• Nie Znaleziono Wyników

Assessment of urban freight travel characteristics

N/A
N/A
Info
Pobierz
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Assessment of urban freight travel characteristics"

Copied!
20
0
0

Ładowanie.... (Zobacz pełny tekst teraz)

Pobierz teraz ( 20 Stron )

Pełen tekst

(1)Delft University of Technology. Assessment of urban freight travel characteristics A case study of Delhi Errrampalli, Madhu; Kayitha, Ravinder ; Chalumuri, Ravi Sekhar ; Tavasszy, Loriant A.; Borst, Jeroen ; Chandra, Satish DOI 10.1016/j.trpro.2020.08.053 Publication date 2020 Document Version Final published version Published in Transportation Research Procedia. Citation (APA) Errrampalli, M., Kayitha, R., Chalumuri, R. S., Tavasszy, L. A., Borst, J., & Chandra, S. (2020). Assessment of urban freight travel characteristics: A case study of Delhi. Transportation Research Procedia, 48, 467485. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trpro.2020.08.053 Important note To cite this publication, please use the final published version (if applicable). Please check the document version above.. Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons. Takedown policy Please contact us and provide details if you believe this document breaches copyrights. We will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.. This work is downloaded from Delft University of Technology. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to a maximum of 10..

(2)   

(3)

(4)  

(5)   . . Available online at www.sciencedirect.com . /G6CHEDGI6I>DC-:H:6G8=+GD8:9>6   Q . ScienceDirect.  LLL :AH:K>:G 8DB

(6) AD86I:

(7) EGD8:9>6. Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 .   

(8) !

(9)      .     

(10)  

(11)        

(12) 

(13)      !   #+3/46!6/3)/5'1#)/+38/78$6'375468'8/43!1'33/3-'3*3:/6432+38$!/:/7/43#"+386'1"4'*"+7+'6).378/898+""+;. #+3/46!6/3)/5'1#)/+38/78$6'375468'8/43!1'33/3-'3*3:/6432+38$!/:/7/43#"+386'1"4'*"+7+'6).378/898+""+; +1./. 3*/'  !64,+7746/:/13-/3++6/3-'3*+47)/+3)+7+1,8%3/:+67/8=4,$+).341-=$%+1,8#8+:/3;+-   +1,8$.++8.+61'3*7  #+3/46437918'38#2'68/8/+7$  $.+'-9+$.++8.+61'3*7  /6+)846#"+386'1"4'*"+7+'6).378/898+""+;+1./. 3*/'.  1(-%53)1(5  2*-652164%153246%1(/2+-56-'5%1(1(-%1*4)-+,664%1532460%4.)6-5):3)'6)(62+429%6%2* %&276

(14) &; 2%(*4)-+,6'2156-676)5%4271(

(15) 2*626%/*4)-+,6028)0)16%1(6,)%8)4%+)53))(2*647'.5211(-%1 42%(5-5%&276 .0,4'28)4521/;  

(16) .0%(%;'203%4)(62  .0-1()8)/23)('27164-)524)28)46,)626%/64-3 ):3)15)5-1'4)%5)5%&276 (7)626,)()/%;5%6',)'.32565&;!4%153246)3%460)16%1(!4%**-'2/-')62//3/%<%5)6'!,) 924.-1+'21(-6-2152*647'.(4-8)45%/52()6)4-24%6)%56,);924.*24/21+,27454)57/6-1+-1,-+,564)55%1(*%6-+7)/)%(-1+62 %''-()165!,)1))(-54)'2+1-<)(*24'2//%&24%6-21%021+5656%.),2/()4562-()16-*;236-0%/*4)-+,632/-'-)5%1(37457)%4%3-( ()3/2;0)162*-03428)0)16516,-5(-4)'6-21'4)%6-1+&)66)4(%6%%1(02()/5%4) 1))()(62)1%&/)3/%11)4562&)66)434)(-'6 *4)-+,6 028)0)16 %1( ()5-+1 &)66)4 -1*240)( 32/-'-)5 1 6,) 34)5)16 567(; 6,) *4)-+,6 64%153246 (%6% ,%5 &))1 ):,%756-8)/; '2//)'6)( 62 %55)55 6,) 74&%1 *4)-+,6 ',%4%'6)4-56-'5 2* )/,- 24 6,-5 374325) 6,) *-)/( 5748);5 1%0)/; 276)4 '24(21 64%**-' 5748);5%6 /2'%6-215%1(*2'%/32-165748);%6 /2'%6-2159-6,-16,)'-6;,%8)&))1'21(7'6)(!,)4)57/65'%10%.)%+22( (%6%&%5) 62 71()456%1( 6,) *4)-+,6 ',%4%'6)4-56-'5 2* % '-6; %1( -6 927/( &) ,-+,/; 75)*7/ -1 ()8)/23-1+ *4)-+,6 64%8)/ ()0%1( 02()/5 %1( %/52 )8%/7%6) %334234-%6) *4)-+,6 4)/%6)( 64%153246 32/-'-)5 *24 6,)-4 )**)'6-8) -03/)0)16%6-21 21 6,) 74&%1 42%( 1)6924.&;6,)32/-';0%.)45%1('21')41)(%76,24-6-)5  © 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. = !,)76,2457&/-5,)(&;/5)8-)4" This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) !,-5-5%123)1%'')55%46-'/)71()46,)$/-')15),663'4)%6-8)'20021524+/-')15)5&;1'1(   Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the World Conference on Transport Research – WCTR 2019 ))44)8-)971()44)53215-&-/-6;2*6,)5'-)16-*-''200-66))2*6,)#24/(21*)4)1')21!4%153246)5)%4',>#!  +=;46*70G76C!G:><=I:A=>>IN*JI:GDG9DC!D86A+D>CI MI:GC6A/G6K:A. . . DGG:HEDC9>C<6JI=DG   ;6M    2'/1'**6+77:GG6BE6AA> B69=J<B6>A 8DB B69=J 8GG>C>8 >C.  P  /=:JI=DGH +J7A>H=:97N AH:K>:G 1  /=>H>H6CDE:C688:HH6GI>8A:JC9:GI=:3 ) )A>8:CH:=IIE

(17)

(18) 8G:6I>K:8DBBDCH DG<

(19) A>8:CH:H

(20) 7N C8 C9

(21) 

(22)  +::G G:K>:LJC9:GG:HEDCH>7>A>IND;I=:H8>:CI>;>88DBB>II::D;I=:2DGA9DC;:G:C8:DC/G6CHEDGI-:H:6G8=Q2/- . 2352-1465 © 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the World Conference on Transport Research – WCTR 2019 10.1016/j.trpro.2020.08.053.

(23) 468 . Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . &+)',+"'& 5(,*+7 5$163257,11',$ &=,9>;:=? 4> , 60D 070809? 49 ?30 491=,>?=@.?@=0 :1 , 9,?4:9 ,> 4? ;=:A4/0> >0=A4.0> 0>>09?4,7 1:= ;=:8:?492 0.:9:84.,9/>:.4,7/0A07:;809?,9/;7,D>,>429414.,9?=:70494917@09.492?30;,??0=9:1/4>?=4-@?4:9:10.:9:84. ,.?4A4?40>,9/48;=:A492;=:/@.?4A4?D9/4,>;09/> ?: :14?>":9?=,9>;:=?,9/7:24>?4.>.:8;,=0/?:,9 ,A0=,20?: 49:?30=/0A07:;492.:@9?=40>9/4,91=0423??=,9>;:=?8,=60?4>0C;0.?0/?:2=:B,?,:8;:@9/ 99@,7=:B?3$,?0$:1,-:@?

(24) -D /=4A09-D?302=:B?349?308,9@1,.?@=492=0?,47,>?8:A492 .:9>@80= 2::/>  := .:9>@80= ;,.6,20/ 2::/> " ,9/ 0.:880=.0 >0.?:=> B34.3 3,A0 7,=20 1=0423? ?=,9>;:=? =0<@4=0809?> ,.=:>> ?30 .:@9?=D B34.3 4> 2090=,77D /:90 -D =:,/ ?=,9>;:=?,?4:9 9 9/4, =:,/ 1=0423? .:9>?4?@?0> ,=:@9/ 

(25)  :1 ?30 ?:?,7 1=0423? 8:A0809? .:9>4>?492 :1   84774:9 30,AD /@?D ?=@.6> ,9/  84774:9 7423?/@?D?=@.6>.:A0=4928:=0?3,9   68:1=:,/7092?3.,==D4928:=0?3,9

(26) &84774:980?=4. ?:9:17:,/,99@,77D !B492?:;::==:,/.:9/4?4:9>,9/.30.6;:>?/07,D>?=@.6>499/4,?=,A071:= /,D>,8:9?3:9,9,A0=,20 .:8;,=0/?: /,D>49/0A07:;492.:@9?=40>&,9/ &30/07,D>.:@7/=,9201=:814A0;0=.09?:1?480 ?,60949,5:@=90D?:,3423:1 &30,A0=,20>;00/:1?=@.6>:99/4,9=:,/>4>,-:@? 683:@=,9/,?=@.649 9/4,.,9.:A0=:97D  

(27) 68,/,D.:8;,=0/?:  6849/0A07:;0/.:@9?=40>>@.3,>?30'%,9/@=:;0 :=0:A0=:9,9,A0=,20?:?,7?=4;0C;09>0>49.=0,>0>,-:@? /@0?:?30/07,D>,?.30.6;:>?>,9/:9=:,/1:= 1477492491:=8>=0<@4=0/-DA,=4:@>2:A0=9809?/0;,=?809?>.30.6492:1/:.@809?>,9/;3D>4.,7.30.6492:1?30 A034.70>/=4A0=>,9/.:9>429809?>-D$024:9,7&=,9>;:=?!114.0>,9/?=,114.;:74.0,9/.:770.?4923423B,D?:77,9/ ?,C0>&30B:=6492.:9/4?4:9>1:=?30?=@.6/=4A0=>,7>:/0?0=4:=,?492,9/?30DB:=61:=7:923:@=>=0>@7?492493423 >?=0>> ,9/ 1,?42@0 B34.3 70,/> ?: ,..4/09?> &30=0 4> 49.=0,>492 =0.:294?4:9 49 9/4, ?3,? ?=,9>;:=? 491=,>?=@.?@=0 .:@7/ -0.:80 , >0=4:@> -:??7090.6 1:= 1@?@=0 0.:9:84. 2=:B?3 &30 900/ 4> =0.:294E0/ 1:= .:77,-:=,?4:9 ,8:92>? >?,603:7/0=>?:4/09?41D:;?48,7;:74.40>,9/;@=>@0,=,;4//0;7:D809?:148;=:A0809?> (/+,,7<$678'<5($ &30 ;=0>09? >?@/D .:9>4/0=> 0734 @=-,9 =:,/ 90?B:=6 ,> :-50.?:1 >?@/D > ;0= ?30 09>@> :1 9/4, 09>@> . 07343,> 84774:9;:;@7,?4:9B34.3=0.:=/0/,/0.0994,7;:;@7,?4:92=:B?3:1,-:@? &3049.=0,>0 49@=-,94E,?4:970,/>?:2=:B?3:1A034.@7,=;:;@7,?4:949@=-,9,=0,>,9/?34>>.09,=4:,..070=,?0>A,=4:@>?=,114. ;=:-708>>@.3,>.:920>?4:9,4=;:77@?4:9,9/=0/@.?4:949>,10?D&30=04>>429414.,9?8:809?@8492:A0=9809??: ?,60?30.4?D7:24>?4.>>D>?08,>>@>?,49,-70/0A07:;809?;=4:=4?D$0.09?A0=/4.?-D ,?4:9,7=009&=4-@9,7 & :19/4,:9-,99492 D0,=>:7/?=@.6>?:09?0=49?:?30.4?D :1073449A40B:13423;:77@?4:9084>>4:9-D?30>0 A034.70> 9 :=/0= ?: >?@/D ,9/ @9/0=>?,9/ ?30>0 4>>@0> 90B ;:74.40> ,=0 900/0/ ,9/ 499:A,?4:9 900/> ?: -0 ;=:8:?0/&30=:,/>:107343,A09@8-0=:1?480=0>?=4.?4:9>1:=2::/>A034.70>,9/?30=04> 3:@=>-,91:=>:80 =:,/>&30=0>?=4.?4:94>1=:8 ?:.  ,9/ "?:.  "1:=8:>?:1?30=:,/>490734 ((')257+(5(6(1778'< 07344>69:B9,>:90:1?308:>?,4=;:77@?0/.4?40>49?30B:=7/,>?30,4=<@,74?D49/0C#:18:>?,=0,>4> ,-:A0   0734 4= ":77@?4:9 $0,7?480 #  # 1=:8  ?:  4> 49 =,920 :1 2::/ ?: 8:/0=,?0 # 8:=0?3,9  4>.:9>4/0=0/@930,7?3D4= :B 84>>4:91=:88:?:=A034.70>4>:90:1?308,5:==0,>:9> 1:= ;::= <@,74?D 49 0734 &30 ?=,114. .:920>?4:9 :9 0734 =:,/ 4> ,> 49?484/,?492 ,> ?30 ;:77@?0/ ,4= ? B,> ,7>: =0A0,70/1=:8?30;,>?>?@/40>?3,?,-:@?  1=0423?A034.70>.=:>>0/ .:@9?>?,?4:9>,??30-:=/0=>:1073449 , /,D $$  70,=7D 1=0423? ?=,9>;:=?,?4:9 3,> 4?> 1,4= >3,=0 49 ;:77@?4:9 ,9/ .:920>?4:9 :1 0734 &30 ,A0=,20>3,=0:11=0423??=,9>;:=?,?4:9A034.70>4907344>=07,?4A07D7:B49:A0=,77>4?@,?4:9:B0A0=/@0?:?480 B49/:B=0>?=4.?4:9>-D7:.,7,@?3:=4?40>?30>3,=0:11=0423?A034.70>A,=40>/@=492/4110=09??480:1?30/,D9423? :=49>?,9.0.0=?,49?D;0>:11=0423?,.?4A4?40>021@=94?@=0/074A0=D8476A,90?.,=0,77:B0/-0?B009  ,9/   " @=492 ?3,? ?480 ?30 >3,=0 :1 1=0423? A034.70 49.=0,>0> ?:   9 ?30 9423? ,1?0=    ,77 1=0423?A034.70>,=0,77:B0/49?30.4?D=0>@7?492498,5:=4?D:11=0423?A034.70>:90734=:,/90?B:=6(>?=@.6>.

(28) . . Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–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

(30) 470 .                  . Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? 

(31)  .

(32) . . . . .  . . . 

(33) . .

(34)  .  

(35) . . . 

(36) .

(37) 

(38) .

(39) 

(40) .

(41) . . 

(42) .

(43)  .  

(44) .  

(45) . . 

(46) 

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

(48) . Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . . 471 . 3:@=/@=,?4:9,9/.:770.?0//,?,1=:8?301=0423?A034.70>:9>,8;70-,>4>&30>,8;70>4E0.:770.?0/,?/4110=09? :@?0=.:=/:97:.,?4:9>,=024A0949&,-70 =:8?30&,-70 4?.,9-0>009?3,?,?:?,7:1

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

(50) Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . 472 . <@,9?4?D:11=0423??=,114.49?3,?,=0,&30A034.70>?D;0>.:9>4/0=0/1:==0423?&=,9>;:=?,=024A0949?3042  &30>070.?0/7:.,?4:9>1:=?34>>@=A0D,=024A0949&,-70 &30>07:.,?4:9>3,A0-009>070.?0/.:9>4/0=4928,=60? ,=0,>,9/>3:;;492,=0,>&3020:2=,;34.7:.,?4:9>:1?30>0;:49?>,=0>3:B94942  /67A: .:A:8I:9'D86I>DCHIDDC9J8I!D86A+D>CI.JGK:N>C:A=>=DJGH )6B:D;I=:!D86A+D>CI. )6IJG:D;'6C90H:

(51) JH>C:HH8I>K>IN. .6BEA:.>O:D;!G:><=I 1:=>8A:H$CI:GK>:L:9. . )D. !+D9:. . !+ . O69EJG.67O>(6C9>. !GJ>I1:<:I67A:.  . . !+ . *@=A6.67O>(6C9>. !GJ>I1:<:I67A:.  . . !+ . GN6+JG6.67O>(6C9>. !GJ>I1:<:I67A:.  . . !+ . "=6CI6"=6G.67O>(6C9>. !GJ>I1:<:I67A:. . . !+ . *A9:A=>.67O>(6C9>. !GJ>I1:<:I67A:. . . !+ . .=6=96G6.67O>(6C9>. !GJ>I1:<:I67A:. . . !+ . (6C96L6A>.67O>(6C9>. !GJ>I1:<:I67A:.  . . !+ . .=6=96G6. !GJ>I1:<:I67A: !DD9"G6>CH !D99:G. . . !+ . "6O>EJG. !>H=+DJAIGN. .  . !+  . DCC6J<=I+A68:. -:I6>A.=DEE>C<6G:6H.  . . !+ . =6C9C>=DL@ . -:I6>A

(52) 2=DA:.6A:.=DEE>C<6G:6H.  . . !+ . .6GD?>C>)6<6G. -:I6>A

(53) 2=DA:.6A:.=DEE>C<6G:6H.  . . !+ . '6?E6I)6<6G. -:I6>A

(54) 2=DA:.6A:.=DEE>C<6G:6H.  . . !+ . +>I6BEJG6. -:I6>A

(55) 2=DA:.6A:.=DEE>C<6G:6H. . . !+ . ):=GJ+A68:. -:I6>A

(56) 2=DA:.6A:.=DEE>C<6G:6H. . !+ . "6C9=>)6<6G. 2=DA:.6A:.=DEE>C<6G:6H.    . . !+ . -6?DJG>"6G9:C. -:I6>A

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

(58) ,'/2&. 5$)),&"2/80(859(< 9:=/0=?:,>>0>>?30.@==09??=,114.A:7@80>4?@,?4:9:9?30=:,/90?B:=6:10734.7,>>4140/?=,114.A:7@80.:@9? >@=A0D> ,? 14A0 7:.,?4:9> 3,> -009 ;=:;:>0/ ,9/ ?304= 20:2=,;34. 7:.,?4:9> ,=0 >3:B9 49 42  &30>0 >070.?0/ 7:.,?4:9>:94/-7:.6?=,114.A:7@80.:@9?7:.,?4:9>,=0  $492$:,/$,523,?  :99,@23? "7,.0!@?0=4=.70

(59) 

(60) $492$:,/ ,=,49,  &!=4/20,9/  D;,>>.

(61) . Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–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

(62)    . 4.!(&&+&01 . . .  . 

(63)  .  

(64) .   .   .  . .  .  .  .  .  . . .  . 

(65)  .  

(66) . .   .

(67) .   . .  . 

(68)  .  

(69) .   .   .  . .  .  .  .  .  . . .  . 

(70)  .  

(71) .   .   .  . . . .

(72) . . 

(73) .  . . )&1&+. . 

(74) . 03$*1 32.   1  )$*1("4 31&1   . &20&.+. . . .

(75) . .

(76) . .2"+0"'')$ .+3,& &()$+&1.  1 32.)$*1("4 ..%1 &( 31&1 4.!(&&+&01 "01. . . .2"+0"'')$ .+3,& &()$+&1. &30 .:770.?0/ ?=,114. /,?, 3,> -009 ,9,7D>0/ 49 ?0=8> :1 3:@=7D A034.@7,= ?=,114. /4>?=4-@?4:9 ,9/ ?=,114. .:8;:>4?4:91:=,77?307:.,?4:9>,9/,?D;4.,73:@=7D/4>?=4-@?4:9:1?=,114.A:7@80,9/?=,114..:8;:>4?4:9,?$,5:6=4 :=/0= :90734@=2:,9C;=0>>B,D4>>3:B94942

(77) =:8?3042

(78) 4?.,9-0>009?3,??30?:?,7/,47D A:7@80 3:@=>09?0=492,9/0C4?4920734?3=:@23$,5:6=4:=/0=4>49?30:=/0=:1

(79)  ?3:@>,9/>,9/?30;0,6 3:@=4>:..@==49249?300A09492-0?B009  ,9/  =>B4?3,;0,6A:7@80:1,-:@? ?3:@>,9/>?.,9,7>: -04910==0/1=:8?30,9,7D>4>?3,?,-:@?,=0.:9>4>?492:1;=4A,?0A034.70>8,497D.,=>,9/?B:B30070=>&30 1=0423??=,9>;:=?4>,-:@? 8,497D.:9>4>?:1::/>@?:>&&,9/& 0"'')$ .+3,&#5 &()$+&5/& 0"'')$ .+3,&#53&+5/& 0"'')$.,/.1)2).        "01 . ),&. .2"+")+5 .3+,&

(80)  . !><  #DJGAN>HIG>7JI>DCD;A6HH>;>:9/G6;;>81DAJB:6C9/G6;;>8DBEDH>I>DC6I-6?D@G>DG9:G:A=> "JG<D6C MEG:HHL6N. &30>@88,=D:1,77?30 :@?0=.:=/:97:.,?4:9>4>;=0>09?0/49&,-70

(81) ,9/?=,114..:8;:>4?4:94>;=0>09?0/49 42 =:8?30&,-70

(82) 4?.,9-0:->0=A0/?3,?8,C48@89@8-0=:1A034.70>49?30:=/0=:1,-:@?

(83)  ?3:@>,9/> 09?0=492,9/0C4?492?3=:@23$,5:6=4:=/0=1:77:B0/-D3,E4;@=:=/0=B4?3,909?=D0C4?A:7@80:1,-:@? 

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

(85)  ;0= ,99@8 ? .,9 ,7>: -0 9:?4.0/ ?3,? ?30 2::/> ?=,114. 1:=8> ,-:@?  :1 ?30 ?:?,7 ?=,114. B4?3 ,9:?30=  :1 ?=,114. 4> .:8;:>0/ :1 >7:B 8:A492 A034.70> %( 7460 -4.D.70 ,948,7 .,=?> 0?. &30 ;,??0=9 :1 0C?0=9,71=0423??=,114.49?30.4?D:9,9:=8,7B:=6492/,D,7:92B4?3?304=.:8;:>4?4:9B,>0>?48,?0/,9/>3:B949 42&30=0>@7?>=0A0,7?3,?,?:?,7:1,-:@? &3:@>,9/>1=0423?A034.70>09?0=,9/70,A00734.4?D:99:=8,7.

(86) Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . 474 . B:=6492/,D,9/,-:@? :1?30>01=0423?A034.70>,=01:@9/?:-0;,>>492?3=:@23?30.4?DB34.3B,>,7>:,78:>? >,8049?30D0,= $$  /67A: .JBB6GND;A6HH>;>:9/G6;;>81DAJB:=DJGH6I>;;:G:CI*JI:GDG9DCHD;:A=> . )D. *JI:GDG9DC. 6GH. JID. JH:H. /2. ""1. '/. #/. (/. .(1. /DI6A.   .   .    .   .   .   .   .    .    . . 696GEJGDG9:G.    . . G?JC"6G=N6 )6<6GDG9:G.   .   .   .    .   .   .   .    .   .   . . -6?D@6G>DG9:G.   .   .   .   .   .   .  .   .   .    . . />@G>DG9:G.   .   .   .  .   .   .    .    .   .   . . .>C<=JDG9:G.   .  .  .   .    .    .   .   .    .    . . 'DC>DG9:G.   .    .   .    .   .   .   .   .   .   . . EH6G6DG9:G >AH=69"6G9:C.    .    .    .    .    .   .   .   .   .   . . "=6O>EJGDG9:G.   .   .   .   .   .   .   .   .   .   . . =>AA6D6G9:G.    .   .   .    .    .   .   .    .    .    .  . &6A>C9>&JC? DG9:G.    .   .   .   .   .   .    .   .   .   . /DI6A.    .   .    .    .   .   .   .   .   .   . .          . .,-7 311+5).(0 $58)/6$  33*6873 33*6%(2 %  $:3&-++0+5 . .2.86   86+6 873 . . $:3;0+ $58)/6$ . 807.;0+ $58)/6$ . .,(56. . <)0+' <)0+  ".)/6-(:6(2* 7-+5' #%. . #1(00(56

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

(88) . Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . . 475 . )" !+)" !)+)"*+"*"&+!)&

(89) ) 5(,*+7 5$)),&"2/80($72&$/2,176 &30 .:770.?0/ 1=0423? ?=,114. /,?, 3,> -009 ,9,7D>0/ 49 ?0=8> :1 3:@=7D A034.@7,= ?=,114. /4>?=4-@?4:9 ,9/ ?=,114. .:8;:>4?4:9,?,77?307:.,?4:9>?D;4.,73:@=7D/4>?=4-@?4:9:1?=,114.A:7@80,9/?=,114..:8;:>4?4:9,?E,/;@=  Exit Exit Entry Entry   472,852 550,841 (in 2009) (in 2009)     Passing Through    Average Growth 3%  per annum  GAV LCV 28% 23%.  . 

(90)     .  .  . 

(91)         .       .  . GAV 23%. HAV 26%. MAV 23%. MAV 26%. LCV 24%. HAV 27%.       . MAV 18%. GAV 14%. LCV 19%. HAV 49%. 6/DI6A/G6;;>8 . . . . 7!G:><=I/G6;;>8. !><  +6II:GCD;/DI6A MI:GC6A/G6;;>86I*JI:GDG9DCHD;:A=>. !+(/385%3081+!+(/385

(92)    . 

(93)  .   .  . .  . . . 

(94)  .   .  . . .              

(95)  

(96)                         

(97)  

(98)    . +/(-##&  +(0)" "%& (".. +/(-##&  +(0)" "%& (".. %,-E4,9/44>>3:B94942=:8?30424?.,9-0:->0=A0/?3,??30?:?,7/,47DA:7@80 3:@=>09?0=492 ,9/0C4?492E,/;@=%,-E4,9/44>49?30:=/0=:1,-:@??3:@>,9/>,9/?30;0,63:@=4>:..@==49249?3084/9423? -0?B009

(99)   ,9/   => B4?3 , ;0,6 A:7@80 :1 ,-:@?  1=0423? A034.70> =:8 ?30 42  4? .,9 ,7>: -0 4910==0/?3,?,-:@? ,=0.:9>4>?492:1::/>@?:>,9/::/>(,9>&4>,-:@?

(100) ,9/&,9/&,=0  0,.3?.,9,7>:-0:->0=A0/?3,?%7:B:A492(034.70>%(>,=0,-:@?  -"&$%/-##& +(0)"3"%& ("3," -"&$%/-##& +(0)"30"(3," -"&$%/-##& +),+.&/&+*   ++!.

(101)  ++!. 0(/&2("-0 '.  * &"."( 1+2("-0 '. &$%/-0 '. 

(102)   0(/& ++!.  ++!.0/+ ++!.*   2("   .  -0 '. ++!..    0/+           &$%/   1+ -0 '. 2("     -0 '.       &)" &)" +/(&(3+0()".

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

(104) Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–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

(105)  33*6873

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

(107) . Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . . 477 . 03$*1

(108) .  1 . "01

(109) .  . .  . 

(110)  .  

(111) .   .   .  . .  .  .  .  .  . . . .  . . 

(112)  . .  . 

(113)  .  

(114) .   .   .  . .  .  .  .  .  . . .  . 

(115)  .  

(116) .   .   .  . . . . . .  

(117) . . .   . .  . 32. 31&1)$*1("4

(118)  . .  .   . . )&1&+.  .  . . &20&.+.  . .  . . .  . .  . .2"+0"'')$ .+3,& &()$+&1.  1 32.)$*1("4 ..%1 &( 31&1 4.!(&&+&01 "01. . . .2"+0"'')$ .+3,& &()$+&1.   ,=0 .:9>4>?492 :1 ;=4A,?0 A034.70> 8,497D .,=> ,9/ ?B: B30070=> &30 1=0423? ?=,9>;:=? 4> ,-:@?  8,497D .:9>4>?:1::/>@?:>&&,9/&&30>@88,=D:1?=,114.:9,77?3084/-7:.67:.,?4:9>4>;=0>09?0/49&,-70 ,9/?=,114..:8;:>4?4:94>;=0>09?0/4942=:8?30424?.,9-04910==0/?3,?,-:@? ,=0.:9>4>?492:1 ;=4A,?0A034.70>8,497D.,=>,9/?B:B30070=>&301=0423??=,9>;:=?4>,-:@?8,497D.:9>4>?:1::/>@?:>& &,9/& 0"'')$ .+3,&#5 &()$+&5/& 0"'')$ .+3,&#53&+5/& 0"'')$.,/.1)2).        4.!(&&+&01 . ),&. ),&. !+(/385%3081+  !+(/385    . .2"+")+5 .3+,& . !><  #DJGAN>HIG>7JI>DCD;A6HH>;>:9/G6;;>81DAJB:6C9/G6;;>8DBEDH>I>DC6I)6G6>C6DC->C<-D69 /67A: .JBB6GND;A6HH>;>:9/G6;;>81DAJB:=DJGH6I>;;:G:CI(>9AD8@'D86I>DCHD;:A=> . )D. (>9 AD8@. 6GH. JID. JH:H. /2. ""1. '/. #/. (/. .(1. /DI6A. . ->C<-D69 -6?<=6I.   .    .   .    .   .  .   .   .    .    . . DCC6J<=I+A68: -:<6A>C:B6.   .   .   .   .   .    .   .   .    .   . . ->C<-D69 )6G6>C6.   .   .    .   .    .    .   .  .   .   . . $/*G>9<:.   .   .   .   .   .   .   .   .   .   . . )# NE6HH.   .   .  .   .   .    .  .   .   .    .          . 33*6873 33*6%(2 %  $:3&-++0+5 . .,-7 311+5).(0 $58)/6$ . .2.86  86+6 . $:3;0+ $58)/6$ . 873. . 807.;0+ $58)/6$. . <)0+'.  <)0+ ".)/6-(:6(2* 7-+5' #% . .,(56. . #1(00(56 . !><  /G6;;>8DBEDH>I>DC6I>;;:G:CI(>9AD8@'D86I>DCHD;:A=>. )" !+!",$)&)-$ !)+)"*+"*. *(,675,%87,21 ?:?,7:1

(119)  1=0423?A034.70>,? :@?0=.:=/:97:.,?4:9>,9/   1=0423?A034.70>,? 1:.,7;:49?>B4?349 .4?D B0=0 49?0=.0;?0/ ,9/ 49?0=A40B0/ &3=:@23 ?30 =:,/>4/0 49?0=A40B> ,20 :1 ?30 A034.70> B0=0 =0.:=/0/ ,7:92 B4?3 :?30= 48;:=?,9? ?=,A07 .3,=,.?0=4>?4.> ,9/ ,9,7D>0/ 1:= ,77 ?30 >,8;70/ A034.70> =:8 ?30 8:/07 D0,= 8,9@1,.?@=492 :1 A034.70 /,?, ?30 ,20 :1 A034.70 3,> -009 /0?0=8490/ ,9/ ,20 /4>?=4-@?4:9 4> /0A07:;0/ 1:= /4110=09?1=0423?A034.70?D;0>,?:@?0=.:=/:9>,9/B4?349.4?D42 ;=0>09??30/4>?=4-@?4:9:1A034.70>,>;0=?30.

(120) Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . 478 .  .

(121) .  

(122) . . . 

(123)   .  .

(124) .  

(125) . . .  .

(126) .  

(127) . . .  .

(128) .  

(129) . . . 

(130)   . 

(131)   .  .

(132) .  

(133) . . . 

(134)   . 

(135)   . D0,=:18,9@1,.?@=0,>:-?,490/,?:@?0=.:=/:9;:49?>,9/1:.,7;:49?>=:8?3042 4?.,9-01:@9/?3,??30 80,9,20:11=0423?A034.70>4>,78:>?>,80,?:@?0=.:=/:9>,9/B4?349?30.4?DA,=D492-0?B009 ,9/ D0,=> ,9/?30>3,=0:1 D0,=,9/8:=0:7/A034.70>B4?349?30.4?D4>=,924921=:8 ?:,9/?:,?:@?0=.:=/:9> ,>>3:B949&,-70     

(136)     (:6C<: (:6C<:  !  3:6GH !  3:6GH .     3:6GH    3:6GH. . . . .     

(137)  

(138)                  (:6C<: (:6C<: (:6C<:  !  3:6GH !  3:6GH !  3:6GH.       3:6GH    3:6GH   3:6GH. . .   .    

(139)  

(140)  

(141)  !><  <:>HIG>7JI>DCD;>;;:G:CI!G:><=I1:=>8A:H6I*JI:GDG9DCH6C9!D86A+D>CIHL>I=>C>IN>C:A=> /67A: .=6G:D; 3:6G6C9(DG:*A91:=>8A:HL>I=>CI=:>IN6C96I*JI:GDG9DCH . )D    . 'D86I>DC *JI:GDG9DCH 2>I=>CI=:>IN. <:. '/. #/. (/. ". "1.   3:6GH.          . (DG:/=6C 3:6GH.  .   3:6GH.          . (DG:/=6C 3:6GH.  .    .    .    .    . 8(/!6(' 9 .,>0 :1 1=0423? A034.70> ?B: ?D;0> :1 1@07> ,=0 8,497D @>0/ &30D ,=0 40>07 ,9/ :8;=0>>0/ ,?@=,7 ,>  &301@07@>,20/4>?=4-@?4:9:1/4110=09?1=0423?A034.70>,?:@?0=.:=/:9>,9/B4?349?30.4?D4>>3:B94942. =:842. 4?.,9-0>009?3,?0,AD(034.70>8:>?7D@>040>07B30=0,>::/>@?:,9/::/>(,9,78:>? @>0 ,>1@079.,>0:1&,-:@? ,9/@>040>07,>1@07,?:@?0=.:=/:9>,9/B4?349.4?D=0>;0.?4A07D. :1(56+,32)5(,*+7"(+,&/( &30:B90=>34;:1/4110=09?1=0423?A034.70>,?:@?0=.:=/:9>,9/B4?349?30.4?D3,>-009,9,7D>0/,9/>3:B949 42 =:8?3042 4?.,9-0>009?3,?;=4A,?0.:8;,9DA034.70>,=0342349.,>0:130,ADA034.70>&,9/.

(142) . Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . . 479 . &,?:@?0=.:=/:9>,9/B4?349?30.4?D&30;=4A,?0A034.70>3,=04>,78:>?>,801:=7423?A034.70>&,9/ (B4?349?30.4?DB30=0,>4?4>34230=,?:@?0=.:=/:9>   

(143)   . .                     $ $ $(2/+5 $  % $ $ $  %             .+6+0  .+6+0  !><  !J:A0H6<:<:>HIG>7JI>DCD;!G:><=I1:=>8A:H6I*JI:GDG9DCH6C9L>I=>CI=:>IND;:A=>.         .  

(144) . .  .  .  . . . . . . $. $. !+5632(0.5+*. $(2/+5. . .  . $.      !97314(2<. . % 397. . $ !+5632(0.5+*. $. $. .      !97314(2<. % 397. !><  *LC:GH=>E>HIG>7JI>DCD;!G:><=I1:=>8A:H6I*JI:GDG9DCH6C9L>I=>CI=:>IND;:A=>.  8(/)),&,(1&<. 

(145)   

(146)  . &308470,201@070114.409.D49?0=8>:16874?=0/,?,:1/4110=09?1=0423?A034.70>3,>-009,9,7D>0/,9/>3:B9 49 42

(147)  =:8 ?30 42

(148)  4? .,9 -0 :->0=A0/ ?3,? 7423? A034.70> &  ,9/ ( 3,A0 34230= 1@07 0114.409.D B34.3,=08:>?7D=@9:9 0,AD1=0423?A034.70>3,A01@070114.409.D,-:@?,9/ 6874?=01:=&,9/& =0>;0.?4A07D423?A034.70>9,807D&3,>,-:@?. 6874?=0B30=0,>,9/(3,>8:=0?3,9 6874?=0            .    .    .         !  

(149)   

(150) 

(151)  

(152) 

(153)  !><  !J:A ;;>8>:C8ND;>;;:G:CI!G:><=I1:=>8A:H.  ,67$1&( 5$9(//(' &30/4>?,9.0?=,A0770//,?,49?0=8>:168?=4;6849>4/0.4?D,9/68/,D:1/4110=09?1=0423?A034.70>3,>-009 ,9,7D>0/,9/>3:B94942 =:8?3042 4?.,9-0:->0=A0/?3,?,A0=,20?=4;/4>?,9.0:1&4>,-:@? 68 ,9/ 1:= & 4? 4> ,-:@?.  68 B30=0,> A034.70 ?D;0 & 3,> ,-:@?   68 ,9/ >8,770= A034.70> ,=0 3,A492 , ?=4;.

(154) Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . 480 .        

(155)  

(156) .      .        

(157)  . /4>?,9.0:1,-:@? 6877?30>0A034.70?D;0>?=,A07>,-:@?  68B4?349?30.4?D9/4?.,9,7>:-0:->0=A0/ ?3,??308,C48@8,A0=,20/4>?,9.0?=,A0770/49,/,D-D?30>0A034.70?D;0>4>,-:@? 68&34>.70,=7D49/4.,?0 ?3,??30>01=0423?A034.70>1,.07:?:1.:920>?4:9,9/:?30=;=:-708>?:?=,A078:=0/4>?,9.0>49,/,D0C;0=409.492 7:?:1/07,D>,9/49.=0,>0/:;0=,?492.:>?>            

(158)   

(159)     . .  . .

(160).  . . .     . $ $ $(2/+5 $  % $ $ $(2/+5 $  %                     

(161)    

(162) . .  .

(163) . .  .    . $ $ $(2/+5 $  %       !><  >HI6C8:/G6K:AA:97N>;;:G:CI!G:><=I1:=>8A:H.  5(48(1&<2) 5,36 &301=0<@09.D:1?=4;>/,?,:1/4110=09?1=0423?A034.70>3,>-009,9,7D>0/,9/>3:B94942 =:8?3042  4?.,9-0:->0=A0/?3,?423?(034.70>,=03,A4928:=0/,47D?=4;>,9/0,AD(034.70>,=08:=049!..,>4:9,7?=4;>   

(164)  . .                       $ $ $  % $ $ $  %            )(66.32(00< &++/0< $5.&++/0< .&++/0< (.0< )(66.32(00< &++/0< $5.&++/0< .&++/0< (.0<  !><  !G:FJ:C8N>HIG>7JI>DCD;!G:><=I1:=>8A:H6I*JI:GDG9DCH6C9L>I=>CI=:>IND;:A=>. 

(165) #(,*+7$55,(' &30B0423?.,==40/-D/4110=09?1=0423?A034.70>3,>-009,9,7D>0/,9/>3:B94942 =:8?3042 4?.,9 -0 :->0=A0/ ?3,? & (034.70> ,=0 .,==D492 ,A0=,20 B0423? 8:=0 ?3,9

(166)  ?:990 B30=0 ,> & A034.70 4> .,==D492 ,A0=,207:,/>:1?:990&30&4>.,==D492,A0=,20B0423?,-:@? ?:990,9/>8,770=A034.70>7460,9/( ,=0.,==D49270>>?3,9,?:990@=?30=,9,9,7D>4>3,>-009.,==40/:@??:,>>0>>?30>3,=0:108;?DA034.70>,9/?30 =0>@7?4>,7>:;=0>09?0/4942 =:842 4?.,9-0>009?3,??30  A034.70>,=0=@9949208;?D:9?30 =:,/90?B:=6:10734@=?30=?30?:?,7B0423?.,==40/-D?30>01=0423?A034.70>:9?3009?4=0=:,/90?B:=6:10734 3,> -009 0>?48,?0/ 1=:8 ,A0=,20 /4>?,9.0 ?=,A0770/ ,9/ B0423? .,==40/ 49 , /,D B34.3 .:80> ?: -0 ,-:@?    4774:90?=4.&:990&;0=/,D.

(167) Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . . # "    .   .  .          . 

(168)  .     '/.  #/ (/ "   .  "1. 481 .   "$!.        . BEIN.  . 'D69:9. . '/. #/ (/ "   . "1. !>< K:G6<:2:><=I6GG>:96C9.=6G:D; BEIN1:=>8A:H>C>;;:G:CI!G:><=I1:=>8A:H.  $77(512) 27$/5(,*+7 5,36 9?30;=0>09?>?@/D?30?:?,7?=4;>3,A0-0090>?48,?0/1=:8,77?30E:90>B34.3,=049?30:=/0=:1,-:@?  ?3:@>,9/>:11=0423??=4;>2090=,?0//,47D49?30.4?D:10734&30.:8;,=4>:9:1?:?,71=0423??=4;>,=08,/0B4?3 ;,>>0920=?=4;>49:=/0=?:@9/0=>?,9/?30>3,=0:11=0423??=4;>49?30.4?D:10734,9/>3:B949?3042 ,=:8 ?3042 4?.,9-0:->0=A0/?3,??30>3,=0:11=0423??=4;>4>:97D,-:@?

(169) B34.34>A0=D49>429414.,9?3:B0A0=4? 4>2:492?:4917@09.03@2049?=,114..:920>?4:9,4=;:77@?4:9,9/=:,/>,10?D=07,?0/4>>@0>:1?30.4?D:10734&30 ;,??0=9:1?:?,71=0423??=4;>,=0.7,>>4140/@9/0=1:@=.,?02:=40>&30D,=0  C?0=9,7C?0=9,7  C?0=9,79?0=9,7  9?0=9,7?:C?0=9,7  9?0=9,79?0=9,7 ..:=/4927D?301=0423??=4;>,=0,9,7D>0/,9/=0>@7?>,=0>3:B94942 -=:8?3042 -4?.,9-0>009 ?3,? ?30 8,5:=4?D :1 1=0423? ?=4;> ,=0 9?0=9,7  9?0=9,7 B34.3 4> ,78:>?   &30 9?0=9,7C?0=9,7 ,9/ C?0=9,7 9?0=9,7,=0,78:>?>,80,-:@?0,.3,9/C?0=9,7C?0=9,7?=4;>;,>>492?3=:@23,=0,-:@?    #"" 

(170) " " ! . !G:><=I. $    /G>EH $.       +6HH:C<:G  $ $ /G>EH     . % ,%4)2*4)-+,6!4-35-1!26%/!4-35. . . &%66)412*4)-+,6!4-35. !>< .=6G:6C9+6II:GCD;!G:><=I/G>EH>C:A=>. &30 8:/,7 >;74? :1 ?30>0 1=0423? ?=4;> 3,> -009 ,9,7D>0/ ,9/ ;=0>09?0/ 49 42  =:8 ?30 42  4? .,9 -0 :->0=A0/?3,?30,AD1=0423?A034.70>3,=04>,-:@? 49.,>0 :1&=4;>,-:@?

(171) 49.,>0:1&=4;>,-:@? 

(172) 49.,>0:1&=4;>,9/,-:@? 49.,>0:1&=4;>9?30;=0>09?>?@/D1:=0.,>?492:1?301=0423??=4;>,=0 ,7>:.,==40/:@?-,>0/:9?30/0A07:;0/1=0423??=,A07/08,9/8:/07$$&'071?& ! ,9/4?B,>1:@9/ ?3,??30?:?,71=0423??=4;>,=02:492?:-0,=:@9/ ?3:@>,9/>49?30D0,= B4?3,2=:B?3=,?0:1 ;0=,99@8    .

(173) Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 66'25'11/+8'1$6'375468'8/43"+7+'6).!64)+*/'   ? . 482 .                    .   #

(174) " "1 .   #

(175) ". '/ . "1 . " . '/ . "  #/ /6C@:G  . (/  . (/ .   #

(176) " "  . "1 . #/ .   #

(177) " " . '/ . (/ /6C@:G  . /6C@:G . (/ . #/ . "1 . '/ . #/ . /6C@:G . !><  !G:><=I(D96A.EA>I;DG>;;:G:CI/NE:HD;/G>EH>C:A=>. 67,0$7,212) 5$)),&2$'6217+(2$'(7:25.. . .  .  .  .  .  .  .  . 9 ,9/ $$3,>.:9/@.?0/,>?@/D?:0>?48,?0?=,114.7:,/>49?0=8>:1A034.70647:80?0=>?=,A0770/ (&:9?30=:,/90?B:=6:10734,9/,..:=/4927D;=:50.?0/1:=?30D0,=> ,9/ $$ '?474>492 ?34>/,?,?30;=:50.?4:9>3,A0-0098,/01=:8?302=:B?31,.?:=>1:=,77?30A034.70?D;0>&300>?48,?0/(&1:= ,9/1:=0.,>?0/(&1:=?30D0,= ,=0;=0>09?0/4942 =:8?3042 4?.,9-0:->0=A0/?3,??30 0>?48,?0/?:?,7?=,114.7:,/>49?0=8>:1(&,=0,-:@? 4774:9>,9/

(178) 4774:9>49 ,9/ =0>;0.?4A07D &30(&-D1=0423?A034.70>,=02:492?:-0,-:@? 4774:9,9/

(179) 4774:9>49 ,9/ =0>;0.?4A07DB34.3 4>3,A492,>3,=0:1,-:@? &302=:B?3:1?:?,7(&4>49.=0,>492B4?3;0=,99@82=:B?3B30=0,>1=0423? A034.70>2=:B?34>,-:@?;0=,99@8       6GH   /LD2=::A:GH  JIDH    "DD9H1:=>8A:H    JH:H     /DI6A             .                78/2'8+*/3!6+7+38#89*= !><   HI>B6I:91:=>8A:&>ADB:I:GH/G6K:AA:9

(180) 6N;DG9>;;:G:CI1:=>8A:/NE:H;DG>;;:G:CI3:6GH.

(181) . Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–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

(182) @B5. K6>A67>A>IND;>CI:GBD96AIG6CHEDGI688:HH. )D D;>CI:GBD96A=J7H688DG9>C<IDINE:G6>A >CA6C9L6I:GL6N 6>G45. DHID;8DC<:HI>DC. K:G6<:8DC<:HI>DC9:A6N4K:= =DJGH

(183) N:6G5. -D69FJ6A>IN. +:G8:CI6<:D;GD69JC9:G<D>C<B6>CI:C6C8:E:GN:6G45. !>C6C8>6A=:6AI=. /G6CHEDGI7J9<:I4-+5. 8DCDB>8 Q ':K:AD;H:GK>8:;DGGD69H AD<>HI>8H -:A>67>A>IND;IG6K:AI>B: H:GK>8:FJ6A>IN DHIHD;IG6CHEDGIH:GK>8:H

(184) /DI6A8DHIHD;9:A>K:GN 88:HH>7>A>IN;DG;G:><=IK:=>8A:H CK>GDCB:CI6A "G::C=DJH:<6HH:H C:G<N:;;>8>:C8N. .D8>6A. +6G6B:I:G4JC>I5. (:6CHE::9D;;G:><=IK:=>8A:H4@B

(185) =5 IG>EH9:K>6I>C<;GDBB:6CIG6K:AI>B: (:6C8DHIH;>M:96C9GJCC>C<8DHIHE:G9:A>K:G>:H +:G8:CI6<:D;688:HH>7A:GD69HE:GK:=>8A:86I:<DGN45 2:AAIDL=::AH"#":B>HH>DCH;DG0!/4IDC *:F

(186) N:6G5 /DI6A:C:G<NJH:9688DG9>C<ID;G:><=IIG6;;>8KDAJB:4(%

(187) IDC @B5. >GEDAAJI>DC. /DI6A:B>HH>DCHD;6>GEDAAJI6CIH+( )*M4@<

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• !9,9:=8,7B:=6492/,D,?:?,7:1,-:@?  84774:9A034.70>09?0=,9/70,A00734.4?DB34.33,>2=:B9B4?3

(189) ;0=,99@8,-:@?  84774:9A034.70>49 &301=0423??=,114.1:=8>,-:@? :1?30?:?,7?=,114.B4?3 ,9:?30= :1?=,114.4>.:8;:>0/:1>7:B8:A492A034.70>7460-4.D.70.D.70=4.6>3,B>,948,7.,=?>0?. • ,C48@89@8-0=:1A034.70>49?30:=/0=:1,-:@?

(190)  ?3:@>,9/>09?0=492,9/0C4?492?3=:@23$,5:6=4:=/0= 1:77:B0/-D3,E4;@=:=/0=B4?3,909?=D0C4??=,114.A:7@80:1,-:@? 

(191) ?3:@>,9/>,9/,749/4@95:=/0= B4?3,909?=D0C4??=,114.A:7@80:1,-:@? ?3:@>,9/> • ?:?,7:1,-:@? &3:@>,9/1=0423?A034.70>09?0=,9/70,A00734.4?D:9,9:=8,7B:=6492/,D,9/,-:@?. :1?30>01=0423?A034.70>,=01:@9/?:-0;,>>492?3=:@23?30.4?DB34.3B,>,78:>?>,8049 &3:@23.

Cytaty

Pobierz teraz ( PDF - 20 Stron - 2.72 MB )

Powiązane dokumenty

"Szkice - Bohdan Zaleski, Adam Asnyk, Henryk Sienkiewicz", Marya Konopnicka, Lwów 1905 : [recenzja]

Ale p. Konopnicka nie jest historykiem literatury i studyum nau­ kowego nie zamierzała zapewne pisać — możnaby jej to więc wyba­ czyć, możnaby tylko

"Geschichte der Reformation in Polen", Theodor Wotschke, Leipzig 1911 : [recenzja]

Przesyłane mu sumy były podówczas będącymi w zwyczaju podarkami, jakie stale kanclerz lub podkanclerzy otrzymywali od osób prywatnych czy korporacyi

On the passage of a shock wave through dusty-gas layer

For a dusty-air layer of finite thickness, the reflected rarefaction wave interacts with the first contact region and reflects as a compression wave, which is

Efficient Algorithms for Network-Wide Road Traffic Control

intersections in order to improve the urban road network throughput. The proposed MPC strategy uses the LTM as the prediction model and aggregates the traffic flow dynamics to tens

Odpowiedź na replikę Jerzego Dowiata

C enne jest 'wyznanie, że autor zasygnalizow ał tylko zagad­ n ien ie i naszkicow ał nasuw ające się w nioski rezygnując z „szerszych rozm iarów aparatu

Widok Iwona Słomak, Retoryka miłosnej batalii „Wojsko serdecznych nowo rekrutowanych afektów” Hieronima Falęckiego, Warszawa 2017, ss. 247

Pracę cechuje mnogość wyliczeń, cytatów, przypisów, w których możemy znaleźć łacińską wersję przywoływanych przekładów dzieł. Dowodzi to dbałości o

Kamishibai, booktalking, storytelling…, czyli formy pracy z młodym czytelnikiem

Doświadczenia wielu książnic oraz wypracowane przez nie formy działania mogą stać się inspiracją dla osób, które chciałyby odpowiednio zagospodarować czas wolny dzieci

View of De martyrum in scriptis sancti Augustini cultu

Bo i który z biskupów stojąc przy ołta- rzu w miejscu poświęconym ciałem świętych powiedział: składamy ci w ofie- rze Piotrze, Pawle albo Cyprianie, lecz to, co się składa