Some construction of optimum chemical balance weighing designs

(1)

! " # $ % & ' ( ) * & " " & * # + , - . & ( % * & * # /,+& #,(!,%,0&! ##1234#1565# !"#$%&'() *+"($,(-. /('0#"1(2( 3"(415, --#

**!"#$%!& '()%'!&$!+$!,'")"$%-#"*%./$**

**0./.&%#$1#2-&2$3# *2& $**

.4567896:#"78# 9:98;# <=>8?# @8;A:=B# B8C# @DB?A;E@A=DB# F8A7DG# HD;# D9A=FEF# @78F=@:I# J:I:B@8#

C8=<7=B<# G8?=<B?K# &A# EA=I=L8?# :# ;8I:A=DB# J8AC88B# A78# =B@=G8B@8# F:A;=@8?# DH# ACD# <;DE9# G=>=?=JI8# G8?=<B?#C=A7#A78#?:F8#:??D@=:A=DB#?@78F8#:BG#A78#G8?=<B#F:A;=M#DH#:#@78F=@:I#J:I:B@8#C8=<7=B<# G8?=<BK ;<=$>?7@5:$@78F=@:I#J:I:B@8#C8=<7=B<#G8?=<B4#<;DE9#G=>=?=JI8#G8?=<BK# # # *A$*&'(!3)%'*!&$ # *E99D?8#C8#:;8#<=>8B#6#DJN8@A?#AD#J8#C8=<78G#=B#$#C8=<7=B<?#DB#:#@78F=@:I# J:I:B@8K#"78#G8?=<B#F:A;=M#B#7:?#A78#8I8F8BA?#O64#6#D;#5#=H#A78#DJN8@A#=?#9I:@8G# DB# A78# I8HA# 9:B4# ;=<7A# 9:B4# D;# =?# BDA# =B@IEG8G# =B# A78# 9:;A=@EI:;# C8=<7=B<4# ;8?98@A=>8IPK# &H# B# =?# HEII# @DIEFB# ;:BQ4# A78# I8:?A# ?RE:;8?# 8?A=F:A8?# DH# A78# A;E8# C8=<7A?#:;8#<=>8B#JP## # # #

>

T

#

!

B

7

B

"6

B

S

=

# ####U6V# # C=A7#A78#>:;=:B@8#F:A;=M## # # #

!

S 1 6 1 V T ':;U 88 7 4 C % B B > #

$

" #

$

#

$

# ####U1V# #

C78;8#># =?# A78# @DIEFB# >8@AD;# DH# EBQBDCB# C8=<7A?# DH# 6# DJN8@A?# :BG# =# =?# A78# @DIEFB#>8@AD;#DH#;8?EIA?#=B#A78#$#C8=<7=B<?K#/;DF#WDA8II=B<#U6XYYV#C8#7:>8#

3<DEFE6E?F$ GA$ BP# BDB?=B<EI:;# C8=<7=B<# G8?=<B# =?# ?:=G# AD# J8# D9A=FEF# =H# 6 88 4 $#:BG#488S 54# S S 4 64 14KKK4 4 K 8 8 6 8! 8 # ################################################# Z #[;DH8??D;4#-89:;AF8BA#DH#0:A78F:A=@:I#:BG#*A:A=?A=@:I#08A7DG?4#[DLB:\#$B=>8;?=AP#DH#+=H8# *@=8B@8?K# ZZ

# [7K-K4# -89:;AF8BA# DH# 0:A78F:A=@:I# :BG# *A:A=?A=@:I# 08A7DG?4# [DLB:\# $B=>8;?=AP# DH# +=H8# *@=8B@8?K#

(2)

];DB=?^:C#!8;:BQ:4##0:^<D;L:A:#_;:@LPQ# 12`#

"78# 9;DJI8F# =?# AD# @7DD?8# A78# G8?=<B# F:A;=M# B# =B# ?E@7# :# C:P# A7:A# A78# >:;=:B@8# H:@AD;?# :;8# F=B=F=L8GK# *8>8;:I# F8A7DG?# DH# @DB?A;E@A=DB# DH# A78# G8?=<B# F:A;=M#B#:;8#:>:=I:JI8#=B#A78#I=A8;:AE;8K#-8P#U6Xa6V4#*:7:#U6Xa3V4#b:<8P:F:#:BG# *:7:# U6Xc2V4# !8;:BQ:# :BG# b:AEI?Q:# U6XccV# :BG# DA78;?# 7:>8# ?7DCB# 7DC# A78# D9A=FEF# @78F=@:I# J:I:B@8# C8=<7=B<# G8?=<B# @:B# J8# @DB?A;E@A8G# H;DF# A78# =B@=G8B@8#F:A;=@8?#DH#A78#J:I:B@8G#=B@DF9I8A8#JID@Q#G8?=<B?K##

&B#A78#9;8?8BA#9:98;#C8#?AEGP#:#F8A7DG#DH#@DB?A;E@A=DB#DH#A78#G8?=<B#F:A;=M# B#HD;#:#@78F=@:I#J:I:B@8#C8=<7=B<#G8?=<B#HD;#:#H=M8G#BEFJ8;#6##DH#DJN8@A?#:BG# :#H=M8G# BEFJ8;# $# DH# C8=<7=B<?K# &A# =?# J:?8G# DB# ACD# =B@=G8B@8# F:A;=@8?# DH# A78# <;DE9# G=>=?=JI8# G8?=<B?# C=A7# A78# ?:F8# :??D@=:A=DB# ?@78F8# EBG8;# A78# ?DF8# @DBG=A=DBK##

# #

**A$%!& '()%'*!&$!+$'-#$3# *2&$".'(*B$ #

B# =B@DF9I8A8# JID@Q# G8?=<B# =?# ?:=G# AD# J8# 9:;A=:IIP# J:I:B@8G# C=A7# ACD# :??D@=:A8#@I:??8?#=H#A78#8M98;=F8BA:I#F:A8;=:I#=?#G=>=G8G#=BAD# 9#JID@Q?#DH#,#EB=A?# 8:@74#G=HH8;8BA#A;8:AF8BA?#J8=B<#:99I=8G#AD#A78#EB=A?#=B#A78#?:F8#JID@Q4#A78;8#:;8#

!

, : % #A;8:AF8BA?#:BG#8:@7#D@@E;?#=B#"#JID@Q?K#"78;8#@:B#J8#8?A:JI=?7#:#;8I:A=DB# DH#:??D@=:A=DB#J8AC88B#:BP#ACD#A;8:AF8BA?#?:A=?HP=B<#A78#HDIIDC=B<#;8RE=;8F8BA?d# ACD#A;8:AF8BA?#:;8#8=A78;#H=;?A#:??D@=:A8?#D;#?8@DBG#:??D@=:A8?4#8:@7#A;8:AF8BA#7:?# 8M:@AIP# $_% %A7# :??D@=:A8?4# % 64 1K# /D;# :BP# ACD# A;8:AF8BA?# C7=@7# :;8#

%

A7# :??D@=:A8?#A78#BEFJ8;#DH#A;8:AF8BA#@DFFDB#AD#A78#

8

A7#:??D@=:A8#DH#A78#H=;?A#:BG# A78# ,A7# :??D@=:A8# DH# A78# ?8@DBG# =?# 6%_8,# :BG# =A?# =BG898BG8BA# DH# A78# 9:=;# DH# A;8:AF8BA?#C8#?A:;A#C=A7K# I?D#6%_8, 6%_,84 4 4% 8 , 64 1K#"CD#A;8:AF8BA?#C7=@7#:;8#

%

A7# :??D@=:A8# D@@E;# AD<8A78;# =B# 8M:@AIP#

&

_%# JID@Q?K# "78# BEFJ8;?# 1 6 1 64 4 4 4 4 4 49 " , $ $

&

: #:;8#@:II8G#A78#9:;:F8A8;?#DH#A78#H=;?A#Q=BG4#C78;8:?#6%_8,# :;8# @:II8G# A78# 9:;:F8A8;?# DH# A78# ?8@DBG# Q=BGK# # <;DE9# G=>=?=JI8# G8?=<B# =?# :# 9:;A=:IIP#J:I:B@8G#=B@DF9I8A8#JID@Q#G8?=<B#C=A7#ACD#:??D@=:A8#@I:??8?#HD;#C7=@7# A78#:# A;8:AF8BA?# F:P# J8# G=>=G8G# =BAD#;# <;DE9?# DH#

<

# G=?A=B@A# A;8:AF8BA?# 8:@7# ?E@7# A7:A# A;8:AF8BA?# J8IDB<=B<# AD# A78# ?:F8# <;DE9# :;8# H=;?A# :??D@=:A8?# :BG# ACD# A;8:AF8BA?# J8IDB<=B<# AD# G=HH8;8BA# <;DE9?# :;8# ?8@DBG# :??D@=:A8?K# e8# 7:>8#

!

6 4 6 4 ₆ # " ₁ # " #;< $ < $ < ; : # <"6

!

&

₆' ;"6

!

&

₁ #" ,"6

!

K# !DB?=G8;# ACD# <;DE9# G=>=?=JI8# G8?=<B?# C=A7# A78# 9:;:F8A8;?#

1 4 6 4 4 4 4 4 4

9 "

,

₆ ₁

2

#

:

₂ ₂ ₂

&

₂

&

₂ K#e8#:??EF8#A7:A#:??D@=:A=DB#?@78F8#=?#A78#?:F8#

:BG#:GG=A=DB:IIP#

&

₆₆ '

&

₆₁ #

&

₁₆ '

&

₁₁ #

&

K#+8A#&₂#G8BDA8#A78#J=B:;P#F:A;=M#DH# D;G8;#

:

(

9

₂4

2

#641K#"78B#EBG8;#DE;#:??EF9A=DB#

(3)

*DF8#!DB?A;E@A=DB#DH#,9A=FEF#!78F=@:I#]:I:B@8#e8=<7=B<#-8?=<B?$ _12a#

# # &₆&₆S '&₁&S₁ # "₆'"₁ "

&

!

*_: '

&

G_:G_:S 4# ####U2V#

#

C78;8#*_:#G8BDA8?#A78#=G8BA=AP#F:A;=M#DH#D;G8;#:#:BG#G_:#G8BDA8?#A78#:(6#>8@AD;# C=A7#A78#EB=A#8I8F8BA?#8>8;PC78;8K#"78B# # # # ) ) * + , , -. " " # _S _S 1 S S 6 1 6 1 1 : 9 : 9 G G & G G & B # ####UYV# #

=?# A78# G8?=<B# F:A;=M# DH# :# @78F=@:I# J:I:B@8# C8=<7=B<# G8?=<BK# &B# A7=?# G8?=<B#

:

6 #

#:BG#$#9₆'9₁K#

'H<?7<I$ GA# /D;# :# BDB?=B<EI:;# @78F=@:I# J:I:B@8# C8=<7=B<# G8?=<B# C=A7#

B

# <=>8B#JP#UYV#8?A=F:A8G#C8=<7A?#:;8#EB@D;;8I:A8G#=H#:BG#DBIP#=H## # # # 9₆'9₁ #Y "₆'"₁ "

&

!

K# ####U3V# # [;DDHK#/D;#A78#G8?=<B#F:A;=M#

B

#<=>8B#JP#UYV#C8#7:>8# # # # BSB# 9₆'9₁ "(

!

*_: '(G_:G_:S 4# ####U`V# # C78;8#(#9₆'9₁ "Y "₆'"₁ "

&

!

K#/;DF#U`V#C8#7:>8# # # #

!

)_* + , -. " ' ' " " ' # " _S 1 6 1 6 6 S 6 6 : : : : ( 9 9 ( ( 9 9 * G G B B K# ####UaV# #

":Q=B<# =BAD# @DB?=G8;:A=DB# UaV# C8# 7:>8# !D>

)

T₈4

)

T₈S

!

#5# HD;# #

S

4 6414KKK4 4

8 8 :#

S

8 !

8

=H# :BG# DBIP# =H# (#5K# ]EA4# H;DF# =A?# G8H=B=A=DB# (#5# =H# :BG# DBIP# =H#

!

&

" ' # ' ₁ ₆ ₁ 6 9 Y " " 9 K#W8B@8#A78#"78D;8FK##

&H# 8?A=F:A8G# C8=<7A?# :;8# EB@D;;8I:A8G# A78B#

" #

1 6 1 T ':; )₈ 4 9 $9 # 64 14KKK4 K 8 : "7E?#H;DF#-8H=B=A=DB#6#:BG#"78D;8F#6#C8#7:>8K#

%?7?JJ87=$ GA$ &H# A78# @DBG=A=DB# U3V# 7DIG?# A78B# :# @78F=@:I# # J:I:B@8# C8=<7=B<# G8?=<B#C=A7#

B

#<=>8B#JP#UYV#=?#D9A=F:IK#

# #

(4)

];DB=?^:C#!8;:BQ:4##0:^<D;L:A:#_;:@LPQ# 12c#

***A$2(!),$3*K* *0/#$3# *2& $/#.3*&2$'!$!,'*")"$ 1#*2-*&2$3# *2& $

#

e8# 7:>8# ?88B# =B# !D;DII:;P# 6# A7:A# =H# A78# 9:;:F8A8;?# DH# ACD# <;DE9# G=>=?=JI8# G8?=<B?# ?:A=?HP# A78# @DBG=A=DB# U3V# A78B# :# @78F=@:I# J:I:B@8# C8=<7=B<# G8?=<B# C=A7#

B

# <=>8B# JP# UYV# =?# D9A=F:IK# $BG8;# A7=?# @DBG=A=DB# A78# I=?A# DH# :II# 9:;:F8A8;?# @DFJ=B:A=DB?# DH# A78# 8M=?A=B<# <;DE9# G=>=?=JI8# G8?=<B?# C=A7# A78# ?:F8# :??D@=:A=DB# ?@78F8# :BG# HD;# !₆₆_$!₆₁ !₁₆_$!₁₁ !4_{# =B# A78# ;:B<8#} _:_%_X54_# ₆₅₅₄ 2 9 % # 4 654 2 2 " , % #2 64 1#U!I:ACD;A7P4#6Xa2V#=?#<=>8B#=B#":JI8#6K# # # ":JI8#6K# # e8=<7=B<# G8?=<B# /=;?A#<;DE9#G=>=?=JI8#G8?=<B# *8@DBG#<;DE9#G=>=?=JI8#G8?=<B# 6# 1# 2# Y# 3# `# a# c# X# 65# 66# 61# 62# 6Y# 63# 6`# 6 $# )8H8;8B@8?#

BEFJ8;# : 9 "# , &6 &1

)8H8;8B@8?

BEFJ8;# : 9 "# , &6# &1#

c# 61# *6c# c# Y# 2# ` 2# 1# )3Y# c# c# 2# 2# 5# 6# c# 61# *6c# c# Y# 2# ` 2# 1# )62Y# c# c# 3# 3# 1# 2# c# 6`# *6X# c# c# `# ` `# Y# *)2`# c# c# Y# Y# 5# 1# c# 1Y# *6X# c# c# `# ` `# Y# )33# c# 6` `# 2# 5# 1# c# 1Y# *6X# c# c# `# ` `# Y# )62`# c# 6` 65# 3# Y# `# c# 1Y# *15# c# 61# X# ` X# `# *)2a# c# 61 `# Y# 5# 2# c# 1Y# *)2c# c# 61# `# Y 1# 2# )6`Y# c# 61 X# `# a# `# c# 2`# *15# c# 61# X# ` X# `# )3a# c# 1Y X# 2# 5# 2# c# 2`# )3c# c# 1Y# X# 2 1# 2# )6`Y# c# 61 X# `# a# `# X# 61# *16# X# 2# 1# ` 1# 6# *)12# X# X# 2# 2# 5# 6# X# 61# *16# X# 2# 1# ` 1# 6# *)`3# X# X# `# `# 2# Y# X# 1Y# *16# X# 2# 1# ` 1# 6# )`1# X# 16 a# 2# 6# 1# X# 1Y# *11# X# `# Y# ` Y# 1# *)1Y# X# 6c `# 2# 5# 1# X# 1Y# *)12# X# X# 2# 2 5# 6# )3X# X# 63 3# 2# 1# 6# X# 1Y# *)12# X# X# 2# 2 5# 6# )6`3# X# 63 65# `# a# `# X# 1Y# *)`3# X# X# `# ` 2# Y# )3X# X# 63 3# 2# 1# 6# X# 1Y# *)`3# X# X# `# ` 2# Y# )6`3# X# 63 65# `# a# `# X# 2`# *12# X# X# `# ` `# 2# *)13# X# 1a X# 2# 5# 2# X# 2`# *)12# X# X# 2# 2 5# 6# )`3# X# 1a X# 2# 2# 1# X# 2`# *)1Y# X# 6c# `# 2 5# 1# )`5# X# 6c `# 2# 2# 6# X# 2`# *)`3# X# X# `# ` 2# Y# )`3# X# 1a X# 2# 2# 1# X# 2`# )3X# X# 63# 3# 2 1# 6# )`1# X# 16 a# 2# 6# 1# X# 2`# )`1# X# 16# a# 2 6# 1# )6`3# X# 63 65# `# a# `#

X# Yc# *)1Y# X# 6c# `# 2 5# 1# )`a# X# 25 65# 2# Y# 1#

X# Yc# )`1# X# 16# a# 2 6# 1# )`3# X# 1a X# 2# 2# 1#

X# Yc# *)13# X# 1a# X# 2 5# 2# )`6# X# 16 a# 2# Y# 6#

X# Yc# )`5# X# 6c# `# 2 2# 6# )`c# X# 25 65# 2# 6# 2#

61# 6`# *c1# 61# Y# 2# X 2# 1# )6Y3# 61# 61 3# 3# 6# 1#

(5)

*DF8#!DB?A;E@A=DB#DH#,9A=FEF#!78F=@:I#]:I:B@8#e8=<7=B<#-8?=<B?$ _12X# ":JI8#6#U@DBAKV#

6# 1# 2# Y# 3# `# a# c# X# 65# 66# 61# 62# 6Y# 63# 6`#

61# 1Y# *1a# 61# `# 2# `# 2# 6# *)Y1# 61# 6c# `# Y# 5# 1#

61# 21# *)``# 61# c# Y# `# 5# 1# )665# 61# 1Y# c# Y# Y# 1# 61# 2`# )665# 61# 1Y# c# Y# Y# 1# )6YY# 61# 61# 3# 3# 5# 1# 61# 2`# )665# 61# 1Y# c# Y# Y# 1# )6a3# 61# 61# a# a# 1# Y# 6c# 1Y# *2a# 6c# 61# Y# `# Y# 6# *)XX# 6c# 61# `# X# 5# 2# 6c# 2`# *)a1# 6c# 6c# `# `# 5# 1# )6X`# 6c# 6c# X# X# `# Y# 15# 2`# *)6`a# 15# 6`# c# 65 5# Y# )6c5# 15# 15# a# a# `# 1# # # (#+#(#&%# $ #

!8;:BQ:# ]K4# b:AEI?Q:# bK# U6XccV4# f,B# @DB?A;E@A=DB# DH# D9A=FEF# @78F=@:I# J:I:B@8# C8=<7=B<# G8?=<B?Kg#hK#&BG=:B#*A:A=?AK# ??K#1`4#1aO25K# !I:ACD;A7P#eKW4#U6Xa2V4#f":JI8?#DH#ACDi:??D@=:A8i@I:??#9:;A=:IIP#J:I:B@8G#G8?=<B?Kg#%]*# 99I=8G# 0:A78F:A=@?#*8;=8?#`2K# -8P# K#U6Xa6V4#j,B#?DF8#@78F=@:I#J:I:B@8#C8=<7=B<#G8?=<B?Kg# E?A;:IK#hK#*A:A=?AK#624##62aO6Y6K# WDA8II=B<#WK#U6XYYV4#j*DF8#=F9;D>8F8BA?#=B#C8=<7=B<#:BG#DA78;#8M98;=F8BA:I#A8@7B=RE8?Kg# BBK# 0:A7K#*A:A=?AK#634#1XaO25`K#

b:<8P:F:# *K4# *:7:# _K0K# U6Xc2V4# j%DA8# DB# A78# @DB?A;E@A=DB# DH# D9A=FEF# @78F=@:I# J:I:B@8# C8=<7=B<#G8?=<B?Kg# BBK#&B?AK#*A:A=?AK#0:A7K#23# 4#YYaOY31K#

*:7:# _K0K# U6Xa3V4# j # BDA8# DB# ;8I:A=DB# J8AC88B# =B@DF9I8A8# JID@Q# :BG# C8=<7=B<# G8?=<B?Kg# BBK# &B?AK#*A:A=?AK#0:A7K#1a4#2caO2X5K# # # # !"#$%&'() *+"($,(. /('0#"1(2( 3"(415, # ,#1&#$;!& '();%L#$!,'M"./&M%-$%-#"*%N&M%-$);O.3P1$ 1.2!1M%-$ $

e# 9;:@P# 9DG:BD# BDCk# F8ADGl# QDB?A;EQ@N=# D9APF:IBP@7# @78F=@LBP@7# EQ^:GmC# C:<DCP@7# CPQD;LP?AENk@8# ;8I:@N8# 9DF=lGLP# F:@=8;L:F=# =B@PG8B@N=# @Lln@=DCD# L;mCBDC:oDBP@7# EQ^:GmC# D#JIDQ:@7# B=8QDF9I8ABP@7# L# 9DGL=8IBPF=# <;E9:F=# D# A:Q=@7# ?:FP@7# ?@78F:A:@7# 9:;AB8;?AC:# :#F:@=8;Lk#@78F=@LB8<D#EQ^:GE#C:<DC8<DK#

Some construction of optimum chemical balance weighing designs

!"#$%!& '()%'*!&$!+$!,'*")"$%-#"*%./$

0./.&%#$1#*2-*&2$3# *2& $

>

T

#

!

B

B

B

=

!

!

$

$

$

!

%

8

%

&

&

&

<

!

!

&

!

&

!

9

"

,

2

:

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

:

9

2

&

!

&

:

6 #

B

&

!

B

!

&

!

!

!

)

)

!

8

!

8

!

&

" #

B

B

**!"#$%!& '()%'!&$!+$!,'")"$%-#"*%./$**

**0./.&%#$1#2-&2$3# *2& $**