Zastosowanie metody wielokryterialnej do analizy diagnostycznej pacjenta z chorobą zwyrodnieniową stawu biodrowego

(1)

ZASTOSOWANIE METODY WIELOKRYTERIALNEJ DO

ANALIZY DIAGNOSTYCZNEJ PACJENTA Z CHOROBĄ

ZW YRODNIENIOWĄ STAWU BIODROWEGO

Luiza Fabisiak1_{, K arina Szczypiór-Piaseck a}2_,

Ryszard Budziński3_{, Paweł Ziętek}4

_{=DFKRGQLRSRPRUVNL8QLZHUV\WHW7HFKQRORJLF]Q\Z6]F]HFLQLH} :\G]LDá,QIRUPDW\NL.DWHGUD,QĪ\QLHULL2SURJUDPRZDQLD HPDLOOIDELVLDN#ZL]XWHGXSO _{3RPRUVNL8QLZHUV\WHW0HG\F]Q\} .DWHGUDL.OLQLND2UWRSHGLL7UDXPDWRORJLLL2QNRORJLL1DU]ąGX5XFKX HPDLONDULQDV]F]\SLRU#LQWHULDSO _{8QLZHUV\WHW6]F]HFLĔVNL} :\G]LDá1DXN(NRQRPLF]Q\FKL=DU]ąG]DQLD ,QVW\WXW,QIRUPDW\NLZ=DU]ąG]DQLX HPDLOU\V]DUGEXG]LQVNL#ZQHL]SO _{3RPRUVNL8QLZHUV\WHW0HG\F]Q\} .DWHGUDL.OLQLND2UWRSHGLL7UDXPDWRORJLLL2QNRORJLL1DU]ąGX5XFKX HPDLOSDXO]#ZSSO

Słowa kluczowe_{0&'0(OHFWUH7UL$+3FKRURED]Z\URGQLHQLRZDVWDZXELRGURZHJR}

Streszczenie _{$UW\NXáSU]HGVWDZLDZLHORNU\WHULDOQąSURFHGXUĊSRVWĊSRZDQLDSU]\NZDOLILNDFMLSD} FMHQWyZGR]DELHJXZ\PLDQ\VWDZXELRGURZHJRZSURFHVLHOHF]HQLD=DVWRVRZDQR PHWRGĊ(OHFWUH7ULZK\EU\GRZ\PV\VWHPLH'66$UW\NXáVNáDGDVLĊ]RSLVXNRP SHWHQFMLHNVSHUWyZGU]HZDGHF\]\MQHJRRUD]PRGHORZDQLDUDQNLQJyZLNODV\ILNDFML SRGMĊWHJRSUREOHPX3U]\NáDGHPEDGDZF]\PVąSDFMHQFL]UyĪQ\P]DDZDQVRZDQLHP FKRURE\]Z\URGQLHQLRZHMNWyU\FKVWDQRNUHĞORQRZWUDNFLHOHF]HQLDV]SLWDOQHJR

Wprowadzenie

=DDZDQVRZDQH]PLDQ\]Z\URGQLHQLRZHSRZRGXMą]DEXU]HQLDZELRPHFKDQLFHZ\VWąSLH QLHLQQ\FKG\VIXQNFMLQLHVSUDZQRĞüLL]RODFMĊVSRáHF]Qą0QRJRĞüXZDUXQNRZDĔRUyĪQ\PQD VLOHQLXVWDQXSDFMHQWDSRZRGXMHSUREOHP]XVWDOHQLHPRSW\PDOQHJRPRPHQWXOHF]HQLDRSHUDF\M QHJRSDFMHQWyZ]FKRUREą]Z\URGQLHQLRZąVWDZXELRGURZHJR3UREOHPNODV\ILNDFMLSDFMHQWyZ GRRSHUDFMLMHVW]áRĪRQ\2SXEOLNRZDQHEDGDQLDXND]XMąUyĪQRURGQRĞüSDUDPHWUyZZDULDQWyZ

(2)

NODV\ILNDFMLSDFMHQWyZ]FKRUREą]Z\URGQLHQLRZąVWDZXELRGURZHJR6URNRZVNLLZVSyáSUD FRZQLF\ZVZRMHMSUDF\RFHQLDOLMDNRĞüFKRGXRUD]VWDQIXQNFMRQDOQ\SDFMHQWyZ]DNZDOLILNRZD Q\FKGR]DELHJXHQGRSURWH]RSODVW\NL6URNRZVNL%XáDWRZLF]LLQ.ROHMQ\PNU\WHULXP MHVW]DOHĪQRĞüPLĊG]\REQLĪHQLHPVLá\PLĊĞQLRZHMDZ\VWĊSRZDQLHPFKRURE\]Z\URGQLHQLRZHM VWDZXELRGURZHJRRUD]QDMEDUG]LHMSRZWDU]DOQHLPLDURGDMQHWHVW\IXQNFMLWDNLHMDNPDUV]RUD] FKyGSRVFKRGDFK$URNRVNL+DDUDLLQ$URNRVNL6XHWWD=DXZDĪDVLĊSU]\ W\PXERJRĞüSURSR]\FMLRFHQLDMąF\FKZV]\VWNLHQDMZDĪQLHMV]HSDUDPHWU\]]DNUHVXELRPHFKD QLNLZMHGQ\PV\VWHPLHLZW\PNRQWHNĞFLHNODV\ILNDFMĊFKRUHJRSDFMHQWDGR]DELHJXRSHUDF\M QHJR-HVWWR]DVDGQLF]\SUREOHPPHG\F]Q\Z\PDJDMąF\RGSRZLHGQLHJRUR]ZLą]DQLD3UREOHP GUXJLWRGREyUDGHNZDWQHMPHWRG\V\VWHPXZVSRPDJDQLDGHF\]MLZW\P]DNUHVLH

:VSyáF]HĞQLH SURZDG]ąF\ DQDOL]\ G\VSRQXMą GXĪą LORĞFLą Z\SUDFRZDQ\FK PH WRG ]ZLą]DQ\FK ] LQWHUSUHWDFMą RGZ]RURZDQ\FK ]MDZLVN 3RZVWDMH SUREOHP XĪ\WHF]QRĞFL W\FK PHWRG GOD NRQNUHWQ\FK SUREOHPyZ GHF\]\MQ\FK &HOHP DUW\NXáX MHVW Z\SUDFRZDQLH L]ZHU\ILNRZDQLHSURFHGXU\EDGDZF]HMGODRFHQ\FKRURE\]Z\URGQLHQLRZHMVWDZXELRGURZH JR =ZHU\ILNRZDQLH RGSRZLHGQLHM PHWRG\ ZLHORNU\WHULDOQHM SR]ZROL QD SUHF\]\MQH XVWDOHQLH NZDOLILNDFMLSDFMHQWDGR]DELHJX

Uwarunkowania formalnej oceny wielokryterialnego problemu decyzyjnego u badanych pacjentów

2SHUDFMDQLHVLH]DVREąSRSUDZĊVWDQXIXQNFMRQDOQHJRDOHUyZQLHĪU\]\NRSRZLNáDĔLLQ Q\FK]DJURĪHĔ&KRURED]Z\URGQLHQLRZDVWDZXELRGURZHJRMHVWFKRUREąSU]HZOHNáąZNWyUHM QLHGDVLĊFRIQąü]DLVWQLDá\FK]PLDQ2GSRZLHGQLRGREUDQ\SURJUDPIL]MRWHUDSLLMHVWZVWDQLH VSRZROQLüSRVWĊSFKRURE\$QDOL]LH]RVWDá\SRGGDQHGDQHEDGDQ\FKSDFMHQWyZREHMPXMąFHVWDQ LFK]GURZLD0LPRLVWQLHQLDUyĪQRURGQ\FKPHWRGZVSRPDJDQLDGHF\]MLG\OHPDWHPSR]RVWDMH QDGDOGREyURGSRZLHGQLHJR]HVWDZXQDU]ĊG]LLQG\ZLGXDOQLHQDSRWU]HE\EDGDQHJRSUREOHPX :SUDNW\FHLVWQLHMHZLHOHPHWRGSUH]HQWXMąF\FKUyĪQHSRGHMĞFLDGRUR]ZLą]DĔғ problemów de F\]\MQ\FK7HFKQLNLDJUHJDFMLZLHOXNU\WHULyZVWRVRZDQHZPHWRGDFK0&'$0&'0Wielo-kryterialnej Analizy Decyzji Wielokryterialnego Podejmowania Decyzji]JUXSRZDQHVąZWU]\ QDVWĊSXMąFHPRGHOHWHFKQLNDJUHJDFML – IRUPDUHODF\MQDRSDUWDQDUHODFMLSU]HZ\ĪV]DQLD – IRUPDIXQNF\MQDRSDUWDQDIXQNFMLXĪ\WHF]QRĞFL – IRUPDV\PEROLF]QDRSDUWDQDUHJXáDFKGHF\]\MQ\FK/H[HU9DNLF :PHWRGRORJLLEDGDZF]HMGRUR]ZLą]DQLDFHOXSUDF\]DSURSRQRZDQRPHWRGĊ(OHFWUH7UL NWyUDVWRVRZDQDMHVWGR]DJDGQLHQLDNODV\ILNDF\MQHJR:PHWRG]LHWHMUHODFMDSU]HZ\ĪV]DQLD XĪ\ZDQDMHVWGRV]DFRZDQLDVWRSQLDSU]HZ\ĪV]DQLDZDULDQWyZGHF\]\MQ\FKa (obiektów) nad profile bNWyUHVHSDUXMąRGVLHELHNODV\'XPSRV=RSRXQLGLV0HWRGDWD]DMPXMHVLĊ ]DJDGQLHQLHP VRUWRZDQLD L Z\NRU]\VWXMH SVHXGRNU\WHULD NWyUH Z\]QDF]DMą ZVSyáF]\QQLNL ]JRGQRĞFLLZLDU\JRGQRĞFLRUD]ZVNDĨQLNLQLH]JRGQRĞFL3RGF]DVZ\]QDF]DQLDW\FKZDUWRĞFL ]DFKRG]ąW\ONRQLHZLHONLHUyĪQLFHGRW\F]ąFHSU]\QDOHĪQRĞFLSURJyZUyZQRZDĪQRĞFLSUHIHUHQFML

(3)

LZHWDGRSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKSU]HG]LDáyZ0LDQRZLFLHZVSyáF]\QQLNL]JRGQRĞFLLZLDU\JRGQRĞFL RSLVDQHVąZ]RUDPLL JG]LHZVNDĨQLNL]JRGQRĞFLĳkPRJąSU]\MąüZDUWRĞFL – ĳk(ai, bj JG\¦k(bj±¦k(aiޒqk – ĳk(ai, bj JG\¦k(bj±¦k(aipk – , gdy qk ޒ¦k(bj±¦k(aipk oraz: JG]LHZVNDĨQLNLQLH]JRGQRĞFLPRJąSU]\MąüZDUWRĞFL – dk(ai, bj gdy ¦k(bj±¦k(ai) vk – dk(ai, bj JG\¦k(bj±¦k(ai) ޒpk – JG\pk ¦k(aj±¦k(aiޒvk 1LHSU]\SDGNRZRZSRZ\ĪV]\FKZ]RUDFKXĪ\WRQRWDFML]DSLVXZDULDQWyZMDNRai i bj. Zapis WHQZ\QLND]IDNWXĪHZPHWRG]LH(OHFWUH7ULZDULDQW\GHF\]\MQHaiSRUyZQ\ZDQHVą]SUR filami wariantów (bj3URILOHVąÄV]WXF]Q\PLZDULDQWDPL´RJUDQLF]DMąF\PLSRV]F]HJyOQHNODV\ MDNRĞFLRZH6ąRQHGHILQLRZDQHSU]H]GHF\GHQWDZPRPHQFLHXVWDODQLDZDUWRĞFLSURJyZLZDJ NU\WHULyZ:DĪQHMHVWDE\SURILOHE\á\RNUHĞORQHSRSUDZQLHW]QDE\SURILO]GHILQLRZDQ\MDNR QDMOHSV]\LVWRWQLHE\áSURILOHPRSW\PDOQ\PLWG3RSUDZQH]GHILQLRZDQLHSURILOLSR]ZDODSR SUDZQLHXV]HUHJRZDüNODV\MDNRĞFLRZH1DSRGVWDZLHZ\]QDF]RQHJRZVSyáF]\QQLNDZLDU\JRG QRĞFLL]GHILQLRZDQHJRSU]H]GHF\GHQWDSR]LRPXFLĊFLDȜZ\]QDF]DQHVąUHODFMHȜSUHIHUHQFML PLĊG]\ZDULDQWDPLDSURILODPL5HODFMHZ\]QDF]DQHVąZHGáXJQDVWĊSXMąF\FKUHJXá – – – – :RSDUFLXRUHODFMHȜSUHIHUHQFML]DFKRG]ąFHPLĊG]\ZDULDQWDPLDSURILODPLZ\NRQXMHVLĊ SU]\G]LDáZDULDQWyZGRNODV0RĪQDGRWHJRFHOXZ\NRU]\VWDüGZLHSURFHGXU\NWyUHGDMąMHGQDN ]QDF]ąFRUyĪQHZ\QLNLNODV\ILNDFML3URFHGXU\WHQRV]ąQD]ZĊSURFHGXU\RSW\PLVW\F]QHMLSH V\PLVW\F]QHM3URFHGXUDRSW\PLVW\F]QDVNáDGDVLĊ]GZyFKNURNyZ

3RUyZQDMZDULDQWai]NROHMQ\PLSURILODPLbjUR]SRF]\QDMąFRGQDMJRUV]HJRb). 3U]\G]LHOai do klasy CjMHĞOLbjMHVWSLHUZV]\PQDSRWNDQ\PSURILOHPWDNLPĪHbjޓai. 1DWRPLDVWSURFHGXUDSHV\PLVW\F]QD]EXGRZDQDMHVWQDVWĊSXMąFR

3RUyZQDMZDULDQWai]NROHMQ\PLSURILODPLbjUR]SRF]\QDMąFRGSURILOXQDMOHSV]HJR -HĞOLbjMHVWSLHUZV]\PQDSRWNDQ\PSURILOHPGODNWyUHJRai S bj, to ai przydziel do klasy

Cj+1 /D*DXIIUHLLQ

(4)

: SXEOLNDFML ]DVWRVRZDQR PHWRGĊ (OHFWUH 7UL NWyUD ]QDMGXMH ]DVWRVRZDQLH QS Z V\WX DFMDFKNLHG\]EDGDüQDOHĪ\EDUG]RGXĪąLORĞüZDULDQWyZGHF\]\MQ\FK3RUyZQ\ZDQLHLFKSD UDPLPRJáRE\E\üNáRSRWOLZHZREHFF]HJRZáDĞFLZHMHVWSRUyZQDQLHLFKQDMSLHUZ]SURILODPL ]DSURSRQRZDQ\PLSU]H]GHF\GHQWD3R]ZDODWRRGU]XFLüZDULDQW\QDMJRUV]H]SXQNWXZLG]HQLD GHF\GXMąFHJRDQDVWĊSQLHUR]SDWU]\üLQQąPHWRGąW\ONRWHZDULDQW\NWyUH]QDOD]á\VLĊZQDMOHS V]\FKNODVDFKMDNRĞFLRZ\FK0RXVVHDX9LLQ

Drzewo kryterialne i kryteria oceny

.RQVWUXNFMĊPRGHOXGODSRWU]HERFHQ\XĪ\WHF]QRĞFLSUREOHPXGHF\]\MQHJRRSDUWRQDUR]ZLą ]DQLDFKPHWRG\F]Q\FKV\VWHPX'663DNLHWV\VWHPX'66XPRĪOLZLáRFHQĊSRVWDZLRQHJR SUREOHPXGHF\]\MQHJRSU]\XĪ\FLXPHWRGZVSRPDJDQLDGHF\]ML(OHFWUH7UL$E\RGZ]RURZDüSR VWDZLRQ\SUREOHPGHF\]\MQ\ZSLHUZV]\PNURNXREOLF]HĔQDOHĪDáRVWZRU]\üRGSRZLHGQLHGU]HZR GHF\]\MQHWDNDE\]EXGRZDQ\PRGHOE\áSRF]ĊĞFL]DXWRPDW\]RZDQ\SRSU]H]V\VWHP'66%HFNHU %XG]LĔVNL-HVWWRZDĪQ\SUREOHPGODNDĪGHMDQDOL]\SU]\F]\QRZRVNXWNRZHMF]\RSW\PDOL ]DFMLZLHORNU\WHULDOQHM:RSUDFRZDQLXGU]HZDNU\WHULDOQHJRNU\WHULD±SRGNU\WHULDSRVáXĪRQR VLĊZ\W\F]Q\PLQDSRGVWDZLHNZHVWLRQDULXV]DNWyU\XPRĪOLZLáGRNáDGQHEDGDQLHVWDQXSDFMHQWD ] FKRUREą ]Z\URGQLHQLRZą VWDZX ELRGURZHJR : HIHNFLH ]RVWDá XWZRU]RQ\ ]ELyU NU\WHULyZ LSRGNU\WHULyZNWyU\WZRU]\ÄGU]HZRNU\WHULDOQH´RVWUXNWXU]HDGDSWDF\MQHM 1DSRQLĪV]\PU\VXQNXSU]HGVWDZLRQRPRGHOGU]HZDGHF\]\MQHJRZRFHQLHEDGDQHJR SDFMHQWD]FKRUREą]Z\URGQLHQLRZąVWDZXELRGURZHJRZNWyU\PXZ]JOĊGQLRQRVSHF\ILNDFMĊ NU\WHULyZLSRGNU\WHULyZQDSRGVWDZLHNZHVWLRQDULXV]DEDGDQ\FKSDFMHQWyZ:GU]HZLHGH F\]\MQ\PZ\VWĊSXMąSDUDPHWU\VWURMHQLDWMQDGDZDQLDZDJQDSRWU]HE\LQWHUSUHWDFMLLGHF\]ML .U\WHULDF]ąVWNRZHVNáDGDMąVLĊ]SRGNU\WHULyZNWyUHSRGSRU]ąGNRZDQHVąORNDOQHPXVWURMHQLX F]\OLQDGDQLXRGSRZLHGQLFKZDJ33UHIHUHQFMHGODNU\WHULyZF]ąVWNRZ\FK)VąWRWDN]ZD QHSDUDPHWU\SUHIHUHQFMLRGELRUFyZVWRVRZDQHZSU]\SDGNDFKNLHURZDQLDUR]ZLą]DĔUyĪQ\FK SUHIHUHQFML1DOHĪ\ZVSRPQLHüĪHZUR]SDWU\ZDQ\PSU]\SDGNX]DáRĪRQRSUHIHUHQFMĊOHNDU] IL]MRWHUDSHXWDPHWRGą$+3RUD](OHFWUH7ULNWyUąSU]HGVWDZLRQRZGDOV]HMF]ĊĞFLSUDF\

(5)

Rysunek 1. 0RGHOSDUDPHWUyZNU\WHULDOQ\FKZRFHQLHEDGDQHJRSDFMHQWD]DUWUR]ąVWDZXELRGURZHJR /HJHQGD'±GDQHĨUyGáRZHRGHNVSHUWyZVNDODZSNW±3±SDUDPHWU\ORNDOQHJRVWURMHQLDSRGNU\WHULyZ ZVXPD3 )±SDUDPHWU\SUHIHUHQFMLRGELRUF\WMNU\WHULDIXQNFMLFHOX:3/ZVXPD)

(6)

Weryfikacja badań

3U]HGVWDZLRQHEDGDQLDRSDUWRQDZ\QLNDFK]NZHVWLRQDULXV]\EDGDĔSDFMHQWyZ]DUWUR ]ąVWDZXELRGURZHJR%DGDQLRPSRGGDQD]RVWDáDJUXSDSDFMHQWyZRF]HNXMąF\FKQD]DELHJ ZV]F]HSLHQLDHQGRSURWH]\VWDZXELRGURZHJR%DGDQLDSU]HSURZDG]RQRZ.DWHGU]HL.OLQLFH 2UWRSHGLL7UDXPDWRORJLLL2QNRORJLL1DU]ąGX5XFKX3RPRUVNLHJR8QLZHUV\WHWX0HG\F]QHJR Z 6]F]HFLQLH 3RSU]H] NODV\ILNDFMH SUDNW\F]Qą VNDWHJRU\]RZDQR ZV]\VWNLH F]\QQLNL PDMąFH ZSá\ZQDELHĪąFąRUD]SU]\V]áąGHF\]MĊOHNDU]DGR]DNODV\ILNRZDQLDSDFMHQWD]DUWUR]ąVWDZX ELRGURZHJRGRRSHUDFMLOXEUHKDELOLWDFML .ZHVWLRQDULXV]HVNODV\ILNRZDQR]DSRPRFąVLHGPLXFHFKDWU\EXW\ZDUXQNRZH±U\V :EDGDQLDFKZ\NRU]\VWDQR]PLHQQHNWyUHSU]\MPRZDá\ZDUWRĞFLFDáNRZLWH]]DNUHVX>±@ 'DQHFKDUDNWHU\]RZDá\VWDQ]PLHQQ\FKMDNR'±]PLDQ\]Z\URGQLHQLRZH'±Z\VWĊSR ZDQLHEyOX'±EDGDQLHUXFKRPRĞFLVWDZXELRGURZHJR'±DQDOL]DFKRGX'±RFHQD VLá\PLĊĞQLRZHM'±RFHQDVNUyFHQLDPLĊĞQLD'±LQQHGROHJOLZRĞFL 1DOHĪ\]D]QDF]\üĪHSU]\MĊFLHVDP\FKNU\WHULyZQLHUR]ZLą]DáRSUREOHPXZ\ERUXGHF\]ML .RQLHF]QHE\áRXVWDOHQLHZHNWRUDSUHIHUHQFMLGODW\FKNU\WHULyZ:]ZLą]NX]RWU]\PDQ\PL Z\QLNDPL QDVXZDMą VLĊ S\WDQLD -DNLPL SUHIHUHQFMDPL NLHUXMą VLĊ OHNDU]H NWyU]\ NODV\ILNXMą SDFMHQWyZ]DUWUR]ąVWDZXELRGURZHJRGRRSHUDFML"1DMDNLHFHFK\]ZUDFDMąQDMZLĊNV]ąXZD JĊ"8]\VNDQLHRGSRZLHG]LRUD]XVWDOHQLHZHNWRUDSUHIHUHQFMLGODZ\EUDQ\FKNU\WHULyZZ\PDJD ]DVWRVRZDQLDPHWRG\$+3ZXMĊFLXSRMHG\QF]\POXEJUXSRZ\PLGHQW\ILNXMąFHMZWU\ELH GLDORJRZ\PUR]P\WHZ\SRZLHG]LZ\EUDQHMJUXS\HNVSHUWyZOHNDU]DOHNDU]\OXEIL]MRWHUD SHXW\IL]MRWHUDSHXWyZ3URSR]\FMĊZ\NRU]\VWDQLDZVSRPQLDQHMSURFHGXU\SU]HGVWDZLRQRQD U\VXQNX Rysunek 2. 8VWDODQLHSUHIHUHQFMLPHWRGą$+3SRUyZQDQLDSDUDPLZEDGDQ\PSUREOHPLHGHF\]\MQ\P ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQHQDSRGVWDZLHV\VWHPX'66

(7)

=QDMGXMąF\VLĊQDZLHU]FKRáNXKLHUDUFKLF]QHMVWUXNWXU\GHF\]\MQHMFHOQDGU]ĊGQ\GHILQLX MHVLĊMDNRVWDQGRFHORZ\NZDOLILNDFMDGRRSHUDFMLZ\QLNDMąF\]RGSRZLHGQLHJRUR]ZLą]DQLD SUREOHPX GHF\]\MQHJR Z W\P SU]\SDGNX OHNDU]D 5HDOL]DFMD FHOX QDGU]ĊGQHJR SU]H] NDĪG\ ]ZDULDQWyZZ\QLND]HVSHáQLHQLDFHOyZSRĞUHGQLFKNWyUHZ\UDĪRQHVąSU]H]RGSRZLDGDMąFHLP kryteria i podkryteria. 3RGVWDZąSU]HSURZDG]DQLDREOLF]HĔDQDOLW\F]Q\FKMHVWXWZRU]HQLHSU]HFKRGQLHMED]\GD Q\FKVáXĪąFHMZ\áąF]QLHGREDGDĔDQDOLW\F]Q\FKLNODV\ILNDF\MQ\FK%D]DGDQ\FKU\VGR GDOV]HJRSU]HWZDU]DQLDSRFKRG]L]WUDQVSR]\FMLZ\EUDQ\FKSDUDPHWUyZU\VELODQVyZZVSyO Q\FKLNU\WHULDOQ\FK]PRGHOLF]ąVWNRZ\FKU\V Rysunek 3. =HVWDZLHQLHGDQ\FKZHMĞFLRZ\FKGRDQDOL]RZDQLD ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQHQDSRGVWDZLHV\VWHPX'66 3RXWZRU]HQLXPRGHOXMDNUyZQLHĪGU]HZDGHF\]\MQHJRRUD]ZSURZDG]HQLXGRV\VWHPX '66]HVWDZXGDQ\FKZNROHMQ\PHWDSLHZHU\ILNDFML]DVWRVRZDQRPHWRGĊ(OHFWUH7UL0HWRGDWD ]RVWDáD]DSURSRQRZDQDDE\Z\EUDüQDMOHSV]HG]LDáDQLD]GDQHJR]HVWDZXNU\WHULyZLSRGNU\ WHULyZRUD]XWZRU]\üUDQNLQJ0RGHOJUXSRZDQLD(OHFWUH7ULQLHQDU]XFDSU]HFKRGQLRĞFLSUHIH UHQFMLLGRSXV]F]DV\WXDFMĊQLHSRUyZQ\ZDOQRĞFLMDNMXĪZVSRPQLDQRZHZF]HĞQLHMV]HMF]ĊĞFL SUDF\:SURZDG]HQLHRSUDFRZDQHJRUR]ZLą]DQLDLQIRUPDW\F]QHJRSR]ZROLáRQDRGNU\FLHÄSHá QLHMV]HM´ZLHG]\RSDFMHQWDFKMDNUyZQLHĪZSURFHVLHGHF\]\MQ\PF]\OLRZ\ERU]HOHNDU]D :HIHNFLHRWU]\PXMHP\W]ZVSU]ĊĪHQLH]ZURWQHF]\OLJUDGDFMĊSURILOLRUD]UHJXá\OLQJZLVW\F] QHNWyUHSU]HGVWDZLRQRQDU\VXQNX

(8)

Rysunek 4. 5DQNLQJLJUXSRZDQLHOLQJZLVW\F]QHRELHNWyZZEDGDQ\PSUREOHPLHGHF\]\MQ\P ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQHQDSRGVWDZLHV\VWHPX'66 Rysunek 5. 6WDW\VW\NDX]\VNDQ\FKSURILOLOLQJZLVW\F]Q\FKZPRGHORZDQLX(OHFWUH7UL ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQHQDSRGVWDZLHV\VWHPX'66 =SU]HGVWDZLRQHJR]HVWDZLHQLDU\VLU\VZ\QLNDĪH]ELRURZRĞüFKDUDNWHU\]RZDáDVLĊ ZDUWRĞFLDPLZ\VRNLPL1DOHĪ\]ZUyFLüXZDJĊSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPQDSURILO:ZBZ\VRNL NWyU\NODV\ILNXMHSDFMHQWDGRQDW\FKPLDVWRZHJR]DELHJXRSHUDF\MQHJRZ\PLDQ\VWDZXELRGUR ZHJR-DNZLDGRPRGHF\]MDRRSHUDFMLSRZLQQDQDVWąSLüSRU]HWHOQHMHOLPLQDFMLLQQ\FKPRĪOL Z\FKG\VIXQNFMLJHQHUXMąF\FKOXEZ]PDJDMąF\FKGROHJOLZRĞFLSDFMHQWD:V\WXDFMLJG\SURILO MHVWZ\VRNLRUD]ĞUHGQLPRĪQD]DVWRVRZDüIDUPDNRWHUDSLĊOXEGREU]H]DSODQRZDQą IL]MRWHUDSLĊNWyUDPRĪHRGGDOLüNRQLHF]QRĞü]DELHJXRSHUDF\MQHJROXE]PQLHMV]\üSU]\NUHGR OHJOLZRĞFLZWUDNFLHRF]HNLZDQLDQD]DELHJHQGRSURWH]RSODVW\NL

Wyniki końcowe

:]ZLą]NX]SU]HSURZDG]RQ\PLEDGDQLDPLFHOHPSUDF\E\áRZ\áRQLHQLHSDFMHQWDNWyU\ Z]DáRĪRQHMDSULRULSLĊFLRVWRSQLRZHMVNDOLSURILORZDQLDSURSRUFMRQDOQHJR:ZBZ\VRNLZ\

(9)

VRNLĞUHGQLQLVNLQDMQLĪV]\QDMOHSLHMVSHáQLDSRVWXODW]DNZDOLILNRZDQLDGRRSHUDFML:\QLNL ZIRUPLHUDQNLQJXKLHUDUFKLF]QHJRSU]HSURZDG]RQ\FKDQDOL]SU]HGVWDZLRQRZWDEHOL

Tabela 1. 5DQNLQJNODV\ILNDFMLEDGDQ\FKSDFMHQWyZ]FKRUREą]Z\URGQLHQLRZąVWDZXELRGURZHJR

Lp Nazwa potoczna & ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 237<0,=0

.BBBB3 :ZBZ\VRNL .BBBB3 :ZBZ\VRNL .BBBB3 :ZBZ\VRNL … … … … .BBBB3 :ZBZ\VRNL .BBBB3 :ZBZ\VRNL 0BBBB3 :ZBZ\VRNL .BBBB3 :ZBZ\VRNL … … … … 0BBBB3 Wysoki .BBBB3 Wysoki 0BBBB3 Wysoki .BBBB3 Wysoki .BBBB3 Wysoki .BBBB3 Wysoki 0BBBB3 Wysoki … … … … .BBBB3 ĝUHGQL .BBBB3 ĝUHGQL 0BBBB3 ĝUHGQL … … … … .BBBB3 ĝUHGQL 0BBBB3 ĝUHGQL ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQH :\QLNLSRND]DQHZWDEHOLSU]HGVWDZLDMąJUXSĊEDGDQ\FKSDFMHQWyZ]FKRUREą]Z\URG QLHQLRZąVWDZXELRGURZHJR1DOHĪ\]D]QDF]\üĪHRVWDWHF]Q\PHWDSHPOHF]HQLDFKRURE\]Z\ URGQLHQLRZHMVWDZXELRGURZHJRMHVWHQGRSURWH]RSODVW\ND:SU]HGVWDZLRQ\PSU]\SDGNXWRRN SDFMHQWyZNWyU]\Z\PDJDMąQDW\FKPLDVWRZHJR]DELHJXRSHUDF\MQHJR2SHUDFMDQLHVLH]D VREąSRSUDZĊVWDQXIXQNFMRQDOQHJRDOHUyZQLHĪU\]\NRSRZLNáDĔLLQQ\FK]DJURĪHĔ3U]HGVWD ZLRQ\UDQNLQJPRĪHSRPyFOHNDU]RPLIL]MRWHUDSHXWRPZSRGMĊFLXGHF\]MLRVSRVRELHOHF]HQLD &KRURED]Z\URGQLHQLRZDVWDZXELRGURZHJRMHVWFKRUREąSU]HZOHNáą1LHGDVLĊFRIQąü]DLVW QLDá\FK]PLDQDOHRGSRZLHGQLRGREUDQDUHKDELOLWDFMDMHVWZVWDQLHVSRZROQLüSRVWĊSFKRURE\ SRSUDZLüVSUDZQRĞüLNRPIRUWĪ\FLDFKRUHJRRUD]RGGDOLüNRQLHF]QRĞüRSHUDFML]ZáDV]F]DXSD FMHQWyZNWyU]\PXV]ąF]HNDüODWDPLQDHQGRSURWH]RSODVW\NĊ

(10)

Podsumowanie

:DUW\NXOH]ZHU\ILNRZDQRRFHQĊVWDQXIXQNFMRQDOQHJRSDFMHQWD]FKRUREą]Z\URGQLHQLR ZąVWDZXELRGURZHJRGRRSHUDFML]]DVWRVRZDQLHPUHODFMLSU]HZ\ĪV]HQLD(OHFWUH7UL%DGDQLD WH áąF]ą QLH]EĊGQą LORĞü LQIRUPDFML GRW\F]ąF\FK VXELHNW\ZQ\FK RGF]Xü SDFMHQWD ] EDGDQLHP IXQNFMRQDOQ\PNWyUH]DSRPRFąSRPLDUyZLWHVWyZMDNUyZQLHĪPHWRG\GHF\]\MQHMZVSRPRJą OHNDU]DZSRGMĊFLXGHF\]ML1DOHĪ\ZVSRPQLHüĪHZDUXQNLHPMHVWSRVLDGDQLHZLHG]\RSUHIH UHQFMDFKZVND]DQHMJUXS\EDGDQ\FKLGRVWRVRZDQLHRSLVXPHWRGGRRGZ]RURZ\ZDQHMU]HF]\ZL VWRĞFLZW\PSU]\SDGNXOHNDU]D0HWRGD(OHFWUH7ULSRPLMDZNODV\ILNDFMDFKDWU\EXWGHF\]\MQ\ WMQLHZSURZDG]DVLĊ]PLHQQHM]DOHĪQHMFRSR]ZDODQDRGNU\ZDQLHÄQLH]GRPLQRZDQHM´ZLH G]\RUR]SDWU\ZDQ\PSURFHVLHGHF\]\MQ\P:Z\QLNXSU]HSURZDG]RQ\FKEDGDĔRWU]\PDOLĞP\ UDQNLQJNODV\ILNDFMLEDGDQ\FKSDFMHQWyZGRRSHUDFML$UW\NXáXND]XMHZRELHNW\ZQ\VSRVyE IDNW\F]Q\VWDQIL]\F]Q\EDGDQHJRSDFMHQWD%DGDQLHSDFMHQWDZHGáXJ]DSURSRQRZDQHJRQDU]Ċ G]LDXPRĪOLZLDNODV\ILNDFMĊRUD]ZHU\ILNDFMĊSDFMHQWyZGROHF]HQLD:DUWRUyZQLHĪXZ]JOĊGQLü NRV]W\OHF]HQLDSRQRV]RQHSU]H]EXGĪHW\SDĔVWZ.RV]W\WHVąRJURPQHLVWDOHURVQąD]ZLą]DQH Vą]UR]SR]QDQLHPOHF]HQLHPUHKDELOLWDFMąDEVHQFMą]DZRGRZąLĞZLDGF]HQLDPLUHQWRZ\PLSD FMHQWyZ]FKRUREą]Z\URGQLHQLRZąVWDZXELRGURZHJR1LHGRVNRQDáRĞüV\VWHPyZRSLHNL]GUR ZRWQHMEáĊGQDGLDJQR]DRUD]VWDQGDUGRZHSURJUDP\UHKDELOLWDF\MQHZ\GáXĪDMąOHF]HQLHW\PVD P\PSRJáĊELDMąVWDQGHJUDGDFMLVWDZX]ZLĊNV]DMąFQLHVSUDZQRĞüLGROHJOLZRĞFLEyORZH1DOHĪ\ SRV]XNLZDü]DWHPWDNLFKQDU]ĊG]LNWyUHE\XVSUDZQLá\QLHW\ONRSRGMĊFLHGHF\]MLSU]H]OHNDU]D DOHUyZQLHĪZVSRPRJá\OHF]HQLHSDFMHQWDSRSU]H]RGSRZLHGQLąIL]MRWHUDSLĊF]\IDUPDNRWHUDSLĊ

Literatura

$URNRVNL0+DDUD0+HOPLQHQ+$URNRVNL-Physical function in men with and without hip osteoarthri-tis. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 85±

$URNRVNL+,LQ+LSPXVFOHVWUHQJWKDQGFURVVVHFWLRQDODUHDLQPHQZLWKDQGZLWKRXWKLSRVWHRDUWKULWLV The Journal of Rheumatology, 29±

%HFNHU-%XG]LĔVNL57UDQVIRUPDWLRQRI.QRZOHJH6XRUFHVLQ'HFLVLRQ6XSSRUW6\VWHPJournal of Automa-tion, Mobile Robotics & Intelligent Systems, 9/2±

/H[HU09DNLF+Multiple Criteria Decision Making in Natural Resource Management, Lecture Notes. :LHQ8QLYHUVLWlWIU%RGHQNXOWXU

0DPDJKDQL)Evaluation and selection of an antivirus and content filtering software1HZ<RUN6W-RKQ )LVKHU&ROOHJH

0RXVVHDX96áRZLĔVNL5=LHOQLHZLF]3Electre Tri 2.0a Methodological guide and user’s manualV± 3DU\Ī8QLYHUVLWH3DULV'DXSKLQH

0RXVVHDX96áRZLĔVNL5 Inferring an Electre Tri Model from Assignment ExamplesV±$PVWHUGDP .OXZHU$FDGHPLF3XEOLVKHUV

6URNRZVNL*%XáDWRZLF],.DĨPLHUF]DN87\PD55DG]LPLĔVND$6WURMHN.6URNRZVND$2FHQD MDNRĞFLRZDFKRGXRUD]EDGDQLHIXQNFMLELRGUDSDFMHQWyZ]DNZDOLILNRZDQ\FKGR]DELHJXHQGRSURWH]RSODVW\NL VWDZXELRGURZHJRNowiny Lekarskie, 79±

6XHWWD&,LQ0XVFOHVL]HQHXURPXVFXODUDFWLYDWLRQDQGUDSLGIRUFHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVLQHOGHUO\PHQDQGZRPHQ HIIHFWVRIXQLODWHUDOORQJWHUPGLVXVHGXHWRKLSRVWHRDUWKULWLVJurnal of Applied Physiology, 102±

(11)

APPLICATION OF METHOD FOR MULTI-CR ITER I A DI AGNOSTIC A NALYSIS OF PATIENT WITH OSTEOARTHR ITIS OF THE HIP

Key words

_{0&'0(OHFWUH7UL$+3+LSRVWHRDUWKULWLV}

Abstr act _{$GYDQFHGGHJHQHUDWLYHFKDQJHVFDXVLQJGLVWXUEDQFHVLQELRPHFKDQLFVGLVDELOLW\DQGVRFLDOLVR}

ODWLRQ$PXOWLWXGHRIFRQGLWLRQVRIYDU\LQJVHYHULW\RIWKHSDWLHQWFDXVHVSUREOHPZLWKGHWHUPLQ LQJWKHRSWLPDOWLPLQJRIWUHDWPHQW7KHFODVVLILFDWLRQRISDWLHQWVIRUVXUJHU\LVFRPSOH[3XE OLVKHGVWXGLHVVKRZDYDULHW\RISDUDPHWHUVYDULDQWVDQGFODVVLILFDWLRQRIHYDOXDEOHSDWLHQWVZLWK RVWHRDUWKULWLVRIWKHKLS,WQRWHVWKHODFNRISURSRVDOVIRUDVVHVVLQJWKHSHUIRUPDQFHLQWKHILHOGRI ELRPHFKDQLFVLQRQHV\VWHPDQGZLWKWKHFODVVLILFDWLRQRIDVLFNSDWLHQW7KHSDSHUSUHVHQWVWKH SUREOHPRIWKHPHWKRGRORJ\IRUVSHFLILFGHFLVLRQSUREOHPV 7KHaimRIWKHDUWLFOHZDVWRGHYHORSDQGYHULI\WHVWSURFHGXUHIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIRVWHRDU WKULWLV RI WKH KLS 9HULILHG DSSURSULDWH PHWKRG RI PXOWLFULWHULD (OHFWUH 7UL ZKLFK DOORZHG WR HVWDEOLVKHG SDWLHQW TXDOLILFDWLRQV IRU VXUJHU\ RU KLS UHSODFHPHQW SURJUDP RI SK\VLRWKHUDS\ RU pharmacotherapy.