Widok Lęk ironistki. Jażń ludzka w kulturze literackiej Richarda Rorty'ego

:LW3LHWU]DN

Lęk ironistki.

Jaźń ludzka w kulturze literackiej

Richarda Rorty’ego

3U]H]RVWDWQLHVWRSLĊüG]LHVLąWODW¿OR]R¿DSRGZLHORPDZ]JOĊGDPLFRUD] Z\UDĨQLHM]EOLĪDáDVLĊGRV]HURNRSRMĊWHMOLWHUDWXU\:\QLNDMąFD]WHJRPDULDĪX ]PLDQDVWDWXVX¿OR]R¿LRGQRVLVLĊSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPGRPHWRG\MHMXSUDZLDQLD RUD]SRGHMĞFLDGRXVWDOHĔ=MHGQHMVWURQ\LQWHUSUHWDF\MQDZROQRĞüD]GUXJLHM RGU]XFHQLHGRJPDWX3UDZG\SU]H]GXĪHÄ3´XF]\QLá\G\VNXUV\¿OR]R¿F]Q\ L¿NF\MQ\ZVSyOQLNDPLZG]LHOHRSLVXNRQG\FMLOXG]NLHM1DURG]LP\PJUXQFLH MHGQ\P]QDMZDĪQLHMV]\FKWHRUHW\NyZNWyU]\XND]DOLZVSyáLVWRWQRĞüOLWHUDWXU\ L¿OR]R¿LMHVW0LFKDá3DZHá0DUNRZVNL3RVWXODW\VZRMH0DUNRZVNLZ\SUD-FRZXMHZRGQLHVLHQLXQDMSLHUZGR'HUULG\SyĨQLHM]DĞGR1LHW]VFKHJRÄ-HĞOL >«@¿OR]R¿DPRĪHE\üWUDNWRZDQDMDNRªURG]DMSLVDUVWZD©±]DXZDĪD0DUNRZ-VNL±WRQLHGODWHJRĪHPRĪHFDáNRZLFLH]HUZDü]ZáDVQąWUDG\FMąSURFHGXUDPL LVSRVREDPLOHJLW\PL]DFMLHIHNWyZVZRMHMDNW\ZQRĞFLOHF]GODWHJR±LMHVW WRSU]\SDGHN'HUULG\±ĪHZQLH]Z\Ná\VSRVyESRWUD¿SRáąF]\üĞFLVáąDUJX-PHQWDFMĊ]ªOLWHUDFNLP©LGLRPHPQLHRSXV]F]DMąFNUĊJXS\WDĔRQDMRJyOQLHMV]H ZDUXQNLPRĪOLZRĞFLWHJRFRMHVWLMDNMHVW´-HG\QLHWDNLHÄQLH]Z\NáHSRáąF]HQLH´ XPRĪOLZLDÄMHGQRF]HVQHXSUDZLDQLH¿OR]R¿LLSUREOHPDW\]RZDQLHMHMVWDWXVX UR]V]F]HSLHQLHMHMSRZLQQRĞFLQDXVWDODQLHªPHWRGRORJLF]Q\FK©UHJXáLUHJXáW\FK SRGGDZDQLHSUyELHF]\WDQLDLSLVDQLD´௘13RGREQLHFKRüE\GRVá\QQHMKochanicy francuza-RKQD)RZOHVDJG]LHQDUUDFMD¿NF\MQDSU]HPLHV]DQDMHVW]SDVVXVDPL SRĞZLĊFRQ\PLUHÀHNVMLQDGWHFKQLNąSUR]DWRUVNą2SLVDUVWZR¿OR]R¿F]QHPXVL MDNSRZLDGDZRGQLHVLHQLXGR'HUULGLDĔVNLHMDQDOL]\+XVVHUOD&KULVWRSKHU 1RUULVMHGQRF]HĞQLHP\ĞOHü]DSRPRFąZ\SUDFRZDQ\FKXSU]HGQLRNRQFHSWyZ

RUD]SRGZDĪDüLFKRF]\ZLVWRĞüL]QDF]HQLHSRGáXJWHMNRQFHSFMLP\ĞOHQLHWRSR- 0LFKDá3DZHá0DUNRZVNLEfekt inskrypcji. Jacques Derrida i literatura+RPLQL .UDNyZV±  /LF]QHXZDJLQDUUDWRUD]ZUDFDMąFHXZDJĊQDMHM¿NF\MQ\VWDWXVÄ2SRZLHĞüNWyUą VQXMĊMHVWW\ONRWZRUHPZ\REUDĨQL6WZRU]RQHSU]H]PQLHSRVWDFLHQLHLVWQLDá\QLJG\SR]D PRMąLPDJLQDFMą´௘QDNáDQLDMąGRSU]HP\ĞOHQLDSRGVWDZRZ\FK]DVDGIXQNFMRQRZDQLDG]LHáD ¿NFMLOLWHUDFNLHM-RKQ)RZOHVKochanica FrancuzaSU]Há:.RPRUQLFNDĝZLDW.VLąĪNL :DUV]DZDV

VáXJLZDQLHVLĊQDU]ĊG]LDPLNWyUH]DNDĪG\PUD]HPWU]HEDGRNáDGQLHVSUDZG]Lü F]\DE\QDSHZQRVáXĪąQDV]\PFHORP3_{7RWHĪGHNRQVWUXNFMDZ\ZUDFDMąF} QDQLFHXWDUWHNDWHJRULHLVSRVRE\UR]XPRZDQLDRWZLHUDSU]HG¿OR]R¿ąQRZH ĞFLHĪNLP\ĞOHQLDNWyUH'HUULGDQD]\ZD,QQ\PL¿OR]R¿LÄ/LWHUDWXUDMHVWW\ONR MHGQ\P]W\FKNRQLHF]QLHPQRJLFK,QQ\FK6WDQRZL,QQHNWyUHQLHLVWQLHMHSR]D ]ERNX¿OR]R¿LOHF]ZHZQąWU]QLHM>«@´௘4)LOR]R¿DZXMĊFLX'HUULG\]DZG]LĊF]D RWZDUFLXQDOLWHUDWXUĊSU]HVWU]HĔQLH]QDQ\FKGRWąGPRĪOLZRĞFLNWyUHSR]ZDODMą XZROQLüVLĊMHMRGW\UDQLLNDWHJRULLÄSUDZG\RVWDWHF]QHM´ 8F]\QLHQLHOLWHUDWXU\IRUPąMDNUyZQLHĪSU]HGPLRWHPQDP\VáX¿OR]R¿F]QHJR QLHZ\V]áRRF]\ZLĞFLHSRUD]SLHUZV]\RG'HUULG\LMHJRSRNROHQLDMXĪERZLHP 1LHW]VFKHSLVDáSRGREQąÄ¿OR]R¿ĊOLWHUDFNą´QLHGRJPDW\F]QąLDV\VWHPDW\F]Qą 0DUNRZVNLĞZLHWQLHSRND]XMHLQVSLUDFMĊOLWHUDFNąZG]LHOH1LHW]VFKHJRF]\QLąF SRMĊFLHLQWHUSUHWDFMLQDGU]ĊGQąNDWHJRULą¿OR]R¿F]QąÄ:HGáXJ1LHW]VFKHJR ĞZLDWWHNVWLVWQLHMHW\ONRGODWHJRĪHLVWQLHMąLQWHUSUHWDFMHQLHLVWQLHMHĞZLDW QLH]LQWHUSUHWRZDQ\ERLQWHUSUHWRZDOQRĞüMHVWSRGVWDZRZ\PZDUXQNLHPMHJR LVWQLHQLD´௘5ĝZLDW]DWHPMHVWNRQVWUXNFMąSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKLQWHUSUHWDFMLDFR]DW\P LG]LHLVWQLHMHMDNRSHUVSHNW\ZLF]QDPRĪOLZRĞüERNDĪGDZ\NáDGQLDSU]HNV]WDáFD U]HF]\ZLVWRĞüNWyUDMHVWPRĪOLZDW\ONRMDNRFLąJáD]PLHQQRĞü:WDNLPXMĊFLX U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLURODV]WXNLZRJyOHMHVWQLHSRGZDĪDOQD6]F]HJyOQLHLVWRWQHVą MHMGZLHIXQNFMH3RSLHUZV]HVSHáQLDRQDÄIXQNFMĊNU\W\F]Qą´]RVWDMHERZLHP XĪ\WDSU]H]1LHW]VFKHJRGRÄUR]ELyUNLGZyFK>«@]GH]DNWXDOL]RZDQ\FKW\SyZ Z\NáDGQLZ\NáDGQLQDXNRZHMLZ\NáDGQLPRUDOQHM´3RGUXJLH]DĞV]WXNDÄMHVW QLHW\ONRWZRU]HQLHPSLĊNQ\FKIRUPDOHVSRVREHPLVWQLHQLDF]áRZLHNDNWyU\ WZRU]\ZDUWRĞFLLSU]HNUDF]DZáDVQHRJUDQLF]HQLDZ\]ZDODMąFVLĊMHGQRF]H-ĞQLHVSRGZáDG]\QRZRF]HVQHMGHNDGHQFML>«@´௘SRSU]H]VLOQHLQWHUSUHWDFMH ZV]WXFHF]áRZLHNWZRU]\ÄQRZąZ\NáDGQLĊĞZLDWD´௘6:V]HONLHZDUWRĞFLĞZLDWD ELRUąVLĊQLH]WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHJRQDGDQLDDOHVąWZRUDPLVLOQ\FKLQWHUSUHWDFML Ä2WRFRSU]HQLNDPRMHSLVPD±VWZLHUG]D1LHW]VFKH±WRĪHZDUWRĞüĞZLDWDWNZL ZQDV]\FKLQWHUSUHWDFMDFK>«@ĪHGRW\FKF]DVRZHLQWHUSUHWDFMHE\á\RFHQDPL SHUVSHNW\ZLF]Q\PL]JRGQLH]NWyU\PLSRGWU]\PXMHP\VZHĪ\FLHWR]QDF]\ VZąZROĊPRF\ZLPLĊZ]URVWXPRF\ĪHNDĪGHZ\Z\ĪV]HQLHF]áRZLHNDQLHVLH

]VREąSU]H]Z\FLĊĪHQLHZĊĪV]\FKLQWHUSUHWDFMLĪHNDĪGHX]\VNDQHZ]PRFQLH- &KULVWRSKHU1RUULVWhat’s Wrong with Postmodernism7KH-RKQV+RSNLQV8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV%DOWLPRUHV

 &\W]D0DUNRZVNLEfekt inskrypcjiV

 0LFKDá3DZHá0DUNRZVNL1LHW]VFKH)LOR]R¿DLQWHUSUHWDFML8QLYHUVLWDV.UDNyZ V

QLHLSRZLĊNV]HQLHPRF\RWZLHUDQRZHSHUVSHNW\Z\LVNáDQLDGRZLDU\ZQRZH KRU\]RQW\´௘7_{ĝZLDWWRIDQWD]PDWVNRQVWUXRZDQ\SU]H]VLOQąZ\REUDĨQLĊNWyUD} QDGURG]HLQWHUSUHWDFMLQLHW\ONRZ\WZDU]DQRZ\REUD]U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLDOHWHĪ QDQRZRSU]HSLVXMHMDĨĔOXG]Ną)LOR]R¿DZHGáXJ1LHW]VFKHJRL'HUULG\WRVD-PRĞZLDGRP\G\VNXUVPDMąF\QDFHOXWZRU]HQLHQRZ\FKLQWHUSUHWDFMLĞZLDWD MHGQRF]HĞQLHNZHVWLRQXMąFPRĪOLZRĞüRVLąJQLĊFLDZ\NáDGQLSUDZG]LZHM 7DNLHDQW\HVHQFMDOLVW\F]QHXMĊFLH¿OR]R¿LVWDQRZLIXQGDPHQWQDNWyU\P5L-FKDUG5RUW\EXGXMHVZRMąSRVWPHWD¿]\F]QąZL]MĊÄNXOWXU\OLWHUDFNLHM´:áDĞQLH Z\NáDGQLWHJRSRMĊFLDFKFLDáE\PVLĊZQLQLHMV]\PWHNĞFLHSU]\MU]HüQLHFREOLĪHM 3RMĊFLHNXOWXU\OLWHUDFNLHM]DNáDGDMDNZLDGRPRGZDNOXF]RZHZ\]QDF]QLNL PDMąFH]DSHZQLüMHMUDFMĊE\WXF]\OLGRJáĊEQąLURQLĊRUD]VROLGDUQRĞü:\GDMH VLĊMHGQDNĪHQLHFRZWOHSLVDUVWZDDXWRUDKonsekwencji pragmatyzmuGDVLĊ GRVWU]HFWU]HFLNOXF]RZ\HOHPHQWRSLVXMąF\VWUXNWXUĊÄOLWHUDU\FXOWXUH´DPLD-QRZLFLHGRMPXMąFHSRF]XFLHOĊNX W Konsekwencjach pragmatyzmu5RUW\VWZLHUG]DĪHÄGZXG]LHVWRZLHF]Q\ WHNVWXDOL]PFKFHZFHQWUXP>NXOWXU\@XV\WXRZDüOLWHUDWXUĊRUD]WUDNWRZDüQDXNĊ L¿OR]R¿ĊMDNRZQDMOHSV]\PZ\SDGNXJDWXQNLOLWHUDFNLH´௘8 3RÄ]ZURFLHMĊ]\NR-Z\P´MDN5RUW\QD]\ZDUHZROXFMĊSRVWVWUXNWXUDOLVW\F]Qą¿OR]R¿DEH]SRZURWQLH XWUDFLáDPRQRSROQD3UDZGĊRVWDWHF]QąW\PVDP\PG]LHOąFORVUHOLJLL]DUyZQR ERZLHPWUDG\F\MQLHSRMĊWD¿OR]R¿DMDNLUHOLJLDRSDUWHVąQDZLHU]HZLVWQLHQLH ÄIDNW\F]QHJRVWDQXU]HF]\´RGNWyUHJR]DOHĪ\QDV]ORV 5HOLJLDPRQRWHLVW\F]QDGDMHQDG]LHMĊQD]EDZLHQLHSRSU]H]ZHMĞFLHZQRZąUHODFMĊ ]SR]DOXG]NąRVREąRQDMZ\ĪV]HMPRF\:LDUDZDUW\NXá\ZLDU\PRĪHE\üW\ONRZWyUQD ZREHFWDNLHMUHODFML'OD¿OR]R¿LZV]DNĪHSUDZG]LZDZLDUDQDOHĪ\GRVDPHMLVWRW\]ED-ZLHQLHSRSU]H]¿OR]R¿ĊSROHJDáRE\QDX]\VNDQLX]HVSRáXSU]HNRQDĔSU]HGVWDZLDMąF\FK U]HF]\ZWHMMHGQHMSRVWDFLZMDNLHMRQHQDSUDZGĊLVWQLHMą9_. :SU]HFLZLHĔVWZLHGRQLFKZNXOWXU]HOLWHUDFNLHMZL]MDQLH]PLHQQHM3UDZG\ ]DVWąSLRQD]RVWDMHSU]H]1LHW]VFKHDĔVNąSUDZGĊÄUXFKOLZąDUPLĊPHWDIRUPH-WRQLPLLDQWURSRPRU¿]PyZ´௘_{:REHFWDNLHJRVWDQRZLVNDZV]HONLHLGHHNWyUH} XZDĪDP\]DSUDZG]LZHVWDMąVLĊW\PF]DVRZRVNXWHF]Q\PLVSRVREDPLRSLVX U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLVáXĪąF\PLUR]ZLą]\ZDQLXSU]\JRGQLHQDSRWNDQ\FKSUREOHPyZ 2E\ZDWHOWDNLHMNXOWXU\VLáąU]HF]\SR]EDZLRQ\MHVWVWDELOQHMMDĨQLNWyUDVWDMH  )ULHGULFK1LHW]VFKH3LVPDSR]RVWDáHSU]Há%%DQDVLDN$OHWKHLD.UDNyZV  5LFKDUG5RUW\Konsekwencje pragmatyzmuSU]Há&.DUNRZVNL,)L63$1:DUV]DZD V  5LFKDUG5RUW\)LOR]R¿DMDNRSROLW\NDNXOWXUDOQDSU]Há%%DUDQ&]\WHOQLN:DUV]DZD V  1LHW]VFKH3LVPDSR]RVWDáHV

VLĊwork in progress5R]ZDĪDMąFNRQVW\WXFMĊSRGPLRWXOXG]NLHJR5RUW\QDGDMH OLWHUDWXU]HPLHMVFHZDĪQLHMV]HZHZVSyáF]HVQHMKXPDQLVW\FHQLĪ'HUULGDF]\LGąF\ ]DSU]\NáDGHPDXWRUDGramatologii0DUNRZVNL5RUW\VXJHUXMHERZLHPĪHF]\-WDQLHMDNQDMZLĊNV]HMOLF]E\SRZLHĞFLL]DSR]QDZDQLHSRVWDFLMH]DOXGQLDMąF\FK MHVWGURJąGRDNXPXODFMLZLHORĞFLMĊ]\NyZRSLVXQDVVDP\FK3RSU]H]F]\WDQLH SRZLHĞFLQDV]DMDĨĔXOHJDFLąJá\P]PLDQRPEH]SU]HUZ\SR]RVWDMąFZRWZDUFLX QDQRZHPRĪOLZRĞFLDXWRGHVNU\SFML6WDQRZLVNR5RUW\¶HJRXZ]JOĊGQLDMąFZDJĊ SRZLHĞFLMDVQRXMPXMH.DFSHU%DUWF]DN .XOWXUDOLWHUDFNDWR>«@SU]HVWU]HĔVZRERGQHMDXWRNUHDFMLLHODVW\F]QLHMV]HJRSRGHMĞFLD GRPRĪOLZRĞFLQDE\ZDQLDQRZ\FKVáRZQLNyZLMĊ]\NyZ1DMZDĪQLHMV]\QLHMHVWWXV\VWHP SRMĊüSR]ZDODMąF\QDDUJXPHQWDFMĊLZQLRVNRZDQLHZMHGQ\PSDUDG\JPDFLHSRMĊFLR-Z\PDOH]PLHQLDQLHW\FKSDUDG\JPDWyZ>«@7RZáDĞQLHNVLąĪNLSU]HGHZV]\VWNLP SRZLHĞFLVąEH]FHQQ\PLSRPRVWDPLGRLQQ\FKSDUDG\JPDWyZSRMĊFLRZ\FKSRQLHZDĪ 5RUW\ZLG]LZSRZLHĞFLRSLVDU]DFKQLHGRĞFLJQLRQ\FKREVHUZDWRUyZUyĪQRURGQ\FKIRUP Ī\FLD>«@,QQ\PLVáRZ\SRZLHĞFLMDNRVZRERGQHJU\Z\REUDĨQLLRSLVyZ]HZ]JOĊGX QDVZRMąSUHF\]MĊRUD]SU]HNUDF]DQLHEDULHULSU]HVąGyZVWDMąVLĊQLHW\ONRSRUWUHWDPL LQQRĞFLDOHUyZQLHĪSRODPLGRĞZLDGF]DOQ\PLQDNWyU\FKPRĪQDWHVWRZDüQLHGRVWĊSQH JG]LHLQG]LHMNRPELQDFMHSHUVSHNW\ZVWDQRZLVNHNVFHQWU\F]QRĞFLLWS11 -HVWZLĊFNXOWXUDOLWHUDFNDZL]MąĞZLDWDZNWyU\PNDĪGDLQQRĞüPDUDFMĊ E\WXLQLHMHVWQDUDĪRQDQDSRWĊSLHQLHF]\ZURJRĞüMHMRE\ZDWHOHERZLHP±]D-]QDMRPLHQL]SU]HUyĪQ\PLVSRVREDPLE\FLD±JRWRZLVąQDDNFHSWDFMĊZV]HONLHM RGPLHQQRĞFL3RZLHĞüDZ]DVDG]LHMHMurealnieniERKDWHURZLHJUDMąWXZLĊF UROĊLQVWUXNWDĪRZ\FKSU]\NáDGyZUyĪQLFZSDUDG\JPDFLHOXG]NLP3RQDGWR MDNVWZLHUG]D5RUW\F]\WDQLHSRZLHĞFLPRĪHUyZQLHĪSRPyFÄZ\NURF]\üSR]D URG]LFyZQDXF]\FLHOLWUDG\FMHLLQVW\WXFMHNWyUHRJUDQLF]DMą>«@QLH]DOHĪQRĞü ZWHQVSRVyESR]ZROLü>F]\WHOQLF]FH@RVLąJQąüZLĊNV]ąLQG\ZLGXDOQRĞüLVD-PRG]LHOQRĞü´௘12_{&KRü5RUW\SLV]HWXRXNRĔF]HQLXDXWRRSLVXRÄRVLąJQLĊFLX} ZLĊNV]HMLQG\ZLGXDOQRĞFL´௘WRMHGQDNSRGVWDZąLVWQLHQLDLIXQNFMRQRZDQLD ZNXOWXU]HOLWHUDFNLHMMHVWFLąJáHSRV]XNLZDQLHLVWZDU]DQLHQRZ\FKOHSV]\FK VáRZQLNyZNWyUHGąĪąGRZ\EDZLHQLDRGHJRW\]PX:GDOV]HMF]ĊĞFLHVHMXWy-bawienie od egotyzmu5RUW\GRFLHUDMąFGRVHGQDVZ\FKUR]ZDĪDĔSRGNUHĞOD LĪWRZáDĞQLHLGHDNRPSOHWQRĞFLMDNLHJRĞRSLVXMHVWQDMZLĊNV]\P]DJURĪHQLHP GODRE\ZDWHODNXOWXU\OLWHUDFNLHM  .DFSHU%DUWF]DNĝZLDWQLHVFDORQ\%LXUR/LWHUDFNLH:URFáDZV  5LFKDUG5RUW\:\EDZLHQLHRGHJRW\]PX3URXVWL-DPHVMDNRüZLF]HQLHGXFKRZH SU]Há$ĩ\FKOLĔVNLÄ7HNVW\'UXJLH´V

/XG]LHF]\WDMąSLVPDUHOLJLMQHLWUDNWDW\¿OR]R¿F]QHĪHE\XFLHFRGQLHZLHG]\QDWHPDW VSUDZSR]DOXG]NLFKQDWRPLDVWSRZLHĞFLF]\WDMąSRWRĪHE\XFLHFRGHJRW\]PXÄ(JR-W\]P´ZW\PVHQVLHZMDNLPXĪ\ZDPWHJRVáRZDQLHR]QDF]DÄVDPROXEVWZD´2]QDF]D FRĞEOLĪV]HJRUDF]HMÄVDPR]DGRZROHQLX´-HVWWRJRWRZRĞüGRX]QDQLDĪHSRVLDGDVLĊ MXĪFDáąZLHG]ĊQLH]EĊGQąGRZV]HONLFKDQDOL]FDáHNRQLHF]QHUR]XPLHQLHQDVWĊSVWZ UR]ZDĪDQHJRG]LDáDQLD13_. &]\WDQLHSRZLHĞFLWRZ\EDZLHQLHRGHJRW\]PXDZLĊFRGRVWDWHF]QHJR SU]HNRQDQLDRSHáQLZLHG]\ZGDQ\PPRPHQFLHOXENZHVWLL 3RMĊFLXHJRW\]PX5RUW\GDMHSU]HFLZZDJĊZVZHMLGHLOLEHUDOQHMLURQLVWNL NWyUąRSLVXMHZ3U]\JRGQRĞFLLURQLLLVROLGDUQRĞFL:\UDĪHQLDWHJRXĪ\ZD5RUW\ ÄGODR]QDF]HQLDWDNLHMRVRE\NWyUDVWDZLDF]RáRSU]\JRGQRĞFLMHJROXEMHMQDMEDU-G]LHM]DVDGQLF]\FKSU]HNRQDĔLSUDJQLHĔ±NRJRĞNWRMHVWQDW\OHKLVWRU\F\VWą LQRPLQDOLVWąE\SRU]XFLüSRJOąGLĪRZH]DVDGQLF]HSU]HNRQDQLDLSUDJQLHQLD PDMąRGQLHVLHQLHGRF]HJRĞLVWQLHMąFHJRSR]D]DVLĊJLHPF]DVXLSU]\SDGNX´௘14_. ,URQLVWNDMHVWZLĊFRVREą]DZV]HJRWRZąGR]PLDQ\VZ\FKSRJOąGyZQDU]HF] OHSV]\FKUR]ZLą]DĔF]\OLWDNLFKNWyUHRNDĪąVLĊVNXWHF]QLHMV]HZGDQHMV\WXDFML 6SRáHF]HĔVWZRLURQLVWHNE\áRE\ZHGáXJ5RUW\¶HJRLGHDOQ\PXVWURMHPOLEHUDOQ\P ÄZNWyU\PERKDWHUHPE\áE\%ORRPRZVNLªVLOQ\SRHWD©DQLHZRMRZQLNNDSáDQ PĊGU]HFF]\SRV]XNXMąF\SUDZG\ªORJLF]Q\©ªRELHNW\ZQ\©QDXNRZLHF´௘15_{. Przez} VLOQHJRSRHWĊ5RUW\UR]XPLHWXZ\WZyUVLáQDWXUDOQ\FK]GROQ\ÄGRRSRZLHG]HQLD KLVWRULLZáDVQHJRSRZVWDQLD]DSRPRFąVáyZNWyU\FKQLJG\SU]HGWHPQLHXĪ\-ZDQR´௘166LOQ\SRHWDMHVWUHZROXF\MQ\PXĪ\WNRZQLNLHPMĊ]\NDNWyU\GRVWDUF]D QDPQRZ\FKVSRVREyZPyZLHQLDRQDVVDP\FKLURQLVWND]DĞ]GDMHVRELHVSUDZĊ ]IDNWXĪHNDĪG\VLOQ\VáRZQLNMHVWRVLąJQLĊFLHPSU]HMĞFLRZ\P 'OD5RUW\¶HJRWDNF]ĊVWRSRGNUHĞODQDÄSU]\GDWQRĞüVáRZQLNyZ´SROHJDQDLFK ]GROQRĞFLGRRSLVDQLDMDNQDMV]HUV]HMOLF]E\RGPLHQQ\FKVWDQRZLVN&]\WDP\ ZLĊFQLHW\ONRSRWRDE\VDPHPXPyFRSLVDüVLĊZVSRVyEFLHNDZV]\LEDUG]LHM QDPQDGDQ\PHWDSLHĪ\FLDRGSRZLDGDMąF\DOHWHĪZFHOXXĞZLDGRPLHQLDVRELH UR]PDLWRĞFLSRVWDZOXG]NLFK]NWyU\PLPRĪHP\PLHüGRF]\QLHQLD7RWHĪ± LURQLDFRGRPRĪOLZRĞFLRVLąJQLĊFLDVáRZQLND¿QDOQHJRQLHMHVWÄSHUPDQHQWQą SDUDED]ą´MDNSLVDá3DXOGH0DQ17ER5RUW\¶HPXQLHFKRG]LRWRĪHE\ZNDĪG\P XĪ\FLXMĊ]\NDZLG]LHüFLąJáHG]LDáDQLHLURQLF]QHJR]HUZDQLDNWyUHSRZRGXMH  5RUW\Wybawienie od egotyzmuV  5RUW\3U]\JRGQRĞüLURQLDLVROLGDUQRĞüSU]Há:-3RSRZVNL:\GDZQLFWZR$% :DUV]DZDV  5RUW\3U]\JRGQRĞüLURQLDLVROLGDUQRĞüV  5RUW\3U]\JRGQRĞüLURQLDLVROLGDUQRĞüV  3DXOGH0DQIdeologia estetycznaSU]Há$3U]\E\VáDZVNL6áRZRREUD]WHU\WRULD *GDĔVNV

ĪHMĊ]\NVWDMHVLĊW\ONRJUąWURSyZ,URQLD5RUW\¶HJRNZHVWLRQXMHSRMHG\QF]RĞü GDQHJRRSLVXDOH]DZV]HPDMąFQDFHOXSRV]HU]HQLHQDV]HM]GROQRĞFLDNFHSWDFML LQQHJRVWDQRZLVND,QQ\PLVáRZ\5RUW\ZLG]LZLURQLL]DVDGĊPRUDOQą$QW\-HVHQFMDOLVW\F]QDSRVWDZDPRUDOQDZLąĪHVLĊ]OXG]Ną]GROQRĞFLą]UR]XPLHQLD RGPLHQQRĞFLFRRVLąJQąüPRĪQDW\PáDFQLHMMHĞOL]QDVLĊPQyVWZRUR]PDLW\FK SRVWDFLOXG]NLFK5RUW\Z\FLąJDZLĊFZQLRVHNĪHPRUDOLVWDPLPXV]ąSU]HGH ZV]\VWNLPE\üNU\W\F\OLWHUDFF\DWRGODWHJRĪHPDMąRQLÄZ\MąWNRZRV]HURNL NUąJ]QDMRP\FK6ąGRUDGFDPLPRUDOQ\PLQLHGODWHJRĪHSRVLDGDMąV]F]HJyOQ\ GRVWĊSGRSUDZG\PRUDOQHMOHF]GODWHJRĪHVąRE\FL3U]HF]\WDOLZLĊFHMNVLąĪHN VąSU]HWROHSLHM]DEH]SLHF]HQLSU]HGU\]\NLHPZSDGQLĊFLDZSXáDSNĊVáRZQLND SRMHG\QF]HMNVLąĪNL´௘18.U\W\F\OLWHUDFF\SRNURMX+DUROGD%ORRPDNWyUHJR5RUW\ GDU]\V]F]HJyOQ\PLZ]JOĊGDPLSRWUD¿ąRWZRU]\üQDPRF]\QDQLHVSRW\NDQH SRáąF]HQLDPLĊG]\SRV]F]HJyOQ\PLG]LHáDPLOLWHUDFNLPLF]\WRSRHW\FNLPL F]\SUR]DWRUVNLPLG]LĊNLF]HPXRVLąJDP\EDUG]LHM]QLXDQVRZDQąZL]MĊ]DZV]H MXĪSU]\JRGQLH]PLHQQHMQDWXU\OXG]NLHM0RUDOQRĞüZNXOWXU]HOLWHUDFNLHMSROHJD ZLĊFQDRGU]XFHQLXHJRW\]PXQDU]HF]VROLGDUQRĞFL]ZV]HONąRGPLDQąLQQRĞFL :WHQVSRVyESRMĊFLDLURQLLLVROLGDUQRĞFLWZRU]ąJáyZQ\]UąE5RUWLDĔVNLHM WHRULLNXOWXU\OLWHUDFNLHMMHGQRF]HĞQLHVWDQRZLąFSRGVWDZRZHFHFK\MDĨQLOL-EHUDOQHM,URQLVWNDVROLGDU\]XMHVLĊ]ZV]\VWNLPLOXGĨPLEH]]QDF]HQLDMDNLP VáRZQLNLHPVLĊSRVáXJXMąLSRGZDUXQNLHPĪHQLHF]\QLąRQLNU]\ZG\EOLĨQLP WROHUXMHRQDNDĪGąIRUPĊRGPLHQQRĞFLRGZáDVQHJRVWDQRZLVND5RUW\FKĊWQLH XWRĪVDPLDVLĊ]RWZDUWąVROLGDUQRĞFLąLURQLVWHNSLV]ąFZLĊNV]RĞüVZRLFKWHNVWyZ ZGXFKXSHáQHMGREUHMZROLSROHPLNLLW\ONRZNUyWNLPIUDJPHQFLH3U]\JRGQRĞFL LURQLLLVROLGDUQRĞFLGRSXV]F]DGRVLHELHP\ĞOĪHVWDQRZLVNRLURQLF]QHPXVL Z\WZDU]DüZF]áRZLHNXSRF]XFLHOĊNX ,URQLVWNĊFDá\F]DVQLHSRNRLHZHQWXDOQRĞüĪHXURG]LáDVLĊZQLHZáDĞFLZ\PSOHPLHQLX ĪHQDXF]RQRMąJUDüZQLHZáDĞFLZąJUĊMĊ]\NRZą2EDZLDVLĊĪHSURFHVXVSRáHF]QLHQLD NWyU\GDMąFMHMMĊ]\NXF]\QLá]QLHMOXG]NąLVWRWĊE\üPRĪHGDáMHMQLHZáDĞFLZ\MĊ]\N DW\PVDP\PXF]\QLá]QLHMQLHZáDĞFLZąOXG]NąLVWRWĊ1LHSRWUD¿MHGQDNSRGDüNU\WH-ULXPWHMQLHZáDĞFLZRĞFL19_. ,URQLVWNDF]\OLDQW\HVHQFMDOLVW\F]QD¿JXUDSRGPLRWRZRĞFLOXG]NLHMUR]XPLD-nej jako work in progressRGF]XZDFLąJáąQLHSHZQRĞüFRGRVZRMHJRDXWRRSLVX 6NRURQLHLVWQLHMHVáRZQLN¿QDOQ\ZNWyU\PPRJáDE\XFKZ\FLüVZRMąQDWXUĊ PXVLMXĪ]DZV]HV]XNDüNROHMQ\FKVSRVREyZRSLVXZáDVQHMWRĪVDPRĞFL5RUW\ V]\ENR]E\ZDWĊPRĪOLZRĞüSU]HNV]WDáFDMąFQLHSRNyMZSRZyGGRUDGRĞFL

 5RUW\3U]\JRGQRĞüLURQLDLVROLGDUQRĞüV±  5RUW\3U]\JRGQRĞüLURQLDLVROLGDUQRĞüV

-HGQDNSU]\JáĊEV]\P]DVWDQRZLHQLXMDVQ\PVWDMHVLĊĪH5RUW\E\üPRĪH WURFKĊSU]HFLZVRELHVXJHUXMHLĪEUDNVáRZQLND¿QDOQHJRPXVLZ\ZRá\ZDü SU]\QDMPQLHMFKZLODPLSRF]XFLHOĊNXNWyUHQRVLZVRELHZV]HONLHFHFK\Z]QLR-VáHJRVWUDFKXSU]HGDEVROXWHP5RPDQW\F]QD]JUXQWXZL]MD5RUW\¶HJRVSRW\ND VLĊZW\PSXQNFLH]NODV\F]Qą¿JXUąGHPLXUJRSRGREQą7\OHĪHJG]LH(PHUVRQ GRVWU]HJDáSU]HĞZLWXEyVWZLRQHMQDWXU\LVWQLHMąFHMWXĪSRGSRZLHU]FKQLąU]HF]\- ZLVWRĞFLZLG]LDOQHM5RUW\ZSUDZG]LHW\ONRSU]H]FKZLOĊVWDMHZREHFQLHSU]H-EUDQHJRRFHDQXPRĪOLZRĞFLMĊ]\NRZ\FK7\PVDP\PUDG\NDOL]XMHRQSURMHNW URPDQW\]PXF]\WR(PHUVRĔVNLHJRF]\QSEOLVNLHJR5RUW\¶HPX6KHOOH\RZ-VNLHJREH]SRĞUHGQLRQDGDMąFQDMZ\ĪV]\PDQGDWWZyUF]\OXG]NLHMNUHDW\ZQRĞFL MĊ]\NRZHM,GLRPMDNRSU]HVWU]HĔQLHRJUDQLF]RQ\FKPRĪOLZRĞFLQDSDZDZLĊF QDG]LHMąLZ]EXG]DSUDJQLHQLHWZRU]HQLDDOHMHGQRF]HĞQLHSUH]HQWXMHSU]HVWU]HĔ SU]HUDĪDMąFRQLHRJDUQLRQąZNWyUHMLURQLVWNDQLJG\QLHRGQDMG]LHVSRNRMX 'DMHWXRVRELH]QDüOĊNLURQLVWNLSU]HGZáDVQąVNRĔF]RQRĞFLąSU]HG+H-LGHJJHURZVNąMHG\QąQDMEDUG]LHMZáDVQąPRĪOLZRĞFLąMHVWHVWZD-HĞOLSRWHQFMDá MĊ]\NDMHVWQLHVNRĔF]RQ\WRF]áRZLHNVND]DQ\MHVWQDEH]RZRFQHSRGUyĪH SRVNU\SWRULXPNVLąĪHNMXĪQDSLVDQ\FKZFHOXSRV]HU]DQLDVLHELHVDPHJRMHGQDN RVWDWHF]QLHQLHPRĪHRQRVLąJQąüQDZHWW\PF]DVRZHJRVSHáQLHQLD2F]\ZLĞFLH 5RUW\EH]]ZáRF]QLH]ZUDFDXZDJĊĪHSRGVWDZRZą]DVDGąV]F]ĊĞFLDZNXOWXU]H OLWHUDFNLHMMHVWSRV]XNLZDQLDQRZV]\FKLFLHNDZV]\FKDXWRRSLVyZRUD]VWDZDQLH VLĊEDUG]LHMVROLGDUQ\P]HZV]\VWNLPLLQQ\PLLVWRWDPLOXG]NLPL1LHPQLHMSR-]RVWDMHZUDĪHQLHĪHSRF]XFLHOĊNXQLHGDVLĊWDNáDWZRZ\NRU]HQLü.OXF]RZ\P SXQNWHPRGQLHVLHQLDMHVWWXXOXELHQLHF5RUW\¶HJR+DUROG%ORRP'RVNRQDOH ]QDQąWHRULĊOĊNXSU]HGZSá\ZHPNWyUąNU\W\N]<DOHSURPRZDáZWHWUDORJLL RSXEOLNRZDQHMZODWDFKVLHGHPG]LHVLąW\FKZSyĨQLHMV]HMID]LHWZyUF]RĞFL%OR-om nieco poszerza. O ile w/ĊNXSU]HGZSá\ZHPLSyĨQLHMV]\FKSXEOLNDFMDFK WHRULĊWĊUR]ZLMDMąF\FK%ORRPORNRZDáĨUyGáRVWUDFKXZNRQG\FML]DSyĨQLHQLD >condition of belatedness@PáRGHJRWZyUF\Z]JOĊGHPZLHONLFKSUHNXUVRUyZ RW\OHZRSXEOLNRZDQHMZURNXNVLąĪFHThe Western CanonNU\W\NVXJHUXMH ĪHĨUyGáHPLQQHJRURG]DMXGUĊF]ąFHJRQLHSRNRMXMHVWWRĪHQDV]RJUDQLF]RQ\F]DV QD]LHPLQLHSR]ZROLQDPQLJG\SU]HF]\WDüNVLąĪHN]DOLF]DQ\FKGR=DFKRGQLHJR .DQRQXĪHE\QLHZVSRPQLHüR.DQRQLHĝZLDWRZ\P_{2WRZLĊFQDMVLOQLHMV]\} F]\WHOQLNĞZLDWDMDNPyZLVLĊR%ORRPLHSU]\]QDMHĪHZL]MDOLF]E\NVLąĪHN NWyUHF]áRZLHNPXVLDáE\SU]HF]\WDüDE\]D]QDMRPLüVLĊ]NDQRQHPSU]HNUDF]D OXG]NLHPRĪOLZRĞFL1LJG\QLH]GRáDP\SU]HF]\WDüZV]\VWNLHJRSR]RVWDMHW\ONR SU]\JRGQ\Z\EyUW\FKÄNLONX´SR]\FMLQDNWyU\FKVLĊVNXSLP\%ORRPVSRJOąGD ZSU]HV]áRĞüZNWyUHMZLG]LQLHSU]HEUDQ\RFHDQNVLąĪHNRIHUXMąF\FKQLH]QDQH

 +DUROG%ORRPThe Western Canon: The Books and School of the Ages+DUFRXUW 1HZ<RUNV

ĞFLHĪNLMĊ]\NRZH5RUW\QDWRPLDVWVSRJOąGDZSU]\V]áRĞüNXSU]HVWU]DáRZLLQ-ZHQFMLVáRZQLNRZHM0LPRWHMUyĪQLF\REDMF]XMąGRMPXMąF\OĊNVSRZRGRZDQ\ ZáDVQąNUXFKRĞFLąLQLHWUZDáRĞFLą21%ORRPDJRQLVWDGRRVWDWQLHMFKZLOLLG]LH ]DSU]\NáDGHPVWDURWHVWDPHQWRZHJR-DNXEDLVWDZLDF]RáD$QLRáRZLĞPLHUFL ]PDJDMąFVLĊRQLHRVLąJDOQHEáRJRVáDZLHĔVWZRÄZLĊFHMĪ\FLD´5RUW\DNFHSWXMH ¿]\F]QąVNRĔF]RQRĞüMDNRNRQLHF]Q\SXQNWJUDQLF]Q\DQLGREU\DQL]á\ =DUyZQRHVWHW\F]Q\OĊN%ORRPDMDNLĞZLDWRSRJOąGRZ\5RUW\¶HJRZLRGą QDV]SRZURWHPNXSRMĊFLXSRGPLRWRZRĞFL:ZL]MLjaOXG]NLHJRDXWRUDKonse-kwencji pragmatyzmuGRVWU]HFPRĪQDZ\UDĨQLHREHFQ\FKRüQLHDQDOL]RZDQ\ EH]SRĞUHGQLRDVSHNWOĊNX:VSyáF]HVQ\F]áRZLHNĪ\MąF\ZĞZLHFLHSU]\JRGQLH ]PLHQQ\FKVáRZQLNyZRGF]XZDWUXGQ\GRRNUHĞOHQLDQLHSRNyMĪHRWRMĊ]\N NWyU\PVLĊSRVáXJXMHPRĪHE\üQLHDGHNZDWQ\GRDNWXDOQLHSDQXMąFHJRVáRZQLND OXEWHĪPRĪHQLHZ\VWDUF]DüĪHE\RSLVDüRWDF]DMąFąJRU]HF]\ZLVWRĞü6NRUR ]DĞĞZLDWMHVWSURGXNWHPSU\ZDWQ\FKJLHUMĊ]\NRZ\FKWRMHGQRVWND]DZV]HMHVW ZREHFSá\QQHMSU]HVWU]HQL]WHNVWXDOL]RZDQHMUHDOQRĞFL]DSyĨQLRQD3RZUDFDZLĊF NDWHJRULD%ORRPDW\OHĪHZNXOWXU]HOLWHUDFNLHM5RUW\¶HJRĨUyGáHPSU]HUDĪHQLD QLHVąGRNRQDQLDSRHWyZVSU]HGODWDOHREHFQLHSDQXMąFHJU\MĊ]\NRZH,]QRZX DQDORJLĊ]DEXU]DXMĊFLHF]DVX%ORRPRZVNLHIHESUDJQLHVNáDPDüSU]HFLZNRF]D-VRZLE\VWZRU]\üWDNą¿JXUDFMĊMĊ]\NRZąNWyUDSR]ZROLPXFKRüE\QDFKZLOĊ VWZRU]\üÄQLHVDPRZLWH´ZUDĪHQLHĪHSUHNXUVRUZ\GDVLĊSRHWąSyĨQLHMV]\P QLĪDGHSW22_{%ORRPFKFHZLĊFSRZURWXGRSRF]ąWNyZ±]DOHĪQLHMDNąRSW\NĊ} SU]\Mąü±GR]DFKRGQLRHXURSHMVNLHJRillo temporeDOERGRKHEUDMVNLHMERVNLHM  1DZVSyOQH%ORRPRZLL5RUW\¶HPXSRF]XFLHOĊNXZVND]Dá$GDP/LSV]\FGRVWU]HJDMąF MHGQRF]HĞQLHNOXF]RZąUyĪQLFĊÄRLOH>«@F]áRZLHN%ORRPDSU]HĪ\ZDF]DVMDNRQLHXVWDQQH VSDGDQLHX5RUW\¶HJRF]DVMHVWW\ONRĨUyGáHPOHNNLHJRQLHSRNRMXĪHG]LĞMHV]F]HQLHVWZRU]\áHP QRZHMPHWDIRU\´1LHVSRVyEMHGQDN]JRG]LüVLĊQDWDNLHXMĊFLH5RUWLDĔVNLHMDXWRNUHDF\MQRĞFL SRQLHZDĪyZÄOHNNLQLHSRNyM´MDNGDOHMSRND]XMĊVWDQRZLMHGHQ]NOXF]RZ\FKPHFKDQL]PyZ QDSĊGRZ\FKja ironicznego. 0LĊG]\OXG]LH.RQFHSFMDSRGPLRWRZRĞFLZSLVPDFK+DUROGD Blooma8QLYHUVLWDV.UDNyZV

 %ORRPZ\MDĞQLDZ]ZLĊ]áHMGH¿QLFMLQDSRF]ąWNXVZHJRRSXVPDJQXPÄ3yĨQ\SRHWD ZNRĔFRZHMID]LHUR]ZRMXGĨZLJDMąFEU]HPLĊVZRMHMVDPRWQHMQLHPDOVROLSV\VW\F]QHMZ\-REUDĨQLQDSRZUyWRWZLHUDVZyMZLHUV]QDG]LHáRSUHNXUVRUD>«@2LOHMHGQDN>QDSRF]ąWNX@ jego wiersz E\áRWZDUW\QDZSá\ZSUHNXUVRUDRW\OHWHUD]VDPVLĊQDĔotwiera2VWDWHF]Q\ UH]XOWDWUHZL]MLMHVWQLHVDPRZLW\QLHZ\GDMHQDPVLĊMXĪĪHSUHNXUVRUQDSLVDáZLHUV]DGHSWD OHF]±SU]HFLZQLH±ĪHWRSyĨQLHMV]\SRHWDVWZRU]\áQDMEDUG]LHMFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHG]LHáD SUHNXUVRUD´:JUXQFLHU]HF]\ÄFKRG]LRWDNLHXV\WXRZDQLHSUHNXUVRUDZHZáDVQ\PG]LHOH ĪHRNUHĞORQHIUDJPHQW\MHJRG]LHáD]DPLDVWE\ü]DSRZLHG]LąQDV]HJRQDGHMĞFLDZ\GDMąVLĊ ĞZLDGHFWZHP]DFLąJQLĊWHJRXQDVGáXJXDQDZHWFRQLHXQLNQLRQHEOHGQąZ]HVWDZLHQLX]QD-V]\PLRVLąJQLĊFLDPL´/ĊNSU]HGZSá\ZHPSU]Há$%LHOLN5REVRQL06]XVWHU8QLYHUVLWDV .UDNyZV.XUV\ZDZRU\JLQDOH

ĞZLDWáRĞFLNWyUHMRG]\VNDQLHRSLVXMHNDEDOLVW\F]Q\U\WXDáÄWLNNXQ´௘23_5RUW\ ]NROHLVXJHUXMHĪHF]áRZLHNPXVLSR]RVWDüRNURN]DJUDPLMĊ]\NRZ\PLVNáDGD-MąF\PLVLĊQDZVSyáF]HVQ\PXĞZLDW/ĊNWHQMDNVDP5RUW\ZVND]XMHW\F]\VLĊ LURQLVWNLEDUG]LHMQLĪVLOQHJRSRHW\SRQLHZDĪXWU]\PDQHZGXFKX.XKQRZVNLP ]UHZROXFMRQL]RZDQLHMĊ]\NDVZRMHMG]LHG]LQ\SR]ZDODVLOQHPXSRHFLHQDFKZLOĊ ÄSU]HĞFLJQąü´SDQXMąF\VáRZQLN24_{,URQLVWNDMDNR¿JXUDRSLVXMąFDSRZV]HFKQLHMV]ą} IRUPĊMDĨQLOXG]NLHMSR]RVWDMHMHGQDN]DZV]HZV\WXDFMLÄ]DQLHSRNRMHQLD´ĪHJUD ZQLHZáDĞFLZąJUĊMĊ]\NRZą :\GDMHVLĊZLĊFĪH5RUWLDĔVNDSRGPLRWRZRĞüQLHFRQDSU]HNyUVDPHPX¿OR-]RIRZLQLHMHVWZROQ\PRGOĊNXÄWHNVWXDOQ\PNRQVXPHQWHPVáRZQLNyZ´௘ZUĊF] SU]HFLZQLHLVWQLHQLHZSU]\JRGQ\PĞZLHFLHSRFLąJD]DVREąGRĞüQLHZ\JRGQH SRF]XFLHQLHPRĪOLZRĞFLVSHáQLHQLD-DNMXĪZVSRPLQDáHPZNXOWXU]HOLWHUDFNLHM NWyUDZHGáXJ5RUW\¶HJR]DVWąSLáDGRJPDW\F]QHLHVHQFMDOLVW\F]QHUHOLJLĊL¿OR]R¿Ċ MDĨĔSRGOHJDFLąJá\PUHGHVNU\SFMRPQLHNRĔF]ąFHPXVLĊZ\VLáNRZLDXWRNUHDFML 'RGDüWXQDOHĪ\ĪHSU]HPLDQDWDQLHMHVWNXPXODW\ZQDDOHSU]HELHJDSRGREQLH GRUHZROXFMLZUR]XPLHQLX.XKQDPDP\ZLĊFGRF]\QLHQLD]QLHNRĔF]ąF\PL VLĊVHULDPL]HUZDĔXVNRNyZLSRZWyU]HĔ258MĊFLHWDNLHSURZDG]LQDVWRGR

JáĊEV]HMVWUXNWXU\SRGPLRWRZHJROĊNX-DĨĔERZLHPMDNRwork in progress jest ¿JXUąDSRUHW\F]Qą=MHGQHMERZLHPVWURQ\jaLVWQLHMHMXĪ]DZV]HZ]JRG]LH ]LPSHUDW\ZHPDXWRNUHDF\MQ\P]JRGQLH]NWyU\PDXWRWUDQVIRUPDFMHRGE\ZDMą VLĊQDGURG]HUHZROXFML2GQLHVLHQLHGR.XKQDMHVWWXRW\OHLVWRWQHĪHSR]ZDOD GRVWU]HFLĪSU]HPLDQDSRGPLRWXQLHMHVWZĪDGQ\PVWRSQLXOLQHDUQDDQLW\P EDUG]LHMNXPXODW\ZQD'XĪROHSLHMRSLVXMHLURQLVWNĊPHWDIRU\NDSU]HVWU]HQ-QDSRQLHZDĪZDOF]ąFRSRV]HU]HQLHVZRMHJRVáRZQLNDVWDUDVLĊRQDSU]\Mąü QDW\OHUR]OHJáąZDUVWZĊRSLVXMĊ]\NRZHJRĪHE\PyF]SRZRG]HQLHPRSLVDü WHQVNUDZHNU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLZNWyU\PSU]\V]áRMHMĪ\ü=GUXJLHMVWURQ\SU]H- 1RUPDQ)LQNHOVWHLQSLV]HĪHQLHVSHáQLRQ\PPDU]HQLHP%ORRPDMHVWÄGRNRQDüDNWX WLNNXQNWyU\SR]ZROLáE\QDRGWZRU]HQLHXWUDFRQHJRNRVPRVXWHNVWXDOQHJR´The Ritual of New Criticism. Jewish Tradition and Contemporary Literature6WDWH8QLYHUVLW\RI1HZ <RUN3UHVV$OEDQ\V  5\VXMHVLĊWXFLHNDZDOLQLDSRG]LDáXPLĊG]\LURQLVWNąDVLOQ\PSRHWąERPRĪQDVąG]Lü ĪHWRZáDĞQLHLVWQLHQLHWHJRGUXJLHJRVWZDU]DGODLURQLVWNLV\WXDFMĊOĊNRJHQQą7HPDWWRZV]DN QDRVREQHRPyZLHQLH  .XKQGH¿QLXMHUHZROXFMĊQDXNRZąMDNR]ZURWZSU]HNRQDQLDFKGDQHMJUXS\VSHFMDOLVWyZ JG\JUXSDWDNDÄQLHSRWUD¿MXĪXQLNDüDQRPDOLLEXU]ąF\FKRERZLą]XMąFąWUDG\FMĊSUDNW\NL QDXNRZHMUR]SRF]\QDMąVLĊQDG]Z\F]DMQHEDGDQLDZZ\QLNXNWyU\FK]RVWDMHZNRĔFXZ\-SUDFRZDQ\QRZ\]HVSyá]DáRĪHĔGRVWDUF]DMąF\SRGVWDZ\QRZHMSUDNW\NLQDXNRZHM´.XKQ GRGDMHÄMHVWWRSURFHVUHZROXF\MQ\NWyUHJRQLHPRĪH]D]Z\F]DMGRNRQDüMHGHQF]áRZLHNLNWyU\ QDSHZQRQLH]DFKRG]L]GQLDQDG]LHĔ´7KRPDV.XKQStruktura rewolucji naukowychSU]Há +2VWURPĊFND$OHWKHLD:DUV]DZDV±

VWU]HĔPRĪOLZRĞFLUR]ZRMXMĊ]\NDMHVWQLHRJUDQLF]RQDZREHFF]HJRSU]HPLDQ\ ZHZQąWU]SRGPLRWRZHQDGURG]HREFRZDQLD]OLWHUDWXUąVąSR]RUQH-HĞOLMĊ]\N RIHUXMHQLHVNRĔF]HQLHZLHOHPRĪOLZRĞFLUHGHVNU\SFMLZV]HONLH]PLDQ\MDNLP SRGOHJDjaPXV]ąRND]DüVLĊ]áXGQHERZRWFKáDQLQLHVNRĔF]RQRĞFLQLHPRĪH E\üPRZ\RÄSU]HVWU]HQQ\PUR]ZRMX´ 3LV]ąFĪHNXOWXUDOLWHUDFNDÄWRWDNDNWyUDZ\U]HNDVLĊZ\VLáNyZ]PLHU]DMąF\FK GRSRMHGQDQLDQDV]\FKSU\ZDWQ\FKGUyJUDG]HQLDVRELH]ZáDVQąVNRĔF]RQRĞFLą ]QDV]\PSRF]XFLHPRERZLą]NXZREHFLQQ\FKLVWRWOXG]NLFK´5RUW\VSLQDMHGQą NODPUąWU]\DQDOL]RZDQHWXVWUXNWXU\MDĨQLQRZRF]HVQHM3RSLHUZV]HQDFLVN QDSU\ZDWQRĞüXZ\SXNODLURQLF]QąSRMHG\QF]RĞüOXG]NLHMHJ]\VWHQFMLNWyUHM QLHGDVLĊVSURZDG]LüGRMHGQHJRSDUDG\JPDWXSRGUXJLHSRF]XFLHRERZLą]NX ZREHFLQQ\FKZVND]XMHQDZ\UDĨQLHRGG]LHORQąRGSU\ZDWQHMDXWRNUHDW\ZQRĞFL VROLGDUQRĞü:UHV]FLHSRWU]HFLHQLHEH]SRĞUHGQLHSU]\ZRáDQLHVSRVREyZUDG]H-QLDVRELH]ZáDVQąVNRĔF]RQRĞFLąSR]DZ\UDĨQ\PRGZRáDQLHPGRLPSHUDW\ZX DXWRNUHDW\ZQRĞFLSRGNUHĞODNRQLHF]QRĞü]PDJDQLDVLĊ]W\PFR*UDKDP$OOHQ ZRGQLHVLHQLXGR%ORRPDQD]ZDáÄOĊNLHPSU]HGZ\ERUHP´௘26_{F]\OLVWUDFKHP} ĪHQLHXGDVLĊSU]HF]\WDüZV]\VWNLHJR:SU]\SDGNX5RUW\¶HJR]PDJDQLD WHQD]QDF]RQHVąQLHXVWDMąF\PQLHSRNRMHPRWRF]\MHVWHĞP\Z\VWDUF]DMąFR RWZDUFLE\]UR]XPLHüRWDF]DMąF\QDVĞZLDW-DĨĔLURQLF]QD]DZV]HSR]RVWDQLH GRWNQLĊWDQLHSHZQRĞFLąFRGRWHJRF]\MĊ]\NNWyU\PVLĊSRVáXJXMHQLHSR]RVWDMH ZNRQG\FML]DSyĨQLHQLDZREHFSá\QQHJRLQLHSU]HEUDQLHUyĪQRURGQHJRĞZLDWD ]WHNVWXDOL]RZDQHJR3RPLPRĪH]DVDGQLF]\P]DGDQLHPXSUDZLDQLDSLVDQLD ZMDNLHMSRVWDFLE\QLHE\áRZHGáXJ5RUW\¶HJRMHVW]QDMG\ZDQLHUR]ZLą]DĔSU]\-JRGQLHSRZVWDá\FKSUREOHPyZLGHDQLH]DSRĞUHGQLF]RQHMZQLF]\PLSU]\JRGQHM JU\MĊ]\NRZHMXMDZQLDVZyMPQLHM]EDZLHQQ\DVSHNW:WHNVWXDOLVW\F]QHMZL]ML U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLSURPRZDQHMSU]H]5RUW\¶HJRLURQLDLVROLGDUQRĞü]GDMąVLĊQLHVWDU-F]DüGRRSLVXMHGQRVWNLNWyUD±MXĪ]DZV]HVWDMąFSU]HGRWFKáDQLąPRĪOLZRĞFL ±QLHPRĪHZ\]E\üVLĊRZHMQLHSHZQRĞFLĪHQLJG\QLHSRVáXJXMHVLĊDNWXDOQ\P VáRZQLNLHP.DWHJRULDOĊNXSRGREQLHMDNX%ORRPDVWDMHVLĊZWHRULLNXOWXU\ OLWHUDFNLHM5RUW\¶HJRMHGQ\P]NOXF]RZ\FKLPSXOVyZ]DSHZQLDMąF\FKF]áRZLH-NRZLNUHDW\ZQRĞüDFR]DW\PLG]LHSDUDGRNVDOQLHSHáQLHMV]HĪ\FLH  $OOHQVWZLHUG]DĪHFDáDWHRULDOĊNXSU]HGZSá\ZHPMHVWZU]HF]\VDPHMZ\UD]HP GRMPXMąFHJRQLHSRNRMXĪHQLHXGDVLĊGRWU]HüGRZV]\VWNLFKÄZDĪQ\FKNVLąĪHN´FRMHVWUyZ-QLHSRGVWDZRZąSU]\F]\QąVWUDFKXHIHEDMDNSRF]XFLH]DSyĨQLHQLDThe Anxiety of Choice, the Western Canon and the Future of LiteratureZThe Salt Companion to Harold Bloom UHG*UDKDP$OOHQL5R\6HOODUV6DOW&DPEULGJHV±