Classification via spectral clustering

(1)

! " # $ % & ' ( ) * & " " & * # + , - . & ( % * & * # /,+& #,(!,%,0&! #1234#5616# !"#$%&' ()#&*+

**!"#$$%&%!#'%() *%# $+,!'-#" !".$',-%)/**

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

*789:;<=# 9=>?:8;@AB# @?# AD:# ?:;@9:=I# A8E# 7<;:@:@DA@AB# <=BD;@:HM# N>:# ;<:H8;# A8E# E<I# DG# 7;87<;@AB# F<:<# GD;# CADEA# 9=>?:8;@AB# M8:HDF?# ?>9H# <?# CSM8<A?L# -8?7@:8# :H@?#G<9:#?789:;<=#9=>?:8;@AB#OD;#9=>?:8;@AB#N<?8F#DA#?789:;<=#F89DM7D?@:@DAR#B@J8?# J8;I#7;DM@?@AB#;8?>=:#GD;#9=>?:8;#D:H8;#:H<A#B@J8A#NI#AD;M<=#F@?:;@N>:@DAL#&A#:H@?# 7<78;# <=BD;@:HM# DG# ?789:;<=# 9=>?:8;@AB# @?# F8?9;@N8F# O@A# MD?:# 7D7>=<;# GD;MR# <AF# ?DM8#8M7@;@9<=#;8?>=:#DG#>?8#DG#:H@?#M8:HDF#GD;#?:<AF<;F#<AF#ADAS?:<AF<;F#9=>?:8;# ?H<78?#<;8#B@J8A# /@;?:#9H<7:8;#7=<98?#?789:;<=#9=>?:8;@AB#<MDAB#D:H8;#9=>?:8;@AB#:89HA@K>8?L# *89DAF#7<;:#F8?9;@N8?#@A#F8:<@=?#9=>?:8;@AB#F89DM7D?@:@DA4#EH@9H#@?#:H8#H8<;:# DG#?789:;<=#9=>?:8;@AB#M8:HDF?L# T<;:# :H;88# :D# G@J8# F8?9;@N8?# ;8?>=:?# DG# 8M7@;@9<=# ?@M>=<:@DA?# @AJ8?:@B<:@AB# K><=@:I#DG#?789:;<=#9=>?:8;@AB#J?L#D:H8;#9=>?:8;@AB#:89HA@K>8?# @A#9<?8#DG#?:<AF<;F# <AF#ADAS?:<AF<;F#9=>?:8;#?H<78?4#@A#9<?8#DG#F<:<#E@:H#AD@?I#J<;@<N=8?#<AF#@A#9<?8# DG#F<:<#?8:#E@:H#ADM@A<=#F<:<L# /@A<==I#?DM8#9DA9=>?@DA?#<AF#;8M<;C?#<;8#B@J8A# # # %%6 $+,!'-#" !".$',-%)/ #$ +#-'%'%()%)/ #"/(-%'?@ # "H8;8#@?#N@B#A>MN8;#DG#CADEA#9=>?:8;@AB#<=BD;@:HM#N>:#G8E#DG#:H8M#<;8#MD?:# 7D7>=<;#O<AF#MD?:#E@F8=I#>?8F#NI#;8?8<;9H8;?RL## ################################################# U #THL-L4#!H<@;#DG#(9DADM8:;@9?#<AF#&AGD;M<:@9?4#$A@J8;?@:I#DG#(9DADM@9?4#V;D9W<EL#

(2)

155# Y@8;<;9H@9<=#<BB;8B<:@J8#9=>?:8;@AB#M8:HDF?#OZD;FDA#O1[[[R#7L#\[RR]# V<;F#H@8;<;9H@9<=#9=>?:8;@AB4## ?@AB=8#=@AC#H@8;<;9H@9<=#9=>?:8;@AB4# 9DM7=8:8#=@AC#H@8;<;9H@9<=#9=>?:8;@AB4# <J8;<B8#=@AC#H@8;<;9H@9<=#9=>?:8;@AB4# 09K>@::I#O1[^^R#H@8;<;9H@9<=#9=>?:8;@AB4# 98A:;D@F#H@8;<;9H@9<=#9=>?:8;@ABL# ,7:@M@X<:@DA#M8:HDF?]#

*SM8<A?# M8:HDF# E@:H# J<;@<A:?# =@C8# &?DF<:<# <=BD;@:HM4# H<;F# 9DM78:@:@J8# =8<;A@AB#D;#A8>;<=#B<?#O?DG:#9DM78:@:@J8#=8<;A@ABRL#

T<;:@:@DA@AB# <;D>AF# M8FD@F?4# <=?D# 9<==8F# *SM8FD@F?# M8:HDF# O_<>GM<A4# )D>??88>E#O1[[6RRL#

*@A98# :H8# 8AF# DG# :E8A:@8:H# 98A:>;I# :ED# A8E# N;<A9H8?# H<?# N88A# F8J8=D78F# K>@:8#G<?:]#

0DF8=#`#N<?8F#9=>?:8;@AB# *789:;<=#9=>?:8;@AB##

*789:;<=# 9=>?:8;@AB4# N<?8F# DA# ?789:;<=# F89DM7D?@:@DA# DG# F@?:<A98# M<:;@Q# # @?# AD:##@A#G<9:#A8E#M8:HDF#N>:#;<:H8;#A8E#E<I#DG#7;87<;@AB#F<:<#GD;#a9=<??@9<=b#CS M8<A?# 7;D98F>;84# N>:# 8M7@;@9<=# ;8?>=:?# GD;# F@GG8;8A:# 9=>?:8;# ?H<78?# <;8# J8;I# 7;DM@?@AB# <AF# :H@?# aN;<A9Hb# DG# 9=>?:8;@AB# @?# ED;:H# ?87<;<:8# ?:>F@8?L# /D;# >AF8;?:<AF@AB#:H8#@F8<#DG#?789:;<=#M8:HDF?#DA8#?HD>=F#?:<;:#E@:H#:H8#F8?9;@7:@DA# DG#F89DM7D?@:@DA#M8A:@DA8F#<NDJ8L# # # %%%6 $+,!'-#" >,!(@+($%'%() #

*789:;<=# F89DM7D?@:@DA# <=BD;@:HM# <99D;F@AB# :D# JDA# +>QN>;B# O566^R# <AF# %BL&, -./#O5661R#9<A#N8#?:<:8F#@A#B8A8;<=#GD;M#@A#:H8#GD==DE@AB#E<I]#

+8:#A#M8<A?#F<:<#M<:;@Q#E@:H#"#;DE?#<AF##0#9D=>MA?#4#)#`#A>MN8;#DG#9=>?:8;# :D# F@J@F8# A# OB@J8A# NI# ;8?8<;9H8;# N8GD;8# ?:<;:# DG# F89DM7D?@:@DAR# L# *<M7=8# @A7>:# F<:<# @?# 7;8?8A:8F# DA# G@B>;8# 1L# %8Q:# G@B>;8?# E@==# N8# ?HDE@AB# :H8# ?<M8# F<:<# @A# :;<A?GD;M8F#?7<98L#

(3)

!=<??@G@9<:@DA#'@<#*789:;<=#!=>?:8;@AB# _152# /@B>;8#1L#&A7>:#F<:<#N8GD;8#?789:;<=#F89DM7D?@:@DAL# # *D>;98]#,EA#;8?8<;9H#E@:H#>?8#DG#0.1&"23#-#=@N;<;IL# # +8:#> #N8#?@M@=<;@:I#M<:;@Q#DG#DNP89:?#G;DM# LA # > #9<A#N8#9<=9>=<:8F#@A#M<AI# E<I?#N>:#MD?:#DG:8A#@:?#8=8M8A:?## #<;8#F8G@8F#<99D;F@AB#:D#O1R#_4' # # # ! " 5 1 5 #

$

% & & % 0 * '* 4* 5 5 4' & # # O1R# # EH8;8]#5`#?9<=@AB#7<;<M8:8;L#0D?:#DG:8A#@:?#9<=9>=<:8F#<99D;F@AB#:D#%B4#cD;F<A# <AF#V8@??#<=BD;@:HM#DG#@:8;<:@DA<=#9HDD?@AB#DG##54#M@A@M<=@X@AB#:H8#@AA8;#9=<??# F@?:<A98?# DG# ;<AFDM# ?>N?8:# DG# A # ]# A' L# O:H@?# M8:HDF# ;8K>@;8?# 7;D988F@AB?# DG# <77;DQ@M<:8=I#G8E#H>AF;8F?#9=>?:8;@AB#7;D98F>;8?#DG#DNP89:?#DG# A' RL#

/D;# > #E8@BH:?#M<:;@Q B #@?#9DA?:;>9:8F#F>8#:D#O5R# # #

(4)

15d# # # ( ) ( * + , % %

$

_% ' 4 ' 4 # 6 " ' 4' 4' BFI 6 BFI 1 # O5R# # EH8;8]#B%f6_4'e#`#E8@BH:?#M<:;@Q4# <AF#+<7=<9@<A#

"

#<99D;F@AB#:D#O2R# # # # C D C D B > B

"% & - - & # O2R#

#

&A# B;<7H# :H8D;I#" #@?#:;8<:8F#<?#<=B8N;<@9<=#;87;8?8A:<:@DA#DG#B;<7H#9;8<:8F# G;DM#DNP89:?#DG# A # # # /@B>;8#5L#-<:<#@A#:;<A?GD;M8F#?7<98# *D>;98]#,EA#;8?8<;9H#E@:H#>?8#DG#0.1&"23#-#=@N;<;IL# # /@;?:#) #8@B8AJ89:D;?#DG#+<7=<9@<A# " 9;8<:8?# , # M<:;@QL#(<9H#8@B8AJ89:D;#@?# :;8<:8F#<?#9D=>MA#DG#, #O:H>?# , #M<#H<?#F@M8A?@DA?#" - RL#"H8#M<@A#<@M#DG#:H@?#) ?:87#@?#:D#E@F8A#F<:<#@A#:;<A?GD;M8F#?7<98#O?88#G@B>;8#5R#

(5)

!=<??@G@9<:@DA#'@<#*789:;<=#!=>?:8;@AB# _153#

,7:@DA<=#M<:;@Q#, #@?#<#;8?>=:#DG#AD;M<=@X<:@DA#DG# , F>8#:D#OdRL#"H@?#?:87#@?#g A<;;DE@AB#F<:<#@A#:;<A?GD;M8F#?7<98#O@:#9<A#N8#DN?8;J8F#DA#G@B>;8#2R# # # #

$

% % " * *' 4' 4' 7 7 7 1 5 g _# _OdR# # /@B>;8#2L#-<:<#@A#:;<A?GD;M8F#?7<98#<G:8;#AD;M<=@X<:@DA#?:87L# *D>;98]#,EA#;8?8<;9H#E@:H#>?8#DG#0.1&"23#-#=@N;<;IL# #

&A#=<?:#?:<B8#, OD;# , @G#AD;M<=@X<:@DA#?:87#@?#DM@::8FR##@?#9=>?:8;8F#E@:H#DA8#g DG#a?:<AF<;Fb#<=BD;@:HML#0D?:#DG:8A#*SM8<A?#@?#>?8F#GD;#:H@?#7>;7D?8L# # # %*6 $+,!'-#" !".$',-%)/ %) !#$, (& 'E+%!#" #)> )()F'E+%!#" !".$',- $?#+,$ #

/D;# M8<?>;@AB# :H8# K><=@:I# DG# M8:HDF?# N<?8F# DA# ?789:;<=# F89DM7D?@:@DA# ?8J8;<=#8Q78;@M8A:?#H<J8#N88A#9<;;@8F#D>:L#&A#<==#?@M>=<:@DA?#:H8#<FP>?:8F#)<AF#

(6)

15^#

OY>N8;:4# ;<N@8# O1[h3RR# @AF8Q# H<?# N88A# >?8F# GD;# M8<?>;@AB# :H8# K><=@:I# DG# 9=>?:8;@ABL# /@;?:# :ED# 8Q78;@M8A:?# 8Q<M@A8?# :H@?# :89HA@K>8# @A# 9<?8# DG# ADAS ?:<AF<;F# <AF# ?:<AF<;F# OB@J8A# G;DM# M>=:@J<;@<:8# AD;M<=# F@?:;@N>:@DAR# 9=>?:8;# ?H<78?L#

&A# G@;?:# 8Q78;@M8A:?# :H8# ;8?>=:?# DG# 9=>?:8;@AB# E@:H# >?8# DG# ?789:;<=# F89DM7D?@:@DA4# *SM8<A?# <=BD;@:HM4# *SM8FD@F?# <=BD;@:HM4# V<;F# 9=>?:8;@AB4# <AF# 9DM7=8:8#=@AC#9=>?:8;@AB#H<J8#N88A#9DM7<;8F#DA#3#F<:<#MDF8=?]#894$-.:; <=$0:; <<<; 804.&>4 ?-::4"4L# /D;# 8<9H# MDF8=# G@G:I# ;8<=@X<:@DA?# H<?# N88A# B8A8;<:8F# E@:H#>?8#DG#0.1&"23#-#=@N;<;IL#/@B>;8#d#?HDE?#?<M7=8#F<:<?8:?#B8A8;<:8F#G;DM# 8<9H#MDF8=L# # # /@B>;8#dL#-<:<?8:?#>?8F#@A#G@;?:#8Q78;@M8A:#L# *D>;98]#,EA#;8?8<;9H#E@:H#>?8#DG#0.1&"23#-#=@N;<;IL# # # "<N=8#1#?HDE?#:H8#;8?>=:?#DG#?@M>=<:@DAL#&A#d#DG#3#9<?8?#9=>?:8;@AB#N<?8F#DA# ?789:;<=# F89DM7D?@:@DA# B@J8?# :H8# MD?:# <99>;<:8# 9=<??# ?:;>9:>;8L# &A# G@G:H# 9<?8# ?789:;<=#9=>?:8;@AB#=D?8?#DA=I#E@:H#V<;F#M8:HDFL# # !"#$%&' ()$*' ((( !*#&+, -%''#.#

(7)

!=<??@G@9<:@DA#'@<#*789:;<=#!=>?:8;@AB# _15\#

"<N=8#1L# J8;<B8#<FP>?:8F#)<AF#J<=>8?#G;DM#36#?@M>=<:@DA?# #

## #*`0&-":# *@0&#=4#: V<;F# 9DM7=8:8#=@ACL# ?789:;<=#9=>?:L#

?7@;<=?# 64625[1\# 64653h[h# 646d6dd2# 64635d15# D# ED;M?# 6431[d63# 64363h2d# 64325[5# 64d[132^# D# E2# `64665\1# `646613\# 6466h362# 646166hh# GHIJIKLC# ?M@=8I# 64\15^1h# 64h6h3hd# D# 64^d31^3# 64[352[\# 9<??@A@# 643h21h^# 64h6[61# 64h\3^32# 643h2d5h# GHLIMMCK# *D>;98]#,EA#;8?8<;9HL# # #

"H8# ?89DAF# ?@M>=<:@DA# 9DM7<;8?# 9=>?:8;@AB# ;8?>=:?# DG# MDF8=# 9D;A8;?# G;DM# 0.1&"23#-# =@N;<;I# O2SF@M8A?@DA<=# ?7H8;@9<=# AD;M<=# F@?:;@N>:@DA# E@:H# 8K><=# ?:<AF<;F#F8J@<:@DA#<AF#M8<A?#<:#:H8#9D;A8;?#DG#<#2SF@M8A?@DA<=# HI78;9>N8L#"H8# A>MN8;#DG#9=<??8?#@?#ARL# # # "<N=8#5L# J8;<B8#<FP>?:8F#)<AF#J<=>8?#G;DM#36#?@M>=<:@DA?#GD;#2=$"&$:#F<:<?8:# #

## *S0&-":# *B0&#=4#: V<;F# 9DM7=8:8#=@ACL# ?789:;<=#9=>?:L#

# 64h2d3# D D D 64[2\\#

*D>;98]#,EA#;8?8<;9HL# #

#

,A8#9<A#DN?8;J8#:H<:#EH@=8#9=>?:8;@AB#N<?8F#DA#?789:;<=#F89DM7D?@:@DA#B@J8?# J8;I# BDDF# ;8?>=:?# @A# 9<?8# DG# 9=>?:8;# ?H<78?# O8Q78;@M8A:# 1R# @:?# 78;GD;M<A98# @?# B8::@AB#ED;?8#GD;#8==@7?D@F<=#9=>?:8;?#B@J8A#G;DM#AD;M<=#F@?:;@N>:@DA#O8Q78;@M8A:#5RL# # # *6 $+,!'-#" !".$',-%)/ *$6 )(%$E *#-%#N",$ # &A#:H@;F#8Q78;@M8A:#GD;#G@J8#MDF8=?#DG#2.):,&$840#- =@N;<;I#OV<=8?@<C#->F8C# O566hR# `# MDF8=?# h# :D# 15R# G@G:I# ;8<=@X<:@DA?# H<J8# N88A# B8A8;<:8F# E@:H# DA84# :ED4# :H884#<AF#GD>;#AD@?I#J<;@<N=8?L#"H8#;8?>=:?#DG#:H@?#?@M>=<:@DA#7;8?8A:?#:<N=8#2L#

# #

(8)

15h#

"<N=8#2L# J8;<B8#<FP>?:8F#)<AF#J<=>8?#G;DM#36#?@M>=<:@DA?#@A#8Q78;@M8A:#2# #

!=>?:8;@AB#M8:HDF?# 0DF8=# AD@?I#

J<;@<N=8?# #*S0&-":# *B0&#=4#: V<;F# 9DM7=8:8#=@ACL# ?789:;<=#9=>?:L#

1# 64^5[6\\# 64\h\66\# 64\23[2[# 642[d[d[# GHLGKIOI# 5# 64d3^1h2# 643[[h6^# 643\211^# 645\2\\2# GHOKCLP# 2# 642[h5\\# 64d31h3d# 64ddd53\# 641[56[2# GHMKOKIP# '&&&# d# 6422[65[# 645[[[h\# 642[162[# 641h^d\# GHPOIGIM# 1# 64\2\\3[# GHIIDJDP# 64[\12d# 643223hh# 64h^h12\# 5# 64^hd2[2# GHIDGKJK# 64[623[[# 642[[d6\# 64\[h6\5# 2# _64^5[h[# _64\3h^hd# _GHLKCGCO# _64d66h1d# _64\3[[5h# &i# d# 64^d3\21# 64^dd63# 64\5\611# 642[255\# GHOJJDIK# 1# 64^d3d65# GHIOLGCM# 64[d\62h# 642361^2# 64[6653[# 5# 643622h# GHLLCLMI# 64h2d2^[# 646[^2[2# 64hd6d2\# 2# 64266^\1# 64\dd653# 64\562\h# 6415h52[# GHICLKJO# i# d# 6422dd^^# 6431d13# 6432h1\h# 6416\dh[# GHLKCMDK# 1# 64hdd^12# 64[[h2^2# D# 64d6^d\\# 64h\hd# 5# _64hdd[5h# _GHIIJLJO# _64[[dd6d# _6423135^# _64[52\\[# 2# 64h6\25[# 64[d^2hh# GHILDJCD# 642^56[\# 64h3[5d\# i&# d# 64\36^1h# 64h1h[[[# GHIJLGC# 645h6h5# 64h\\[12# 1# 64d^31^5# 6435\1h[# 642[251# 6421h^1^# GHLJPLOP# 5# 642\\\h1# 642\5212# 6423113# 645\1653# GHMKCDLP# 2# 64215\dd# 645326\5# 645[d^2[# 641\h[dh# GHJCLIPC# i&&# d# _GHCLPGGL# 641[\2d5# 64525\1h# 641h523^# 645^65^[# *D>;98]#,EA#;8?8<;9HL# # &A#B8A8;<=#:H8#;8?>=:?#DG#:H@?#8Q78;@M8A:#=8<F#:D#9DA9=>?@DA]#"H8#MD;8#AD@?I# J<;@<N=8?#:H8#N8::8;#N8H<J@D;#DG#?789:;<=#9=>?:8;@ABL# # *%6 $+,!'-#" !".$',-%)/ &(- )(@%)#" >#'# #

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dL#

(9)

!=<??@G@9<:@DA#'@<#*789:;<=#!=>?:8;@AB# _15[#

"<N=8#dL# J8;<B8#<FP>?:8F#)<AF#J<=>8?#G;DM#36#?@M>=<:@DA?#@A#8Q78;@M8A:#d# #

# *S0&-":# *B0&#=4#: V<;F# 9DM7=8:8#=@ACL# ?789:;<=#9=>?:L#

0DF8=#3# 64[2\# 64[\\3[[# 1# 643\2\2h# 64[351[1# 0DF8=#^# 64h3[5[\# 64[2h3d5# 64h[h[3[# 64\[[21# 64h56\[2# 0DF8=#\# 64\\dd1d# 64[^[[dd# 64[d^21d# 64h5\2^5# 64hhd6h\# 0DF8=#h# 64\3[263# 64[[1525# 64[^55[d# 64[d\3[1# 64hdh6[2# 0DF8=#[# 64h\dh6d# 64[[^551# 64[[53\d# 64[\h15h# 64\[h56^# 0DF8=#16# 64[652h3# 1# 1# 1# 64h[5hh5# *D>;98]#,EA#;8?8<;9HL# # # ?#E8#9<A#DN?8;J8#GD;#?>9H#C@AF#DG#F<:<#:H8#>?<B8#DG#?789:;<=#:89HA@K>8?#@?# ;<:H8;# >?8=8??L# &A# B8A8;<=# @:# B@J8?# M>9H# ED;?8# ;8?>=:?# :H<A# *B0&#=4#:# <AF# H@8;<;9H@9<=#M8:HDF?L#

# #

*%%6 &%)#" -,@#-7$

#

)8?>=:?# DG# 8Q78;@M8A:?# 8M7DE8;# :D# ?:<:8# :H8?@?# :H<:# M8:HDF?# N<?8F# DA# ?789:;<=#F89DM7D?@:@DA#B@J8?#N8::8;#;8?>=:?#:H<A#a:;<F@:@DA<=b# <=BD;@:HM?#@A#9<?8# DG#>A:I7@9<=#9=>?:8;#?H<78?#<AF#GD;#F<:<?8:?#E@:H#AD@?I#J<;@<N=8?#EH@=8#:H8I#FDAj:# @M7;DJ8# O<AF# ?DM8:@M8?# F89;8<?8R# ;8?>=:?# DG# 9=<??@G@9<:@DA# GD;# 8==@7?D@F<=# 9=>?:8;?#B@J8A#G;DM#AD;M<=#F@?:;@N>:@DA#<AF#GD;#F<:<?8:?#E@:H#J<;@<N=8?#M8<?>;8F# DA#ADM@A<=#?9<=8?L#

&A# ;8<=# ;8?8<;9H# 7;DN=8M?# ;8B>=<;# ?H<78?# <;8# ;<:H8;# ;<;8# EH@=8# ADAS?:<AF<;F## 9=>?:8;?# <778<;# MD;8# DG:8A4# ?D# E8# 9<A# <=?D# ?:<:8# :H<:# :H@?# M8:HDF# M<I# N8# GD;# ;8?8<;9H8;?#<#BDDF#<=:8;A<:@J8#:D#E@F8=I#>?8F#CSM8<A?4#*SM8FD@F?#D;#H@8;<;9H@9<=# 9=>?:8;@AB#<=BD;@:HM?L#

# #

-,&,-,)!,$

!=@M8?9>SY<>=@9<# L# O566^R# YDE# :D# 9HDD?8# :H8# A>MN8;# DG# 9=>?:8;?L# "H8# !;<M8;# 0>=:@7=@9@:I# *D=>:@DA4#V]#YLYLScL#+8AX4#)L#-89C8;#O(F?LR4#!#D-"2&: 4" (-,- !"-.>:4:4#k8;=@A4#77L#13`52L# !;@?:@<A@A@#%L4#_<AFD=<#cL#O5661R4#*789:;<=#08:HDF?#GD;#!=>?:8;@AB; E&)$-. F"G=$0-,4=" H$=2&::4"I

8>09=:4)04#<J<@=<N=8#<:#H::7]llEEELA@7?L99l%&T*5661l7<78;?l7?BXl 23L7?LBX#

(J8;@::#kL*L4#+<AF<>#*L4#+88?8#0L#O5661R4#?.):,&$ -"-.>:4:4#(FE<;F# ;AD=F4#+DAFDAL#

Z<:A<;#(L4#V<=8?@<C#0L#O;8FLR#O566dR4#J&,=#> :,-,>:,>2%"&' -"-.4%> 64&.=6>04-$=6&' 6 1-#-"4-23

0-$*&,4"I=6>234#VIF<EA@9:ED# (4#V;D9W<EL#

ZD;FDA# L-L#O1[[[R4#?.-::4G42-,4="4#!H<7M<A#<AF#Y<==l!)!4#+DAFDAL#

Y<;:@B<A#cL L#O1[\3R4#?.):,&$4"I -.I=$4,30:4#V@=8I4#%8E#mD;C4#+DAFDA4#*IFA8I4#"D;DA:DL# Y>N8;:#+LcL4# ;<N@8#TL#O1[h3R4#!DM7<;@AB#7<;:@:@DA?4#K=)$"-. =G ?.-::4G42-,4="4#ADL#14#1[2S51hL#

(10)

126#

_<>GM<A#+L4#)D>??88>E#TLcL#O1[[6R4#L4"#4"I I$=)9: 4" #-,-M -" 4",$=#)2,4=" ,= 2.):,&$ -"-.>:4:4# V@=8I4#%8E#mD;CL#

JDA# +>QN>;B# $L# O566^R4# ! ,),=$4-. =" :9&2,$-. 2.):,&$4"I4# 0<Q# T=<A9C# &A?:@:>:8# GD;# k@D=DB@9<=# !IN8;A8:@9?4#"89HA@9<=#)87D;:#")S1d[L#

%B# L4# cD;F<A# &L4# V8@??# m# O5661R4# # ,A# *789:;<=# !=>?:8;@AB]# A<=I?@?# <AF# <A# =BD;@:HM E&)$-.

F"G=$0-,4=" H$=2&::4"I 8>09=:4)04# <J<@=<N=8# <:# H::7]llEEELA@7?L99l%&T*5661l# 7<78;?l#

7?BXl 23L7?LBX#

V<=8?@<C# 0L4# ->F8C# L# O566hR4# ?.):,&$840; -# 7<9C<B8# <J<@=<N=8# <:# H::7]llEB;@:L<8LPBD;<L7=l# C8@@l9=>?:8;*@M###

#

!"#$%&' ()#&*

#)#"%Q# $7.+%,R @,'(>#@% 7"#$E&%7#!S% $+,7'-#"),S #

_=<?IG@C<9P<# ?78C:;<=A<# :D# ;DXE@P<Pn9<# ?@o# DF# CDp9<# 7D7;X8FA@8BD# E@8C># M8:DF<# <A<=@XI# ?C>7@8pL# 08:DF<# :<4# M@MD# A@8C@8FI# A@8XNI:# ;DXN>FDE<A8P# 7DFN>FDEI# :8D;8:I9XA8P4# F<P8# N<;FXD# FDN;8#EIA@C@#8M7@;I9XA8#X<;qEAD#A<#XN@D;<9H#:8?:DEI9H#P<C#@#A<#;X89XIE@?:I9H#XN@D;<9H#F<AI9HL# ;:IC>W# 7;X8F?:<E@<# A<PE<rA@8P?X8# C;DC@# <=BD;I:M># C=<?IG@C<9P@# ?78C:;<=A8P4# E?C<X>P8# ?I:><9P84## E#C:q;I9H#?:D?DE<A@8#<=BD;I:M>#F<P8#F>r8#=87?X8#;8X>=:<:I#OM@8;XDA8#@AF8C?8M#)<AF<R#A@r#@AA8# M8:DFI# <A<=@XI# ?C>7@8pL# V# X<CDp9X8A@8# 7;X8F?:<E@DA8# ?n# ;8CDM8AF<9P8# FD:I9Xn98# ?I:><9P@4## E#C:q;I9H#E<;:D#?:D?DE<s#:n#:89HA@Co#C=<?IG@C<9P@L#