Od epoché do Gelassenheit : "mistyczny" sens Heideggerowskiej radykalizacji fenomenologii

Pełen tekst

(1)Zeszyty Naukowe nr. 846. 2010. Uniwersytetu Ekonomicznego w Krakowie. 3LRWU$XJXVW\QLDN Katedra Filozofii. 2GHSRFKpGR*HODVVHQKHLW Å0LVW\F]Q\µVHQV+HLGHJJHURZVNLHM UDG\NDOL]DFMLIHQRPHQRORJLL :VWÚS &yŧEDUG]LHMG]LZDF]QHJRQLŧVLOLþVLĕQDVQXFLHWDNLFKDQDORJLL=MHGQHM VWURQ\ŋFLŋOHQDXNRZ\G\VWDQVXMćF\VLĕRGXF]XFLRZ\FKHNVSOR]MLLGXFKRZ\FK HNVWD]SURJUDP+XVVHUORZVNLHMF]\VWHMIHQRPHQRORJLLD]GUXJLHMPLVW\F]QDP\ŋO 0LVWU]D(FNKDUWD²HNVWDW\F]QDVWU]HOLVWDLPURF]QD]DUD]HPXSRUF]\ZLHZWãD F]DQDZUDP\GLDOHNW\F]QHMŋFLVãRŋFLRUD]G\VF\SOLQ\LUyZQLHZ\WUZDOHMHUR]VD G]DMćFDVãRZHPZ\WUZDãDDVFH]DLGURELD]JRZDU]HWHOQRŋþEDGDF]DDQDSU]HFLZ QLHMSURZRNDF\MQDHPID]DLJXELćFHGHWDOHÅZL]MRQHUVWZRµKHUHW\FNLHJRPLVW\ND LWHRORJD7UXGQRREDUG]LHMKRUUHQGDOQHQLHSRUR]XPLHQLH5]HF]\ZLŋFLHWUXGQR RP\ŋOLFLHOLEDUG]LHMRGOHJã\FKQLŧFLGZDM&yŧMHGQDNMHŋOLQLHRQLVDPLDOH P\ŋORZHWURS\SU]H]QLFKSRGMĕWHZPLDUĕJG\]DF]\QDMćŧ\þVZRLPZãDVQ\P ŧ\FLHPSU]\FLćJDMćVLĕL]EOLŧDMćE\ZUHV]FLHVLĕSU]HFLćþLQDãRŧ\þQDVLHELH EDUG]RQLHSU]\]ZRLFLH"7H]DNWyUćFKFLDãE\PSRVWDZLþLX]DVDGQLþEU]PL]DWHP WDNUDG\NDOQDIHQRPHQRORJLDNLHG\SRU]XFD+XVVHUODL]DWRZDU]\V]DRELHUDVRELH 0DUWLQD+HLGHJJHUDXMDZQLD]DVNDNXMćFćEOLVNRŋþ](FNKDUWLDĸVNLPVSRVREHP P\ŋOHQLD%RVNRŋþ)HQRPHQRORJLDXMDZQLDZWHQVSRVyEVZHSHãQHGXFKRZH REOLF]HVZRMćÅPLVW\F]QćLVNLHUNĕµ7DNZãDŋQLHUR]XPLHPGURJĕF]\VWHMIHQRPH QRORJLLRGHSRFKp do *HODVVHQKHLW . &KRþ]DSRQLŧV]HXMĕFLHUHODFMLHSRFKHL*HODVVHQKHLWRGSRZLHG]LDOQ\MHVWHPRVRELŋFLHWR MHGQDNWU]HEDZLHG]LHþŧHVDPRVNRMDU]HQLHLSRZLć]DQLHW\FKNDWHJRULL]DZG]LĕF]DP%:HOWHPX 3RU%:HOWH0HLVWHU(FNKDUW*HGDQNHQ]XVHLQHQ*HGDQNHQ)UHLEXUJ²%DVHO²:LHQ V².

(2) 104. Piotr Augustyniak. =UHV]WćQLHW\ONRIHQRPHQRORJLDDOHWHŧP\ŋO(FNKDUWDXMDZQLDWXSHãQLĕVZHM LVWRW\3RND]XMHVLĕMDNRILOR]RILDZVHQVLHŋFLVã\PMDNRP\ŋOHQLHQDGZ\UD] VXEWHOQHRVWUHMDNEU]\WZDLZ\EXFKRZHMDNG\QDPLWDZLĕFDUF\SRWU]HEQH DQDZHWSRŧćGDQHZF]DVDFKLQWHOHNWXDOQHMPLDãNRŋFLLQXG\ 5DG\NDOL]DFMDIHQRPHQRORJLL 'ãXJ ZG]LĕF]QRŋFL MDNL 0DUWLQ +HLGHJJHU ]DFLćJQćã QD VZRMHM GURG]H P\ŋOHQLDZREHF(GPXQGD+XVVHUODLMHJRNRQFHSFMLIHQRPHQRORJLL]RVWDãJUXQ WRZQLHSU]HEDGDQ\LRSLVDQ\ŦDGQDU]HWHOQDSUH]HQWDFMDP\ŋOL+HLGHJJHUDQLH PRŧHSU]HFLHŧSRPLQćþWHJRZDŧQHJRHWDSXMHJRELRJUDILLLQWHOHNWXDOQHM6DP +HLGHJJHURWZDUFLHSU]\]QDZDãŧHVSRWNDQLH]LGHćIHQRPHQRORJLLE\ãRGODQLHJR GHF\GXMćF\PNURNLHPNXVIRUPXãRZDQLXS\WDQLDRVHQVE\FLD3&DãD]ãRŧRQRŋþ UHODFMLXF]QLDGRPLVWU]DZ\FKRG]LMHGQDNQDMDZJG\ZHťPLHVLĕSRGXZDJĕŧH ZHGãXJ+HLGHJJHUDWDVDPDIHQRPHQRORJLF]QDPHWRGDP\ŋOHQLDNWyUDSR]ZDOD QDSRVWDZLHQLHRZHJRS\WDQLDMHVWQLHZ\VWDUF]DMćFDGODMHJRRSUDFRZDQLDLPXVL ]RVWDþZW\PFHOXJUXQWRZQLH]PRG\ILNRZDQD&KRG]LWXRPRŧOLZRŋþRNUHŋOHQLD SLHUZRWQHJRSROD ZDUXQNXPRŧOLZRŋFL

(3) ]MDZLDQLDVLĕIHQRPHQXZVSRVyEEDUG]LHM ťUyGãRZ\QLŧ]URELãWR+XVVHUONUHŋOćF\SURMHNWIHQRPHQRORJLLF]\VWHMF]\OLWUDQV FHQGHQWDOQHM2LOHGOD+XVVHUODSROHPW\PMHVWF]\VWDŋZLDGRPRŋþZREUĕELH NWyUHMNRQVW\WXXMćVLĕVHQV\WHJRFRGDQHRW\OHGODMHJRXF]QLDÅSROHPµW\P MHVWXMDZQLDMćF\FKDUDNWHUVNU\WRŋFLE\FLDF]\OLVWUXNWXUDVWULFWHRQWRORJLF]QD %\FLHMDNRZDUXQHNPRŧOLZRŋFLWHJRŧHE\WMHVWMHVWMHGQRF]HŋQLHZDUXQNLHP PRŧOLZRŋFLMHJRMDZLHQLDVLĕ%\þE\WHP E\WRZDþ

(4) WRZLĕFGOD+HLGHJJHUDMDZLþ VLĕE\þIHQRPHQHP)HQRPHQDOQRŋþWHJRFRGDQHMHVW]DWHPF]ĕŋFLćMHJRE\WRZHM REHFQRŋFL7RFRGRVWĕSQHP\ŋOHQLXMHVWPXZLĕFGDQHQDPRF\VZRMHJRE\FLD7H IXQGDPHQWDOQHUR]VWU]\JQLĕFLDNWyU\FK+HLGHJJHUGRNRQXMHZH:SURZDG]HQLDGR %\FLDLF]DVXSRGZDŧDMć+XVVHUORZVNL]DELHJZ]LĕFLDZQDZLDVLVWQLHQLDŋZLDWD . 0DWRRGELFLHUyZQLHŧZSROVNLHMUHFHSFMLP\ŋOL+HLGHJJHUD3RUQS.0LFKDOVNL+HLGHJ JHULILOR]RILDZVSyãF]HVQD:DUV]DZDV²RUD]%%DUDQ6DJD+HLGHJJHUD.UDNyZ V² 3. Å7DNRWR]QDOD]ãHPVLĕQDGURG]HS\WDQLDRE\FLHRŋZLHFRQ\SU]H]QDVWDZLHQLHIHQRPHQROR JLF]QHµ 0+HLGHJJHU0RMDGURJDGRIHQRPHQRORJLLSU]Hã&:RG]LĸVNLVZ0+HLGHJ JHU.XU]HF]\P\ŋOHQLD:DUV]DZDV²

(5) . +HLGHJJHUS\WDUHWRU\F]QHVNćGLZMDNLVSRVyERNUHŋODVLĕWRFR]JRGQLH]]DVDGćIHQRPH QRORJLLPXVLE\þGRŋZLDGF]DQHMDNRÅU]HF]VDPDµ"&]\MHVWWRŋZLDGRPRŋþLMHJRSU]HGPLRWRZRŋþ F]\WHŧE\FLHE\WXZMHJRQLHVNU\WRŋFLLVNU\FLX 0+HLGHJJHU0RMDGURJDGRIHQRPHQRORJLL« V

(6) . &KRG]LWXRSDU:SURZDG]HQLDSW)HQRPHQRORJLF]QDPHWRGDEDGDQLD 0+HLGHJJHU %\FLHLF]DVSU]Hã%%DUDQ:DUV]DZDV²

(7) .

(8) Od epoché do Gelassenheit…. 105. ,VWQLHQLHDZ]DVDG]LHE\FLHWHJRFRGDQHMDNRIHQRPHQQLHPRŧHE\þMDNFKFLDã +XVVHUOWUDNWRZDQHMDNRMHGHQ]ZLHOXIHQRPHQyZ]HVIHU\RERZLć]\ZDQLD NWyU\SRGREQLHMDNLQQHIHQRPHQ\SRWU]HEXMHXJUXQWRZDQLDVZHJRE\FLDGDQ\P ZSLHUZRWQ\PSROXNRQVW\WXFMLVHQVX:HGãXJ+HLGHJJHUDE\FLHLVWQLHQLHPXVL E\þX]QDQH]DIHQRPHQIHQRPHQyZF]\OLZãDŋQLH]DWĕSLHUZRWQćLQVWDQFMĕNWyUD VSUDZLDŧHIHQRPHQMHVWIHQRPHQHPŧHSRMDZLDVLĕLMHVWÅRGELHUDQ\µSRSU]H] P\ŋOHQLH)HQRPHQRORJLD]PLHU]DMćFDGR]EDGDQLDWHMVHQVRURGQHMVIHU\PXVLZLĕF ]NRQLHF]QRŋFLRND]DþVLĕRQWRORJLć 0RŧQDSRZLHG]LHþŧHSRGVWDZRZ\]DU]XW+HLGHJJHUDZREHF+XVVHUORZ skiej koncepcji HSRFKpVSURZDG]DVLĕGRWHJRŧHSU]\MPXMHRQDSHZQHEDUG]R PRFQH]DãRŧHQLHPLDQRZLFLHŧH]MDZLDQLHVLĕIHQRPHQyZGRNRQXMHVLĕZVIHU]H RERZLć]\ZDQLDQRZRŧ\WQHJRUR]UyŧQLHQLDQDSRGPLRWLSU]HGPLRW:HGãXJ +HLGHJJHUDWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQDUHGXNFMD]DPLDVWEUDþZQDZLDVUyZQLHŧWĕSU]HG PLRWRZRSRGPLRWRZćNRUHODFMĕGRSURZDG]DGR²MDNŧHFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHMGOD GXFKDQRZRŧ\WQRŋFL²WH]\RSLHUZRWQHMUROLSRGPLRWXLMHJRWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHM VXELHNW\ZQRŋFLZSURFHVLHNRQVW\WXFMLVHQVXWHJRFRGDQHMDNRSU]HGPLRW7R FRURELDXWRU0HG\WDFMLNDUWH]MDĸVNLFKMHVWZLĕFGODMHJRXF]QLDZJUXQFLHU]HF]\ NROHMQćSRVWDFLć]DSRPQLHQLDE\FLDMHJRSU]HNV]WDãFHQLHPZIXQGXMćFćŋZLDW SU]HGVWDZLHQLDSRGPLRWRZRŋþSRGPLRWX1LHXPQLHMV]DMHGQDNZQLF]\PGãXJX ZG]LĕF]QRŋFL+HLGHJJHUDNWyU\EH]SURMHNWXVZRMHJRPLVWU]DQLHPyJãE\RGNU\þ ŧHLQWU\JXMćFDJRRGPãRGRŋFLNZHVWLDF]\PMHVW6HLQVSURZDG]DVLĕGRWUDQVFHQ GHQWDOQHJRS\WDQLDRRQWRORJLF]QHVWUXNWXU\MDZQRŋFLE\WX +HLGHJJHURZL QLH FKRG]LãR ]UHV]WćR]Z\NãH ]DNZHVWLRQRZDQLHSURMHNWX F]\VWHMIHQRPHQRORJLLDOHRMHJRUDG\NDOL]DFMĕ-HŋOLPRŧQDXŧ\þWHUPLQRORJLL VDPHJR+XVVHUODMHJRXF]Hĸ]DPLHU]DãZ]LćþZQDZLDVQLHW\ONRSHãHQ]GURZR UR]VćGNRZ\FKSU]HGVćGyZLSU]HGUR]VWU]\JQLĕþŋZLDWQDWXUDOQHJRQDVWDZLHQLD DOHUyZQLHŧIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHGćŧHQLHGRSHãQHMEH]]DãRŧHQLRZRŋFL0\ŋO+HLGHJ . (+XVVHUO0HG\WDFMH.DUWH]MDĸVNLH=GRGDQLHPXZDJNU\W\F]Q\FK5RPDQD,QJDUGHQD :DUV]DZDV . 3RU3$XJXVW\QLDN7UDQVFHQGHQWDOQ\VHQVRQWRORJLL+HLGHJJHUDVÅ/RJRVL(WKRVµ QU

(9) V² . &RGRWUHŋFLIHQRPHQRORJLDMHVWQDXNćRE\FLXE\WX²RQWRORJLć 0+HLGHJJHU%\FLH LF]DV«V

(10) . Å&]\VWDµ]QDF]\ÅWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQDIHQRPHQRORJLDµ$OH]DÅWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQćµX]QDQD ]RVWDMHÅVXELHNW\ZQRŋþµSR]QDMćFHJRG]LDãDMćFHJRLVWDQRZLćFHJRZDUWRŋFLSRGPLRWX2ED WHUPLQ\²ÅVXELHNW\ZQRŋþµLÅWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQ\µ²ZVND]XMćŧHÅIHQRPHQRORJLDµŋZLDGRPLH L]GHF\GRZDQLHQDZLć]XMHGRWUDG\FMLILOR]RILLQRZRŧ\WQHM 0+HLGHJJHU0RMDGURJDGRIHQRPH QRORJLL«V

(11) . 3RU0+HLGHJJHU.RQLHFILOR]RILLL]DGDQLHP\ŋOHQLDSU]Hã.0LFKDOVNLV²>Z@ LGHP.XU]HF]\P\ŋOHQLD:DUV]DZDV².

(12) 106. Piotr Augustyniak. JHUDSUREOHPDW\]XMćFSURMHNWKXVVHUORZVNLHMIHQRPHQRORJLLQLH]PLHU]DãDZLĕF GREDUG]LHMUDG\NDOQHJRÅZ\]ZROHQLDVLĕµ]]DãRŧHĸDOHGRREQDŧHQLDŧHZV]HONLH WDNLHGćŧHQLHVDPR]ZLć]DQHMHVW]]DãRŧHQLHPQRZRŧ\WQHMZL]MLSRGPLRWRZRŋFL MDNRÅF]HJRŋµDEVROXWQLHSLHUZRWQHJR =DPLDVWepoché… 7HQDSRUHW\F]Q\LSRZLNãDQ\FKDUDNWHU+XVVHUORZVNLHMHSRFKp²WRŧHZãDŋQLH SRSU]H]IDNWXSDUWHJR]PLHU]DQLDGRLGHDãXSHãQHMEH]]DãRŧHQLRZRŋFLXMDZQLD RQDW\PPRFQLHMV]HXZLNãDQLHZVZHQLHXSU]\WDPQLDQH]DãRŧHQLH²VWDZLDSU]HG SURMHNWHPUDG\NDOQHMIHQRPHQRORJLLQLHODGDZ\]ZDQLH5DG\NDOQHJRQDP\VãX NWyUHJRSURJUDPFKFLDãVIRUPXãRZDþ+HLGHJJHUQLHGDVLĕERZLHPZŧDGHP VSRVyEUHDOL]RZDþZREUĕELHRERZLć]\ZDQLDW]ZÅQDWXUDOQHJRQDVWDZLHQLDµ2G SLHUZV]\FKVWURQ%\FLDLF]DVX+HLGHJJHUQLHPDZćWSOLZRŋFLŧHSUyEDGRWDUFLD GRťUyGãRZHJRIHQRPHQXE\FLDGRPDJDVLĕMDNLHJRŋRGSRZLHGQLNDGODÅHSRFKpµ F]\WHŧZ\UDŧDMćFVLĕŋFLŋOHMZ\PDJD]DVDGQLF]HM]PLDQ\ZQDVWDZLHQLXEDGDF]D :HGOH+HLGHJJHUDSU]\QDOHŧQRŋþP\ŋOHQLDGRXMDZQLDMćF\FKVWUXNWXUE\FLD XND]XMHVLĕQDMSLHUZZW\PŧHP\ŋOHQLHMHVW]DZV]HF]\LPŋP\ŋOHQLHPDPLDQR ZLFLHSHZQHJRE\WXNWyUHPXÅZMHJRE\FLXFKRG]LRVDPRWRE\FLHµE\WX NWyU\PP\ZV]\VF\MHVWHŋP\-DNZLHP\E\WWHQMHVWQD]\ZDQ\SU]H]+HLGHJJHUD terminem 'DVHLQ6NRURVSRVyEE\FLD'DVHLQSROHJDQDW\PŧHFKRG]LPX]DZV]H RVZHZãDVQHE\FLHWRPRŧQDSRZLHG]LHþŧH]DZV]HZSHZLHQVSRVyEÅRGQRVL VLĕGR>«@E\FLDµ$ZLĕF]DZV]HMDNRŋMHUR]XPLHMDNRŋMHP\ŋOLDZLĕFWHŧ ujawnia1LHR]QDF]DWRMHGQDNŧHNDŧGRUD]RZRMHVWWRWDNLHP\ŋOHQLHNWyUH RGVãDQLDE\FLHZMHJRZãDVQHMSUDZG]LH+HLGHJJHUXZDŧDŧHLVWQLHMćUyŧQH ÅZDULDQW\µ'DVHLQGDMćFHVLĕVSURZDG]LþGRGZX]DVDGQLF]\FKPRGL'RZãDŋFL ZHJR HLJHQWOLFK

(13) LQLHZãDŋFLZHJR XQHLJHQWOLFK

(14) VSRVREXHJ]\VWRZDQLD%\FLH QLHZãDŋFLZHQLHR]QDF]DWXMDNLHMŋ]DZLQLRQHMOXEQLH]DZLQLRQHMGHIRUPDFML 'DVHLQ1LHMHVWQDZHWF]\PŋZWyUQ\PZREHFE\FLDZãDŋFLZHJR3U]HFLZQLHMHVW RQRF]\PŋÅQDMQRUPDOQLHMV]\PZŋZLHFLHµDPLDQRZLFLHMHVWOXG]NLPÅ]UD]X L]Z\NOHµ>=XQlFKVWXQG=XPHLVW@F]\OLSU]HFLĕWQ\PFRG]LHQQ\PVSRVREHP. . :QDVWĕSXMćF\VSRVyE+HLGHJJHUXVWRVXQNRZXMHVLĕGRVã\QQHM+XVVHUORZVNLHMÅ]DVDG\ ZV]\VWNLFK]DVDGµSRVWXOXMćFHMPLQGćŧHQLHGRDEVROXWQHMEH]]DãRŧHQLRZRŋFLZEDGDQLX*G\E\ ŋP\VS\WDOLVNćGZãDŋFLZLHÅ]DVDGDZV]\VWNLFK]DVDGµF]HUSLHVZćQLHGDMćFćVLĕSRGZDŧ\þVãXV] QRŋþRGSRZLHGťPXVLDãDE\EU]PLHþ]VXELHNW\ZQRŋFLWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHMNWyUDMHVWMXŧ]DãRŧRQD MDNRU]HF]ILOR]RILL 0+HLGHJJHU.RQLHFILOR]RILL«V

(15) . 3RU0+HLGHJJHU%\FLHLF]DV«V. . 5R]XPLHQLHE\FLDVDPRMHVWRNUHŋOHQLHPE\FLD'DVHLQ 0+HLGHJJHU%\FLHLF]DV«V² WXLGDOHMSU]HNãDG]PRG\ILNRZDQ\SRSU]H]SU]\ZUyFHQLHRU\JLQDOQHJRWHUPLQXÅ'DVHLQµ

(16) .

(17) Od epoché do Gelassenheit…. 107. HJ]\VWRZDQLDÅSU]HFLĕWQćSRZV]HGQLRŋFLćµ-HJRQLHZãDŋFLZRŋþSROHJD]Dŋ QDW\PŧHGRNRQXMćFHVLĕZMHJRREUĕELHRGQLHVLHQLHGRE\FLDMHVWRGZURWHP LXFLHF]NćSU]HGQLP7RRGQLHVLHQLHGRE\FLDZPRGXVLHXFLHF]NLGRSURZDG]DGR MHJRQLHP\ŋOHQLD%\FLHXMDZQLDVLĕWXW\ONRSRŋUHGQLRMDNRWRFRP\ŋOHQLHFKFH SRPLQćþL]LJQRURZDþ7RZãDŋQLHSRZV]HGQLHXFLHNDQLHSU]HGS\WDQLHPRVHQV E\FLDSU]HFKRG]LZWUDNFLHG]LHMyZP\ŋOHQLDZFRUD]JãĕEV]H]DSRPQLHQLHE\FLD :SU]HFLZLHĸVWZLHGRE\FLDQLHZãDŋFLZHJRE\FLHZãDŋFLZHQLH]DSRŋUHGQLF]D XMDZQLHQLDE\FLDZWDNLPRGQLHVLHQLXGRQLHJRNWyUHMHVWRGPRZćXMDZQLHQLDJR ÐZZãDŋFLZ\VSRVyEHJ]\VWRZDQLDRSLHUDVLĕQDSHZQ\PV]F]HJyOQ\PQDVWURMX QD]\ZDQ\PSU]H]+HLGHJJHUDWUZRJćNWyU\Z\U\ZD'DVHLQ]]XSHãQLHÅQDWXUDO QHJRµ]DWUDFHQLDZFRG]LHQQRŋFLL]ZUDFDMHZSURVWNX]DJDGFHZãDVQHJRE\FLD NXS\WDQLXRMHJRVHQV$]DWHPW\ONRZãDŋFLZ\VSRVyEHJ]\VWRZDQLDLXPRŧOL ZLDMćFDJRWUZRJDRWZLHUDPRŧOLZRŋþXMDZQLHQLDE\FLDXPRŧOLZLDMćFW\PVDP\P IHQRPHQRORJLF]QćUDG\NDOL]DFMĕP\ŋOHQLD :Å%\FLXLF]DVLHµ]DWHP+XVVHUORZVNDUHGXNFMDWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQD]RVWDãD ]DVWćSLRQDSU]H]ILJXUĕ]DSRŋUHGQLF]RQHJRZWUZRG]HSU]HMŋFLDRGQLHZãDŋFL ZHJRGRZãDŋFLZHJRVSRVREXHJ]\VWRZDQLD7RZãDŋQLHSU]HMŋFLHPDNLHURZDþ P\ŋOHQLHNXXMDZQLDQLXRQWRORJLF]QHJRSRODNRQVW\WXFMLMDZQRŋFL&KRþWĕSURSR ]\FMĕ+HLGHJJHUDPRŧQDX]QDþ]D]GHF\GRZDQLHSU]HãRPRZćWRMHGQDNRQVDP GRFKRG]L]F]DVHPGRZQLRVNXŧHRSLHUDMćFVLćQDWDNSRMĕWHMHJ]\VWHQFMDOQHM ÅZãDŋFLZRŋFLµDWDNŧHV]HU]HMQDWDNSRMĕW\P'DVHLQQLHPRŧOLZHMHVWťUyGãRZH RGVãRQLĕFLHWHJRSROD F]\OLSUDZG\E\FLD

(18) :+HLGHJJHU]HQDUDVWDãRSU]HNRQDQLH ŧHZMHJRSURMHNFLH]RNUHVXÅ%\FLDLF]DVXµNZHVWLD'DVHLQ]\VNDãDQLHEH]SLHF]Q\ SU\PDWZREHF]]DãRŧHQLDEH]Z]JOĕGQLHSU\PDUQHMNZHVWLLE\FLD2]QDF]DWR]Dŋ ŧHMHJRP\ŋOHQLHQD]QDF]RQHE\ãRZFLćŧVXELHNW\ZL]DFMćLSU\PDWHPHJRSRPLPR ŧHZãDŋQLHWDNLHSRGHMŋFLHPLDãRRQRSU]H]Z\FLĕŧ\þ,QQ\PLVãRZ\+HLGHJJHU GRV]HGã]F]DVHPGRZQLRVNXŧHMDNGãXJR'DVHLQEĕG]LHUR]XPLDQHMDNRE\W. . 0+HLGHJJHU%\FLHLF]DV«V. . ÅZVDP\PPRGXVQLHZãDŋFLZRŋFL>«@'DVHLQFKRG]LZSHZLHQVSRVyERMHJRE\FLHGRNWy UHJRRGQRVLVLĕRQRZPRGXVSU]HFLĕWQHMSRZV]HGQLRŋFLFKRþE\W\ONRZPRGXVXFLHF]NLSU]HGQLP L]DSRPQLHQLDRQLPµ 3RU0+HLGHJJHU%\FLHLF]DV«V

(19) . 3RU.0LFKDOVNL+HLGHJJHU«V². . 6SUDZDWRQLH]Z\NOHVNRPSOLNRZDQDGRW\NDERZLHPGHOLNDWQHMNZHVWLLÅ]ZURWXµ:LĕN V]RŋþZ\SRZLHG]LVDPHJR+HLGHJJHUDQDWHQWHPDWSRGNUHŋODSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPSRJãĕELHQLH stanowiska z %\FLDLF]DVX SRU0+HLGHJJHU/LVWRKXPDQL]PLHSU]Hã-7LVFKQHUV² >Z@0+HLGHJJHU=QDNLGURJL:DUV]DZDV²

(20) WDNDE\SU]H]Z\FLĕŧ\þREHFQćZQLP FKRþQLH]DPLHU]RQćWHQGHQFMĕPRUDOQRDQWURSRORJLF]Qć 0+HLGHJJHU3U]\F]\QNLGRILOR]RILL (=Z\GDU]DQLD

(21) SU]Hã%%DUDQL-0L]HUD.UDNyZV

(22) NWyUD]UHV]WćGRFKRG]LZSHãQLGR JãRVXQLHZVDP\P6HLQXQG=HLWDOHZSyťQLHMV]HMQLHFRUR]SUDZFH2LVWRFLHSRGVWDZ\ (zamiesz F]RQHMZ0+HLGHJJHU=QDNLGURJL:DUV]DZDV²

(23) .

(24) 108. Piotr Augustyniak. RGQRV]ćF\VLĕGRÅZãDVQHJRE\FLDµWDNGãXJRQLHEĕG]LHRQR]GROQHGRXMDZQLHQLD E\FLDZMHJRťUyGãRZHMSUDZG]LHZMHJR]XSHãQHMÅLQQRŋFLµZREHFE\WX =DLQWHUHVRZDQLHP\ŋOHQLDPXVL]DWHPSU]HVXQćþVLĕ]ÅPRMHJRµE\FLDLE\FLD E\WyZ LFKMDZQRŋFL

(25) QDÅE\FLHVDPRµ VNU\WHťUyGãRZV]HONLHJRMDZLHQLDVLĕ

(26) 6SRVREHPWHMQRZHMUDG\NDOL]DFMLLSU]HNURF]HQLDHSRFKpMHVWUXFKRG'DVHLQ MDNRE\WXRGQRV]ćFHJRVLĕGRÅVZRMHJRµE\FLDNX'DVHLQ MDNSU]HIRUPXãRZXMH ten termin w 3U]\F]\QNDFKGRILOR]RILL

(27) MDNRVSRVREXXND]\ZDQLDVLĕÅE\FLD VDPHJRµ:SXQNFLHGRMŋFLDE\W]DLQWHUHVRZDQ\ZãDVQ\PE\FLHP]XSHãQLH]QLND 3RMDZLDVLĕZMHJRPLHMVFHHNVWDW\F]QDHNVLVWHQFMD]GROQDSRU]XFLþSHUVSHNW\Zĕ ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDVREćQDU]HF]Z\GDQLDVLĕF]HPXŋQDMVNUDMQLHMQLHVZRMHPX QLHSU]\VZDMDOQHPXLQLHRVZDMDOQHPXDZLĕFWDMHPQLF\E\FLDNWyUHQLJG\QLH PRŧHE\þZãDVQHDOH²RGZURWQLH²NWyUHPXZVSRVyEVXZHUHQQ\SU]\QDOHŧ\ ZV]\VWNRFRMHVWZV]F]HJyOQRŋFLVDPR'DVHLQ1LHFKRG]LWXMXŧ]DWHPRSU]HM ŋFLHGRÅZãDŋFLZHJRµE\FLDVREćERÅZãDŋFLZRŋþµR]QDF]DE\FLHÅZãDV\Pµ JUD VãyZHLJHQWOLFK i HLJHQ

(28) F]\OLSRVLDGDQLHVLHELHZHZãDVQ\PE\FLX3U]HMŋFLHWR SURZDG]LþPDGR]XSHãQLHLQQHJRE\FLDÅVREćµMXŧQLHÅVZRLPZãDVQ\PµDOH SU]\VZRMRQ\P L SRVLDGDQ\P SU]H] RZć QLHRSDQRZDQć ťUyGãRZR ZãDGDMćFć ZV]HONLPE\WHPLQQRŋþE\FLDVDPHJR+HLGHJJHUQD]\ZDWHQUDG\NDOQ\UXFK SU]HPLDQ\E\FLDVREćSU]HMŋFLHPRGÅSLHUZV]HJRSRF]ćWNXµ GHUHUVWH$QIDQJ) do ÅLQQHJRSRF]ćWNXµ GHUDQGHUH$QIDQJ

(29) Å3LHUZV]\PSRF]ćWNLHPµMHVWE\WOXG]NL NWyU\Z]DLQWHUHVRZDQLXZãDVQ\PE\FLHPQLH]GROQ\MHVWGRP\ŋOHQLDZSHãQL VXZHUHQQHJRGDU]ćFHJRťUyGãDMDZQRŋFLF]\OLE\FLDRGMHJRVWURQ\Å,QQ\P SRF]ćWNLHPµMHVWWRÅFRŋµFRSRMDZLDVLĕZPLHMVFXF]ãRZLHND²WHUPLQÅF]ãRZLHNµ ERZLHPZ\UDŧDMćF\HJ]\VWHQFMDOQH]DWURVNDQLHRVLHELHF]\OLRVZRMHE\FLHVWDMH VLĕRGWćG]XSHãQLHEH]Xŧ\WHF]Q\Å,QQ\SRF]ćWHNµMHVWWRWDNLHP\ŋOHQLHNWyUHMXŧ ]XSHãQLHQLHLQWHUHVXMHVLĕÅVREćµLQLHWURV]F]\VLĕÅRVLHELHµDOHMHVW]XSHãQLH ]DWUDFRQHZVSUDZLHNWyUćMHVWSUDZGDE\FLDÅ,QQ\SRF]ćWHNµWR]DWHP]XSHãQ\ ]DQLNF]ãRZLHNDMHJRSU]HNV]WDãFHQLHZSXVWHPLHMVFHXMDZQLDQLDVLĕVNU\WRŋFL E\FLDVDPHJR Z'DVHLQF]\OLZE\FLHWXRWRGDMćFH]QDNVZHMťUyGãRZHMVNU\WR. . Å1D'DVHLQ>«@QLHPRŧQDQDWUDILþMDNRQDFKDUDNWHUQDSRW\NDQHJRLREHFQHJRE\WXµ 0+HLGHJJHU3U]\F]\QNLGRILOR]RILL«VWXLGDOHMWãXPDF]HQLH]PLHQLRQHSRSU]H]SU]\ ZUyFHQLHRU\JLQDOQHJRWHUPLQX'DVHLQ

(30) Å'DVHLQWR>«@LVWRF]HQLHRZHMRWZDUWRŋFLNWyUDGRSLHUR RWZLHUDVNU\ZDQLHVLĕ LVWRWĕ%\FLD

(31) LMHVWZWHQVSRVyESUDZGćVDPHJR%\FLD>«@'DVHLQMDNR LVWRF]HQLHSU]HŋZLWXVNU\ZDQLDVLĕQDOHŧ\GRVDPHJRWHJRVNU\ZDQLDVLĕµ 0+HLGHJJHU3U]\ F]\QNLGRILOR]RILL«V²

(32) . ÅF]ãRZLHNHNVLVWXMćFNXSUDZG]LHE\FLDSU]\QDOHŧ\GRQLHJRµ 0+HLGHJJHU/LVWRKXPD QL]PLH«V

(33) Å=DWHPZRNUHŋOHQLXF]ãRZLHF]HĸVWZDF]ãRZLHNDMDNRHNVLVWHQFMLFKRG]LRWR ŧHQLHF]ãRZLHNMHVWW\PFRLVWRWQHOHF]E\FLHMDNRZ\PLDUHNVWDW\F]QRŋFLHNVLVWHQFMLµ LELGHP V

(34) . 3RUQS0+HLGHJJHU3U]\F]\QNLGRILOR]RILL«V².

(35) Od epoché do Gelassenheit…. 109. ŋFL

(36) 'ODWHJRGURJDRGÅSLHUZV]HJRµGRÅLQQHJRSRF]ćWNXµWRQLHŧDGQHÅQDZUy FHQLDµNXZãDVQHPXE\FLXDOHUDG\NDOQ\ÅVNRNµ 6SUXQJ

(37) ZLQQHQLHRSDQRZDQH $GRNãDGQLHWRE\FLHSU]HMĕW\PZSUyELHVNRNXSU]H]RZRťUyGãRZHÅZ\GDU]DQLH E\FLDµÅ:\GDU]DQLHµ (UHLJQLV

(38) E\FLDÅSU]\VZDMDµ HUHLJQHW

(39) VRELHW\FKNWyU]\ U\]\NXMćFVLHELHU]XFDMćVLĕZMHJREH]JUXQW 1LHPDWXMXŧPLHMVFDQDE\FLH F]ãRZLHND0RŧOLZ\MHVWW\ONRÅF]ãRZLHNµE\FLDÅ&]ãRZLHNµ]NRQLHF]QRŋFLREMĕW\ FXG]\VãRZHP%RSU]HFLHŧMXŧQLHF]ãRZLHNDOHNWRŋOXEFRŋFRSRU]XFLãRLVWRWQLH OXG]NLH]DLQWHUHVRZDQLH]DMĕFLHL]DWURVNDQLHVREć 6SyMU]P\GRMDNSU]HG]LZQHJRSU]HIRUPXãRZDQLDSURMHNWXUDG\NDOL]DFML IHQRPHQRORJLLGRFLHUDZWHQVSRVyEXF]Hĸ+XVVHUOD-HVWWRSU]HIRUPXãRZDQLH WDNUDG\NDOQHŧHNRPHQWDWRU]\FKĕWQLHPyZLćRRVWDWHF]Q\PSRU]XFHQLXPHWRG\ IHQRPHQRORJLF]QHM-HGQDNVDP+HLGHJJHUQLHE\ãVNãRQQ\WDNP\ŋOHþLMHV]F]H ZUSLVDãRVZRLPP\ŋOHQLXUyZQLHŧ]SyťQHJRRNUHVXMDNRSHZQHMPRŧOL ZRŋFLWNZLćFHMZIHQRPHQRORJLLERRQDVDPDQLHMHVWQLF]\PLQQ\PQLŧUDG\ NDOQćPRŧOLZRŋFLćP\ŋOHQLD6ćG]ĕŧH+HLGHJJHUPDUDFMĕLŧHWU]HEDUyZQLHŧ MHJRSyťQćP\ŋOUR]SDWU\ZDþMDNRSUyEĕGDOV]HMUDG\NDOL]DFMLIHQRPHQRORJLL 5yZQLHŧERZLHPZ3U]\F]\QNDFKGRILOR]RILLSRGREQLHMDNZH:SURZDG]HQLXGR %\FLDLF]DVXFKRG]LZFLćŧRÅWRVDPRµF]\OLRPRŧOLZRŋþGRWDUFLDGRťUyGãRZHJR SRODNRQVW\WXFMLVHQVXGRE\FLDMDNRťUyGãRZHMQLHVNU\WRŋFLNWyUDEĕGćFRWZLH UDQLHPVLĕVNU\WHJRMDNRVNU\WHJRMHVWťUyGãHPP\ŋOHQLDLZV]HONLHMMDZQRŋFL E\WX&KRG]LZFLćŧRÅWRVDPRµQDZHWMHŋOLãćF]\VLĕWR]UDG\NDOQ\P]HUZDQLHP ]WHUPLQRORJLćWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHJRG\VNXUVX -HŋOLZLĕF]JRG]LþVLĕŧHSyťQDP\ŋO+HLGHJJHUDZFLćŧMHVWZDULDFMćQD Z\MŋFLRZ\WHPDWUDG\NDOL]DFMLIHQRPHQRORJLLWRRND]XMHVLĕFRŋEDUG]R]DVND NXMćFHJRPLDQRZLFLHŧHIHQRPHQRORJLDZVZHMQDMEDUG]LHMUDG\NDOQHM+HLGHJJH URZVNLHMSRVWDFLXMDZQLDEDUG]RJãĕERNćVWUXNWXUDOQćEOLVNRŋþ]P\ŋOćPLVW\F]Qć LWR]QyZZMHMQDMEDUG]LHMUDG\NDOQHMVSHNXODW\ZQHMZHUVMLMDND]DSLVDQDMHVW w .D]DQLDFK0LVWU]D(FNKDUWD . 3RU&:RG]LĸVNL'ODF]HJRMHVWUDF]HMQLFQLŧFRŋ«3URMHNWRQWRORJLLDSRIDW\F]QHM V²>Z@LGHP3DQ6RNUDWHV(VHMHWU]HFLH:DUV]DZDV² . 3RU0+HLGHJJHU3U]\F]\QNLGRILOR]RILL«V. . 3RU0+HLGHJJHU0RMDGURJDGRIHQRPHQRORJLL«V. . +HLGHJJHUVWZLHUG]DZ3U]\F]\QNDFKGRILOR]RILL« V

(40) ŧHSRVWDZLRQHZ%\FLXLF]DVLH S\WDQLHRVHQVF]\SUDZGĕE\FLDSR]RVWDMHMHJRÅS\WDQLHPMHG\Q\PERGRW\F]\SU]HFLHŧWHJRFR QDMEDUG]LHMMHG\QHµ . .ZHVWLDQDZLć]DĸLRGQLHVLHĸ+HLGHJJHUDGR(FNKDUWDQLHMHVWMDVQD&RSUDZGD+HLGHJJHU ZGRMU]Dã\PRNUHVLHVZRMHMWZyUF]RŋFLQLHSRŋZLĕFDMHJRP\ŋOLRVREQHJRVWXGLXPMHGQDNŧH]QD LRGQRVLVLĕGR(FNKDUWDZHZF]HVQ\PRNUHVLHVZHMWZyUF]RŋFL SRU23|JJHOHU'URJDP\ŋORZD 0DUWLQD+HLGHJJHUDSU]Hã%%DUDQ:DUV]DZDV

(41) -HGQDN]QLHOLF]Q\FKZ]PLDQHN PRŧQDVLĕGRP\ŋODþŧHE\ãDWRGOD+HLGHJJHUDQLH]Z\NOHLVWRWQDLQVSLUDFMD1DXZDJĕ]DVãXJXMH.

(42) 110. Piotr Augustyniak. *HODVVHQKHLW &HOHPNWyU\0LVWU](FNKDUWVWDZLDVRELHZ.D]DQLDFKMHVWGRSURZDG]HQLH VZRLFKVãXFKDF]\GR]MHGQRF]HQLD]%RJLHP(FNKDUW]GDMHVRELHVSUDZĕŧH PyZLćFR%RJXQLHEĕG]LHGREU]HUR]XPLDQ\ERMHJRVãXFKDF]H²LQDF]HMQLŧ VDP0LVWU]²SU]H]%RJDUR]XPLHMćSHZLHQV]F]HJyOQ\E\WSRVLDGDMćF\VZRMć WRŧVDPRŋþLRGUĕEQRŋþ7HQVSRVyEZ\REUDŧDQLDVRELH%RJDZ\QLND]GDQLHP (FNKDUWD]]DVDGQLF]HJRFHOXMDNLF]ãRZLHNVWDZLDVRELHZVZRLPFRG]LHQQ\P ŧ\FLX7\PFHOHPMHVWÅZãDVQDNRU]\ŋþµDVSRVREHPFRG]LHQQHJRÅQDWXUDOQHJRµ OXG]NLHJRG]LDãDQLDMHVWG]LDãDQLHÅ]HZ]JOĕGXQDVLHELHµ7DNRNUHŋORQDFRG]LHQ QRŋþF]ãRZLHNDQD]QDF]RQDMHVWV]F]HJyOQ\PURG]DMHPUDFMRQDOQRŋFLNWyUćPRŧQD QD]ZDþÅORJLNćKDQGOXµ&]ãRZLHNG]LDãDMćF]HZ]JOĕGXQDVLHELHLVZRMćNRU]\ŋþ SRVWĕSXMHZHGãXJ]DVDG\ÅFRŋ]DFRŋµLFKFHZNDŧGHMV\WXDFMLSR]\VNDþZLĕFHM QLŧWUDFL1LHLQDF]HMMHVWNLHG\yZF]ãRZLHNFRG]LHQQRŋFL]ZUDFDVLĕGR%RJD 3URV]ćFJRRUyŧQHU]HF]\LVNãDGDMćFPXUyŧQHRILDU\FKFHX]\VNDþFRŋNRU]\VW QHJRGODVLHELH2GGRF]HVQ\FKNRU]\ŋFLSRF]\QDMćFQD]EDZLHQLXZLHF]Q\P NRĸF]ćF&]ãRZLHNSRWU]HEXMHZLĕFWDNLHJR%RJDNWyU\PRŧHE\þSDUWQHUHP KDQGOX0XVLE\þRQRGUĕEQ\PVWRMćF\PQDSU]HFLZNRF]ãRZLHNDE\WHP,QLFQLH ]PLHQLDQDZHWWRŧHPDWRE\þE\WÅZV]HFKPRJćF\µ7\POHSLHMERZLĕFHMPRŧH GDþF]ãRZLHNRZLZ]DPLDQ-HŋOLFKRG]LRPRŧOLZRŋþÅ]MHGQRF]HQLDµ]WDNLP %RJLHPPRŧHWRE\þW\ONR]MHGQRF]HQLHZG]LDãDQLX6DPLZVRELHF]ãRZLHN L%yJPXV]ćSR]RVWDþRGUĕEQL]DPNQLĕFLZVZRLPZãDVQ\PE\FLHEH]UHV]W\ ]ZãDV]F]DNUyWNDUR]SUDZDSW*HODVVHQKHLWZNWyUHM+HLGHJJHUF]\QL]WHM(FNKDUWLDĸVNLHMNDWHJR ULLNOXF]GRSU]H]Z\FLĕŧHQLDQRZRF]HVQHMGRPLQDFMLWHFKQLNLMDNRRVWDWHF]QHMIRUP\]DSRPQLHQLD E\FLD3DGDMćWDP]QDQHVãRZDR(FNKDUFLHÅRGNWyUHJRPRŧQDVLĕMHGQDNQDXF]\þZLHOHGREUHJRµ 0+HLGHJJHU:\]ZROHQLHSU]Hã-0L]HUD.UDNyZV

(43) :DUWRSU]\WRF]\þWHŧ]QDPLHQQH VãRZDZ\SRZLHG]LDQHZLQQ\PPLHMVFXÅ3UDZG]LZHMLZLHONLHMPLVW\FHSU]\SDGDZXG]LDOHQDM ZLĕNV]DRVWURŋþLJãĕELDP\ŋOHQLD>«@ŊZLDGHFWZHPWHJR0LVWU](FNKDUWµ 0+HLGHJJHU=DVDGD UDFMLSU]Hã-0L]HUD.UDNyZV

(44) 8ZDŧDPŧH+HLGHJJHUSU]\QDMPQLHMRGF]DVXSUDF\ nad 3U]\F]\QNDPLGRILOR]RILLSR]RVWDMHSRGSU]HPRŧQ\PZSã\ZHP(FNKDUWD6ćG]ĕSDUDGRN VDOQLHŧHZãDŋQLHZ\WUZDãHSU]HPLOF]DQLHWHMQLHZćWSOLZHMLQVSLUDFMLŋZLDGF]\RMHMRJURPQ\P ZSã\ZLHQDSyťQHPRG\ILNDFMHSURMHNWX+HLGHJJHUD3R]RVWDZLDMćFUR]VWU]\JQLĕFLHWHMKLSRWH]\ V]F]HJyãRZ\PVWXGLRP+HLGHJJHURZVNLPFKFLDãE\PRJUDQLF]\þVLĕWXGRZ\ND]DQLDVWUXNWXUDOQHM EOLVNRŋFLREXVSRVREyZP\ŋOHQLD . 3RU'Z,,VL =JRGQLH]NRQZHQFMćSU]\MĕWćZOLWHUDWXU]HWHPDWXRGZRãDQLDGR .D]Dĸ(FNKDUWDRSDWUXMĕVNUyWHP'ZQXPHUHPWRPXRUD]QXPHUHPVWURQ\ 0HLVWHU(FNKDUW'LH GHXWVFKHQ:HUNH3UHGLJWHQUHG-4XLQWW,,,,,6WXWWJDUW>RGSRZLHGQLR@² RGSRZLHGQLR'Z,'Z,,'Z,,,

(45) . Å1LHNWyU]\OXG]LHFKFćMHGQDNSDWU]HþQD%RJDRF]DPLWDNMDNSDWU]ćQDNURZĕLFKFć %RJDWDNNRFKDþMDNNRFKDMćNURZĕ.RFKDV]MćGODPOHNDLGODVHUDLGODWZRMHMZãDVQHMNRU]\ŋFL 7DNF]\QLćZV]\VF\OXG]LHNWyU\NRFKDMć%RJDGOD]HZQĕWU]QHJRERJDFWZDOXEGODZHZQĕWU]QHM SRFLHFK\&LQLHNRFKDMć%RJDZãDŋFLZLHOHF]NRFKDMćVZćZãDVQćNRU]\ŋþµ 'Z,V

(46) &\WDW\ z .D]DĸSRGDMĕZHZãDVQ\PSU]HNãDG]LH.

(47) Od epoché do Gelassenheit…. 111. ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLMHJRXWU]\PDQLHP7RZãDŋQLHWHQ%yJVWDMHVLĕZZ\NãDGQLILOR ]RILF]QHMPHWDIL]\F]Q\PDEVROXWHPNWyUHJRSRMDZLHQLHVLĕZREUĕELHP\ŋOHQLD VNXWHF]QLHXQLHPRŧOLZLDZHGãXJ+HLGHJJHUDPRŧOLZRŋþZQLNQLĕFLDZSUDZGĕ E\FLD %yJ GR NWyUHJR FKFH SURZDG]Lþ (FNKDUW QLH PD QLF ZVSyOQHJR ] WDNć QDGU]ĕGQć ÅRQWRWHRORJLF]Qćµ LQVWDQFMć L GODWHJR SRGREQLH MDN +HLGHJJHU (FNKDUW Z VSRVyE EDUG]R ]GHF\GRZDQ\ SRVWXOXMH MHM SRU]XFHQLH QD GURG]H GRSUDZG]LZHM%RVNRŋFL%LRUćFSRGXZDJĕVSRVyEZMDNLWHQPHWDIL]\F]Q\ Å%yJµSRMDZLDVLĕZP\ŋOHQLXMHJRRGU]XFHQLHPRŧOLZHEĕG]LHW\ONRSRSU]H] Z\MŋFLH]FRG]LHQQHMÅORJLNLKDQGOXµ]UDFMRQDOQRŋFLSR]\VNLZDQLDNRU]\ŋFL NWyUDPDXWUZDOLþLXPRFQLþFRG]LHQQH]DJURŧRQHWUZDQLHF]ãRZLHND(FNKDUW VWRVXMHUyŧQHJRURG]DMXRNUHŋOHQLDGODRSLVXWHJRXSUDJQLRQHJRVWDQX0yZL RNRQLHF]QRŋFLÅRGG]LHOHQLDµF]\WHŧÅRGRVREQLHQLDµ DEHJHVFKHLGHQKHLW) PyZLRE\FLXÅQLH]ZLć]DQ\PLZROQ\Pµ OHGLFXQGYUv)PyZLZUHV]FLHRE\FLX JHOk]HQF]\OLE\FLXZVWDQLHÅSR]RVWDZLHQLDVLHELHµNWyUHFKĕWQLHRNUHŋODWHŧ MDNRÅZ\MŋFLH]VLHELHµ331LHWUXGQRGRVWU]HFWXWĕVDPćVWUXNWXUĕNWyUćX+HLGHJ JHUDMHVWSRU]XFHQLHÅSLHUZV]HJRSRF]ćWNXµ:JUXQFLHU]HF]\ŋUHGQLRZLHF]QHPX 0LVWU]RZLFKRG]LERZLHPRSRU]XFHQLHSU]H]F]ãRZLHNDWHJRVSRVREXHJ]\VWR ZDQLDNWyU\SROHJDQDQLHXVWDQQHMWURVFHRZãDVQHÅE\FLHµ(FNKDUWQD]\ZDWHQ PRGXVHJ]\VWHQFMLÅ]UD]XL]Z\NOHµ]XSHãQLHRGUXFKRZ\LÅQDWXUDOQ\µQLH]Z\NOH ciekawym terminem HLJHQVFKDIW2]QDF]DRQWDNLVSRVyEE\FLDNWyU\ZREHF . 3RU0+HLGHJJHU2QWRWHRORJLF]QDVWUXNWXUDPHWDIL]\NLSU]Hã-0L]HUDÅ/RJRVL(WKRVµ QUV² . &]ãRZLHNRZL V]XNDMćFHPX %RVNRŋFL ² SRZLDGD (FNKDUW ² ÅQLH Z\VWDUF]D GREUR DQL PćGURŋþDQLVDP%yJ7DNRWRVDPDSUDZGD%yJZUyZQLHPDã\PVWRSQLXPXZ\VWDUF]DFRMDNLŋ NDPLHĸDOERMDNLHŋGU]HZRµ 'Z,,,V

(48) . Å*G\JãRV]ĕND]DQLDWURV]F]ĕVLĕRWRE\PyZLþRRGRVREQLHQLXPLDQRZLFLHŧHF]ãRZLHN SRZLQLHQE\þQLH]ZLć]DQ\«µ 'Z,,V

(49) . ÅF]ãRZLHNNWyU\MHVW]MHGQRF]RQ\]%RJLHP>«@SR]RVWDMHQLH]ZLć]DQ\LZROQ\ZHZV]\VW NLFKVZRLFKG]LHãDFKVSUDZLDMHW\ONR%RJXQDFKZDãĕQLHV]XNDVZHJRµ 'Z,V

(50) . Å.WRE\ZMHGQHMFKZLOLRSXŋFLãZV]\VWNRWHPXZV]\VWNRE\ãRE\GDQH*G\E\]DŋMDNLŋ F]ãRZLHNWUZDãSU]H]GZDG]LHŋFLDODWZZ\U]HF]HQLXDOHQDFKZLOĕSRQRZQLHSRVLDGãVLHELHWHQ QLJG\MHV]F]HQLHRSXŋFLãVLHELH>JHOk]HQ@µ 'Z,V²

(51) 33. Å%yJSUDJQLHWDNEDUG]RWHJRŧHE\ŋZ\V]HGã]VLHELHVDPHJR>«@MDNE\]DOHŧDãDRGWHJR FDãDMHJRV]F]ĕŋOLZRŋþµ 'Z,V

(52) . Å7\PUD]HPUR]XPLHPE\FLHPDãŧRQNLHPLQDF]HMWRFLZV]\VF\NWyU]\]ZLć]DQLVć]HLJHQ VFKDIWZPRGOLWZDFKSRVWDFKF]XZDQLDFKLZHZV]HONLHJRURG]DMX]HZQĕWU]Q\FKþZLF]HQLDFK LXPDUWZLHQLDFK-DNDNROZLHNHLJHQVFKDIWZMDNLPNROZLHNG]LHOH>«@RGELHUDZROQRŋþ>«@ SRGćŧDQLD]D%RJLHPVDP\Pµ 'Z,V²

(53) 3R]RVWDZLDPZSU]HNãDG]LHWHUPLQRU\JLQDOQ\ SRQLHZDŧQLHMHVWWRDQLÅZãDVQRŋþµDQLÅZãDŋFLZRŋþµ1DMFKĕWQLHMWãXPDF]\ãE\PWRSRMĕFLHQHR ORJL]PHPÅVZRMRŋþµMDNRR]QDF]HQLHRQWRORJLF]QRHJ]\VWHQFMDOQHMVWUXNWXU\ÅV]XNDQLDVZHJRµ.

(54) 112. Piotr Augustyniak. GRŋZLDGF]HQLDHJ]\VWHQFMDOQHMNUXFKRŋFLQDNLHURZXMHF]ãRZLHNDQDSU]\ZãDV] F]DQLHLSRGSRU]ćGNRZ\ZDQLHVRELHRWDF]DMćFHJRŋZLDWD.RQVHNZHQFMHWHJR VSRVREXE\FLDVćGDOHNRVLĕŧQH:HGãXJ(FNKDUWDGRW\F]ćFSU]HGHZV]\VWNLP OXG]NLHJRG]LDãDQLDZFRG]LHQQ\PŋZLHFLHGHWHUPLQXMHRQUyZQLHŧZROĕLLQWHOHNW F]ãRZLHND:RODF]ãRZLHNDNWyUHJRVSRVREHPE\FLDMHVWHLJHQVFKDIWWRFKFHQLH SRVLDGDQLDDMHJRSR]QDQLHWRVSRVyEZVWĕSQHJRZLUWXDOQHJRRSDQRZ\ZDQLD ŋZLDWDFRXPRŧOLZLDZNROHMQ\PNURNXMDNQDMEDUG]LHMQDPDFDOQćLZ\PLHUQć HNVSDQVMĕ(FNKDUWZVã\QQ\P.D]DQLXRSLVXMHSU]HNURF]HQLHRZHJRFRG]LHQ QHJRVSRVREXE\FLDMDNRUDG\NDOQHXEyVWZRZNWyU\PF]ãRZLHNQLHW\ONRQLFQLH PDDOHWHŧQLFQLHZLHLQLF]HJRQLHFKFH 7HQDNWUDG\NDOQHJRJHOk]HQF]\OLSR]RVWDZLHQLDVLHELH(FNKDUWEH]ZDKDQLD ZVSRVyEJRGQ\QDMZLĕNV]\FKPLVWU]yZGHNRQVWUXNFMLRSLVXMHMDNRÅŋPLHUþ F]ãRZLHNDµF]\OLNUHVWHJRSRGVWDZRZHJRQDVWDZLHQLDNWyUHQDZ\NOLŋP\XWRŧVD PLDþ]F]ãRZLHF]HĸVWZHP3R]RVWDZLHQLHVLHELHQLHMHVWMHGQDNR]QDNćMDNLHJRŋ HNVWUHPDOQHJRÅZ\REFRZDQLDµ.WR]GREĕG]LHVLĕQDWDNLUDG\NDOQ\VNRNSR]D FRG]LHQQHJRVLHELHWHQSRZLH(FNKDUWEĕG]LHVRELHVDPHPXSU]\ZUyFRQ\ ZVSRVyEEDUG]LHMťUyGãRZ\&]\PMHVWWRÅLQQHµE\FLHVREćQDNWyUHVLĕWX ZVND]XMH"(FNKDUWRSLVXMHMHZVSRVyEEDUG]RUDG\NDOQ\MDNRMHGQRŋþ]%RJLHP -HVWWRWDNLVSRVyEHJ]\VWRZDQLDZNWyU\PÅ%yJLMDMHVWHŋP\MHGQ\Pµ:W\P VSRVRELHE\FLDNWyU\PLDãE\þGRSLHURSXQNWHPZ\MŋFLDGRSRV]XNLZDĸXQLIL NDFML]%RJLHPREMĕW\FXG]\VãRZHPÅF]ãRZLHNµRGUD]X]QDMGXMHVLĕXFHOX 3DWU]\ERZLHPQDVLHELHLQDF]HMQLHRGVWURQ\GRWNOLZLHRGF]XZDQHMVNRĸF]R QRŋFLÅZãDVQHJRµE\FLDDOHRGVWURQ\VDPHM%RVNRŋFL:WHMSHUVSHNW\ZLH]MHG QRF]HQLH]%RJLHPWRQLHMDNLŋRQW\F]Q\SURFHVVFDODQLDGZXLVWRWSLHUZRWQLH RGUĕEQ\FKQLHRGZRãDOQLHSU]\ZLć]DQ\FKGRVDP\FKVLHELHDOHWRRGNU\FLHLFK ťUyGãRZHMMHGQRŋFLLZVSyãSU]\QDOHŧQRŋFL:WHMQRZHMSHUVSHNW\ZLH%yJQLH MHVWMXŧZŧDGQHMPLHU]HE\WHPRGUĕEQćZ\ŧV]ćLVWRWćDOHZV]HFKRJDUQLDMćF\P ťUyGãRZ\PGDU]ćF\PERVNLPE\FLHPVDP\P8ŋPLHUFRQ\ÅF]ãRZLHNµ F]ãR ZLHNNWyU\ÅXPDUãµMDNRSU]\ZLć]DQLHLRGQLHVLHQLHGRZãDVQHJRE\FLD

(55) RND]XMH . 3RU'Z,,V². . Å-DNLZLQLHQE\þF]ãRZLHNNWyU\FKFHRJOćGDþ%RJD"3RZLQLHQE\þPDUWZ\µ 'Z,,V

(56) . . Å.WRZWHQVSRVyEZ\MG]LH]VLHELHWHQEĕG]LHSU]\ZUyFRQ\VRELHZHZãDŋFLZ\VSRVyEµ 'Z,V

(57) . 'Z,V. . Å-HVWRQ>%yJ²3$@SRGVWDZćLREUĕF]ćZV]\VWNLFKVWZRU]Hĸµ 'Z,V

(58) Å,PEOLŧHM LJãĕELHMSR]QDMHVLĕ%RJDMDNRMHGQRW\PEDUG]LHMSR]QDMHVLĕJRMDNRNRU]Hĸ]NWyUHJRZ\URVã\ ZV]\VWNLHU]HF]\*G\SR]QDMHVLĕNRU]HĸMćGURLJUXQW%RVNRŋFLMDNRMHGQRZWHG\SR]QDMHVLĕ ZV]\VWNLHU]HF]\µ 'Z,,V

(59) Å.DŧGHVWZRU]HQLHZVRELHVDP\PMHVWQLF]\P>«@2WyŧSHZLHQ PLVWU]SRZLDGDŧHZV]\VWNLHVWZRU]HQLDSU]\MPXMćVZHE\FLHEH]SRŋUHGQLRRG%RJDµ 'Z, V

(60) Å-DWZLHUG]ĕZV]\VWNLHVWZRU]HQLDVćMHGQ\PE\FLHPµ 'Z,V

(61) .

(62) Od epoché do Gelassenheit…. 113. VLĕ]DŋÅXF]HVWQLNLHPµE\FLDVDPHJR-HVWVSRVREHPZMDNLRZD%RVNRŋþSR]R VWDMćFZVZ\PQLHRGZRãDOQ\PXNU\FLXZVNU\WRŋFLVZHJRÅRGRVREQLHQLDµURG]L VLĕLXMDZQLDVRELHVDPHM6NU\WD%RVNRŋþWRERZLHPZLHF]QHURG]HQLH6\QD SU]H]2MFDZ\SRZLDGDQLHVLĕZ6ãRZLHQLHZ\F]HUSDQHMWDMHPQLF\ VNU\WHJR 3RF]ćWNXÅ&]ãRZLHNµ]DŋZMHJRLQQ\PťUyGãRZ\PVSRVRELHE\FLDZVSyãURG]L VLĕZW\FKZLHF]Q\FKQDURG]LQDFKMDNRWRVDPR6ãRZRMDNR6\Q:WHQVSRVyE ÅF]ãRZLHNµWRQLFLQQHJRQLŧZ\GDU]HQLHP\ŋOHQLDNWyUHÅXREHFQLDµWRZLHF]QH PLVWHULXP%RVNRŋFLZŋZLHFLHMHJR]DSRPQLHQLD²ZŋZLHFLHE\WyZ]DWUDFRQ\FK Z]XSHãQLHRGUXFKRZ\PLQLH]DZLQLRQ\P]DLQWHUHVRZDQLXZãDVQ\PE\FLHP=D VSUDZćWHJRÅF]ãRZLHF]HJRµP\ŋOHQLDZV]\VWNLHLVWRW\VWDMćVLĕÅGRSHãQLRQHµRVLć JDMćVZyMťUyGãRZ\VHQVXF]HVWQLFWZDZ%RVNRŋFLE\FLD 2ND]XMHVLĕZLĕFŧHZRWFKãDQLDFK.D]Dĸ(FNKDUWDPDPLHMVFHUXFKNWyU\ GRNãDGQLHRGSRZLDGDVNRNRZLZÅLQQ\SRF]ćWHNµNLHG\WR'DVHLQ]XSHãQLH QLH]DWURVNDQHRVZRMHE\FLHVWDMHVLĕVSRVREHPZMDNLDOHWKHLF]QDSUDZGDE\FLD VDPHJRGDMHRVRELH]QDN&yŧWRMHGQDNR]QDF]D"&RVLĕWXZãDŋFLZLHG]LHMH" *G]LHVLĕ]QDOHťOLŋP\SRGćŧDMćFWURSHPW\FKQLHSU]\]ZRLW\FK]EOLŧHĸLDQDORJLL" &]\+HLGHJJHUWZRU]ćFSURMHNWUDG\NDOL]DFMLIHQRPHQRORJLLLZFLćŧJRSU]HIRU PXãRZXMćFQLHGRSURZDG]LãRVWDWHF]QLHGR]QLHVLHQLDMHMJUDQLFNWyUH+XVVHUO SURMHNWRZDãQLHMDNRFRŋ]DZĕŧDMćFHJRPRŧOLZRŋFLIHQRPHQRORJLLDOHXVWDQD ZLDMćFHJRMHMLVWRWĕ"=SHZQRŋFLć+HLGHJJHUGRNRQXMHWDNLHJRNURNXLQDF]HM-HVW ZLĕFEH]ZćWSLHQLD]GUDGćIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHMPHWRG\&]\QLHMHVWWRMHGQDNSU]\ VãRZLRZDÅEãRJRVãDZLRQDZLQDµG]LĕNLNWyUHMIHQRPHQRORJLDQLHMHVWW\ONRMHGQ\P ]NLHUXQNyZ;;ZLHF]QHMILOR]RILLDOHVDPćLVWRWćP\ŋOHQLDMHJRQDMZ\ŧV]ć RVWDWHF]QćPRŧOLZRŋFLć]DZV]HJRWRZćE\E\þSRGMĕWćLXU]HF]\ZLVWQLRQć7D PRŧOLZRŋþZ]\ZDUyZQLHŧREHFQLHGRSRGMĕFLDQDMZLĕNV]HJRU\]\NDNWyU\P MHVW]XSHãQHSU]HIRUPXãRZDQLHL]DU\]\NRZDQLHZãDVQHMHJ]\VWHQFMLZGćŧHQLXNX ÅF]HPXŋµ]XSHãQLHVNU\WHPXLQLHRVLćJDOQHPX&]\]UHV]WćWRťUyGãRLÅPLHMVFHµ . Å3RZLQLHQHŋFDãNRZLFLHZ\]E\þVLĕWZHMWZRMRŋFLLZSã\QćþZMHJRMHJRŋþDWZRMHWZRMH LMHJRMHJRSRZLQQ\VWDþVLĕMHGQ\PPRLPWDN]XSHãQLHDE\ŋZUD]]QLPZLHF]QLHSR]QDZDãMHJR QLHLVWQLHMćFćLVWQRŋþLMHJRQLHQD]ZDQćQLFRŋþµ 'Z,,,V²

(63) . Å*G\>«@6\QURG]LVLĕ]2MFDELHU]HVLĕWRVWćGŧH2MFLHFREMDZLDPXVZćWDMHPQLFĕµ 'Z,,V

(64) Å:>VZHM²3$@SãRGQRŋFL2MFLHFZ\SRZLDGDZVZRLPZLHF]Q\P6ãRZLH>«@ FDãNRZLFLHVZćZãDVQćQDWXUĕµ 'Z,,V²

(65) Å6\QMHVWREUD]HP%RJDSRQDGREUD]HPRQ MHVWREUD]HPMHJRVNU\WHM%RVNRŋFLµ 'Z,,,V²

(66) . Å3RZLHG]LDãHPZ3DU\ŧXZV]NROHŧHZV]\VWNLHU]HF]\]RVWDã\E\GRSHãQLRQHZSUDZG]L ZLHSRNRUQ\PF]ãRZLHNXµ 'Z,V

(67) Å2Q>%yJ@MHVWSLHUZV]ćVSUDZF]RŋFLćL]WHJRZ]JOĕGX SU]HOHZDVLĕZHZV]\VWNLHU]HF]\>«@-HVWRQWHŧQLH]ãRŧRQ\ZVZ\PE\FLX>«@7DNLMHVW%yJ DZV]\VWNLH]MHGQRF]RQH>ZVRELH@U]HF]\XWU]\PXMćVLĕZW\PF]\PRQMHVW7DPVWZRU]HQLDVć MHGQ\PZMHGQ\PL%RJLHPZ%RJXZQLFKVDP\FKVć]DŋQLF]\P>«@-HVWRQťUyGãHPLGODWHJR ZOHZDVLĕZHZV]\VWNLHU]HF]\>«@6]F]HJyOQLH]DŋZGXV]ĕUR]XPQćZMHM]GROQRŋFL>GRW\F]ćFHM@ ZV]\VWNLFKU]HF]\LZSU]\ZRG]HQLXVWZRU]HĸGRLFKSLHUZV]HJRťUyGãDµ 'Z,,,V²

(68) .

(69) 114. Piotr Augustyniak. ZV]HONLHJRE\WRZDQLDLZV]HONLHMMDZQRŋFLVDPRÅF]ãRZLHNDµQLHQDFKRG]LLQLH Z\WUćFD]FRG]LHQQHMÅUyZQRZDJLµ",F]\EH]QLHJRQDZHWQDMEDUG]LHM]DEH]SLH F]RQHLXWUZDORQHŧ\FLHPDMDNLNROZLHNVHQV"&]\QLHSR]RVWDMH]XSHãQćEH]P\ŋO QRŋFLć" Literatura $XJXVW\QLDN37UDQVFHQGHQWDOQ\VHQVRQWRORJLL+HLGHJJHUDÅ/RJRVL(WKRVµQU

(70) $XJXVW\QLDN3+HLGHJJHUD*UHF\0\ŋO3DUPHQLGHVDMDNRťUyGãRP\ŋOHQLDWUDQVFHQ GHQWDOQHJRÅ/RJRVL(WKRVµQU

(71) %DUDQ%6DJD+HLGHJJHUD.UDNyZ +HLGHJJHU0%\FLHLF]DVSU]Hã%%DUDQ:DUV]DZD +HLGHJJHU0.XU]HF]\P\ŋOHQLD:DUV]DZD +HLGHJJHU02GF]\W\LUR]SUDZ\SU]Hã-0L]HUD.UDNyZ +HLGHJJHU02QWRWHRORJLF]QDVWUXNWXUDPHWDIL]\NLSU]Hã-0L]HUDÅ/RJRVL(WKRVµ QU +HLGHJJHU03U]\F]\QNLGRILOR]RILL (=Z\GDU]DQLD

(72) SU]Hã%%DUDQL-0L]HUD.UDNyZ +HLGHJJHU0:\]ZROHQLHSU]Hã-0L]HUD.UDNyZ +HLGHJJHU0=DVDGDUDFMLSU]Hã-0L]HUD.UDNyZ +HLGHJJHU0=QDNLGURJL:DUV]DZD +XVVHUO(0HG\WDFMH.DUWH]MDĸVNLH=GRGDQLHPXZDJNU\W\F]Q\FK5RPDQD,QJDUGHQD :DUV]DZD 0HLVWHU(FNKDUW'LHGHXWVFKHQ:HUNH3UHGLJWHQUHG-4XLQWW,,,,,6WXWWJDUW>RGSR ZLHGQLR@ 0LFKDOVNL.+HLGHJJHULILOR]RILDZVSyãF]HVQD:DUV]DZD 3|JJHOHU2'URJDP\ŋORZD0DUWLQD+HLGHJJHUDSU]Hã%%DUDQ:DUV]DZD :HOWH%0HLVWHU(FNKDUW*HGDQNHQ]XVHLQHQ*HGDQNHQ)UHLEXUJ²%DVH²:LHQ :RG]LĸVNL&3DQ6RNUDWHV(VHMHWU]HFLH:DUV]DZD From Epoché to Gelassenheit – “The Mystical Sense” of Heidegger’s Radicalisation of Phenomenology 7KHDUWLFOHLVGHYRWHGWR+HLGGHJHU·VSURMHFWRIWKHUDGLFDOLVDWLRQRISKHQRPHQRORJ\ 0\EDVLFDLPLVWRVKRZWKHVWUXFWXUDOVLPLODULWLHVZKLFKRFFXUEHWZHHQWKLVSURMHFWDQG WKHP\VWLFDOWKRXJKWRI0DVWHU(FNKDUW)ROORZLQJWKLVOLQHRIWKLQNLQJ,DOVRDWWHPSW WRVKRZWKHSKLORVRSKLFDOUHOHYDQFHRI(FNKDUW·VWKRXJKWDQGXVHLWWRVKHGOLJKWRQWKH WRUWXRXVFRXUVHRI+HLGHJJHU·VSURMHFWZKLFKLVGLIILFXOWWRH[SOLFDWH$SUHVHQWDWLRQRI WKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWZRHVVHQWLDOWHUPVKROGVDQLPSRUWDQWSODFHLQWKHSDSHU2QHLV WKHFRQFHSWRIHSRFKpZKLFKLVNH\WRWKHWUDGLWLRQRISKHQRPHQRORJ\7KHRWKHULV*HODV VHQKHLWZKLFKLVFUXFLDOWR(FNKDUW·VGRFWULQH,QVKRUW,EHOLHYH+HLGHJJHU·VODWHUWKRXJKW ZDVDOVRDQDWWHPSWWRUDGLFDOLVH+XVVHUO·VSKHQRPHQRORJ\7KHSDWKRIWKLVUDGLFDOLVD WLRQFDQEHVFKHPDWLFDOO\WUHDWHGDVDQDWWHPSWWRGHHSHQDQGFURVV+XVVHUO·VFRQFHSWRI HSRFKpE\UHIHUHQFLQJWKHVWDWHRIEHLQJJHODVVHQDVGHVFULEHGE\&KDUW.

(73)