• Nie Znaleziono Wyników

View of THE SPECIFICITY OF LEGAL AND METHODOLOGICAL CONDITIONS OF THE HISTORIC PROPERTIES VALUATION

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "View of THE SPECIFICITY OF LEGAL AND METHODOLOGICAL CONDITIONS OF THE HISTORIC PROPERTIES VALUATION"

Copied!
13
0
0

Pełen tekst

(1)

!"#$%&'()*"+),-%$.*'*/#0121314'$5-%$.*6,)+6-(1,)7*,%$#-%*-'#+6$.1/18$'999 !"

!"#$% &"'(% )*+(,% !-.'/'0#1$#'*% 2*"*13.% 45678% 9:4;,% <4=>7

# $ % & ' ($ ) (* ) % & ' + ) , $ & , - . / (0 (1 ) % % & ' + ) , $ / , 2 (3 4 5 6 ) % 7 (8 3 , 4 ' 9 (8 3 ' / : ' * / ; (< , / = & % ' > 5 & 5 (?3 % @ / : ' * ) A A B 3 9 4 % ' * / (= (C D ' 9 5 > , / & ; (E 3 5 & $ % 3 (F ) ' + ) $ 3 % * / (G / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / 3 @ / (/ (I ) 9 = ) . 4 (I & 2 / ) , 3 D , & 2 ) ; 4D J(I J(K% 3 =)- 6& :' */ & 2)("L;("MA NOM(CD ' 9 5 >,;(& A @ 3 / D 7 (P3 ' Q4=@ J& $4J+D

R 1 ) + > % / 2 6 5 (P > (?> $ 3 = , / - 5 = ) (< , / = & % ' > 5 & 5 4 (?3 % @ / : ' * ) A B 3 9 4 % ' * / & 2 ) (= (C D ' 9 5 > , / & ; (C D ' 9 5 > , OM"L

!"#$%&'()*"+),-%$.*'*/#0121314'$5-%$.

6,)+6-(1,)7*,%$#-%*-'#+6$.1/18$' 1*$.)+)(0#+5#*5)9%0(1,%/

83,4'9(83'/:'*/

<,/=&%'>5&5( ?3%@/:'*)AB394%'*/( =( CD'95>,/&

!:;<=>?><@A<B*?3 % 5 ) H S (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / () (- 6 3 % 3 * 5 & % 9 & (9 3 P > 5 * ) = > @ (= > 9 , 3 - 9 3 (, / & (5 > D * ) /-6(=3%5)HS(@35&%/3D,3;(3D&(%T=,/&U(6/'5)%>-9,3;(,34*)=3(-9>(5&U(3%5>'5>-9,3;(-)(=(+)A V W - 9 & ,/ 4(9 ($4U >@ (9 % TU ,/ - )=3 ,/ & @ (% )$9 3 . )=>@ (/ (. 3 *)H - / )=>@ (' 5 3 ,)=/ ()(' +& - >X / - & (=>A - & , > (5 & 2 ) (' & 2 @ & , 5 4 (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / J (K % 9 & * V 3 $ 3 (' / Y (5 ) (5 3 * U & (, 3 (= > @ T 2 (+ ) ' / 3 $ 3 , / 3 (+ % 9 & 9

% 9 & - 9 ) 9 , 3 = - Y (@ 3 . W 5 * ) = & 2 ) (= / & $ 9 > (' + & - . 3 D , & . () % 3 9 (/ , $ > = / $ 4 3 D , & 2 ) (+ ) $ & . H - / 3 ; (. 3 * (% T = A , / & U (' 9 - 9 & 2 T D , & . (' 5 3 % 3 , , ) H - / (+ % 9 > (= > P ) % 9 & (/ (% & 3 D / 9 3 - . / (+ % ) - & $ 4 % > (= > - & , >J (? (3 % 5 > * 4 D &

$ ) * ) , 3 , ) (9 3 % T = , ) (3 , 3 D / 9 > (4 = 3 % 4 , * ) = 3 : (+ % 3 = , > - 6 (/ (@ & 5 ) $ ) D ) 2 / - 9 , > - 6 (= > - & , > (, / & % 4 A - 6 ) @ ) H - / () (- 6 3 % 3 * 5 & % 9 & (9 3 P> 5 * ) = > @ ; (. 3 * (/ () @ T = / & , / 3 (- & - 6 (/ (- 9 > , , / * T = (= + V > = 3 . W - > - 6 , 3 (/ - 6 (= 3 % 5 ) H S J (? (3 , 3 D / 9 / & (= > * 3 9 3 , ) ; (U & (X 4 , * - . ) , 4 . W - & (= (K ) D ' - & (4 % & 2 4 D ) = 3 , / 3 (+ % 3 = , &

) % 3 9 (= > 5 > - 9 , & (@ & 5 ) $ ) D ) 2 / - 9 , & ($ ) 5 > - 9 3 - & (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / (9 3 P > 5 * ) = > - 6 (= > @ 3 2 3 . W (+ / D A , > - 6 (9 @ / 3 , (/ (4 9 4 + & V , / & : J (? (+ % 3 = ) $ 3 = ' 5 = / & (, / & (= ' * 3 9 3 , ) (- 9 > , , / * T =; (* 5 T % & (, 3 D & U >

4 = 9 2 D Y $ , / S ; () * % & H D 3 . W - (= 3 % 5 ) H S (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / (= + / ' 3 , > - 6 ($ ) (% & . & ' 5 % 4 (9 3 P > 5 * T = (9 (9 3 ' 5 ) A ' ) = 3 , / & @ (+ ) $ & . H - / 3 (@ / & ' 9 3 , & 2 ) (/ (* ) ' 9 5 ) = & 2 ) J (G / & (= ' * 3 9 3 , ) (% T = , / & U (9 3 ' 3 $ (= > - & , >

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

!CDEF* GHI?>DE<J *9 3 P > 5 & * ; (- & - 6 > (% > , * ) = & ; (= > - & , 3 ; (= 3 % 5 ) H S (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / () (- 6 3 A

% 3 * 5 & % 9 & (9 3 P > 5 * ) = > @

,!0K"

]3*5;( U&( ,/&%4-6)@)H-/( )( -63%3*5&%9&( 93P>5*)=>@( @)2W( P>S( /( 'W( +%9&$@/)5&@( )P%)54

%>,*)=&2)(=/WU&('/Y(9(=>'5Y+4.W-W(+)5%9&PW(/-6(=>-&,>J(C*%&HD),3(=3%5)HS(5>-6(,/&%4A -6)@)H-/;( PY$W-3( =>,/*/&@( +%9&+%)=3$9),&.( +%9&9( %9&-9)9,3=-Y( @3.W5*)=&2)( +%)-&$4% >

^ _ _ G (" ! ` ` A M N ` a

^ _ _ G (O ` L M A M N N " ([ ) , D / , & \ 6 5 5 + 7 b b = > $ 3 = , / - 5 = ) J 4 = @ J & $ 4 J + D

(2)

F)-6;5*F);'7;('

!O

=>-&,>;( =/,,3( )P&.@)=3S( 93%T=,)( /-6( =3%5)HS( @35&%/3D,W( [4U>5*)=W\;( .3*( %T=,/&U( =3%A 5)HS(,/&@35&%/3D,W([=3%5)HS(6/'5)%>-9,W;(,34*)=W(/(3%5>'5>-9,W\J(Z3'5)')=3,/&(=V3H-/A

=&.(+%)-&$4%>(=>-&,>;(=('9-9&2TD,)H-/(=(93*%&'/&()*%&HD3,/3(/-6(=3%5)H-/(,/&@35&%/3DA ,>-6;( =>@323( )$( %9&-9)9,3=->( @3.W5*)=&2)( +)'/3$3,/3( =/&$9>( '+&-.3D,&.J( C( '+&->X/-&

=>-&,>('53,)=/(53*U&(X3*5;(=>'5Y+4.W->(=(=/&D4(+%9>+3$*3-6(P%3*(,)5)=3:(-&,)=>-6

$ D 3 (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / (+ ) $ ) P , > - 6 (+ ) = ) $ 4 . & ; (U & (% > , & * (5 & 2 ) (' & 2 @ & , 5 4 (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / (. & ' 5 )2%3,/-9),>J(C2%3,/-9&,/3(=(93*%&'/&()P%)54(=>,/*3.W(53*U&(9(+%9>'V424.W-&2)(2@/,/&

+%3=3(+/&%=)*4+4;(92)$,/&(9(93+/'&@(3%5J("Ma;(4'5(";(+*5(`J(<'53=>()(2)'+)$3%-&(,/&%4A -6)@)H-/3@/(cd9J<J("aaN;(,%(""L(+)9J(N`";(5J.J(d9J<J(9(OM"L(%J(+)9J(NeO;(aeL;("MfagJ

Z 3 ' 3 $ , / - 9 > @ (- & D & @ (+ % & 9 & , 5 ) = 3 , & 2 ) (3 % 5 > * 4 V 4 (. & ' 5 ($ ) * ) , 3 , / & (3 , 3 D / 9 > (X 4 , * - . ) , 4 . W A ->-6((=(K)D'-&(4=3%4,*)=3:(+%3=,>-6(/(@&5)$)D)2/-9,>-6(=(93*%&'/&()*%&HD3,/3(=3%A 5)H-/(,/&%4-6)@)H-/()(-63%3*5&%9&(93P>5*)=>@J(h3$3,/3@/('9-9&2TV)=>@/()P.Y5)(3*5>

+%3=,&;(*5T%>-6(93+/'>(=/WUW('/Y(9(+%)PD&@35>*W(=>-&,>(5>-6(,/&%4-6)@)H-/J(Z3D/-9),)

$)(,/-67(<'53=Y(9($,/3(Of(D/+-3(OMMf(%J()()-6%),/&(93P>5*T=(/()+/&-&(,3$(93P>5*3@/

cd9J<J( 9( OMMf;( ,%( "!O;( +)9J"L!e;( 5J.J( d9J<J( 9( OM"`;( +)9J"``!( =%39( +TiJ( 9@Jg;( <'53=Y( 9( $,/3 O " (' / & % + , / 3 (" a a N (%J () (2 ) ' + ) $ 3 % - & (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / 3 @ / (c d 9 J < J (9 (" a a N ; (, % ("" L ; (+ ) 9 J (N ` " ; 5J.J( d9J<J( 9( OM"L( =%39( +TiJ( 9@Jg( )%39( I)9+)%9W$9&,/&( I3$>( B/,/'5%T=( 9( $,/3( O"( =%9&H,/3 OMM`(%J(=('+%3=/&(=>-&,>(,/&%4-6)@)H-/(/('+)%9W$93,/3()+&%354('93-4,*)=&2)(cd9J<J 9(OMM`;(,%(OMN;(+)9J(O"Ma;(d9J<J(9(OMML;(,%("a!;(+)9J("!Oe(/(d9J<J(9(OM"";(,%("!L;(+)9J(aeLgJ

#,3D/9W(93+/'T=(=>,/*3.W->-6(9(X4,*-.),4.W->-6()+%3-)=3:(@&5)$)D)2/-9,>-6(=(5>@

9 3 * % & ' / & () P . Y 5 ) 7 (j> @ - 9 3 ' ) = W (, ) 5 Y (/ , 5 & % + % & 5 3 - > . , W (k ?> - & , 3 (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ ) H - / (9 3 P > 5 * ) A

= > - 6 l ([ P > V > (_ 5 3 , $ 3 % $ (mJf () + % 3 - ) = 3 , > (+ % 9 & 9 (K ) D ' * W (] & $ & % 3 - . Y (_ 5 ) = 3 % 9 > ' 9 & : (I 9 & - 9 ) A 9,3=-T=(B3.W5*)=>-6(=("aae(%J\()%39(B/Y$9>,3%)$)=>('53,$3%$(=>-&,>(kK%3=3($) ,/&%4-6)@)H-/l([B_?(OfM\;(=%39(9(#,&*'&@(kG/&%4-6)@)H-/(93P>5*)=&l()+%3-)=3,>

+ % 9 & 9 (E ) @ / 5 & 5 (B / Y $ 9 > , 3 % ) $ ) = > - 6 (_ 5 3 , $ 3 % $ T = (?> - & , > ([ ^ , 5 & % , 3 5 / ) , 3 D (m3 D 4 3 5 / ) , (_ 5 3 , A

$3%$'( 1)4,-/D\( =( OM""( %J( ckB/Y$9>,3%)$)=&( '53,$3%$>( =>-&,>l( OM""gJ

!"#$%&'()*-'#+6$.1/18$'*1*$.)+)(0#+5#*5)9%0(1,%/

K)$(+).Y-/&@(,/&%4-6)@)HS()(-63%3*5&%9&(93P>5*)=>@(,3D&U>(%)94@/&S(53*W(,/&%4A -6)@)HS;(*5T%W(=+/'3,)($)(%&.&'5%4(93P>5*T=(D4P()P.Y5)(&=/$&,-.W(93P>5*T=([*%3.)=W;

=).&=T$9*W( -9>( 2@/,,W\;( 3( 53*U&( /,,W( ,/U( =>@/&,/),&( ,/&%4-6)@)H-/;( .&U&D/( 9( +%9&+/'T=

'9-9&2TD,>-6( +%3=3( =>,/*3( .&.( '9-9&2TD,>( -63%3*5&%( $D3( $9/&$9/-5=3( *4D54%)=&2)J

(_3@)(+).Y-/&(93P>5*4(9$&X/,/)=3,)(=(<'53=/&(9(Of(D/+-3(OMMf(%J()()-6%),/&(93P>5A

*T=(/()+/&-&(,3$(93P>5*3@/(cd9J<J(,%("!O;(+)9J"L!e;(5J.J(d9J<J(9(OM"`(%J(+)9J"``!(=%39 9(+Ti,J(9@Jg;($)*),4.W-(/-6(+)$9/3V4(,3(93P>5*/(,/&%4-6)@&;(%4-6)@&(/(3%-6&)D)2/-9,&J K%9>(-9>@;(93(93P>5&*(,/&%4-6)@>(=(4'53=/&(49,3,)(,/&%4-6)@)H-/;(/-6(-9YH-/(D4P(9&A '+)V>;( PY$W-&( $9/&V&@( -9V)=/&*3( D4P( 9=/W93,&( 9( .&2)( $9/3V3D,)H-/W( /( '53,)=/W-&( H=/3$&-A 5=)(@/,/),&.(&+)*/(PW$i(9$3%9&,/3;(*5T%>-6(93-6)=3,/&(D&U>(=(/,5&%&'/&('+)V&-9,>@(9&

=92DY$4(,3(+)'/3$3,W(=3%5)HS(6/'5)%>-9,W;(3%5>'5>-9,W(D4P(,34*)=WJ

(Z2)$,/&(9(4'53=W()()-6%),/&(93P>5*T=(/()+/&-&(,3$(93P>5*3@/;(X)%@3@/()-6%),>

93P>5*T=( 'W7( =+/'( $)( %&.&'5%4( 93P>5*T=;( 49,3,/&( 93( +)@,/*( 6/'5)%//;( 45=)%9&,/&( +3%*4( *4DA 54%)=&2)()%39(4'53D&,/3()-6%),>(=(@/&.'-)=>@(+D3,/&(932)'+)$3%)=3,/3(+%9&'5%9&,,&2)

(3)

!"#$%&'()*"+),-%$.*'*/#0121314'$5-%$.*6,)+6-(1,)7*,%$#-%*-'#+6$.1/18$'999 !f

3DP)(=($&->9./()(4'53D&,/4(D)*3D/93-./(/,=&'5>-./(-&D4(+4PD/-9,&2);($&->9./()(=3%4,*3-6 93P4$)=>;( $&->9./( )( 9&9=)D&,/4( ,3( %&3D/93-.Y( /,=&'5>-./( $%)2)=&.;( $&->9./( )( 4'53D&,/4( D)A

*3D/93-./( D/,//( *)D&.)=&.( D4P( $&->9./( )( 9&9=)D&,/4( ,3( %&3D/93-.Y( /,=&'5>-./( =( 93*%&'/&( D)5,/A '*3( 4U>5*4( +4PD/-9,&2)J

(C('+&->X/-&(93P>5*T=('53,)=/(+%9&$&(='9>'5*/@(/-6('9-9&2TD,3()-6%),3(+%3=,3J K)$D&23.W(),&()-6%),/&(/()+/&-&;(P&9(=92DY$4(,3('53,(93-6)=3,/3;(=('9-9&2TD,)H-/7(PYA

$W-&(*%3.)P%393@/(*4D54%)=>@/;(4*V3$3@/(4%P3,/'5>-9,>@/;(%4%3D/'5>-9,>@/(/(9&'+)V3@/

P4$)=D3,>@/;($9/&V3@/(3%-6/5&*54%>(/(P4$)=,/-5=3;($9/&V3@/(P4$)=,/-5=3()P%),,&2);

)P/&*53@/(5&-6,/*/;(3(9=V3'9-93(*)+3D,/3@/;(6453@/;(&D&*5%)=,/3@/(/(/,,>@/(93*V3$3@/

+%9&@>'V)=>@/;( -@&,53%93@/;( +3%*3@/;( )2%)$3@/( /( /,,>@/( X)%@3@/( 93+%).&*5)=3,&.( 9/&D&A ,/;( @/&.'-3@/( 4+3@/Y5,/3.W->@/( =>$3%9&,/3( 6/'5)%>-9,&( PW$i( $9/3V3D,)HS( =>P/5,>-6( )')A P/'5)H-/(D4P(/,'5>54-./(c83'/:'*/(OM"LgJ

(n=/$&,-.3(93P>5*T=(+%)=3$9),3(.&'5(,3('9-9&PD4(*%3.)=>@;(=).&=T$9*/@(/(2@/,A ,>@J(E%3.)=W(&=/$&,-.Y(93P>5*T=(=(X)%@/&(9P/)%4(*3%5(&=/$&,->.,>-6(93P>5*T=(9,3.A

$4.W->-6('/Y(=(=).&=T$9*/-6(&=/$&,-.3-6(93P>5*T=(+%)=3$9/(2&,&%3D,>(*),'&%=35)%

9 3 P > 5 * T =J (?) . & = T $ 9 * W (& = / $ & , - . Y (9 3 P > 5 * T = (= (X ) % @ / & (* 3 % 5 (& = / $ & , - > . , > - 6 (9 3 P > 5 * T = 9,3.$4.W->-6('/Y(,3(5&%&,/&(=).&=T$95=3(+%)=3$9/(=).&=T$9*/(*),'&%=35)%(93P>5*T=J Z(*)D&/(=T.5([P4%@/'5%9;(+%&9>$&,5(@/3'53\(+%)=3$9/(2@/,,W(&=/$&,-.Y(93P>5*T=(=(X)%A

@/&(9P/)%4(*3%5(3$%&')=>-6(93P>5*T=(,/&%4-6)@>-6(9(5&%&,4(2@/,>J(?(&=/$&,-./(5&.

4.Y5&('W(93P>5*/(,/&%4-6)@&(=+/'3,&($)(%&.&'5%4;(93P>5*/(9,3.$4.W-&('/Y(=(=).&=T$9*/&.

&=/$&,-./(93P>5*T=()%39(/,,&(93P>5*/(,/&%4-6)@&(=>9,3-9),&(+%9&9(=T.53([P4%@/'5%93;

+%&9>$&,53( @/3'53\( =( +)%)94@/&,/4( 9( =).&=T$9*/@( *),'&%=35)%&@( 93P>5*T=J( F%)@3$9&A ,/&@( /( 93%9W$93,/&@(93')P&@( *%3.)=&.( &=/$&,-./( 93P>5*T=;( ,3( *5T%>( '*V3$3.W( '/Y( 93')P>

=).&=T$9*/-6(&=/$&,-./(93P>5*T=;(93.@4.&('/Y(=(/@/&,/4(2&,&%3D,&2)(*),'&%=35)%3(93A P>5*T=(G3%)$)=>(^,'5>545(d9/&$9/-5=3([G^d\J(?(3%-6/=4@($)*4@&,53-./(&=/$&,->.,&.

G ^ d (+ % 9 & - 6 ) = > = 3 , & (' W (, 3 ' 5 Y + 4 . W - & (* 3 % 5 > (& = / $ & , - > . , & 7 (* 3 % 5 > (& = / $ & , - > . , & (9 3 P > 5 * T =

= + / ' 3 , > - 6 ($ ) (% & . & ' 5 % 4 (9 3 P > 5 * T =;** 3 % 5 > (& = / $ & , - > . , & (9 3 P > 5 * T = (, / & (= + / ' 3 , > - 6 ($ ) (% & . & A '5%4;**3%5>( &=/$&,->.,&( 93P>5*T=( %4-6)@>-6;( *3%5>( &=/$&,->.,&( 93P>5*T=( 5&-6,/*/;**3%A 5>(&=/$&,->.,&(93P>5*4(3%-6&)D)2/-9,&2);**3%5>(3$%&')=&(93P>5*T=(,/&%4-6)@>-6('5)A ')=,>-6($D3(2@/,,&.(&=/$&,-./(93P>5*T=J(?&$V42('53,4(,3(f"JMfJOM"`(%J(&=/$&,-.3(53 )P&.@)=3V3( VW-9,/&( "ef( "aO( *3%5( &=/$&,->.,>-6;( =( 5>@( "`N( f!a( *3%5( &=/$&,->.,>-6( 93A P>5*T=(3%-6/5&*54%>(/(P4$)=,/-5=3;(aMO`(*3%5(&=/$&,->.,>-6(+3%*T=(/(OL(LOL(*3%5(&=/A

$&,->.,>-6( -@&,53%9>J

K ) $ ' 5 3 = ) = W (/ (. & $ , ) - 9 & H , / & (, 3 . P 3 % $ 9 / & . (+ ) = ' 9 & - 6 , W (X ) % @ W () - 6 % ) , > (9 3 P > 5 * T = (. & ' 5

= + / ' ($ ) (% & . & ' 5 % 4 (9 3 P > 5 * T =J (d ) (% & . & ' 5 % 4 (9 3 P > 5 * T = (= + / ' 4 . & (' / Y (9 3 P > 5 & * (, / & % 4 - 6 ) @ >

,3 (+)$' 5 3 =/ & ($& - >9 . / (=>$3 ,& . (+% 9 & 9 (=). & =T$9 */ & 2)(*),' & % =3 5 )% 3 (9 3 P>5 *T=(9 (4% 9 Y $4 PW$i(,3(=,/)'&*(=V3H-/-/&D3(93P>5*4(,/&%4-6)@&2)(D4P(4U>5*)=,/*3(=/&-9>'5&2)(2%4,A 54;( ,3( *5T%>@( 9,3.$4.&( '/Y( 93P>5&*( ,/&%4-6)@>J( Z( $3,>-6( G^d( =>,/*3;( U&( ,3( OfJMaJOM"L( %J

=+/'&@($)(%&.&'5%4(93P>5*T=(P>V)()P.Y5>-6(!a(fe"()P/&*5T=(,/&%4-6)@>-6J(?(2%4+/&

5&.(%)$93.)=)(=>)$%YP,/3('/Y(,3'5Y+4.W-&()P/&*5>7(4%P3,/'5>*Y([)P/&*5>(=/&D)+%9&'5%9&,A ,&\;('3*%3D,&;()P%),,&;(+4PD/-9,&;(93@*/;(+3V3-&;($=)%>;(+3%*/;(@/&'9*3D,&;(2)'+)$3%-9&;

+% 9 & @ >' V )=& ;(- @ & ,5 3 % 9 & (/ (/ ,,& \ J(_9 - 9 & 2TV )=& ($3 ,& ()(D / - 9 P/ & (9 3 P>5 *T=(,/ & % 4- 6)@ >- 6 /( /-6( %)$93.3-6( =( +)'9-9&2TD,>-6( =).&=T$95=3-6( +)$3,)( =( 53P&D/( "J

(4)

F)-6;5*F);'7;('

!`

j3P&D3("J(Z3P>5*/(,/&%4-6)@&(=+/'3,&($)(%&.&'5%4(93P>5*T=(0('53,(,3(OfJMaJOM"L(%J j3PD&("J(^@@)o3PD&(@),4@&,5'(&,5&%&$(/,(3(D/'5()X(%&2/'5&%()X(@),4@&,5'(0('535&(),(f"JM!JOM"L ?).&=T$95=) m)/o)$&'6/+

<%P3,/A '5>*3 <%P3, +D3,,/,2 _3*%3DA ,& _3-%&$

CP%),,& d&X&,'/o&

K4PD/-9A ,& K4PD/- Z3@*/ 13'5D&' I&9>$&,A -.),3D,& I&'/$&,5/3D

Z/&D&: F%&&,

])D=3%-9A ,& ]3%@

F)'+)A $3%-9& n-),)A @/-

B/&'9A *3D,& I&'/$&A ,5/3D K%9&@>A 'V)=& ^,$4'5%/3D 1@&,53A %9& 1&@&,5A &%>

^,,& C56&%

I39&@ j)53D d)D,)HDW'*/&"`O"(`L`""L!LOae!NeeL`eOeO"fO(OMNf!NffN`"Oe(ffO E4.3='*)A+)@)%'*/&OOL"N"M`"eOOLffM`MafNe"MaL"M"M!"La"LNf(MM` p4P&D'*/&L"e`fNf"N!"fONM``afMeaaLfL!aL"af`ef(N`a p4P4'*/&fLLLe"M`"!LOfO"`OMffMaNNO(MeN"M"NN""N`(MLN qT$9*/&ffLN""L"LN"aONMfaL"OMa!La`"Oa"Lf"O"O!Nf B3V)+)D'*/&L!"(Mff!!f`MfOOea`OaOefOfL"(L"eN!`!f`LOL(O!f B39)=/&-*/&"Oa"(M!M!e!OM"`LMfaN!feO"N"O("!"OaOfeff!!N(""f C+)D'*/&fN!!eLL"L"Oe"LeOOe"aMeN"(MLO"O!"``"`af(MeN K)$*3%+3-*/&LM"(M!fafO!M"aOMffONOea""L"("efN!fNeOeM`(fO` K)$D3'*/&!aLONa"a``NO""Nef""ML`!NLf`f"O`O(ONO K)@)%'*/&!"LOL"M!O`e"`OOeOeNOON"aaeN`""f"L`"eMf("a" rDW'*/&!e!M!"Nf`"fO"NNOM!"!LOOO"(LeLOMN""M"f`f(eN` r=/Y5)*%9>'*/&`!`L""aLN"a"MOOf"ea"aOONNO"a`"Oa"(!LL ?3%@/:'*)A@394%'*/&!NaMM"OeOaeOeOe```eLO`OffO(M`"O"!LeL"`aL(aMM ?/&D*)+)D'*/&"`f"("f`fe`e!OONa""(MfLaf""a!"(`L!O!LfefONaN("fe Z3-6)$,/)+)@)%'*/&LNee"!aOeeOfO!aNLa"!f""Of!!"fMfOL"eaf(!OO I39&@"(M!!"O(Naf"(MNa`(!"L`"f`(efeN(fLfL(O!aOO(eaf"e(a`OO(`OM`(N"`f(Le!!a(fe"

Cytaty

Powiązane dokumenty

Zwraca uwagę na to, że inne są w nich kręgi odbiorców sztuki, inne jest też podejście do dzieła sztuki — istnieje pełna podziwu świadomość, że jest

Analiza determinantów elastyczności przepisów prawa podatkowego w płasz- czyźnie samego podjęcia decyzji o zastosowaniu odpowiednich środków techniki prawodawczej pozwala uznać,

Artymiuka orzecznictwa Sądu Najwyższego pozwoliły mu na wyodrębnienie kilku grup oko- liczności, których zaistnienie świadczyło o tym, iż dobro wymiaru sprawiedliwo- ści

Cała ta sprawa roli naturalizmu w nauce w przypadku koncepcji inte- ligentnego projektu nie jest jednak, na szcze˛s´cie, w naszej sprawie az˙ tak waz˙na, gdyz˙ rozpoznanie, z˙e

Niech zwracają uwagę na wspa­ niałą filozofię religii, przez k tó rą Siostra Profesor w zbogaca i zdobi intelektu­ alną kulturę Polski i Europy, a w tej kulturze

Ale Gilson w swoich wnioskach idzie jeszcze dalej. Uwaz˙a mianowicie, z˙e pewna zgodnos´c´ pomie˛dzy bergsonizmem a mys´l ˛a chrzes´cijan´sk ˛a, przynajmniej w podobnie

Jan Paweł II, który w swoich przemówieniach i dokumentach papieskich akcentuje zawsze godnos´c´ osobow ˛ a człowieka, stwierdza, z˙e współczesny kryzys wartos´ci ludzkich polega