Archive of SID.

(1)

(2)

!

1

* 2

! (hkarimi@mail.kntu.ac.ir)

! (setak@kntu.ac.ir)

" # $% #

&

' ( $)

*+#

, - +" &. # / , 0 1 , 2'

2 /

3 4 5 6#

- #' 7 8 9

. 5 , 2 " 1 / ; #

7 9 $% # 2 ; 0 "

" 5< 2 " ; # = 1 > ? .

= #' @A, , B = " A & "

C D <

' " 4 E " F ) " &) &@G = #' )# 5< 2 7 3 H I 2

.

" , "

; # ' J / K L # = - @ 8 M ' L " N/ 1 2'

# / # @/ 1 7 "

O #

7 / P 2

. -" ?9, * " ) < Q $% # &G 2 "

1 7 . '

#! " R

* P ($@M ' =

.

: - +" $) & " # ' " ' -" ?9, * 2'

2

1 -

"

# ! " # $ %

& % "' (

)

* + ( - . / 0 " + 1 % 2 ' .

4 5' 6 7 8 9 4 ' - :; ' "

. 5 :;

$ 7 < + 9 4 = >

? & @ ' 3

]4

1 [ : 0 F G ' ( '

7 51

]5

2 [

* ; 4 7 /

6

] 3 [ /

* ' KL 7 ]

4 [

+ M /

* ' KL 7

] 5 [

$' 1 /

* LPQ 8

]9

6 [

! 9 / ]10

7 [ 4 % /

* ' KL 11

] 8 [

–S

T -E -+# 2 1 2 9

* U V

; % # - W :

3Dantzig

4Ramser

5Bodin

6Golden

7Desrochers

8Laporte

9Osman

10 Fisher

11 Eksioglu

(3)

8 ' .

% 8 7 + 6 T U /< V 7 '

" ' $ W 8 6 T + 9 4 = X;

"

:- " ' .

" ' % ; . " 7 T ' /8 *' 5' 6 "

.

* + 7 LY$

7 + Z8 "' 8Y ' % F LQ [ - 5' 6 * ! " # $ \ "

Q

< % " +

*]

8 K!

. ' ' \ * + [ - * & 7 LY$ % Q /2 P "

%

: 0 5 9 _$ K 9 $ / `] @

"

. 2 / ; 7 L a b% "

% ' % [ - "

Y @ 7 ' . ' - / % .

' 0 * L( = Q @ 8c$ d . " $ \ " K ' .

' /2 P "

8 ; . % "

$ \ 2 + / " [ - "

\ ' G "

% ) 2 P "

] 9 [ .(

K

" ' " "+ 9 7 \4 e ' /8 : - = Q @ X0 " K ' +

% 8 4 % < V * $

1

* ' KL ] 10 [

% ' . f ' + 2 "

X "+

f ' /* L( = Q @ 8c$ d "+

"& '

+ /f ' 7 ' % 8 ; L . " 9 _$ g + $ 7 LY$ a

\ )

2 P "

] 11 [ .(

/' c ' K ' ' * $

+ 5' 6 '

"

% ' 2

. ' + "

. a 7 . a /"

9 4 e ' " 1 .

' . 7 7 ; L . g + $ ' ' 8 h ' $ Qb( i /8; . 7

. '

/8; . 7 ' /g- + * L(

8; . 8G 8 L% "+ 9 ; L . "& '

.

% $1 + T

< ' ' "' c ' K ' ' + T ' 7 0 $ X $ / 4

' "&

% ) L

] 12 [ (

' ' ' ' T

8; . L$ j / ' $ Qb(

' >

) L ] 13 [ .(

8; . 7 '

+ F LQ % 8 + "

\ "

% .

5 \$ + K % 8 7 " K ' ' c ' K ' kX "

X + / K ' 7 ' ' "+

\

% . X + U 7 ' % 8 l 0 /' "+

' c 7 $ k% / T 7KL 8; . 7 $

l ] '

. k% /' ` 0 a ' % : 7 ' * L( = Q + ' # 7 $

> 4 k L_$ "

.

X + / * l; [ /< V 7 ' 8 \ ' "+

.

+ + "

X 8 : - = Q 8; . ' $ \ d . ' "

8 5 ' ' "+

.

* /2 P * Q

* ' KL 3

] 14 [ U 7 + X '

$ % ' "+

% \ ! 8T' 7 $ .

.

4 L

* ' KL ]

15 [ X 4 ' 9 " K ' 7 + / .

m ' ] ] 13 [ /

+ 8; . 7 9 4 e ' ' n _Y$

& " "

X 5' 6 n _Y$ "

2 ' "+

% . "+

. '

< V X / "

8 ' # 7 ! "+ L% h ' "+

. F G $ / d + U 7

] ; ' % ' (

* ' KL 5

] 16 [ ' .

T % " 8; . 7 $ U - % + \ K ' / c

+ 8 l "

. K ' '

k% T 2 L . " ' % : - " K ' 7 j /8 L% T 2 L . " ' F LQ 7KL 8; . 7 $ / ; L . & c g - )

@ / + a 9 $ 8 Q * /l ' " 0 @ / L

0 ( 8 ' % / .

% 8 G K ' /l ] 7 ! "+ L% K ' /g- '

$ 8; . 7 ' *

\

L .]

16 [ + 5' 6 % 8 : - = Q @ " ' /o 7 \ * + / # . < V ' "

.

% $ :;

+ 5' 6 '

0 $ / " "

' 0 / "

.

1Kagaya

2 Interval

3Yaman

4Montemanni

5Aissi

(4)

* L

* ' KL L @ $ 8; . 7 ' 4 ' 9 / ' k FbG- % ' ( ]

15 [ ' - :; '

8 9 4 .

% 7 ; +

' < V 7 ' "

X o /8 9 4 ' - \ "' o / ` Y "+

T ` 0 .

X ` % ' % ' ( o 7 j ; % 4 " p9 ' ' "+

] 1

17 [

8 *

.

' % 7 "

` 0 7 $ + ' q c a /

T X .

6 7 ; ' T % 8 5'

2 /= 8L - ' ' q c "+

T .

X f ' +' &>$ "+

' = 8L - ' 2

. +' &>$ k ' ; d ' =' XM 8L -

> = > 8 T T ' ] 8L - ' " 4

.

2 -

%

&

8X0 q 4

{ }

^V ^A ' G= , e ' '

. Q L> % o V

* L% Q L> A 8 0 "

. '

o Q L>

/ 0 4

* ! 8

. q 4 7 " ' e '

T .

* L% "

* + a a )

&

( + 5' 6 % ' 0 \ "

[ ]

^{t ,}^ij ^t^ij

ij /

ij t

t < L 0 .

X + q "+

8 L ' $ M 7 9 / 7 ' )

# $ * & h

i) (d 8 ' :$ 7 2 / ' ]

( %

*] r ! k% " ' 8

* + 7 $ )

&

( \ . 9 4 e ' "' s :$ h q 7 .

j ; % % "' K ' 0 $ )

1997 (

% . : 1 ( "' K ' /[

2 (

q c K '

' . 8 ` Y = K ' # . < V ' .

' e ' @ ' " ! l $ *] "' + .

2 " '

* \ ' :$ / "+

.

s :$

1 .

" ' '

* + + L - a /R )

&

( 5' 6 \

[ ]

^ij ^ij

R

ij t t

t ,

` Y .

s :$

2 . ` 0 a " ' q c a ' ' f

"

7 X & ` 0 7 & 7 5 \$ /R

' 7 ' ` 0 .

` 0 a " ' q c * &

' ' f

"

5' 6 R ) , (R f ' 7 ' ` 0 7 X RD

5' 6 ) (R * ! B .

s :$

3 . k% " ' % k 4 ' ` 0 ' ` 0 a L$ 7 ' q c * & 7 ! /7 $

0 " '

. q g $ * L - * s ' :$ 0 $ )

8 9 t + \ = Q & / \ * + &

(/

T + p-

.

p- . ` 0 " q c * & 7 ! > f

* + % )

&

( 2 " \

* ' "

2 ' T ' 7 ! /` 0 k% / ' ' p. ` 0 ' %

' T ' 7 $ .

5 Gu . 0 @ $ > " ' f `

F / .

q c % 8 u 2 . " ' '

"

R L L% / F +

8 .

{ } { } ={ } { } { } { }

=

f R B j i

F ij R

B f j i

F ij f

R B j i

R ij R

B f j i

R ij R

B j i

R ij f

j i

R

ij t t t t t

t f

R RD

\ ) ( , ) (

\ ,

\ ) ( , ) (

\ , ) ( , ,

) , (

s :$ h /F

{ }

ⁱ^,^j ^f ^\^B⁽^R⁾

t t_ij^F _ij^R

{ }

ⁱ ^j ^B ^R ^f

t

t_ij^R _ij^F , ₁( )\ 6

v .

1Kouvelis

2Bender’s decomposition

(5)

{ } { } { } { } { } { } { } { }

{ } { } ( , )

) (

) , (

) ( , ,

\ ) ( , ) ( , ,

f F RD t

t

t t

f R RD

F B j i

F ij f

j i

F ij

R B j i

F ij f

j i

F ij f

R B j i

F ij R

B f j i

F ij f

j i

F ij f

R B j i

F ij R

B f j i

F ij f

j i

F ij

=

= +

=

p- 0 $

"

5' GQ 5' 6 q g $ / )

1 ( T .

) 1

( )

(

i j i

ij R All ij

i j i y ij R S ij

R All

x max t x min t y

min

Q L>

8 ' L$ S

All Z 8; . L$ k

8 "

.

p- 0 $ .

1 5' GQ ) 2 ( 5' GQ + ) 1 ( 8 ] .

) 2

( )

(

( )

(

⁺

)

i j i

ij ij ij ij All ij

i j i y ij All ij

x t x min t t t x y

min

5' GQ ' ) 2 ( w 0 $ % 0 /

"

xij

> ' ' a / T >

% . 7 X ' 2 .

X 4 ' 7 ` 0 X i

/ 2 _$ j

=1 yij

5' 6 7 x ' Z

=0 yij

T .

+] w a /q g $ * % T "

s :$

5 ' GQ w 7 0 $ / )

3 ( ) 4 ( T 8

] .

) 3 (

i j i ij ij

All

x t x

min

) 4

( )

(

( )

(

^t ^t ^t ^x ^y

)

^y ^All

i j i

ij ij ij ij ij+

%W - 5' GQ ' % 8

) 4 (/

yij

$

* ! ' ` 0 a < L < X 8 u *] /5' GQ 7 '

8 . 5' GQ 0 $ )

3 ( ) 4 ( 8; . L$ ` 0 " p9 % 8 9 % X $ / KL "

7 All) ( >

.

"

p9 + ' % 7 2 a b% "

\ .

5 ' GQ ' " p9 7 )

5 (/

) 6 (/

) 7 (/

) 8 (/

) 9 (/

) 10 ( ) 11 (

8 * !

.

) 5 } (

0 {

\

1 i

x

i j

ij =

) 6 } (

0 {

\

1 j

x

j i

ij =

) 7 } (

0 {

\ )

(d C x₀ i

C

u_i + _i _i

) 8 j (

i j i

x d d C Cx C d u

u_j _i + _j + _ij +( _j _i) _ji \{0}, \{0},

) 9 } (

0 {

\ i C

u d_i _i

) 10 } (

0 {

\

0 i

u_i

) 11

{ }

ⁱ ^j ⁱ ^j (

x_ij 0,1 , ,

(6)

0 4

8 4 * L

.

i w $ @ $ % 8 "' * & u

. i L .

5 ' GQ

) 5 ( ) 6 (/

a 4 + 0 T " ' :$ % U # 7 .

5' GQ

"

) 7 (/

) 8 ( ) 9 (

" /

\ ' $ + qy.

) MTZ q :

( L0 M ' " ' % @ $ "

* ' KL 1

] 18 [

9 : .

5' GQ ) 10 ( ) 11 (

* ! ' ` 0 " p9 o " w k .

2 0 $ "+

) 5 ' GQ : )

3 (

$ ) 11 ( ( 5' GQ @ $ . " 6 K! / )

4 (

>

.

' / 51 . L$ /g- '

. . ' j L

% . ; G- - F G * + ' ' 2 7 * $ .

f ' + K + U 7 8 "

\ +' &>$ f ' /2 ' T h ' % 8 &>$ f ' /

T .

3 -

&) *+ # ,-. / )

* L 2 / ! / G- 8L - " X ' % "' ( "+

8 c + " + :$ " ' )

4 ( 8 .

+ K

+' @ $ % 8 +' f ' /U # 7 . " K ' ]

19 [

8 d '

. 51 ' 7 " ' %

j ; % ]

17 [

* ' KL L / ]

15 [

8 4 '

. L% :$ X $ % 8 7 +' f ' 6 +

8 c

"

) 4 (

k X ` 0

.

8 c 7 9 4 e ' * 2 /+' f ' @ $ . "

"

) 4 ( . .

1 7 ' % 8 %W =+

. )

"+ ] (

" /` 0 * c + " 4 0 ; / )

12 ( T 9 # .

) 12

i j i (

ij ijx t

iter 2 . 9 : / ' L * Q

` 0 % "

' All L

iter .

` 0 : All $ "

K$

iter ' .

= 4 / * l; 0 $ 8 + 5' 6 k ' ; "

:

= 4

\6 1 .

=

{ }

iter

= Alliter

.

2 = 4 . +] 2 )

3 (

$ ) 11 ( 8 c " 0 % 5' 6 7 / % . ' )

4 (

8 c +

) 13 (

\

% .

) 13

( )

(

( )

^iter

i j i

ij ij ij ij

ij t t x y y All

t +

6 >

` 0 % 4

> "

. $ . ' 2 iter

% .

` 0 ] 8 "

xiter iter / q g $ * &

LBiter

8 +' f ' ' 7 . * L % .

= = 4 .

L. a b%

. / 6 + ] 8 ` 0 0 $ .

'

* + ' /8; . 7 )

&

( ' + o 7 \ )

14 ( 8

' - \ ' a b% ' % ]

4 .

) 14

( )

îj îj îjîter (

ij

ij t t t x

t = +

+' f ' Q 9 % / 7 .

iter /8 ] T 8 y

. . " / 7 0 $

5' GQ /+' f ' "1 )

15 (

>

.

) 15

( )

(

( )

(

⁺

)

=

i j i

iter ij iter ij ij ij ij

i j i

iter ij ij

iter t x t t t x y

UB

1Miller

(7)

= = 4 .

{ } 4

iter

iter UB LB

,..., 2 ,

1min

s- k ' ; / ' Z

x 7 15' 6 +

=iter iter

iter iter

iter All y

All = 2 = 4

.

4 - .1 2 3 4 5 ' - < +] ' 8 d ' % "+' &>$ f ' k ' ; /8L - 7 ' 4

.

@ $ k ' ; 7

MATLAB 7.8 GAMS 23.5

8 % G % $ 5' 6 .

CPLEX+

% . * Q

= ' & 9 '

GAMS23.5

8 ` Y

. + ' @ $ 0 L$

2.53 GHz e9 .

2.99GB 8 = >

. +

% > ] + / G 0 7 " 5 '

' 9 @G$ "

@ $ % 4

* ' KL L

] 15 [

\ / >

8 4

. 7 h' ] '

http://www.idsia.ch/~roberto/RTSPinst.zip 0

. 7 G$ "

\6 o / e ' "

8 z 9 o * L .

" # $ " ' d

10 4 ) 7 9 4 e ' (

9 4 ' - < +] ' %

o " l $ $ 0

$ 9 0 / 91 / 13 / 92 / 64 / 10 / 28 / 55 / 96 97 8 .

" ' d " 7 L 17

4

) 7 9 4 e ' (

o " l $ $ 0

$ 16 0

/ 43 / 92 / 80 / 96 / 66 / 4 / 85 / 94 / 68 / 76 / 75 / 40 / 66 / 18 / 71

4 8 . 7 9 _$ { c6 Q a % \ : $ + / 7 ; $ "

0

$ 100 .

8 9 t

"

2 0 ' 1

8 ]

.

( k ' ; + \ * 51 . L$ ' @ $ . | 9' .

+ 4'& 0 $ /k

) . 10 4 ( 8 e9 . + + }' T 8 G * T ' - / \ ' @ $ 2 / .

. o + ~ ; 7 L /

8 G * f' &4 ' - k ' ; + \ * .

& M *]

nY! % "

@ ' 0 $ 8 )

4 ( " 2 + /

"

10 + T 4 F L

k . ; $ * + /

F G T + .

0 - T ' @ $ 2 / \ +' &>$ k ' ; + % )$

17

4 ( 8 .

" ' d $ G c ~ X $ 8L - 7 ' 10

17 8 ' ] 4 .

"

20 4 / ! + }' T

8 \ ' ' e9 . .

d ; 7 L

•'&

$ Q L> ' ' - < +] ' / 9 : "

8 9 . 2 0 ' ] 8 ~ 1

8 ]

. * ' = /2 0 7 2 * %

.

* ! = * 4

8 9 t 8 \ '

. q g $ ' )

3 ( 8 * ! = * ' / .

k> =' XM *

* ' *] . * + +' &>$ k ' ; " ' K$ :$ l $ $

% .

(8)

"#

$ 1 :

" '() * +, $" - .

- ! ) 0 ( 2) "3) 4"5 6 ) "

7 8

9

355 / 1 4

284 R-10-100.1 200

520 / 1 4

216 400

096 / 1 3

224 R-10-100.2 200

006 / 1 3

194 400

032 / 1 3

224 R-10-100.3 200

898 / 0 3

194 400

592 / 1 3

255 R-10-100.4 200

366 / 1 4

211 400

371 / 1 4

281 R-10-100.5 200

039 / 1 3

191 400

133 / 2 4

2525 R-10-1000.1 200

050 / 1 3

1298 400

635 / 0 2

1597 R-10-1000.2 200

937 / 0 3

1460 400

249 / 1 3

1828 R-10-1000.3 200

326 / 1 4

1457 400

842 / 1 5

2614 R-10-1000.4 200

989 / 0 3

1816 400

328 / 2 4

2618 R-10-1000.5 200

312 / 2 4

1867 400

577 / 60 2

1487 gr17.rm.0.25.1 480

328 / 59 2

1401 800

318 / 59 2

1545 gr17.rm.0.25.2 480

697 / 58 2

1464 800

524 / 61 2

1608 gr17.rm.0.25.3 480

830 / 51 2

1381 800

234 / 59 2

1540 gr17.rm.0.25.4 480

186 / 54 2

1389 800

617 / 60 2

1443 gr17.rm.0.25.5 480

831 / 56 2

1372 800

2 0 ' ' ] ~ )

1 (

* ! 8 ' ` 0 +' &>$ k ' ; T T * + ' %

.

@ ' :$ /7 •L )

4 ( d " 2 :9 X ` 0 ' % k% T / .

' ( 7

97 / 2 .

FbP

" ' % d "

17 / 4 2

' ) 4 ( 8 ' ] = &;

.

5 -

.7 3 89 : #- ;

' + "

2 8 : - = Q 8; . ' "

* + "

)

&

(

< V 7 ' \

8 '

. 2 a "+

4V h @ Y "& '

8 / "

. . * • ;

/2 8 d ' +' &>$ f ' .

0 = Q ; " ' + T /5 ' @G$ "

0 "

4 > b6 7 " 2 /*] + j

. .

* ! ] 8 ~ ' +' k ' ; %

(9)

8 u ' . * + < % .

$] 5 :; * Q k ' ; /* $

. T L " [ - "

7 •L / % . ( 7 " ' f T k ' ; + * $

" " X ! +' &>$

d ' .

X d L $ G % $ "+

* K 5 LQ ; $

X .

=>

[1] Dantzig, G. B., & Ramser, J. H., "The Truck Dispatching Problem", Management Science, Vol.6, pp.80-91, 1959

[2] Bodin, L., "A Taxonomic Structure for Vehicle Routing and Scheduling Problems", Computers & Urban Society, Vol.1, pp.11-29, 1975.

[3] Bodin, L., & Golden, B., "Classification in Vehicle Routing and Scheduling",Networks,Vol.11, pp.97-108, 1981.

[4] Bodin, L., Golden, B., Assad, A. A., & Ball, M, "Routing and Scheduling of Vehicles and Crews", Computers

& Operation Research, Vol.10, pp.63-211, 1983.

[5] Desrochers, M., Lenstra, J. K., & Savelsbergh, M. W., "A Classification Scheme for Vehicle Routing and Scheduling Problems",European Journal of Operational Research, Vol.46, pp.322-332, 1990.

[6] Laporte, G., & Osman, I. H., "Routing problems: A bibliography", Annals of Operations Research, Vol.61, pp.227-262, 1996.

[7] Fisher, M., Vehicle Routing. In Ball. M. O., "Handbooks in OR & MS (Chapter 1) ",Elsevier Science, Vol.8, 1995.

[8] Eksioglu, B., Vural, A. V., & Reisman, A., "The vehicle routing problem: A taxonomic review",Computers

& Industrial Engineering, Vol.57, pp.1472–1483, 2009.

[9] Yu, G., & Yang, J., "On the Robust Shortest Path Problem",Computers & and Operations Research, Vol.25, pp.457-468, 1998.

[10] Kagaya, S., Kikuchi, S., & Donnelly, R. A., "Use of A Fuzzy Theory Technique for Grouping of Trips in The Vehicle Routing and Scheduling Problem", European Journal of Operational Research, Vol.76, pp.143-158, 1994.

[11] Yaohuang, G., Binglei, X., & Qiang, G., "Overview of Stochastic Vehicle Routing Problem", Journal of Southwest Jiaotong University, Vol.10, ppp.113–121, 2002.

[12] Alumar, S. A., Stefan, N., & Saldanha-da-Gama, F., "Hub Location under Uncertainty", Transportation Research Part B, Vol.46, pp.529–543, 2012.

[13] Pereira, J., & Averbakh, I., "Exact and Heuristic Algorithm sor The Interval Data Robust Assignment Problem",Computers & Operations Research, Vol.38, pp.1153–1163, 2011.

[14] Yaman, H., Karasan, O. E., & Pinar, M. C., "The Robust Spanning Tree Problem with Interval Data", Operations Research Letters, Vol.29, pp.31–40 ,2001.

[15] Montemanni, R., Barta, J., Mastrolilli, M., & Gambar, L., "The Robust Traveling Salesman Problem with Interval Data", Transportation Science, Vol.41, pp.366–381, 2007.

[16] Aissi, H., Bazgan, C., & Vanderpoote, D., "Min–Max and Min–Max Regret Versions of Combinatorial Optimization Problems: A Survey", European Journal of Operational Research, Vol.197, pp.427–438, 2009.

[17] Kouvelis, P., & Yu, G., "Robust Discrete Optimization and its applications", Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1997.

[18] Miller, C., Tucker, A., & Zemlin, R., "Integer Programming Formulation of Travelling Salesman Problems",

Journal of the Association for Computing Machinery, Vol.7, pp.326-329, 1960.

[19] Benders, J. F., "Partitioning Procedures for Solving Mixed Integer Variables Programming Problmes", Numerische Mathematik, Vol.4, pp.238-252, 1962.

(10)