• Nie Znaleziono Wyników

Geometrical presentation of preferences by using unfolding models

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Geometrical presentation of preferences by using unfolding models"

Copied!
9
0
0

Pełen tekst

(1)

! " # $ % & ' ( ) * & " " & * # + , - . & ( % * & * # /,+& #,(!,%,0&! ##1234#1565# # # # # !"#!$%&'(!)*+ # #

!"#!$%&'()*+%!,!-$($&"-*".*+%!.!%!-'!,**

/0*1,&- *1-.")2&- *#"2!),*

* *

(34567859# $789:;<7=# <># ?# >@AB<?:# B?>A# 98# CD:E<;<CA7><97?:# >B?:<7=F# &E# ?>>DCA># EG?E# ;<88AHA7E#

<7;<I<;D?:># @AHBA<IA# I?H<9D># 9JKABE># 98# BG9<BA# <7# EGA# >?CA# >@?BA4# JDE# ;<88AH# L<EG# HA>@ABE# E9# LG?E# EGAM# B97><;AH# ?7# <;A?:# B9CJ<7?E<97# 98# EGA# 9JKABE>N# ?EEH<JDEA>F# &7# D789:;<7=4# EGA# ;?E?# ?HA# D>D?::M# @HA8AHA7BA#>B9HA>#98#;<88AHA7E#<7;<I<;D?:>#89H#?#>AE#98#BG9<BA#9JKABE>F#"GA>A#;?E?#B?7#JA#B97BA<IA;# ?>#@H9O<C<E<A>#JAELAA7#EGA#A:ACA7E>#98#EL9#>AE>4#<7;<I<;D?:>#?7;#BG9<BA#9JKABE>F##

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

(2)

HEDH#.?J9H>V<#

2XX#

&&@*.1))0*-"-#!$%&'*1-.")2&- *

#

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

F

F

F

F

] ! -R 4]S R!4-S R 4!S R]4!S R 4-S R]4-S _-_]_! # /<=DHA#6F#/D::M#797CAEH<B#D789:;<7=#?7?:M><>Z#?S#D7<;<CA7><97?:`#JS#EL9#;<CA7><97?:# *9DHBAZ#9L7#HA>A?HBG#J?>A;#97Z#!9O#?7;#!9O#1556F#

(3)

\A9CAEH<B?:#QHA>A7E?E<97#,8#QHA8AHA7BA>#]M#$><7=#$789:;<7=#09;A:># 2Xa#

"GA# D7<;<CA7><97?:# C9;A:# B?7# JA# =A7AH?:<YA;# E9# >AIAH?:# ;<CA7><97># R>AAZ# ]A77AEE4#b?M>#6[X5SF#&7#EGA#CD:E<;<CA7><97?:#B?>A##EGA#>@?BA#B?7#JA#;<I<;A;#D@# <7E9# <>9E97<B# HA=<97># JM# EGA# GM@AH@:?7A># ;A8<7A;# JM# A?BG# @?<H# 98# 9JKABE># R>AAZ# /<=F#6JSF#"GA#<>9E97<B#HA=<97>#?HA#:?JA:A;#?BB9H;<7=#E9#EGA#@HA8AHHA;#9H;AH#89H#EGA# @9<7E># <7# ?# @?HE<BD:?H# <>9E97<B# HA=<97F# /9H# AO?C@:A4# ?::# @9<7E># <7# EGA# >G?;A;# HAP =<97#<7#/<=DHA#6J#G?IA#EGA#@HA8AHHA;#9H;AH<7=# !-!]!!F#

# "GA# C?<7# @H9J:AC# L<EG# EGA>A# D789:;<7=# EABG7<c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

&

$

%

&

' ' ( ! * + +* * + +* +* . . . / d 1 1 4# R6S# # LGAHAZ#

(4)

HEDH#.?J9H>V<# 2Xe#

$

%

&

! ( ! ! & *& +& +* 1 0 . 6 1 #f#;<>E?7BA#JAELAA7#B+#?7;#<*4# S R d +* +* 2 . . ! #f#C979E97<B#HA=HA>><97#98#. #97#+* #+*F# /9H#797CAEH<B#@HA8AHA7BA#KD;=ACA7E>#;<>@?H<E<A>#.d #CD>E#>?E<>8M#EGA#C979P+* E97<B#HA>EH<BE<97Z# # g g g g* d+* d+* + +* # *. ). # " # #

$789:;<7=# >9:DE<97# B?7# JA# B9C@DEA;# JM# EGA# C?K9H<Y?E<97# ?:=9H<EGC4# LGAHA# *")(**# <># HA;DBA;# JM# <EAH?E<IA:M# E?V<7=# \DEEC?7# EH?7>89HCF# 8EAH#3# >EA@# 98#

<EAH?E<97# EGA# D@;?EA># 98# A# ?7;# 0# JAB9CA># R>AAZ# ]9H=4# \H9A7A7# 15534# @F# 1[af 1[eS## # #

+

,

+

6 6 6 6 6 6

,

6 6 6 6 6 6 S 4 R S 4 R S 4 R S 4 R ( ( ( ( ( ( " ( ( ( ( ( ( " " ! " ! 3 3 3 3 4 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 0 0 A / A 0 A / C 0 0 0 A / A 0 A / C A DD ED DD ED EE EE # R1S# # LGAHAZ# #

+ ,

CEE- - , 6R& R- ,S 6EE4S ( ( -" ! ( " 4# #

+ ,

CDD, , - 6R& R- ,S 6EE4S ( ( -" ! ( " 4# * E*F*?#B9:DC7#IABE9H#98#97A>4# S 4 RA3(6 03(6 /ED #f#C?EH<O#L<EG#A:ACA7E>## # # . / . 0 1 ! 2 ( ! ( ( ( ( ( ( 5 S 4 R 89H## ######### ########## 5 ######## 5 S 4 R 89H## ### S 4 R 6 6 6 6 6 6 3 3 +* 3 3 +* 3 3 +* +* +* . . . ' 0 A 0 A 0 A # N# S 4 RA3(6 03(6 /EE #f#;<?=97?:#C?EH<O#L<EG#A:ACA7E># !(

&

4 * +* ++ ' ' # S 4 RA3(6 03(6 /DD #f#;<?=97?:#C?EH<O#L<EG#A:ACA7E># !(

&

+ +* ** ' ' F#

(5)

\A9CAEH<B?:#QHA>A7E?E<97#,8#QHA8AHA7BA>#]M#$><7=#$789:;<7=#09;A:># 2X[#

!" #$%&'(#

2e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hS#?7;#@H9=H?C>#Ri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

(6)

HEDH#.?J9H>V<# 2a5# (5 IABE9H#C9;A:#R@G?>A#&'S4# (5 ><C@:A#D789:;<7=#C9;A:#R@G?>A#&&&S4# (5 LA<=GEA;#D789:;<7=#C9;A:#R@G?>A#&&S4# (5 =A7AH?:#D789:;<7=#C9;A:#R@G?>A#&SF#

"GA# @G?>A># ?HA# <7# 8?BE# 89DH# ;<>E<7BE# C9;A:>4# LG<BG# ?HA# 7A>EA;# <7# EGA# >A7>A# EG?E#A?BG#@G?>A#<>#?#>@AB<?:#B?>A#98#EGA#97A#@HABA;<7=#<EF#

"GA# ><C@:A>E# G;85>6* H>?;I# ?>>DCA># EG?E# EGA# >DJKABE># B9::?@>A# EGA# CD:E<;<P CA7><97?:# >E<CD:D># >@?BA# <7E9# 97A# ;<CA7><97# HA@HA>A7E<7=# EGA# 9H;AH# 98# @HA8AHP A7BAF#WA#B?7#D>A#EG<>#C9;A:#LGA7#?#>DJKABEN>#:<V<7=#89H#?#>E<CD:D>#<>#@HA>DCA;# E9#<7BHA?>A#9H#;ABHA?>A#:<7A?H:M#?:97=#A?BG#;<CA7><97F#"GA# C9;A:#?>>DCA>#EG?E# EGA#@HA8AHA7BA>#L9D:;#G?IA#EGA#89::9L<7=#89HC#R-?I<>974#6[e^4#@F#6X1SZ# # # # 4 6

&

! " ! ! & * +& *& *+ 6 1 5 # # R2S# LGAHAZ# *+

# # F# EGA# >EHA7=EG# 98# @AH>97# *N# @HA8AHA7BA6# # R*!6#414# #4,S# 89H# >E<CD:<##

+#R+!6#414# #4-S4## *& 6 #F#:<7A?H#HA=HA>><97#LA<=GE4## +& 1 #F#:9B?E<97#98#>E<CD:D>#+#?:97=#?EEH<JDEA#&##R&!6#414# #4HS4## * 5 #F#?;;<E<IA#B97>E?7E#D7<cDA#E9#>DJKABE#*F##

"GA# IABE9H# C9;A:# HA@HA>A7E># A?BG# >DJKABEN># @HA8AHA7BA# ?># ?# IABE9H# ;<HABEA;# E9L?H;>#G<>#HA=<97#98#C?O<CDC#@HA8AHA7BAF#&E#<>#?#>@AB<?:#B?>A#98#EGA#<;A?:#@9<7E# C9;A:#LG9>A#<;A?:#@9<7E>#?HA#?::#<78<7<EA:M#8?H#?L?M#8H9C#EGA#@9<7E>#HA@HA>A7E<7=# EGA#BG9<BA#9JKABE>F#"GA#@H9KABE<97>#98#EGA#>E<CD:D>#@9<7E>#97E9#EGA#IABE9H#HA@H9P ;DBA# EGA# >DJKABEN># @HA8AHA7BA# I?:DA>4# ?7;# ?# @HA8AHA7BA# H?7V<7=# <># <7EAH@HAEA;# ?># EGA#9H;AH#98#EGA#@H9KABE<97>#98#EGA#>E<CD:<#@9<7E>#97#EG<>#:<7AF#09HA9IAH4#EGA#?7=:A# LG<BG#EGA#IABE9H#C?VA>#L<EG#A?BG#;<CA7><97#B?7#JA#EG9D=GE#98#?>#HA@HA>A7E<7=# EGA#>?:<A7BA#98#EG?E#;<CA7><97#<7#EGA#@HA8AHA7BA#KD;=CA7EF#&7;<I<;D?:#;<88AHA7BA># <7#@HA8AHA7BA#?HA#AO@HA>>A;#JM#EGA#;<88AH<7=#;<HABE<97>#LG<BG#EGA#IABE9H>#G?IA#<7# EGA#B9CC97#>@?BAF#

$J;* 4KHLI;* MNO>I?KNP* H>?;I# <># EGA# 8<H>E# 98# EGHAA# C9;A:># LG<BG# ?>>DCA#

797:<7A?H# :<V<7=# 8D7BE<97F# &7# EG<># C9;A:4# @HA8AHA7BA># G?IA# EGA# 89::9L<7=# 89HC# R-?I<>974#6[e^4#@F#6X2SZ# # # #

$

%

4 6 1 * ! & +& *& *+ !

&

0 (1 "5 ! # ## R^S# ################################################# 6#<E#L<::#JA#?>>DCA;#EG?E#G<=GAH#I?:DA>#98# *+ # ;A><=7?EA#>C?::AH#?C9D7E>#98#@HA8AHA7BA#

(7)

\A9CAEH<B?:#QHA>A7E?E<97#,8#QHA8AHA7BA>#]M#$><7=#$789:;<7=#09;A:># 2a6#

LGAHA#0 #<>#EGA#:AIA:#?:97=#;<CA7><97#&#EG?E#EGA#>DJKABE#*#B97><;AH>#<;A?:#R<;A?:#*&

@9<7E#B99H;<7?EASF#

"GA#C9;A:#?>>DCA>#EG?E#>DJKABE>#>G?HA#EGA#>?CA#>AE#98#HA8AHA7BA#;<CA7><97># JDE#EGAM#;<88AH#<7#EAHC>#98#LGAHA#EGA<H#<;A?:#@9<7E>#?HA#:9B?EA;#<7#EGA#>@?BAF#(?BG# >DJKABE# G?># 97A# C9>E# @HA8AHHA;# @9<7E# <7# EGA# >@?BA# R<;A?:# @9<7ES# LG<BG# >AHIA># ?># ?#HA8AHA7BA#@9<7E#E9#@HA8AHA7BA#9JKABE>N#>B9HA>#JM#B9C@?H<7=#EGA<H#;<>E?7BA>#8H9C# <;A?:# @9<7EF# &E# <># EGA# B<HBD:?H# <;A?:# @9<7E# C9;A:# <7# LG<BG# @HA8AHA7BA# ;ABHA?>A># L<EG#EGA#>cD?HA#98#EGA#;<>E?7BA#8H9C#EGA#<;A?:#@9<7EF#

&7#5J;*=;KPJ5;?*MNO>I?KNP*H>?;I#>DJKABE>#?HA#?:>9#?>>DCA;#E9#G?IA#?7#<;A?:# @9<7E# ?7;# E9# >G?HA# EGA# >?CA# >AE# 98# HA8AHA7BA# ;<CA7><974# JDE# EGAM# ;<88AH# B97><;P AH?J:M#<7#EGA#I?:DA#EGAM#?EE?BG#E9#EGA#;<CA7><97>#98#EGA#>@?BAF# BB9H;<7=#E9#EGA# LA<=GEA;#C9;A:4#@HA8AHA7BA>#G?IA#EGA#89::9L<7=#89HC#R-?I<>974#6[e^4#@F#6X3SZ# # # #

$

%

F 6 1 1 * ! & +& *& *& *+ !

&

6 0 (1 "5 ! # # R3S# # "G<>#<>#?7#A::<@E<B?:#<;A?:#@9<7E#C9;A:F#"GA#:97=A>E#?O<>#B9HHA>@97;>#L<EG#EGA# :A?>E# <C@9HE?7E# ;<CA7><974# ><7BA# <E# E?VA># =HA?EAH# I?H<?E<97# <7# EG<># ;<CA7><97# E9# @H9;DBA#?#=<IA7#BG?7=A#<7#?EEH<JDEA#>EHA7=EGF#"GA#>G9HEA>E#?O<>#<>#EGA#C9>E#<C@9HP E?7E4# ><7BA# ?# >C?::# BG?7=A# <7# EG<># ;<CA7><97# M<A:;# :?H=A# BG?7=A># <7# ?EEH<JDEA# >EHA7=EGF#

$J;*P;N;67I*MNO>I?KNP*H>?;I#;H9@>#EGA#?>>DC@E<97#EG?E#>DJKABE>#>G?HA#EGA#

>?CA# 8<OA;# >AE# 98# HA8AHA7BA# ;<CA7><97F# &E# ?::9L># EGAC# E9# >EHDBEDHA# EGA# >@?BA# ?># EGAM#L<>G#JM#@H9I<;<7=#EGA<H#9L7#HA8AHA7BA#?OA>#>@?BAF#(?BG#>DJKABE#<>#I<ALA;# ?>#G?I<7=#?#>@AB<8<B4#C9>E#@HA8AHHA;#<;A?:#@9<7E#<7#EGA#>@?BA4#H9E?E<7=#EGA#?OA>#E9# G<>#9L7#HA8AHA7BA#;<CA7><97>4#?7;#EGA7#?EE?BG<7=#?7#AI?:D?E<IA#LA<=GE#E9#A?BG#98# EGACF#!97>AcDA7E:M#EG<>#<>#EGA#A::<@E<B?:#<;A?:#@9<7E#C9;A:#L<EG#H9E?E<97F# BB9H;P <7=#E9#EG<>#C9;A:4#@HA8AHA7BA>#G?IA#EGA#89::9L<7=#89HC#R-?I<>974#6[e^4#@F#6XXSZ# # # #

$

%

4 6 1 j j 1 * ! & +& *& *& *+ !

&

6 0 (1 "5 ! # # RXS# # LGAHAZ##A !j A$*4#0 !j 0$*4#$ F* #9HEG9=97?:#H9E?E<97#C?EH<O#<;<9>M7BH?E<B#E9# >DJKABE#*F#

(8)

HEDH#.?J9H>V<# 2a1# , ,, ,,, 4 3 2 1 0 # /<=DHA#^F#&>9P@HA8AHA7BA#B97E9DH>#89H#<;A?:#@9<7E#C9;A:># ###############################*9DHBAZ#9L7#HA>A?HBGF# # # &>9P@HA8AHA7BA#B97E9DH>#89H#EGHAA#I?H<?7E>#98#<;A?:#@9<7E#C9;A:#@HA>A7E>#/<=F# ^F#&;A?:#@9<7E#&#G?>#B<HBD:?H#B97E9DH>#R><C@:A#D789:;<7=#C9;A:S4#<;A?:#@9<7E#&&#G?># A::<@E<B?:# B97E9DH># LG9>A# ?OA># @?H?::A:# EGA# ;<CA7><97># RLA<=GEA;# D789:;<7=# C9;A:S4#?7;#@9<7E#&&&#G?>#A::<@E<B?:#B97E9DH>#LG9>A#?OA>#G?IA#JAA7#H9E?EA;F#

"GA# ?@@:<B?E<97># 98# EGA# AOEAH7?:# D789:;<7=# C9;A:># 89H# @HA8AHA7BA# HA>A?HBG# @HA>A7E>#?C97=#9EGAH>Z#]9H=#?7;#\H9A7A7##R1553S4##.?J9H>V<#R155eSF#

# #

'"-')1,&"-,*

#

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kF/F4#b?M>#WF+F#R6[X5S4# 7#8"+.+,5-)+(-&8$9-2(8.+-:;$<5"5!,+-+-:$"=5$<+,5-)+(-&8+"0$(2$ >&-*5.$?!525!5-@5$<&"&A$B?)0@=(,5"!+*&C#6[X54#%9#134#1af^2F#

]9H=# &F4# \H9A7A7# QF# R1553S4# 7(.5!-$ ,#8"+.+,5-)+(-&8$ )@&8+-:A$ 4=5(!0$ &-.$ &DD8+@&"+(-)A$ /5@(-.$

E.+"+(-4#*@H<7=AHP'AH:?=4#%AL#l9HVF#

!99CJ># -F'F# R6[35S4# ?)0@=(8(:+@&8$ /@&8+-:$ F+"=(#"$ &$ 9-+"$ (2$ 75&)#!5,5-"4# TQ>MBG9:9=<B?:# )AI<ALU4#%9#3a4#6^3f63eF#

(9)

\A9CAEH<B?:#QHA>A7E?E<97#,8#QHA8AHA7BA>#]M#$><7=#$789:;<7=#09;A:># 2a2# !9O#"F/F4#!9O#0F F F#R1556S4$7#8"+.+,5-)+(-&8$/@&8+-:F$/5@(-.$5.+"+(-A#+97;97Z#!G?@C?7#?7;# b?::F# -?I<>97#0F+FR6[e2S4#7#8"+.+,5-)+(-&8$)@&8+-:4#W<:AM4#%AL#l9HVF# .?J9H>V<# F#R1551S4#9-2(8.+-:$G&*($,(.58$D(,+&!#$D!525!5-@G+$6$)*&8(6&-+#$6+58(60,+&!(60,4# TQH?BA#%?DV9LA# V?;AC<<#(V979C<BY7AK#LA#WH9Bm?L<DU#7H#[^14#61ef62aF#

.?J9H>V<# F# R155eS4# H.5-"02+*&@G&$ D!525!5-@G+$ I$ 60*(!I0)"&-+5,$ ,(.58+$ ?>EJ7 ?4# TQH?BA# %?P DV9LA# V?;AC<<#(V979C<BY7AK#LA#WH9Bm?L<DU#7H#a#R615aS4#1eXf1[^F## # # !"#!$%&'(!)*+$ # !"#!$%0'Q-(*+%!Q!-$('R(*+%!.!%!-'R&* Q*S0:"%Q0,$(-&!#*#"2!)&*1-.")2&- * #

7?:<Y?# D789:;<7=# KA>E# >YBYA=n:7MC# @HYM@?;V<AC# >V?:9L?7<?# L<A:9LMC<?H9LA=9F# .?Vm?;?# 97?4#oA#HA>@97;A7B<#@9>EHYA=?Kp#LMJH?7A#9J<AVEM#L#EAK#>?CAK#@HYA>EHYA7<4#?:A#Hno7<p#><q#L#9BA7<A# L?o79rB<#<BG#@9>YBYA=n:7MBG#?EHMJDEnLF#W#?7?:<Y<A#D789:;<7=#;?7MC<#>p#Y?YLMBY?K#9BA7M#@HA8AP HA7BK<# R7@F# H?7=9LA# D@9HYp;V9L?7<A# @HA8AHA7BK<S# HA>@97;A7EnL# LY=:q;AC# J?;?7MBG# 9J<AVEnLF# -?7A#EA#C9o7?#EH?VE9L?s#K?V9#@9;9J<At>EL?#C<q;YM#;L9C?#YJ<9H?C<Z#HA>@97;A7EnL#<#9J<AVEnLF# W#LM7<VD#?7?:<YM#D789:;<7=#9EHYMCDKA#><q#L#EAK#>?CAK#@HYA>EHYA7<#V978<=DH?BKA#@D7VEnL#HA@HAYA7P EDKpBMBG#9BA7<?KpBMBG#9H?Y#J?;?7A#9J<AVEMF#QD7VEM#HA@HAYA7EDKpBA#HA>@97;A7EnL#E9#@D7VEM#T<;A?:P 7AU4# ?# 9;:A=m9rB<# @D7VEnL# HA@HAYA7EDKpBMBG# 9J<AVEM# 9;# @D7VEnL# <;A?:7MBG# 9;@9L<?;?Kp# H?7=9P LACD#D@9HYp;V9L?7<D#@HA8AHA7BK<F#

W#?HEMVD:A#Y?@HAYA7E9L?79#LMJH?7A#C9;A:A#?7?:<YM#D789:;<7=F#W>V?Y?79#7?#Hno7<Bq#C<q;YM# LAL7qEHY7p#<#YAL7qEHY7p#?7?:<Yp#D789:;<7=F#,CnL<979#HnL7<Ao#C9;A:#LAVE9H9LM#Jq;pBM#>YBYAP =n:7MC#@HYM@?;V<AC#C9;A:D#@D7VED#<;A?:7A=9#9H?Y#L?o97A#C9;A:A#D789:;<7=F#

Cytaty

Powiązane dokumenty

pressure due to the incident and diffracted waves and that due to the ship motions, is measured by running the model in waves, free to heave..

Upon presenting the theory formed in line with the understanding developed in antiquity, I accept as a functional divi- sion for the purpose of the discussion the

[r]

Jako najistotniejsze wymienił zaangażowanie się młodych w życie Kościoła, świadectwo życia kapłańskiego, konieczność spotkań z rodzicami i wypracowanie wspólnego

We wstępie Linde zapow iadał kon­ tynuow anie przekładów , w ykorzystując dorobek pisarski Józefa M aksym i­ lia n a O ssolińskiego, aby niem ieccy uczeni nie mogli

Adam, stworzo­ ny na Boże podobieństwo, zrodził swego syna Seta, który choć jest podobny do Adama i jest na obraz Adama, to przede wszystkim jest też podobny do Boga (na

In terms of computational efficiency, the modified Kirchhoff migration is preferred for microwave imaging with ultrasparse UWB MIMO arrays while the NUFFT-based MIMO-RMA is best

The second irony here is that while wicked problems have come to form a key notion in fields such as public administration theory and policy studies, the planning doctrines