH

*RGDZDUHQHVVLVDQHVVHQWLDOSRVLWLYHFRPSRQHQWRIWKHLGHDRIVLQµ:DKO

 S  ,Q PHQWLRQLQJ WKH FRQQHFWLRQ EHWZHHQ 3ODWR DQG .LHUNHJDDUG

IRUDVHFRQGWLPH-:DKODVVHUWWKDWWKH$EVROXWHGLIIHUHQFHFDQQRWEHFRQ

FHLYHGE\XQGHUVWDQGLQJ,QWKLVUHDOPDERYHXQGHUVWDQGLQJWKHRSSRVLWLRQ

EHWZHHQVLPLODULW\DQGGLIIHUHQFHGLVDSSHDUVDVGRHVDQ\RWKHURSSRVLWLRQ

DQG.LHUNHJDDUGIROORZVRQWKLVVXEMHFWWKHWUDGLWLRQRULJLQDWHGLQWKHGLDOHF

WLFRIParmenides DQGFRQWLQXHGE\WKHQHJDWLYHWKHRORJ\XSKHOGE\P\VWLFV

7KHUHLVDFRQIXVLRQRIXQGHUVWDQGLQJKHUHDQDORJRXVWRWKDWZHH[SHULHQFHLQ

UHDGLQJ3ODWR·VGLDORJXHZKLFKVKRZVTXLWHZHOOWKHLURQ\RIXQGHUVWDQGLQJ

WRLWVHOI´:LWKLQXVWKHUHLVDQXQKDSS\ORYHRIWKHXQNQRZQµ:DKO

S  7KLV XQNQRZQ ZKLFK LV WKH DEVROXWHO\ GLIIHUHQW ´WKLV RWKHUµ WKH

)UHQFKLQWHUSUHWHUH[SODLQV´LVORYHµ:DKOS-:DKO·V3ODWRQLVLQJ

LQWHUSUHWDWLRQRI.LHUNHJDDUGFXOPLQDWHVLQWKHIROORZLQJWH[W

6XFKLV.LHUNHJDDUG·VSDUDGR[)RUKLPWKHUHLVDUHODWLRQWRDEHLQJWKDWLVQRW

IRUXVH[FHSWLQWKLVUHODWLRQDQGWRZKRPZHFDQQRWEHUHODWHG1HYHUKDVWKH

DQWLQRP\ DW WKH ERWWRP RI Parmenides EHHQ VR GHHSO\ H[SHULHQFHG 1RU KDV WKH

DQWLQRP\DWWKHERWWRPRIIDLWKGHÀQHGDVWKHLQQHUPRVWUHODWLRQDQGDVDUHODWLRQ

WRVRPHWKLQJH[WHUQDODWWKHVDPHWLPHHYHUEHHQEHWWHULOOXPLQDWHGS

+\SRWKHWLFDOO\DVVXPLQJWKH:DKOLDQLQWHUSUHWDWLRQWKHIROORZLQJSDUD

JUDSKVZLOOWU\WRHOXFLGDWH3ODWRDQG.LHUNHJDDUG·VIXQGDPHQWDOFRQYHUJHQFH

LQWKHOLJKWRIWKHLGHDRIRWKHUQHVV7KHSDUDGR[LFDOUHDOLW\RI.LHUNHJDDUGLDQ

VLQZRXOGEHWKHH[LVWHQWLDOHTXLYDOHQWRIGLIIHUHQFHDVUHTXLUHGLQParmenides, VXJJHVWHGLQSophistDQGH[SODLQHGE\WKH'\DGLQ3ODWR·VXQZULWWHQGRFWUL

QHV6XFKDQDVVXPSWLRQLQYROYHVWKHWUDQVSRVLWLRQRI3ODWRQLFPHWDSK\VLFV

WRWKHUHDOPRIÀQLWHVXEMHFWLYLW\1RWRQO\ZLOOWKLVFODULI\WKHGHHSHVWVSH

FXODWLYHURRWVRI.LHUNHJDDUGLDQWKRXJKWEXWZLOODOVRHQDEOHDUHIRXQGDWLRQ

RIVXSUHPHJHQHUDRQWKHHLGHWLFH[SHULHQFHRIRQH·VRZQIUHHGRPWKURXJK

LQWHQVLYHDQGUHODWLRQDOGLDOHFWLF

7KHSUHVHQWSDSHUDWWHPSWVWRYHULI\WKHSDVVDJHIURPVDPHWRRWKHUIURP

WKHVWDQGSRLQWRIWKH3ODWRQLFSURSRVDODVUHDGLQDQH[LVWHQWLDONH\,QRWKHU

ZRUGVWKHSUHVHQWWH[WVHWVRXWWRXQYHLOWKHH[LVWHQWLDOPHDQLQJRIDFHQWUDO

LQWXLWLRQRIDQLGHDFRQFHLYHGDEVROXWHO\DQGLQDOOLWVSXULW\WKHLGHDRIRWKHU

QHVVZKRVHFRQFHSWXDOLVDWLRQZLOOHQDEOHHLWKHUWKHFRQÀUPDWLRQRUUHMHFWLRQ

RI-:DKO·VYLHZ7RWKDWHQG,ZLOOEULHÁ\GLVFXVVVRPHIXQGDPHQWDOQRWLRQV

RI3ODWR·VPHWDSK\VLFVLQRUGHUWRDSSURDFK.LHUNHJDDUG·VWKRXJKW

Some principles of platonic metaphysics

3ODWR·VPHWDSK\VLFVDVRSSRVHGWR3DUPHQLGHDQPRQLVPPRGHUQLGHQWLW\

SKLORVRSKLHVDQGWKHVXSHULRULW\RIGLIIHUHQFHRYHURQHQHVVDQGLGHQWLW\DSSH

DUVDVDS\UDPLGDOSOXUDOLVPZKRVHDSH[LVWKHSUHHPLQHQFHRIWKH2QH7KXV

WKHRXWFRPHRI3ODWR·VHQGHDYRXULVDFRQFHSWLRQRIWKHDEVROXWHWKDWGRHVQRW

OHDYHRXWPXOWLSOLFLW\RURQHQHVVEHLQJRUQRQEHLQJLGHQWLW\RUGLIIHUHQFH

PRWLRQRUUHVWEXWLQFRUSRUDWHVDOORIWKHPDQDORJRXVO\LQWRWKHHLGHWLFIRXQ

GDWLRQRIWKHUHDO

,QRWKHUZRUGVWKH3ODWRQLFDEVROXWHKDVORVWWKHLQHUWULJLGLW\RI(OHDWLF

UHDOLW\WRDFKLHYHDGLDOHFWLFYLWDOLW\WKDWWDNHVDSSHDUDQFHVLQWRDFFRXQW7R

3ODWRWKHUHLVDGLDOHFWLFRIthe contingentDQGDGLDOHFWLFRIthe absolute7KH3OD

WRQLFGLDOHFWLFRIWKHFRQWLQJHQWH[SUHVVHVWKHSURJUHVVLYHPXWDEOHWHPSRUDO

DQGVXFFHVVLYHPXOWLSOLFLW\SURSHUWRWKHVHQVLEOHZRUOGZKHUHDVKLVGLDOHFWLF

RIWKHDEVROXWHH[SUHVVHVWKHVLPXOWDQHRXVLPPXWDEOHQRQSURJUHVVLYHDQG

HWHUQDOPXOWLSOLFLW\SURSHUWRWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHZRUOG

3ODWRQLF LQWHOOLJLELOLW\ LV GLDOHFWLF ZKLFK SUHVXSSRVHV DQ DWWHPSW WR FRQ

FHLYHDQLGHDOZRUOGWKDWLVG\QDPLFDQGDOLYHDQDFWLYHHWHUQLW\,QIDFWWKH

3ODWRQLFeidosEHLQJLQLWVHOIDVLPSOHLPPXWDEOHDQGHWHUQDOHVVHQFHSDUWLFL

SDWHVVLPXOWDQHRXVO\LQPRWLRQOLIHDQGWKRXJKW7KLVSDUWLFLSDWLRQHQDEOHVLW

UHODWLRQDOO\WRVKDSHWKHEHFRPLQJRIWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHZKLFKWDNHVSODFHLQWKH

RQWRORJLFDOkoinonía RILGHDV7KXVWKHLGHDOkoinoníaLQYROYHVWKHPRYHPHQWRI

WKRXJKWLHDJHQXLQHG\QDPLVPLQZKLFKRQHLGHDUHIHUVWRWKHRWKHU

1RZWKHG\QDPLVPRIWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHSUHVXSSRVHVLWVRZQSRZHUWKHLGHDO

dynamisKHQFH3ODWRFDPHWRFRQFHLYHEHLQJDVDFWLYHSRWHQF\+HVD\V´0\

VXJJHVWLRQZRXOGEHWKDWDQ\WKLQJZKLFKSRVVHVVHVDQ\VRUWRISRZHUWRDIIHFW

DQRWKHURUWREHDIIHFWHGE\DQRWKHUHYHQIRUDPRPHQWKRZHYHUWULÁLQJWKH

FDXVHDQGKRZHYHUVOLJKWDQGPRPHQWDU\WKHHIIHFWKDVUHDOH[LVWHQFHDQG,

KROGWKDWWKHGHÀQLWLRQRIEHLQJLVVLPSO\SRZHUµ3ODWRSSH$ERYH

WKHSRWHQF\RIVHQVLEOHEHLQJVLVWKHSRWHQF\RIWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHLHWKHFUHDWLYH

SRZHURILGHDVZKLFKDUH´WKHFDXVHRIWKLQJVDIWHUZDUGVH[LVWLQJZKLFKGLG

QRWH[LVWEHIRUHµ3ODWRSSE7KXVWKH3ODWRQLFZRUOGRILGHDVFRQ

VWLWXWHVDQRUGHUHGZKROHDPXOWLSOLFLW\RUJDQLVHGE\DFHUWDLQG\QDPLFZKLFK

VLPXOWDQHRXVO\RUJDQLVHVERWKWKHRQWRORJLFDODQGWKHNQRZOHGJHVSKHUHSUH

FLVHO\EHFDXVHWKHSRZHURIWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHLVWKHFRQVWLWXWLYHVRXUFHRIERWK

%XWWKHVLPXOWDQHRXVPXOWLSOLFLW\RILGHDVZRXOGQRWEHSRVVLEOHZLWKRXW

WKHUHDOLW\RILGHQWLW\DQGGLIIHUHQFHRIEHLQJDQGQRQEHLQJZKLFKLVSUR

SRVHGE\WKHWKHRU\RIVXSUHPHJHQHUDDVDFRQGLWLRQRIWKHSRVVLELOLW\RIWKH

LGHDOZRUOG,QIDFWDFFRUGLQJWR3ODWRDXQLYHUVDOUHDOLW\PXVWH[LVWWKDWHLWKHU

HQFRPSDVVHVDQGGHWHUPLQHVWKHZKROHLQWHOOLJLEOHZRUOGRUFRQWDLQVLWLQWHQ

VLYHO\LQLWVRZQUHDOLW\6XFKLVWKHPHWDSK\VLFDOFRQVLVWHQF\RIWKHVXSUHPH

JHQHUDZKLFKPD\EHDWWULEXWHGWRWKHZKROHLGHDOZRUOGE\YLUWXHRIWKHODW

WHU·VLQFOXVLRQLQWKHIRUPHU

7KHVXSUHPHJHQHUDFRPSULVHWKUHHSDLUVRIRSSRVLWHVEHLQJDQGQRQ

EHLQJ LGHQWLW\ DQG GLIIHUHQFH UHVW DQG PRWLRQ ZKLFK DUH LQWHQGHG WR

DFFRXQWIRUWKHH[SHULHQFHRIWKHPXOWLSOHDQGGLIIHUHQW,QWKLVVHQVHLQ

3ODWR·VParmenidesWKHQHJDWLRQRIQRQEHLQJPXOWLSOLFLW\DQGPRYHPHQW

HQWDLOVWKHQHJDWLRQRIWKHLURSSRVLWHV,QSophist,WKHLVVXHLVIXUWKHUH[D

PLQHGDQGWKHUHDOLW\RIQRQEHLQJLVDGPLWWHGDVDSUHVXSSRVLWLRQRIWKH

DSSDUHQWRIHUURUIDOVHKRRGGHFHLWOLHVHWFDOORIZKLFKSRLQWWREHLQJDV

QRQEHLQJDQGWRWKHLGHQWLFDODVWKHRWKHU7KXVQRQEHLQJÀOWHUVLQWRWKH

VHQVLEOHGLVFRXUVHWKRXJKWWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHEUHDNLQJWKHPXSDQGGLDOHF

WLFDOO\PRELOLVLQJWKHP

)RU3ODWRQRQEHLQJKDVDFHUWDLQUHDOLW\LHFRQVWLWXWHVDFHUWDLQZD\RI

EHLQJRQZKLFKLWVQHJDWLRQPXVWEHIRXQGHGMXVWDVWKHDIÀUPDWLRQRIWKH

UHDO PXVW UHODWH WR D FHUWDLQ NLQG RI QRQEHLQJ ,Q RWKHU ZRUGV EHLQJ DQG

QRQEHLQJHQWDLOHDFKRWKHU²WKH\DUHUHODWLRQDOO\DIÀUPHG1HLWKHURIWKHP

FDQEHQDPHGZLWKRXWVLPXOWDQHRXVO\HYRNLQJWKHRWKHUEHFDXVHERWKUHVXOW

IURPWKHLUPXWXDOLPSOLFDWLRQIURPWKHLUFRUUHODWLYHUHIHUHQFH$FFRUGLQJWR

WKLVZKHQHYHUWKHRWKHUH[LVWVEHLQJLVQRWIRUXV3ODWRSSD7KLV

LVEHFDXVHRQFHEHLQJKDVEHHQDIÀUPHGQRQEHLQJIROORZVIURPQHFHVVLW\

MXVWDVRQFHQRQEHLQJLVDIÀUPHGWKHUHDOLW\RIEHLQJPXVWQHFHVVDULO\EH

LQIHUUHG%RWKDUHIRXQGHGRQWKHVDPHRQWRORJLFDOGHQVLW\DQGDOOWRWKH

QRQEHLQJKDYLQJEHHQVKRZQWRSDUWDNHRIEHLQJMXVWDVWKHODWWHUGRHVLQ

WKHIRUPHU

1RZ3ODWRWKLQNVWKDWWKHOLQNEHWZHHQEHLQJDQGQRQEHLQJLVQRWEDVL

FDOO\DFRQWUDGLFWLRQEXWUDWKHUWKHYHU\GLIIHUHQFHRIEHLQJLQEHLQJ7KLVLV

VSHOWRXWDVIROORZV´ZKHQZHVSHDNRIQRWEHLQJZHVSHDNQRWRIVRPHWKLQJ

RSSRVHGWREHLQJEXWRQO\GLIIHUHQWµ3ODWRSSE1HJDWLRQWKHQLV

QRWVLPSO\RSSRVLWLRQEXWDERYHDOOGLIIHUHQFHIXQFWLRQDOO\HVWDEOLVKHGDVD

UHODWLYHQRQEHLQJIURPZKLFKDEVHQFHDQGGHSULYDWLRQIROORZ

$OO WKDW LV UHDO SDUWLFLSDWHV DQDORJRXVO\ LQ WKH GLIIHUHQFH RI EHLQJ

EHFDXVHLWSDUWLFLSDWHVLQWKHLGHDRIRWKHU,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHRWKHULVLQ

EHLQJLWVHOIZLWKRXWPDNLQJXSLWVQDWXUHEXWRQWKHFRQWUDU\SUHVXSSR

VLQJSDUWLFLSDWLRQLQEHLQJDQGVDPHQHVV)RUWKLVUHDVRQ3ODWRLQVLVWVWKDW

DERXWDQ\UHDOLW\ZHPD\ULJKWO\VD\WKDWLWLVQRQEHLQJDQGRQWKHFRQ

WUDU\LQVRIDUDVLWSDUWLFLSDWHVLQEHLQJWKDWLWH[LVWVDQGLVDEHLQJ'LIIH

UHQFHDQGLGHQWLW\FRUUHODWHE\YLUWXHRIWKHLUPXWXDOLQWHOOLJLEOHLPSOLFD

WLRQMXVWDVEHLQJDQGQRQEHLQJGRKHQFHHYHU\WKLQJZRXOGEHLWVHOIDQG

DQRWKHUVLPXOWDQHRXVO\

3UHFLVHO\EHFDXVHEHLQJLVLGHQWLW\DQGQRQEHLQJLVGLIIHUHQFHWKH\HQDEOH

ERWKWKHRQHQHVVDQGWKHPXOWLSOLFLW\RIWKHUHDOVKDSLQJDYDULHJDWHGSOXUDOLW\

IXOORIFRQWUDVWV(DFKEHLQJLVRQO\RQHEXWGLIIHUHQWDQGVHSDUDWHIURPPDQ\

RWKHURQHV%RWKWKHFRQFHSWXDODQGLQWHOOLJLEOHkoinoníaDQGWKHVHQVLEOHH[L

VWHQWLDO DQWKURSRORJLFDO DQG PRUDO RQH IROORZ IURP WKLV PXOWLSOH XQLYHUVH

PDGHUHDOE\GLIIHUHQFH,QWHUFRXUVHFRPPXQLFDWLRQGLDORJXHDQGUHVSRQVL

ELOLW\WRWKHRWKHUVWHPIURPGLIIHUHQFH

1RQEHLQJGRHVQRWLQDQGRILWVHOILQYROYHFRQWUDGLFWLRQWKHQEXWUDWKHU

GLIIHUHQFH DV H[SHULHQFH GHPDQGV 1HYHUWKHOHVV DV WKH FRQFHSWXDO RUGHU

GHPDQGVGLIIHUHQFHGRHVSUHVXSSRVHFRQWUDGLFWLRQRULQRWKHUZRUGVDEVR

OXWHRWKHUQHVVZKLFKLVFDSDEOHRILQWHQVLYHO\FRQWDLQLQJDQ\RWKHUGLVWLQFWLRQ

5DGLFDOGLIIHUHQFHDIÀUPHGDVDEVROXWHFRQWUDGLFWLRQHQFRPSDVVHVWKHZKROH

LQWHOOLJLEOHZRUOGDQGULVHVDERYHLWDVWKHVXSUHPHSULQFLSOHRIDOOPXOWLSOLFLW\

%XWDEVROXWHGLIIHUHQFHDVDÀUVWSULQFLSOHRIWKHUHDOLVOLQNHGWRDQDIÀU

PDWLYH FRUUHODWH LH D VXSUHPH SULQFLSOH LQ ZKLFK DOO RQHQHVV DQG LGHQWLW\

SDUWLFLSDWH6XFKLVWR3ODWRWKHUHDOLW\RIWKH2QHZKRVHDEVROXWHQHVVFDQEH

QHJDWHGRQO\E\WKHDEVROXWHO\GLYHUVHE\WKHUDGLFDOGLIIHUHQFHKHFDOOVWKH

,QGHÀQLWH'\DGRU7KH*UHDWDQG7KH6PDOO2QHDQG'\DGFDQQRWEHGLVVR

FLDWHGIURPHDFKRWKHU7KH\FDOOIRUHDFKRWKHUVLQFHSXUHRWKHUQHVVUHMHFWV

VLQJOHQHVVLQLWVHOI7KLVÀUVWQHJDWLRQRIWKHÀUVWLVSUHVXSSRVHGE\DOOEHLQJ

DQGQRQEHLQJE\WKHLGHQWLFDODQGWKHGLYHUVHE\WKHVLPXOWDQHRXVPXOWLSOL

FLW\RIWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHDQGE\WKHVXFFHVVLYHDQGRQJRLQJSOXUDOLW\RIWKHVHQVL

EOH+HQFH$ULVWRWOHLQGLVFXVVLQJ3ODWR·VWKRXJKWUHIHUVWRWKHRSSRVLWLRQE\

FRQWUDULQHVV$ULVWyWHOHVSS,DEHWZHHQERWKSULQFLSOHVLHWR

WKHUDGLFDOFRQWUDGLFWLRQ3ODWRQLFGLDOHFWLFFXOPLQDWHVLQRUUDWKHUVWDUWVZLWK

7KHQRWLRQVRIWKHVHVXSUHPHSULQFLSOHVSRLQWWRWKH$WKHQLDQPDVWHU·V

RUDOWHDFKLQJVZKLFKKHLPSDUWHGWRWKRVHLQLWLDWHGLQWRKLVNQRZOHGJH,Q

WKLVVHQVH3ODWR·VXQZULWWHQGRFWULQHZRXOGFRQWDLQWKHNH\WRKLVV\VWHP

DQGFRPSHODUHFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIKLVWKHRU\LQWKHOLJKWRIWKHLQGLUHFWFRQWUL

EXWLRQRIKLVWRULRJUDSK\WRSKLORVRSKLFDOWUDGLWLRQ$FFRUGLQJWRWKLVRUDO

WUDGLWLRQ3ODWRZRXOGFODLPWKDWWKRVHSULQFLSOHVDUHWKHSULPDU\HOHPHQWV

DQGWKHPRVWXQLYHUVDOJHQHUD7KHLUGXDOLW\GRHVQRWQHJDWHWKHDEVROXWH

VXSUHPDF\RIWKH2QHRYHUWKH'\DGRUWKDWRIERWKRIWKHPRYHUEHLQJ,Q

RWKHUZRUGVSULQFLSOHGXDOLW\EUHDNVZLWK3DUPHQLGHDQPRQLVPDQGVDYHV

WKRXJKWIURPWKHGXDOLVWLFWKUHDWLQVRIDUDVLWPDLQWDLQVWKHVXSUHPDF\RI

WKH2QHDQGVXERUGLQDWHVDQ\RWKHUUHDOLW\WRLWHYHQWKHQHJDWLRQSURSHU

WRWKH'\DG,IWKHRULJLQDORSSRVLWLRQRIWKHÀUVWSULQFLSOHVH[SODLQVWKH

PXOWLSOLFLW\ RI WKH UHDO LW LV SUHFLVHO\ EHFDXVH RI WKH SULRULW\ RI RQHQHVV

ZKLFKDFFRXQWVIRUDQGHQDEOHVHYHU\RSSRVLWLRQDQGWKHUHIRUHHYHU\NLQG

RIGLDOHFWLF

7KH3ODWRQLF2QHFRQVWLWXWHVWKHFRPSOLFDWLRRIHYHU\GHWHUPLQDWLRQDQG

IXOÀOVWKHIXQFWLRQRIIRUPDODQGHIÀFLHQWFDXVHRIDOOEHLQJV,QGHHGHYHU\

EHLQJLVRQHEHFDXVHRIWKHRQHQHVVFRQVWLWXWLYHO\UHSURGXFHGLQKLPDQGLV

VXFKEHFDXVHLWUHFHLYHVIURPWKHRQHWKHOLPLWWKDWVKDSHVLWVRZQEHLQJ,IWKH

2QHGLGQRWH[LVWWKHUHZRXOGEHQRRQHQHVVDWDOOLQEHLQJVDQGWKHUHIRUH

WKHUHZRXOGEHQRPXOWLSOLFLW\HLWKHU,QRSSRVLWLRQWRWKHXQLI\LQJSULQFLSOH

WKH'\DGFRQVWLWXWHVWKHDEVROXWHLQGHWHUPLQDWLRQOLPLWOHVVQHVVDQGLQGHÀQL

WHQHVVIURPDQGLQZKLFKERWKWKHVHQVLEOHDQGWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHZLOOEHIRUPHG

+HQFHLWZRUNVDVDUHFHSWLYHDQGSDVVLYHPDWHULDOSULQFLSOH'XDOLW\LVWKH

GLIIHUHQFHRIWKH2QHDQGDVVXFKFRQGLWLRQVDQGVXSSRUWVDQLQGHÀQLWHPXO

WLSOLFLW\RIRWKHUEHLQJV0RUHRYHUEHLQJDEVROXWHRWKHUQHVVLWDFFRXQWVIRUDOO

GLIIHUHQFHVDOOFRQWUDVWVDOOYDULDWLRQVDOOGHJUHHVDQGVL]HVRIEHLQJVIRUERWK

WKHJUHDWHUDQGWKHVPDOOHU

%RWKWKH2QHDQGWKH'\DGDUHZKROO\SUHVHQWLQWKHUHDODQGDUHUHFHLYHG

E\DOOLWVVSKHUHVE\SDUWLFLSDWLRQEHFDXVHEHLQJLVLQLWVHOIDFRPSRVLWHRIRQH

QHVVDQGGXDOLW\LGHQWLW\DQGGLIIHUHQFH1RZWKHGLIIHUHQWVSKHUHVRIWKHUHDO

HQFRPSDVVWKHVHQVLEOHLGHDODQGPRUDOGLPHQVLRQV+HQFHWKHWZRSULQFL

SOHVFRQVWLWXWHWKHFDXVHRIEHLQJWKHIRXQGDWLRQRINQRZOHGJHDQGWKHVRXUFH

RIYDOXH7KXVWKH\IXOÀODQRQWRORJLFDONQRZOHGJHDQGD[LRORJLFDOIXQFWLRQ

DFFRUGLQJWRZKLFK2QHQHVVRSHUDWHVDVJRRGWUXWKSDWWHUQOLPLWPHDVXUH

DQGWKH'\DGDVWKHLURSSRVLWH

,QGHHGRQHQHVVDPRXQWVWROLPLWDQGWKXVGHWHUPLQHVWKHLGHQWLW\VXE

VLVWHQFHDQGRUGHURIWKHUHDO+HQFHRQHQHVVLVWKHIXQGDPHQWDOFDWHJRULFDO

FRQVWLWXHQWRIHYHU\EHLQJ%XWRQHQHVVUHFHLYHGE\EHLQJVE\SDUWLFLSDWLRQDV

WKHLUVWUXFWXUDOODZLVDWWKHVDPHWLPHWKHHVVHQFHRIJRRGQHVVDQGWKHUHIRUH

VLQJXODUJRRGQHVVLVWKXVIRXQGHGRQWKHGHOLPLWDWLRQRIPXOWLSOLFLW\E\RQH

QHVV7KHFRQYHUWLELOLW\RIRQHQHVVLQWRJRRGQHVVDQGYLFHYHUVDHQDEOHVWKH

GLUHFWSDVVDJHIURPWKHRQWRORJLFDOWRWKHD[LRORJLFDORUPRUDOVSKHUH7KHUHLV

DFRUUHVSRQGHQFHEHWZHHQRQHQHVVJRRGQHVVDQGWUXWKRQWKHRQHKDQGDQG

PXOWLSOLFLW\HYLODQGIDOVHKRRGRQWKHRWKHU%XWWKHIXQFWLRQDOSRO\YDOHQFHRI

WKHSULQFLSOHVPDQLIHVWVLWVHOIQRWRQO\DWWKHOHYHORIWKHFRQVWLWXWLYHIRXQGD

WLRQRIEHLQJEXWDOVRDWWKDWRILWVLQWHOOLJLEOHVHQVLEOHNQRZOHGJHDQGPRUDO

G\QDPLVP7KXVWKH2QHEHFRPHVPRYHUDQGHVSHFLDOO\HQGRIWKHUHDO7KH

UHIRUHentiaZLOOEHSHUIHFWHGE\DFHUWDLQUHGXFWLRQWRRQHQHVVWKURXJKWKH

H[FOXVLRQRIQRQEHLQJZKLFKHDWVLQWRWKHYHU\FRUHRIEHLQJ(YHU\UHDOLW\

RXWVLGHWKH2QHVLQFHLWLVDQRWKHUZLWKUHVSHFWWRLWUHTXLUHVWKLVUHGXFWLRQ

7KHSUHVHQWGLVFXVVLRQVKRXOGVXIÀFHWRRXWOLQHWKHEDVLFPHDQLQJRI3ODWRQLF

GLDOHFWLFDVDUHODWLRQDOG\QDPLVPDFFRUGLQJWRZKLFKERWKVHQVLEOHDQGLQWHOOL

JLEOHEHLQJVXQIROGWKHLULGHQWLW\E\FRQVWDQWO\FODVKLQJZLWKWKHRWKHU:LWKRXW

FRQVWLWXWLQJWKHLURZQQDWXUHWKLVRWKHUQHVVLVQHYHUWKHOHVVWKHLUYHU\EHLQJLQ

WKHQRQEHLQJPRGH7KXVWKHUHDOLVDFFRUGLQJWR3ODWRdynamisHQHUJ\DFWLYH

SRZHUWKDWPXVWLQWHQVLI\LWVHOILQGLDOHFWLFRSSRVLWLRQWRWKHRWKHU)URPWKH

NQRZOHGJHSRLQWRIYLHZ3ODWRQLFGLDOHFWLFLVDGHHSHQLQJH[SHULHQFHWKDWFXOPL

QDWHVLQWKHLQHIIDEOH7KLVHLGHWLFH[SHULHQFHDSSUHKHQGVWKDWZKLFKLVFRPPRQ

WRDQGFRQVWLWXWLYHRIEHLQJVXSWRWKDWÀVVXUHOHVV2QHQHVVRXWVLGHZKLFKWKHUH

FDQRQO\EHDEVROXWHQRWKLQJQHVVLHUDGLFDORWKHUQHVV

1RZWKLVUHDOLW\VKDSLQJdynamis PDQLIHVWVLWVHOILQWKHKXPDQVSLULWDVéros, LHDVDQDFWLYHSRWHQF\DVDQHYHUSRVVLEOHSRZHUWKDWLVWKHUHIRUHDOZD\VGHSUL

YHGRILWVZKROHJRRG7KHRWKHUQHVVRIORYHLVLQDVHQVHLWVRZQPeníaGLDOHFWL

FDOO\WHQGLQJWRZDUGVPórosZKLFKFRQVWLWXWLQJéros DVZHOOH[SHFWVWRDFWXDOLVH

LWVLGHQWLW\7KHRWKHUQHVVRI3ODWRQLFérosQRWRQO\FRQVLVWVLQLWVLQWULQVLFGHSUL

YDWLRQEXWDOVRLQDQRWKHUVHQVHSRLQWVWRWKHSXUHXQPL[HGDEVROXWH%HDXW\WR

ZKLFKLWDVSLUHVDQGZKRVHFRQWHPSODWLRQIHFXQGDWHVLW3ODWRSSEF

/RYHLPSUHJQDWHGE\EHDXW\LVFDSDEOHRISURFUHDWLQJEHJHWWLQJSURGXFLQJ

RUUDWKHUVHOISURGXFLQJLIVXFKLQWHUSUHWDWLRQEHDOORZHGWKHVSLULWXDOEHLQJ

H[LVWHQWLDOLGHQWLW\DQGIXOOQHVVEHTXHDWKHGWRLWE\PórosLWVIDWKHUDQGSUHVHQW

in érosDVQRQEHLQJFDSDEOHRIFRPLQJLQWRWKLVLQKHULWDQFH

/RYHWRXFKHGE\EHDXW\JLYHVELUWKWRWKDWIRUZKLFKLWZDVIHFXQGDWHG

ORQJDJRLWEUHHGVLWERWKQHDUDQGIDUDZD\IURPLWLWWKLQNVRILWDQGWKDW

ZKLFKLWKDVEURXJKWIRUWKHQGVXSE\QRXULVKLQJLWWRJHWKHUZLWKWKHEHDXWL

IXOREMHFWRIZKLFK,KDYHVSRNHQDOWKRXJKWKHFRXSOH·VFRPPXQLW\LVLQÀQL

WHO\FORVHUWKDQWKDWEHWZHHQXVDQGRXUFKLOGUHQDQGWKHLUDIIHFWLRQVRXQGHU

EHFDXVHWKH\VKDUHWKHPRVWEHDXWLIXODQGORQJHVWOLYLQJFKLOGUHQ3ODWR

SSF7KLVVSLULWXDOUHDOLW\LVWKHRIIVSULQJRIORYH,WVWDUWVIURPLWVRZQ

QRWKLQJQHVV IURP WKH RWKHU DQG EHFRPHV VXFK WKURXJK WKH LQVWDQWDQHRXV

WRXFKRIRWKHUQHVVLQLWVHOI

+HQFHWKHIROORZLQJ3ODWRQLFDVVHUWLRQWKHREMHFWRIORYH´LVJHQHUDWLRQ

DQGELUWKLQEHDXW\µ3ODWRSSG3URFUHDWLQJDQGJLYLQJELUWKLQ

EHDXW\ORYHDFWXDOLVHVEHLQJUHQHZVLWSURGXFHVLWFRQVWDQWO\7KLVLVWKH

RQO\ZD\LQZKLFKDPRUWDOEHLQJPD\DFKLHYHLPPRUWDOLW\E\´JHQHUDWLRQ

EHFDXVHWKHQHZLVDOZD\VOHIWLQWKHSODFHRIWKHROGµ3ODWRSSG 7RSXWLWLQDQXWVKHOOérosPDNHVWKHDVFHQWWKURXJKZKLFKWKHSRRUPXOWL

SOLFLW\RIWKHUHDOULVHVWRWKHIXOOULFKQHVVRIWKH2QHWKDWXQGLPLQLVKHGULFK

QHVVQHJDWHGDWWKHYHU\RULJLQRIEHLQJWRHQDEOHWKHPXOWLSOHWREH+HQFHWKH

LQWHUPHGLDWHQDWXUHRIORYHORFDWHGEHWZHHQEHLQJDQGQRQEHLQJEHWZHHQ

RQHQHVVDQGRWKHUQHVVDVDERQGWKDWXQLWHVWKHZKROHZLWKLWVHOI/RYHLVD

ERQGRISHUIHFWLRQEHFDXVHLWQHJDWHVGLIIHUHQFHSURGXFLQJVLPLODULW\

From eidos to existence: the Kierkegaardian path /HDYLQJDVLGH.LHUNHJDDUG·VUHMHFWLRQRIWKHDEVWUDFWFDWHJRULVDWLRQRI3OD

WRQLF PHWDSK\VLFV ZKLFK VHHNV WR VWUHVV WKH H[LVWHQWLDO FDWHJRULVDWLRQ RI KLV

RZQWKRXJKW,ZRXOGOLNHWRGZHOORQD.LHUNHJDDUGLDQWH[W´3ODWRWHDFKHV

WKDWRQO\LGHDVKDYHWUXHEHLQJ7KXVLWPD\DOVREHVDLGDQGPRUHWUXO\WKDW

RQO\WKHKXPDQH[LVWLQJWKDWUHODWHVWRFRQFHSWVSULPLWLYHO\DVVXPLQJWKHP

UHYLHZLQJ WKHP PRGLI\LQJ WKHP FUHDWLQJ WKHP DQHZ RQO\ WKDW H[LVWLQJ LV

LQWHUHVWHGLQH[LVWHQFH$Q\RWKHUKXPDQH[LVWLQJLVPHUHO\DFRS\H[LVWHQFH

DSDUWLFXODUFDVHLQWKHZRUOGRIÀQLWXGHWKDWYDQLVKHVZLWKRXWWUDFHDQGKDV

QHYHUEHHQLQWHUHVWHGLQH[LVWHQFH$QGWKLVDSSOLHVERWKWRDQ\ERXUJHRLV·V

H[LVWLQJDQGIRUH[DPSOHWRD(XURSHDQZDUDVORQJDVLWLVQRWUHODWHGWR

FRQFHSWVLQZKLFKFDVHUHDOH[LVWLQJLVLQVSLWHRIHYHU\WKLQJGXHRQO\WRWKH

6LQJXODU RQH WKURXJK ZKRP WKLV KDSSHQV %XW ZKHUHDV KH ZKR UHODWHV WR

FRQFHSWVLVLQWHUHVWHGWKURXJKWKHPLQH[LVWHQFHVXFKH[LVWLQJEHFRPHVWKHQ

QDWXUDOO\DVWUXJJOHDJDLQVWGHPRQVDQGDJDLQVWWKRVHIRUFHVZKRVHH[LVWHQFH

ZRXOGQRWRWKHUZLVHVKRZµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS;,^$

7KLVSDUDJUDSKPDNHVWKH3ODWRQLFLGHDOZRUOGGHVFHQGIURPLWVUHDOLW\LQ

LWVHOIWRWKHFRQFUHWHH[LVWHQFHRIWKHLQGLYLGXDOZKRVHRQWRORJLFDOFRQVLVWHQF\

ZLOOGHSHQGDFFRUGLQJWR.LHUNHJDDUGRQWKHLGHDODVVLPLODWLRQKHIUHHO\SHU

IRUPV+HGRHVQRWGHQ\WKHUHDOLW\RIWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHLQLWVHOILHWKHVXEVL

VWHQFHRIDFRQFHSWXDOUHDOLW\SUHVKDSLQJDOOKXPDQNQRZOHGJH+HZRXOG

WKHUHIRUHEHH[HPSWIURPWKHFULWLFLVPOHYHOOHGDW+HJHO·VXQUHDODEVWUDFWLRQ

DQGDWFHUWDLQ3ODWRQLFLQWHUSUHWDWLRQWKDW,WKLQNDLPVDWHQKDQFLQJWKHYDOXH

RIVLQJXODUH[LVWHQFH2QWKHFRQWUDU\WKH'DQLVKH[LVWHQWLDOLVWZRXOGDIÀUP

WKHFRQVLVWHQF\RIWKHLGHDO7KLVVHHPVWRIROORZIURPDMXYHQLOHQRWH

6LEEHUQPDGHWRGD\LQKLVOHFWXUHDYHU\JRRGREVHUYDWLRQWKHH[LVWHQFHVKRXOG

EHDGPLWWHGRIDJHQXLQHLGHDOEHLQJWKDWKDVLQLWVHOIDFHUWDLQEHLQJHYHQEHIRUH

H[SUHVVLQJLWVHOILQDFWXDOEHLQJ7KLVREVHUYDWLRQFRXOGEHERUQHRXWE\WKHIDFW

WKDWLQVSHDNLQJRIHWHUQDOWUXWKVLWZRXOGQRWEHVDLGWKDWWKH\DUHEHLQJFUHDWHG

QRZEXWWKDWWKH\DUHEHLQJUHYHDOHGQRZLHLQWKHIXOOQHVVRIWLPH.LHUNHJDDUG

SS,,$

1RZWKHFRQVLVWHQF\RIWKHLGHDOVXEVLVWLQJSHUKDSVWR.LHUNHJDDUGLQWKH

GLYLQHPLQGPDQLIHVWVLWVHOISDUWLFXODUO\²DQGKHUHOLHVKLVFHQWUDOLQWHUHVW²LQ

VLQJXODUH[LVWHQFH)RUWKLVUHDVRQWKHWUXHEHLQJDWWULEXWHGWRLWE\3ODWRFRU

UHVSRQGVWRWKHWUXHEHLQJDVVXPHGE\LQGLYLGXDOVXEMHFWLYLW\LQ.LHUNHJDDUG·V

WKRXJKW

,QRWKHUZRUGV.LHUNHJDDUGDSSURDFKHVWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHWKHLGHDOIURPWKH

VWDQGSRLQWRIWKHHLGHWLFLQWXLWLRQRIVLQJXODUH[LVWHQFH+HGRHVQRWVWUHVVWKH

UHDOLW\RIWKHFRPPRQDQGFRQVWLWXWLYHLQLWVHOIEXWUDWKHUWKHVXEMHFWLYHH[SH

ULHQFHRIWKLV´WUXWK´WRPHµWKLV´IRFXVµ´WKLVLQQHUFHQWUHRIJUDYLW\µWKDQNV

WRZKLFKWKHKXPDQEHLQJPD\FDOOKLPVHOI´,µ.LHUNHJDDUGSS,

$7RWKHVXEMHFWLYHSKLORVRSKHUKHZDQWHGWREHLGHDVDUHFRQFHLYHGDV

´WKHQDWXUDOÁRZHUVRIWKHWUHHRIOLIHµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS,$,Q

WKLVVHQVHLWFDQEHFOHDUO\VHHQWKDWWKH\DUHDVWKH\ZHUHLQ3ODWR·VWKRXJKW

dynamis VHOIPDQLIHVWLQJWKHDFWLYHSRZHUSHUVRQDOIUHHGRPFRQVWLWXWHV

,QSULQFLSOHZHPLJKWFODLPWKDW.LHUNHJDDUGKDVSHUIRUPHGDVRUWRIH[L

VWHQWLDO WXUQ LQ UHODWLRQ WR 3ODWRQLF PHWDSK\VLFV E\ VWDUWLQJ IURP WKH LQQHU

H[SHULHQFHUHYHDOLQJWKHJUHDWFDWHJRULHVRIVSLULWXDOEHLQJZKLFKLVDVOHJL

WLPDWHDVWKHH[WHUQDOH[SHULHQFHRIVHQVLEOHFRVPRV7KH$WKHQLDQSKLORVR

SKHUDWWHPSWVWRDFFRXQWIRUWKHRQJRLQJDQGPXWDEOHPXOWLSOLFLW\WKURXJK

WKHGLDOHFWLFDQGUHODWLRQDOG\QDPLVPRIWKHDEVROXWHDQGHWHUQDO.LHUNHJDDUG

VHHNVWRH[SODLQHPSLULFDOFRQWLQJHQF\DQGWHPSRUDOLW\WKURXJKWKHGLDOHFWLF

LQWHQVLYHDQGUHODWLRQDOEHFRPLQJRIWKHIUHHEHLQJZKRDFKLHYHVDQDEVROXWH

DQGHWHUQDOV\QWKHVLV7R3ODWRWKHVXSUHPHJHQHUDFRQVWLWXWHWKHZRUOGLQDQ

RUGHUO\ZD\7RWKH'DQLVKH[LVWHQWLDOLVWWKH\FRQVWLWXWHWKHUHDOLWLHVRUGHULQJ

VSLULWXDOH[LVWHQFHWKURXJKZKLFKKLVWRU\DQGWKHZRUOGZLOOSDVVLQRUGHUWR

REWDLQWKHLURZQLQWHOOLJLELOLW\LQDQGWKURXJKLW7KHLGHDOPDGHÁHVKDQG

EORRGLQLQQHUOLIHLHH[LVWHQWLDOO\UHFHLYHGE\SDUWLFLSDWLRQFRQFUHWLVHVWKH

PXWDEOHDQGWHPSRUDODQGWRXFKHGE\HWHUQLW\WUDQVIRUPVDWWKHVDPHWLPH

WKHHQWLUHXQLYHUVH

,QP\YLHZWKLVPHWDSK\VLFDOVXEMHFWLYHRUH[LVWHQWLDOWXUQKDGEHHQGHYH

ORSLQJHYHUVLQFHWUDQVFHQGHQWDOSKLORVRSK\WXUQHG3ODWRQLFLGHDVLQWRWKLQ

NLQJODZVODLGGRZQE\WKLQNLQJLWVHOIZKLOHWUDQVIRUPLQJVSHFXODWLRQLQWRD

WKHRU\RIFRQVFLRXVQHVVDSKLORVRSK\RIWKHVXEMHFW6WDUWLQJIURPWKDWLQLWLDO

FRQYHUVLRQWKH+HJHOLDQV\VWHPDGYDQFHGRQVXEMHFWLYLW\GHFODULQJLWVLGHQ

WLW\ZLWKWKHREMHFWRIÀQLWHFRQVFLRXVQHVVZKLFKLVFDSDEOHRIFRQVXPPDWLQJ

LWVVHOIUHÁHFWLRQLQWKHDEVROXWHLGHDLQRUGHUWRFRQFUHWLVHWKHDEVWUDFWDQG

LQWHOOHFWXDOFRQFHSWRI3ODWRQLFSKLORVRSK\

:LWK+HJHOSKLORVRSK\NHSWWKHLQWHOOHFWXDOVSHFLÀFDWLRQVWDPSHGRQLWE\

PRGHUQLW\DVZHOODVWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHVXSUHPHFDWHJRULHVZKLFK

DUHPXWXDOO\LPSO\LQJMXVWDV3ODWRKDGFODLPHG,QIDFWWKHDQFLHQWSKLORVR

SKHUDQGWKHPRGHUQV\VWHPDWLFLDQFRLQFLGHDVWRWKHUHFLSURFDOLPSOLFDWLRQRI

FRQWUDULHVZKLFKLVSUHVHQWLQHYHU\VLQJXODUEHLQJLQWKHIRUPRIDGLDOHFWLF

UHTXLUHPHQWWKDWLPSRVHVLWVHOIRQWKHXQLW\DQGLGHQWLW\RIWKHUHDO7KLVPHDQV

WKDWWRERWKUHDOLW\ZRXOGKDYHDIXQGDPHQWDOO\GXDOVWUXFWXUHE\YLUWXHRI

ZKLFKHDFKFRQWUDU\DSSHDUVDQGFRQWLQXHVLQWKHRWKHU1HYHUWKHOHVV3ODWR

DQG+HJHOZRXOGGLVDJUHHDERXWWKHQDWXUHRIWKHRSSRVLWLRQGLIIHUHQFHPXO

WLSOLFLW\LQGHWHUPLQDWLRQWRWKHIRUPHUDQGQHJDWLRQDVDIRUFHWKDWSHUYDGHV

DQGPRGLÀHVHYHU\ZD\RIEHLQJWRWKHODWWHU

7KHQHJDWLYHYDOHQFHRIRWKHUQHVVUHSUHVHQWHGDVDGHVWUXFWLYHSRZHUDV

DQDFWLYHIRUFHQHJDWLQJEHLQJLVDOVRSUHVHQWLQ.LHUNHJDDUG+HVKDUHVZLWK

3ODWRDQG+HJHOWKHLGHDRIDIXQGDPHQWDOO\GXDOVWUXFWXUHRIWKHUHDOZKHUH

FRQWUDULHVLPSO\HDFKRWKHUDQGRQHQHVVFRQVWLWXWHVWKHUHPRWHVWJRDORIDVSL

UDWLRQ7KH'DQLVKH[LVWHQWLDOLVWVKDUHVZLWKWKH*HUPDQV\VWHPDWLFLDQDORQH

KRZHYHUWKHDIÀUPDWLRQRIWKHHQRUPRXVGLDOHFWLFSRWHQWLDORIQRQEHLQJ

$VIROORZVIURPWKLVEULHIKLVWRULFDOGLVFXVVLRQ.LHUNHJDDUGZRXOGVHHP

WRKDYHUHFHLYHGIURPPRGHUQWKRXJKWWKHVSHFXODWLYHSULPDF\RIVXEMHFWLYLW\

ZKLFKHFKRHVLQKLPWRVXFKDQH[WHQWWKDWKLVSKLORVRSK\PD\EHVHHQDVD

WKHRU\RIWKHVXEMHFW+LVVXEMHFWUHÁHFWVLWVHOIDVWKHREMHFWRIDQLPSRVVLEOH

IUHHGRP2QWKHRQHKDQGLWPDQLIHVWVLWVHOILQWKHLGHDRIDQLGHDO,ZKLFKLV

VKRZQWRWKHVSLULWDVWKHGXHHQGRILWVRZQEHFRPLQJ2QWKHRWKHUKDQGLW

LVEHLQJFRQVWDQWO\EHOLHGE\VLQJXODUKLVWRU\DQGIRUHYHUQHJDWHGE\WKHDFWLYH

SUHVHQFHRIWKHRWKHUDWWKHYHU\FRUHRIVDPHQHVV7KHPXWXDOLPSOLFDWLRQRI

EHLQJDQGQRQEHLQJZKLFKDPRXQWVWRWKHPXWXDOEHORQJLQJRILGHQWLW\DQG

GLIIHUHQFHFRUUHVSRQGVWKXVWRWKHG\QDPLVPRIWKH,ZKLFKZDQWVRQHQHVVLQ

VSLWHRIWKHQRWKLQJQHVVDWWKHYHU\ERWWRPRILWVFRQVWLWXWLRQ

7KHLGHDOQHVVRQZKLFK.LHUNHJDDUG·VLQWHUHVWIRFXVHVUHJXODWHVWKHVXE

MHFW·V FRQVFLRXVQHVV DQG DIÀUPV LWVHOI DV D SUHVXSSRVLWLRQ RI WKDW FRQVFLR

XVQHVVLQWKHVHOIFRQVFLRXVSRVLWLRQRIWKH,LHLQWKHDIÀUPDWLRQRIDIUHHGRP

WKDWLQYROYHVEHLQJDQGWKLQNLQJUHDOLW\DQGLQWHOOLJLELOLW\7KXVWKHLGHDLV

WRKLPWKHSURGXFWRIDVXEMHFWLYHDFWLRQWKDWSDUDGR[LFDOO\WUDQVFHQGVLWV

RZQLPPDQHQFHDQGJUDIWVWKHVXEMHFWRQWRWKHGLYLQH6SLULWXDOUHDOLW\ZKLFK

KDVEHFRPHVXFKWKURXJKWKHYLWDOUHDOLVDWLRQRIWKHLGHDSRVVHVVHVWKHXQLW\

JRRGQHVVDQGWUXWKWKDW3ODWRDWWULEXWHVWRWKHUHDOEHFDXVHRILWVSDUWLFLSDWLRQ

LQWKH2QHDQGWKDW.LHUNHJDDUGDWWULEXWHVWRWKHKXPDQEHLQJWKDWLVWUDQV

SDUHQWO\IRXQGHGRQ*RG$VWRWKHUHVW.LHUNHJDDUGZDQWVKLV*RGWRHVFDSH

WKHDEVWUDFWLRQRIWKHXQPRYHGPRYHULQRUGHUWREHFRQFHLYHGWRJHWKHUZLWK

WKH3ODWRQLF$EVROXWHIURPWKHH[LVWHQWLDOSRLQWRIYLHZDVDOLYLQJUHVSRQVH

WRH[LVWHQWLDOUHVWOHVVQHVV

7KHLGHDFRQFHLYHGE\.LHUNHJDDUGFRQVWLWXWHVWKHHQGRIH[LVWHQWLDODVSLUD

WLRQE\ZKLFKH[LVWHQFH\HDUQVWREHZKDWLWLVQRW\HWVRWKDWLWVQRQLGHQWLW\

PD\EHFRPHWUXWKDQGJRRGDQGRQHQHVV,QWKLVVHQVHWKH'DQLVKWKLQNHU·V

FRQFHSWRIH[LVWHQFHDSSURDFKHVWKDWRI3ODWR·VérosWKH´RIIVSULQJRIWKHLQÀ

QLWHDQGWKHÀQLWHWKHHWHUQDODQGWKHWHPSRUDOZKLFKWKHUHIRUHLVFRQVWDQWO\

VWULYLQJµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS9,,)ROORZLQJLQWKHIRRWVWHSVRIWKH

$WKHQLDQSKLORVRSKHU.LHUNHJDDUGFRQFHLYHVH[LVWHQFHDVDWHPSRUDODQGÀQLWH

PeníaEHJRWWHQDQGIHFXQGDWHGE\WKHPóros RIHWHUQLW\DVDVHOISURGXFLQJIRUFH

JLYLQJELUWKWRLWVHOILQLQH[KDXVWLEOH/LJKW7KH,LVWKHIUXLWRIWKDWORYHWKHPRVW

EHDXWLIXOFRQFHSWLRQE\WKHGLYLQHUDFHZKLFKZDQWHGWRFRQTXHUQRWKLQJQHVV

$QGMXVWDVWKHÀUVWÀDWLVWKHRQO\SRZHUFDSDEOHRIXQLYHUVDOEHLQJWKHÀDWRI

KXPDQORYHLVWKHRQO\SRZHUFDSDEOHRISHUVRQDOEHLQJ+HQFHWKHH[LVWHQWLDO

SUDLVHRIWKHIUHHSRZHURIéros: ´,WLVDQLQFUHGLEO\VWXSHQGRXVGLVFXVVLRQRIWKH

SRZHURIORYHWRHQQREOHDPDQLHRIWKHUHELUWKRIPDQWKURXJKErosZKLFK

PD\EHIRXQGLQSymposiumµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS,,,$

The Penía-PórosGLDOHFWLFDVVXPHGERWKE\3ODWRQLFérosDQGE\.LHUNHJDDU

GLDQH[LVWHQFHLVWKHDQWKURSRORJLFDOHPERGLPHQWRIDPHWDSK\VLFDOGLDOHFWLF

WKDWFRQVWLWXWHVWKHÀQLWHEHLQJDVVXFKDQGDFFRUGLQJWR3ODWRWKHLQWHOOLJLEOH

ZRUOGDVZHOO1RZDGHJUHHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQERWKWKLQNHUVVKRXOGEHSRLQ

WHGRXWWKDWEHFRPHVHVVHQWLDO3ODWRUHIHUVUDGLFDORWKHUQHVVWRWKHVXSUHPHSULQ

FLSOHVDQGFODLPVLWLVUHFHLYHGE\SDUWLFLSDWLRQE\WKHRWKHUEHLQJVDVGLIIHUHQFH

.LHUNHJDDUGFRQFHLYHV2WKHUQHVVDVDEVROXWHFRQWUDGLFWLRQDQGORFDWHVLWLQWKH

LPPDQHQFH RI WKH ÀQLWH DQG UHODWLYH VXEMHFWLYLW\ RI WKH KXPDQ EHLQJ ,Q WKLV

VHQVH:DKOKROGVWKDW´WKHH[LVWHQFHRI2WKHUQHVVRIQRQEHLQJZKLFK3ODWR

KDGDEVWUDFWO\VWDWHGLQSophistLVKHUHDVVHUWHGLQFRQFUHWRµ:DKOSS

WRVXFKDQH[WHQWWKDW´QHYHUKDVWKHDQWLQRP\DWWKHERWWRPRIParmenides EHHQH[SHULHQFHGVRGHHSO\µ:DKOSS.HSWE\ÀQLWHVXEMHFWLYLW\

QRQEHLQJGLIIHUHQFHWKHRWKHUFRQVWLWXWHVLWVQHJDWLRQIRUZKLFKWKHUHDVRQLV

WZRIROG2QWKHRQHKDQGÀQLWHVXEMHFWLYLW\LVWKHRXWFRPHRIWKHPHWDSK\VLFDO

OLPLWWKDWFRQVWLWXWHVLWDQGVHSDUDWHVLWIURPWKHUHVWDV3ODWRPDLQWDLQV2QWKH

RWKHUKDQGLWDOVRVSOLWVDZD\IURPLWVHOIDQGFRXQWHUDFWVLWVHOIE\YLUWXHRIDQ

RULJLQDOSRVVLELOLW\WKDWLVSDUDGR[LFDOO\WKHSRVVLELOLW\RILWVEHLQJ

7R 3ODWR ´WKH 2QH SUHFHGHV VHSDUDWLRQ DQG RQO\ ZLWK VHSDUDWLRQ GRHV

QXPEHUVWDUW>7R.LHUNHJDDUG@2QHQHVVSUHFHGHVFRQWUDGLFWLRQDQGRQO\ZLWK

FRQWUDGLFWLRQGRHVH[LVWHQFHVWDUWµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS,,,$7KLV

SULPHYDORQHQHVVPD\EHFRQVWUXHGHLWKHUDVWKHGLYLQH$EVROXWHRUDVWKH

HVVHQFLDOFRQVWLWXWLRQRIIUHHGRPZKLFKIRUHVKDGRZHGE\WKHLGHDEHFDPH

ORVWDWWKHEHJLQQLQJRIH[LVWHQWLDOEHFRPLQJ,IIUHHGRPKDGQRWIDOOHQLILWKDG

QRWEHHQPRUWDOO\ZRXQGHGÀQLWHEHLQJZRXOGQRWKDYHEHJXQEHFDXVHDOO

EHJLQQLQJSUHVXSSRVHVQRWKLQJQHVV

+HQFHÀQLWHVXEMHFWLYLW\LVQRWIRUXVFRQVWDQWO\DQGIURPQHFHVVLW\,QGHHG

LWGRHVQRWFRQVWLWXWHDQDIÀUPDWLRQRIEHLQJSXUHDQGVLPSOHEXWKDVWRHPHUJH

H[QLKLORDVWKHGLDOHFWLFDIÀUPDWLRQRIEHLQJDJDLQVWQRWKLQJQHVVDQGPRUH

SUHFLVHO\RIIUHHGRPLHVSLULWXDOEHLQJDJDLQVWVLQ,QRWKHUZRUGVLQP\

YLHZ.LHUNHJDDUGZRXOGÀQGLQWKH,WKHPHWDSK\VLFDOVWUXFWXUHWKDWVKDSHV

WR3ODWRWKHSXUHUHDOLW\RIWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHLQLWVHOI7KLVPHDQVWKDWWKHIRUPHU·V

H[LVWHQWLDOLVPZRXOGLQFOXGHDXQLYHUVDOFDWHJRULVDWLRQRIÀQLWHVXEMHFWLYLW\

DQDORJRXVO\YDOLGIRUDOOEHLQJVVLQFHWRKLPDZKROHFRQFHSWLRQRIOLIHDQG

WKHZRUOGPD\EHGHGXFHGIURPWKHVLQJXODU

Parmenides DQGSophistIXQGDPHQWDOO\LOOXPLQDWHGE\WKHXQZULWWHQGRFWUL

QHVUHSUHVHQW3ODWR·VHQGHDYRXUWRVDYHWKHPXOWLSOLFLW\RIWKHUHDOIURP3DU

PHQLGHDQPRQLVP$QDORJRXVO\.LHUNHJDDUG·VH[LVWHQWLDOLVPZRXOGFRQVWL

WXWHDQHIIRUWWRVDYHWKHLQGLYLGXDOIURPZKDWKHFDOOV+HJHOLDQSDQWKHLVP

1RZWKHLURULJLQDOLQWHQWLRQZRXOGVHHPWRKDYHUHTXLUHGUHVRUWLQJWRRWKHU

QHVVWRLWVVXSUHPHDEVROXWHFRQWUDGLFWLRQYDOHQFHDQGWRLWVDGGHGYDOXHDV

SRZHU7KHODWWHUZRXOGEHWKHSRZHURIWKHQHJDWLYHPHWDSK\VLFDOO\DFWLQJ

HLWKHURQWKHSOXUDOLW\RIWKHLQWHOOLJLEOHDQGVHQVLEOHZRUOGLQRUGHUWRVKDSH

EHLQJRURQIUHHGRPWRVKDSHWKH,

7RSXWLWEULHÁ\.LHUNHJDDUGLDQRWKHUQHVVGRHVQRWWDNHSODFHLQWKHLQWHO

OLJLEOHZRUOGLQRUGHUWRSURYLGHWKHIRXQGDWLRQRIWKHLPPHGLDWHRUGHURI

EHLQJEXWLQWKHLQQHUH[SHULHQFHRIWKHVLQJXODUZKLFKMXVWLÀHVDQ\UHÁHFWHG

RSSRVLWLRQEHWZHHQLGHDDQGSKHQRPHQRQ,QRWKHUZRUGVWKH'DQLVKH[LVWHQ

WLDOLVWZRXOGIURPWKH3ODWRQLFVWDQGSRLQWSDVVIURPDPHWDSK\VLFRFRQFHS

WXDOFRQFHSWLRQRIH[SHULHQFHWRDQHWKLFRPHWDSK\VLFRFRQFHSWXDORQHVLQFH

KHVHHVIUHHG\QDPLVPDVWKHGHHSHVWRULJLQRIPHWDSK\VLFDONQRZOHGJH7KLV

FDQEHVHHQLQDVHQVHLQWKHIROORZLQJWH[W´'RXEWFRPHVHLWKHURIUHODWLQJ

UHDOLW\WRLGHDOQHVV²WKLVLVFRJQLWLRQVLQFHGLVFRXUVHLVDERXWLQWHUHVWDQG,

DPLQWHUHVWHGDWPRVWLQVRPHWKLQJRWKHUWKDQPHHJLQWUXWK2URIUHODWLQJ

LGHDOQHVVWRUHDOLW\DQGWKLVLVWKHHWKLFDOPRPHQWLQZKLFKLWLV,WKDWDPLQWH

UHVWHGLQP\VHOI'RXEWFDQQRWEHRYHUFRPHE\V\VWHPEXWE\IDLWKMXVWDV

IDLWKKDVEURXJKWGRXEWLQWRWKHZRUOGµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS,9%

7KHWH[WIROORZLQJWKLVH[SUHVVO\UHIHUVWRIUHHGRPDVWKHRULJLQRIDQGVROXWLRQ

WRGRXEW

,IIUHHGRPFRQVWLWXWHVWKHGHHSHVWURRWRIPHWDSK\VLFDONQRZOHGJHLWIRO

ORZVWKDWDUHIRXQGDWLRQRIWKHVSHFXODWLYHVSKHUHPD\EHSURYLGHGIURPRXW

VLGHWKHUHDOPRIWKHKXPDQO\UDWLRQDO7KLVLVQRWPHUHO\DWKHRU\RINQRZOHGJH

SUREOHPEXWDQRQWRORJLFDOTXHVWLRQ:LOOLQJLVORFDWHGLQWKH2QHZKHUHDV

RQHQHVVLVVHHQDVWKHRULJLQDOSRVVLELOLW\RIWKH,DQGÀQLWHUHDVRQDVDFRQVH

TXHQFHRIHYLO7KHERWWRPXSUHODWLQJRIWKHUHDOWRWKHLGHDOWR.LHUNHJDDUG

WKHWKHRU\RINQRZOHGJHSUREOHPLVDWVWDNHKHUHHQWDLOVDGLDOHFWLFSDVVDJH

%XWWKHWRSGRZQUHODWLQJRIWKHLGHDWRWKHUHDOWKLVLVVDLGWREHWKHGHFLVLYH

LVVXHHQWDLOVDSDWKHWLFSDVVDJH7KLVLVH[SODLQHGDVIROORZV´$Q\PDQPD\

FRQFHLYHDSDWKHWLFSDVVDJHZKHQHYHUKHZDQWVEHFDXVHIRULQÀQLWXGHZKLFK

OLHVLQSDWKRVFRXUDJHLVHQRXJK7KURXJKDVLPLODUSDVVDJH3ODWRFODLPHGWKDW

*RGMRLQHGLGHDVWRPDWWHUµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS,9&7KH.LHU

NHJDDUGLDQUHIRXQGDWLRQRIWKHVSHFXODWLYHZKLOHNHHSLQJWKHERWWRPXSGLD

OHFWLFRINQRZOHGJHFRQFHLYHVHWKLFDODFWLRQDVWKHSURSHUO\FUHDWLYHPRPHQW

DQDORJRXV WR GHPLXUJLF HIIHFWLYHQHVV 7KLV LV FDSDEOH RI UHSURGXFLQJ LQ WKH

ZRUOGWKHUHDOLQWHOOLJLELOLW\SUHVXSSRVHGE\DOONQRZOHGJHLQWHQGLQJWRVSHDN

WKHODQJXDJHRILQÀQLWXGHDQGHWHUQLW\

7KLVLVQRWWRVD\WKDWWKH.LHUNHJDDUGLDQGHVFHQWUHVSRQGVIURPDQHWKLFDO

VWDQGSRLQWWRWKH3ODWRQLFDVFHQWIURPWKHUHDOWRWKHLGHDO,IWKLVZHUHWKH

FDVHZHZRXOGVLPSO\VSHDNRIDQH[LVWHQWLDODSSOLFDWLRQRIWKHPHWDSK\VLFDO

RURIDWKHRUHWLFDOJXDUDQWHHRIWKHPRUDOEXWQHYHURIWKHRUHWLFRPHWDSK\VL

FDOWKLQNLQJ7RSXWLWPRUHDFFXUDWHO\.LHUNHJDDUGGRHVQRWDVVXPH3ODWRQLF

PHWDSK\VLFVDVDVSHFXODWLYHVXSSRUWRIKLVH[LVWHQWLDOSKLORVRSK\RUKLVHWKLFV

²KHJURXQGVHWKLFVRQLWVHOIGHHSHQVLWDQGUHIRXQGVKLVZRUOGYLHZRQLW

$QGKHFDQGRLWSUHFLVHO\EHFDXVHKHKDVGLVFRYHUHGIUHHGRPLHVXEMHF

WLYHDFWLRQLQE\DQGIRULWVHOIZKLFKXQGHUOLHVDOOLGHDOQHVVDQGUHDOLW\7KH

DFWLRQRIWKH,ZKLFKFRQVWLWXWHVLWVRZQFDXVHDQGHIIHFWH[SODLQVERWKNQR

ZLQJDQGEHLQJDFFRUGLQJWRWKHSULQFLSOH

,DFWHUJRVXPEHFDXVHWKLVFRJLWRLVVRPHWKLQJGHULYDWLYHLHLVDOVRLGHQWLFDOZLWK

©,DFWªLHLVWKHFRQVFLRXVQHVVRIIUHHGRPLQDFWLRQDQGWKHUHIRUHZHFDQQRWVD\

FRJLWR HUJR VXP LQ RWKHU ZRUGV LW LV DQ DWWHQGDQW FRQVFLRXVQHVV .LHUNHJDDUG

SS,9&

)UHHGRP LGHQWLÀHV DFWLRQ ZLWK VHOIFRQVFLRXVQHVV LQ ´GRLQJ WKH WUXWKµ

.LHUNHJDDUGSS,9&V\QWKHVLVLQJLGHDOQHVVDQGUHDOLW\7KH

VSLULWXDOGHQVLW\RIEHLQJLVIRXQGHGRQWKLVV\QWKHVLVQRWWKURXJKSXUHFRQ

WHPSODWLRQEXWWKURXJKWKHHIIHFWLYHDQGSDUDGR[LFDOFRQFUHWLVDWLRQRIZKDW

ZLWKRXWEHLQJH[LVWV

,Q.LHUNHJDDUGLDQWHUPVWKHDFWLYHVHOIFRQVFLRXVQHVVRIIUHHGRPFRLQFLGHV

ZLWKWKHFRQVFLRXVQHVVRIDQDEVROXWHFRQWUDGLFWLRQRURIDSDUDGR[ZKLFK

UXOLQJRXWDOOGLDOHFWLFFRQWLQXLW\FRPSHOVWKHSDWKHWLFSDVVDJH0DKULN

SS3DUDGR[LHDEVROXWHGLIIHUHQFHFRQVWLWXWHVWRKLPWKHHVVHQWLDOIRUP

RIÀQLWHIUHHGRPZKLFKKHDVVLPLODWHVWR&KULVWLDQLW\UHPDUNLQJ´$ERXWWKH

SDUDGR[DQGDEVXUGLW\RI&KULVWLDQLW\QRWKLQJFDQEHVDLGLQP\YLHZH[FHSW

WKDWLWLVFHUWDLQO\WKHÀUVWIRUPLQERWKWKHKLVWRU\RIWKHZRUOGDQGFRQVFLR

XVQHVVµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS,9&7KHÀUVWIRUPRIFRQVFLRXVQHVV

DQGRIKLVWRU\LHWKHIRUPRIIUHHGRPLQDFWLVWKHYHU\FRQWUDGLFWLRQJLYLQJ

ULVHWRH[LVWHQFHZKLFKLVDIÀUPHGLQWKHVHSDUDWLRQRIWKHKXPDQEHLQJIURP

*RGWKHGHSDUWXUHIURPWKH2QHDQGWKHORVVRIXQLW\

,QDWH[WFDOOHG´DEVROXWHSDUDGR[µ.LHUNHJDDUGFODLPV´%HFDXVHSKLORVR

SK\LVPHGLDWLRQLWFDQQRWHQGEHIRUHSODFLQJWKHXOWLPDWHSDUDGR[LQIURQWRI

LWVH\HV7KLVSDUDGR[LVWKH0DQ*RGµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS,9&

7KHVSHFXODWLYHGHQVLW\RIWKHHVVHQWLDOO\SDUDGR[LFDOOLHVSUHFLVHO\LQWKHPHWD

SK\VLFDORSSRVLWLRQWKURXJKZKLFKIUHHGRPLVDZDUHRILWVEHLQJEHIRUH*RG

DVEHIRUHWKHFKDVPRITXDOLWDWLYHGLIIHUHQFHZKLFKRQO\SDWKHWLFSDVVDJHPD\

EULGJH+HQFH:DKOSRLQWVWRWKLVEHLQJEHIRUH*RGWKHKXPDQEHLQJV·WKHDQ

GULFUHDOLW\DVDQHVVHQWLDOHOHPHQWRIVLQLHDVWKHRWKHUZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKH

Other0RUHRYHUGLIIHUHQFHEHFDXVHRILWVSDUDGR[LFDOQDWXUHVXUSDVVHVÀQLWH

XQGHUVWDQGLQJWREHFRPHTXRDGQRVDQGWKHVXEMHFWRIP\VWLFDOH[SHULHQFH

3DYOLNRYD 0DKULN%LQHWWL 3DYOLNRYD3DYOLNRYD =DOHF

=DOHF 3DYOLNRYD

7KXV.LHUNHJDDUGLDQRWKHUQHVVWDNHVSODFHVLQÀQLWHVXEMHFWLYLW\DQGIRU

WKLVYHU\UHDVRQFRQVWLWXWHVDV:DKOFODLPVWKHPRVWGHHSO\H[SHULHQFHGIXQ

GDPHQWDODQWLQRP\7KLVPHDQVWKDWWR.LHUNHJDDUGUDGLFDOGLIIHUHQFHFRXOG

QRWH[LVWZLWKRXWWKHDIÀUPDWLRQRIKXPDQZLOOLQJZKLFKWDNHVSODFHDEVROX

WHO\LQWKHDIÀUPDWLRQRIWKHDXWDXWDQGLVLQVHSDUDEOHIURPWKHVHOISRVLWLRQ

RIJRRGDQGHYLODWWKHYHU\FRUHRIIUHHGLDOHFWLF7KLVLVWDQWDPRXQWWRPDLQ

WDLQLQJWKHUHDOLW\RIVLQDVWKHYROXQWDU\SRVLWLRQRIWKHKXPDQEHLQJEHIRUH

*RGVHOISUHVXSSRVHGE\LWVRZQUHDOLVDWLRQVRWKDWKLVDFWLRQPD\EHIUHH

DQGQDWXUDODWWKHVDPHWLPH,QWKLVVHQVH.LHUNHJDDUGFODLPVWKDW´VLQSUH

VXSSRVHVLWVHOIDQGFRPHVLQWRWKHZRUOGLQVXFKDZD\WKDWLQSRVLWLQJLWVHOI

LWSUHVXSSRVHVLWVHOIµ.LHUNHJDDUGSS,9

%XWVLQZKLFKLVWKHGLIIHUHQFHRIÀQLWHIUHHGRPDQGWKHUHIRUHLVQRWWR

.LHUNHJDDUGLPPHGLDWHEXWUHÁHFWHGDEVROXWHO\RSSRVHVDQRWKHU)UHHGRP

LHGLYLQH)UHHGRP,WVKRXOGEHKLJKOLJKWHGWKDWKHUH.LHUNHJDDUGGHSDUWV

IURP 3ODWRQLF WKRXJKW VLQFH KLV G\DG LV QRW D QHFHVVDU\ DQG LQGHSHQGHQW

GHULYDWLYHRIWKHLPSHUVRQDO2QHEXW*RGWKH)DWKHU·VIUHHDQGORYLQJFUH

DWLRQ:KDWSURSHUO\VHSDUDWHV.LHUNHJDDUGIURP3ODWRLV&KULVWLDQLW\ZKLFK

VLQFHLWVYHU\EHJLQQLQJKDVDVVHUWHGWKH$EVROXWH·VIUHHSDWHUQLW\DJDLQVWWKH

KHDWKHQ

&KULVWLDQWKRXJKWKDUPRQLVHVGLYLQHDQGKXPDQIUHHGRPE\PHDQVRID

VSLULWXDO URXQG WULS +HQFH LQ PDLQWDLQLQJ *RG·V IDWKHUKRRG .LHUNHJDDUG

GHSDUWVIURPWKHLQH[RUDEOHQHVVRIWKH3ODWRQLF2QHLQÁXHQFHGE\&KULVWLD

QLW\7RKLPWKHGLIIHUHQFHLVWKDWEHWZHHQWZRIUHHGRPV1RZZKRFDXVHVWKH

.LHUNHJDDUGLDQGLIIHUHQFHRIIUHHGRP*RGRUWKHKXPDQEHLQJ"7KHKXPDQ

EHLQJGRHVVLQFHKLVRZQSRVLWLRQSUHVXSSRVHVLWDFFRUGLQJWR.LHUNHJDDUG$

VHFRQGTXHVWLRQDULVHV:KDWLVWKHPHWDSK\VLFDOFDWHJRU\RIGLIIHUHQFHRIVLQ

DVSUHVXSSRVHGE\KXPDQIUHHGRP",WLVTXDOLWDWLYHGLIIHUHQFHLHWKHGLVWLQF

WLRQEHWZHHQLQÀQLWHDQGÀQLWHLHÀQLWXGH

%HLQJWKHTXDOLWDWLYHO\GLIIHUHQWIURPWKH,QÀQLWHÀQLWXGHLVFHUWDLQO\DVVX

PHGDQGUHDOLVHGE\WKHKXPDQEHLQJ·VIUHHDFWLQJLQWKHVHQVHWKDWRQO\LQLW

LV*RGDFNQRZOHGJHGDVVXFKZKLFKLVLQVHSDUDEOHIURPVLQFRQVFLRXVQHVVDV

KXPDQVHOIDFNQRZOHGJHPHQW1HYHUWKHOHVVDQGLQDQRWKHUVHQVHÀQLWXGHLV

DQHFHVVLW\RIIUHHGLYLQHFUHDWLRQEHFDXVHDOWKRXJK*RGPD\FUHDWHRUQRW

RQFHKHGHFLGHVWRGRLWKHFDQRQO\SURGXFHÀQLWHEHLQJV7KXVTXDOLWDWLYH

GLIIHUHQFHLVVHOISUHVXSSRVHGE\KLVFUHDWLYHDFWLRQMXVWDVLQWKHKXPDQEHLQ

J·VFDVH

7KXVERWKIUHHGRPVSURGXFHWKHVDPHGLIIHUHQWLDOHIIHFW%RWKFRQWDLQHYLO

DVDSRVVLELOLW\EXWRQFHLQDFWUHDOLVHLWDVQHFHVVDU\+HUHWKH3ODWRQLFXQL

YHUVHFRLQFLGHVDJDLQZLWKWKH&KULVWLDQXQLYHUVHDQGWKHG\DGEHFRPHVDQ

LQGHSHQGHQWFRXQWHUSRZHURQFHWKHGLYLQHSRZHUKDVGHFLGHGWRFUHDWH7KH

GLIIHUHQWLDO HIIHFW ZRXOG FRPSULVH WKHQ WKH WKHDQGULF V\QHUJ\ .LHUNHJDDUG

GHIHQGHGDSSO\LQJLWWRIUHHDFWLQJDQGVSHFLÀFDOO\WRWKHSUREOHPRIHYLO

ZKLFKKHFRQFHLYHVDVUHDOSRVLWLRQDQGQRWDVGHSULYDWLRQ,WLVLQWKLVVHQVH

WKDW,LQWHUSUHWWKHIROORZLQJ.LHUNHJDDUGLDQWH[W

&KULVWLDQLW\KDVEHHQWKHÀUVWWRVKHGOLJKWRQWKHFRQFHSWRIV\QHUJ\DQGWKH

UHIRUHWKLVLVWKHÀUVWWLPHÀQLWXGHKDVDWWDLQHGZRUWKVSHFXODWLRQVXSSRUWDQG

IUHHGRPUHDOLW\7KHÀUVWGHWHUPLQDWLRQRI&KULVWLDQLW\E\V\QHUJ\LVVLQ7KXVVLQ

LVQRWMXVWÀQLWXGHEXWWKHUHLVDPRPHQWRIIUHHGRPDQGDPRPHQWRIIUHHÀQLWXGH

LQVLQ,,,$

7RSXWLWEULHÁ\ERWKÀQLWXGHFRQWULEXWHGE\*RGDQGÀQLWHIUHHGRPLH

WKH,FRQWULEXWHGE\WKHKXPDQEHLQJFRRSHUDWHRQVLQ

.LHUNHJDDUGLDQGLIIHUHQFHWKHQRUDWOHDVWSDUWRILWLVKXPDQIUHHGRPRU

H[LVWHQFHLWVHOI7KLVLVVHSDUDWHGIURPLWVHOIDQGWKHOtherE\WKHTXDOLWDWLYH

FODVKEHWZHHQWKHRQHDQGWKHPXOWLSOHUHVWDQGEHFRPLQJEHLQJDQGQRQ

EHLQJJRRGDQGHYLOWKHLQÀQLWHDQGWKHÀQLWHHWHUQLW\DQGWLPHWKHLGHDODQG

KLVWRU\OLPLWDQGLQGHWHUPLQDWLRQ6XFKRSSRVLWLRQWHDUVIUHHDFWLRQDSDUW7R

SXWLWPRUHFOHDUO\IUHHGRP·VVHOISRVLWLRQFRLQFLGHVZLWKLWVQHJDWLRQSUHFL

VHO\EHFDXVHLWLVGLIIHUHQFHWKDWLVDIÀUPHGZKLFKLVSHUFHLYHGE\VXEMHFWLYLW\

RQFHLWKDVIRXQGLWVHOILQIURQWRI*RG%HIRUH*RGWKH,LVWKHRWKHUDQGIURP

QRZRQLWZLOOVHHNLWVLGHQWLW\RXWVLGHLWVHOIDELGLQJLQWKH2QHZKLFKGLVUH

JDUGVRSSRVLWLRQDQGFRLPSOLHVHYHU\WKLQJ

)LQLWHIUHHGRPLVWKHRWKHUZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKH2QO\2QHLQLWVHOILWVYROXQ

WDU\UHMHFWLRQWKHÀUVWQHJDWLRQRIWKHÀUVWIURPZKLFKPXOWLSOLFLW\WKHUXS

WXUHDQGGLVSHUVLRQRIVSLULWXDOUHDOLW\DULVH,WFRQWDLQVWKHFRQWUDGLFWLRQRIDQ

DXWDXWRQDQGE\ZKLFKHYHU\IRUPRIGLDOHFWLFLVIRXQGHGDQGPDGHSRVVL

EOH)UHHGRPKDVEHHQERUQJXLOW\DQGZLOODOZD\VEHDQRWKHUZLWKUHVSHFWWR

LWVHOIIRUDVORQJDVLWOLYHV7KLVHQDEOHVWKHSOXUDOLW\RIRSWLRQVSUHVHQWHGWR

IUHHZLOOWKHLPPHGLDWHGLDOHFWLFRIEDGÀQLWXGHRURIWKHZRUVWLQÀQLWXGHWKH

LURQLFLQGLIIHUHQFHRIDHVWKHWLFVDQGWKHKXPRXURIWKHUHOLJLRXVPRFNLQJWKH

ZRUOG

+XPDQJXLOWPDNHVH[LVWHQFHDPL[WXUHRIWZRSULQFLSOHVDQXQOLPLWHG

LQGHWHUPLQDWHDQGLQÀQLWHPDWHULDOSULQFLSOHDQGDOLPLWLQJGHWHUPLQLQJDQG

XQLI\LQJIRUPDORQH7KHIRUPHUPDNHVIUHHGRPSRVVLEOHWKHODWWHUPDNHVLW

QHFHVVDU\EXWDOZD\VDVSRVVLEOHIURPZKLFKWKHFRQWLQXRXVFRQWLQJHQF\RI

LWVGHÀQLWLRQDQGRQHQHVVDULVHV$VIUHHGRPLVDOZD\VJXLOW\H[LVWHQFHLVD

SDUDGR[LFDOPL[WXUHDQDEVROXWHFRQWUDGLFWLRQDQGLWVEHLQJEHIRUH*RGWKH

PRPHQWRIVLQ

7KHEHFRPLQJRI.LHUNHJDDUGLDQIUHHGRPZKLFKLVLGHDODQGUHDOdynamis DW WKH VDPH WLPH XQLÀHV LQ LWVHOI WKH LQWHOOLJLEOH DQG VHQVLEOH PRWLRQ RI WKH

3ODWRQLFXQLYHUVH+HQFHLWVLPPDQHQWGLIIHUHQFHRSSRVHVDGH[WUDERWKWKH

SXUHO\ÀQLWHDQGWKHSXUHO\HWHUQDO+RZHYHULWLVWKHDEVROXWHGLPHQVLRQWKDW

RSHUDWHVWKHUDGLFDOQHVVRIWKHRSSRVLWLRQZKHUHDVWKHUHLVDOZD\VDGHJUHH

RIUHODWLYLW\UHJDUGLQJWKHÀQLWHZKLFKHQDEOHVUHSHWLWLRQ2QWKHRWKHUKDQG

WKHÀQLWHQHJDWHVWKHÀQLWHRQO\VXFFHVVLYHO\ZKHUHDVIUHHGRPGHQLHVLWVHOI

FRPSOHWHO\EHIRUH*RGLQWKHVLPXOWDQHLW\RIDEHLQJWKDWFRQIRUPVWRWKDWRI

WKHEHLQJRQZKLFKLWLVIRXQGHG)RUWKLVUHDVRQIUHHGRPLVWKHRQO\UHDOLW\

FDSDEOHRIEHLQJE\QRWEHLQJQHJDWLQJLWVRZQOLIHRUOLYLQJLWVRZQGHDWKDQG

HWHUQDOO\FRQWUDFWLQJDPRUWDOVLFNQHVVWKDWUHSURGXFHVDQGHPSRZHUVHYLOOLNH

DQHVVHQWLDOPHWDVWDVLV-XVWDV3ODWRDIÀUPVWKHUHDOLW\RIQRQEHLQJLQSophist, .LHUNHJDDUGDIÀUPVHYLODVDSRVLWLYHFRXQWHUSRZHUDQDFWLYHSRZHURUDQ

DOPLJKWLO\GHVWUXFWLYHSRVLWLRQ

%XW IUHHGRP ZKLFK KDV FHUWDLQO\ EHFRPH DQRWKHU LV QRW DQRWKHU EXW LQ

DVVXPLQJLWVVDPHQHVVDQGWKRXJKLWSURGXFHVGLIIHUHQFHLWRQO\GRHVLWWKUR

XJK SDUWLFLSDWLQJ LQ LGHQWLW\ 3UHFLVHO\ EHFDXVH IUHHGRP SDUWLFLSDWHV LQ WKH

2QHVLQDIÀUPVLWVHOIQRWRQO\DVRWKHUQHVVZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHOtherEXWDOVR

DVRWKHUQHVVZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHVDPHLHDVDORVVRILGHQWLW\VWHPPLQJIURP

WKHIDOORIFUHDWLRQDPL[WXUHRIEHLQJDQGQRQEHLQJ,QWKLVVHQVHLWPD\EH

FODLPHGWKDWDV.LHUNHJDDUGSXWVLW´WKHUHVXOWRIWKHGLYLVLRQRIDXQLW\LQWKH

VSLULWXDOZRUOGLVDOZD\VWKUHHQHYHUWZRµSS,9%^LHWKH

EHLQJLQ%HLQJRIQRQEHLQJ

3DUWLFLSDWLRQLQRQHQHVVLVWKHLQQHUDVSHFWRIIUHHGRPWKHSULQFLSOHDQG

IRXQGDWLRQ WR ZKLFK LW LV FDOOHG EDFN IURP WKH H[LOH RI VHSDUDWLRQ 3UHFLVHO\

EHFDXVHRILWVLQQHUFKDUDFWHURQHQHVVLVWR.LHUNHJDDUG´WKHWUXHplhrojoría, ZKLFKJURZLQJVWURQJHUDQGVWURQJHUWXUQVWKHXQIRUHVHHQZLQGVIDUWKHUDQG

IDUWKHU DZD\ DQG YLFWRULRXV OHDGV WKH KXPDQ EHLQJ EH\RQG DQ\ REVWDFOHµ

SS,,$+HQFHWKHLUUHVLVWLEOHIRUFHZLWKZKLFKH[LVWHQFHWHQGV

WRWKH2QHWRWKH:KROHWRWKHFRPSOLFDWLRWKDWQHJDWHVDOOFRQWUDGLFWLRQDQG

´LVZKROO\SUHVHQWERWKLQHDFKRQHLQSDUWLFXODUDQGLQDOOµ.LHUNHJDDUG

SS,,,$7KHRPQLSUHVHQFHRIWKH2QH:KROHPDNHVDOOWKH6DPH

DQGIUHHGRPDSURPLVHRIHTXDOLW\WKDWKDVDOUHDG\EHHQIXOÀOOHGWKRXJKLWKDV

QRWUHDFKHGWKHFUHVFHQGRRILWVLQWHQVLW\\HW

,GHQWLW\GHIRUPHGE\WKHIDOODSSHDUVEHIRUHKDQGDVWKHWRWDOUHVWRIIUH

HGRP ZKHUHDV LWV RQHQHVV GLYLGHG IURP LWVHOI LQ HVVHQFH IRUHVKDGRZV WKH

FRPLQJEDFNWRJHWKHURIRSSRVLWHV,QRWKHUZRUGVLWVLJQDOVWKHUHSHWLWLRQRI

WKHPXOWLSOHLQWKH2QHRIEHFRPLQJLQWKH,PPXWDEOHRIQRQEHLQJLQ%HLQJ

RI WKH ÀQLWH LQ WKH ,QÀQLWH RI WLPH LQ (WHUQLW\ +RZHYHU SDUDGR[LFDOO\ WKH

UHWXUQRIIUHHGRPWRLWVRULJLQDOFRQGLWLRQLVLQLWVHOILPSRVVLEOHEHFDXVHÀQLWH

IUHHGRPLVDOVRLQLWVHOIGXDOLW\LQGLIIHUHQFH,QWKLVVHQVHRQO\2QHQHVVLQ

LWVHOIPD\JXDUDQWHHDQGEULQJDERXWDOORQHQHVV

2QO\*RGFDQIXOÀOWKHLGHQWLW\RIKXPDQIUHHGRPGHVWUR\LQJGLIIHUHQFH

DQGSURGXFLQJKLVRZQOLNHQHVV,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHFRLQFLGHQFHRIFRQWUDULHV

FDQRQO\EHUHDOLVHGE\KHZKRRYHUFRPHVDOOFRQWUDGLFWLRQDQGLVWKHVRXUFH

RIDOOSHUIHFWLRQZKRVHVLPSOLFLW\UHMHFWVGLYLVLRQZKRVHSRZHULJQRUHVWKH

LPSRVVLEOHDQGZKRVHQDPHLV/RYHEHFDXVHRQO\ORYHFDQWXUQHYLOLQWRJRRG

/RYHIRUJHWVVLQDQGLWVIRUJHWIXOQHVVLVWDQWDPRXQWWRGHVWUXFWLRQ7KURXJK

ORYHWKHUHLVIRUJLYHQHVVDQGLQIRUJLYHQHVVWKHUHFRQFLOLDWLRQRIWKHZRUOGLV

DFKLHYHG1RWLQYDLQGRHV:DKOFRQFOXGH´WKLVRWKHURQHLVORYHµS

ZKLFKSURJUHVVHVWRZDUGVLove

/RYH LV PRUH SHUIHFW WKDQ IDLWK EHFDXVH ZKHUHDV WKH ODWWHU DWWHPSWV WKH

SDUDGR[LFDO XQLRQ RI RSSRVLWHV ZKLFK LV ORVW DJDLQ HDFK WLPH /RYH XQLWHV

RYHUFRPLQJ GLIIHUHQFH DQG SURGXFLQJ OLNHQHVV RXW RI WKDW ZKLFK SUHFLVHO\

WKURXJKOLNHQHVVNHHSVWKHSXULW\RILWVRWKHUQHVV,Q/RYHWKHSXULW\RIRWKHU

QHVVVKLQHVDVSXUHFUHDWXUHQHVVXQEOHPLVKHGZLWKRXWFRQIXVLRQRUVHSDUD

WLRQDVFUHDWLRQGHYRLGRIDOOHYLOEHFDXVH´nihil extra Deum, nihil praeter Deumµ

.LHUNHJDDUGSS,,,$LVOHIWLQLW7RSXWLWPRUHDFFXUDWHO\

/RYHGHVWUR\VWKHHYLORIIUHHÀQLWXGHEXWQRWÀQLWXGHWKHGLIIHUHQFHRIWKH

GLIIHUHQWEXWQRWWKHGLIIHUHQWIURPWKH(TXDOEHFDXVHLWVIDLWKIXOQHVVLVLQFD

SDEOHRIQHJDWLQJZKDWLWKDVRQFHORYHG)UHHÀQLWXGHGLIIHUHQWLDWHVWKHRWKHU

GLYLQH/RYHPDNHVLWHTXDOOLNHDERQGWKDWXQLWHVWKH:KROHZLWKLWVHOI3ODWR

SSESUHVHUYLQJWKHSXULW\RIWKHRWKHULQLWVRZQVDPHQHVV,Q*RG

HYHU\WKLQJVKLQHVOLNHWKRVH´opposita iuxta se posita magis illucescuntµ.LHUNH

JDDUGSS,9$

+RZHYHUWKHERQGRI/RYHLVWRH[LVWHQFHDGHVLGHUDWXPDQHQGOHVVSDWK

DORQJZKLFKWKHIXOOQHVVRIAgaphEHFRPHVNQRZQWKURXJKVOLJKWWRXFKHV,W

ZLOODOZD\VEHLQQRVDQGTXRDGQRVWKHpeniaWKDWGHVSHUDWHO\SD\VHYHU\

LQVWDQWRILWVOLJKW

Conclusion

-XVWDVWKHFODVVLFDOZRUOGHPEDUNHGRQWKHWDVNRIDFFRXQWLQJIRUWKHH[WHU

QDOH[SHULHQFHRIWKHVHQVLEOHWKHPRGHUQZRUOGDVVXPHGWKHUHVSRQVLELOLW\

RIH[SODLQLQJLQQHUH[SHULHQFHEHLWLGHDOPRUDORUFRJQLWLYH$QGMXVWDVWKH

$WKHQLDQSKLORVRSKHUVWDUWVZLWKWKHODQJXDJHRILPPHGLDWHUHDOLW\DQGOHDSV

IURP LW WR LWV LQWHOOLJLEOH IRXQGDWLRQ WKH 'DQLVK H[LVWHQWLDOLVW FRQVLGHUV WKH

VHOIFRQVFLRXVODQJXDJHRILQGLYLGXDOIUHHGRPLQRUGHUWRH[SODLQDQ\RWKHU

UHÁHFWLRQWKURXJKLW

%XW ERWK VHDUFKHV OHDG WR D VLQJOH VSHFXODWLYH DQVZHU DQG FXOPLQDWH LQ

WKH VDPH PHWDSK\VLFDO FDWHJRULVDWLRQ ZKLFK DSSOLHV DQDORJRXVO\ WR HYHU\

WKLQJUHDO,QGHHGEHLQJDQGQRQEHLQJLGHQWLW\DQGGLIIHUHQFHRQHQHVVDQG

RWKHUQHVV UHVW DQG EHFRPLQJ H[SODLQ WKH GLDOHFWLF LQWHQVLYH DQG UHODWLRQDO

G\QDPLVPRIentia$WWKHVDPHWLPHWKH\HVVHQWLDOO\GHWHUPLQHWKHSRZHURI

KXPDQH[LVWHQFHLQÀQLWHO\SRVVLEOHDQGIRUHYHUGHSHQGLQJRQWKHDEVROXWH

7KXVWKHKLVWRU\RIWKRXJKWKDVUHSHDWHGWKHVDPHLQWKHRWKHUDFKLHYLQJ

WKHIXQGDPHQWDOFRQWLQXLW\FKDUDFWHULVWLFRISKLORVRSKLFDOWKLQNLQJZKLFKPD\

GHHSHQLQGHÀQLWHO\EXWLVFRQVWDQWO\VXEMHFWWROLPLWDWLRQ7KURXJKUHSHWLWLRQ

WKLQNLQJVWDUWVUHWHOOLQJDQDORJRXVO\DVWRU\WKDWKDVDOUHDG\EHHQQDUUDWHG

DQGE\WKHHQGRILWVGLVFRXUVHWKHLQHIIDEOHH[SHULHQFHWKDWQHLWKHU3ODWRQRU

.LHUNHJDDUGKDVEHHQDEOHWRGHVFULEHLVRQFHDJDLQOHIWRXW

7KHP\VWHU\RIGLIIHUHQFHLVQHLWKHU.LHUNHJDDUGLDQQRU3ODWRQLF,WKDVQR

QDPHDQGWKHUHIRUHHYHU\QDPHQDPHVLWLQWKHLQQHUVLOHQFHWKDWGLDORJXH

\HDUQVIRUUHVWLQJRQWKHHTXDOLW\IRUZKLFKWKHSRRUVLQJXODUDQGH[LVWLQJéros NHHSVRQORQJLQJ

Acknowledgment

7KHZRUNLVSHUIRUPHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKH5XVVLDQ*RYHUQPHQW3URJUDPRI

&RPSHWLWLYH*URZWKRI.D]DQ)HGHUDO8QLYHUVLW\

References

>@ $ULVWyWHOHVAristotle´s Metaphysics. 9RO*UHDW%ULWDLQ2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV

>@ %LQHWWL0 3DYOLNRYD0.LHUNHJDDUGRQWKHUHFRQFLOLDWLRQRIFRQVFLHQFHXLinguae, 12GRL;/

>@ +HLEHUJ3$.XK9 7RUVWLQJ((GVSøren Kierkegaard´s Papirer >6¡UHQ.LHU

NHJDDUGV3DSHUV@. 9RO .¡EHQKDYQ*\OGHQGDO

>@ 'UDFKPDQQ$%+HLEHUJ-//DQJH+2,EVHQ$ +LPPHOVWUXS-(GV

Søren Kierkegaards Samlede Værker>6¡UHQ.LHUNHJDDUGV&RPSOHWH:RUNV@. 9RO .¡EHQKDYQ

*\OGHQGDO

>@ 0DKULN77KHJROGHQUXOHRIPRUDOLW\$QHWKLFDOSDUDGR[Ethics and Bioethics (in Central Europe), 8KWWSVGRLRUJHEFH

>@ 3DYOLNRYD0 0DKULN7$XGHQ·VFUHDWLYHFROOLVLRQZLWK.LHUNHJDDUGXLinguae, 13(3),GRL;/

>@ 3DYOLNRYD0 =DOHF%6WUXJJOHIRUWKHKXPDQVHOIDQGDXWKHQWLFLW\.LHUNHJDDU

G·VFULWLTXHRIWKHSXEOLFHVWDEOLVKHGRUGHUPHGLDDQGIDOVH&KULVWLDQLW\Bogoslovni Vestnik, 79GRL%93DYOLNRYD

>@ 3ODWR  6RSKLVW Plato in Twelve Volumes. 9RO  &DPEULGJH +DUYDUG 8QLYHUVLW\

3UHVV/RQGRQ:+HLQHPDQQ/WG5HWULHYHG'HFHPEHUIURPKWWSZZZSHUVHXV

WXIWVHGXKRSSHUWH[W"GRF 3HUVHXV$WH[W$$WH[W'6RSK

>@ 3ODWR  6\PSRVLXP Plato in Twelve Volumes. 9RO  &DPEULGJH +DUYDUG 8QLYHUVLW\

3UHVV/RQGRQ:+HLQHPDQQ/WG5HWULHYHG'HFHPEHUIURPKWWSZZZSHUVHXV

WXIWVHGXKRSSHUWH[W"GRF 3HUVHXV$WH[W$$WH[W'6\P

>@=DOHF% 3DYOLNRYD0&LYLFYLUWXHVDQGIXQFWLRQVRIUHOLJLRQLQSXEOLFOLIHEuro- pean Journal of Science and Theology, 15

>@:DKO-Études Kierkegaardiennes>.LHUNHJDDUGLDQ6WXGLHV@3DULV-9ULQ