...
(First name and family name of reviewer, scientific title)
...
...
(address)
Review
of the paper intended for publication in the journal
POLITYKA ENERGETYCZNA (Energy Policy Journal)
Title of the paper:...
...
...
A. Evaluation of the paper’s content:
1. Does the paper include new scientific content or value of utility (specify to what extent)?...Y/N
……….
2. Are the assumptions and methodology of work properly adopted?... Y/N 3. Is the correct terminology used? ...Y/N 4. Are the SI units applied consistently?... Y/N 5. Does the title of the paper correspond to its content?... Y/N 6. Does the abstract capture the essence of the paper?... Y/N 7. Is the illustrative material (tab., fig.) properly selected and not repetitive?………. Y/N 8. Is the choice of cited literature accurate and sufficient?... Y/N 9. Conclusion:
9.1. The paper is suitable for publication... Y/N 9.2. The paper may be published after considering the comments made in
the review process...Y/N 9.3. The paper is not suitable for publication... Y/N
Verte!
B. Short justification (please express remarks and comments that should be considered by the authors to receive a positive review)
... ...
(place, date) (signature)
Please send the signed review to the address:
Prof. Eugeniusz Mokrzycki
Mineral and Energy Economy Research Institute PAN Wybickiego 7
31-261 Krakow POLAND
or send the scanned document to the email address: mokrzy@min-pan.krakow.pl
