Marta Skrzypczyńska - Pomiar cyklu koniunkturalnego w Polsce - analiza porównawcza

Pomiar cyklu koniunkturalnego w Polsce

– analiza porównawcza

0DUWD6NU]\SF]\ñVND

1DGHVïDQ\F]HUZFDU=DDNFHSWRZDQ\VLHUSQLDU

Streszczenie

:DUW\NXOHSRGMÚWRSUöEÚRV]DFRZDQLDSU]HELHJXF\NOXNRQLXQNWXUDOQHJRZ3ROVFHREMDZLDMÈFHJR VLÚ ZDKDQLDPL DNW\ZQRĂFL JRVSRGDUF]HM PLHU]RQHM NZDUWDOQ\P UHDOQ\P 3.% RUD] PLHVLÚF]QÈ SURGXNFMÈ Z SU]HP\ĂOH SU]HWZöUF]\P 'RNRQDQR WHJR ]D SRPRFÈ WU]HFK PHWRG VWUXNWXUDOQ\FK PRGHOL V]HUHJöZ F]DVRZ\FK ILOWUX F]ÚVWRWOLZRĂFLRZHJR RUD] PRGHOL ] SU]HïÈF]DQLHP W\SX 0DUNRZDQDSUöELHRGVW\F]QLDGRVW\F]QLDU

3RPLDU ]D SRPRFÈ WU]HFK PHWRG ZVND]XMH QD SRGREQH NV]WDïWRZDQLH VLÚ ZDKDñ WHJR VDPH- JRPLHUQLNDDNW\ZQRĂFL1LHFRRGPLHQQ\FKDUDNWHUSURFHVöZNRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FKRG]ZLHUFLHGOD-MÈ ZDKDQLD UHDOQHJR 3.% RUD] SURGXNFML Z SU]HP\ĂOH SU]HWZöUF]\P Z SU]\SDGNX NWöU\FK RG-QRWRZDQR RGSRZLHGQLR F]WHU\  L SLÚÊ QLHSHïQ\FK F\NOL =LGHQW\ILNRZDQH F\NOH QLH FHFKXMÈ VLÚ ĂFLVïÈUHJXODUQRĂFLÈMHGQDNLFKĂUHGQLDGïXJRĂÊGODREX]PLHQQ\FKMHVW]EOLĝRQDLZ\QRVLRNR-ïR ļ ODW =ZURW\ NRQLXQNWXU\ Z SU]HP\ĂOH SU]HWZöUF]\P Z\VWÚSRZDï\ ]Z\NOH R MHGHQ NZDU-WDï ZF]HĂQLHM OXE UöZQROHJOH Z]JOÚGHP 3.% ] Z\MÈWNLHP ODW ļ 3RWZLHUG]RQD ]RVWD-ïD ZLÚNV]D ]PLHQQRĂÊ ZDKDñ Z SU]HWZöUVWZLH SU]HP\VïRZ\P Z SRUöZQDQLX ] UHDOQ\P 3.% :SU]HFLZLHñVWZLHGRUHDOQHJR3.%SU]HWZöUVWZRSU]HP\VïRZHFKDUDNWHU\]XMHVLÚWDNĝHDV\PH-WULÈID]F\NOX]HZ]JOÚGXQDF]DVWUZDQLDRUD]DPSOLWXGÚ

6ïRZD NOXF]RZH F\NO NRQLXQNWXUDOQ\ SXQNW\ ]ZURWQH ILOWU &KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOGD PRGHO

QLHREVHUZRZDOQ\FKNRPSRQHQWöZPRGHO]SU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZD

-(/&&(

:VWÚS

&\NONRQLXQNWXUDOQ\REMDZLDVLÚZDKDQLDPLZRNöïGïXJRRNUHVRZHJRWUHQGXSR]LRPXOXEG\QDPL- NLUöĝQRURGQ\FKPLHUQLNöZRSLVXMÈF\FKDNW\ZQRĂÊJRVSRGDUF]È:DKDQLDNRQLXQNWXUDOQHFKD- UDNWHU\]XMHQDSU]HPLHQQRĂÊLFKZ\VWÚSRZDQLDZbRNUHVDFKRGURNXGRODWRUD]QLHUHJXODU-QRĂÊF]DVXWUZDQLDLDPSOLWXG\=DSURSRQRZDQDFKDUDNWHU\VW\NDïÈF]\FHFK\F\NOLRSLVDQHSU]H] /XFDVDRUD]+đEQHULLQ$UW\NXïZSLVXMHVLÚZQXUWEDGDñF\NOLZ]URVWRZ\FK 5HDOQ\3.%RUD]SURGXNFMDZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PVÈQDMF]ÚĂFLHMZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQ\PLPLHU- QLNDPLDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDUF]HM2EDQLHVÈGRVNRQDï\PLUHSUH]HQWDQWDPLDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDU- F]HM'DQHR3.%SXEOLNRZDQHVÈFRNZDUWDïZGRGDWNXGOD3ROVNL]bGZXPLHVLÚF]Q\PRSöěQLH-QLHPDWDNĝHSRGOHJDMÈF]ÚVW\PUHZL]MRP3URGXNFMDZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PUHSUH]HQWXMHW\ONR F]ÚĂÊDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDUF]HMDMHMZDKDQLDVÈSU]\F]\QÈ]QDF]Q\FKZDKDñSURGXNWX %DGDQLHSU]HELHJXF\NOXNRQLXQNWXUDOQHJRZ3ROVFHMHVWLVWRWQH]SRZRGXEUDNXNRQVHQVXVX FRGRMHJRSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FK'DW\]ZURWöZNRQLXQNWXU\ZUDPDFKF\NOXRGFK\OHñRGGïXJR-RNUHVRZHJRWUHQGXGODZLHOX]PLHQQ\FKHNRQRPLF]Q\FKPRĝQDRGQDOHěÊZZLHOXSUDFDFKSRU QS$GDPRZLF]LLQ*UDG]HZLF]LLQ3XQNW\]ZURWQHF\NOXX]\VNDQH]DSRPRFÈPR- GHOL]SU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZDZ\]QDF]\ïD)LF1DGDOQLHOLF]QHVÈEDGDQLDSRUöZQX-MÈFHRV]DFRZDQLDZDKDñNRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FKZ3ROVFHRWU]\PDQH]DSRPRFÈNLONXPHWRG3U]HELHJ VNïDGRZ\FKF\NOLF]Q\FKX]\VNDQ\FKQDSRGVWDZLHNLONXQDU]ÚG]L]DSUH]HQWRZDOL6NU]\SF]\ñVNL RUD]$GDPRZLF]LLQMHGQDNJïöZQ\PFHOHPW\FKDQDOL]E\ïREDGDQLHV\QFKURQL]D-FMLZDKDñNRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FKZb3ROVFHLVWUHILHHXUR

&HOHP SUH]HQWRZDQHM DQDOL]\ MHVW RV]DFRZDQLH SU]HELHJX SROVNLHJR F\NOX NRQLXQNWXUDOQHJR Z\UDĝDMÈFHJRVLÚZDKDQLDPLSRGVWDZRZ\FKPLHUQLNöZDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDUF]HMUHDOQHJR3.% RUD]SURGXNFMLZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\P:W\PFHOXXĝ\WRWU]HFKPHWRGVWUXNWXUDOQ\FKPR-GHOLV]HUHJöZF]DVRZ\FKILOWUXF]ÚVWRWOLZRĂFLRZHJRRUD]PRGHOL]SU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZD $UW\NXïVNïDGDVLÚ]SLÚFLXF]ÚĂFL3LHUZV]D]DZLHUDRSLVGDQ\FKRUD]EDGDQLHQLHVWDFMRQDUQRĂFL SURFHVöZJHQHUXMÈF\FKDQDOL]RZDQHV]HUHJLF]DVRZH:bNROHMQ\FKWU]HFKF]ÚĂFLDFK]DSUH]HQWRZDQR ]ZLÚ]ïÈFKDUDNWHU\VW\NÚNDĝGHM]Z\NRU]\VWDQ\FKPHWRGRUD]Z\QLNLRV]DFRZDñF\NOXNRQLXQNWX-UDOQHJR:\RGUÚEQLHQLHVNïDGRZHMF\NOLF]QHMZIRUPLHRGFK\OHñRGWUHQGX]RVWDïRSU]HSURZDG]RQH ]DbSRPRFÈVWUXNWXUDOQ\FKPRGHOLV]HUHJöZF]DVRZ\FKZHGïXJVSHF\ILNDFML:DWVRQDRUD]ILO-WUX&KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOGD&KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOG0RGHOH]SU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZDSRU +DPLOWRQ.URO]LJSRVïXĝ\ï\GRSRPLDUXZDKDñF\NOLF]Q\FKQDED]LHG\QDPLN1DVWÚS- QLHGRNRQDQRGDWRZDQLDSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FKRUD]REOLF]RQRZDUWRĂFLVWDW\VW\NRSLVRZ\FKX]\VND-Q\FKNRPSRQHQWöZF\NOLF]Q\FKWDNĝHGODSRV]F]HJöOQ\FKID]=DïRĝRQRZ\VWÚSRZDQLHGZöFKID] F\NOXZ]URVWRZHMHNVSDQVMLLVSDGNRZHMVSRZROQLHQLDUHFHVML:SLÈWHMF]ÚĂFLSRUöZQDQRZ\QLNL RWU]\PDQHQDSRGVWDZLHWU]HFKZ\NRU]\VWDQ\FKPHWRG$UW\NXïNRñF]\VLÚSRGVXPRZDQLHP

2. Charakterystyka danych empirycznych

6]HUHJLF]DVRZHVïXĝÈFHGRSRPLDUXZDKDñNRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FKSRFKRG]È]ED]\GDQ\FK(XURVWDW 3R]LRPQRPLQDOQHJR3.%]RVWDïXUHDOQLRQ\GHIODWRUHP3.%5HDOQ\3.%RUD]SURGXNFMDZSU]H-WZöUVWZLHSU]HP\VïRZ\P]RVWDï\]ORJDU\WPRZDQHDQDVWÚSQLHRF]\V]F]RQH]ZDKDñVH]RQRZ\FK

]DSRPRFÈPHWRG\75$026($76SRU*RPH]0DUDYDOO3R]RVWDïHREVHUZDFMHQLHW\SRZH Z\VWÚSXMÈFHZ,9NZDUWDOHURUD]Z,9NZDUWDOHUZV]HUHJXUHDOQHJR3.%]RVWDï\ XVXQLÚWH SU]H] REOLF]HQLH ĂUHGQLHM DU\WPHW\F]QHM VÈVLHGQLFK REVHUZDFML 6]HUHJ 3.% REHMPRZDï ODWDļFRRGSRZLDGDïRREVHUZDFMRPNZDUWDOQ\P6]HUHJSURGXNFMLZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]H- WZöUF]\PREHMPRZDïRNUHVRGVW\F]QLDGRVW\F]QLDUREVHUZDFMH3U]HELHJ]PLHQ-Q\FK]DSUH]HQWRZDQRQDZ\NUHVLH:V]HONLHDQDOL]\GRW\F]ÈFH3.%RUD]SURGXNFMLZbSU]HP\ĂOH SU]HWZöUF]\P]RVWDï\SU]HSURZDG]RQHRGSRZLHGQLRZXMÚFLXNZDUWDOQ\PRUD]PLHVLÚF]Q\P

3U]HGSU]\VWÈSLHQLHPGRPRGHORZDQLDRNUHĂORQRVWRFKDVW\F]QÈQDWXUÚSURFHVöZJHQHUXMÈF\FK DQDOL]RZDQH V]HUHJL F]DVRZH : W\P FHOX SU]HSURZDG]RQH ]RVWDï\ WHVW\ QLHVWDFMRQDUQRĂFL $') SRU'LFNH\)XOOHURUD]bVWDFMRQDUQRĂFL.366SRU.ZLDWNRZVNLLLQ:\QLNLWHVWöZ SU]HGVWDZLRQRZWDEHOL:\QLNLWHVWöZ$')]HVWDïÈRUD]WUHQGHPOLQRZ\PLbVWDïÈQLHSR]ZDODMÈ QDRGU]XFHQLHKLSRWH]\]HURZHM]DNïDGDMÈFHMLVWQLHQLHSLHUZLDVWNDMHGQRVWNRZHJR:\QLNLWHVWöZ VWDFMRQDUQRĂFL.366SRWZLHUG]DMÈZQLRVNLZ\FLÈJQLÚWHQDSRGVWDZLHWHVWöZ$')5HDOQ\3.%RUD] SURGXNFMDZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PVÈSURFHVDPL]LQWHJURZDQ\PLZVWRSQLXSLHUZV]\P,

6WUXNWXUDOQHPRGHOHV]HUHJöZF]DVRZ\FKļVSHF\ğNDFMD:DWVRQD

6WUXNWXUDOQH PRGHOH V]HUHJöZ F]DVRZ\FK QD]ZDQH VÈ LQDF]HM PRGHODPL QLHREVHUZRZDOQ\FK NRPSRQHQWöZunobserved components modelUC modelOXEPRGHODPLSU]HVWU]HQLVWDQöZstate space model 0RGHOH WH SR]ZDODMÈ QD GHNRPSR]\FMÚ V]HUHJX F]DVRZHJR QD QLHREVHUZRZDOQH VNïDGRZH QS WUHQG RUD] F\NO ] XZ]JOÚGQLHQLHP ZïDVQRĂFL VWRFKDVW\F]Q\FK SURFHVöZ MH JHQH-UXMÈF\FK=HZ]JOÚGXQDZF]HĂQLHMV]HZ\QLNLWHVWöZQDREHFQRĂÊ SLHUZLDVWNöZMHGQRVWNRZ\FK Z SU]HSURZDG]RQHM DQDOL]LH MHGQRZ\PLDURZHM SU]\MÚWR VWUXNWXUÚ PRGHOX ]DSURSRQRZDQÈ SU]H] :DWVRQD t t t t t t t t t t C C C T T C T Y μ φ φ ξ ε = + + + + + = = 2 2 1 1 1 _ _ _  JG]LH ξ_t ξ

ε_t~i.i.d. N(0; σε2) oraz ~i.i.d. N(0; σ2).

:SU]HGVWDZLRQ\PPRGHOXWUHQGTtMHVWSURFHVHPEïÈG]HQLDORVRZHJR]GU\IHPȝ6NïDGRZD

F\NOLF]QD Ct MHVW QDWRPLDVW VWDFMRQDUQ\P SURFHVHP $5 6NïDGQLNL ORVRZH SRFKRG]ÈFH ]b

UöZ-QDñWUHQGXRUD]NRPSRQHQWXF\NOLF]QHJRVÈQLHVNRUHORZDQH7DNÈVDPÈSRVWDÊPRGHOXSU]\MÚOL 6NU]\SF]\ñVNLGOD3.%RUD]$GDPRZLF]LLQGODSURGXNFMLVSU]HGDQHMZSU]HP\ĂOH SU]HWZöUF]\P5öZQDQLHSRPLDUXLXNïDGUöZQDñVWDQXSU]HGVWDZLDMÈVLÚRGSRZLHGQLR =

[

]

1 t 0 1 1 t t t C C T y _              RUD] ξ_t ε + + = 1 t t t C C T t t t t C C T μ 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 2 1 1 2 1 φ φ _ _ _  C_t

3DUDPHWU\μ 2 2 1 2_{, , ,} ,σ_ε φ φ σ_ξ ]RVWDï\RV]DFRZDQHPHWRGÈQDMZLÚNV]HMZLDU\JRGQRĂFLSU]\]DVWR-VRZDQLXILOWUX.DOPDQD:\QLNLHVW\PDFMLGODUHDOQHJR3.%SU]HGVWDZLRQRZbWDEHOL:V]\VWNLH SDUDPHWU\PRGHOXVÈLVWRWQHVWDW\VW\F]QLHSU]\SURFHQWRZ\PSR]LRPLHLVWRWQRĂFL0RĝQD]DWHP SU]\MÈÊĝHX]\VNDQHNRPSRQHQW\V]HUHJXVÈGREU\PRG]ZLHUFLHGOHQLHPWHQGHQFMLGïXJRRNUHVRZHM RUD]ZDKDñF\NOLF]Q\FKNWöUH]LOXVWURZDQRQDZ\NUHVLH

&KDUDNWHU\VW\NÚ SU]HELHJX SURFHVöZ NRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FK REHMPXMÈFÈ ĂUHGQLH RGFK\OHQLH RG WUHQGXRGFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZHRUD]F]DVWUZDQLDF\NOXLbSRV]F]HJöOQ\FKMHJRID]]DZLHUDWDEHOD ]DVDG\Z\]QDF]DQLDSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FK]DPLHV]F]RQRZXZDG]HZWDEHOL:bODWDFKļ OLF]ÈFRGID]\Rĝ\ZLHQLDPLDï\PLHMVFHF]WHU\QLHSHïQHF\NOHZbSU]HELHJXZDKDñUHDOQHJR 3.%:W\PRNUHVLHĂUHGQLHRGFK\OHQLHNRPSRQHQWXF\NOLF]QHJRRGSURGXNWXSRWHQFMDOQHJRZID-]LHVSDGNRZHMZ\QLRVïRDZID]LHZ]URVWRZHM:\VWÈSLïDDV\PHWULDID]]HZ]JOÚGX QDDPSOLWXGÚID]DZ]URVWRZDRG]QDF]DïDVLÚZLÚNV]\PLZDKDQLDPLZ\UDĝRQ\PL]DSRPRFÈRG-FK\OHñVWDQGDUGRZ\FK3U]HFLÚWQHGïXJRĂFLID]E\ï\]EOLĝRQH&\NONRQLXQNWXUDOQ\WUZDïĂUHGQLR EOLVNRF]WHU\ODWD'DW\Z\]QDF]RQ\FKSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FKQLHRGELHJDMÈ]QDF]QLHRGZ\QLNöZ X]\VNDQ\FKSU]H]$GDPRZLF]LLQSRUWDEHOD :SU]\SDGNXSU]HWZöUVWZDSU]HP\VïRZHJRQLHX]\VNDQR]DGRZDODMÈF\FKZ\QLNöZHVW\PD- FMLSRPLPRZ\NRU]\VWDQLDRSUöF]PRGHOX:DWVRQDWDNĝHVSHF\ILNDFML&ODUNDEÚGÈFHMUR]-V]HU]HQLHPPRGHOX:DWVRQDSU]H]X]PLHQQLHQLHGU\IXZUöZQDQLXWUHQGX:\QLNMHVW]JRGQ\ ]UH]XOWDWDPLZF]HĂQLHMV]HJREDGDQLDSRU'XGHN3DFKXFNLPLPR]DVWRVRZDQLDRGPLHQQHM VWUXNWXU\PRGHOXQLHREVHUZRZDOQ\FKNRPSRQHQWöZ3U]\F]\QÈEUDNXRV]DFRZDñPRJï\E\ÊWUXG-QRĂFL]ZLÈ]DQH]QLHZïDĂFLZ\PGRERUHPZDUWRĂFLVWDUWRZ\FK%HOO+LOOPHU

)LOWUF]ÚVWRWOLZRĂFLRZ\&KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOGD

0HWRG\DQDOL]\VSHNWUDOQHMXPRĝOLZLDMÈZ\RGUÚEQLHQLHZDKDñ]RNUHĂORQHJRSDVPDF]ÚVWRWOLZR-ĂFL 'R WHJR FHOX PöJïE\ ]RVWDÊ Z\NRU]\VWDQ\ ķLGHDOQ\ĵ ILOWU SDVPRZRSU]HSXVWRZ\ band–pass

filter c t y NWöUHJR]DVWRVRZDQLHZ\PDJDMHGQDNQLHVNRñF]RQHMLORĂFLREVHUZDFMLSRU%D[WHU.LQJ  =

( )

_t c t B L y y      JG]LH = = – =

( )

j j jL B L B dla t 1, 2...,∞ ∞

∑

∞ 

= WHJR Z]JOÚGX Z SUDNW\FH Z\NRU]\VWXMH VLÚ DSURNV\PDFMH ķLGHDOQ\FKĵ ILOWUöZ 3U]\NïDGD-PLWDNLFKSU]\EOLĝHñVÈILOWU\%.ļ%D[WHU.LQJDļRUD]&)ļ&KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOGD :FHOXHNVWUDNFMLVNïDGRZ\FKF\NOLF]Q\FKZ\NRU]\VWDQRDV\PHWU\F]Q\ILOWUSDVPRZRSU]HSXVWRZ\ &KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOGD )LOWU &) PD FHFK\ ZVSöOQH ILOWUöZ +3 ļ +RGULFND3UHVFRWWD +RGULFN 3UHVFRWWļRUD]%.3RSLHUZV]HSRGREQLHMDN+3JHQHUXMHNRPSRQHQWZ\MĂFLRZ\RWHMVDPHM OLF]ELHREVHUZDFMLFRZHMĂFLRZ\V]HUHJF]DVRZ\3RGUXJLHXVWDZLHQLHRSXV]F]DQHJRSDVPDF]Ú-VWRWOLZRĂFLSU]HELHJDZWHQVDPVSRVöEMDNZbILOWU]H%.&HFKÈRGUöĝQLDMÈFÈ&)RG+3Lb%.MHVW NRQLHF]QRĂÊ RNUHĂOHQLD QDWXU\ VWRFKDVW\F]QHM SURFHVX JHQHUXMÈFHJR REVHUZRZDQ\ V]HUHJ F]DVR-Z\F]\OLRNUHĂOHQLDF]\SURFHVMHVWQLHVWDFMRQDUQ\LbMDNLHPXURG]DMRZLQLHVWDFMRQDUQRĂFLSRGOHJD

*G\SURFHVJHQHUXMÈF\GDQHMHVWVWDFMRQDUQ\SU]HG]DVWRVRZDQLHPILOWUX&)QDOHĝ\XVXQÈÊĂUHG- QLÈDMHĂOLMHVWSURFHVHP,]GU\IHPQDOHĝ\XVXQÈÊGU\I:bSU]\SDGNXSURFHVXWUHQGRVWDFMRQDU- QHJRWU]HEDXVXQÈÊWUHQGGHWHUPLQLVW\F]Q\'ODV]HUHJXRVNRñF]RQHMOLF]ELHREVHUZDFMLHVW\PDWR-UHPNRPSRQHQWX c t y^ ]SU]HG]LDïXZDKDñbR]DGDQHMF]ÚVWRWOLZRĂFLMHVW = t

( )

_t c t B L y y^ ^      JG]LH ₌ =

( )

( ) 1 , t t T j j t j t L B L B^

_∑

^ _ _ _      dla t =1,2...,T SRU&KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOGJG]LHZDJLB^j, tVÈ]PLHQQHZF]DVLH

$V\PHWU\F]QRĂÊ ILOWUX Z\QLND ] ]DOHĝQRĂFL LQGHNVX VXP\ RG F]DVX D MHM VNXWNLHP MHVW SU]HVXQLÚFLHID]RZHZVWRVXQNXGRZHMĂFLRZHJRV]HUHJXQDSRF]ÈWNXLNRñFXSUöE\FRSRZRGXMH QLHSHZQRĂÊV]DFXQNXQDNRñFDFKSUöE\:DJLX]\VNXMHVLÚSU]H]UR]ZLÈ]DQLHSUREOHPXRSW\PD-OL]DF\MQHJRRSRVWDFL _{_} = =

)

)

(

(

( )

{ }

T t t c t c t t t T j B y y y E t j 1 2 1 ,..., , , min ^ ^ _ _ _  dla t =1,2...,T =DSLVILOWUXZbG]LHG]LQLHF]ÚVWRWOLZRĂFLRUD]ZSï\ZUHZL]MLGDQ\FKQDRV]DFRZDQLDNRPSR-QHQWXF\NOLF]QHJRSUH]HQWXMH6NU]\SF]\ñVNL :SU]HSURZDG]RQHMDQDOL]LHILOWU&)Z\NRU]\VWDQR]HZ]JOÚGXQDWRĝHQLHWUDFLREVHUZD-FML QD SRF]ÈWNX L NRñFX SUöE\ RUD] XZ]JOÚGQLD VWRFKDVW\F]QÈ QDWXUÚ GHNRPSRQRZDQ\FK V]HUH-JöZF]DVRZ\FKGRbZ\RGUÚEQLHQLDZDKDñF\NOLF]Q\FKRbF]ÚVWRWOLZRĂFL]b]DNUHVXURNXļODW RGSRZLDGDMÈF\FK ZF]HĂQLHM SU]\MÚWHM FKDUDNWHU\VW\FH ZDKDñ =JRGQLH ] Z\QLNDPL WHVWöZ $') L.366SU]HGVWDZLRQ\PLZWDEHOL]DïRĝRQRĝH]PLHQQHVÈSURFHVDPL,]GU\IHP3U]HGRV]D-FRZDQLHPNRPSRQHQWXF\NOLF]QHJRXVXQLÚWRGU\ISU]H]RGMÚFLHĂUHGQLHMSLHUZV]\FKSU]\URVWöZ REVHUZRZDQ\FKV]HUHJöZF]DVRZ\FK'HNRPSR]\FMÚV]HUHJöZQDWUHQGRUD]VNïDGRZÈF\NOLF]QÈ LOXVWUXMHZ\NUHV:DUWRĂFLVWDW\VW\NRSLVRZ\FKGODVNïDGRZ\FKF\NOLF]Q\FKRUD]GDW\SXQNWöZ ]ZURWQ\FKPDNVLPDLbPLQLPDORNDOQHNRPSRQHQWXF\NOLF]QHJR]DZLHUDWDEHOD 3U]HWZöUVWZR SU]HP\VïRZHRG]QDF]DVLÚZLÚNV]ÈDPSOLWXGÈZDKDñQLĝUHDOQ\3.%DID]DVSRZROQLHQLDMHVWNUöW-V]DRGZ]URVWRZHM$PSOLWXGDZDKDñID]\VSDGNRZHMZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PMHVWQLH]QDF]QLH Z\ĝV]D RG DPSOLWXG\ ID]\ Z]URVWRZHM : SU]\SDGNX UHDOQHJR 3.% Z\VWÚSXMH ]MDZLVNR RGZURW- QH'ïXJRĂÊWUZDQLDID]F\NOXZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PMHVW]UöĝQLFRZDQD:DKDQLDDNW\ZQR-ĂFL3.%RUD]ZSU]HWZöUVWZLHSU]HP\VïRZ\PRG]QDF]DMÈVLÚWÈVDPÈOLF]EÈF\NOLPLPRSHZQ\FK UöĝQLFMHĂOLFKRG]LRSXQNW\]ZURWQH:ODWDFKļ]DUöZQRZZDKDQLDFKUHDOQHJR3.% MDNLSURGXNFMLZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\P]LGHQW\ILNRZDQRSLÚÊQLHSHïQ\FKF\NOL]DF]\QDMÈFGD- WRZDQLHRGID]\Z]URVWRZHM,VWRWQHUöĝQLFHGRW\F]ÈSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FK2GQRVLVLÚWRGRRNUH-VöZSU]HGURUD]SRbU:ODWDFKļZZDKDQLDFK3.%RGQRWRZDQRGZDF\NOH DZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PļMHGHQF\NO3RQDGWRRG,,NZDUWDïXUGRNRñFDUZDKD-QLD F\NOLF]QH UHDOQHJR 3.% ZVND]XMÈ QD ID]Ú VSRZROQLHQLD 3U]HELHJ VNïDGRZHM F\NOLF]QHM 3.%

SRRNUHVLHVSDGNXSR]RVWDïVWDELOQ\ZRGUöĝQLHQLXRGF\NOXSU]HP\VïXSU]HWZöUF]HJRNWöU\RG F]HUZFDUE\ïZID]LHZ]URVWRZHM8]\VNDQHUöĝQLFHPRJÈZ\QLNDÊ]HVWRSQLDDJUHJDFMLDQD- OL]RZDQ\FKPLHUQLNöZDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDUF]HM3URGXNFMDZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PUHSUH]HQ- WXMHRNRïRDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDUF]HMZVWRVXQNXGR3.%:ODWDFKļSXQNW\]ZURW-QHSURGXNFMLSU]HP\VïRZHMZ\VWÚSXMÈUöZQRF]HĂQLH]H]ZURWDPLUHDOQHJR3.%OXEZ\SU]HG]DMÈMH RMHGHQNZDUWDï3URGXNFMDZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PGRNïDGQLHMLV]\EFLHMV\JQDOL]XMHPRPHQW ]PLDQ\ID]\]HZ]JOÚGXQDF]ÚVWRWOLZRĂÊPLHVLÚF]QÈ0RPHQW\Z\VWÈSLHQLDSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FK ]DUöZQRGOD3.%MDNLSURGXNFMLZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PVÈ]EOLĝRQHGRZ\QLNöZ*UDG]HZL-F]DLLQDOHUöĝQLÈVLÚZVWRVXQNXGRUH]XOWDWöZX]\VNDQ\FKSU]H]$GDPRZLF]LLQ SRU WDEHOD  5R]ELHĝQRĂFL PRJÈ Z\QLNDÊ ]b SU]\MÚFLD RGPLHQQHM UHJXï\ GDWRZDQLD ]ZURWöZ NRQLXQNWXU\

0RGHOH]SU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZD

0RGHOH]SU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZDMarkov-switching modelsQDOHĝÈGRNODV\PRGHOLQLHOL- QLRZ\FKZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQ\FKGRPRGHORZDQLDF\NOXNRQLXQNWXUDOQHJRZbSRVWDFLG\QDPLN3DUD-PHWU\WHJRPRGHOX]PLHQLDMÈVLÚZF]DVLHZb]DOHĝQRĂFLRGQLHREVHUZRZDOQHMG\VNUHWQHM]PLHQQHM UHĝLPXs_t ∈{1,...,N} RG]ZLHUFLHGODMÈFHMVWDQZNWöU\P]QDMGXMHVLÚJRVSRGDUNDZbF\NOXNRQLXQN-WXUDOQ\PNVWDQRZ\PRGHOZHNWRURZHMDXWRUHJUHVMLU]ÚGXp ]SU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZDGOD KZ\PLDURZHJRZHNWRUDV]HUHJöZF]DVRZ\FK06N9$5pPDSRVWDÊ ∆y_t = A₀(s_t)+A₁(s_t)∆y_t_₁ +…+A_p(s_t)∆y_t__p +ε_t(s_t)   JG]LHZHNWRUVNïDGQLNöZORVRZ\FK ε_t(s_t)_{MHVWbZLHORZ\PLDURZ\PSURFHVHPELDïHJRV]XPX} 0DFLHU]H SDUDPHWUöZA₀(s_t),…,A_p(s_t),Σ(s_t)VÈ RGSRZLHGQLNDPL PDFLHU]\ SDUDPHWUöZ PR-GHOX9$5 A₀,…,A_p,Σ,DOHZW\PSU]\SDGNXLFKZDUWRĂFL]PLHQLDMÈVLÚZ]DOHĝQRĂFLRG]PLHQQHM UHĝLPXst

3URFHVHPNLHUXMÈF\P]PLDQDPLVWDQöZMHVWG\VNUHWQ\VNRñF]RQ\MHGQRURGQ\KVWDQR-Z\ïDñFXFK0DUNRZDst

P

(

s_t=j|s_t_₁=i_t_₁,…,s₁ =i₁,X₀=i₀

)

=P

(

s_t=j|s_t_₁= =i

)

p_ij  

JG]LH p dla ij i,j =1,…,K MHVW SUDZGRSRGRELHñVWZHP SU]HMĂFLD SRPLÚG]\ VWDQDPL ïDñFXFKD

NWöU\FKOLF]EDMHVWUöZQDOLF]ELH]PLHQQ\FKUHĝLPX

=D]Z\F]DM]DNïDGDVLÚĝHïDñFXFK0DUNRZDMHVWQLHSU]\ZLHGOQ\LbHUJRG\F]Q\3DUDPHWU\PR-GHOXV]DFXMHVLÚ]DSRPRFÈPHWRG\QDMZLÚNV]HMZLDU\JRGQRĂFLSU]\Z\NRU]\VWDQLXDOJRU\WPX(0 expectation maximizationSRU'HPSVWHU/DLUG5XELQ3UDZGRSRGRELHñVWZDZ\JïDG]RQH QD SRGVWDZLH NWöU\FK RVWDWHF]QLH ]DOLF]D VLÚ REVHUZDFMÚ GR GDQHM ID]\ F\NOX NRQLXQNWXUDOQHJR PRĝQDRWU]\PDÊ]DSRPRFÈ]DSURSRQRZDQHJRSU]H].LPDILOWUXW\SXbackwardZNWöU\P DOJRU\WPZ\JïDG]DMÈF\VWDUWXMH]SXQNWXNRñFRZHJRFDïHMGRVWÚSQHMSUöE\:]ZLÈ]NX]W\PĝH ZPRGHOX069$5SUDZGRSRGRELHñVWZDGOD]PLHQQHMREVHUZRZDOQHMyt RUD]]PLHQQHMUHĝLPXst+1

]DOHĝÈW\ONRRGREHFQHJRVWDQXstDQLHRGbZF]HĂQLHMV]HMKLVWRULL]JRGQLH]ZïDVQRĂFLÈïDñFXFKöZ

= = = ( Y ) Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ; , Pr ) ; , | ( ) ; , | Pr( ) ; , , | ( ) ; , , | Pr( ) ; , | Pr( 1 1 . 1 1 1 . 1 . 1 1 1 t t t t t T t t t t t t t T t T t t t t T t t s s s f s s s s f s s s s + + + + + + + + + θ θ θ θ θ θ _ *ïöZQÈ]DOHWÈPRGHOL069$5MHVWLFKHODVW\F]QRĂÊ,VWQLHMHZLHOHZDULDQWöZPRGHOL069$5 0RĝQD ]DïRĝ\Ê ]PLHQQRĂÊ ZV]\VWNLFK SDUDPHWUöZ Z ]DOHĝQRĂFL RG WHM VDPHM ]PLHQQHM UHĝLPX DOHWDNĝHZ\VWÚSRZDQLHUöĝQ\FK]PLHQQ\FKUHĝLPXGODNDĝGHJR]UöZQDñOXEGODSDUDPHWUöZ :SUDNW\FHSURZDG]LWRMHGQDNGRV]\ENLHJRZ]URVWXOLF]E\SDUDPHWUöZLbSUREOHPöZ]LFKRV]DFR- ZDQLHP'ODWHJRQDMF]ÚĂFLHM]DNïDGDVLÚĝHWDVDPD]PLHQQDJHQHUXMHUHĝLP\GODZV]\VWNLFKUöZ-QDñPRGHOXMDNUöZQLHĝRJUDQLF]DVLÚOLF]EÚVWDQöZ:bEDGDQLDFKHPSLU\F]Q\FKR]QDF]DWRĝH Z\VWÚSXMHZVSöOQ\F\NORQDU]XFRQHM]JöU\OLF]ELHID]1DMF]ÚĂFLHM]DNïDGDVLÚZ\VWÚSRZDQLHN = 2 UHĝLPöZFRRGSRZLDGDGZöPID]RPF\NOXNRQLXQNWXUDOQHJRVSDGNRZLLZ]URVWRZLDNW\ZQRĂFL JRVSRGDUF]HM&]DVDPLMHGQDNRND]XMHVLÚWRQLHZ\VWDUF]DMÈFH:HGïXJ)HUUDU\UR]ZDĝHQLH PRĝOLZRĂFLLVWQLHQLDWU]HFLHJRUHĝLPXSR]ZDODOHSLHMRSLVDÊJRVSRGDUNÚVWUHI\HXUR0RĝOLZHVSH-F\ILNDFMHPRGHOX069$5SU]HGVWDZLDWDEHODZNWöUHMSDUDPHWU\]DOHĝQHRG]PLHQQHMUHĝLPX RNUHĂORQHVÈQDVWÚSXMÈFRMGODĂUHGQLHMIGODVWDïHMAGODSDUDPHWUöZDXWRUHJUHV\MQ\FKH dla KHWHURVNHGDVW\F]QRĂFLVNïDGQLNDORVRZHJR

0RGHO SU]HïÈF]QLNRZ\ ZHNWRURZHM DXWRUHJUHVML MHVW UR]V]HU]HQLHP PRGHOX DXWRUHJUHV\MQHJR ] SU]HïÈF]DQLHP W\SX 0DUNRZD -HGQDN SXQNWHP Z\MĂFLD SU]HSURZDG]RQHM DQDOL]\ MHVW PRGHO MHGQRZ\PLDURZ\RUD]]DïRĝHQLHZ\VWÚSRZDQLDGZöFKUHĝLPöZRGSRZLDGDMÈF\FKRNUHVRPVSR-ZROQLHQLD L SU]\VSLHV]HQLD DNW\ZQRĂFL JRVSRGDUF]HM SRU +DPLOWRQ  :\EöU RGSRZLHGQLH-JRPRGHOX]RVWDïGRNRQDQ\QDSRGVWDZLHNU\WHULöZLQIRUPDF\MQ\FK$NDLNHijD+DQQDQD4XLQQD L6FKZDU]DRUD]LVWRWQRĂFLSDUDPHWUöZ'ODSLHUZV]\FKSU]\URVWöZUHDOQHJR3.%X]\VNDQRRV]D- FRZDQLDSU]HïÈF]QLNRZHJRPRGHOX]bGZRPDUHĝLPDPLRUD]bKHWHURVNHGDVW\F]QRĂFLÈVNïDGQLNDOR-VRZHJR Z ]DOHĝQRĂFL RG UHĝLPX 06,+$5 D GOD SLHUZV]\FK UöĝQLF SURGXNFML Z SU]HP\ĂOH SU]HWZöUF]\PļDXWRUHJUHV\MQ\PRGHOSU]HïÈF]QLNRZ\]H]PLHQQÈZDULDQFMÈVNïDGQLNDORVRZHJR ]HZ]JOÚGXQDUHĝLP06,+$52V]DFRZDQLDSDUDPHWUöZ]RVWDï\SU]HGVWDZLRQHZWDEHODFK LDQDZ\NUHVLH]DSUH]HQWRZDQRSU]HELHJF\NOXNRQLXQNWXUDOQHJR

'DW\Z\VWÈSLHQLDSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FKX]\VNDQHGODZDKDñUHDOQHJR3.%VÈ]EOLĝRQHGRbX]\- VNDQ\FKSU]H])LFSRUWDEHODPLPRZ\VWÈSLHQLDSU]HVXQLÚÊJöUQ\FKSXQNWöZ]ZURW-Q\FK R ļ NZDUWDï\ Z VWRVXQNX GR Z\QLNöZ SUH]HQWRZDVNDQ\FKSU]H])LFSRUWDEHODPLPRZ\VWÈSLHQLDSU]HVXQLÚÊJöUQ\FKSXQNWöZ]ZURW-Q\FK Z DUW\NXOH 'UXJÈ UöĝQLFÈ MHVW SRGZ\ĝV]HQLHĂUHGQLFKVWöSZ]URVWX]DUöZQRGODRNUHVXVSRZROQLHQLDMDNLSU]\VSLHV]HQLDJR-VSRGDUF]HJR 1LH]QDF]QH UR]ELHĝQRĂFL PRJÈ Z\QLNDÊ ] UHZL]ML GDQ\FK RUD] UR]V]HU]HQLD ]DNUH-VXSUöE\ :PRGHOX]HVWDïÈ]DOHĝQÈRGUHĝLPXVWDïDv1 RGQRVLVLÚGRNZDUWDOQHMVWRS\Z]URVWX

ZRNUHVLHVSRZROQLHQLDDv2 –ZRNUHVLHRĝ\ZLHQLD¥UHGQLDDQQXOL]RZDQDVWRSDZ]URVWXUHDOQH- JR3.%ZRNUHVLHVSRZROQLHQLDZ\QLRVïDDbZbRNUHVLHRĝ\ZLHQLDSRGF]DVJG\ZSU]H- P\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PZRNUHVLHVSRZROQLHQLDRGQRWRZDQRVSDGNLĂUHGQLRRDZRNUHVLHRĝ\-ZLHQLDRZbXMÚFLXDQQXDOL]RZDQ\P3URGXNFMDZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PFKDUDNWHU\]XMHVLÚ ]DWHPZLÚNV]ÈDPSOLWXGÈZDKDñ3RGREQLHMDNSR]RVWDQLHZbRNUHVLHVSRZROQLHQLDZ]URVWXJRVSR-GDUF]HJRWDNĝHSU]HMĂFLH]bRNUHVXRĝ\ZLHQLDUHĝLPZbVWDQVSRZROQLHQLDUHĝLPMHVWEDUG]LHM SUDZGRSRGREQHGODbUHDOQHJR3.%:\QLNLGODSURGXNFMLZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PZVND]XMÈQD

WHQGHQFMHSU]HFLZQHZ\ĝV]HMHVWSUDZGRSRGRELHñVWZRSR]RVWDQLDZbUHĝLPLHRĝ\ZLHQLDQLĝVSDG-NXDNW\ZQRĂFL3UDZGRSRGRELHñVWZDSR]RVWDQLDZbRNUHĂORQHMID]LHF\NOXVÈZ\VRNLHGODRE\GZX ]PLHQQ\FK2F]HNLZDQ\F]DVWUZDQLDID]F\NOXZSU]\SDGNXUHDOQHJR3.%MHVWQLH]QDF]QLHGïXĝ-V]\GODID]\VSDGNRZHM3U]HFLZQD]DOHĝQRĂÊ]DFKRG]LZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PJG]LHRF]HNXMH VLÚĝHRNUHVRĝ\ZLHQLDJRVSRGDUF]HJREÚG]LHREOLVNRPLHVLÚF\GïXĝV]\RGRNUHVXVSRZROQLHQLD DNW\ZQRĂFL'ODREXPLHUQLNöZDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDUF]HMZDULDQFMDVNïDGQLNDORVRZHJRZ\ND]X- MHSHZQÈDV\PHWULÚLĂZLDGF]\RZLÚNV]HM]PLHQQRĂFLVWöSZ]URVWXZRNUHVLHVSDGNXQLĝ]ZLÚN-V]HQLD DNW\ZQRĂFL :DKDQLD UHDOQHJR 3.% ZVND]XMÈ QD Z\VWÈSLHQLH F]WHUHFK QLHSHïQ\FK F\NOL DZDKDQLDSU]HWZöUVWZDSU]HP\VïRZHJRļSLÚFLXQLHSHïQ\FKF\NOL3U]HELHJZDKDñRE\GZXPLHU- QLNöZMHVWSRGREQ\MHGQDNLVWQLHMÈGZDZ\MÈWNL:ODWDFKļID]DVSRZROQLHQLDZSU]HP\-ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PWUZDïDNUöFHMZSRUöZQDQLX]3.%3RQDGWRZDKDQLDUHDOQHJR3.%ZVND]XMÈQD Z\VWÚSRZDQLHID]\VSRZROQLHQLDJRVSRGDUF]HJRRG,,NZDUWDïXUSRGF]DVJG\ZSU]HP\ĂOH SU]HWZöUF]\PID]DWD]RVWDïD]DNRñF]RQDZVW\F]QLXUSXQNWHPNWöU\Z\]QDF]DPLQLPXP ZDKDñ3R]DZ\ĝHMZ\PLHQLRQ\PLZ\MÈWNDPLSXQNW\]ZURWQHZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PZ\VWÚ-SXMÈ]Z\NOHRMHGHQNZDUWDïZF]HĂQLHMQLĝZSU]\SDGNX3.%OXEZW\PVDP\PF]DVLH

3RUöZQDQLHZ\QLNöZQDSRGVWDZLHUöĝQ\FKPHWRGSRPLDUX

1D Z\NUHVLH  ]RVWDï\ SU]HGVWDZLRQH ZDKDQLD DNW\ZQRĂFL JRVSRGDUF]HM Z 3ROVFH RNUHĂORQH QD SRGVWDZLHWU]HFKPHWRGLFKSRPLDUX3R]DQLHZLHONLPLSU]HVXQLÚFLDPLSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FKX]\- VNDQ\FK]DSRPRFÈILOWUX&)RUD]PRGHOXQLHREVHUZRZDOQ\FKNRPSRQHQWöZ8&PLQLPDLPDNVL-PDZDKDñZVWRVXQNXGRSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FKRNUHĂORQ\FKQDSRGVWDZLHPRGHOL]SU]HïÈF]DQLHP W\SX 0DUNRZD QLH PD LVWRWQ\FK UöĝQLF Z SU]HELHJX ZDKDñ NRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FK FR SRWZLHUG]DMÈ ZVSöïF]\QQLNLNRUHODFML

2EOLF]RQ\ ZVSöïF]\QQLN NRUHODFML NU]\ĝRZHM cross-correlation SRPLÚG]\ VNïDGRZ\PL F\- NOLF]Q\PLZF\NOXRGFK\OHñGODUHDOQHJR3.%ZVND]XMHQDLVWRWQÈL]DUD]HPQDMVLOQLHMV]ÈNRUH-ODFMÚGRGDWQLÈGOD]HURZHJRRSöěQLHQLD:VSöïF]\QQLNNRUHODFMLUöZQRF]HVQHMZ\QLöVïLMHVW LVWRWQ\SU]\SR]LRPLHLVWRWQRĂFL'RVSUDZG]HQLDF]\Z\VWÚSXMHLVWRWQD]DOHĝQRĂÊSRPLÚG]\ SUDZGRSRGRELHñVWZDPL]QDOH]LHQLDVLÚJRVSRGDUNLZbVWDQLHRĝ\ZLHQLDDVNïDGRZ\PLF\NOLF]Q\PL X]\VNDQ\PL]DSRPRFÈILOWUX&)RUD]PRGHOXQLHREVHUZRZDOQ\FKNRPSRQHQWöZ8&SRVïXĝ\ï\ PRGHOHORJLWRZH=PLHQQD]DOHĝQDSU]\MÚïDZDUWRĂÊGODRNUHVXRĝ\ZLHQLDLGODVSRZROQLHQLD =PLHQQ\PLQLH]DOHĝQ\PLE\ï\SLHUZV]HUöĝQLFHPLÚG]\NRPSRQHQWDPLF\NOLF]Q\PLZVND]XMÈFH QDNLHUXQHNLFK]PLDQ:\QLNLRV]DFRZDñSDUDPHWUöZPRGHOLORJLWRZ\FK]DZLHUDWDEHOD-DNRĂÊ RV]DFRZDQ\FKPRGHOLMHVW]DGRZDODMÈFDQDFRZVND]XMHLVWRWQRĂÊ]PLHQQ\FKREMDĂQLDMÈF\FKLFK GRGDWQLDZDUWRĂÊSR]LRPGRSDVRZDQLDGRGDQ\FKDWDNĝHWUDIQRĂÊSURJQR]3RWZLHUG]DWRZ\VWÚ- SRZDQLHLVWRWQHM]DOHĝQRĂFLSRPLÚG]\NRPSRQHQWDPLF\NOLF]Q\PLDSUDZGRSRGRELHñVWZHP]QD-OH]LHQLDVLÚJRVSRGDUNLZbID]LHSU]\VSLHV]HQLDDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDUF]HM =EOLĝRQ\SU]HELHJZDKDñX]\VNDQ\FKQDSRGVWDZLHZ\NRU]\VWDQ\FKPHWRGSRPLDUXUHDOQHJR 3.%SRWZLHUG]DMÈGDW\SXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FK1LHREVHUZXMHVLÚWXLVWRWQ\FKUöĝQLFSR]DMHGQ\P Z\MÈWNLHP 1D SRGVWDZLH SU]HïÈF]QLNRZHJR PRGHOX 0DUNRZD RUD] PRGHOX QLHREVHUZRZDOQ\FK NRPSRQHQWöZ]LGHQW\ILNRZDQRF]WHU\QLHSHïQHF\NOHWDNĝHGDW\]ZURWöZNRQLXQNWXU\RUD]bGïX-JRĂFLID]E\ï\EDUG]RSRGREQH=DSRPRFÈILOWUX&)Z\NU\WRQDWRPLDVWGRGDWNRZ\F\NOZODWDFK ļSU]\SDGDMÈF\QDRNUHVRGb,9NZDUWDïXUGR,NZDUWDïXU:\QLNWHQUöĝQLVLÚ

RGbUH]XOWDWXX]\VNDQHJRSU]H]*UDG]HZLF]DLLQSRUWDEHODFRPRĝHZ\QLNDÊ]SU]\MÚ- FLDRGPLHQQHJR]DNUHVXZDKDñF\NOLF]Q\FKWUZDMÈF\FKRGGZöFKGRODW:\NRU]\VWDQHPHWR- G\SRPLDUXZDKDñNRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FKSR]ZROLï\QD]LGHQW\ILNRZDQLHQLHUHJXODUQ\FKZDKDñZ\-VWÚSXMÈF\FKZRNUHVDFKļOHWQLFKSRGF]DVJG\Z3ROVFHLVWRWQÈUROÚRGJU\ZDMÈWDNĝHZDKDQLD ļOHWQLHSRU6NU]\SF]\ñVNL)D]\Z]URVWRZHF\NOX]LGHQW\ILNRZDQHQDSRGVWDZLHPRGH-OXQLHREVHUZRZDOQ\FKNRPSRQHQWöZRUD]ILOWUX&)FKDUDNWHU\]XMÈVLÚZ\ĝV]ÈDPSOLWXGÈZDKDñ SRGF]DVJG\PRGHO]SU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZDZVND]XMHQDZ\VWÚSRZDQLH]DOHĝQRĂFLSU]H-FLZQHM%LRUÈFMHGQDNSRGXZDJÚGïXJRĂÊWUZDQLDID]RUD]VNDOÚZDKDñQLHVWZLHUG]DVLÚLVWQLHQLD DV\PHWULLID]ZF\NOXUHDOQHJR3.% :ZDKDQLDFKSURGXNFMLSU]HP\VïRZHM]DREVHUZRZDQRSLÚÊQLHSHïQ\FKF\NOLRbĂUHGQLHMGïXJR-ĂFLļURNXRUD]QLH]QDF]QHSU]HVXQLÚFLHSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FK3RGREQLHMDNGODF\NOXUHDOQHJR 3.%Z\QLNL6NU]\SF]\ñVNLHJRZVND]XMÈQDZ\VWÚSRZDQLHZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PWDN- ĝHF\NOöZļOHWQLFK=DUöZQRILOWU&)MDNLbSU]HïÈF]QLNRZ\PRGHO0DUNRZDZVND]XMÈQDDV\-PHWULÚID]F\NOXSU]HWZöUVWZDSU]HP\VïRZHJRSROHJDMÈFÈQDbZ\VWÚSRZDQLXUöZQRF]HĂQLHUöĝQLF PLÚG]\F]DVHPWUZDQLDID]RUD]ZLHONRĂFLDPLLFKDPSOLWXG)D]DZ]URVWRZDWUZDGïXĝHMLRG]QD-F]DVLÚPQLHMV]ÈDPSOLWXGÈ

6. Podsumowanie

3U]HSURZDG]RQHEDGDQLHGRVWDUF]DNRPSOHNVRZHMFKDUDNWHU\VW\NLZDKDñNRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FKZOD-WDFK ļ 8]\VNDQH Z\QLNL SRWZLHUG]DMÈ Z\VWÚSRZDQLH ZDKDñ DNW\ZQRĂFL JRVSRGDUF]HM Zb3ROVFHLZVND]XMÈQDLFK]EOLĝRQHNV]WDïWRZDQLHVLÚQLH]DOHĝQLHRGSU]\MÚWHMPHWRG\SRPLDUX 'DW\ SXQNWöZ ]ZURWQ\FK GOD WHM VDPHM ]PLHQQHM E\ï\ EDUG]R SRGREQH QDWRPLDVW ZDKDQLD NR- QLXQNWXUDOQHRNUHĂORQH]DSRPRFÈWHMVDPHMPHWRG\ZVND]Dï\QDUöZQRF]HVQHOXEZ\SU]HG]DMÈ-FHZ\VWÚSRZDQLH]ZURWöZNRQLXQNWXU\ZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PZVWRVXQNXGRUHDOQHJR3.% 1DMEDUG]LHMSRGREQHZ\QLNLX]\VNDQRGODZDKDñUHDOQHJR3.%SU]\Xĝ\FLXPRGHOLQLHREVHUZR-ZDOQ\FKNRPSRQHQWöZRUD]PRGHOX]SU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZD%DGDQLHZ\ND]DïRQDWRPLDVW RGPLHQQ\FKDUDNWHUSURFHVöZNRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FKRG]ZLHUFLHGORQ\FKZbZDKDQLDFKUHDOQHJR3.% RUD]SURGXNFMLZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\P:LÚNV]RĂÊPRGHOLZVND]XMHQDZ\VWÈSLHQLHF]WHUHFK QLHSHïQ\FKF\NOLZbZDKDQLDFKUHDOQHJR3.%RUD]SLÚFLXQLHSHïQ\FKF\NOLZbSU]\SDGNXSURGXN-FMLZbSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\P=LGHQW\ILNRZDQHF\NOHQLHFHFKXMÈVLÚĂFLVïÈUHJXODUQRĂFLÈMHGQDN LFK ĂUHGQLD GïXJRĂÊ GOD REX ]PLHQQ\FK MHVW ]EOLĝRQD L Z\QRVL RNRïR ļ ODW  3RWZLHUG]RQD ]R-VWDïDZLÚNV]D]PLHQQRĂÊZDKDñZbSU]HWZöUVWZLHSU]HP\VïRZ\PZbSRUöZQDQLX]UHDOQ\P3.% :bSU]HFLZLHñVWZLHGRUHDOQHJR3.%SU]HWZöUVWZRSU]HP\VïRZHFKDUDNWHU\]XMHVLÚWDNĝHDV\PH-WULÈID]F\NOXSU]HMDZLDMÈFÈVLÚGïXĝV]\PF]DVHPWUZDQLDRUD]PQLHMV]ÈDPSOLWXGÈID]\Z]URVWX DNW\ZQRĂFL QLĝ MHM VSDGNX 1DMZLÚNV]È UöĝQLFÚ PLÚG]\ ZDKDQLDPL 3.% RUD] SURGXNFML Z SU]H- WZöUVWZLHSU]HP\VïRZ\P]DREVHUZRZDQRZODWDFKļ)OXNWXDFMHZVNDěQLND3.%ZVND]D-ï\ĝHVSRZROQLHQLHJRVSRGDUF]H]DSRF]ÈWNRZDQHZ,,NZDUWDOHUWUZDQDGDOVWDQQDNRQLHF USRGF]DVJG\ZVNDěQLNSURGXNFMLZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PV\JQDOL]XMHID]ÚRĝ\ZLHQLD RG,,NZDUWDïXU

=SU]HSURZDG]RQHMDQDOL]\X]\VNDQRQLHFRRGPLHQQ\REUD]ZDKDñNRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FKZ3RO-VFH Z ODWDFK ļ QD SRGVWDZLH UHDOQHJR 3.% RUD] SURGXNFML Z SU]HP\ĂOH SU]HWZöUF]\P

5R]ELHĝQRĂÊZ\QLNöZZVND]XMHQDNRQLHF]QRĂÊUR]V]HU]HQLD]ELRUX]PLHQQ\FKZFHOXLGHQW\IL-NDFMLREV]DUöZSU]\F]\QLDMÈF\FKVLÚGRVWDELOL]DFMLDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDUF]HMPLHU]RQHM]DSRPRFÈ 3.%ZODWDFKļ8]\VNDQHUöĝQLFHZVND]Dï\WDNĝHQDSHZQÈXïRPQRĂÊSRGHMĂFLDMHGQR-Z\PLDURZHJRZ\QLNDMÈFÈ]QLHGRVNRQDïRĂFLSRMHG\QF]\FKPLHUQLNöZDNW\ZQRĂFLJRVSRGDUF]HM 5R]ZLÈ]DQLHPWHJRSUREOHPXPRJïDE\E\ÊNRQVWUXNFMDELHĝÈFHJR]ïRĝRQHJRZVNDěQLNDNRQLXQN- WXU\DQDVWÚSQLHDQDOL]DMHJRZDKDñ7DNĝH]DïRĝHQLHRZ\VWÚSRZDQLXWU]HFKID]F\NOXNRQLXQN- WXUDOQHJRZ]ERJDFLïRE\Z\QLNLSU]HSURZDG]RQHMDQDOL]\3URSRQRZDQ\SU]HELHJZDKDñF\NOLF]-Q\FKREHMPRZDïE\VSRZROQLHQLHRUD]GZLHID]\Rĝ\ZLHQLDXPLDUNRZDQHJRRUD]V]\ENLHJR

%LEOLRJUDğD

$GDPRZLF]('XGHN63DFKXFNL':DOF]\N.Synchronizacja cyklu koniunkturalnego

 SROVNLHMJRVSRGDUNL]NUDMDPLVWUHI\HXURZNRQWHNĂFLHVWUXNWXU\W\FKJRVSRGDUHN6]NRïD*ïöZQD

 +DQGORZDZ:DUV]DZLH,QVW\WXW5R]ZRMX*RVSRGDUF]HJR

%D[WHU0.LQJ5*Measuring Business Cycles: Approximate Band-Pass Filters for Economic Time Series1%(5:RUNLQJ3DSHU

%HOO : +LOOPHU 6  ,QLWLDOL]LQJ WKH .DOPDQ )LOWHU IRU1RQVWDWLRQDU\ 7LPH 6HULHV 0RGHOV Journal of Time Series Analysisļ

&KULVWLDQR/-)LW]JHUDOG7-The Band Pass Filter:RUNLQJ3DSHU)HGHUDO5HVHUYH  %DQNRI&OHYHODQG

&ODUN 3.  7KH &\FOLFDO &RPSRQHQW RI 86 (FRQRPLF $FWLYLW\ The Quarterly Journal of Economicsļ

'HPSVWHU$3/DLUG105XELQ'%0D[LPXP/LNHOLKRRG(VWLPDWLRQIURP,QFRPSOHWH  'DWDYLD(0$OJRULWKPJournal of the Royal Statistical Society6HULHV%ļ

'LFNH\'$)XOOHU:$'LVWULEXWLRQRIWKH(VWLPDWRUVIRU$XWRUHJUHVVLYH7LPH6HULHVZLWK  D8QLW5RRWJournal of the American Statistical Associationļ

'XGHN63DFKXFNL'Unobserved Component Model with Observed Cycle, Use of BTS Data

for Short-term Forecasting of Manufacturing ProductionWK_{&,5(7&RQIHUHQFH1HZ<RUN}

)HUUDUD/A Real-time Recession Indicator for the Euro Area035$:RUNLQJ3DSHU  0đQLFK3HUVRQDO5H3(&$UFKLYH

)LF7&\NONRQLXQNWXUDOQ\Z3ROVFH:QLRVNL]PRGHOL0DUNRZDZ$:HOIHUHGSiódme warsztaty doktorskie z zakresu ekonometrii i statystyki0HWRG\LORĂFLRZHZQDXNDFKHNRQRPLF] nych6]NRïD*ïöZQD+DQGORZDZ:DUV]DZLH

*RPH]90DUDYDOO$Program TRAMO and SEATS: Instructions for the User, Beta Version  %DQFRGH(VSDóD:RUNLQJ3DSHUV

*UDG]HZLF] 0 *URZLHF - +DJHPHMHU - 3RSRZVNL 3  &\NO NRQLXQNWXUDOQ\ Z 3ROVFH ļ  ZQLRVNL]DQDOL]\VSHNWUDOQHMBank i Kredytļ

+DPLOWRQ-$1HZ$SSURDFKWRWKH(FRQRPLF$QDO\VLVRI1RQVWDWLRQDU\7LPH6HULHVDQG  WKH%XVLQHVV&\FOHEconometricaļ

+RGULFN 5- 3UHVFRWW (&  3RVWZDU 86 %XVLQHVV &\FOHV $Q (PSLULFDO ,QYHVWLJDWLRQ Journal of Money, Credit and Bankingļ

+đEQHU'/XELñVNL00DïHFNL:0DNRZVNL=Koniunktura gospodarcza3DñVWZRZH

 :\GDZQLFWZR(NRQRPLF]QH:DUV]DZD

.LP &K-  '\QDPLF /LQHDU 0RGHOV ZLWK 0DUNRY6ZLWFKLQJ Journal of Econometrics

 ļ

.URO]LJ+0Markov-Switching Vector Autoregressions. Modelling, Statistical Inference and Applications to Business Cycle Analysis6SULQJHU%HUOLQ

.ZLDWNRZVNL '3 3KLOOLSV &% 6FKPLGW 3 6KLQ <  7HVWLQJ WKH 1XOO +\SRWKHVLV RI  6WDWLRQDU\DJDLQVWWKH$OWHUQDWLYHRID8QLW5RRWJournal of Econometricsļļ /XFDV 5( -U  Understanding Business Cycle &DUQHJLH ļ 5RFKHVWHU &RQIHUHQFH 6HULHV RQ  3XEOLF3ROLF\

0DF.LQQRQ-*1XPHULFDO'LVWULEXWLRQ)XQFWLRQVIRU8QLW5RRWDQG&RLQWHJUDWLRQ7HVWV Journal of Apllied Econometricsļ

6NU]\SF]\ñVNL 3  :DKDQLD DNW\ZQRĂFL JRVSRGDUF]HM Z 3ROVFH L VWUHILH HXUR 0DWHULDï\  L6WXGLD1DURGRZ\%DQN3ROVNL:DUV]DZD

:DWVRQ0:8QLYDULDWH'HWUHQGLQJ0HWKRGVZLWK6WRFKDVWLF7UHQGVJournal of Monetary Economicsļ

Aneks

½UöGïDV]HUHJöZF]DVRZ\FK ļUHDOQ\3.%ļGDQHNZDUWDOQHFHQ\VWDïHUREOLF]RQ\QDSRGVWDZLH3.%ZbFHQDFKELH-ĝÈF\FKRUD]GHIODWRUD3.%SR]\VNDQ\FK]ED]\GDQ\FK(XURVWDW ļQRPLQDOQ\3.%ļGDQHNZDUWDOQHFHQ\ELHĝÈFHGDQH*86SR]\VNDQH]ED]\GDQ\FK(XURVWDW ļGHIODWRU3.%ļGDQHNZDUWDOQHLQGHNVMHGQRSRGVWDZRZ\ GDQH*86SR]\VND-QH]ED]\GDQ\FK(XURVWDW ļSURGXNFMDVSU]HGDQDSU]HP\VïXSU]HWZöUF]HJRļGDQHPLHVLÚF]QHFHQ\VWDïHLQGHNVMHGQR-SRGVWDZRZ\ GDQH*86SR]\VNDQH]ED]\GDQ\FK(XURVWDW :\NUHV 5HDOQ\3.%RUD]SURGXNFMDZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PRF]\V]F]RQH]ZDKDñVH]RQRZ\FKLbREVHUZDFML QLHW\SRZ\FK 11,8 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 11,9 12,0 12,1 12,2 12,3 12,4 12,5 12,6 PKB realny 3,8 4,0 4,2 4,4 4,6 4,8 5,0 5,2 Przemysł przetwórczy

:\NUHV 3URGXNWSRWHQFMDOQ\RUD]VNïDGRZDF\NOLF]QDUHDOQHJR3.%LZbSU]HWZöUVWZLHSU]HP\VïRZ\PX]\VNDQ\FK ]PRGHOXQLHREVHUZRZDOQ\FKNRPSRQHQWöZ :\NUHV 3URGXNWSRWHQFMDOQ\RUD]VNïDGRZDF\NOLF]QDUHDOQHJR3.%LSURGXNFMLZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\P Z\RGUÚEQLRQH]DSRPRFÈDV\PHWU\F]QHJRILOWUX&KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOGD -0,08 -0,06 -0,04 -0,02 0,00 0,02 0,04 11,4 11,6 11,8 12,0 12,2 12,4 12,6

PKB realny Produkt potencjalny Składowa cykliczna

1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 -0,12 -0,10 -0,08 -0,06 -0,04 -0,02 0,00 0,02 0,04 0,06 0,08 0,10 3,8 4,0 4,2 4,4 4,6 4,8 5,0 5,2 -0,03 -0,02 -0,01 0,00 0,01 0,02 0,03 0,04 11,8 11,9 12,0 12,1 12,2 12,3 12,4 12,5 12,6 PKB realny Produkt potencjalny Składowa cykliczna Przemysł przetwórczy Produkt potencjalny Składowa cykliczna 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

:\NUHV

3UDZGRSRGRELHñVWZDZ\VWÈSLHQLDRĝ\ZLHQLDQDWOHSLHUZV]\FKSU]\URVWöZUHDOQHJR3.%LbSURGXNFML ZSU]HWZöUVWZLHSU]HP\VïRZ\PRUD]RNUHVöZVSRZROQLHQLD

8ZDJD ]H Z]JOÚGX QD SU]\MÚWÈ UHJXïÚ GDWRZDQLD SDWU] XZDJD Z WDEHOL  RNUHV RG NZLHWQLD GR OLVWRSDGD  U GODb SURGXNFML Zb SU]HWZöUVWZLH SU]HP\VïRZ\P ]RVWDï ]DNODV\ğNRZDQ\ GR ID]\ VSRZROQLHQLD PLPR ĝH PRGHO SU]HïÈF]QLNRZ\ZVND]\ZDïZ\VWÚSRZDQLHZW\PRNUHVLHID]\Rĝ\ZLHQLD :\NUHV 3RUöZQDQLHPLDUVNïDGRZHMF\NOLF]QHMGODUHDOQHJR3.%RUD]ZSU]HWZöUVWZLHSU]HP\VïRZ\P -0,5 -0,3 -0,1 0,1 0,3 0,5 0,7 0,9 1,1 1,3 1,5 -0,5 0,0 0,5 1,0 1,5 2,0 2,5 3,0 Okres spowolnienia PKB realny kw./kw. (lewa oś)

Prawdopodobieństwo ożywienia (prawa oś)

Okres spowolnienia

Przemysł przetwórczy m/m (lewa oś) Prawdopodobieństwo ożywienia (prawa oś)

-0,5 -0,3 -0,1 0,1 0,3 0,5 0,7 0,9 1,1 1,3 1,5 -9 -7 -5 -3 -1 1 3 5 7 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 -0,5 -0,3 -0,1 0,1 0,3 0,5 0,7 0,9 1,1 1,3 1,5 -0,10 -0,08 -0,06 -0,04 -0,02 0,00 0,02 0,04 0,06 0,08 0,10 -0,6 -0,1 0,4 0,9 1,4 -0,08 -0,06 -0,04 -0,02 0,00 0,02 0,04 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Okres spowolnienia

Składowa cykliczna CF (lewa oś)

Okres spowolnienia

Składowa cykliczna CF (lewa oś) Składowa cykliczna UC (lewa oś)

Prawdopodobieństwo ożywienia (prawa oś)

7DEHOD 7HVW\QLHVWDFMRQDUQRĂFL$')RUD]VWDFMRQDUQRĂFL.366 $0RGHO]HVWDïÈLWUHQGHPOLQLRZ\P =PLHQQD $') .366 VWDW\VW\NDt pYDOXH _{VWDW\VW\NDLM}2 3.%UHDOQ\    3U]HWZöUVWZR SU]HP\VïRZH    %0RGHO]HVWDïÈ =PLHQQD $') .366 VWDW\VW\NDt pYDOXH _{VWDW\VW\NDLM}2 3.%UHDOQ\    3U]HWZöUVWZR SU]HP\VïRZH    &0RGHO]HVWDïÈGODSLHUZV]\FKSU]\URVWöZ =PLHQQD $') .366 VWDW\VW\NDt pYDOXH _{VWDW\VW\NDLM}2 3.%UHDOQ\    3U]HWZöUVWZR SU]HP\VïRZH    _{:DUWRĂFLXVWDORQHSU]H]0DF.LQQRQDGODWHVWXMHGQRVWURQQHJR} _{6WDW\VW\NDWHVWXDV\PSWRW\F]QHZDUWRĂFLNU\W\F]QHGODPRGHOX]HVWDïÈLWUHQGHPOLQRZ\PSU]\SR]LRPLHLVWRWQRĂFL} Z\QRV]ÈRGSRZLHGQLRDGODPRGHOX]HVWDïÈSRU.ZLDWNRZVNL LLQ

_{: W\P SU]\SDGNX LVWQLHMÈ SRGVWDZ\ GR RGU]XFHQLD KLSRWH]\ ]HURZHM SU]\ SURFHQWRZ\P SR]LRPLH LVWRWQRĂFL}

7DEHOD

2V]DFRZDQLDSDUDPHWUöZPRGHOLQLHREVHUZRZDOQ\FKNRPSRQHQWöZGODUHDOQHJR3.%GODRNUHVX,NZDUWDï ļ,9NZDUWDïU

b :DUWRĂÊSDUDPHWUX %ïÈGVWDQGDUGRZ\ Statystyka z pYDOXH

μ     ln (1000Ʊ2 Ƥ)     ƴ1     ƴ2     ln (1000Ʊ2 ƭ)     Stany w momencie

t = T + 1 RMSE Statystyka z pYDOXH

Tt     Ct     C_t-1     /RJDU\WP ZLDU\JRGQRĂFL  6,&  /LF]ED SDUDPHWUöZ  +4  $,&  8ZDJDDOJRU\WPRVLÈJQÈï]ELHĝQRĂÊSRLWHUDFMDFK

7DEHOD

&KDUDNWHU\VW\NDSU]HELHJXZDKDñNRQLXQNWXUDOQ\FK

Realny PKB

Model UC b faza wzrostowa faza spadkowa

G D 'DWRZDQLH ,NZ ,,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,9NZ ¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊID]\ ZNZDUWDïDFK   ¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊF\NOX ZbNZDUWDïDFK   ¥UHGQLHRGFK\OHQLHRGWUHQGX Z   2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZHID]\ ZbSNWSURF   2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZHF\NOX ZbSNWSURF  

Filtr CF b bID]DZ]URVWRZD bID]DVSDGNRZD

G D 'DWRZDQLH ,NZ ,,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,9NZ ¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊID]\ ZNZDUWDïDFK   ¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊF\NOX ZbNZDUWDïDFK   ¥UHGQLHRGFK\OHQLHRGWUHQGX Z   2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZHID]\ ZbSNWSURF   2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZHF\NOX ZbSNWSURF   06$5 b bbID]DZ]URVWRZD bbID]DVSDGNRZD G D 'DWRZDQLH ,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,9NZ ¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊID]\ ZNZDUWDïDFK  

¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊF\NOX ZbNZDUWDïDFK   ¥UHGQLDVWRSDZ]URVWXNZNZ Z   2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZHID]\ ZbSNWSURF   3URGXNFMDZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\P

Filtr CF b faza wzrostowa faza spadkowa

G D 'DWRZDQLH                     ¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊID]\ ZPLHVLÈFDFK   ¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊF\NOX ZbPLHVLÈFDFK   ¥UHGQLHRGFK\OHQLHRGWUHQGX Z   2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZHID]\ ZbSNWSURF   2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZHF\NOX ZbSNWSURF  

06$5 b faza wzrostowa faza spadkowa

G D 'DWRZDQLH                   ¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊID]\ ZPLHVLÈFDFK   ¥UHGQLDGïXJRĂÊF\NOX ZbPLHVLÈFDFK   ¥UHGQLDVWRSDZ]URVWXPP Z   2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZHID]\ ZbSNWSURF   8ZDJDSXQNW\]ZURWQHVNïDGRZ\FKF\NOLF]Q\FKX]\VNDQ\FKQDSRGVWDZLHPRGHOX8&RUD]ğOWUX&)]RVWDï\Z\]QD- F]RQHMDNRPDNVLPDLbPLQLPDORNDOQHX]\VNDQ\FKNRPSRQHQWöZF\NOLF]Q\FK:PRGHOXSU]HïÈF]QLNRZ\PW\SX0DU- NRZDSU]\SRU]ÈGNRZDQLHREVHUZDFMLGRID]\VSRZROQLHQLDQDVWÈSLïRZSU]\SDGNXJG\SUDZGRSRGRELHñVWZRZ\JïD-G]RQHX]\VNDQH]PRGHOL]bSU]HïÈF]DQLHPW\SX0DUNRZDE\ïRPQLHMV]HQLĝ:SR]RVWDï\FKSU]\SDGNDFKX]QDQR ĝHJRVSRGDUND]QDMGRZDïDVLÚZVWDQLHRĝ\ZLHQLD:UDPDFKNDĝGHM]PHWRGID]DF\NOXSRZLQQDWUZDÊFRQDMPQLHMGZD NZDUWDï\DFDï\F\NOFRQDMPQLHMURNX *ļSXQNWZ\]QDF]DMÈF\PDNVLPXPZDKDñ 'ļSXQNWZ\]QDF]DMÈF\PLQLPXPZDKDñ

7DEHOD

3U]HELHJF\NOXNRQLXQNWXUDOQHJRZ3ROVFHļSU]HJOÈGOLWHUDWXU\

Realny PKB

Model UC b faza wzrostowa faza spadkowa

$GDPRZLF]LLQ  b G D 'DWRZDQLH _{,NZ ,NZ} ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ Filtr CF b b b b b $GDPRZLF]LLQ  'DWRZDQLH b ,NZ ,9NZ ,,NZ ,,NZ *UDG]HZLF]LLQ  'DWRZDQLHb ,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,9NZ 06$5 )LF 'DWRZDQLH ,NZ ,,,NZ ,9NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ¥UHGQLDVWRSD Z]URVWX NZNZZb   3URGXNFMDZSU]HP\ĂOH

Filtr CF b faza wzrostowa faza spadkowa

$GDPRZLF]LLQ  b G D 'DWRZDQLH         *UDG]HZLF]LLQ  'DWRZDQLH ,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,9NZ ,NZ ,,NZ ,,,NZ ,9NZ b b 8ZDJDUöĝQLFHZZ\VWÚSRZDQLXSXQNWöZ]ZURWQ\FKPRJÈZ\QLNDÊ]SU]\MÚFLDRGPLHQQ\FKUHJXïGDWRZDQLD UHZL]MLGDQ\FKDWDNĝHUR]V]HU]HQLD]DNUHVXSUöE\ *ļSXQNWZ\]QDF]DMÈF\PDNVLPXPZDKDñ 'ļSXQNWZ\]QDF]DMÈF\PLQLPXPZDKDñ

7DEHOD .RPELQDFMHGODPRGHOX069$5 MSM MSI μ zmienna μ VWDïD v zmienny v VWDï\ A_iVWDïD ȈVWDïD 0609$5 OLQLRZ\9$5 06,9$5 OLQLRZ\9$5 Ȉ]PLHQQD 060+9$5 06+9$5 06,+9$5 06+9$5 Ai ]PLHQQD ȈVWDïD 060$9$5 06$9$5 06,$9$5 06$9$5 Ȉ]PLHQQD 060$+9$5 06$+9$5 06,$+9$5 06$+9$5 ½UöGïRRSUDFRZDQLHQDSRGVWDZLH.URO]LJ 7DEHOD 2V]DFRZDQLDSDUDPHWUöZPRGHOX06,+$5GODUHDOQHJR3.%GODRNUHVX,,NZDUWDïļ,9NZDUWDï U Oszacowania parametrów PKB v1  v2  6(VSRZROQLHQLH  6(Rĝ\ZLHQLH  5HĝLP 5HĝLP /LF]EDREVHUZDFML Oczekiwana _GïXJRĂÊ 5HĝLP     5HĝLP     7DEHOD 2V]DFRZDQLDSDUDPHWUöZPRGHOX06,+$5GODSURGXNFMLZSU]HP\ĂOHSU]HWZöUF]\PGODRNUHVX NZLHFLHñļVW\F]HñU Oszacowania parametrów Przetwórstwo SU]HP\VïRZH v₁  v₂  PMt-1  PMt-2  6(VSRZROQLHQLH  6(Rĝ\ZLHQLH  5HĝLP 5HĝLP /LF]EDREVHUZDFML Oczekiwana _GïXJRĂÊ 5HĝLP     5HĝLP    

8ZDJD Z\QLNL Z WDEHOL  PRJÈ UöĝQLÊ VLÚ RG Z\QLNöZ GOD SU]HïÈF]QLNRZ\FK PRGHOL 0DUNRZD SU]HGVWDZLRQ\FK ZWDEHOL]HZ]JOÚGXQDSU]\MÚWÈUHJXïÚGDWRZDQLDSRUZ\NUHV

7DEHOD

:\QLNLHVW\PDFMLSDUDPHWUöZPRGHOLORJLWRZ\FK

$3LHUZV]HUöĝQLFHVNïDGRZHMF\NOLF]QHMUHDOQHJR3.%X]\VNDQH]DSRPRFÈğOWUX&)MDNR]PLHQQD QLH]DOHĝQD

3UöED,,NZDUWDïļ

,9NZDUWDïUb :VSöïF]\QQLN %ïÈGVWDQGDUGRZ\ pYDOXH

6WDïD   

=PLHQQDQLH]DOHĝQD   

¥UHGQLDDU\WPHW\F]QD]PLHQQHM

]DOHĝQHM  2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZH]PLHQQHM]DOHĝQHM 

0F)DGGHQ5NZDGUDW  6NRU\JRZDQ\ 5NZDGUDW 

/RJDU\WPZLDU\JRGQRĂFL  $,&  6,&  +4  /LF]EDSU]\SDGNöZķSRSUDZQHM SUHG\NFMLĵ  7HVWLORUD]XZLDU\JRGQRĂFL &KLNZDGUDW >@ 8ZDJDDOJRU\WPRVLÈJQÈï]ELHĝQRĂÊSRLWHUDFMDFK %3LHUZV]HUöĝQLFHVNïDGRZHMF\NOLF]QHMUHDOQHJR3.%X]\VNDQH]DSRPRFÈPRGHOX8&MDNR ]PLHQQDQLH]DOHĝQD 3UöED,,NZDUWDïļ

,9NZDUWDïU :VSöïF]\QQLN %ïÈGVWDQGDUGRZ\ pYDOXH

6WDïD   

=PLHQQDQLH]DOHĝQD   

¥UHGQLDDU\WPHW\F]QD]PLHQQHM

]DOHĝQHM  2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZH]PLHQQHM]DOHĝQHM  0F)DGGHQ5NZDGUDW  6NRU\JRZDQ\ 5NZDGUDW 

/RJDU\WPZLDU\JRGQRĂFL  $,&  6,&  +4  /LF]EDSU]\SDGNöZķSRSUDZQHM SUHG\NFMLĵ  7HVWLORUD]XZLDU\JRGQRĂFL &KLNZDGUDW >@ 8ZDJDDOJRU\WPRVLÈJQÈï]ELHĝQRĂÊSRLWHUDFMDFK

&3LHUZV]HUöĝQLFHVNïDGRZHMF\NOLF]QHMZSU]HWZöUVWZLHSU]HP\VïRZ\PX]\VNDQH]DSRPRFÈ ğOWUX&)MDNR]PLHQQDQLH]DOHĝQD

3UöEDNZLHFLHñļVW\F]Hñ

Ub :VSöïF]\QQLN %ïÈGVWDQGDUGRZ\ pYDOXH

6WDïD   

=PLHQQDQLH]DOHĝQD   

¥UHGQLDDU\WPHW\F]QD]PLHQQHM

]DOHĝQHM  2GFK\OHQLHVWDQGDUGRZH]PLHQQHM]DOHĝQHM  0F)DGGHQ5NZDGUDW  6NRU\JRZDQ\ 5NZDGUDW 

/RJDU\WPZLDU\JRGQRĂFL  $,&  6,&  +4  /LF]EDSU]\SDGNöZķSRSUDZQHM SUHG\NFMLĵ  7HVWLORUD]XZLDU\JRGQRĂFL &KLNZDGUDW >@ 8ZDJDDOJRU\WPRVLÈJQÈï]ELHĝQRĂÊSRLWHUDFMDFK

0HDVXULQJWKHEXVLQHVVF\FOHLQ3RODQGļFRPSDUDWLYHDQDO\VLV

Abstract

7KHDUWLFOHSUHVHQWVWKHPRGHOLQJRIEXVLQHVVF\FOHLQ3RODQGVLQFHWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWR-DQXDU\ 7KHDQDO\VLVZDVFRQGXFWHGRQWKHEDVLVRITXDUWHUO\UHDO*'3DQGPRQWKO\SURGXFWLRQLQ PDQXIDFWXULQJ XVLQJ XQREVHUYHG FRPSRQHQWV PRGHO &KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOG EDQGSDVV ILOWHU DQG 0DUNRYVZLWFKLQJPRGHO

2Q WKH RQH KDQG WKH F\FOLFDO IOXFWXDWLRQV RI HDFK LQGLFDWRU PHDVXUHG ZLWKLQ WKUHH DERYH PHQWLRQHGPHWKRGVDUHVLPLODU2QWKHRWKHUKDQGWKHUHDUHVRPHGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHSDWWHUQRI IOXFWXDWLRQVEHWZHHQUHDO*'3DQGSURGXFWLRQLQPDQXIDFWXULQJZKLFKUHYHDOHGDOPRVWDQG F\FOHVUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHVHF\FOHVDUHQRWVWULFWO\SHULRGLFEXWWKH\ODVWVLPLODUO\ORQJDERXWļ \HDUV7XUQLQJSRLQWVLQPDQXIDFWXULQJXVXDOO\OHDGE\QRPRUHWKDQPRQWKVRUFRLQFLGHZLWK WKHLUFRXQWHUSDUWVRIUHDO*'3H[FOXGLQJ\HDUVļ7KHUHZDVDOVRFRQILUPHGWKHJUHDWHU YRODWLOLW\LQPDQXIDFWXULQJFRPSDUHGWRUHDO*'3,QYHUVHO\WRUHDO*'3WKHEXVLQHVVF\FOHSKDVHV LQPDQXIDFWXULQJDUHDV\PPHWULFERWKZLWKOHQJWKDQGDPSOLWXGH

Keywords EXVLQHVV F\FOH WXUQLQJ SRLQWV &KULVWLDQR)LW]JHUDOG EDQGSDVV ILOWHU XQREVHUYHG