• Nie Znaleziono Wyników

Manual of isotope radiography

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Manual of isotope radiography"

Copied!
54
0
0

Pełen tekst

(1)

SHIP STRUCTURE COMMITTEE

w

jIp=

LABORATORIUM VOOR

0074

CHEEPSCONSTRUcTEg

ssc-i 21

MANUAL OF ISOTOPE RADIO'3RAPHY

by

E. L. Criscuolo

D. Polansky

and C. H. Dyer

(2)

SHIP STRUCTURE COMMITTEE

MEMBER AGENCiES: ADDRESS CORRESPONDENCE To..

May 23, 1960

Dear Sir:

As part of its research program related to the fabrica-tion of hull structures of ships, the Ship Structure Committee

sponsored a study at the Naval Ordnance Laboratory to prepare a manual to guide field workers in the techniques involved in the use of four selected gamma ray sources for detecting flaws

in welded engineering structures. Herewith is a copy of

SSC-121, "Manual of Isotope Radiography, Il by E. L. Criscuolo, D. Polansky and C. H. Dyer.

This project has been conducted under the advisory

guidance of the Flaw Detection Advisory Group of the Ship Struc-ture Subcommittee.

Distribution of this report is being made to those indi-viduals andagencies associatedwith and Interested in the work of the Ship Structure Committee. Any questions, comments, criti-cisrn or other matters pertaining to the report should be addressed to the Secretary, Ship Structure Committee.

Sincerely yours,

E. H. Thiele

Rear Admiral, U. S. Coast Guard Chairman, Ship Structure Committee

BUREAU OF SHIPS, DEPT. OF NAVY SECRETARY

MILITARY SEA TRANSPORTATION SERVICE, DEPT. OF NAVY SHIP STRUCTURE COMMITTEE

UNITED STATES COAST GUARD. TREASURY DEFT. U S COAST GUARD HEADQUARTERS

MARITIME ADMINISTRATION, DEPT. OF COMMRE WASHINGTON 2, D. C.

(3)

s-

tQL Serial No. SSC-121 Final Report of Project SR-127 to the

SHIP STRUCTURE COMMITTEE

on

MANUAL OF ISOTOPE RADIOGRAPHY

by

E. L. Criscuolo, D. Polansky and C. H. Dyer

Naval Ordnance Laboratory White Oak, Maryland

under

Department of the Navy

Bureau of Ships Project Order-92703 BuShips Index No. NS-O2l-201

Washington, D. C.

National Academy of Sciences-National Research Council May 23, 1960

(4)

PREFACE

The purpose of this manual is to present information and experimental data on the radiography of steel (particular-ly welds) using isotopes. This information will assist the radiographer in selecting the proper technique. The technique described can be applied to the radiographic inspection of

welds contained in ship structures. No attempt is made in

this document to evaluate the discontinuities other than to

familiarize the reader withthe interpretation and classifica-tion of defects.

(5)

CONTENTS

Page

INTRODUCTION i

CHARACTERISTICS OF GAMMA RAYS 1

Absorption 1

Ionization Z

Film Blackening by Gamma Rays 3

Effect of Electric and Magnetic Fields 4

Isotopes 4

FILM CHARACTERISTICS 6

RADIOGRAPHIC TECHNIQUES 6

Setup 8

Estimation of Exposure Time 11

DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES 16

INTERPRETATION OF RADIOGRAPHS 17

General 17

Film Viewing Procedure 17

Standards 17

RADIATION SAFETY 1 9

General 20

Methods of Protection 20

Radiation Monitoring 21

Care of Radioactive Capsules 22

Conclusions 22

GLOSSARY 23

REFERENCES 24

LIST OF TECHNIQUE AND SENSITIVITY CURVES 25

(6)

Chairman:

Members:

FLAW DETECTION ADVISORY COMMITTEE

for the

SHIP STRUCTURE SUBCOMMITTEE

D. T. O'Connor

Machlett Laboratories, Inc.

Samuel Baum

Consulting Welding Engineer

C. H Hastings

AVCO Manufacturing Corporation

Research & Advanced Development Division

Harold Hoviand

Industrial X-ray Engineers F. L. Johnson

Materials Engìneer

Bethlehem Steel Company

M. J. Letich Principal Surveyor

American Bureau of Shipping

F. H. Martin

Bureau of Ships

M. S. Northup

Esso Research and Engineering Company J. T. Norton

Department of Metallurgy

Massachusetts Institute of Technology W. W. Offner

President, X-ray Engineering International R. H. Slaughter, Jr.

Manager, Power Department Ingalls Shipbuilding Corporation

(7)

INTRODUCTION

The development of industrial radiography has centered around such

available radiation sources as X-ray machines and radium. Lìght-weight

portable X-ray machines and radioactive isotopes have extended the

appli-cability of radiography. Isotope s, because of their low cost and wide energy

range, have, to a large extent, displaced radium. The information contained

in this report will assist in the proper selection of isotopes and the estima-tion of exposure time for a given material.

CHARACTERISTICS OF GAMMA RAYS

Gamma rays are penetrating rays of nuclear origin. They differ from

high-energy X-rays only in their origin and therefore have the same valuable

characteristics as X-rays. Those characteristics of gamma rays which are of

particular interest ìn industrial radiography include their beìng differentially absorbed by all material, able to ionize matter,

capable of blackening photographic film,

4, propagated in straight lines, and

5. not affected by electric or magnetic fìelds,

Absorption

Gamma rays are absorbed in material in accordance with the absorp-tion formula

J = I

eJx

o

where I is the initial radiation intensity, I the transmitted radiation

inten-sity after penetrating the material, x the material thickness, t the linear

absorption coefficient, and e is 2.718. The linear absorption coefficient p.

is defined as the fractional reduction in intensity per unit length of material. Although the value of this coefficient varies with different materials as well as with different amounts of radiation energy for the same material, eaci

(8)

t he n

i = e/'

z 1n2 = 1n2 .693 X i 1,'2

This thickness of material (x1/2) is called the half-value layer (HVL) forthe particular material and energy and is useful in the calculation of exposure times and identifying unknown sources.

The energy of X or y-radiation is measured in electron volts (ev), thousand electron volts (key), or million electron volts (Mev). An electron volt is defined as the energy of an electron that has been accelerated by a

potential of one volt, Thus an X-ray machine operated at one hundred

thousand volts accelerates the electrons to the energy of loo KeV. Those electrons that strike the target in the tube and are stopped emit X-rays that

have a peak energy of 100 KeV. In general, the higher the energy of the

radiation, the greater is its ability to penetrate material.

Table I lists the half-value layers and energies of the most common isotopes used in radiography, thulium (Tm 170), iridium (Ir 192), cesium

(Cs 137) cobalt (Co 60) and radium (Ra 226). It can be seen that for iron

or mild steel the HVL increases with increasing energy. Also there is a dif-ference in HVLs for iron and lead, the lead having the greater ability to

"stop' the radiation. This agrees with the fact that materials with higher

densities and atomic numbers have smaller HVLS. For alloy steels and other materials, the HVLs can be obtained by means of the previous formula.

-2--seen from the absorption formula that there will be one thickness of material that will reduce the initial radiation intensity by one-half. That is, when

Ionization

(9)

-3-TABLE I

CHARACTERISTICS OF ISOTOPES USED IN RADIOGRAPHY

*Measured value broad beam

**Injtial HVL

***Large thickness HVL

is, particles of matter attain a. plus or minus charge. This is the primary means

by which radiation is detected and measured. If a volume is irradiated, some cf the electrons are knocked away from an atom so that we have free electrons

availa-ble. If these electrons are attracted to a positively charged anode, which may

be located centrally in the volume of gas, we will have a current flow. Current

flow gives an indication of the amount of radiation incident upon the volume of gas. This method of radiation detection is used in ionization chambers.

Film Blackening Gamma Rays

Gamma rays cause film blackening in much the same manner as light.

When film is exposed to gamma rays, a latent image is produced, which, upon

development, is made visible. Radiography makes use of this important

charac-teristic. Gamma rays absorbed in the emulsion produce development centers in

the silver halide crystal. The development centers are tiny particles of metallic

170

Tm Ir192 Cs1 37 Cc)60 Ra226

Average Energy (Mev) 083 .28 .66 L25

Production Process Pile Pile Fission Pile Mined &

Produced Produced Product Produced Refined

Half Life 125 74 37 5.3 1590

days days years years years

HVL Lead (in.) 060**

--

.39 .47 .51

HVL* Iron or mild steel .42*** .52 .67 .75 .80

Radiation output

(10)

-4-silver within the crystal. The development process will reduce this whole

crystal to metallic silver, thus developing the latent image. The film charac-terìstic and development procedure will be treated in a later section.

Effect of Electric and Magnetic Fields

Industrial radiography can be carried out under practically any envi-ronmental condition because local electric or magnetic fields have no effect

on gamma radiation. The propagation of radiation in straight lines allows the

exposure to be arranged in the simplest possible geometry: gamma source-object-film in a straight line.

Isotopes

Elements with the same atomic number but with different atomic

weights are called isotopes. Some isotopes are stable; others are unstable

or radioactive. A radioactive isotope is one in which the nuclei of the atoms disintegrate. The disintegration (decay) of the nuclei proceeds with the emission of alpha or beta particles; accompanying this decay,

general-ly with the beta particle, is a gamma ray. It is those isotopes that emit

gamma rays that are of value in radiography.

The decay of an isotope is purely random, and the number of dis-integrations per second is proportional to the amount of radioactive material present. This leads to a decay formula similar to the absorption formula described earlier

N = N e_Tt

o

where N is the number of disintegrations per unit time, N the number of radioactive atoms present at t = o, T the decay constant, t the time. and e

is 2.718.

In a manner analogous to that described for finding the half-value layer we can find a time such that the number of radioactive atoms

remain-ing is one-half the original amount. This length of time T is called the

half-life of the isotope. Since the number of disintegrations per unit time

(11)

Days Years 1 00 90 80 70 60

'o

0 5 10 15 -5--20 25 30 35 40 45

Fig. 1. Decay curves for cesium, thulium, iridium and cobalt. output is also halved in the time T. The activity of a radioactive source is

measured by its disintegration rate. The curie is the unit of measurement of

source activity and is defined as the quantity of any radioactive material that

has a disintegration rate of 3.7x101° disintegrations/sec. Radiation is

meas-ured in roentgens per time, and one method of measuring source strength Is by specifying the radiation output in roentgens per hour at one meter.

Table I gives the half-lives and the radiation outputs of the isotopes

commonly used In radiography, while Fig. 1 is a graph of the decay curves of

the isotopes. An example Illustrating the use of Fig. 1 follows: Consider a two-curie source of Cobalt 60 which has an output of 2.64 roentgens/hr at one meter; three years later the source will have decayed to 67% of its original

ys) ays) == E ====-

a---EE

E a---=_ = ni EEEEE E E _: E====

--. _&

-!EEEE

-_______,__________________'_____II_______________________________________b:.___________

---______________I___________---

---

-..---,-

---___ iii.i..uiu ________ _______________________w___.________..______.______.__.__________ . u

- -

-u-.

-(d

.---..-.----.-...U..---'.

...u...&

...UUU.USUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

uu

.UUUU$..R..aW!tI!Ufl UUIU..U.U..I.IIllUuU

:lEEI::!I::::fl:i:!

...

uu

...uuu..u..ui.I.uuu.Iu.uuuuRu

:::::h::::hd!iIdïiE

u u u i PEE! u!

. .

±

....

-:

:::::i:ii=.i:.1it

..._

!I

---e

....

¡:!!IEE!EF

...:.

:... a.0

...u..._.

...à... ..

.0

- 1 uuuuiuu.uuu..uu

LUUUIUIIIHII1

!iiL!:!ìP.hi

uu-uuuuuu

u::r.ioi

P' IEEE!!

...uiiiuuuauuu.iuiiiiuui

u.0 u

---U!UUUII u H - H-11 21) 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180

(12)

-6-value. This is equivalent to 1. 34 curies and will have an output of 1.77

roentgens/hr at one meter.

FILM CHARACTERISTICS

X-ray film consists of a silver halide emulsion placed upon both sides

of a clear safety base sheet. Radiation absorbed by the emulsion makes the

silver halide grains developable. When a film is developed, those areas that absorbed radiation are dark, while those that absorbed less radiation are lighter. The "darkness" of a film is measured in units of density. Density is defined as the logarithm of the ratio of the incident light on the film to the emergent light (D =

log'o).

For example, a density of one indicates that the incident light on

Ii

a film is ten times more intense than the emergent light, while a density of i . 3 indicates that the incident light is 20 times more intense than the emergent light.

The density of darkness on a film is dependent on the exposure time. A plot of the density versus log exposure, which gives the characteristic curve of the exposed film, is shown in Fig. 2. From curves of this type, one can deter-mine the change in exposure time to get a given change in density, deterdeter-mine the relative speeds between different films, and, by the slope of the curve,

de-termine which film will give the highest contrast at a given density. The slope

of the straight line portion of a characteristic curve is called the film gradient0 Satisfactory industrial radiographs vary in density from about i . Z to 3. 0, al-though the best sensitivity is obtained at a density of about 2,5.

The speed of a film is the reciprocal of the tìme required to get an

arbi-trary density on the film. In general, each film manufacturer selects one of his

films as speed 100 and bases the speed of his other types of film relative to the arbitrary film. For example, Eastman Kodak rates Type A film a speed of 100, Type M film as 30, and Type AA as 200, when they are used with high-energy radiation.

RADIOGRAPHIC TECHNIQUES

The radiographic procedure consists of four steps--setup, exposure, de-velopment, and interpretation. Each of these steps will be considered separately.

(13)

o.

7

10

20

Relative Exposure

Fig. Z.

Characteristic curves Eastman F, AA, and M Film

(14)

Setup

The setup includes all the preliminary steps before actually making the exposure, such as the selection of film and screen combination, source, source-to-film distance, filter and scatter precautions.

The selection of film and screens usually depends upon the resolution

required in the radiograph and the length of exposure that can be tolerated. The

characteristics of several industrial X-ray films are given in Table II.

Slow-speed film, such as Eastman Type M, du Pont 510, Ansco Superay B, or equiva-lent, is generally used on reactor components, aircraft parts, and crìtical welds.

TABLE II

INDUSTRIAL X-RAY FILMS OF SIMILAR CHARACTERISTICS

-8-*When used with calcium tungstate screens

The primary function of the intensifying screen is to reduce the

expo-sure time. The screens are placed on each side of the film inside the holder or

cassette. When irradiated, lead screens eject photoelectrons which are

cap-tured by the film, thus producing increased blackening of the developed film. For radiography with isotopes, lead screen thicknesses of .005-in, front and

.010-in, back are commonly used.

The chemical screens depend upon the emission of light for intensifica-tion. A calcium tungstate screen, when used with screen-type film such as Eastman F, Ansco high speed, or du Pont 504, reduces exposure time by as

Contrast Grain Speed Ansco du Pont Eastman

High Fine Slow Superay B 510 M

High Medium Medium Superay A 506 AA

Medium Coarse Fast Superay C 508 K

(15)

-9-much as 30 times.

The selection of the proper radioactive isotope is important in produc-ing a good radiograph. Those sources of greatest interest are Tm 170, Ir 192, Cs 137, and Co 60. A good rule for the selection of an isotope for inspection of a given thickness of material is to choose a source whose half-value layer thickness is 1/3 to 1/6 times the section thickness. The HVL for steel with

Co 60 is about 0.75 in., and 3 in. represents 4 half-value layers; therefore

Co 60 is satisfactory.

The source-to-film distance is another factor to consider. Since the

image on the film is formed by geometrical projection, the source size and distances will determine the geometrical unsharpness. A large distance will result in a very long exposure time; a too-short distance will produce an un-sharp image. Figure 3 shows the geometry involved in the proper setup. The source size, distance of the object from the film, and the source-film distance are factors related in the following manner

ljnsharpness = object-to-film distance x source size source-object distance

For optimum resolution, the unsharpness owing to geometry should be equal to

or less than the film unsharpness.

For example, a radiographic setup is to be made with Co 60 to inspect

2 in. of steel at a distance of 2 ft. The source size is a 1/8-in, cube. The

film unsharpness is .003 in. (Type AA film). Is the geometrical resolution

sat-isfactory in this setup?

2 in.

TJnsharpness - 22 in.

x(.125 in.)

.011 in.

Since the film unsharpness is less than the geometrical unsharpness, the source-to-film distance should be increased for improved resolution. Typical values of film unsharpness are given in Table III.

Another consideration is scatter, a complicated subject of which only a

brief discussion will be given here. Scatter originates primarily from two

(16)

Ug I

b

a 0

Focal Spot Width

Ug

-lo-ljnsharpness due to Geometry

Fig. 3. Line diagram showing the geometry for a

radiographic set-up.

a Focal Spot to Object Distance

Object to FiLm

(17)

*1/4-in, lead filter used

scatter). Scatter tends to fog the film, thus reducing contrast. In almost any

setup, there is a certain amount of radiation being scattered from the wall, ceil-ing, and floor of a room. Room scatter can be minimized (a) by irradiating only the pertinent area so that little radiation reflects off the wall, and (b) by

shield-ing the film (placshield-ing lead behind it) to avoid back scatter from the floor. With

Tm 170 and Ir 192, a 1/4-in, back lead is sufficient, whereas 1/2 in. is

nec-essary for Cs 137 and Co 60.

Scatter from the object can be prevented from reachìng the film by plac-ing a lead filter of the proper thickness over the film which will differentially filter the scattered radiation and allow the primary radiation to penetrate. A .030-in, lead filter for Ir 192 and a 1/8-in, or 1/4-in, for Co 60 are commonly used.

Estimation of Exposure Time

An accurate estimation of exposure time is very important with isotopes since the time involved is usually long compared to exposures made with X-ray

equipment. The opportunity for a second exposure may not always occur.

There are approximately three ways of estimating exposures (i) by technique

and sensitivity curves, (2) by calculation, and (3) by radiation measurements.

TABLE III

INHERENT UNSHARPNESS OF FILM AND SCREENS1

Co 60 - l-in. Steel

Film Screen Unsharpness

in.)

Eastman Type A or AA None 002

Eastman TypeA Lead .003

Eastman Type F* None .005

(18)

-12--Exposure calculators are also available and eliminate the need for calculation. They are a convenient form of the technique curve.

In estimating the exposure time, the shape of the object must be

con-sidered. If the object is a flat plate of known and uniform thickness, it is

simple to estimate the exposure time. An object with varying thickness s a

bit more difficult to estimate because the exposure for each thickness must be considered. Some complex objects will require two or more exposures for com-plete coverage.

Technique and Sensitivity Curves. The technique curve is the easiest method of determining exposure time if the section thickness and material are known. This curve is a plot of exposure as a function of thickness on semi-log paper (Fig. 4). If a radiograph of 2 in. of steel is to be made with one curie of Co 60 to obtain a density of 1.5, the exposure time is determined in

the following manner: first, locate the point on the 1. 5 density technique

curve that corresponds to Z in, of steel. From this point, the exposure factor, 125, on the ordinate can be located. The exposure factor may be used as a relative guide or it may be used with the following formula which considers source strength and distance:

Exposure factor x distance (in.2)

Exposure time

-source strength (milliroentgens/hr at i m)

(minutes)

From Table I, it can be seen that one curie of Co 60 produces 1. 32 roentgens/

hr at one meter or 1 320 milliroentgens/hr. Inserting the values in the formula,

the exposure time (in minutes) can be calculated as follows: Exposure factor = 125

Source strength = 1 320 milllroentgens/hr at i m

Distance = 30 in.

125 (30)(30) 1320

t = 85 min.

Technique charts i to 23 for various isotopes can be found at the end of this

report. These charts also include sensitivity loops which define an area on

(19)

meas-i

-'3-//

//

//

/2%

2.5

J

Densi y

7/

2.0

//

1.5

/

00)

A

1.0

////

0ot

/

N 2 4 r

Steel Thickness (inches)

Fig. 4. Sample technique and sensitivity curves used in determining exposure time.

(20)

*ASTM specification E 142 - 59T

-14-ure of film quality and is indicated by the visibility of a hole in a penetrameter. The penetrameter is a small strip of material that is radiographically similar to the material being X-rayec and contains three holes, whose diameters are one, two and four times the thickness of the penetrameter. The penetrameter thick-ness expressed as a percentage of the total thickthick-ness of the material being

radiographed is defined as sensitivity. The penetrameter is marked with a

num-ber that indicates the thickness of material for which the penetrameter represents

2% sensitivity. For example, if an object to be X-rayed is 1 in. thick, what

penetrameters should be used to indicate i and 2% sensitivity? For 1%

sensi-tivity, one uses a penetrameter usually marked with which is .010 in.

thick (1% of i in). For 2% sensitivity, a penetramenter marked "i" is used

This penetrameter thickness is .020 in. (2% of i in.).

Calculations of Exposure Time. A quick calculation can be made by es-timating the attenuation of the X-ray beam as it passes through a given thickness

of absorber. The sensitivity of the film is then used to obtain the exposure time

to produce the density desired.

The half-value layer has previously been defined as the thickness of

material that will reduce a given initial radiation intensity to one-half. This

value will vary a little as a function of thickness but is almost constant beyond the second or third half-value layers. From the half-value layer figures in Table I the transmitted radiation intensity per unit of source output is obtained for any thickness of the material by using one_half raised to the power of the

number of half-value layers represented by the absorber thickness. For example,

if the absorber thickness is 1.5 in. and the half-value layer is .5 in., then the

number of half-value layers is 1 .5 divided by .5 or 3. The transmitted radiation

intensity would then be (1/2) or 1/8 the initial intensity. The sensitivity of

the film is given in Table IV.

A typical example for calculating the exposure time to produce a film density of 2.0, given a Co 60 source, output of 2 roentgens/hr at one meter, an iron absorber thickness of 4.5 in., a distance of i m, and a film AA, follows:

(21)

Film Density

1 2 3

AA .35 0.8 1.3

M 2.5 5 9.3

From Table I, the H for iron with Co 60 is .75 in.; therefore .75 in. - 6

half-value layers. The transmitted radiation intensity per unit of source output for

this thickness is

16

1

64

The output of source after passing through iron is then 2/64 rhm, and from Table

IV, 0.8 is required to produce a film density of 2. Therefore the exposure time

is

.8

2/64 = 25.6 hr

The above calculation was made for a source-film distance of one meter.

If a distance of other than one meter is used, the output of the source would

have to be calculated for the source-film distance being used.

The ìnverse square law states that the intensity of radiation is inversely proportìonal to the square of the distance:

(dz )2

I d1

where d1 is the original distance, d2 the new distance,

Ii the original intensity,

and I the new intensity, Ii 5 roentgens/hr is obtained at 1 m, the intensity at

3 m is

-15-TABLE IV

EXPOSURES IN ROENTGENS FOR HEAVILY FILTERED

(22)

-16-'2 = roentgens/hr

Estimation of Exposure Times Ra.diation Measurement. Another

method of estìmating exposure time is by direct measurement. If a survey meter or other type of detector is used behind the objects to measure the in-tensity of radiation, then the exposure time may be estimated very

accurate-ly. After a reading is made in roentgens or milliroentgens/hr, and the

num-ber of roentgens it takes to produce a given density on the film is known, then the exposure time necessary to produce the required density may be

cal-culated. For example, if an intensity of 50 milliroentgen/hr ìs transmitted

through the object and . 8 roentgens is required to produce the proper film

density, then the exposure time is . 8 divided by 0.50 roentgens/hr (50

milliroentgens/hr) or 16 hr.

This method is satisfactory where the radiation intensity is low. In

areas where a high radìation level exists, a remote reading-type dosimeter

should be used. In any case, care should be used in applying this method

because of the possible danger of excessive radiation exposure to personnel. DEVELOPMENT PROCEDURES

Film should be developed according to standard procedures as pub-lished by ASTM in E94-52T, Tentative Recommended Practice for Radiographic Testing, or according to manufacturers' recommendations. Reasonable care in processing of film will ensure the highest quality radiograph.

The processing cycle for radiographs includes X-ray developer, rinse, stop, fixer, and wash. A typical cycle might be to develop for S min. at 68 F (8 min. for maximum speed), rinse 15 sec in clear water, place for 30 sec in the stop bath, fix for 5-10 mir..., and then wash in running water for about 30 min. After washing, the film may be placed in an emulsion hardening bath

for about 1 min. Film should be dried by a forced draft of air.

It is during the developing cycle while the emulsion is soft that care should be taken to see that the films do not contact each other and that han-dling of the film is at a minimum. Poor procedure during developing will re-suit in film blemishes that may appear as defects or may mask actual defects

(23)

-17-in the material radiographed.

INTERPRETATION OF PADIOGRAPHS General

Interpretation is an important step of radiographic inspection. The

in-terpreter must be given a set of standards and/or reference radiographs by which an evaluation of the object can be made. Familiarity with the material inspected, radiographic procedure, and service requirements are necessary before an intel-ligent evaluation can be made.

Film Viewing Procedure

An important piece of equipment used by an interpreter is the viewer. Two types are necessary--a large screen and a high-brightness spot viewer. Some manufacturers make these combined into one unit with a dial to control the

intensity of the spot light. Another device which is useful in the viewing room

is a small magnifier of approximately 7X. This is made in several styles in which

the reticle contains scales, lines, and/or different size circles for ease in meas-ure ment.

A few procedures that should be followed when viewing film are: View film in a darkened room. A dim sidelight for notetaking Is permissible.

Illuminate the film area only (avoid glare) Use Spot viewer for dense areas.

Keep films clean.

The first thing that an interpreter looks for on a radiograph is the penetrameter. This device will indicate if the technique is satisfactory. Secondly, a compari-son is made to the radiographic standard to accept or reject the specimen. A record of the findings is made for future reference

Standards

Numerous standards have been developed during the past twenty years

for castings and weidments of aluminum, magnesium, steel, and bronze. In

(24)

The product specification usually defines which degree is acceptable. In practice, the interpreter makes a comparison to the standard and makes a

decision to accept or reject the specimen part. The terminology used by

most standards to describe discontinuities in castings and weldments is given in ASTM E52-49T and is as follows.

1. Gas

1. 1 Gas Holes 1.2 Gas Porosity 2. Shrinkage

1 Shrinkage Cavity

2.2 Shrinkage Porosity or Sponge 2.3 Micro-shrinkage Heterogeneities 3. 1 Foreign Materials 3.2 Segregations Sharp Discontinuities 4.1 Hot Cracks 4.2 Cold Cracks 4.3 Cold Shut 5, Miscellaneous 1 Surface Irregularities 5.2 Misruns 5. 3 Core Shift 6 Weld Discontinuities la Inadequate Penetration 6.lb Incomplete Fusion 6.2 Undercut 6.3 Porosity 6.4 Slag 6.5 Cracks

Below is a list of ASTM and Military Standards:

E71-52, Radiographìc, Industrial Standards for Steel Castings. X-ray Radiographic Standards, Set of 31 plates in binder.

Gamma Ray Radiographic Standards, Set of 31 plates in binder. E98-53T, Radiographs, Reference for Inspection of Aluminum and

(25)

-19-E99-55T, Reference Radiographs for Steel Welds.

NAVSHIP 250-537-1, Radiographic Standards for Bronze Castings. NAVSHIP 250-692-Z, X-ray Standards for Production and Repair Welds. MIL-R-11468, Radiographic Inspection; Soundness Requirements for

Arc and Gas Welds in Steel.

MIL-R-11469, Radiographic Inspection; Soundness Re quirements for Steel Castings.

OD-7574, X-ray Standards for Shielded Arc Welds in Aluminum, Parts I and IÏ.

Many times the film interpreter will find defects that will cause rejec-tion or necessitate repair of completed work. At times he will be called upon

to substantiate his findings. The use of film standards and ASTM terminology

give the film interpreter a solid foundation for his decisions.

The value of radiographic inspection is not only to reject defective

parts but also to assist in the production of higher quality material. For

ex-ample, in the inspection of ship welds, the radiographer may find the first in-dication of poor quality by noting porosity or other discontinuities in the welds. A conference between radiographer and welder should be held, and this "de-fect" can be corrected by the welder, Occasional conferences between welder and radiographer should assure the welder that radiography is used to assist him. With or without radiography, welders today produce high quality welds

most of the time. It is the function of radiography to detect any discontinuities

and determin.e whether they are of significance for the specific application.

RADIATION SAFETY

The characteristics of X-rays and gamma rays that make them useful for industrial inspection are the same characteristics that make them dangerous to the human, body. The ability of radiation to penetrate large masses of

ma-terial and to ionize matter can result in damage to the body. This problem of

radiation injury has been recognized since the early days of X-rays. Recent

advances in nuclear technology have emphasized and enlarged the problem so

that considerable work has been done on the subject of radiation safety. Groups such as the National Bureau of Standards, the Atomic Energy Commis-sion, the Public Health Service, the National Committee on Radiation Proteo-tion, and many others have published very valuable data on radiation safety.

(26)

-20-A few of the basic safety guides will be mentioned here. Detailed information

can and should be obtained from the references listed at the end of this report.

General

The unit of dose is the roentgen. Table V lists the present basic maxi-mum permissible dose per week. This dose is further limited, by the present recommendation that the yearly dose should not exceed 5 roentgens, thus

giv-ing an average weekly maximum permissible dose of 100 mìiliroentgens. The

basic approach of people working with radiation should be that any unnecessary radiation exposure, no matter how small, is too much. Obviously, exposure resulting from carelessness and bad habits can only lead to overexposure and should be assiduously avoided.

TABLE V

PERMISSIBLE WEEKLY DOSE FOR BLOOD FORMING ORGANS, GONADS AND EYES

There are two simple means of minimizing exposure to radiation--shielding and distance. For field calculations, the inverse square law is a good guide, that is, doubling the distance between radiation source and ob-ject reduces the intensity (dose rate) to one-fourth of its original value. Thus,

Radiation R. B.,EO* Rems* Rads or

Roe ntgens X-rays 0.1 to 100 Mev 1 0.3 0,3 Electrons 0.1 to 100 Mev 1 0.3 0.3 Photons up to 10 Mev 10 0,3 0.03 Neutrons-thermal to lo Mcv lO 0.3 0.03 Alpha particles 10-20 0.3 0.03-0.015 *See glossary Methods of Protection

(27)

in the use of isotopes in the field, the radiation area can be roped off to pre-vent accidental exposure.

The effectìveness of material as shielding is based on its atomic num-ber and density. The measured value of this effectiveness is expressed in terms of half-value layers. Lead, with its high atomic number, is an excel-lent and relatively inexpensive shielding material.

Table VI lists the half-value layers for different gamma ray energies. As can be seen from the table, radiation intensities can be reduced with

con-siderably less thickness of lead than the other materials listed. It is by the use of these simple methods, shielding and inverse square law, that the ra.dìographer can minimize the radiation received either by himself or nearby workers.

TABLE VI

SHIELDING HALF-VALUE LAYERS2

-21-Radiation Monitoring

Radiation monitoring of an area is accomplished with the use of instru-ments either based on the ionization produced in a given volume of air (Cutie Pie Meter) or the response of crystals to radiation (crystals that fluoresce and whose light output is then measured). These instruments should be used during field exposures to determine the extent of the radiation field that may require

roping. 0.5 2.91 1.46 0. 425 0.159 0.8 3.60 i . 76 0.533 0.273 LO 4.00 i . 96 0.597 0.350 1,5 4.85 2.49 0.744 O. 478 2.0 5.59 2.99 0. 894 0,573

Energy Half-Value Layer sin.)

(28)

-22

Personnel monitoring is done with the use of film badges and/or pocket

dosimeters. Film badges are of practically universal use. They integrate the

dose receìved and thus give an excellent record of the total exposure received by a person. Film badge service is available to small groups by many reputa-ble laboratories listed in the scientific journals.

The self-reading pocket dosimeter is generally used in conjunction with the film badge on a specific job where it is necessary to know the dose received

during progress of the work. Dosimeters for this use are generally in the O-200

mr range. Pocket dosimeters of higher ranges are available, although these are designed for high-radiation fields--much higher than normally experienced. Care of Radioactive Capsules

The radioactive material contained in a metal capsule is considered a

sealed source. Rupture of the capsule may result in contamination of

surround-ing area and personnel. In order to check the condition of the capsule, periodic

wipe tests are made. This test consists of wiping the source container with a piece of cotton and then checking the cotton with a survey meter to determine

whether it has been contaminated. For cesium and some cobalt sources, ALO

Regulations3 require a wipe test once every six months. If a leaker is detected,

steps should be taken to prevent spread of the contamination and the proper authorities should be notified.

Conclusions

Shielding and distance are the simple measures to minimize exposure

that can be observed in work with radiation. People working with radiation

should be required to wear film badges. Radiation survey meters should be available to survey the area and to allay the fears of the uninformed who must come near the area. Establishment of standard procedures should he required

of persons working with radiation. Information such as is contained in the

references listed at the end of this report should be available and made re-quired reading by operating personnel.

(29)

-23-GLOSSARY

Roentgen:

The roentgen is defined as that quantity of X- or gamma-radiation which results in the associated corpuscular emission per 0.001293 gram of air producing in air ions carrying one electrostatic unit of charge of either sign.

Rad:

The unit of absorbed dose, which is loo ergs/gram.

Roentgen Equivalent Man:

That quantity of ionizing radiation which, when absorbed by man, produces an effect equivalent to the absorption by man of one roentgen of

X- or gamma-radiation (400 KVP).

Relative Biological Effectiveness.

The rates of gamma- or X-ray dose to the dose that is required to produce the same biological effect by the radiation, in question.

Maximum Permissible Dose:

That dose of ionizing radiation that, in the light of present knowl-edge, is not expected to cause detectable bodily injury to a person at any time during his lifetime.

rhm (roentqen/hr at i m):

Abbreviated form of expressing roentgens per hour at one meterwhìch

(30)

-24-REFERENCES

Hirschfield, J. J., O'Connor, and Polansky, D., Gamma y Sources

and Techniques for Gamma Ray Radiography (NAVORD Report 2666).

Washington: Naval Ordnance Laboratory.

Generai Handbook for Radiation Monitoring (LA 1835). Los Alamos,

New Mexico: Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory.

Standards for Protection Against Radiation, 10 CFR, Part 20, Jan. 20 and Amendment of May 14, 1957.

GENERAL REFERENCES

X-ray Protection (Handbook 60). Washington: National Bureau of Standards.

Permissible Dose for External Sources of Ionizing Radiation (Handbook

59). Washington: National Bureau of Standards.

Photographic Dosimetry of X- and Gamma Rays (Handbook 57).

Wash-ington: National Bureau of Standards.

Kinsman, S., ed., Radiological Health Handbook. Cincinnati, Ohio: Sanitary Engineering Center, U. S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare.

Radiological Safety Regulations (NAVMED P-1325). Washington: Bu-reau of Medicine and Surgery, U. S. Department of the Navy.

'Recommendations of the International Commission on Radiological Pro-tection" (Supplement No. 6), British Journal of Radiology, 1955.

Frazier, P. M., Buchanan, C. R., and Morgan, G. W., Radiation

Safety in Industrial Radiography with Radioisotopes (AECU-2967). Washington: Atomic Energy Commission, 1954.

8, Information on Licensing of Industrial Radiography Programs (AEC

(31)

-25-TECHNIQUE AND SENSITIVITY CURVES

Chart No. Description

i Tb 1.70, M film, Lead screens, No filter.

2 Tb 170, M film, Lead screens, .030" lead filter.

3 Tb 170, F film, Lead screens, No filter.

4 Th 170, F film, Lead screens, .030" lead filter.

5 Tb 170, F film, Patterson 245 screens, No filter.

6 Tb 170, F film, Patterson 245 screens, .030" lead filter.

7 Ir 192, M film, Lead screens, No filter.

8 Ir 192, M film, Lead screens, .030" lead filter.

9 Ir 192, AA film, Lead screens, No filter.

10 Ir 192, AA film, Lead screens, .0301 lead filter.

11 Ir 192, F film, Lead screens, No filter.

12 Ir 192, F film, Lead screens, .030" lead filter.

13 Ir 192, F film, Calcium tungstate screens, No fìlter.

14 Ir 192, F film, Patterson 245 screens, .030" lead filter.

15 Cs 137, M film, Lead screens, No filter.

16 Cs 137, M film, Lead screens, .125" lead. filter.

ï 7 Cs 1 37, AA film, Lead screens, No filter.

18 Cs 137, AA film, Lead screens, .125" lead filter.

19 Cs 137, F film, Lead screens, .1.25" lead filter.

20 Cs 1 37, F film, Calcium tungstate screens, . 25" lead filter.

21 Co 60, AA film, Lead screens, No filter.

22 Co 60, F film, Lead screens, . 25 lead filter.

(32)

o N Kl EXPOSURE FACTOR g-(ii m j m o Ql -i Ib 8

i

i i T U.UUUIuIUlIUhlUUUUuIUIUuuIUhIIlUI

uuuuuuuuii w

uiiuiuiu u

I

IlIiUI

1111111

....iiiiu I

u u u u u u u u u u u u u u u u u -4 z Ö

:::iitmrni

uiiiiiiIiiiiauIui1ãiUUIIiiiblIWfl i: uuuIuuIUIfllUlUuUuulIUlUIuIIuI I Ii .UIlIIIIIIIlllIIIuIUIUIIllIIH iilil ii

UiiIiiiuiliÍiiÍHiÍNiUiliUIIuIuIIïI I[Ï1 iii [

-urn..

.iíuniiunnuuniuuuuuuuiiuuuiuu I L

1I

.

u....u.II

w -(p

UlIIUI

O (D (J)

usi...

O')

-uuuuuu _ uu.uuuii

I

..uuI..

O. -F

u....uii

O (D

iUUU

'1 uuuuuuu

u..aiii

p P P

usi...

us... (D

-s.l...

g-. CD' (D

u...

p

u... i

(1)

uuuiii

uuuuiuu og-..

5lUIII

s...

II AhIIH

Hillil

II (t rn II .U...u.I.uuIIIuII.u..uI..unhIIflhI1lu'lnIml .. nm irnuiniri i u.i.uuu.IIIIIIIIIIIISS51UUIUIIIIUIIIIIUI11 .WI . liii. UhluhlU u..l.IIuIIIIIIIIIIIuuUUlIIIIIIIIIIII1ilUU 9 5flpVUNU RliIIUUIIIhIIUII5lIIIII Nil n uni immii 'i u Iflil uuilnIIuIIIIIIuIIIuuuIuIIuuuunhIIiiu r. I II . IUUII1I 111111111 I il uuBII.IInIInlmuui.UlIuIInIUhIIliflUU liDi. unNi IHIUUI 1.1111 urO uuu..u..IIIIIIIIIIHu....l.UUIlIIflhIIWIflINlU . ...

i.

iUlih5 1t

. ii . nun HIIII-5 ir ullUIIIIIIIIIIIIS5UIIIIlIIIlIIUlIliiIIIiIhI . :

i "IIiuhIIIIuulSIlI'IlIIil

I. ihNn1li iii u IUIIIIIIIIIIIIiulUUlIIIIIIIIUIIIIUIJWH I Ii.11hIi'UUh

I

-. I Uil flUIIIUNIIIÏ iidrt u IIIIIIIuhIIIIUluIIIIUIIMIIIIIIIIUIIII1III m.mvli.0 .. : I tmi IuiUiNuuiiiiIirni UIIIIIIIIIIIIUi.iUU1IIIIII1IIIUIIIUIWII i l.UIUhkUIlllJUI'I ...lili u

ii

su...

-g-.. 5SSlIUIIU -3 (0 . -(D II 5lUlIUU . p UliUIiUiI rio -to UI LJL

O.

r CO P Q tri -.(- . -XA IHISUISIilIIl li

...

..11.iiI!L

IHHIICUIIII1II

OIIIIH

r4 tri

iL1III-3

CD c1 tr13 IN1IUi.i.IliIIIIIIlIUItlllIluIiØl o 1111 lUiU.UiiIlI1lIIlIlllIUhIHhhl i I IIIII I :IIIII::IflUIUlIuIlluIuInuu

III IMINII

gLi...n:IfflwJmi+

iiiIUUliiIliUUlIlIflhIIlIIHhhIII ...U.uuuuu.uunu.u.unuuIlI luuIuiUluUIuIuluuuIunnnIuuumIu iWhIlhUhlIIIllIlHflhl (n IIlu...iu.nuuInuIInlnnImqwnu i urnuuiuiuuriuiur uuuIIUulUuiUUlIUhIlWuulrnmIuu,m I il uwumunmwuiirr II J tiri

..hu.U...h

I

Jp1u,.In9...IuIuIr

lilium hUU2iIIWi5IU 11H

LIA

-ill 111 uu.iuunnuuiusuuuiuuumnmuimmuuiui iIIIIUllIiIIllISSUUIIiI iUIUIIIl9fip9Iflj UUUUIIIiIiIIIIIIi5iUIiIIUIlllIIIIl lIUUUUiUuIIIUli. IIIII9fl '90

IIIUUIII IUIIIISBU ...IuhIuIn....u.luhIuIpiIiØpIUUIUU1IUIIIII11Iu.UU

lili

bohiIo1i1

J

UUIUI1U ulIllIIIi.SilIiUU llIIIIIiIiIIiliii.UIIU1U IIUI1U1IU1II1IIS5ISUU1JII UiUIIIIIiIIIIII5illIlIl INI

Ill HlliuiLII1l uuuiuuiuuuiiuiuiui nu i ill IIIDffl

fl

u...u.nuiiulu...9IuuliilliIi

jt1

IIIIII1I1I1IIII5UIiUIUII i1II1IIIIUUIIIISU5UIIIIUI

Lu..ui.

lU iIIlfliUllU9UiU lUll 1111011 i.jji

u.:.u:nuu.n...m:uul:unInu

fl

flfl

l'il'

UUUI1IIIIIIIIIIIIIUU lU i II i 11H II

I.,

II J

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!L!

z

.'

II Il II ir tri riTi

unuisuuiniuuniu iuiuui.uiuiiiuinui IIIIUliiIUiIIIIIIflUIH IiiIUUUlUUlIIIiIiIIilIl

iiui.siumiiniiun

iliflhll intim

umUrnuuuulnunumlrnnu

IL1ll

iIIIl555lIIlIiiliiIliiIIflhIlIhII UhliUllUUUiUhiiiIIIlIiUllulIIi

-I'll'

illlillii.IIIUiiiiIIIllillIllIilIII iIiIlUUlBlUIlilUiiIiiIHlIulIHhIi iiiiISi5UlUUIUiiIiNUiIilUII1 Uil 11ll

1111111 I ililIlSSIiIIlIIiIiIIliIlluIII iiIIi.u...iuulIIiIIu.u1IkiIJJII

ìIHI

IIlUUiillIIIlIlIIIilWUU ililii.UiUiUIIiiIiiIiillIiill II JI nrnuhiimiuunorrl IIuUnulIUI11IllInmi1uIwI1 J J i rnlniu'uh''n Il1 iUiIIh Ululi

5liUiliIIi' III iiuun'uiuqu

u9ilInJp.J:1jg

SU

_____I.lIIlIlhS

I

(33)

ru o o EXPOSURE FACTOR o o, o o o o o

U...

u

U...

.i...

1fi

U.... U... S...

i::

I

r

r.

R...'..

U'...-

RU....'. U.U..." U.S...'. USUflhI

± i-î U

IIIIIIIHIIIII

IIIÍi!!iHfl!

Hill!

LI

uiiriii:iirii

-Offi 'JUIHUIIHI

14- IIiiI1IiN1IIIiIHIH

ïI1!!IIIIIII

ILllh1HIIi!lliIIIIH

111111M II u iii

-- -r

r r L U lUll llUhI U UII Ifllu11Ufl L' B I IIIIIIUIUUUS rj B IIIUIIUHIURU U U IUIIUIII1MUU -lIllUluUulU.' unmuuUUm ijii41 I IIlIillURIIIH

:

---L ii:llhI:qiI

-.

Il U UUI

I U..'..

U Illl -j-UUUUI iuuIl.2. i

I UU

CA _uJUUUUII CA IUll -iiUUII iUIUi...irjiU.SBUIt

BIJ. I

UUU III r I L I

:

:''

t':I..i UI u u il

I..

...

o o UUUUUUU CD CD UU.UUU ?,. '1 , O .CD w w .-,-'-e- Ô CD CD --. CD' -U.. U.U.. -I : îrH-fI-U z o T1 '-(D CD p p '1 CD p w UUUUUIIUIIIII UUIUIIIllII UUUUIIIIUI IIUUIUU

U..'..-1 -.

I.

L

'.I..IIIU

U.UU'lIl UUUIUUU

...'UI

IUUUU IE1Í

L

IU.'.

:Y 4 9UUUJII 'r

UU. ...!

US1I I i-L BU I1il'iIhIIhLi MlItou,tIur: UUUIRIIDII I P...nu.i1q1...

U.q1

L L

1H"

!I1'1!III i

1 fi-t-a

WIllihiBhhhhi IhiuiMiBhilul iuihiliui

mii... liWiuifli IIIIIIIIIIU

lUI

'ht'

Mn...

U.U...

Utili" htli liii

L flU.UIUIII IflulliUll uIflhIIDIIIIiIt'DktIlUHhhhII UUUUBII 11h11h11 UUUIIIIIIPIi U "'II"flIOJIII9jU1II1I IIhI11h11 U.uI Ii IIIII_r B IIIIIHILI1IIIIIUIIIII L IIEUUII hUh UUIIIIIIIIIN -URRIIUUUI1UhIII1IIII

-....

i u

i -y y ululi It'll U1111q111'::0IIIffl i I t11 ':gù

U...

u i. r' i lI&miu

U'..,

kil

ff lliILuNrnIlII11UÌI

rniiuiiIï rnij;

.UIUIUIUUIII1111III1III1UIIIIIII

Il liii MI Ihi L H U. f -(J, o o

(34)

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIHUIIIIUI IIIIIIIIIlIIIIIIIIIIIII lIIllIIllIuIn IIIIlItI'uI'u lIli 111111111 lIli 111111111 II liii Ill II liii Ill 'IlIllIllIl" IIIIIlluIIIlII lIllIlIlIllIll lIlIlIlIllIll II 1111111111 III 1111111111 IIIIIIIIIIIIII lIlIlulIlIllIl 111111111111 111111111111 IIIIuIIIIII,II lIli 111111111 11H 111111111 II 1111111111 UI 1111111111 IIIIIIIIIuuuII lui IH liii

IUI III liii

¡III III 11111 liii III 1101 IlIllIllIllIll UllIllIlIllIll UllIlIllIllull III IllIllIltI 111111111111 UI 11111111111 IIlIIIIItlIl'lI m 11111111111 III 11111 lIli 11111111 lIlt IllIluIllIluIll o

uuuiva

III..

'i

uuuuuuus O

iuuuuuss

lIIIIIIlIIIIlIIHhItIIIIIIuuIlIuhIIIIIIuIIuuuuuuUIUIIUNNllIIIIIIlIIlIIItItlIIIIIIuIIIU

IIIUU

m Ii , Q _ a) o E

u.u...

,, E >" ;-. -4 c

IlUUUN

fl . .2 -.,

uuuuu.

-C) .

iiiiuu

c -, uuuuuuuuu - '

IIUUU

'C r '4-' °) O

uuiiiuu

I .i a) a) a) I ' § I W .

.u.u....u.

C' E o o

iuiuius

E-' .., '

uiiia

s

uuu.us

. . II ii u " IIUUUU N r !!!!!!!I.! 5 (

si

z

u....,-uiuuuuu 'O ¡iiiiiiiiuiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiaiiiiiiii;;ir;iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii... 5IIIIIlIIIllIIIIIIIItIIIIIuIIUtIIIIIItIIIlIlUIIUlIUIUU z I. uuuIIIuuUIuIUUUfllIIIiIIlltlIIIIlIIIIIIIIuIuUIIIIlIIIIh1IIuIIPIIUUUIUP ftlIllIIIuIIIItilIuiIhIuuuulIIlIIIIIIIIuIuuIIIIIUUUUU5 HHUU"Ifl".U .ul.u,,.u,... iiuuiuuuuuuuiius O -I', CID dOi3V 3flSOdX3

-N N s

..

(35)

UI

uuuuiuui

urniuuuu

uiiiii

u..u..uiiuui

uuuuuuuu

uuuunuuuu

uuuiuui

...uiuuu

n...iuuui

auuuuiniu

-siuuuuui uuuuiuuit

..a.uuuuuuu

.n.uuuui

iuuiii

uuiuuuuu uuuiuuuu

ti uuuuui ti

uuuuii

t-I UUuuuuII

uuuuuuuiu

,-..u.I.I.. iiuuuiuu uiuiuuu Ö UUUUIIII 1.1 UUIIIII .I...uIluI

- ti uuuuuiiii Cl. UUUUIIIUI ...uuIII - -,uuuuuuiiu

z iuuuuii

r UUUUU - 1,1 UUIUI

- u...

ti uuuuuiu

Ii...

IUII

...

---u... ---u...

u... ...

--u... --u...

...

--u...'

--u...

---u...

--u.u...'.

---u...

-...

-...l

--u.u....' --u.u...

--u...

---u...

---u...'

u.u.uu.

uuuiu

--u.u..'..

__..BUI.

o

'

CD O ' EXPOSURE FACTOR UI II II II .

-IIIIImIIISuuuuuuIuIuuuIufflfluIuuuIuIuuIIIIflIiflIuuflj IIIuIuIIIIuuIIuuuIIIflftIIIflhII$IUIIUIIUIuHIUIHJIOIIIU III.IInhImuu..uInuh,uI,IIIIIIIIft,,luluI.IIIIIIIflIuIuH

UI o o uuuuIIIIHIIIIIIIIIIIIIII1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII u.uuaa.uIu,IIIIIIIIIIUIIIII..UII1IHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII,I UIUlIUhIIIIIIIIIIHIIIIIIIIflhuIIIIIilhIIIIIIIIIIIllhI IIIIIIIIIIIUUIIIIIIIIIIUIIUIHIIIIIUIIHHflUIIIIIIIHUUØ IIIlIUIIIIu..u,u,IuuIIIIImIuuI,.uhuuuuIIflhIm,IIifluI, uuuuinuauiu _...u.uI IIIIIIIu I I I iiiIiIIflIIIIIIIIUI IIIIIIIIIIIIIII II II IIIIIIflIS.u.uufluuuuuunnnIIIIIII.,uuIIIIIuiunmJIHIuth..u...u,.uhlII ,-IIIIIIIIIIIIIU ti II II II II II II

IIIIIIIIIIiUpc;h.Irn:!uuInIuuflIII,IflImII,IflIIffiukImhI...u,uIlluI IIIrnmIIIu.,nnuuwwIuunIIInuuuuuIIIuhIm,Jfl,rnI..uuu..u.uu,uun IIIuIuIIIIuI...uuIUpIuIilHrnII.liuuIIarnIIImIwIrnnuu..n.Iu,l.n

C) IIAIIIIIHIIII IlHIlHhllIfil tri, r ti IJIIIIIIIIIIH CD p z IIUIIIIIIIIII' p I-,. . IHIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIrnIIIIIuuuuuuuIuuuumuIrnIiI5auunnII!sI!ImImrnnI..u..I.,Iu.uu, IIIIIIIIIIIIII II II II II II Il UhlIuIIIIIIlillIIuIIIIIhInUIIuuEIuuIIInII!uIIIIuIflhluuu,u,,Iuflft, t-I p ti IHIIIIIIIIIII C)

I-IIIIHIIJIIIII

Il IIIIIIIIIIIIII (D IIIIIIJIIIUII CD c IIIIIIIIIIIIII t-4 L? Il CD - Cl) IIIIIIHIIIIII II i' UI 'I II UI II i' II IIIuIurnI..uu.IuIIeI!IIwfflIrnIIuuu.Jc!uIIs;!IIIIIIuIIfflIuuuuu,..u,,Iu. IIIIIUOIIIUuIUIIIIIIIIIIIUIIIIIbIUIflIIIIIIIIIIIuIJIIIIh;'uuIuflufluuuu (D ITj ti IIUIIIUHIII C z IIIIIIIIIHIII (D IIIIIIIIIIIIII o C ¿O IIIHIIIIIIIII l-3 IIIIIIIIIIIIII (D NJIIIIIIIIIII ti IIIIIIIIIIIIII Il CD p

ti

-IIIIIIIIIIIIII Q) r '-IIIIIIIIIIIIII 1..< IIIIIIIIIIIIIJ I I iII.mIIII.lulIIII!uIIIIUInIHIIIuIuIIflIIIII:!uIIIIIIIIuIgu...,.,,uu.uI -M IIIIIIUIIIIH o (_) IIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIUIuIIIIuUI.uIuuuuuIuIII!IHhluIIuuIIuuuIIIIIIIh!'IlIIIIIIIuuuuuflunhu (D IllIlIllIllIll Il IIIIIIIIIIIIII I I 'III.uInI.uI.uuuIuuIIIuIm;;uIIuuuIIuuuuIIIIIIIuIII,?'IIIII...u.unu tIIUIlIIIIuliIftuuIInIuIInIIuuuIInhIIInmuIIInIuIIIIuuIuuuIuuuuuIu UHIIIIIIIIII

:

IIIIIIIIIIIIII I z o tri UUIIIUUUUUIIIHIIIIIIIIIIUIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIHIIIIIIIIIIIu...UIuIIuH uU.IuuuuluuunInhuIuIIuuIuunhiInhIImIhIIIIItIIIuiIflhu.IuuuI ti IIIIIIIIIIIIII c1 IlIllIllIllIll 1111111111 lIli

(36)

loo s 5

u-...

u...

u. uu

___

..wuu..u.u....

uuuau.uuuvsi

----N ----N

-u....

4

:::

L.1t4

u...

I-.--u... ..

....

I j uua Hi - :..: ___ ____

-FI1T1UW1-

-IEW1_

-30-T_T

!IIPIII

Q'1WT. C rs - TNCHES) I J I I H Ii II T I Chart No. 5

NOTE: Dashed lines map areas of equal sensitivity T EF x D -F-T = time in minutes D = source-film distance EF = exposure factor

= source output in

muli-roentgens/hr at a meter 2

-.

NNa.

N__N. JI J

u....

u....

u...

u.u...

m.u..

o (J LLh

(37)

I00 5 5 -31-Chart No. 6

---

-th

--w---

-

__=

=-

--. : ___ .

-____ __.. . ______________ . - :

IEI' .

________

-I

_. :

_____=_-ff2

.r.jt=

-

_-. . I . I _

_==_==_ -_

-= -: : :

1I1WWI::::::i

-: . : -.

WIflVN1

.

Ia----

. . .- :-___ . . . . .

---r

.

____._

.___...0

.__.u..._

._._...

.NM...

._._.,

. - . F - . - : U ._p

,

..

u

...

..._... ---:

._..

Idwa'

rju..

. .u

. . .

..

uuuuu..uuwj

.uu....ui

..uiivvu

uuiauwaE

__

_i'

I

-.1 _ -

-

... ...

. . -u ..uuu uuuu

uu

u - U .

uuu

- ua u

iiEl

....

- ...:

i

i.rf

-

-

-

-

a

H.I

U....

. . . -.I V E!EE ::. -= . -.

...

--

iu

.

_____

-:-. ... :

-r. 'IN

-:- -

- .. - . -.

--- _

..-.___m _______ . .

.u.

. I .

,

a a .

--- u_

- a. ...

ti.

-t

...u..sa

...u... .

.

ana.

a

uuu

u.iu --. - u

uuaua

S

uu.uw..u..uu...uuUu

- ¡ T. w

-

-u..u.uuuuuuuuuuuuu

a.uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu uuuuuumuuuuuuuuuuuu -. -.

-

. U11 i .- -_ U uuuuuum

uuuuum',

. i . a AU uuuuuuu..umuuuUUUUUUUUUU

-TECHNIQUE AND SENSITIVITY CURVES

FOR THULIUM-STEEL Eastman Type F film

Patterson 245 screens

030" lead filter

E. K. Liquid Developer 68e- 8 mIn

. : I

fl-_____

j

. . . -NOTF EF

-.

-T = -- ti in e -

-.,r

- sourc ex -- S - - source J (INCHES) DaRhPd lineg - I s . j; w x ) -. map areas i I miLd-a meier I ithance of -. :

_____

--P

-

_____w_____

---

__ :. -. - . - -

-

__J _-J

-_a

_________

U.-r---

aa__a

roentgens. in i n i i E-iiim f-. ouLpuL4 n u t E. s 't 4 - in . r ai

:

-

IIUIIL

uuuuuuuuuauuuuuumuu

UUUUU.UUUUUUUU..U.UUUNUU -L --, -. - . --

----

-

-- ___

.

-

-

a

-:j.: jJ

--

u....

:::

-u.u...

u...

u

-i

STEEL THICICNES- ---i -

-- u.. uuuuu

- -2 3

(38)

e o N W t) IIIuIrnIIIIIuuIII_.,.u.IIIIIuhuIIIIIuIIuuuIuI...illNnIwIIIlIluIuuuliuIHIfl1InIrIII1I:uu IIIIIIIIIIIUlihIIIIIIIUIUIUIIIHhIIIII1::H'I1Wu1191'" I II I

Ill

''

lull

Iuuu

IUIlIIIiIHhlIIlIIIUIUIIIIItlIIUIUIIIlIIIlIUUUIlUUUflhlWIUuI!IIIII II UuuuIIIft1111ilh111111 o ImIIUIIIliIIUIIINI.IUIlUIIUhIIIIIIIIIIHIIU_IUlUUU..øWIIIIIIIdil1111IL'011111IW IllIlIuIuluul I c

uuuuiiiau

IIIIIIuIIuhuIIItII.uI.uuIIImuIIuu.u,Iuuu!uua..uauu!!lIIuI!I!IIIuuI uuuII,III 111111111191 u I

UU

I Iflh;InoHIoluuu:a.uIIu(uuIuIluuuuuIflhu.I....IUHh!!!lIIlUuIIU!IUhuuI!ImIllhuIIPIIuuIuI UI flit IftlihIuUIIIuuIIUIuamUfflIlluIII IIu91IIlUuIiliuIIflhI 11111111 W

uu.iii...

IlliIiiiuiiiuijiiuuuNiulIIfll IIIuIuIIIUuuuuIUUU!lltUOI I IUIIIJII 911111111

liii

Uia

UIIUUIIU t iiiiIuiittiiiIiiiiuIui.uulIuI IIIWPIIIIIUIUIUUUUSrniii!111 U!1'jj'99 11911111

III...

IIIIiuuIiuiIIuIIUhIINuIIIII IliUIIIUUIIIlUIUIUiwi,I I 1.111 H I liii 11111 UhIuuIuIIllIflhIIIIaUIUuuIIIIIIlHIUhuuuuuuuIUIUUUUUfflI UUUWI! !Uh101ll011$I1111hh11 -. IIHIIHI1HHIUIIINIUIIIIH flqIuiuIuIuuUUuUUUUS!II II 1u!I!IIiIuIuu!LuJIr9uIuuluuu.0 ) : d +-. -'-i IIIIIlIIIIIIIIIuhIUIuuuuuIN!!I!!u1u111111Nnn' 111.11111 I.!u ILIIUHI luAu1 u ) s- -.-uuuiuuusu. )_ Q

IiuiiiiUuiiiiiuuIiiIuIiit HIIff$JIlIIuIUIIuIjj9IIi UIhIhduIU!IIIfflj II ilhIIIIlIJ

.'

iuiiiuua

iiuIiuiIiIuiuhItuIiiNuuiiivaIiuI PIiIIIiiUINUUU ijIIaflIfIIIJlWII.lU IJIlUIlUlUIlI Q ui UUUU c iiiiiuuuuu IltflIflhIIUIIIIlIIUIUIHIUIuIUIUhIIUUuIUUU InwmIuI!iluIpq.uu!uIm9lunIuIu.u.

-uhIIIIIIIIItIIIIIIt-.I.IIIuIrIII,IIIuu.uIu..u...:LrInwIliIlIIuI IeiiiiuuIII 11111111 ) o

iuuiu1iu

IIIIIIuIIuIIW,UH.UINuUIPIUIWHhuuIIuIuUUllUU

fljIfl!!uIIIIu 19.I!WI IIIlifl III I I

'

uuiiuiuU UfliuuumIiIfluliNuuIJII -b uiuuui ilhIIIUh,UliIlihIIUIlINIIUuuIIUhuuIuIUUUUIIUlflUUIU lunINlilIlIllul.. H U III . flhuIIIItIIIIlIHhuI..I.uIIflhIUUhhIIUIuIuIUUNUt flIIIIIIIHhuIuuIuI!uI!!uuIIIqIuuIuuIuI9IuI °

II u.iuu

u ) s-. a 1iuuuiuuuum IIItiIIIHhIHIIIuI,.NI.uIIIIIUIIIuI1uuIIUuIUliulUU1 iI'IP!!PIIIII!l!uIIuuIhhh!jllhhI 9

uuiu1su

HIuiIIItIflHuIUhl.UIUIlIUIUIlIIuIIIuIIuIUuIUUSUMiflI1IU&IIII1I1II9IIIuII 11111 III U Q E-Q 4 O O

uuuiiiuu*

iiiiiiiiiiuinø,u..l..rnwpIIUhI,IIuuIuuuIuuuI i!utnlIIII!III ° tn IlIIIIIIIIIuIHHIHNI.IIIU1UIIIIIIuuuIIuuulUIIURI hml,uIiiuIIIIuUIUIIUl I I II IlUlIllUl i iiiiuiuuu. uii,,iurnirnuiw.a.iuiuuiuiiiiiiuuUIUM fflhIuII!IIIIIIIIII

uhu nhIIjftI lull.

E-uii:iu.u. UhitIIiHhiIHIUUUiUiHhIHhIIUhI,uIUhlIIURNIUI IIflh!MIIIII!IIIIuIuluuI!UlIIIIIiuIIuiuuuI UU111111111011111U1U mi1,iD9uiiuuuUIUNr. .,IflffhuIuIIUI!P II.!iuuIlir O I.. UUU iuuuiiiu

miimuiiiiiiø.ui.iiIlliilliiiI'9

u,.

Z 11:11... mijiiiimiiuiiuii.ui.ui UiibuIiI I IllilU. I 111111111

II iiia

uiUiI:uiu..B. IllIIiL'I'9'IIP '«

. ..

h" N

u..

iiiiiluii y

.uiniiui.uiu.iu.

Uil III1IIU U I

I IIHIUIUII Hill HIUhIUfidllflhI1 N.0 I :ii i

lu II b Jb

'U U I UUUUURH 1111111h ff1111111 111111 ui.u.i.... 111111111

i:.uu...1:....

'it'll O Wli1911 UI.. limiti! HUIIIIlIIiUIUlUUUUUUjfl9II Iì? II it:i : IIbßIh

III9:Iu. 111ui

uIIfl IIruhin IUIlIIUIIUUUU .. IIIHuIUhIIIIUIUUI ff1 H111100t111 IUJIUflfl 91IUIUUIIUII lultilli IHIUhIIIUuIIUhU1; III i . UI lIllIUUUiU1II1;pIIlItjuUuIUIUpj liii iiuuuiu INIIIIHI uniuuuunuuiIiuuu' HII.

U_u..

lu II lull lu I III IuIIIIUII InhIulull iii.nuu..uun...a'.unrnj :uuuuu uimuuiuuu

91.

11IIHhIZIIUII9IUUI. tutlIwl .

ItuIII

!I ' !ll9HhuuIIIuu. IflhIIIIiIuI 11N1U11101 II IIIIIIIIIUIUII I illIllifi : IuIu!I.I...

...

lu, Ìf9 II:LIIIuuuuuuIuuIlI Iflulillu lUI IIUhUIUUhIUIUUIU1.wm' U

liii

IUUIUHUIIIIIUUIII Ih UIUIR ... IflHIIIU . IHIHhllIflhIuIUIUIRR!9ì 'qllM1lIII9IiI4I I rhuhhImu Ill 1lIl IIIIUUIIUUIU. :I1" :

HillhIIllllhlu.

U k'

liii 1111 I UgIIIuuIIUU.0 liwililt . , IIIIIIIIIIIIU1IU..U..:IuIlthhIIÌmHw IIIllflUUIM IliIIIIUUt!U&U.. JUIl lili 11111 lU 11111 Il IUIIliUUUI Il I UI IIII fl :. IIIIIUUIUI l Willilli WUIIIII . lIllUluuuuuuIuIU!!IU11WI "in'

9IJ ''

II I I I I 1191IjI I 111111 IUIIUUU 1111111111 . IIlIIIIluIlIuI!II-.UUUUut il!!!! fliiiIUIU UU9 IllulIllillIll III I i

nn°"

IIIIIUUUUU 1111111111 a -lIIfllUlIIUhIUUlIIUUIINuiJiunhIIll lu Pmi

u iioii milIuuiuuui I 11111111111 iiiiiUUU

In hub. uI I

tt

IIIl I l 1111111111 IIIlIIUIIuuIUUUUIU UIIIIIIII -llIlIlIlUuIIUIUUUURH flUB IIIIItI : IhIIUII1 1111111111 HHlUhlIHhuIUIIIUUUUffI!..I IIul{9fbJLllI p. I II I m 1III11111Il11I1IIluuIIIUUUUIUU IflhIIfl IlUlIlII9uuuIU.I..UUI..1p9IIIIIlIIlIluIIlIlI1I I !uh1 UNtI II9 ill I 'Fu lilulullIul uIUU..Uum 11111 . . IIllIIllI_IIIUUflUUIN .h!HuiImlJ!II.0 I ukIIuIkUJU u111j9 I

i u h

UIII' U k 11111 11111 II I I lIlIIIIUUIIUN 111111 : iIIIllIilHhIIUUUUU ululi....,... flhmILII.IU.SHt9IIFUlIII9IIIi9IlUhIIIijIIUiIIIIl9I99IIUUUUU III UlIIIIIluIIIIUIUIUIH4IW IIIUHIIIIHI1

llHIlIIIlUIIUIUUUUUUU: I!li U IIlIIUhIlIIUhIIUIIB1ftfl

Iltr1'IiIII Iq I 91 11P 111111 II U UUBUU U lU MII II III I II I I1111flII0flflIIIIIUUUIUU ILOtI

PJIßIII1IP'"

I lu... fflI,lllil!II

riilli It0iuIlllII

I1INIUIII II9IUIUIIUIUU I III I I 11111 IIUIUUUU.

:

11111101 UUIIOIIIII 19111111 1!11Ullll0hII9h1huhi111 111 I 101111111 UU I 911 blU uuu I UIIIIUUuUIIIIII IUUIUIUIUUUUU h 111P!'

IURP

II 111111I1pUIlII !IUUUUU 111111111 rnI11prnINuIIU.I lUI III 111UhR 11111 1W llIIIIIIlUOIIIII9IllIII1lIUlUNUhUU

liii 1111 IUIUUUIUHI nil

IIIIIIUIIIIIUIIIIIUIU 111111 11111U. Iluilifli IIIII1II1IIIIIIUIIUIIUUUHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIU I 0 w N tO tt) () O.L)V 3flSOdX3 ( W w

(39)

o EXPOSURE FACTOR i-C» A r ° ?J p%) C» A t'i m r r r

r

r r Wiiiiui..a.I.uIuIflhiuiiii....i..uuuuuuuiniuiuiu MUUUIuuIuuIUIuiuUtIUUuuuuuuIIuIIIUI uUUUUIIIIIUUIII!UuUUIUUUIIIHIIIIIIIUIIIIIIUjIIIIII111IIO1IIIIIIIH ...muu.."..."."uj.",,',4L11' llfl) ii ff11 hum I IIIIOIMhIllhIuUUUUUUUIUlUBhIlUlIUuUIUu.uuuuuIuuluiIIIfl I

...

... . .1L1!llhIIfflIffI! 01111 11l!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!il!!!!ffl!!n!! I uII PII ...U.UU.U..IU...U...UU.Uuuuul ii iniiuiuiuuiiuiuuauuuivaui.uuiuiiiiiiippiun ÎI$iÎjOrll1 OiIIiHll .u..U.I.IÏIIIIIIIÌUI.D1ifldiiI9iiijihI II

ooxo

(D C C pi -(D (D r . (DI z o P 11 .u....B..u'u.'uu,'...'rù"wui'mIufl» PIffffl 1flIIlDhj.Ul..IuuuuuuauuuuuHnhIuu III. ...!!I011JillJihii ItIIiIH.U..uIIuhhhIIhu1uu..IIIuIIuIuIhuhIlIhl IrdIH1rnuuu.IUun.uuuuI.uuuuuuuuuiiuIuuiiuuI .u...UuIIIuIIuuu5uu....I.iuIILp,.,9'h 1ff flJuuu.UuuUuuIIIuIIuuuuu.uuuuuuumuiii rD 'w,juut.uu..u.uuuuuuiuiin...nu....umu lin i t .u...IIiIIIiIuuIIiI.t,'.UuIuiu.uuuili'inl iiiuiiiiiIH...iui.iiuiuuiiiuÍiIIliÈ

--ililuli luuipplu ....Uu...uu.uuu...u.uuiuiuuiHuui ti luIIIwI....I5.Iuuuu.uu,,u....uuuuu...uuun.Im u 1 uu ti uuuluuu.I..nu..u...u.q.i.uuuwl!mnbliII1 Uhu u. UlIIIIUIIlIIH..U..UuuIuI liii JI II uu IuuIuIIIuuIuuuuuuuIiuuuIwI!llIuuI.qí.

..

....uuuuuull..._...

u.

UIflh.Hu.UI.uUU...II9ll'i!!Il'H'p

¡jUUI !!!!!!I!!!PflJ!II!!H!!IIIIIIIIIIlIU!

u.

iuiuuuiiiuuuuuumuiiiuuu uuiuuiiiw i au

.uuu.iuumuu..u.ui..uu un uiiui.iuii1,i1! WOJIl ii

i!!i i .IIUIIIUUulIuua...Iuu'uu"UII'urn'hq a. .uuuuuuuu.,..u....uuuuu.u.uuuu niu.nin uu ti Uluuunuu.uuul.u....i.uu.u.ini,u.iiii,..iiu u. u IUUuIHuuuuulI....u.uu,u.uuu.uiuumnrn .0 cn

u

IUuuulpflhIfluu..IIu.uuIuu.U.Uu,uIJp1, L -i 11111 .. -4 ullunhuuuuuuu.u.u.uuuuuuuuuu,.uu...uIphl u. z IIUlU.IIIfl....IIuIuIIIuuIIuuupl L il ö IuuuuuIuuuuuu.uu...uuu a. u.uunumiu...i..'JifffluuJIll m.i...1uuiuunu..uuuuuuuuuuuuuuiiii u.uiuuuuu.u.u...u...uuii.uuiiui III11llIll'IIIIIIIII IIIIIUIUIIDIIIIII 1111111111 11111 VI ti ti (DP w (D (D _P o O -. P i 1= (D 10110111 11011111 11111 11111 1111111111

9III9

?iS 111111111 1111111ff iii lIhIlIllIllIllUlU b .. 1W WIIIIIIIIIIDIIIII I. 11111 UIl It h III II IIIIIIIIIIIIIIOIII lulohlilil I 111011 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIID 11111111 1111111111 11111111 1111111111 tilo I1UIIUIIIIIII lili 1111101 1H IDIlIO 10111111111111 11110111111110 iii 11111101 III 111111111

IlIAD 111111111 kil IlililhIlhIlIl Hit 1111111110 O hIll 111101 Hl 111111111101 11111011111111

11111110111

111111

III 11111111 III III Ill I

ID 01111111111 1h11 11111111 aa.IIIUrIIuIIF!inuuriIuIuIuunIhuhIu 11IIllbl1DlthhIhhIill t hhPhIllhIIlIlIIIlIiIlIIhII i mi IAiDhiHlil11Iu...IIuIuIuIflhull...IuIuuuuuurJuImaulhhoolnIm, uiiiolll i

I

i11flD...uhVIunIrIuu.u.f1.u.uu..uuuIa,n.fl1ìiffiUhu,Duuuùlu '1110111-'iHuIIiilhIffluhiÈi i u lIIIllIhulthhI..u..u.IIuuuuuuuuuu....u.uauu.uiiuuuuuuuuiuj,,ouiii,uoiu I 1 111111 ii JI ii11111hlluoa.u...unnuuulu.u...unnu.uuuuuuluuuuul011uuonhlfflhhmmll 11111111 uhhillIllil 11101 IIlIhIIIlDfllU.I.UIuuIuuuIullIl.a.BUhulUhuIUIUiluIhlhhI0mhhhulllUQhIhlIhhIlwIwl uIHhllIlIlIlIVhlI INIOMIIiIIilOI IlllllhiIlIlIlhIIlhIlIl iiiiiliiiiIIiiiIuohI niillrniohlirni OlhlhlhIhhhlIIlhhhI u.iIÍuiiu.uuiiuuuÍiiiU.iÍuiUiuijiuiuiiiiflhfluiflÍjjjiIjhflIUjiiihijijjffihjhuijijijIllhji ohiuhl,I,hIrnmhIl a...uuuu.uuuuuuuluu...nu.u,nhuuIInunuIluouhIunnhIulhimnulq uhiiuuhIiIlll 11111101 11001011 u IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIOI mi.u...1u.IuuuuuuuIul...ui.u.uujuIiifluiiffiffiUflfluujùflfluiujjflfflOijjijiftiEjjijj

'rJI fl ilIhililli 111111 I111,1I11IIIIIIllHI

iIi io "IHOIm.huh1u.hhh1uh1u11111.u...uu11111uu111u11.1111111111uhu1m10u1ul 11111111111111 hhhuuIIIUIuIuIulluIIlIa.IuIuulnuuuulIuunInmuhinInhiirnIuiiiuio ill 111111111111111k '1:oiwiiiiiioiu III 111 JI Il1111l 1I11HIII.i111II11I ÜU1IÌUUIHUUUiiitiiillfflffl Iii V i 110111 lillO

auIIuIuuuuuuuuullua.IIIuuuuuuuunIuImuhImIhhDtnUtrnuilIuIuhl Ii[UlhlhlhlIIIIllllff 11a.u..IIIuIuIIIluulu..uI.uII.uijÍuuHifluuflflÍüjUÍDmùflflUÌftfl$nHwflmifthiIhhwIIff

I IIII 4 II jill 11H IllIlIjIllIll oI.u..u..IIInu.uunI...uIu,un.uIuIu,nuuuInuuuilumiuhulnuwiuuirnIlhlIlIhog Ii i iHi uuu.u...uuuluuuluuIuu...Iuuuu.uuu.,uuuIinuuIloohIuhluIIpllIhihlllhihiiuiihhm,hIIIhIhllllIo. 1111111 liii ID 11...u..uuunhuuu.uu...uIu..uu.uu.uu,,,,Ifll.u,oDIDIuIuuhIlhInuI,uluiphIflQuIuhhInh'h,Iffl 1hlla...uuuuunuulu,...uuuuuuuuluu.uiulpuuuIuuuurnhmiliuhlIuilh,umluuhh1ulnhIlhhIhhIDIl H1II1I "'H' J!flhI Ill kll III 1 IhlUUUUUIIIIIh0SIIII uuuuuinuuuuuuuuuuii uuau.uuiuuuuuiu lillIlUlillIlI 11111 "11101t'IHr'IHflhiiii' iuiiuiurniuii IIUIIIIIII1HIHIIII I itlHhIIlhlIIIItilikDihIhlfflID u ilIhlIhl IIIIhhilhIhIIlI...iuIuuuIuuuiiuiiUuu...iuIIjiiiiuuuuuuIuuulu,I,lrnuiiphliwl I I

ii I

flhII'hu.uuuuuuuuIIuuuuluua.uIuuuuuuIuIuuuupluuuIuJuuDuIIhhmim Il Il 111111 L111iIh11111ii11i1 1111111

(40)

II WUIIIIUUIIUUI HIffllUWUhIlfflhlIflhIluINulflhlllI iiiIii:iI11 uurnu.1.uuouuwitIIuiIuu,11 uhIlIIIlljIIlHlIlllll,UU,,llUlflH I lUhUIIIUUU I IIfluiiIuiiuiiIU4IuIllIIllIIIuIIIIIIUuUU lull! li I !ll [O !1!Iii!111! iiìiiiiflîiHiEHiiiiiiiiiflmiDUHiiiiuiuiIuluIUIH 1I I 'I ioiiuuiii:::ir.::::u i

I---.ii.1

""I'll.

UU_?1l I II II. iillÌHuIÌüuiIIilhIuiUiiiii IlUIllJlIIIIlllilUllulIliIII 1111111F! :

:::r""

tllllIlIIlllflhliiliilillIlUI 'Ill'.. IlIllIllIllIlli II1IIIIII1IIII IIilIuhIIIHhIIIIIIIIlIuuIIl I

.11u:...II:Ii

I'll"

nl".. ïiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiIÌiiwiiHIIIiiIIiÌUUiiÍi1IÍffllllIlllUl1ilUlIIiHliIlIiUUUII uIiiIiUiiIIiüffluiiIiIiiliiflhI IIHuiiuiiiuuiiiil'U!RHIUII

urn unuu..uirn flUllilIlUUUUIl

VIIIIUH HIIHWIIIIIIIIIIIUIII U

lull

li IUUUUU.ImHlUl JUlI UWUIIiIIII III11II1I1IUUIIII

im: .ff:::::1111W111 1H11 iouou:t o:iuiiou: UI lIUlUlløuliiiillllIuIIIlUlUuuINiilUIUUUUUUU IHIIIIlllUllIUhllllIII '11UIII111II1IIIUUU liii IHIIIIIIDIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIUIII1HHIIIIIIIUUIUU III

Ill JUHIIUIIIIIII1IUU UIIIIU1IIUIUIIII

Uil IIIIIIIIIIIUIIIUI11IIIII1IIJIU1IIIIIIIIIIIIIUUIUU11U IIUIHIIIIIIIUIIIIIIII IlIilllllllllllIulII uiimniimInh.uu..uInhIIIIlllllnhlIIIlliUU i IIiIllhiHllllllllllllIII HilllllIllllllIIlU IüiIÜh,iÎîiuÎiIiiiii.uUÎiuiiiIlIIiIIiiuIIuuuiii.irn ' UriumhuirnI.n.n .uirnuim...ui.. Vii 1IIIIIIIIIIIIUIIIHI1IHIIIØIIII1IIUIIIURIUl' ti 1t IIIUIUHIIIII il Willi 11111111 liii lIrnhlrnrnuhIIHIuiuirnIrnlInua.uuRuU Ii lIlilUlUflhll 11111111 11111111

lilt! VII IrIuhIlUIUlllllPlulIUfthIIIIIaU.UU..

l II1IIII1IUIflU II Iii ill 1111101

WI! IlLil 91 IJIIIIIIIIIUII 11111111 11111111 11111 11h11 il1IHllIlIIlllliIlUlIlUlII1IIIIlUUR li JI IIIUHUIIIIII JI HIUIIHIIIIIUII 11111!!' 'UIIIU--. I u flui i uuiuuuu. J I] fll II hi HIIi!l!119!UU

JrIHN

] 1mk1111..11. 11111 lIpIIlulullIIUullU! H lI'UI it !1l!lI!IIIPI!I!u!. III iiUIulIlUIIUI.UUUUU flUlUIHllIIllllHllIIhIh flHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIHIIIIUII Ill ffl LiI11H1 Ik.

Il."

JI1I'1Uj1' p" IiIiIu1OI l!IIu iiH lIilIIllUIUllId:: llh:Hi:iIIi1miHmmI HIoIrroou.:u

ill"

lUi 0IHIIUU.I

u....

!!l!UUU IIIIIlIIII!..I.!UU iulUIlI.IuIlIlUN jgUr911uii11IiHU I

I IIUIUU

uul!uUU ..UUU.... .1g:::

1IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIUUUUUU t WlIiliIlllIIliuUUU UUI1IIIIIUIIIUUU UU1llIllIhIlIllUU IIIIIII1IIIIIIIIIIIUU IIIUIIII1IIUUIIIUIUI IIIIIIIWIUIIIIIIUUU UIIIIIIIIIIUIIIIIUUU IIIIIUIIIIUIIIUUUUU IIlllllllIiIIIUIUUUU 11111 WIIIUhIlUIU

Ill UIU 110::

:!:aii!

All 1UIIIIUIU 11111 IUIIUIOUU 11111 i illUIllIlIUUUR IOU I IIIIIIIIUUUUUUR 11111 I IIIIIIUIUUUUUUUU 11101 lIlIIllIllUUUU 01111 II1IIIIIIUSUUUU UIIUUIUUU 'uU'uuIUu.. IIIIUIUUUUl' IIIRUUUUU

IIIflhIUU

IuIH.uU

I.IIIUU.U..0

lIna...

hIlIIIIUU11 lIIIlUUU

IUiIUR

IlIlUUUUUUU 'hluu.IUU... IhIlu... UIIllUUUUI UIIUUUU UIIIBUUU IhhI..UU.... UUUIUUUU

U.U...

IIIIUUUUU lllIflUUUU IIIUIUUUUUU

U.'....

IIIIIIIUU

::unn

UIIIIU

W r-W o r-W W r-lIOi3V 3iflSOdX llHOjmftmfhhhhhImfhh!llLu 111111 rn illIlIllIllIlIl lUih9lIIuUIU$UlIiliIlil'iI IilillllhillOJQOuibluIh1Bh1_ IIIHUIIIU

iiiuii.ill'uiuiu..

IUUUULk huluimin i

...

Iiiuuirj I Ilb1IIIIIIUI i lili IIIIIIUUUUUU lIIIk9IiiUUI lU i IIIIIIIIUUUUU IlUbUHUU liii 0 i UIIIIUIIIII9IIUIIHUUU llhIlIllUli lì HIIIIIUIIIUI IIUiU 'rl' uiuíííiiiiuiiuiuui.. ILl E JIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIU 1 II1III11f1W lIUIIIIIUUUUl 11uiuipluuim.t

-Q' IIIIUIIhIIUU1UUURE t I lIfl 2 NWUflMu'ml'. I1mt ,

Illl.iWllIUlUU

IJ lIIh1Iii llftflu1fliUIIURU h k 'lI"IU uuuuuuauu Ill Z Z uu.uu.iuu.. a? ..-, IfllUlUUUIIIlUIIUUOII1iIOIILlhIIhIflIUUUUU JUlI! ci I uiuui.u.:ui.iu... t IllllUIhhI1lIUUU lIUUnh.u....

,ulI'I...u...

i..uuium.... 1H11H11' IUUUUR llk1IIlUUUU lIillIllIl Z ai 11H lOUhUIUIIkUN I Ifl'90i 'Ill ilIlillIll . ' lllIlllIIlUIUlhU. kOlilNi llllll1h" lhIUIk'IUhUUU IIUIILIUUUUU WflIlW lilIp1llUIIIWU.U.U.

u'

;:I!!1I!ßl.,uIuIurn.I._ hUUI

p lUll Ill UUUUU

UIIUIIIUUHUU IIIIIIIUUkUUU11 uilituillI O u N" il

ou ..:

u1IIiiIiiiiIIiO jI10fl11flffffiiIi'iOIMiI6IpihiI1hIuI: ¶11111 fr. I II1IIIIUUUUUIH 11111 IIIL l...IllIlUlIIlll: IIJI.11.... IIUIHU

Cytaty

Powiązane dokumenty

We pleiten daarom voor een nieuw frame, waarin fondsen veel meer worden gezien als handige tools voor het verkrijgen van langdurig commitment en binding tussen

Obejmują one1': planow anie zakresu - określenie i dokumentowanie zakresu projektu jako bazy do podejmowania przy­ szłych decyzji, określenie zakresu - rozbicie

BOCZNIKI POLSKIEGO TOWARZYSTWA MATEMATYCZNEGO Seria I: PRACE MATEMATYCZNE X (1967). ANNALES SOCIETATIS MATHEMATICAE POLONAE Series I: COMMENTATIONES

W agn er od pierw szych lat kapłaństw a in teresow ał się teologią liturgii i jej

2 Properties of a Function of One Variable Exercise 2.7.. 2 Properties of a Function of

Given a density function, the aim of this note is to give a martingale construction of a stable sequence of random elements having the given density function.. The problem was solved

To obtain ∆p you can use the momentum representation of the momentum operator and apply it to the state

The paper has been intended to introduce a method of evaluating the damage hazard and fatigue life of a structural component of an aircraft for: a given spectrum of loading