Modelowanie preferencji konsumentów na rynku motoryzacyjnym

Pełen tekst

(1)=HV]\W\ 1DXNRZHQU. . 8QLZHUV\WHWX(NRQRPLF]QHJRZ.UDNRZLH. 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL .DWHGUD$QDOL]\5\QNXL%DGDñ 0DUNHWLQJRZ\FK. 0RGHORZDQLHSUHIHUHQFML NRQVXPHQWyZQDU\QNX PRWRU\]DF\MQ\P :SURZDG]DQLH &HOHPQLQLHMV]HJRDUW\NXãXMHVWSUyEDPRGHORZDQLDSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZ QDU\QNXVDPRFKRGyZRVRERZ\FK5R]ZDŧDQLD]DZĕŧRQRGRW]ZGHNODURZDQ\FK SUHIHUHQFML VWDWHGSUHIHUHQFHV

(2) NWyUHZRGUyŧQLHQLXRGSUHIHUHQFMLXMDZQLRQ\FK UHYHDOHGSUHIHUHQFHV

(3) QLHVćU]HF]\ZLVW\PLDNWDPL]DNXSXDMHG\QLHZ\UDŧHQLHP JRWRZRŋFLGRQDE\FLDGDQHMNDWHJRULLOXEPDUNLSURGXNWXSU]H]UHVSRQGHQWyZ 3U]\EXGRZLHPRGHOXDQDOLW\F]QHJRVNRU]\VWDQR]WHRUHW\F]Q\FKUDPGRW\F]ćF\FK ]DFKRZDĸNRQVXPHQWyZ U\V

(4) X]QDMćFŧHGHNODUDFMD]DNXSXZWUDNFLHEDGDĸ DQNLHWRZ\FKMHVWV\PXODFMćV\WXDFMLU]HF]\ZLVW\FK6FKHPDWRSLHUDVLĕQDGHIL QLFMLNWyUDWUDNWXMHSURFHVSRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]MLMDNRVHNZHQFMĕRSHUDFMLXP\ VãRZ\FKZ\NRQ\ZDQ\FKZFHOXWUDQVIRUPDFMLSRF]ćWNRZHJRVWDQXZLHG]\GRNRĸ FRZHJRGRFHORZHJRVWDQXMHMZ\NRU]\VWDQLD1D]UyŧQLFRZDQLHSURFHVyZGHF\ ]\MQ\FKPRŧHZSã\ZDþNLONDF]\QQLNyZ ²SUREOHPGHF\]\MQ\ QSSURVW\²]ãRŧRQ\GREU]H]GHILQLRZDQ\²ťOH]GH ILQLRZDQ\ LORŋFLRZ\²MDNRŋFLRZ\ REDUF]RQ\ U\]\NLHP²ZROQ\ RG U\]\ND RGZUDFDOQ\²QLHRGZUDFDOQ\

(5) ²NRQWHNVW QSSRGHMPRZDQLHGHF\]MLSRGSUHVMćF]DVX

(6) 2SLVDQHZGDOV]HMF]ĕŋFLSUDF\Z\QLNLEDGDĸGRW\F]ćQRZ\FKLXŧ\ZDQ\FKVDPRFKRGyZ RVRERZ\FKNWyU\FKFHQDZ\QRVLZSU]\EOLŧHQLXW\V]ã8ŧ\ZDQHZSUDF\]ZURW\ÅU\QHNVDPR FKRGyZRVRERZ\FKµF]\ÅU\QHNPRWRU\]DF\MQ\µSRZLQQ\E\þWXWUDNWRZDQHMDNRV\QRQLP\ 0%HQ$NLYDLLQ([WHQGHG)UDPHZRUNIRU0RGHOLQJ&KRLFH%HKDYLRUÅ0DUNHWLQJ/HWWHUVµ YROQU$XJXVWV.

(7) . 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL. ²F]\QQLNLVSRãHF]QH QSVWRSLHĸRGSRZLHG]LDOQRŋFLGHF\GHQWDGHF\]MDLQG\ ZLGXDOQD²GHF\]MDJUXSRZD

(8) ²F]\QQLNLSV\FKRORJLF]QH QS]GROQRŋFLSR]QDZF]HVWDQSRF]ćWNRZHMZLHG]\ XF]XFLDPRW\ZDFMH

(9) 2]QDF]DWRŧHLVWQLHMHSRWU]HEDZãćF]HQLDW\FK]PLHQQ\FKGRPRGHOXZFHOX OHSV]HMSUHG\NFML]DFKRZDĸQDE\ZF]\FK(OLSV\QDV]DU\PWOHUHSUH]HQWXMćSLĕþ JãyZQ\FKF]\QQLNyZSV\FKRORJLF]Q\FKGHWHUPLQXMćF\FKZ\EyUSURGXNWXLVWD QRZLć]PLHQQHXNU\WH NRQVWUXNW\

(10) ZSU]HFLZLHĸVWZLHGRSURVWRNćWQ\FKHOHPHQ WyZVFKHPDWXNWyUHV\PEROL]XMćZVNDťQLNLUHIOHNV\MQH6WU]DãNLPLĕG]\HOLSVDPL LSURVWRNćWDPLR]QDF]DMćSRPLDUMDNLHJRQDOHŧ\GRNRQDþDE\VFKDUDNWHU\]RZDþ LVNZDQW\ILNRZDþ]PLHQQHXNU\WH. Doświadczenie. Informacja. Wskaźniki pamięci. Pamięć. Percepcja Przekonania. Wskaźniki percepcji. Wskaźniki zaangażowania. Kontekst Motywacja. Odczucia Cele Postawy Preferencje. Wskaźniki odczuć. Ograniczenia i deklarowane zadania. Proces oceny alternatyw. Wskaźniki procesu. Wybór. 5\V0RGHONRQFHSF\MQ\]DFKRZDĸQDE\ZFyZ ŤUyGãR0%HQ$NLYD7KHRUHWLFDO)UDPHZRUNIRU0RGHOLQJ&KRLFH%HKDYLRUÅ0DUNHWLQJ /HWWHUVµYROQU$XJXVWV. (OLSVDXGRãXVFKHPDWXV\PEROL]XMHSURFHVRFHQ\DOWHUQDW\ZSU]H]NRQ VXPHQWD-HVWWRNRQVWUXNWXNU\W\JG\ŧQLHPRŧQDEH]SRŋUHGQLR]DREVHUZRZDþ ZMDNLVSRVyEF]ãRZLHNRFHQLDSURGXNWSU]HGSRGMĕFLHPGHF\]MLR]DNXSLH1D SURFHVRFHQ\SURGXNWX OXEMHJRDWU\EXWyZ

(11) PDMćEH]SRŋUHGQLZSã\ZGZDLQQH NRQVWUXNW\XNU\WH

(12) SRVWDZ\SUHIHUHQFMHRGF]XFLDLFHOH UR]XPLDQHWXWDMMDNR SRWU]HE\

(13) RUD]

(14) PRW\ZDFMDLNRQWHNVW.

(15) 0RGHORZDQLHSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZ«. . :SLHUZV]\P]QLFKGXŧćUROĕRGJU\ZDSRWU]HEDNWyUD]RVWDQLH]DVSRNRMRQD G]LĕNL]DNXSRZLSURGXNWXSRVWDZ\Z]JOĕGHPWHJRSURGXNWX SRVWDZ\Z]JOĕ GHPPDUNLZ]JOĕGHPNUDMXSRFKRG]HQLDSURGXNWXLLQ

(16) RUD]SUHIHUHQFMHGRW\ F]ćFHSURGXNWXMDNRFDãRŋFLEćGť²ZSU]\SDGNXSURGXNWX]ãRŧRQHJRMDNLPMHVW VDPRFKyG²SRV]F]HJyOQ\FKMHJRDWU\EXWyZ'UXJDGHWHUPLQDQWDMHVW]ZLć]DQD ]NRQWHNVWHP]DNXSRZ\P-HVWERZLHPRF]\ZLVWHŧHQLHNDŧG\]DNXSZ\PDJD MHGQDNRZHJR]DDQJDŧRZDQLDFRPDEH]SRŋUHGQLHSU]HãRŧHQLHQDF]DVWUZDQLD SURFHVX QSZ\EyUNRVPHW\NyZQDZãDVQHSRWU]HE\PRŧHWUZDþ]QDF]QLHNUyFHM QLŧZ\EyUNRVPHW\NyZPDMćF\FKE\þSUH]HQWHPGODQDMEOLŧV]HMRVRE\

(17) .RQWHNVW Z\GDMHVLĕE\þ]PLHQQćREVHUZRZDOQćMHGQDNMHJRŋFLVã\]ZLć]HN]PRW\ZDFMć SRZRGXMHŧHRELHWH]PLHQQHVWDQRZLćMHGHQNRQVWUXNWXNU\W\1LHZLDGRPRQS F]\G]LHFNRZUyZQ\PVWRSQLXDQJDŧXMHVLĕZ]DNXSSUH]HQWXGODPDP\MDNZ]D NXSSUH]HQWXGODWDW\ 8VDPHMJyU\VFKHPDWX]QDMGXMćVLĕNROHMQHGZDNRQVWUXNW\XNU\WHNWyU\FK ZSã\ZQDSURFHVRFHQ\DOWHUQDW\ZMHVWMXŧSRŋUHGQL6ćWRSRZLć]DQH]HVREć SDPLĕþRUD]SHUFHSFMDLSU]HNRQDQLD&KRG]LWXRGRŋZLDGF]HQLDNRQVXPHQWyZ G\VRQDQVSR]DNXSRZ\GRW\FKF]DVRZHGRŋZLDGF]HQLD]SURGXNWDPLGDQHMPDUNL OXENDWHJRULL

(18) RUD]LQIRUPDFMĕSã\QćFć]U\QNXQSSU]HND]UHNODPRZ\RSLQLH ]QDMRP\FKF]\SRUDG\HNVSHUWyZ &KDUDNWHU\VW\NDEDGDQLD 0RGHOSUHG\NF\MQ\GRW\F]ćF\SUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZQDU\QNXPRWRU\]DF\M Q\PSRZVWDãZRSDUFLXRGDQH]HEUDQHZWUDNFLHEDGDĸDQNLHWRZ\FKZF]HUZFX LOLSFXU5HVSRQGHQWDPLE\OLPLHV]NDĸF\ZRMHZyG]WZDPDãRSROVNLHJR²SHã QROHWQLSU]HGVWDZLFLHOHURG]LQNWyU]\]QDOLEUDQŧĕPRWRU\]DF\MQć QDMF]ĕŋFLHM E\ã\WRRVRE\EĕGćFHÅJãRZćµURG]LQ\

(19) /LF]EDDQNLHWZ\QRVLãDMHGQDNSR ZHU\ILNDFMLGRDQDOL]\ZãćF]RQRDQNLHW3UyEĕGREUDQRZVSRVyENZRWRZ\ VWRVXMćFNU\WHULDZLHNEDGDQHJRRUD]OLF]EĕRVyEZJRVSRGDUVWZLHGRPRZ\P UHVSRQGHQWD =DVDGQLF]\PFHOHPEDGDĸE\ãDDQDOL]DSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZQDU\QNX PRWRU\]DF\MQ\P=PLHQQD]DOHŧQDSU]\MĕãDGZLHZDUWRŋFL²EDGDQ\SUHIHUXMH DXWRQRZHRUD]²EDGDQ\SUHIHUXMHDXWRXŧ\ZDQH5HVSRQGHQWRPSU]HGVWDZLRQR OLVWĕGZXQDVWXVDPRFKRGyZRVRERZ\FK V]HŋFLXDXWQRZ\FKLV]HŋFLXDXWXŧ\ZD :ŋUyGVDPRFKRGyZQRZ\FKE\ã\7R\RWD<DULV 7HUUDKDWFKEDFNGU]ZLRZ\FP .0

(20) 3HXJHRW 0LVWUDOKDWFKEDFNGU]ZLRZ\FP .0

(21) 6NRGD)DELD +73 &ODVVLFKDWFKEDFNGU]ZLRZ\FP.0

(22) .LD5LR 56VHGDQGU]ZLRZ\FP .0

(23) 2SHO$JLOD (VVHQWLDKDWFKEDFNGU]ZLRZ\FP.0

(24) )LDW3XQWR Y $FWLYHKDWFKEDFNGU]ZLRZ\FP.0

(25) .

(26) . 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL. Q\FK

(27) ]NWyUHMPRJOLZ\EUDþW\ONRMHGHQ²QRZ\EćGťXŧ\ZDQ\:FHOXZ\HOLPL QRZDQLDZSã\ZXFHQ\QDOLŋFLH]QDOD]ã\VLĕZ\ãćF]QLHDXWDNWyU\FKZDUWRŋþZ\QR VLãDRNRãRW\V]ã6FKHPDWSRZLć]DĸPLĕG]\SUHG\NWRUDPL ]PLHQQ\PLGHWHU PLQXMćF\PLSUHIHUHQFMHEDGDQ\FK

(28) D]PLHQQć]DOHŧQćSU]HGVWDZLRQRQDU\V -HGQD]H]PLHQQ\FKQLH]DOHŧQ\FKGRW\F]\ãDRSLQLLEDGDQ\FKRGQRŋQLHGRNUDMyZ ]NWyU\FKSRFKRG]ćOHSV]HWHFKQLF]QLHVDPRFKRG\5HVSRQGHQWRPSU]HGVWDZLRQR OLVWĕV]HŋFLXNUDMyZ-DSRQLĕ1LHPF\)UDQFMĕ&]HFK\.RUHĕ3ãGL:ãRFK\]SURŋEć RLFKXSRU]ćGNRZDQLH²RGQDMOHSV]HJRGRQDMJRUV]HJRSURGXFHQWDDXW/LVWDNUDMyZ QLHE\ãDSU]\SDGNRZD²XZ]JOĕGQLRQRZQLHMERZLHPWHSDĸVWZD]NWyU\FKSRFKR G]Lã\PDUNLZ\PLHQLRQHZS\WDQLXRSUHIHUHQFMH=PLHQQDQLH]DOHŧQDNWyUDWUD ILãDRVWDWHF]QLHGRPRGHOXGRW\F]\ãDNUDMXNWyU\]RVWDãZVND]DQ\SU]H]EDGDQHJR MDNRSLHUZV]\. Opinie nt. krajów, z których pochodzą lepsze technicznie samochody. Faza cyklu życia rodziny. Cechy demograficzne respondenta. Ocena użyteczności atrybutów samochodu (BSA). Preferowany samochód osobowy (nowy–używany). Wartości, którymi kierują się respondenci (LOV) Cechy samochodu uwzględniane w procesie decyzyjnym. 5\V6FKHPDWSRZLć]DĸPLĕG]\SUHG\NWRUDPLD]PLHQQć]DOHŧQć ŤUyGãRRSUDFRZDQLHZãDVQH. =DGUXJćGHWHUPLQDQWĕSUHIHUHQFMLX]QDQRID]ĕF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\:\RG UĕEQLRQRV]HŋþID]

(29) PãRGHRVRE\VWDQXZROQHJR

(30) PãRGHPDãŧHĸVWZDEH] :ŋUyGVDPRFKRGyZXŧ\ZDQ\FKE\ã\7R\RWD&RUROOD ]USU]HELHJNPKDWFK EDFNGU]ZLRZ\FP.0

(31) 5HQDXOW0HJDQH ]USU]HELHJNPKDWFKEDFN GU]ZLRZ\FP.0

(32) 6NRGD2FWDYLD 'LHVHO]USU]HELHJNPKDWFKEDFN GU]ZLRZ\FP.0

(33) .LD&DUQLYDO 'LHVHO]USU]HELHJNPYDQ FP.0

(34) 0HUFHGHV(.ODVVH ]USU]HELHJNPVHGDQGU]ZLRZ\ FP.0

(35) $OID5RPHR 76]USU]HELHJNPVHGDQGU]ZLRZ\ FP.0

(36) . 1DOLŋFLH]QDOD]ã\VLĕSRGZDVDPRFKRG\ QRZ\LXŧ\ZDQ\

(37) ]NDŧGHJR]W\FKNUDMyZ.

(38) 0RGHORZDQLHSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZ«. . G]LHFL

(39) PDãŧHĸVWZD]G]LHþPLQDXWU]\PDQLX ZLHNG]LHFLQLHSU]HNUDF]DODW

(40)

(41) PDãŧHĸVWZD]GRURVã\PLG]LHþPLQDXWU]\PDQLX ZLHNG]LHFLWRODWLZLĕFHM

(42)

(43) PDãŧHĸVWZDEH]G]LHFLQDXWU]\PDQLX²W]ZSXVWHJQLD]GDL

(44) VWDUV]HRVRE\ VWDQXZROQHJR 7U]HFLNRQVWUXNW²ÅFHFK\GHPRJUDILF]QHUHVSRQGHQWDµ²]DZLHUDãWDNLH]PLHQQH MDNÅSãHþµÅZ\NV]WDãFHQLHµRUD]ÅVWDWXV]DWUXGQLHQLDµUHVSRQGHQWD 1DÅRFHQĕXŧ\WHF]QRŋFLDWU\EXWyZVDPRFKRGXµVNãDGDãRVLĕNLONDZ\PLDUyZ

(45) RVLćJLWHFKQLF]QH

(46) EH]SLHF]HĸVWZR

(47) QLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFML

(48) IXQNFMR QDOQRŋþ

(49) Z\VRNLNRPIRUWXŧ\WNRZDQLD

(50) DWUDNF\MQ\Z\JOćG

(51) ]DEH]SLHF]HQLD VDPRFKRGX

(52) LQQHDWU\EXW\ =DGDQLHUHVSRQGHQWDSROHJDãRQDRFHQLHSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKDWU\EXWyZVDPR FKRGXRVRERZHJRQDVNDOLSXQNWRZHM 2VWDWHF]QLHGRPRGHOXZãćF]RQR ]HVWDZ]PLHQQ\FKG\FKRWRPLF]Q\FKSU]\MPXMćF\FKGZLHZDUWRŋFL²UHVSRQGHQW Z\VRNRRFHQLDGDQ\Z\PLDU XZDŧDŧHVDPRFKyGRVRERZ\SRZLQLHQSRVLDGDþ GDQ\DWU\EXW

(53) RUD]²UHVSRQGHQWŋUHGQLROXEQLVNRRFHQLDGDQ\FKZ\PLDU .ROHMQ\]HVWDZ]PLHQQ\FKQLH]DOHŧQ\FKGRW\F]\ãZDUWRŋFLNWyU\PLNLHUXMHVLĕ EDGDQ\6NDODXŧ\WDZEDGDQLDFKE\ãDZ]RURZDQDQDRU\JLQDOQHMOLŋFLHZDUWRŋFL /LVWRI9DOXHVZVNUyFLH/29

(54) LVNãDGDãDVLĕ]QDVWĕSXMćF\FKNDWHJRULL

(55) SRF]X FLHSU]\QDOHŧQRŋFL

(56) ŧ\FLHSHãQHZUDŧHĸ

(57) SU]\MHPQRŋþLUDGRŋþ]ŧ\FLD

(58) VHU GHF]QHVWRVXQNL]LQQ\PL

(59) VDPRUHDOL]DFMD

(60) E\FLHSRZDŧDQ\P

(61) SRF]XFLH VSHãQLHQLD

(62) EH]SLHF]HĸVWZRRUD]

(63) V]DFXQHNGODVDPHJRVLHELH 2VWDWQLSUHG\NWRUE\ã]ZLć]DQ\]FHFKDPLDXWDNWyUHVćSU]H]UHVSRQGHQWyZ XZ]JOĕGQLDQHZSURFHVLHSRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]ML:\V]F]HJyOQLRQRSLĕþFHFKNUDM SRFKRG]HQLDPDUNLSRMHPQRŋþVLOQLNDW\SVLOQLNDPDUNĕLOLF]EĕGU]ZL=DGDQLH UHVSRQGHQWyZSROHJDãRQDVWZRU]HQLXUDQNLQJXZDŧQRŋFLW\FKNDWHJRULL3R]ZR OLãRWRQDXWZRU]HQLHNROHMQHM]PLHQQHMQLH]DOHŧQHM²ÅFHFKDDXWDEUDQDSRGXZDJĕ SU]\]DNXSLHMDNRSLHUZV]Dµ $QDOL]DSUHIHUHQFML]DSRPRFÈPRGHOXORJLWRZHJR 0RGHOORJLWRZ\]EXGRZDQRSU]\SRPRF\SDNLHWX67$7,67,&$=RJyOQHM OLF]E\]PLHQQ\FKREMDŋQLDMćF\FKW\ONRE\ãRLVWRWQ\FKVWDW\VW\F]QLH ²NRU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDRVLćJLWHFKQLF]QHVDPRFKRGX 327SOXV

(64) ²NRU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFML 3.(SOXV

(65) ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\EDGDQHJR 3ID]D

(66) ²PãRGHRVRE\VWDQXZROQHJR. . :DUWRŋþR]QDF]DãDŧHGDQDFHFKDSRMD]GXMHVWGODUHVSRQGHQWD]E\WHF]QDQDWRPLDVWZDUWRŋþ R]QDF]DãDŧHGDQDFHFKDSRMD]GXMHVWQLH]EĕGQD6NDODE\ãDZ]RURZDQDQDRU\JLQDOQHMSUDF\ 0\HUVDRDQDOL]LHVWUXNWXU\NRU]\ŋFL %HQHILW6WUXFWXUH$QDO\VLV

(67) .

(68) . 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL. ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\EDGDQHJR 3ID]D

(69) ²PãRGHPDãŧHĸVWZDEH] G]LHFL ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\EDGDQHJR 3ID]D

(70) ²PDãŧHĸVWZD]G]LHþPLQD XWU]\PDQLX ZLHNG]LHFLQLHSU]HNUDF]DODW

(71) 2VWDWHF]QLHZPRGHOX]QDOD]ãRVLĕMHGQDN]PLHQQ\FKREMDŋQLDMćF\FK:ãć F]RQRWDNŧHSUHG\NWRUÅSãHþµGODNWyUHJRZDUWRŋþS 6]F]HJyãRZHV]DFXQNL SU]HGVWDZLRQRZWDEHOL0RGHOMHVWLVWRWQ\VWDW\VW\F]QLH FKLNZDGUDW SU]\S

(72) DZVSyãF]\QQLN50F)DGGHQDZ\QRVL 7DEHOD=PLHQQHRVWDWHF]QLHZãćF]RQHGRPRGHOXORJLWRZHJR &DãNRZLWDVWUDWDFKLNZDGUDW S :\V]F]HJyOQLHQLH. 6WDãD. 327SOXV 3.(SOXV 3NRELHWD 3ID]D 3ID]D 3ID]D. 2FHQD. ². . ² ² ². %ãćG VWDQGDUGRZ\. . . . . :DUWRŋþWHVWXW. . ². . ² ² ². 3R]LRPS. . . . . ² RFHQD

(73). . ². ² ² ² ². RFHQD

(74). ². . ² ² ². &KLNZDGUDW :DOGD. . . . . . . 3R]LRPS. . . . . . . . ,ORUD]V]DQVGOD MHGQRVWNRZHM ]PLDQ\. . . . . . . . ² LORUD]

(75). . . . . . . . LORUD]

(76). . . . . . . . . . . . . . ŤUyGãRRSUDFRZDQLHZãDVQH]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPSURJUDPX67$7,67,&$. :SLHUZV]\PZLHUV]XWDEHOL RFHQD

(77) ]QDMGXMćVLĕZDUWRŋFLHVW\PDWRUyZPRGHOX NWyUHSR]ZDODMć]DSLVDþJRZSRVWDFLORJLVW\F]QHM P(X) =. 1 , 1 + e –0,61057 + 0,99569*osiągi – 0,67270*eksploatacja – 0,67258*kobieta + 1,83066*faza 1 + 1,59170*faza 2 + 1, 07745*faza 3. LORJLWRZHM. 'ODXãDWZLHQLDVNUyFRQRQD]Z\]PLHQQ\FKÅRVLćJLµÅHNVSORDWDFMDµÅNRELHWDµÅID]Dµ ÅID]DµLÅID]Dµ.

(78) 0RGHORZDQLHSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZ«. . ORJLW3 ;

(79) ² RVLćJL HNVSORDWDFMD NRELHWD² ID]D² ID]D² ID]D. =QDNSU]\ZVSyãF]\QQLNXUHJUHVMLLQIRUPXMHRW\PF]\GDQ\SUHG\NWRUG]LDãD VW\PXOXMćFR ]QDNÅµ

(80) F]\RJUDQLF]DMćFR ]QDNÅ²µ

(81) QDSUDZGRSRGRELHĸVWZR Z\ERUXQRZHJRVDPRFKRGX:\QLNDVWćGŧHZLĕNV]DV]DQVD]DNXSXQRZHJRDXWD Z\VWĕSXMHZŋUyGNRELHWRUD]ZŋUyGRVyENWyUHNãDGćQDFLVNQDQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSOR DWDFML3U]HG]LDã\XIQRŋFLGODHVW\PDWRUyZ ZLHUV]H²ÅRFHQDµLÅRFHQDµ

(82) VćV]HURNLHFRZ\QLND]H]PLHQQRŋFLSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKSUHG\NWRUyZ6WDW\VW\ND :DOGD ZLHUV]FKLNZDGUDW:DOGD

(83) VãXŧ\GRGDWNRZHMRFHQLHSRV]F]HJyOQ\FK]PLHQ Q\FKQLH]DOHŧQ\FK,PZ\ŧV]HZDUWRŋFLSU]\MPXMHÅW\PPRFQLHMV]HVćSRGVWDZ\GR X]QDQLDRV]DFRZDQLDZVSyãF]\QQLND]DUR]ZLć]DQLHLVWRWQHµ'ODVWDW\VW\NL:DOGD REOLF]RQRSR]LRPSNWyU\ZNDŧG\PSU]\SDGNXMHVWPQLHMV]\RG 2LOH]QDNHVW\PDWRUDLQIRUPRZDãRW\PF]\GDQ\SUHG\NWRU]ZLĕNV]DF]\ ]PQLHMV]DV]DQVĕZ\ERUXQRZHJRVDPRFKRGXRW\OHLORUD]V]DQVGODMHGQRVWNR ZHM]PLDQ\SRV]F]HJyOQ\FKSDUDPHWUyZPyZLRW\PMDNVLOQ\MHVWWRERG]LHF :SU]\SDGNX]PLHQQHMÅRVLćJLWHFKQLF]QHµLORUD]MHVWUyZQ\FRR]QDF]D ŧHV]DQVDQDZ\EyUDXWDQRZHJRSU]H]RVRE\NãDGćFHQDFLVNQDRVLćJLWHFKQLF]QH VDPRFKRGXMHVWWU]\NURWQLHPQLHMV]DRGV]DQV\Z\ERUXDXWDXŧ\ZDQHJR=DOHŧ QRŋþWĕSRWZLHUG]DSRUyZQDQLHRIHUW\QDU\QNXSLHUZRWQ\PLZWyUQ\P.ZRWD MDNćWU]HEDSU]H]QDF]\þQD]DNXSQRZHJRVDPRFKRGXZ\VWDUF]DQD]DNXSVDPR FKRGXXŧ\ZDQHJR]ERJDWV]\PZ\SRVDŧHQLHPOXER]GHF\GRZDQLHZ\ŧV]\FKSDUD PHWUDFKWHFKQLF]Q\FK ,ORUD]V]DQVGOD]PLHQQHMÅNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFMLµZ\QRVLFRR]QDF]D ŧHV]DQVD]DNXSXDXWDQRZHJRSU]H]RVRE\NãDGćFHQDFLVNQDQLVNLHNRV]W\HNV SORDWDFMLMHVWSUDZLHGZXNURWQLHZ\ŧV]DQLŧGODRVyEGODNWyU\FKQLVNLHNRV]W\ HNVSORDWDFMLQLHVćQDMZDŧQLHMV]H3RGREQLHQDOHŧ\]LQWHUSUHWRZDþLORUD]V]DQVGOD ]PLHQQHMÅNRELHWDµ

(84) ²V]DQVD]DNXSXQRZHJRVDPRFKRGXMHVWGZXNURWQLH Z\ŧV]DZŋUyGNRELHWQLŧZŋUyGPĕŧF]\]Q :DUWRŋFLLORUD]XV]DQVGOD]PLHQQ\FKÅID]DµÅID]DµLÅID]DµZ\QRV]ć RGSRZLHGQLRL2]QDF]DWRŧH ²SUDZGRSRGRELHĸVWZR]DNXSXQRZHJRVDPRFKRGXSU]H]PãRGHRVRE\VWDQX ZROQHJRMHVWSRQDGV]HŋFLRNURWQLHPQLHMV]HQLŧSUDZGRSRGRELHĸVWZR]DNXSX SU]H]RVRE\]QDMGXMćFHVLĕZSR]RVWDã\FKID]DFKF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\ ²SUDZGRSRGRELHĸVWZR]DNXSXQRZHJRVDPRFKRGXSU]H]PãRGHPDãŧHĸVWZD EH]G]LHFLMHVWSLĕFLRNURWQLHPQLHMV]HQLŧSUDZGRSRGRELHĸVWZR]DNXSXSU]H] RVRE\ZSR]RVWDã\FKID]DFKF\NOXŧ\FLD . 05yV]NLHZLF] 1DU]ĕG]LD VWDW\VW\F]QH Z DQDOL]DFK PDUNHWLQJRZ\FK :\GDZQLFWZR &+%HFN:DUV]DZDV . :SU]\SDGNX]PLHQQHMÅNRELHWDµS .

(85) . 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL. ²V]DQVD]DNXSXQRZHJRVDPRFKRGXSU]H]PDãŧHĸVWZD]G]LHþPLSRQLŧHM URNXŧ\FLDMHVWWU]\NURWQLHPQLHMV]DRGV]DQV\]DNXSXSU]H]RVRE\ZSR]RVWDã\FK ID]DFKF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\ 5HDVXPXMćFPRŧQDSRZLHG]LHþŧHUHVSRQGHQFLSUHIHUXMćF\QRZHDXWDWR SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPD

(86) NRELHW\E

(87) RVRE\NãDGćFHQDFLVNQDQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSOR DWDFMLF

(88) RVRE\NWyU\PQLH]DOHŧ\QDZ\VRNLFKRVLćJDFKWHFKQLF]Q\FKDXWDRUD] G

(89) RVRE\]QDMGXMćFHVLĕZZ\ŧV]\FKID]DFKF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\ WMPDãŧHĸVWZD ]GRURVã\PLG]LHþPLÅSXVWHJQLD]GDµLVWDUV]HRVRE\VWDQXZROQHJR²GRW\F]\WR ZGXŧ\PXSURV]F]HQLXRVyESRURNXŧ\FLD

(90) $QDOL]DSUHIHUHQFML]DSRPRFÈDQDOL]\G\VNU\PLQDF\MQHM /LQLRZDIXQNFMDG\VNU\PLQDF\MQD. :NROHMQHMSUyELH]EXGRZDQLDPRGHOXSUHIHUHQFMLQDU\QNXVDPRFKRGyZ RVRERZ\FKZ\NRU]\VWDQROLQLRZćDQDOL]ĕG\VNU\PLQDF\MQć:WDEHOLSU]HG VWDZLRQRV]F]HJyã\GRW\F]ćFHF]WHUHFKSUHG\NWRUyZNWyUHWUDILã\GRRVWDWHF]QHM SRVWDFLPRGHOX 7DEHOD$QDOL]DG\VNU\PLQDF\MQD²SU]HJOćG]PLHQQ\FKZPRGHOX ƪ:LONVD. &]ćVWNRZD ƪ:LONVD. 3R]LRPS. 3.(SOXV. . . . . . 3ID]D. . . . . . =PLHQQD. :VSyãF]\QQLN ²7ROHUDQFMD WROHUDQFML 5²NZDGUDW

(91). 3ID]D. . . . . . 3ID]D. . . . . . ŤUyGãRRSUDFRZDQLHZãDVQH]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPSURJUDPX67$7,67,&$. 2FHQLDMćFZNãDGSRV]F]HJyOQ\FK]PLHQQ\FKZG\VNU\PLQDFMĕRELHNWyZQDOHŧ\ RV]DFRZDþZVSyãF]\QQLNLG\VNU\PLQDF\MQHIXQNFMLNDQRQLF]Q\FK WDEHOD

(92) NWyUH PyZLćRVLOHLNLHUXQNXRGG]LDã\ZDQLDSRV]F]HJyOQ\FK]PLHQQ\FKQDSU]\QDOHŧ QRŋþRELHNWXGRMHGQHM]Z\UyŧQLRQ\FKJUXS,PZ\ŧV]DMHVWZDUWRŋþWHJRZVSyã F]\QQLNDW\PZDŧQLHMV]ćUROĕSHãQLGDQD]PLHQQDZSURFHVLHG\VNU\PLQDFML3UH G\NWRUHPPDMćF\PQDMZLĕNV]H]QDF]HQLHMHVWSU]\QDOHŧQRŋþGRID]\F\NOXŧ\FLD URG]LQ\=QDNÅ²µR]QDF]DŧHUHVSRQGHQFLQDOHŧćF\GRWHMJUXS\²PãRGHRVRE\ VWDQXZROQHJR²QLHVć]DLQWHUHVRZDQHQRZ\PVDPRFKRGHP$QDORJLF]QHZQLR :DUWRŋþSGOD]PLHQQHMÅQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFMLµE\ãDQLH]QDF]QLHZ\ŧV]DRGZDUWRŋFL GODWHJR]GHF\GRZDQRVLĕZãćF]\þMćGRPRGHOX.

(93) . 0RGHORZDQLHSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZ«. VNLGRW\F]ćPãRG\FKPDãŧHĸVWZEH]G]LHFL ID]D

(94) RUD]PDãŧHĸVWZ]G]LHþPL NWyU\FKZLHNQLHSU]HNUDF]DODW ID]D

(95) 2GPLHQQDLQWHUSUHWDFMDGRW\F]\QDWR PLDVW]PLHQQHMÅQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFMLµ5HVSRQGHQFLNWyU]\NãDGćQDFLVNQD WĕFHFKĕVDPRFKRGXSUHIHUXMć]DNXSDXWDQRZHJR:VSyãF]\QQLNLG\VNU\PLQDFML SR]ZDODMćGRGDWNRZR]DSLVDþIRUPDOQLHUyZQDQLDNDQRQLF]Q\FKIXQNFMLG\VNU\ PLQDF\MQ\FK 7DEHOD6XURZHLVWDQGDU\]RZDQHZVSyãF]\QQLNLNDQRQLF]Q\FKIXQNFML G\VNU\PLQDF\MQ\FK =PLHQQD. 6XURZHZVSyãF]\QQLNL G\VNU\PLQDF\MQH. 6WDQGDU\]RZDQHZVSyãF]\QQLNL G\VNU\PLQDF\MQH. 3.(SOXV. . . 3ID]D. ². ². 3ID]D. ². ². 3ID]D. ². ². . ². 6WDãD. ŤUyGãRRSUDFRZDQLHZãDVQH]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPSURJUDPX67$7,67,&$. 2VWDWQLP HWDSHP DQDOL]\ MHVW Z\]QDF]HQLH IXQNFML NODV\ILNDF\MQ\FK GOD SRV]F]HJyOQ\FKNDWHJRULL]PLHQQHM]DOHŧQHM3RZLQQRVLĕZW\PFHOXVNRU]\VWDþ ]GDQ\FK]QDMGXMćF\FKVLĕZWDEHOL 7DEHOD3DUDPHWU\GODIXQNFMLNODV\ILNXMćF\FKSRV]F]HJyOQHNDWHJRULH]PLHQQHM ]DOHŧQHM =PLHQQD. 6DPRFKyGXŧ\ZDQ\. 6DPRFKyGQRZ\. 3.(SOXV. . . 3ID]D. . . 3ID]D. . . 3ID]D 6WDãD. . . ². ². ŤUyGãRRSUDFRZDQLHZãDVQH]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPSURJUDPX67$7,67,&$. )XQNFMHNODV\ILNDF\MQHRSRVWDFL :Xŧ\ZDQH ² HNVSORDWDFMD ID]D ID]D ID]D. . 8 ² HNVSORDWDFMD ID]D ID]D² ID]D.

(96) . 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL. RUD] :QRZH ² HNVSORDWDFMD ID]D ID]D ID]D VćSRPRFQHZNODV\ILNDFMLQRZ\FKSU]\SDGNyZ3U]\NãDGRZH]DGDQLHPRŧHSROH JDþQDSU]\SLVDQLXGRMHGQHM]NODV RVyESUHIHUXMćF\FKDXWDQRZHDOERXŧ\ZDQH

(97) RVRE\]QDMGXMćFHMVLĕZID]LHF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\ ID]D ID]D RUD] ID]D

(98) NWyUDNãDG]LHQDFLVNQDQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFML HNVSORDWDFMD

(99) 3RGVWDZLDMćFRGSRZLHGQLHZDUWRŋFLGRREXZ]RUyZRWU]\PXMHP\ :Xŧ\ZDQH ² ² RUD] :QRZH ² ² 2]QDF]DWRŧHUHVSRQGHQWRZ\ŧHMZ\PLHQLRQ\FKFHFKDFKSUHIHUXMHDXWRQRZH *G\E\QDWRPLDVWQRZ\PRELHNWHPE\ãDPãRGDRVREDVWDQXZROQHJR ID]D ID]D RUD]ID]D

(100) NWyUHMQLH]DOHŧ\QDQLVNLFKNRV]WDFKHNVSORDWDFML HNV SORDWDFMD

(101) WRV]DFXQNLE\ã\E\QDVWĕSXMćFH :Xŧ\ZDQH ² RUD] :QRZH ² :\QLNLZVND]XMćŧHUHVSRQGHQWWHQSRZLQLHQ]RVWDþVNODV\ILNRZDQ\GRJUXS\ RVyESUHIHUXMćF\FKDXWDXŧ\ZDQH 5HDVXPXMćFRSU]\QDOHŧQRŋFLUHVSRQGHQWyZGRREXJUXS²RVyESUHIHUXMćF\FK DXWDQRZHLRVyESUHIHUXMćF\FKDXWDXŧ\ZDQH²GHF\GXMćF]WHU\]PLHQQH7U]\ ]QLFKPDMćXMHPQHZVSyãF]\QQLNLIXQNFMLG\VNU\PLQDF\MQ\FK ID]DID]DLID]D F\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\

(102) FRR]QDF]DŧHPãRGHRVRE\VWDQXZROQHJRPãRGHPDã ŧHĸVWZDEH]G]LHFLRUD]PDãŧHĸVWZD]G]LHþPLSRQLŧHMURNXŧ\FLDQLHVć]DLQ WHUHVRZDQH]DNXSHPQRZHJRVDPRFKRGX-HG\Q\SUHG\NWRUGODNWyUHJRZVSyã F]\QQLNMHVWZDUWRŋFLćGRGDWQLćWRÅQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFMLµ=QDNÅµPyZL RW\PŧHRVRE\NWyUH]ZUDFDMćXZDJĕQDQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFMLSRMD]GXSUH IHUXMćDXWRQRZH .ODV\ILNRZDQ\RELHNWQDOHŧ\GRNODV\GODNWyUHMZDUWRŋþIXQNFMLNODV\ILNDF\MQHMMHVW QDMZ\ŧV]D:W\PSU]\SDGNX² DXWRQRZH

(103) !² DXWRXŧ\ZDQH

(104) .

(105) . 0RGHORZDQLHSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZ« .ZDGUDWRZDIXQNFMDG\VNU\PLQDF\MQD. .ZDGUDWRZDDQDOL]DG\VNU\PLQDF\MQDMHVWDOWHUQDW\ZćGODDQDOL]\OLQLRZHM ZV\WXDFMLJG\PDFLHU]HZDULDQFMLLNRZDULDQFMLQLHVćUyZQH&KDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\ GODPHWRG\NZDGUDWRZHMMHVW²SU]HGVWDZLRQ\QDU\V²VSRVyERGVHSDURZDQLD NODV1LHMHVWWROLQLDSURVWDDOHSDUDERODHOLSVDOXEKLSHUEROD. Metoda liniowa. Metoda kwadratowa parabola. Metoda kwadratowa elipsa. Metoda kwadratowa hiperbola. 5\V6SRVyERGVHSDURZDQLDNODVZPHWRG]LHOLQLRZHMLPHWRG]LHNZDGUDWRZHM ŤUyGãRRSUDFRZDQLHZãDVQHQDSRGVWDZLH5.RUQ6WDWLVWLFDO3UREOHPVDQG&UHGLW6FRULQJ QLHSXEOLNRZDQHPDWHULDã\7HFKQLFDO8QLYHUVLW\RI.DLVHUVODXWHUQ. :EDGDQLXZ\NRU]\VWDQRSDNLHWVWDW\VW\F]Q\6<67$7NWyU\SRVLDGDLPSOH PHQWDFMHREXW\SyZDQDOL]\G\VNU\PLQDF\MQHM:VSyãF]\QQLNƪ:LONVDMHVW]EOL ŧRQ\GRWHJRX]\VNDQHJRZSRGHMŋFLXOLQLRZ\PGODZV]\VWNLFKSUHG\NWRUyZ ²Z\QRVL:VSyãF]\QQLNNRUHODFMLNDQRQLF]QHMMHVWUyZQ\1DOHŧ\WX GRGDþŧHPRGHO]EXGRZDQ\]DSRPRFćNZDGUDWRZHMDQDOL]\G\VNU\PLQDF\MQHM XZ]JOĕGQLDZV]\VWNLHSUHG\NWRU\ 3HZQ\PXWUXGQLHQLHPNZDGUDWRZHMDQDOL]\G\VNU\PLQDF\MQHMMHVWSUHG\NFMD QRZ\FKRELHNWyZ:SU]\SDGNXDQDOL]\OLQLRZHMHVW\PRZDQRW\OHSDUDPHWUyZ LOHE\ãR]PLHQQ\FKQLH]DOHŧQ\FK RUD]VWDãć

(106) 1DSU]\NãDGGODPRGHOX]WU]HPD ]PLHQQ\PLQLH]DOHŧQ\PLLGZXZDULDQWRZć]PLHQQć]DOHŧQć NODVD$LNODVD%

(107) RV]DFRZDQRGZLHIXQNFMHNODV\ILNDF\MQHRSRVWDFL \$ DE[F[G[ \% HI[J[K[ :SU]\SDGNXSRMDZLHQLDVLĕQRZHJRRELHNWXRFHFKDFK[[L[SRGVWDZLDQR ZDUWRŋFLW\FK]PLHQQ\FKGRREXZ]RUyZLSRUyZQ\ZDQRZLHONRŋFL\$L\%:\ŧV]D ZDUWRŋþNWyUHMŋ]QLFKR]QDF]DãDŧHQRZ\RELHNW]QDMGXMHVLĕZWHMZãDŋQLHNODVLH -HG\Q\PNU\WHULXPNWyUHGHF\GXMHRRGU]XFHQLX]PLHQQHMQLH]DOHŧQHM]PRGHOXMHVWVWRSLHĸ MHMVNRUHORZDQLD]LQQć LQQ\PL

(108) ]PLHQQć ]PLHQQ\PL

(109) ,PSOHPHQWDFMHNZDGUDWRZHMDQDOL]\ G\VNU\PLQDF\MQHMZSDNLHFLH6<67$7RUD]0,1,7$%QLH]DZLHUDMćRFHQ\LVWRWQRŋFL VWDW\VW\F]QHMSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKSUHG\NWRUyZ.

(110) . 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL. 5R]ZDŧDMćFWHQVDPPRGHO ]WU]HPDSUHG\NWRUDPL;;L;

(111) GODIXQNFML NZDGUDWRZ\FKSRZLQQLŋP\RWU]\PDþ \$ DE[F[G[H[[I[[J[[K[L[M[ \% NO[P[Q[R[[S[[U[[V[W[X[ :DQDOL]RZDQ\PWXWDM]ELRU]HREVHUZDFMLZ\VWĕSXMćSUHG\NWRU\]DWHP RV]DFRZDQLHZLHONRŋFL\$L\%E\ãRE\EH]SRPRF\NRPSXWHUDF]\QQRŋFLćQLH ]Z\NOHF]DVRFKãRQQć 1DMOHSV]\PLSUHG\NWRUDPLZDQDOL]LHNZDGUDWRZHME\ã\ ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\3)$=$ ²

(112) ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\3)$=$ ²

(113) ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\3)$=$ ²

(114) ²ZDUWRŋþ²EH]SLHF]HĸVWZR3%(=3, ²

(115) ²ZDUWRŋþ²SRF]XFLHSU]\QDOHŧQRŋFL335=<1 ²

(116) ²NRU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFML3.(3/86

(117) ²FHFKDDXWDEUDQDSRGXZDJĕSU]\]DNXSLHMDNRSLHUZV]D²W\SVLOQLND37<3 ²

(118) =QDNÅ²µSU]\ZLĕNV]RŋFL]QLFKŋZLDGF]\ŧHG]LDãDMćRQHRJUDQLF]DMćFRQD Z\EyUDXWDQRZHJR,QQ\PLVãRZ\MHŋOLEDGDQ\QDOHŧ\GRID]\DOERF\NOX ŧ\FLDURG]LQ\WRSUHIHUXMH]DNXSVDPRFKRGXXŧ\ZDQHJR'RW\F]\WRRVyEPãRG\FK VWDQXZROQHJRPãRG\FKPDãŧHĸVWZEH]G]LHFLRUD]PDãŧHĸVWZ]G]LHþPLSRQLŧHM URNXŧ\FLD:]HVWDZLHSUHG\NWRUyZQDMOHSLHMG\VNU\PLQXMćF\FKNODV\SRMDZLã\ VLĕWDNŧHF]\QQLNLSV\FKRORJLF]QH6ćWRZDUWRŋFLNWyU\PLNLHUXMćVLĕUHVSRQGHQFL ²EH]SLHF]HĸVWZRLSRF]XFLHSU]\QDOHŧQRŋFL%DGDQLGODNWyU\FKEH]SLHF]HĸVWZR RFKURQD]GURZLDEH]SLHF]HĸVWZRVZRMHLVZRLFKQDMEOLŧV]\FKEH]SLHF]HĸVWZR ILQDQVRZHEH]SLHF]QDVWDURŋþ

(119) QLHMHVWZDUWRŋFLćSULRU\WHWRZćQLHZ\ELRUćDXWD QRZHJR'RWHMVDPHMJUXS\EĕGćQDOHŧHþWDNŧHRVRE\NWyUHQLHRGF]XZDMćSRWU]HE\ SU]\QDOHŧQRŋFLGRURG]LQ\JUXS\SU]\MDFLyãRUJDQL]DFMLLVWRZDU]\V]Hĸ 2VWDWQLHGZDSUHG\NWRU\RQDMZLĕNV]HMVLOHG\VNU\PLQDF\MQHMWRÅNRV]W\HNV SORDWDFMLµ UHVSRQGHQFLNWyU]\NãDGćGXŧ\QDFLVNQDQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFML ²Z\ELHUDMćDXWRQRZH

(120) RUD]W\SVLOQLND UHVSRQGHQFLNWyU]\ELRUćWĕFHFKĕDXWD SRGXZDJĕSU]\]DNXSLHVDPRFKRGX²Z\ELHUDMćDXWRXŧ\ZDQH

(121) 1DOHŧ\WXMHGQDNSU]\SRPQLHþŧHQLHVSHãQLRQR]DãRŧHQLDRZLHORZ\PLDUR Z\PUR]NãDG]LHQRUPDOQ\PZ]ZLć]NX]F]\PZDUWRE\ãRE\Z\SUyERZDþLQQH PRG\ILNDFMHDQDOL]\G\VNU\PLQDF\MQHM :QDZLDVDFKSRGDQRVWDQGDU\]RZDQHZDUWRŋFLZVSyãF]\QQLNyZNDQRQLF]QHMIXQNFMLG\V NU\PLQDF\MQHM . 2SUDFRZDQRQDSRGVWDZLH$0LQKDMXGGLQ/LQHDU'LVFULPLQDQW$QDO\VLVDQG,WV9DULD WLRQVPDWHULDã\QLHSXEOLNRZDQH6RXWKHUQ0HWKRGLVW8QLYHUVLW\'DOODVRUD]--LDQJ77DR /LQHDU0HWKRGVIRU&ODVVLILFDWLRQPDWHULDã\QLHSXEOLNRZDQH.

(122) 0RGHORZDQLHSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZ«. . ²DQDOL]ĕOLQLRZćLNZDGUDWRZćRSDUWćQDJĕVWRŋFLMćGURZHM NHUQHOGHQVLW\ EDVHG/'$DQG4'$

(123) ²XUHJXORZDQćDQDOL]ĕG\VNU\PLQDF\MQć UHJXODUL]HGGLVFULPLQDQWDQDO\VLV

(124) ²ÅUHSUHVMRQRZDQćµDQDOL]ĕG\VNU\PLQDF\MQć SHQDOL]HGGLVFULPLQDQWDQD O\VLV

(125) ²HODVW\F]QćDQDOL]ĕG\VNU\PLQDF\MQć IOH[LEOHGLVFULPLQDQWDQDO\VLV

(126) ²DQDOL]ĕOLQLRZć]H]UHGXNRZDQ\PUDQNLQJLHP UHGXFHGUDQNOLQHDUGLVFUL PLQDQW

(127) $QDOL]DSUHIHUHQFML]DSRPRFÈGU]HZNODV\ILNDF\MQ\FK &$57 PRGHOHNVSORUDF\MQ\EH]SU]\FLQDQLD

(128) :RVWDWQLHMSUyELHPRGHORZDQLDSUHIHUHQFMLZ\NRU]\VWDQRDOJRU\WPGU]HZNOD V\ILNDF\MQ\FK²&$57:LHONRŋþGU]HZDZ\QRVLãD OLF]EDOLŋFLF]\OLZĕ]ãyZ NRĸFRZ\FK

(129) ]DŋJãĕERNRŋþGU]HZDE\ãDUyZQD QDMGãXŧV]DÅGURJDµPLĕG]\ ZLHU]FKRãNLHPGU]HZDDOLŋFLHP]QDMGXMćF\PVLĕQDMQLŧHM

(130) :LHONRŋFLWHLQIRU PXMćRW\PŧHPRGHOPRŧQDRSLVDþ]DSRPRFć]GDĸZDUXQNRZ\FK UHJXãW\SX ÅMHŧHOL«WR«µ

(131) RUD]ŧHQDMGãXŧV]DUHJXãDEĕG]LHPLHþSRSU]HGQLNyZ:WDEHOL ]DPLHV]F]RQR]HVWDZUHJXãRSLVXMćF\FKUHVSRQGHQWyZSUHIHUXMćF\FKQRZ\ VDPRFKyG :DŧQ\PX]XSHãQLHQLHPLQWHUSUHWDFMLPRGHOXG\VNU\PLQDF\MQHJRMHVWUDQNLQJ ZDŧQRŋFLSUHG\NWRUyZZNWyU\PNDŧGD]PLHQQDQLH]DOHŧQDRWU]\PXMHOLF]Eĕ SXQNWyZ]SU]HG]LDãXRGGR WDEHOD

(132) ,PZ\ŧV]HVćZDUWRŋFL Z\ŧV]D SR]\FMDZUDQNLQJX

(133) W\PZLĕNV]\ZSã\ZGDQHM]PLHQQHMQLH]DOHŧQHMQD]PLHQQć ]DOHŧQć=UDQNLQJXZ\QLNDŧHQDMZLĕNV]\ZSã\ZQDSUHIHUHQFMHUHVSRQGHQWyZ PLDã\ ²FHFKDDXWDEUDQDSRGXZDJĕSU]\]DNXSLHMDNRSLHUZV]D ²Z\NV]WDãFHQLHEDGDQHJR ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\EDGDQHJR RUD]ZQLHFRPQLHMV]\PVWRSQLX ²NRU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQD]DEH]SLHF]HQLDVDPRFKRGXSU]HGNUDG]LHŧć ²NRU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDGRVWĕSQRŋþVHUZLVX :Sã\ZSR]RVWDã\FK]PLHQQ\FKQLH]DOHŧQ\FKMHVWMHV]F]HQLŧV]\²OLF]EDSXQN WyZQLHSU]HNUDF]D. . :DQDOL]LHZ\NRU]\VWDQRSURJUDP&$57ILUP\6DOIRUG6\VWHPV.

(134) ZDUWRŋþ ŧ\FLH SHãQHZUDŧHĸ. VWDQF\ZLOQ\ ŧRQDW\. . . ŤUyGãRRSUDFRZDQLHZãDVQH. . . . . NDWDOL]DWRU WDN. VWDQF\ZLOQ\ ŧRQDW\. FHFK\EUDQHSRG ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD XZDJĕSU]\]DNX URG]LQ\ DOER SLHDXWD W\SVLOQLND DOER DOERPDUND FHFK\EUDQHSRG ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD XZDJĕSU]\]DNX URG]LQ\ DOER SLHDXWD W\SVLOQLND DOER DOERPDUND FHFK\EUDQHSRG ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD XZDJĕSU]\]DNX URG]LQ\ DOER SLHDXWD W\SVLOQLND DOER DOERPDUND FHFK\EUDQHSRG ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD XZDJĕSU]\]DNX URG]LQ\ DOER SLHDXWD W\SVLOQLND DOER DOERPDUND. 3RSU]HGQLN QU. 3RSU]HGQLN QU. 1U Zĕ]ãD. 3RSU]HGQLN QU FHFK\EUDQHSRG XZDJĕSU]\]DNXSLH DXWD NUDMSRFKR G]HQLDPDUNLDOER SRMHPQRŋþVLOQLND DOEROLF]EDGU]ZL FHFK\EUDQHSRG XZDJĕSU]\]DNXSLH DXWD NUDMSRFKR G]HQLDPDUNLDOER SRMHPQRŋþVLOQLND NUDMZNWyU\PSUR GXNXMHVLĕQDMOHSV]H WHFKQLF]QLHDXWDȴ 1LHPF\ NUDMZNWyU\PSUR GXNXMHVLĕQDMOHSV]H WHFKQLF]QLHDXWD 1LHPF\ NUDMZNWyU\PSUR GXNXMHVLĕQDMOHSV]H WHFKQLF]QLHDXWDȴ -DSRQLDȴ)UDQFMD NUDMZNWyU\PSUR GXNXMHVLĕQDMOHSV]H WHFKQLF]QLHDXWDȴ -DSRQLDȴ)UDQFMD Z\NV]WDãFHQLHȴ ŋUHGQLH. Z\NV]WDãFHQLHȴ Z\ŧV]H. NDWDOL]DWRU WDN. ². ². Z\NV]WDãFHQLHȴ Z\ŧV]H. RVyEVSHã QLDMćF\FKWĕUHJXãĕ SUHIHUXMHQRZ\VDPR FKyG. RVyEVSHã QLDMćF\FKWĕUHJXãĕ SUHIHUXMHQRZ\VDPR FKyG. 2GVHWHNEDGDQ\FK. GRVWĕSQRŋþVHUZLVX WDN. RVyEVSHãQLDMć F\FKWĕUHJXãĕSUH IHUXMHQRZ\VDPRFKyG. RVyEVSHã QLDMćF\FKWĕUHJXãĕ ² SUHIHUXMHQRZ\VDPR FKyG RVyEVSHã QLDMćF\FKWĕUHJXãĕ ² SUHIHUXMHQRZ\VDPR FKyG RVyEVSHã ZDUWRŋþ V]DFXQHN QLDMćF\FKWĕUHJXãĕ GODVDPHJRVLHELH SUHIHUXMHQRZ\VDPR FKyG. ². 3RSU]HGQLN QU. ². 3RSU]HGQLN QU. 7DEHOD=HVWDZ]GDĸZDUXQNRZ\FKRSLVXMćF\FKUHVSRQGHQWyZSUHIHUXMćF\FKQRZ\VDPRFKyG. . 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL.

(135) . 0RGHORZDQLHSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZ«. 7DEHOD5DQNLQJZDŧQRŋFLSUHG\NWRUyZ²PRGHOHNVSORUDF\MQ\]SURVW\PV]DFRZDQLHP EãĕGX =PLHQQD &HFKDDXWDEUDQDSRGXZDJĕSU]\]DNXSLHMDNRSLHUZV]D :\NV]WDãFHQLHEDGDQHJR )D]DF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\EDGDQHJR .RU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQD]DEH]SLHF]HQLDVDPRFKRGXSU]HG NUDG]LHŧć .RU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDGRVWĕSQRŋþVHUZLVX .RU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDZ\VRNLHRVLćJLWHFKQLF]QH 2SLQLDQDWHPDWNUDMyZ]NWyU\FKSRFKRG]ćQDMOHSV]H WHFKQLF]QLHVDPRFKRG\ :DUWRŋþ²E\FLHSRZDŧDQ\P :DUWRŋþ²EH]SLHF]HĸVWZR .RU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDSRVLDGDQLHNDWDOL]DWRUD :DUWRŋþ²V]DFXQHNGODVDPHJRVLHELH .RU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDEH]SLHF]HĸVWZR .RU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDDWUDNF\MQ\Z\JOćG :DUWRŋþ²ŧ\FLHSHãQHZUDŧHĸ :DUWRŋþ²VHUGHF]QHVWRVXQNL]LQQ\PL :DUWRŋþ²SRF]XFLHVSHãQLHQLD :DUWRŋþ²SU]\MHPQRŋþLUDGRŋþ]ŧ\FLD 3ãHþEDGDQHJR :DUWRŋþ²SRF]XFLHSU]\QDOHŧQRŋFL .RU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDIXQNFMRQDOQRŋþ :DUWRŋþ²VDPRUHDOL]DFMD 6WDWXV]DWUXGQLHQLDEDGDQHJR .RU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDZ\VRNLNRPIRUWXŧ\WNRZDQLD .RU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDQLVNLHNRV]W\HNVSORDWDFML ŤUyGãRRSUDFRZDQLHZãDVQH]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPSURJUDPX&$57. /LF]EDSXQNWyZ __________________________________________ _________________________________________ ______________________________________ ______________________ ____________________ __________________ ________________ ______________ ____________ ___________ __________ __________ _________ _________ _________ ________ ________ _______ ______ _____ ___ ___ _. 8SUDV]F]DMćFLQWHUSUHWDFMĕPRŧQDVWZLHUG]LþŧHDXWDPLQRZ\PLVć]DLQWHUH VRZDQHRVRE\]QDMGXMćFHVLĕZID]LHDOERDOERF\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\NWyUH ]ZUDFDMćXZDJĕQDW\SVLOQLND EHQ]\QRZ\²GLHVHO

(136) LPDUNĕVDPRFKRGX)D]D F\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\WRPDãŧHĸVWZD]GRURVã\PLG]LHþPLQDXWU]\PDQLXID]D WRÅSXVWHJQLD]GDµID]D]DŋWRVWDUV]HRVRE\VWDQXZROQHJR:\QLNDVWćGŧH UHVSRQGHQFLNWyU]\Z\EUDOLQRZ\VDPRFKyGVćRVREDPLZŋUHGQLPLVWDUV]\P ZLHNXNWyUHVDPRFKyGSRWU]HEXMćQDZãDVQ\Xŧ\WHN PRŧQDWXSU]\MćþŧHGRURVãH G]LHFLEĕGćFHQDXWU]\PDQLXSRGUyŧXMćVDPRG]LHOQLH

(137) 'UXJćJUXSĕEDGDQ\FKSUH IHUXMćF\FKQRZHVDPRFKRG\VWDQRZLćRVRE\ŧRQDWH ]DPĕŧQH

(138) NWyUHSU]\]DNXSLH.

(139) . 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL. VDPRFKRGXELRUćZSLHUZV]HMNROHMQRŋFLSRGXZDJĕNUDMSRFKRG]HQLDPDUNLDOER SRMHPQRŋþVLOQLNDDOEROLF]EĕGU]ZL 1LHVWHW\QLHSRWZLHUG]Lã\VLĕKLSRWH]\GRW\F]ćFHZSã\ZXZDUWRŋFLNWyU\PL NLHUXMćVLĕEDGDQL F]\QQLNyZSV\FKRORJLF]Q\FK

(140) QDZ\EyUVDPRFKRGX1DMZ\ŧHM ZREXUDQNLQJDFK]QDMGRZDãDVLĕ]PLHQQDÅE\FLHSRZDŧDQ\PµMHGQDNLWDNMHM SR]\FMDE\ãDQLVND1LHSRWZLHUG]LãDVLĕWDNŧHKLSRWH]DRZSã\ZLHSãFLQDZ\EyU VDPRFKRGX3U]\MĕWRDSULRULŧHNRELHW\Z\ELHUDMćDXWDQRZHJG\ŧREDZLDMćVLĕ DZDU\MQRŋFLVDPRFKRGyZXŧ\ZDQ\FKLHZHQWXDOQLHQLHRF]HNLZDQ\FKNãRSRWyZ ]ZLć]DQ\FK]HNVSORDWDFMćWDNLFKSRMD]GyZ &]ĕŋFLRZRSRWZLHUG]LãDVLĕKLSRWH]DRZSã\ZLHRFHQ\Xŧ\WHF]QRŋFLDWU\EXWyZ VDPRFKRGX²NLONDZ\PLDUyZ]QDOD]ãRVLĕZ\VRNRZUDQNLQJX7U]HEDWXMHGQDN GRGDþŧHQLH]DZV]HXF]HVWQLF]\ã\RQHZSRG]LDOHPRGHOX,FKZ\VRNDSR]\FMD Z\QLND]IDNWXŧHQDNDŧG\PHWDSLHSRG]LDãXVćX]QDZDQH]DGUXJćOXEWU]HFLć ZNROHMQRŋFLFRR]QDF]DŧHVćGREU\PL]PLHQQ\PL]DVWĕSF]\PL VXUURJDWHV

(141) 6NRURGDQ\SUHG\NWRUQLHG]LHOLGU]HZDW]QŧHQLHSRMDZLVLĕZŧDGQ\P]GD QLXZDUXQNRZ\PFKDUDNWHU\]XMćF\POLŋFLH-HVWWRFHFKDNWyUćPRŧQDX]QDþ]D ZDGĕWHMPHWRG\&$57²MDNRMHG\Q\DOJRU\WPGRSRG]LDãXGU]HZ²XPRŧOLZLD V]F]HJyãRZćDQDOL]ĕ]PLHQQ\FK]DVWĕSF]\FKL]PLHQQ\FKNRQNXUHQF\MQ\FK FRP SHWLWRUV

(142) FR]QDF]QLHZ]ERJDFDLQWHUSUHWDFMĕPHU\WRU\F]QćPRGHOX 3RGVXPRZDQLH 1DU]ĕG]LDVWDW\VW\F]QHLGDWDPLQLQJZ\NRU]\VWDQHZQLQLHMV]\PDUW\NXOH SR]ZROLã\]EXGRZDþF]WHU\PRGHOHGRSUHG\NFMLSUHIHUHQFMLQDU\QNXPRWRU\]DF\M Q\P1DMOHSV]ćRJyOQćWUDIQRŋþSUHG\NFML]DSHZQLã&$57QDMJRUV]ć]Dŋ²NZD GUDWRZDDQDOL]DG\VNU\PLQDF\MQD7U]HEDMHGQDNSRGNUHŋOLþŧHSURFHQWSRSUDZ Q\FKNODV\ILNDFMLGODW\FKF]WHUHFKPHWRGPLHŋFLVLĕZSU]HG]LDOH²FR R]QDF]DŧHLFKMDNRŋþMHVWSRUyZQ\ZDOQD1LHFRLQDF]HMSU]HGVWDZLDVLĕWUDIQRŋþ SUHG\NFMLSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKNODV²WXUyŧQLFDZMDNRŋFLUR]ZLć]DĸMHVWMXŧ]QDF]QLH ZLĕNV]D:SU]\SDGNXNODV\RVyESUHIHUXMćF\FKDXWDQRZHQDMOHSV]HUR]ZLć]DQLH ]DSHZQLD&$57

(143) QDMJRUV]H]Dŋ²4')

(144) =NROHLZSU]\SDGNXJUXS\ RVyESUHIHUXMćF\FKDXWDXŧ\ZDQHQDMOHSV]HUR]ZLć]DQLHGRVWDUF]DPRGHOORJLWRZ\

(145) DQDMJRUV]H²&$57

(146) . . 3RUyZQDQLHPRGHOLQDOHŧ\RJUDQLF]\þGRPRGHOX&$57]SU]\FLQDQLHPOLQLRZHMDQDOL]\ G\VNU\PLQDF\MQHMNZDGUDWRZHMDQDOL]\G\VNU\PLQDF\MQHM²ZDULDQWMDFNQLIH RGSRZLHGQLNPRGHOX &$57]SU]\FLQDQLHP

(147) RUD]PRGHOXORJLWRZHJREH]LQWHUDNFML.

(148) . 0RGHORZDQLHSUHIHUHQFMLNRQVXPHQWyZ« 7DEHOD3UHG\NFMDSUHIHUHQFML²SRGVXPRZDQLHZ\QLNyZRWU]\PDQ\FK]DSRPRFć QDU]ĕG]L :\V]F]HJyO QLHQLH -DNRŋþFDãHJR PRGHOX RGVHWHN SRSUDZQ\FKNOD V\ILNDFML

(149). 'U]HZD NODV\ILNDF\MQH &$57. /LQLRZDDQDOL]D .ZDGUDWRZD G\VNU\PLQDF\MQD DQDOL]DG\VNU\PL /')

(150) QDF\MQD 4')

(151). 0RGHOORJLWRZ\ EH]LQWHUDNFML. PRGHO HNVSORUDF\MQ\

(152) PRGHO ]SU]\FLQDQLHP

(153). . MDFNQLIH

(154). . PRGHO 7UDIQRŋþSUHG\N HNVSORUDF\MQ\

(155) FMLNODV\ÅDXWR PRGHO QRZHµ ]SU]\FLQDQLHP

(156). . MDFNQLIH

(157). . PRGHO 7UDIQRŋþSUHG\N HNVSORUDF\MQ\

(158) FMLNODV\ÅDXWR PRGHO Xŧ\ZDQHµ ]SU]\FLQDQLHP

(159). . MDFNQLIH

(160). . 1DMZDŧQLHMV]H LVWRWQH

(161) SUHG\N WRU\. ²FHFKDDXWDEUDQD ²NRU]\ŋFL²QD ²ZDUWRŋþ²EH] ²NRU]\ŋFL²QD SRGXZDJĕSU]\ FLVNQDQLVNLH SLHF]HĸVWZR FLVNQDRVLćJL ]DNXSLHMDNR NRV]W\HNVSORD 3EH]SL

(162) WHFKQLF]QH SLHUZV]D WDFML 3.(SOXV

(163) ²ZDUWRŋþ²SRF]X VDPRFKRGX ²Z\NV]WDãFHQLH ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD FLHSU]\QDOHŧQRŋFL 327SOXV

(164) EDGDQHJR URG]LQ\EDGDQHJR 3SU]\Q

(165) ²NRU]\ŋFL²QDFLVN ²ID]DF\NOX 3ID]D

(166) ²PãR ²NRU]\ŋFL²QDFLVN QDQLVNLHNRV]W\ ŧ\FLDURG]LQ\ GHRVRE\VWDQX QDQLVNLHNRV]W\ HNVSORDWDFML EDGDQHJR ZROQHJR HNVSORDWDFML 3.(SOXV

(167) ²NRU]\ŋFL²QD ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD 3.(SOXV

(168) ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD FLVNQD]DEH] URG]LQ\EDGDQHJR ²FHFKDDXWDEUDQD URG]LQ\EDGD SLHF]HQLDVDPR 3ID]D

(169) ²PãR SRGXZDJĕSU]\ QHJR 3ID]D

(170) FKRGXSU]HG GHPDãŧHĸVWZD ]DNXSLHMDNRSLHU ²PãRGHRVRE\ NUDG]LHŧć EH]G]LHFL ZV]D²W\SVLOQLND VWDQXZROQHJR ²NRU]\ŋFL²QD ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD 3W\S

(171) ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD FLVNQDGRVWĕS URG]LQ\EDGDQHJR ²ID]DF\NOX URG]LQ\EDGD QRŋþVHUZLVX 3ID]D

(172) ²PDã ŧ\FLDURG]LQ\ QHJR 3ID]D

(173) ²NRU]\ŋFL²QD ŧHĸVWZD]G]LHþ 3ID]D

(174) ²PãRGHPDã FLVNQDZ\VRNLH PLQDXWU]\PDQLX ²ID]DF\NOX ŧHĸVWZDEH] RVLćJLWHFK WHFK ZLHNG]LHFLQLH ŧ\FLDURG]LQ\ G]LHFL QLF]QH SU]HNUDF]DODW

(175) 3ID]D

(176) ²ID]DF\NOXŧ\FLD ²ID]DF\NOX URG]LQ\EDGD ŧ\FLDURG]LQ\ QHJR 3ID]D

(177) 3ID]D

(178) ²PDãŧHĸVWZD ]G]LHþPLQD XWU]\PDQLX ZLHN G]LHFLQLHSU]H NUDF]DODW

(179). ŤUyGãRRSUDFRZDQLHZãDVQH.

(180) . 0DULXV]âDSF]\ĸVNL. 3HZQ\FKWUXGQRŋFLPRŧHQDVWUĕF]DþSRUyZQDQLHPRGHOL]SXQNWXZLG]HQLD ZDŧQRŋFLSUHG\NWRUyZ:SU]\SDGNXQDU]ĕG]LVWDW\VW\F]Q\FKPRŧQDPyZLþRLFK VWDW\VW\F]QHMLVWRWQRŋFLMHGQDNZPRGHOX&$57EDGDF]SRVãXJXMHVLĕMHG\QLHUDQ NLQJLHPZDŧQRŋFL]PLHQQ\FKQLH]DOHŧQ\FK=GUXJLHM]DŋVWURQ\G]LĕNLDQDOL]LH ]PLHQQ\FK]DVWĕSF]\FKL]PLHQQ\FKNRQNXUHQF\MQ\FK&$57XPRŧOLZLDJãĕEV]\ ZJOćGZVWUXNWXUĕGDQ\FKLLGHQW\ILNDFMĕLQWHUDNFMLPLĕG]\]PLHQQ\PL 3RGVXPRZXMćFZ\QLNLSU]HSURZDG]RQ\FKDQDOL] WDEHOD

(181) ãDWZR]DXZDŧ\þ ŧHNLOND]PLHQQ\FKQLH]DOHŧQ\FK]RVWDãRX]QDQ\FK]DZDŧQH LVWRWQH

(182) ZNDŧG\P ]PRGHOL6ćWRID]\F\NOXŧ\FLDURG]LQ\LÅNRU]\ŋFL²QDFLVNQDZ\VRNLHRVLćJL WHFKQLF]QHVDPRFKRGXµ /LWHUDWXUD %HQ$NLYD0LLQ([WHQGHG)UDPHZRUNIRU0RGHOLQJ&KRLFH%HKDYLRUÅ0DUNHWLQJ /HWWHUVµYROQU$XJXVW -LDQJ-7DR7/LQHDU0HWKRGVIRU&ODVVLILFDWLRQPDWHULDã\QLHSXEOLNRZDQH6RXWKZHVW HUQ0HGLFDO&HQWHU86$ 0LQKDMXGGLQ$/LQHDU'LVFULPLQDQW$QDO\VLVDQG,WV9DULDWLRQVPDWHULDã\QLHSXEOL NRZDQH6RXWKHUQ0HWKRGLVW8QLYHUVLW\'DOODV 5yV]NLHZLF]01DU]ĕG]LDVWDW\VW\F]QHZDQDOL]DFKPDUNHWLQJRZ\FK:\GDZQLFWZR &+%HFN:DUV]DZD 7KH0RGHOLQJRI&RQVXPHU3UHIHUHQFHVRQWKH0RWRU9HKLFOHV0DUNHW 7KHSUHGLFWLYHPRGHOFRQFHUQLQJWKHVWDWHGSUHIHUHQFHVRIFRQVXPHUVRQWKHPRWRU YHKLFOHVPDUNHWZDVGHYHORSHGRQWKHEDVLVRIGDWDFROOHFWHGGXULQJVXUYH\UHVHDUFK FRQGXFWHGLQ-XQHDQG-XO\7KHPDLQDLPRIWKHUHVHDUFKZDVWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHU UHVSRQGHQWVZLWK]ORW\VZRXOGGHFLGHWRSXUFKDVHDQHZRUXVHGFDU,QWKHDUWLFOH WKUHHVWDWLVWLFDOWRROVDUHXVHG ORJLWPRGHODQGOLQHDUDQGTXDGUDWLFGLVFULPLQDQWIXQFWLRQV

(183) DVZHOODVRQHGDWDPLQLQJWRRO²FODVVLILFDWLRQWUHHV &$57DOJRULWKP

(184) ,WWXUQHGRXWWKDW WKHPRVWDFFXUDWHSUHGLFWLRQV²PHDVXUHGE\WKHSURSRUWLRQRISURSHUO\FODVVLILHGFDVHV ²ZHUHSURYLGHGE\&$57DQGWKHOHDVWDFFXUDWH²E\WKHTXDGUDWLFGLVFULPLQDQWIXQFWLRQ 7KHVXEVWDQWLYHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIDOOWKHVROXWLRQVZDVVLPLODU²SHUVRQVZKRSUHIHUQHZ FDUVEHORQJWRWKHILQDOVWDJHVRIWKHKRXVHKROGOLIHF\FOHDQGDWWKHVDPHWLPHGRQRWSD\ DQ\DWWHQWLRQWRDYHKLFOH·VKLJKWHFKQLFDOVSHFLILFDWLRQV.

(185)