☐The article can be published, after taking into account remarks of thereviewer☐

Research Reviews of Czestochowa University of Technology Management

………..

Date of the review

REVIEW OF THE ARTICLE

to Research Reviews of Czestochowa University of Technology Management

Title of the article :

………..

………

Part I. Evaluation of the article (please evaluate each category)

Scale Rating

The importance of the issue discussed in the article

To what extent is the issue presented in the article important in scientific terms?

0 - 10 Cognitive value

To what extent does the study bring something new to subject related literature?

0 - 20 Originality

To what extent the study is original, i.e. it is not a compilation of already known publications?

0 - 10 Application value

To what extent the issues included in the study can be used in practice or for the theory development?

0 - 15 Methodological correctness

To what extent are the research methods properly selected and applied?

0 - 20 Transparency of arguments and logic of content layout

To what extent are considerations included in the article transparent and logical and structure of the study is clear, reliable and following?

0 - 15 Formal evaluation

To what extent is the study written in a correct, professional and understandable language and text illustrations (tables, drawings, charts, etc.) are correctly prepared and presented?

0 - 10

Part II. Conclusions- please select the appropriate option

The article can be published in presented form ☐

The article can be published, after taking into account remarks of the reviewer ☐

The article cannot be published ☐

Research Reviews of Czestochowa University of Technology Management

Part III. Please, fill in the appropriate fields. For ratings below 5 points for one of categories in part I, enter justification in the detailed remarks.

Detailed remarks:

Suggested changes that should be introduced before publishing the article:

Necessary:

Optional:

The following information will be available only to the editorial board of Research Reviews of Częstochowa University of Technology series: Management, according to the procedure: „double – blind review”

……… ………

.

Name and Surname of Reviewer Signiture

Research Reviews of Czestochowa University of Technology Management