...
(First name and family name of reviewer, scientific title)
...
...
(address)
Review
of the paper intended for publication in the journal
ZESZYTY NAUKOWE
Instytutu Gospodarki Surowcami Mineralnymi i Energią PAN
Title of the paper:...
...
...
A. Evaluation of the paper’s content:
1. Does the paper include new scientific content or value of utility (specify to what extent)?...Y/N
……….
2. Are the assumptions and methodology of work properly adopted?... Y/N 3. Is the correct terminology used? ...Y/N 4. Are the SI units applied consistently?... Y/N 5. Does the title of the paper correspond to its content?... Y/N 6. Does the abstract capture the essence of the paper?... Y/N 7. Is the illustrative material (tab., fig.) properly selected and not repetitive?………. Y/N 8. Is the choice of cited literature accurate and sufficient?... Y/N 9. Conclusion:
9.1. The paper is suitable for publication... Y/N 9.2. The paper may be published after considering the comments made in
the review process...Y/N 9.3. The paper is not suitable for publication... Y/N
Verte!
Zeszyty Naukowe
Instytutu Gospodarki Surowcami Mineralnymi i Energią PAN
B. Short justification (please express remarks and comments that should be considered by the authors to receive a positive review)
... ...
(place, date) (signature)
Please send the signed review to the address:
Lidia Gawlik
Mineral and Energy Economy Research Institute PAN Wybickiego 7
31-261 Krakow POLAND
or send the scanned document to the email address: lidia.gawlik@min-pan.krakow.pl
