AHP jako metoda ekonomii eksperymentalnej

AHP JAKO METODA EKONOMII EKSPERYMENTALNEJ

Maria Parlińsk a1_{, Łuk asz Pietrych}2 6]NRáD*áyZQD*RVSRGDUVWZD:LHMVNLHJRZ:DUV]DZLH

:\G]LDá1DXN(NRQRPLF]Q\FK

_{HPDLOPDULDBSDUOLQVND#VJJZSO} _{HPDLOOXNDV]BSLHWU\FK#VJJZSO}

Słowa kluczowe_{ $QDOLW\F]Q\3URFHV+LHUDUFKLF]Q\HNRQRPLDHNVSHU\PHQWDOQD}

Streszczenie W SUDF\GRNRQDQRFKDUDNWHU\VW\NLPHWRG\$+3MDNRQDU]ĊG]LDZVSLHUDMąFHJRSR GHMPRZDQLH GHF\]ML ZLHORNU\WHULDOQ\FK : GDOV]HM F]ĊĞFL SU]\EOLĪRQR ]DJDGQLHQLD PHWRG\F]QHZDUXQNXMąFHSU]HSURZDG]HQLHSRSUDZQHJRHNVSHU\PHQWXHNRQRPLF]QH JR:\ND]DQRĪHPHWRGD$+3]QDMGXMH]DVWRVRZDQLHZHNRQRPLLHNVSHU\PHQWDOQHM 3URZDG]RQHEDGDQLDHPSLU\F]QHPRJąE\üUyZQLHĪRSDUWHQDUyĪQHJRURG]DMXV\PX ODFMDFKNRPSXWHURZ\FK

Wprowadzenie

:REHFQ\FKF]DVDFKSUREOHPDW\ND]ZLą]DQD]SURFHVHPSRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]MLMHVWRE V]DUHPDQDOL]ZWDNLFKG\VF\SOLQDFKMDNPHG\F\QDQHXURORJLDLSV\FKRORJLDDOHWDNĪHHNRQR PLDLPDWHPDW\ND2DNWXDOQRĞFLWHJR]DJDGQLHQLDĞZLDGF]ąUyZQLHĪ1DJURG\1REODSU]\]QD QHZG]LHG]LQLHHNRQRPLLZRVWDWQLFKODWDFK0RĪQDZ\PLHQLüWXWDMQDJURGĊ]URNXGOD 'DQLHOD.DKQHPDQD]D]DVWRVRZDQLHHNVSHU\PHQWyZODERUDWRU\MQ\FKZDQDOL]LHHNRQRPLF]QHM

]XZ]JOĊGQLHQLHPSURFHVyZGHF\]\MQ\FKZZDUXQNDFKQLHSHZQRĞFL±ZVSyOQLH]9HUQRQHP 6PLWKHP ,QQ\P SU]\NáDGHP MHVWQDJURGD ]  URNX GOD 'DQLHOD 0F)DGGHQD NWyU\ EDGDá GHF\]MHSRGHMPRZDQHSU]H]MHGQRVWNLSU]\XĪ\FLXPHWRGVWDW\VW\F]Q\FKĝFLVá\]ZLą]HN]SR GHMPRZDQLHPGHF\]MLPDUyZQLHĪWHRULDJLHURUD]HNRQRPLDHNVSHU\PHQWDOQD -DNVWZLHUG]D.UDZF]\NHNVSHU\PHQWQDMRJyOQLHMXMPXMąFMHVWMHGQą]SRGVWDZRZ\FKPH WRG]GRE\ZDQLDZLHG]\QDXNRZHM.UDZF]\NV3ROHJDQDV]WXF]Q\PZ\ZRá\ZDQLX MDNLHJRĞ]MDZLVNDHNRQRPLF]QHJR]D]Z\F]DMVSURZDG]DQHJRGRSHZQHJRSUREOHPXGHF\]\MQH JRDQDVWĊSQLHMHJRREVHUZDFMLFRSR]ZDODQDIRUPXáRZDQLHZQLRVNyZFRGRMHJRSU]HELHJX LZáDĞFLZRĞFL3RVNURENRV =NROHL$QDOLW\F]Q\3URFHV+LHUDUFKLF]Q\$+3MHVWZLHORNU\WHULDOQąPHWRGąZVSRPDJD QLDSURFHVXGHF\]\MQHJR:SU]\SDGNXWHJRURG]DMXPHWRGQDOHĪ\XZ]JOĊGQLüV]HUHJUyĪQ\FK NU\WHULyZPDMąF\FKZSá\ZQDSRGHMPRZDQHGHF\]MH8PRĪOLZLDRQDGHNRPSR]\FMĊ]áRĪRQHJR SUREOHPXGHF\]\MQHJRRUD]XWZRU]HQLHUDQNLQJXILQDOQHJRGODUR]SDWU\ZDQ\FKZDULDQWyZGH F\]\MQ\FK2PNDUSUDVDG6XVKLOV± &HOHPSUDF\MHVWZ\ND]DQLHĪHPHWRGD$+3PRĪHE\üQDU]ĊG]LHPHNRQRPLLHNVSHU\PHQ WDOQHM6]HURNLH]DVWRVRZDQLHWHMPHWRG\ZHZVSRPDJDQLXGHF\]MLHNRQRPLF]Q\FKWHFKQLF]Q\FK F]\VSRáHF]Q\FKSRWZLHUG]DMHMFHORZRĞü:QLQLHMV]\PDUW\NXOHSU]HGVWDZLRQD]RVWDáDPHWRGD $+3RUD]SUDNW\F]Q\SU]\NáDGZ\NRU]\VWDQLDWHJRQDU]ĊG]LDZUR]ZLą]DQLXZLHORNU\WHULDOQHJR SUREOHPXGHF\]\MQHJR$XWRU]\VNXSLOLV]F]HJyOQąXZDJĊQDSRZLą]DQLDFKWHMPHWRG\]HNRQR PLąHNVSHU\PHQWDOQą

1. Analityczny Proces Hierarchiczny

:OLWHUDWXU]HSU]HGPLRWXRSLVDQRMDNGRWHMSRU\ZLHOHPHWRGUR]ZLą]\ZDQLDSUREOHPyZ ZLHORNU\WHULDOQ\FKDQJ multicriterion decision aid – MCDA'RQDMF]ĊĞFLHMZ\NRU]\VW\ZD

Q\FKPHWRGWHJRW\SXPRĪQD]DOLF]\üSURJUDPRZDQLHZLHORNU\WHULDOQH(/(&75(DQJElimi-nation and Choice Translating Reality,,,,,,,93520(7+((,,,0$3$&&35$*0$

V]WXF]QHVLHFLQHXURQRZH'($DQJMulti Criteria Decision Analysis9'$DQJVerbal

De-cision Analysis $+3 DQJ Analytic Hierarchy Process $13 DQJ $nalytic Network Pro-cess$GDPXVàDVDNV.DĪGD]QLFKPD]DOHW\MDNUyZQLHĪSHZQHRJUDQLF]HQLD .OXF]RZąNZHVWLąMHVWUyZQLHĪGREyURGSRZLHGQLHMPHWRG\Z]DOHĪQRĞFLRGVSHF\ILNLGDQHJR SUREOHPXGHF\]\MQHJR*XLWRXQLRUD]0DUWHOVWZLHUG]DMąĪHSRPLPRRSUDFRZDQLDZLHOXPHWRG ]DOLF]DQ\FKGRJUXS\0&'$QLHMHVWPRĪOLZHZ\UyĪQLHQLHWHMMHGQHMXQLZHUVDOQHMNWyUDPRJáD E\E\üVWRVRZDQDGRNDĪGHJRSUREOHPXGHF\]\MQHJR&HOHPLFKEDGDĔE\áRRNUHĞOHQLHSHZQ\FK Z\W\F]Q\FKGODZ\ERUXRGSRZLHGQLHMPHWRG\0&'$*XLWRXQL0DUWHOV 0HWRGD$+3ED]XMHQDZáDVQRĞFLDFKPDFLHU]\RUD]ZHNWRUyZNWyUHMHWZRU]ą%XGRZD QHVąRQHQDSRGVWDZLHRFHQHNVSHUWyZ]GDQHMG]LHG]LQ\NWyU]\GRNRQXMąSRUyZQDĔSDUDPL ZV]\VWNLFKHOHPHQWyZVWUXNWXU\0HWRGDWD]RVWDáDRSUDFRZDQDSU]H]7KRPDVD6DDW\¶HJRZOD WDFK

 :$QDOLW\F]Q\P3URFHVLH+LHUDUFKLF]Q\PSRGVWDZąMHVW]EXGRZDQLHGODNRQNUHWQHJR SUREOHPX GHF\]\MQHJR VWUXNWXU\ KLHUDUFKLF]QHM -HVW RQD SRG]LHORQD QD NLOND SR]LRPyZ 1D V]F]\FLH]QDMGXMHVLĊFHOJáyZQ\QLĪHMXPLHV]F]DQHVąNU\WHULDZLFKUDPDFKPRĪQDZ\UyĪQLü VXENU\WHULD QDWRPLDVW QDMQLĪV]\ SR]LRP WZRU]ą ZDULDQW\ GHF\]\MQH F]\OL PRĪOLZH UR]ZLą ]DQLD :DĪQH MHVW DE\ WD VWUXNWXUD RSLV\ZDáD SUREOHP GHF\]\MQ\ Z VSRVyE FDáRĞFLRZ\ EH] SRPLQLĊFLDZDĪQ\FKDVSHNWyZNWyUHPRJąZ\ZLHUDüVLOQ\ZSá\ZQDVNXWNLHZHQWXDOQHMGHF\]ML àXF]DN:\VRFNLV±

Rysunek 1. Struktura hierarchiczna

ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQHQDSRGVWDZLHàXF]DN:\VRFNLV :QDVWĊSQ\PHWDSLHLVWRWQąUROĊRGJU\ZDMąHNVSHUFLRUD]LFKLQG\ZLGXDOQHSUHIHUHQFMH :PHWRG]LH$+3SUHIHUHQFMHGHF\GHQWDRNUHĞODQHVąSU]\SRPRF\Z]JOĊGQ\FKRFHQZDĪQRĞFL NU\WHULyZLZDULDQWyZ2GE\ZDVLĊWRQD]DVDG]LHSRUyZQDQLDSDUDPLF]\QQLNyZ]WHJRVDPHJR SR]LRPXZ]JOĊGHPNU\WHULXPNWyUH]QDMGXMHVLĊEH]SRĞUHGQLRZ\ĪHM2WU]\PDQHZWHQVSRVyE Z\QLNLSRUyZQDĔSDUDPLPRĪQD]DSLVDüZPDFLHU]\SUHIHUHQFML7ZyUFDPHWRG\]DSURSRQRZDá ZFHOXZ\UDĪHQLDRFHQG]LHZLĊFLRVWRSQLRZąVNDOĊ%RGLQ*DVVV-HVWWRNOXF]RZ\ PRPHQWNWyU\SR]ZDODZVSRVyELORĞFLRZ\GRNRQDüW\FKSRUyZQDĔ.DĪGHPXVWRSQLRZLZVND OL]RVWDáRSU]\SLVDQH]QDF]HQLHVáRZQHFREDUG]RXáDWZLDSRVWĊSRZDQLHSRGF]DVGRNRQ\ZDQLD RFHQHNVSHUWPRĪHQDMSLHUZGRNRQDüSRUyZQDQLDZHUEDOQLHSyĨQLHMGRSLHURSU]\SLVDüRGSR ZLHGQLąZDUWRĞüOLF]ERZą

Tabela 1. 6NDOD6DDW\CHJR Skala _2EMDĞQLHQLH  EUDNPRĪOLZRĞFLZ\UyĪQLHQLDHOHPHQWXGRPLQXMąFHJR  MHGHQ]HOHPHQWyZPDQLH]QDF]QLHZLĊNV]H]QDF]HQLH  Z\UDĨQDSU]HZDJDMHGQHJR]HOHPHQWyZQDGGUXJLP  EDUG]R]QDF]ąFDSU]HZDJDMHGQHJR]HOHPHQWyZQDGGUXJLP  DEVROXWQDSU]HZDJDMHGQHJR]HOHPHQWyZQDGGUXJLP  ZDUWRĞFLSRĞUHGQLHVWRVXMHVLĊJG\Z\VWĊSXMHSUREOHP]MHGQR]QDF]Q\PXĪ\FLHPNWyUHJRĞ ]HOHPHQWyZVNDOLSRZ\ĪHM 2GZURWQRĞFL GODSRUyZQDĔZSU]HFLZQąVWURQĊ ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQHQDSRGVWDZLH6DDW\V .ROHMQ\PNURNLHPZSURFHGXU]HMHVWZ\]QDF]HQLHSULRU\WHWyZJOREDOQ\FKLORNDOQ\FKGOD SRV]F]HJyOQ\FKHOHPHQWyZVWUXNWXU\-HGQDNDE\MHREOLF]\üQDOHĪ\QDMSLHUZ]QDOHĨüZHNWRU\ ZáDVQHRUD]ZDUWRĞFLZáDVQHPDFLHU]\SRUyZQDĔZ\NRU]\VWXMąF]DJDGQLHQLD]DOJHEU\OLQLRZHM 6DDW\]DSURSRQRZDáNLONDLQQ\FKPHWRGNWyUHZVSRVyEPQLHMVNRPSOLNRZDQ\GDMąSU]\EOLĪRQH Z\QLNL-HGQD]QLFKSROHJDQDSU]HPQRĪHQLXSU]H]VLHELHZV]\VWNLFKHOHPHQWyZ]NDĪGHJR ]ZLHUV]\RGG]LHOQLHRUD]Z\FLąJQLĊFLHGODNDĪGHJRLORF]\QXSLHUZLDVWNDNWyUHJRVWRSLHĔMHVW UyZQ\OLF]ELHW\FKHOHPHQWyZDFR]DW\PLG]LH±WDNĪHVWRSQLRZLPDFLHU]\]HZ]JOĊGXQDWR ĪHZV]\VWNLHDQDOL]RZDQHPDFLHU]HPXV]ąE\üV\PHWU\F]QH:NROHMQ\PNURNXX]\VNDQHZ\ QLNLQRUPDOL]XMHVLĊGRMHGQRĞFLSRSU]H]SRG]LHOHQLHLFKSU]H]VXPĊZV]\VWNLFKSLHUZLDVWNyZ RWU]\PDQ\FKZF]HĞQLHM7DNRWU]\PDQH]QRUPDOL]RZDQHZ\QLNLVąSU]\EOLĪRQ\PLZHNWRUDPL ZáDVQ\PLPDFLHU]\6DDW\.HDUQVV±:OLWHUDWXU]HPHWRGDWDQD]\ZDQDMHVWPH WRGąORJDU\WPLF]Q\FKQDMPQLHMV]\FKNZDGUDWyZOXEĞUHGQLHMJHRPHWU\F]QHM=QDQHVąMHGQDN UyZQLHĪLQQHSRGHMĞFLDPLQPHWRGDQDMPQLHMV]\FKNZDGUDWyZVXPNROXPQRZ\FKPHWRG\ ZDĪRQHXNáDG\UyZQDĔOLQLRZ\FKRSDUWHQDPLQLPDOL]DFMLRGOHJáRĞFL=DNDULD'DKODQ+XVVLQ V 2EOLF]RQHZNWyU\Ğ]Z\ĪHMZ\PLHQLRQ\FKVSRVREyZZHNWRU\ZáDVQHVąW]ZSULRU\WHWDPL ORNDOQ\PL1DQDMZ\ĪV]\PSR]LRPLHVWUXNWXU\F]\OLSR]LRPLHSRUyZQDĔNU\WHULyZZ]JOĊGHP FHOXJáyZQHJRSULRU\WHW\ORNDOQHVąMHGQRF]HĞQLHJOREDOQ\PLLZ\UDĪDMąWRNWyUH]Z\PLHQLR Q\FKNU\WHULyZPDQDMZLĊNV]H]QDF]HQLHZNRQWHNĞFLHVIRUPXáRZDQHJRFHOX1DQDMQLĪV]\P SR]LRPLH JG]LH XPLHMVFRZLRQH Vą ZDULDQW\ GHF\]\MQH SRVWĊSXMH VLĊ SRGREQLH :LHONRĞFL Vą EDUG]RZDĪQHJG\ĪáąF]ąRQH]HVREąHOHPHQW]QDMZ\ĪV]HJRSR]LRPX]HOHPHQWDPLSR]LRPX QDMQLĪV]HJRFRVSUDZLDĪHFDáDVWUXNWXUDMHVWVSyMQąFDáRĞFLą3ULRU\WHW]QDMZ\ĪV]ąZDUWRĞFLą X]QDMHVLĊ]DQDMNRU]\VWQLHMV]\$GDPXVàDVDNV±

.ROHMQ\PLZDUWRĞFLDPLX]\VNLZDQ\PL]G]LDáDĔSU]HSURZDG]DQ\FKQDPDFLHU]DFKSRUyZ QDĔVąȜmax , indeks C.I. (Consistency IndexRUD]ZVSyáF]\QQLNC.R. (Consistency Ratio1DM

ZLĊNV]DZDUWRĞüZáDVQDPDFLHU]\F]\OLȜmax = max{Ȝ1, Ȝ2, Ȝ3, ..., Ȝn`JG]LHn – liczba pierwiast

NyZZLHORPLDQXFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHJRRNUHĞODVWRSLHĔ]JRGQRĞFLSRUyZQDĔSDUDPLF]\OLWRF]\ VąRQHNRQVHNZHQWQHLQLHZ\NOXF]DMąVLHELHQDZ]DMHP:OLWHUDWXU]H]DOHFDVLĊDE\Ȝmax = n

ZDUWRĞüZáDVQDPDFLHU]\MHVWUyZQDU]ĊGRZLPDFLHU]\SRQLHZDĪZyZF]DVZ\VWĊSXMHFDáNRZL WD]JRGQRĞüRFHQ6DDW\2]GHPLUV

Na podstawie ȜmaxREOLF]DVLĊLQGHNVQLH]JRGQRĞFLF]\OLSR]LRPRGFK\OHQLDRGSRĪąGDQHM

VSyMQRĞFL:\UDĪDVLĊJRZ]RUHP CI = (Ȝmax – n) n – 1 1DSRGVWDZLHWHJRLQGHNVXEXGXMHVLĊZVSyáF]\QQLNC.R.NWyU\MHVWáDWZLHMV]\ZLQWHUSUHWDFML JG\ĪZSURFHQWDFKZ\UDĪDZMDNLPVWRSQLXSRUyZQDQLDHOHPHQWyZGDQHJRSR]LRPXVWUXNWXU\ VąQLH]JRGQHZ]JOĊGHPVLHELHEUDNNRQVHNZHQFMLZLFKDQDOL]LH2EOLF]DVLĊJR]HZ]RUX C.R. î C.I. R.I. JG]LH]DR.I.DQJRandom IndexSU]\MPXMHVLĊW]ZORVRZ\LQGHNVQLH]JRGQRĞFL-HVWRQRE OLF]DQ\]SUyE\QDNWyUąVNáDGDMąVLĊORVRZRZ\EUDQHPDFLHU]H$GDPXVàDVDNV Tabela 2. :DUWRĞFLZVSyáF]\QQLND5,GODSUyE\ n                5,                ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQHQDSRGVWDZLH6DDW\2]GHPLUV =DOHFDVLĊDE\ZDUWRĞüZVSyáF]\QQLNDQLH]JRGQRĞFLGODPDFLHU]\RZ\PLDUDFKZLĊNV]\FK QLĪîQLHE\áDZLĊNV]DQLĪGODPDFLHU]\î±QDWRPLDVWGODPDFLHU]\î± 3U]HNURF]HQLHW\FKSURJyZZVND]XMHQDWRĪHRFHQ\QLHVąNRQVHNZHQWQHLSRZLQQ\E\üSRZWy U]RQH3DUOLĔVNDV=GUXJLHMVWURQ\MHGQDNQDOHĪ\]DXZDĪ\üĪHZSUDNW\FHV\WXDFMD JG\C.R. F]\OLV\WXDFMDEUDNXMDNLHMNROZLHNQLH]JRGQRĞFLUyZQLHĪMHVWQLHNRU]\VWQDJG\Ī ZUHDOQ\PSUREOHPLHGHF\]\MQ\PGHF\GHQFLFLąJOH]GRE\ZDMąQRZąZLHG]ĊLQDE\ZDMąQRZH XPLHMĊWQRĞFLFRPRĪHVNXWNRZDü]PLDQąRSLQLLQDGDQ\WHPDW$GDPXVàDVDNV

2. Przykład symulacji

:OLWHUDWXU]H]RVWDáMXĪXNV]WDáWRZDQ\SHZLHQVWDQEDGDĔZ]DNUHVLHVWRVRZDQLD0&'$ ZHNRQRPLLHNVSHU\PHQWDOQHM3U]\NáDGRZR/¡NHQ]DSRPRFąHNVSHU\PHQWXSRUyZQ\ZDá]D VWRVRZDQLHGZyFKPHWRG0&'$GRSURMHNWRZDQLDV\VWHPXHQHUJHW\F]QHJRXZ]JOĊGQLDMąFHJR SUHIHUHQFMHNRQVXPHQWyZ8PRĪOLZLáRWRZ\V]F]HJyOQLHQLHLFK]DOHW3U]HSURZDG]RQHHNVSHU\ PHQW\Z\ND]Dá\ĪHUyĪQHPHWRG\Z\V]F]HJyOQLRQHZUDPDFKJUXS\0&'$QLHPXV]ąSURZD G]LüGRWDNLFKVDP\FKZ\QLNyZ5yĪQLFHWHPRJąE\üVSRZRGRZDQHPLQUyĪQ\PVSRVREHP ]DGDZDQLD S\WDĔ VWRSQLHP WUXGQRĞFL GDQHM SURFHGXU\ F]\ WHĪ UyĪQ\P VSRVREHP Z\UDĪDQLD SUHIHUHQFML-HGQDNĪHPHWRGD$+3RND]DáDVLĊQDMHIHNW\ZQLHMV]DJáyZQLH]HZ]JOĊGXQDPDáR VNRPSOLNRZDQąSURFHGXUĊ/¡NHQV±3RQLĪHM]DSUH]HQWRZDQRLQQ\SURVW\SU]\NáDG ]DVWRVRZDQLDWHMPHWRG\

1DU\VXQNXSU]HGVWDZLRQRVWUXNWXUĊGODSUREOHPXZ\ERUXVDPRFKRGXSU]\MPXMąFF]WHU\ NU\WHULD5R]SRF]\QDMąFSU]HGPLRWRZąDQDOL]ĊRNUHĞORQRQDVWĊSXMąFHNU\WHULDZ\ERUX &HQDĺ 6SDODQLHĺ .RPIRUWĺ 'HVLJQĺ Rysunek 2. 6WUXNWXUDKLHUDUFKLF]QDGODSU]\NáDGRZHJRSUREOHPXGHF\]\MQHJR ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQH 7\PVDP\PQDGDMHVLĊLPZDJĊZDUWRĞüZQDZLDVDFKNWyUDE\áDJáyZQąGHWHUPLQDQWą : W\P SU]\NáDG]LH ]DáRĪRQR ĪH E\áD WR FHQD VDPRFKRGX ZDUWRĞü SRF]ąWNRZD NXSRZDQHJR VDPRFKRGX]JRGQLH]XVWDZąRUDFKXQNRZRĞFL:DUWRĞüWHJRNU\WHULXPZ\QLRVáD1DWR PLDVWQDMPQLHMLVWRWQ\PF]\QQLNLHPLMHGQRF]HĞQLHQDMEDUG]LHMVXELHNW\ZQ\PE\áGHVLJQ %LRUąFSRGXZDJĊIDNWĪHNU\WHULXPFHQ\LVSDODQLDVWDQRZLá\ZDJLSXQNWRZHMPRGHOHP VDPRFKRGXNWyU\ZW\FKNDWHJRULDFKRND]DáVLĊQDMEDUG]LHMHNRQRPLF]Q\E\áUHQDXOWFOLR7RWH GZDF]\QQLNLZ]GHF\GRZDQHMPLHU]HZSá\QĊá\QDUDQNLQJ .ROHMQ\PDVSHNWHPREOLF]HĔSU]\]DVWRVRZDQLXPHWRG\$+3MHVWIDNWĪHVDPRFKRG\VNR GDIDELDLYRONVZDJHQJROIEĊGąFHW\PLVDP\PLVDPRFKRGDPLZVZRMHMNODVLHG]LDáDMąFHZUD PDFKMHGQHMJUXS\SURGXFHQFNLHMX]\VNDá\QLHPDOĪHWDNLHVDPHZ\QLNL'RSLHURF]ZDUWHPLHM VFHSRSU]HFLQNXZ\ND]DáRUyĪQLFHSXQNWRZHVNRGDIDELD±LYRONVZDJHQJROI± 2VWDWQLPDQDOL]RZDQ\PVDPRFKRGHPE\áPHUFHGHVVFODVV0HUFHGHVX]\VNDáQDMZ\ĪV]H ZVSyáF]\QQLNLNRPIRUWXLGHVLJQXDOHLFKZDJLSU]\Z\ERU]HQDMOHSV]HJRVDPRFKR GXZRVWDWHF]Q\PUDQNLQJXZVWRVXQNXGRGZyFKSR]RVWDá\FKNU\WHULyZE\á\PDáR]QDF]ąFH

7RVSRZRGRZDáRĪH]DMąáRQRVWDWQLHPLHMVFH*G\E\]HVSyáGHF\]\MQ\QDGDáQDMZ\ĪV]HZDJL LQQ\PNDWHJRULRPPHUFHGHVE\áE\QLHNZHVWLRQRZDQ\POLGHUHP :PHWRG]LH$+3XWZRU]RQRUDQNLQJILQDOQ\GODVNRĔF]RQHJR]ELyUZDULDQWyZZZ\QLNX F]HJRGRNRQDQRQDVWĊSXMąFHMNODV\ILNDFMLPRĪOLZ\FKGRZ\ERUXVDPRFKRGyZ Tabela 3. 5DQNLQJZDĪQRĞFLNU\WHULyZ Wariant 3R]\FMD 3ULRU\WHWZDJD renault clio I  skoda fabia II  YRONVZDJHQJROI III  PHUFHGHVVFODVV IV  ħUyGáRRSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQH

Podsumowanie

6PLWKRSUDFRZDáSRGVWDZ\PHWRG\F]QHHNVSHU\PHQWXMDNRQDU]ĊG]LDEDGDZF]HJRZHNR QRPLL:\UyĪQLáRQWU]\F]\QQLNLNWyUHGHILQLXMąHNVSHU\PHQWHNRQRPLF]Q\ĞURGRZLVNRLQ VW\WXFMH RUD] ]DFKRZDQLH XF]HVWQLNyZ HNVSHU\PHQWX 6PLWK  V  7H WU]\ F]\QQLNL VWDQRZLąSRGVWDZRZHVNáDGRZHGODNRQVWUXNFMLSRSUDZQHJRPHWRG\F]QLHHNVSHU\PHQWXHNR QRPLF]QHJR0RĪQDVWZLHUG]LüĪH]DSUH]HQWRZDQ\SU]\NáDGZ\ERUXZDULDQWX]DSRPRFąPH WRG\$+3VSHáQLDWHWU]\SRGVWDZRZHHOHPHQW\HNVSHU\PHQWX1DĞURGRZLVNRVNáDGDMąVLĊW]Z ZDUXQNLSRF]ąWNRZHF]\OLZW\PSU]\SDGNXXNáDGSUHIHUHQFMLRUD]ERGĨFHPRW\ZXMąFHZRG SRZLHGQLVSRVyEGRUDFMRQDOQHJR]DFKRZDQLD,QVW\WXFMH]NROHLUHJXOXMą]DVDG\NRPXQLNDFML SRPLĊG]\XF]HVWQLNDPLHNVSHU\PHQWX2GVWURQ\WHFKQLF]QHMPRĪQDVWZLHUG]LüĪH]DZDUWHVą RQHZSHZQ\FKLQVWUXNFMDFKRUD]SURFHGXUDFKREVáXJLZDQ\FK]DSRPRFąRGSRZLHGQLHJRRSUR JUDPRZDQLD : SU]\SDGNX PHWRG\ $+3 QLH]EĊGQH MHVW WDNĪH DE\ SU]HG SU]\VWąSLHQLHP GR KLHUDUFKL]DFMLNU\WHULyZRUD]ZDULDQWyZSRLQVWUXRZDüZ\EUDQąJUXSĊQDWHPDWSU]HELHJXWHJR etapu badania.

:\FKRG]ąF RG RJyOQHM FKDUDNWHU\VW\NL NODV\F]Q\ HNVSHU\PHQW HNRQRPLF]Q\ VNáDGD VLĊ ]NLONXGRNLONXQDVWXVHVML.DĪGDVHVMD]NROHLSU]HELHJDZHGáXJRNUHĞORQHJRVFKHPDWX]D MĊFLHPLHMVFZVDOLNRPSXWHURZHMSU]H]XF]HVWQLNyZEDGDQLDZUĊF]HQLHSLVHPQ\FKSURFHGXU RSLVXMąF\FKGDQ\SUREOHPGHF\]\MQ\XUXFKRPLHQLHSURJUDPXNRPSXWHURZHJRXPRĪOLZLDMąFH JR SRGHMPRZDQLH GHF\]ML -HĪHOL GDQ\ HNVSHU\PHQW MHVW VNRPSOLNRZDQ\ QLHNLHG\ ]DOHFD VLĊ DE\XF]HVWQLF\SU]HV]OLMHGQąOXENLONDUXQGWHVWRZ\FKZFHOX]D]QDMRPLHQLDVLĊ]LQVWUXNFMDPL .UDZF]\NV:SU]\SDGNXPHWRG\$+3SRGVWDZRZ\PRSURJUDPRZDQLHPVáXĪą F\PGRZ\]QDF]HQLDZDJORNDOQ\FKLJOREDOQ\FKMHVWSURJUDP([SHUW&KRLFH'RNRQ\ZDQLH RFHQPRĪHRGE\ZDüVLĊZRNQLHGLDORJRZ\PZ\JHQHURZDQ\PSU]H]WHQSURJUDPEąGĨWHĪQD SU]\JRWRZDQ\PNZHVWLRQDULXV]X

:DĪQ\P HWDSHP EDGDQLD HNVSHU\PHQWDOQHJR MHVW ]GHILQLRZDQLH ]PLHQQ\FK Z\MDĞQLDMą F\FKGDQH]MDZLVNRHNRQRPLF]QH:OLWHUDWXU]HZ\UyĪQLDVLĊGZDURG]DMH]PLHQQ\FK]PLHQQH

HNVSHU\PHQWDOQHSRGOHJDMąFHPDQLSXODFMLRUD]]PLHQQH]DOHĪQHNWyUHVWDQRZLąRG]ZLHUFLH GOHQLHGDQHJRSUREOHPX=PLHQQHSLHUZV]HJRURG]DMXPRJąSU]\MPRZDüZDUWRĞFLPLHU]RQHQD UyĪQ\FKSR]LRPDFKZ]DOHĪQRĞFLRGSRWU]HEGDQHMUXQG\:WUDNFLHEDGDQLDPRJąE\üUyZQLHĪ ZSURZDG]RQHW]ZNRQWUROQHSR]LRP\]PLHQQHM6WRVXMHVLĊMHZFHOXZHU\ILNDFMLF]\EDGDQL SRGHMPXMąGHF\]MH]JRGQH]WHRULąHNRQRPLF]Qą.UDZF]\NV.DĪG\SUREOHPGH F\]\MQ\DQDOL]RZDQ\]DSRPRFąPHWRG\$+3Z\PDJDSRGHMĞFLDSROHJDMąFHJRQDMHJRGHNRP SR]\FML:\V]F]HJyOQLRQHNU\WHULDVWDQRZLą]DUyZQR]PLHQQHHNVSHU\PHQWDOQHMDNL]DOHĪQH F]\OLWHNWyUHRNUHĞODMąZDUXQNLED]RZHGODGDQHJRSUREOHPXHNRQRPLF]QHJR

1D Z\ĪHM Z\PLHQLRQ\FK HWDSDFK EDGDQLD HNVSHU\PHQWDOQHJR PRĪQD VWRVRZDü UyZQLHĪ PHWRG\V\PXODFMLNRPSXWHURZHMàDWXV]\ĔVNDSRGNUHĞODĪHV\PXODFMDNRPSXWHURZDPRĪHE\ü QLHW\ONRQDU]ĊG]LHPZVSLHUDMąF\PHNVSHU\PHQWODERUDWRU\MQ\DOHZUĊF]PRĪHJR]DVWĊSRZDü àDWXV]\ĔVNDV 3RGVXPRZXMąFPRĪQDVWZLHUG]LüĪH$QDOLW\F]Q\3URFHV+LHUDUFKLF]Q\PRĪHE\üVWRVR ZDQ\ZEDGDQLDFKHNVSHU\PHQWDOQ\FK0HWRGĊWĊPRĪQDVWRVRZDüQLHW\ONRGRZVSRPDJDQLD SRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]MLZU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLJRVSRGDUF]HMDOHUyZQLHĪGRV\PXODFMLLSUH]HQWDFML SHZQ\FKPRĪOLZ\FKUR]ZLą]DĔ0LPRSHZQ\FKRJUDQLF]HĔPDFRUD]WRV]HUV]H]DVWRVRZDQLH RUD]Z\VRNąVNXWHF]QRĞü

Literatura

$GDPXV:àDVDN3=DVWRVRZDQLHPHWRG\$+3GRZ\ERUXXPLHMVFRZLHQLDQDG]RUXQDGU\QNLHPILQDQ sowym. Bank i Kredyt, 41±

%RGLQ/*DVV6,2QWHDFKLQJWKHDQDO\WLFKLHUDUFK\SURFHVV Computers & Operations Research, 30± 

*XLWRXQL$0DUWHO-7HQWDWLYHJXLGHOLQHVWRKHOSFKRRVLQJDQDSSURSULDWH0&'$PHWKRGEuropean Journal

of Operational Research, 109±

.UDZF]\N0UHGEkonomia eksperymentalna.:DUV]DZD2ILF\QDD:ROWHUV.OXZHUEXVLQHVV

/¡NHQ(Multi-Criteria Planning of Local Energy Systems with Multiple Energy Carriers.7KHVLVIRUWKH GHJUHH SKLORVRSKLDH GRFWRU 3REUDQH ] KWWSVZZZVLQWHIQRJOREDODVVHWVSURMHFWVHGVHVSHQORNHQBWKHVLVSGI 

àDWXV]\ĔVND 0  6\PXODFMD NRPSXWHURZD Z HNRQRPLL HNVSHU\PHQWDOQHM Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu

6]F]HFLĔVNLHJR, 36±

àXF]DN$:\VRFNL):\NRU]\VWDQLH$QDOLW\F]QHJR3URFHVX+LHUDUFKLF]QHJRZDQDOL]LHV\VWHPXPRW\ZD F\MQHJRSU]HGVLĊELRUVWZDWUDQVSRUWRZHJRUniwersytet Przyrodniczy w Poznaniu, Journal of Agribusiness and

Rural Development, 4± 2PNDUSUDVDG696XVKLO.$QDO\WLFKLHUDUFK\SURFHVV$QRYHUYLHZRIDSSOLFDWLRQVEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 169± 3DUOLĔVND05RODLQIRUPDFMLZJRVSRGDUFHU\QNRZHMQDSRGVWDZLHZ\EUDQ\FKUROQ\FKU\QNyZKXUWRZ\FK. :DUV]DZD:\GDZQLFWZR6**: 3RVNURENR71RZHNRQFHSFMHLWHRULHUR]ZRMXZHNRQRPLL:6&]DMD$%HFOD73RVNURENR-:áRGDUF]\N :\]ZDQLDZVSyáF]HVQHMHNRQRPLL'LILQ:DUV]DZD

6DDW\7/.HDUQV.3Analytical planning. The Organization of Systems3LWWVERXUJK5:63XEOLFDWLRQV 6DDW\7/'HFLVLRQPDNLQJZLWKWKHDQDO\WLFKLHUDUFK\SURFHVVInternational Journal of Services Sciences,

6DDW\7/2]GHPLU0:K\WKHPDJLFQXPEHUVHYHQSOXVRUPLQXVWZRMathematical and Computer

Model-ling, 38±

6PLWK9(FRQRPLFVLQWKHODERUDWRU\Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8±

=DNDULD1)'DKODQ+0+XVVLQ$5&3ULRULWL]DWLRQPHWKRGLQWKHDQDO\WLFKLHUDUFK\SURFHVVXVLQJHYR OXWLRQDU\FRPSXWLQJInternational Journal of Innovative Computing, 1±

AHP AS A METHOD OF EXPERIMENT ECONOMIC

Key words

_{$QDO\WLF+LHUDUFK\3URFHVVH[SHULPHQWDOHFRQRPLFV}

Abstr act _{7KHVWXG\FKDUDFWHUL]HGWKH$+3PHWKRGDVDWRROWRVXSSRUWGHFLVLRQPDNLQJ7KHQH[WVHFWLRQ} GLVFXVVHVWKHPHWKRGRORJLFDOLVVXHVFRQGLWLRQLQJWRFDUU\RXWSURSHUHFRQRPLFH[SHULPHQW,WKDV EHHQVKRZQWKDWWKHPHWKRGRI$+3LVXVHGLQH[SHULPHQWDOHFRQRPLFV(PSLULFDOVWXGLHVFDQ DOVREHFRQGXFWHGRQWKHEDVLVRIYDULRXVW\SHVRIFRPSXWHUVLPXODWLRQV