Coherent risk measures in multiperiod models

(1)

/,+&! ,(",%,0&"! 1234 1565

!"#$%"&'!()*+,7

**!"#$#%&'$()*'+#,)-$#)'(%'+-.&(/#$(!0'**

+!0#.)'

,12345637 #89 :;<=9>?;@ ?: A?89;9BC ;DE@ =9<EF;9E 8<E G99B DBC;?HFA9H GI !;CJB9; 9CK <LK

M6NNNO DB < EDBPL9QR9;D?H E9CCDBPK S9;9 >9 R;9E9BC < ED=DL<; =?H9L DB < =FLCDR9;D?H A?BC9TCK U9 <HH DB <TD?= ?: HIB<=DA A?BEDEC9BAI C? C89 EC<BH<;H A?89;9BA9 <TD?=EK U9 H9EA;DG9 < E9C ?: R;?R9;CI ?: =FLCDR9;D?H =?H9LK U9 R;9E9BC ;9AF;EDV9 :?;=FL<E :?; C89 A?=RFC<CD?B ?: R;DA9 G?FBHE <BH A?;;9ER?BHDBP ?RCD=<L 89HP9EK U9 R;9E9BC < ;9AF;EDV9 :?;=FL< :?; R;DA9 G?FBHE DB C9;=E ?: A8??EDBP ;DE@ =9<EF;9EK

*89':;4<2= A?89;9BC ;DE@ =9<EF;9E4 =FLCDR9;D?H =?H9LK

(7''(%&$!0- &(!%'

#89 E9=DB<L >?;@ ?: !;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNO ?B A?89;9BC ;DE@ =9<EF;9E DE :?AFE9H R;D=<;DLI ?B EFR9;VDE?;I <RRLDA<CD?BEK #89 <TD?=E :?; <AA9RC<GDLDCI C8<C >9;9 RFC :?;><;H GI !;CJB9; 9C <LK HD::9; :;?= C89 ?B9E C8<C 8<V9 G99B FE9H C;<HDCD?B<LLI DB EC<CDECDA<L H9ADED?B C89?;IK W9C DC DE AL9<; C8<C C89 ;9PFL<C?;I DEEF9E A89;9 G?C8 C89 AL<EEDA<L <TD?=E ?: H9ADED?B C89?;I <BH C89 A?89;9BA9 <TD?=E <H?RC9H GI !;CJB9; 9C <LK A<B G9 C<@9B DBC? A?BEDH9;<CD?BK ,B9 =<I :?; DBEC<BA9 C8DB@ ?: A<RDC<L GFHP9CDBP H9ADED?BE4 C89 H9C9;=DB<CD?B ?: R;9=DF= :?; DBEF;<BA9 A?BC;<ACE4 <BH C89 R;DADBP ?: H9;DV<CDV9E DB DBA?=RL9C9 =<;@9CEK

#89 A?89;9BA9 <TD?=E DB !;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNO L9<H C? ;DE@ =9<EF;9E ?: C89 :?;=

& & M-O X EFR.M-O /

!

/

M6K6O

>89;9 Y DE < :FBACD?B :;?= < M:DBDC9O E9C C? )4 <BH / DE < AL<EE ?: R;?G<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E ?B ZK !ACF<LLI4 C89 R<R9; !;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNO FE9E !*01& 23"04!30 ;<C89; C8DC8 A?==?B :?;=FL<CD?BE DB H9ADED?B C89?;I4 <BH <LE? C? EC;9EE C89 <RRLDA<GDLDCI ?: C89 E<=9 B?CD?B DB HD::9;9BC A?BC9TCEK #89 HD::9;9BA9

7

(2)

G9C>99B C89 ;DE@ =9<EF;9E MYO ?: !;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNO <BH C89 <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E "MYO FE9H 89;9 DE `FEC < A8<BP9 ?: EDPB M"MYO X a MYOOK /?; ED=RLDADCI ;9<E?BE >9 A8<BP9 HDEA?FBCDBPK !;CJB9; 9C <LK M1552O FE9 C89 C9;= b;DE@ <H`FEC9H V<LF9Ec :?; >8<C >9 A<LL <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9EK U9 =<I A?=R<;9 C8DE B?C<CD?B C? C89 A;DC9;D?B ?GC<DB9H :;?= < E9C ?: H9ADED?BQC89?;9CDA <TD?=EK #8DE A;DC9;D?B A?;;9ER?BHE C? < FCDLDCI ER9AD:DA<CD?B ?: C89 :?;=

& & 9M-O X EFR.M4M-OO /

!

/

M6K1O

>89;9 - <BH / <;9 H9:DB9H <E <G?V94 <BH >89;9 FMdO DE < FCDLDCI :FBACD?BK #89 DBC9;R;9C<CD?B PDV9B GI ]DLG?< <BH *A8=9DHL9; C? C89 AL<EE ?: R;?G<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E /4 <BH >8DA8 C89D; <TD?= EIEC9= DE H9EDPB9H C? ;9:L9AC4 DE C8<C C8DE AL<EE ;9R;9E9BCE <=GDPFDCI DB C89 E9BE9 ?: (LLEG9;P M6Ne6OK #89;9 DE B? 9TRLDADC <RR9<L C? <=GDPFDCI DB !;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNOK

' '

((7'')(%>.#?/#$(!0')#&&(%>'

S9;9 >9 G;D9:LI ;9VD9> C89 <TD?=<CDA E9CCDBP :?; ;DE@ =9<EF;9E C8<C ><E R;?R?E9H GI !;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNO4 >DC8 E?=9 MED=RL9O =?HD:DA<CD?BEf <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E A9 H? B?C A?BEDH9; HDEA?FBCDBPK +9C Z G9 < :DBDC9 E9C4 EDC8 % 9L9=9BCEK #89 E9C ?: <LL :FBACD?BE :;?= Z C? $ >DLL G9 H9B?C9H GI @MZOK !B 9L9=9BC - ?: @MZO DE C8?FP8C ?: <E < ;9R;9E9BC<CD?B ?: C89 R?EDCD?B C8<C P9B9;<C9E ?FCA?=9 -MgO >89B C89 EC<C9 g ! Z <;DE9EK !B "553),"6*7*,$&23"04!3&H9:DB9H ?B DE < =<RRDBP :;?= @MZO C? $K

#89 BF=G9; M O C8<C DE <EE?AD<C9H C? C89 R?EDCD?B - ! @MZO GI <B <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 " DE DBC9;R;9C9H <E C89 bH9P;99 ?: <AA9RC<GDLDCIc ?: C89 R?EDCD?B -K !B <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 "& DE E<DH C? G9 A?89;9BC D: DC E<CDE:D9E C89

:?F; <TD?=E4 ED=DL<; C? A?89;9BC ;DE@ =9<EF;9EK 08ABCB3B;C'D7E7''

!B !*01& 23"04!3 f +1 # MQ$4$O DE E<DH C? G9 A?89;9BC D: DC E<CDE:D9E C89 :?LL?>DBP :?F; <TD?=E 6

<O C;<BEL<CD?B R;?R9;CIf:?; <LL A ! ) 4 MY h A%!O X MYO i A GO EFR9;<HHDCDVDCIf MY h WO & MYO h MWO4 :?; <LL Y4 W ! +1 AO =?B?C?BDADCIf Y4 W ! +14 D: Y & W4 C89B MWO & MYO HO R?EDCDV9 8?=?P9B9DCIfY ! +1 <BH ' ( 54 M'YO X ' MYO

6

(3)

&F8;48G'D7E M!;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNO

!B ;DE@ =9<EF;9 & H9:DB9H ?B < :DBDC9 E9C DE A?89;9BC D: <BH ?BLI D: C89;9

9TDECE < :<=DLI / ?: R;?G<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E ?B EFA8 C8<C4 :?; <LL ! @MZO

& & M O X EFR.M-O /

!

/

M1K6O

&: <B <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 " E<CDE:D9E M1K6O4 DC DE E<DH C? G9 ;9R;9E9BC9H GI C89 :<=DLI / ?: R;?G<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E4 <BH C89 R;?G<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E DB C89 A?LL9ACD?B

/ <;9 E?=9CD=9E ;9:9;;9H C? <E bC9EC =9<EF;9Ec :?; "K #89 <G?V9 C89?;9= A<B G9

P9B9;<LDJ9H C? C89 A<E9 ?: DB:DBDC9 E<=RL9 ER<A9E Z D: 9DC89; C89 ;9R;9E9BC<CD?B GI R;?G<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E DE ;9RL<A9H GI < ;9R;9E9BC<CD?B DB C9;=E ?: :DBDC9LI <HHDCDV9 =9<EF;9E4 ?; < A?BCDBFDCI R;?R9;CI DE <HH9H C? C89 A?89;9BA9 <TD?=E ME99 -9LG<9B M1551OK

&: " DE < A?89;9BC <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;94 C89B "MAEO X A :?; <LL A ! )j C8DE :?LL?>E :;?= C89 <TD?= ?: R?EDCDV9 8?=?P9B9DCI M>8DA8 D=RLD9E "M5O X 5O <BH :;?= C89 C;<BEL<CD?B R;?R9;CIK /?; A?BV9BD9BA9 >9 DBC;?HFA9 < E9R<;<C9 C9;= :?; C8DE R;?R9;CIK

08ABCB3B;C'D7D' !B <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 " ?B < E<=RL9 ER<A9 Z DE E<DH C? G9 B?;=<LDJ9H D: " MAEO X A :?; <LL A ! )K

&B R<;CDAFL<;4 D: C89 E9C Z A?BEDECE ?: ?BLI ?B9 9L9=9BC g4 C89B C89 ?BLI B?;=<LDJ9H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 DE "MYO X YMgOK #89 A<E9 DB >8DA8 <LL FBA9;C<DBCI 8<E G99B ;9E?LV9H >DLL G9 FE9H G9L?> DB C89 =FLCDR9;D?H A?BC9TC <E < EC<;CDBP R?DBC :?; G<A@><;H ;9AF;ED?BEK

' '

(((7'+-.&(/#$(!0')#&&(%>'

U9 B?> R<EE C? < =FLCDR9;D?H E9CCDBPK #? @99R C89 A?BC9TC <E ED=RL9 <E R?EEDGL9 >9 ECDLL >?;@ >DC8 < :DBDC9 E<=RL9 ER<A9 M:?LL?>DBP !;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNO <BH "<;; 9C <LK M1556OO4 GFC >9 A?BEDH9; 9<A8 E<=RL9 B?> <E < HDEA;9C9Q CD=9 C;<`9AC?;IK U9 G9PDB >DC8 DBC;?HFADBP E?=9 B?C<CD?B <BH C9;=DB?L?PI C8<C >DLL G9 B99H9H G9L?>K

+9C # G9 < R?EDCDV9 DBC9P9; DBHDA<CDBP C89 BF=G9; ?: CD=9 R9;D?HE ?V9; >8DA8 >9 A?BEDH9; ?F; 9A?B?=IK +9C ! G9 < :DBDC9 E9C >8DA8 >9 E8<LL ;9:9; C? <E C89 b9V9BC E9CKc #8DE C9;=DB?L?PI DE <RR;?R;D<C9 DB R<;CDAFL<; :?; C;99 =?H9LEj :?; DBEC<BA9 DB GDB?=D<L =?H9LE C89 9V9BC E9C A?BEDECE ?: C>? 9L9=9BCE MbFRc <BH bH?>BcOK #89 :;<=9>?;@ C8<C >9 FE9 G9L?> <RRLD9E 9kF<LLI >9LL 8?>9V9; C?

(4)

=?H9LE ?GC<DB9H :;?= HDEA;9CDJ<CD?B ?: < A?BCDBF?FE EC<C9 ER<A94 >89;9 ! >?FLH ;<C89; G9 C8?FP8C ?: <E < ;9R;9E9BC<CD?B ?: < P;DH DB C89 EC<C9 ER<A9K

-9:DB9 Z <E C89 E9C ?: <LL E9kF9BA9E M*64 K K K 4 *#O >DC8 *D ! !j >9 ;9:9; C?

EFA8 E9kF9BA9E <E b:FLL 8DEC?;D9EKc #89 A?LL9ACD?B ?: E9kF9BA9E M*64 K K K 4 *# O ?:

L9BPC8 C M6 & C & #O >DLL G9 H9B?C9H GI ZC K

/?; g X M*64 K K K 4 *#O ! Z <BH 6 & C & #4 H9:DB9 C89 ,&;&!30,!*5,*+%&<+, <E M*64

K K K 4 *COK &: < E9kF9BA9 gl X M*64 K K K 4 *CO DE < )!3=*> ?: g ! Z >9 >;DC9 gl gK

#89 A?LL9ACD?B ?: <LL E9kF9BA9E G9PDBBDBP >DC8 < PDV9B E9kF9BA9 ?MglO DE H9B?C9H GI ?MglO fX m g ! Z n gl g oK U9 H9B?C9 GI C C89 <LP9G;< P9B9;<C9H

GI C89 E9CE ?MglO >DC8 gl DB C89 E9C ZC ?: E9kF9BA9E ?: L9BPC8 9T<ACLI C j DB C89

R;9E9BC E9CCDBP DB >8DA8 >9 8<V9 < :DBDC9 E<=RL9 ER<A94 C8DE DE ?: A?F;E9 C89 E<=9 <E C89 ,Q<LP9G;< P9B9;<C9H GI C89E9 E9CEK U9 >;DC9 Zl C89 EF= ?: C89 E9C ?: <LL E9kF9BA9 ?: L9BPC8 <C =?EC Cf Zl X

!

, * , & & ) 6 <BH >9 >;DC9 ZllfX Zl#Q6K &B C89 A?BC9TC ?: < B?BQ;9A?=GDBDBP C;99 =?H9L4 C89;9 DE < ?B9Q?B9 ;9L<CD?B G9C>99B C89 9L9=9BCE ?: Zl <BH C89 B?H9E ?: C89 C;99K #89 9L9=9BCE ?: Z A?;;9ER?BH C? :DB<L B?H9E4 <BH C8?E9 ?: Zll C? R;9Q:DB<L B?H9EK

''

!"#$%&'()&*+!,--('%,.&$&%/!0(,1#)(1!

'

"?BEDH9; < E9kF9BA9 ER<A9 Z <E H9:DB9H DB C89 R;9VD?FE EFGE9ACD?BK &B C89 =FLCDR9;D?H E9CCDBP4 C89 <AA9RC<GDLDCI ?: < PDV9B R?EDCD?B E8?FLH G9 A?BEDH9;9H B?C ?BLI <E < :FBACD?B ?: C89 R?EDCD?B DCE9L:4 GFC <LE? <E < :FBACD?B ?: <V<DL<GL9 DB:?;=<CD?BK

U9 ECDLL H9:DB9 < bR?EDCD?Bc <E < =<RRDBP Y :;?= Z C? )K *FA8 < =<RRDBP =DC8 glK #89 ;9EC;DAC9H =<RRDBP Yn?MglO H9:DB9E < R?EDCD?B ?B ?MglOK U9 9TC9BH ELDP8CLI C89 H9:DBDCD?B GI <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E C8<C ><E PDV9B G9:?;9 GI <LL?>DBP C8<C C89 H9P;99 ?: <AA9RC<GDLDCI ?: < PDV9B R?EDCD?B A<B G9 6K *?4 <B <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 ?B ?MglO DE < =<RRDBP :;?= ?MglO C? C89 9TC9BH9H ;9<L LDB9 $ - m.oK

'

08ABCB3B;C'H7E''

! =FLCDR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 ?B C89 E9kF9BA9 ER<A9 Z DE < =<RRDBP C8<C <EEDPBE C? 9<A8 R<;CD<L 8DEC?;I gl ! Zl <B <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 ?B ?MglOK

#89 <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 ?B ?MglO C8<C DE R;?VDH9H GI < =FLCDR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 >DLL G9 H9B?C9H GI "M% n glOj C89 9L9=9BC ?: C89 9TC9BH9H ;9<L LDB9 <EE?AD<C9H GI C8DE =<RRDBP C? < R?EDCD?B Y ?B ?MglO DE H9B?C9H GI "MY n glOK U89B Y DE < R?EDCD?B ?B Z4 >9 <LE? >;DC9 "MY n glO DBEC9<H ?: "MYn!?MglO n glOK #89 EDCF<CD?B <C C89 DBDCD<L CD=9 DE ;9R;9E9BC9H GI C89 E9kF9BA9 ?: J9;? L9BPC8j

(5)

DBEC9<H ?: MY n 5O4 >9 >;DC9 MYOK $BH9; C89 B?;=<LDJ<CD?B A?BHDCD?B M-9:K 1K1O4 >9 8<V9 "MY n gO X YMgO :?; <LL g ! Z K

U9 E<I C8<C < =FLCDR9;D?H ;DE@ =9<EF;9 DE 5+@3!3%, D: <LL R<;CD<LQDB:?;=<CD?B <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E M% n glO <;9 A?89;9BC ?B ?MglOK

#8DE D=RLD9E DB R<;CDAFL<; C8<C4 :?; <LL R?EDCD?BE Y <BH W <BH :?; <LL R<;CD<L 8DEC?;D9E gl4 C89 :?LL?>DBP 8?LHEf

D: MY n glO & MW n glO :?; <LL gl g4 C89B MY n gO & MW n gOK M2K6O

U9 E8<LL E<I C8<C < =FLCDR9;D?H ;DE@ =9<EF;9 E<CDE:D9E C89 0,3)A*03&

2+%+,+%*5*,$ 5+%B*,*+% D: C89 :?LL?>DBP A?BHDCD?B 8?LHE :?; <LL R?EDCD?BE Y <BH W

<BH :?; <LL R<;CD<L 8DEC?;D9E gl ! Zll

D: MY n gl*O & MW n gl*O :?; <LL * ! !4 C89B MY n glO & MW n glO M2K1O

#89 9T<=RL9 G9L?> E8?>E C8<C C89;9 9TDECE EDCF<CD?BE DB >8DA8 C89 =?B?C?BDADCI R;?R9;CI M2K6O DE E<CDE:D9H GFC C89 EC9R>DE9 =?B?C?BDADCI R;?R9;CI M2K1O H?9E B?C 8?LHK

#I5GJK8'H7E'

"?BEDH9; < C>?QR9;D?H GDB?=D<L C;99j C8<C DE4 L9C ! X m4C&Bo <BH Z X m44C&4BC&

B4C&BBoK *R9AD:I <B <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 :?; R;?HFACE ?B GI & & " M Y nglO X DB: M pO

1 4 6

/

-. * ) * 0

>89;9 [6 DE C89 R;?G<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 C8<C DE ?GC<DB9H GI <EEDPBDBP R;?G<GDLDCI 5Ke

C? < F 9V9BC <BH 5K_ C? < H 9V9BC4 <BH [1 DE ?GC<DB9H GI ;9V9;EDBP C89E9

R;?G<GDLDCD9EK "L9<;LI4 " DE < A?89;9BC =FLCDR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9K "?BEDH9; < R?EDCD?B Y C8<C R<IE 655 D: 4B ?; B4 ?AAF;E4 <BH C8<C R<IE B?C8DBP ?C89;>DE9 M< bGFCC9;:LIcOK !E DE 9<EDLI A?=RFC9H4 >9 8<V9 " MYO X _q >89;9<E " MY n FO X " MY n HO X _5K "?=R<;DBP C89 R?EDCD?B Y C? C89 R?EDCD?B W C8<C R<IE __ DB <LL EC<C9E ?: B<CF;94 >9 E99 C8<C " DE B?C EC9R>DE9 =?B?C?BDAK

*?=9 ?: <FC8?;E ME99 U<BP M1552OO FE9 C89 C9;= bHIB<=DA A?BEDEC9BAIc :?; 9EE9BCD<LLI C89 R;?R9;CI C8<C >9 ;9:9; C? 89;9 <E EC9R>DE9 =?B?C?BDADCIK #? H9:DB9 C89 B?CD?B ?: HIB<=DA A?BEDEC9BAI ?B C89 G<EDE ?: < EC;?BP9; R;9=DE94 >8DA8 =DE9 =?B?C?BDADCI <BH HIB<=DA A?BEDEC9BAI <;9 <ACF<LLI C89 E<=9 FBH9; C89 A?89;9BA9 <EEF=RCD?BK

(6)

08ABCB3B;C'H7D''

! =FLCDR9;D?H ;DE@ =9<EF;9 H9:DB9H ?B < E9kF9BA9 ER<A9 Z DE E<DH C? G9

B$%"2*5"77$&5+%0*0,3%, D: :?; <LL R<;CD<L 8DEC?;D9E gl ! Zll <BH <LL R?EDCD?BE Y <BH

W >9 8<V9

D: MY n gl*O X MW n gl*O :?; <LL * ! !4 C89B MY n glO X MW n glO /4;J;2B3B;C'H7E7'

:& 5+@3!3%,& 247,*)3!*+B& "553),"6*7*,$& 23"04!3& *0& B$%"2*5"77$& 5+%0*0,3%,& *=& "%B&+%7$&*=&*,&*0&0,3)A*03&2+%+,+%*58&

#? 9<A8 gl ! Zll4 ?B9 A8DA8 C89 9V9BCE C8<C =<I ?AAF; M9kFDV<L9BCLI4 C89 EC<C9E ?: B<CF;9 C8<C =<I <;DE9 <:C9; ?B9 CD=9 EC9RO <;9 R<;<=9C;DJ9H GI C89 9V9BC E9C !K ! EDBPL9QR9;D?H R?EDCD?B DE < =<RRDBP :;?= ! C? )K ! EDBPL9QR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 <EEDPBE ;9<L BF=G9;E C? EDBPL9QR9;D?H R?EDCD?BEK

+9C < =FLCDR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 " G9 PDV9BK /?; <BI R<;CD<L 8DEC?;I gl ! Zll4 ?B9 A<B P9B9;<C9 < R?EDCD?B YW ?B ?MglO :;?= < PDV9B EDBPL9QR9;D?H

R?EDCD?B W f ! # ) GI H9:DBDBP

YW MgO X W Mgl*O D: gl* gK M2K2O

&B C8DE >9 A<B DBC;?HFA9 :?; 9<A8 gl ! Zll < EDBPL9QR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 H9B?C9H

GI " glf

"gl f W # "gMYW n glOK M2K_O

#89 :?LL?>DBP L9==< DE 9<EDLI V9;D:D9H HD;9ACLI :;?= C89 A?89;9BA9 <TD?=EK .8GG5'H7E7''

&: " DE < A?89;9BC =FLCDR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;94 C89B <LL EDBPL9QR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E "gl H9;DV9H :;?= " <;9 A?89;9BC <E >9LLK

]DV9B < R;?HFAC Y ?B C89 E9kF9BA9 ER<A9 <BH < =FLCDR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 "4 >9 ADBP

><If

(7)

*DBA9 C8DE DE < EDBPL9QR9;D?H R?EDCD?B4 DCE <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9 8<V9

" MY n glO X "gl M" MY n glOK M2KeO

#8DE D=RLD9E C8<C C89 =FLCDR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 " A<B G9 H9EA;DG9H DB C9;=E ?: C89 A?BHDCD?B<L EDBPL9QR9;D?H <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E "glK

' '

(L7'/$( (%>'(%'(% !+/.#&#'+,$*#&)'

#89 =<DB RF;R?E9 ?: C8DE E9ACD?B DE C? ?GC<DB R;DA9 G?FBHE :?; H9;DV<CDV9 R;?HFACE DB DBA?=RL9C9 =<;@9CEK /?; C8DE RF;R?E9 >9 EFRR?E9 C8<C <;H 9TC9BED?B ?: C89 EC<BH<;H <;GDC;<P9 <;PF=9BC4 <BI ?RR?;CFBDCI C8<C DE <AA9RC<GL9 <AA?;HDBP C8DE =9<EF;9 >?FLH G9 kFDA@LI 9LD=DB<C9H DB C89 =<;@9CK !:C9; C8DE <H`FEC=9BC 8<E C<@9B RL<A94 C89 R;DA9 ?: <BI <EE9C =FEC G9 EFA8 C8<C DC DE B?C R?EEDGL9 C? A;9<C9 <AA9RC<GL9 ?RR?;CFBDCD9E GI =9<BE ?: <BI <H=DEEDGL9 R?;C:?LD? EC;<C9PIK U9 <D= C? A?=RFC9 C89 ;9EFLCDBP R;DA9 G?FBHE 9TRLDADCLIK

U9 <EEF=9 C8<C B G<EDA <EE9CE <;9 R;9E9BC DB C89 =<;@9C4 >8?E9 R;DA9E <;9 H9EA;DG9H GI < :FBACD?B *f Zl# )BK /?; 9<A8 5 & C & #4 <B ?CQ=9<EF;<GL9

:FBACD?B *C f Z# )B DE H9:DB9H GI *CMgO X *Mg nCOK ! C;<HDBP EC;<C9PI DE < :FBACD?B

:;?= Zl C? )B4 DBC9;R;9C9H <E < ;FL9 C8<C <EEDPBE C? 9<A8 R<;CD<L 8DEC?;I gl ! Zl < R?EDCD?B DB C89 G<EDA DBEC;F=9BCEK

&: Pf Zl# )B DE < EC;<C9PI4 >9 >;DC9 PCMgO X PMg nCOK (<A8 C;<HDBP EC;<C9PI

H9:DB9E < R?EDCD?B4 B<=9LI C89 C?C<L ;9EFLC ?: C89 EC;<C9PI >8DA8 DE PDV9B GI

SP fX 1 2 2 0 3 6 5 6 O M ' , , , ' , D D E M_K6O

:?; < E9L:Q:DB<BADBP EC;<C9PI >DC8 J9;? DBDCD<L DBV9EC=9BCK ]DV9B < G<EDA <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 "4 >9 H9:DB9 C89 <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9 ?: < R?EDCD?B Y EFG`9AC C? < EC;<C9PI P GI

"P_{MYO fX " MY h S}P_O _{M_K1O}

+9C FE <EEF=9 C8<C < B?B9=RCI E9C ?: <LL?>9H 89HPDBP EC;<C9PD9E 8<E G99B :DT9HK U9 A<B C89B H9:DB94 :?; <BI R?EDCD?B Y4 C89 ?RCD=<L H9P;99 ?: <AA9RC<GDLDCI C<@DBP 89HPDBP DBC? <AA?FBCf

(8)

"7_{MYO fX EFR "}P_MYOK _{M_K2O}

P!

"?BEDH9; :D;EC4 <E DB "<;; 9C <LK M1556O4 < EDBPL9QR9;D?H 9A?B?=I >DC8 C;<H9H <EE9CE *54 K K K 4 *B <BH >DC8 < A?LL9ACD?B / ?: R;?G<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E ?B C89 :DBDC9 E9C Z ?: EC<C9E ?: B<CF;9K #89 R;DA9 ?: <EE9C D <C CD=9 C MC X 54 6O DE PDV9B GI *DC j *5 DE

C89 BF=9;<D;9 >8DA8 <L><IE 8<E R;DA9 6K

#89 9A?B?=I DE E<DH C? <LL?> 0,!*5,7$& "553),"673& +))+!,4%*,*30 D: DC DE R?EEDGL9 C? :?;= < EC;DACLI <AA9RC<GL9 R?;C:?LD? <C J9;? A?ECj C8<C DE4 D: C89;9 9TDEC R?;C:?LD? >9DP8CE <54 K K K 4 <B EFA8 C8<C 5 5 0 1 0 % * * * D " 5 5 ( 1 0 % * * * / " D . 4 :?; <LL [ ! / 5 5 4 1 0 % * * * / "D . 4:?; E?=9 [ ! /

"<;; 9C <LK M1556O 8<V9 <;PF9H C8<C D: < A?LL9ACD?B ?: C9EC =9<EF;9E DE A8?E9B EF::DAD9BCLI L<;P9 E? <E C? ;9:L9AC < >DH9LI 89LH =<;@9C VD9>4 DC ADLL G9 B? EC;DACLI <AA9RC<GL9 ?RR?;CFBDCD9E DB C89 9A?B?=IK #89 %*!, A?BHDCD?B MbB? EC;DACLI <AA9RC<GL9 ?RR?;CFBDCD9EcO DE < EC;?BP9; ;9kFD;9=9BC C8?FLH G9 ?GC<DB9H GI C89 B?Q <;GDC;<P9 A?BHDCD?B <L?B9K

&B < =FLCDR9;D?H E9CCDBP4 >9 DBC9;R;9C C89 %*!, A?BHDCD?B <E C89 ;9kFD;9=9BC C8<C B? E9L:Q:DB<BADBP DBV9EC=9BC EC;<C9PI >DC8 J9;? DBDCD<L A?EC E8?FLH R;?HFA9 < EC;DACLI <AA9RC<GL9 ;9EFLCK &C DE 9<EDLI V9;D:D9H C8<C < B9A9EE<;I A?BHDCD?B :?; C89 %*!, A?BHDCD?B C? 8?LH :?; < PDV9B =FLCDR9;D?H 9A?B?=I DE C8<C 9<A8 ?: C89 <EE?AD<C9H EDBPL9QR9;D?H 9A?B?=D9E E8?FLH G9 :;99 ?: EC;DACLI <AA9RC<GL9 ?RR?;CFBDCD9EK !E A9V9;4 C8DE A?BHDCD?B DE B?C EF::DAD9BCK

#I5GJK8'M7E'

"?BEDH9; C89 C>?QR9;D?H GDB?=D<L C;99 ?: (T<=RL9 2K6 <P<DB4 >DC8 C89 E<=9 A?LL9ACD?B ?: C>? C9EC =9<EF;9EK *FRR?E9 C89;9 <;9 C>? <EE9CE * <BH rK #89 V<LF9 ?: r DE <L><IE 6554 >89;9<E :?; * >9 8<V9

*M5O X 6554 *MFO X 6654 *MHO X N54

(9)

&C DE 9<EDLI V9;D:D9H C8<C B?B9 ?: C89 EDBPL9QR9;D?H 9A?B?=D9E H9;DV9H :;?= C8DE =?H9L <LL?>E EC;DACLI <AA9RC<GL9 ?RR?;CFBDCD9EK %?> A?BEDH9; C89 HIB<=DA EC;<C9PI C8<C DE H9:DB9H <E :?LL?>EK #<@9 B? R?EDCD?B <C C89 DBDCD<L CD=9j <C CD=9 64 C<@9 < R?EDCD?B 6 DB C89 <EE9C * M<BH a6K6 DB rO D: Bc EC9R C<@9E RL<A9K #89 9TR9AC9H ;9EFLC ?: C8DE EC;<C9PI FBH9; C9EC =9<EF;9 [6 DE

5Ke % M5Ke d 65 h 5K_ d Ma65OO h 5K_ d M5Ke d Ma65O h 5K_ d 65O X 5K_ >8DL9 FBH9; [1 >9 :DBH

5K_ d M5K_ d 65 h 5Ke d Ma65OO h 5Ke d M5K_ d Ma65O h 5Ke d 65O X 5K_K

*? C89 9TR9AC9H ;9EFLC DE R?EDCDV9 DB G?C8 A<E9Ej C89 b=?=9BCF=c EC;<C9PI A;9<C9E < EC;DACLI <AA9RC<GL9 ?RR?;CFBDCIK

'

!% .-)(!%)'

U9 8<V9 A?BEDH9;9H C89 =FLCDR9;D?H 9TC9BED?B ?: C89 B?CD?B ?: A?89;9BC ;DE@ =9<EF;9E <E DBC;?HFA9H GI !;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNOK ,F; =<DB A?BALFED?BE <;9 C8<C C89 <HHDCD?B ?: < HIB<=DA A?BEDEC9BAI <TD?= L9<HE C? < ED=RL9 <BH <CC;<ACDV9 A8<;<AC9;DJ<CD?B ?: A?89;9BC HIB<=DA <AA9RC<GDLDCI =9<EF;9E4 <BH C8<C C89 :;<=9>?;@ ?GC<DB9H DB C8DE >E A8<;<AC9;DJ<CD?BE ?: R;DA9 G?FBHE :?; H9;DV<CDV9 <EE9CE DB DBA?=RL9C9 =<;@9CE C8<C <;9 B<CF;<L A?FBC9;R<;CE ?: C89 >9LLQ @B?>B ;9EFLCE :?; C89 A?=RL9C9 =<;@9C A<E9K

U9 8<V9 >?;@9H >DC8DB C89 ED=RL9EC R?EEDGL9 E9CCDBP C8<C <LL?>E A?BEDH9;<CD?B ?: R<;CD<LLI ;9V9<L9H DB:?;=<CD?B <BH HIB<=DA 89HPDBPK &BC9;R;9CDBP ?F; ;9EFLCE :;?= < A?BCDBF?FEQCD=9 R9;ER9ACDV94 ?B9 =DP8C E?FLH :<V?; <RR;?<A89E C8<C =9<EF;9 HDEA;9R<BAI G9C>99B =?H9LE DB C9;=E ?: 9V9;4 DC ;9=<DBE HD::DAFLC C? =<@9 <BI H9:DBDCDV9 EC<C9=9BCEK &B C8DE R<R9; >9 8<V9 >?;@9H >DC8 C89 <TD?= ?: R?EDCDV9 8?=?P9B9DCI4 :?LL?>DBP !;CJB9; 9C <LK M6NNNOK

$#N#$#% #)' '

!BEA?=G9 /K4 <BH )K !F=<BB M6Ne2O4 -9:DBDCD?B ?: EFG`9ACDV9 R;?G<GDLDCIK !BB<LE ?: 0<C89=<CDA<L *C<CDECDAE4 2_4 6NNi153K

!;CJB9; [8K4 /K -9LG<9B4 tKQ0K (G9; <BH -K S9<C8 M6NNNO4 "?89;9BC =9<EF;9E ?: ;DE@K 0<C89=<CDA<L /DB<BA94 N4 152i11qK

!;CJB9; [8K4 /K -9LG<9B tKQ0K (G9;4 -K S9<C84 <BH SK \F M1552O4 "?89;9BC =FLCDR9;D?H ;DE@ <H`FEC9H V<LF9E <BH r9LL=<BlE R;DBADRL9K 0<BFEA;DRC4 $BDV9;EDCu9 +?FDE [<EC9F;K

(10)

"<;; [K4 SK ]9=<B <BH -K rK 0<H<B M1556O4 [;DADBP <BH 89HPDBP DB DBA?=RL9C9 =<;@9CEK t?F;B<L ?: /DB<BAD<L (A?B?=DAE4 214 626i6esK

"89B .K <BH +K]K (REC9DB M1551O4 !=GDPFDCI4 ;DE@ <BH <EE9C ;9CF;BE DB A?BCDBF?FE CD=9K (A?B?=9C;DA<4 s54 6_52i6__2K

-9LG<9B /K M1551O4 "?89;9BC ;DE@ =9<EF;9E ?B P9B9;<L R;?G<GDLDCI ER<A9EK &Bf \K *<BH=<BB4 [K tK *A8v?BGFA89; M9HEKO4 !HV<BA9E DB /DB<BA9 <BH *C?A8<ECDAEK (EE<IE DB S?B?F; ?: -D9C9; *?BH9;=<BB4 *R;DBP9;4 r9;LDB4 RRK 6i2qK

-F::D9 -K <BH +K]K (REC9DB M6NN1O4 *C?A8<ECDA HD::9;9BCD<L FCDLDCIK (A?B?=9C;DA<4 e54 232i 2N_K (LLEG9;P -K M6Ne6O4 )DE@4 <=GDPFDCI4 <BH C89 *<V<P9 <TD?=EK wF<;C9;LI t?F;B<L ?: (A?B?=DAE4 s34

e_2ieeNK

SFLL tK <BH !K U8DC9 M6NN5O4 [;DADBP DBC9;9EC ;<C9 H9;DV<CDV9E E9AF;DCD9EK )9VD9> ?: /DB<BAD<L *CFHD9E4 24 3s2i3N1K

\<8B9=<B -K <BH !K #V9;E@I M6NsNO4 [;?ER9AC C89?;If <B <B<LIEDE ?: H9ADED?B FBH9; ;DE@K (A?B?=9C;DA<4 _s4 1e2i1N6K

\D;A8 0K M1552O4 (::DAD9BC S9HPDBP DB &BA?=RL9C9 0<;@9CE FBH9; 0?H9L $BA9;C<DBCI4 [8- C89EDE4 SF=G?LHC $BDV9;EDCI4 r9;LDBK

0<BP<E<;DQSDLL4 %9> W?;@K )D9H9L /K M1552O4 -IB<=DA A?89;9BC ;DE@ =9<EF;9EK 0<BFEA;DRC4 *C<B:?;H $BDV9;EDCIK *<V<P9 +K M6N3_O4 /?FBH<CD?BE ?: *C<CDECDAEK UDL9I4 %9> W?;@K

U<BP #K M1552O "?BHDCD?B<L R;9:9;9BA9E <BH FRH<CDBPK t?F;B<L ?: (A?B?=DA #89?;I4 65q4 1qei 216K

U9G9; *K M1552O4 -DEC;DGFCD?BQDBV<;D<BC HIB<=DA ;DE@ =9<EF;9EK 0<BFEA;DRC4 SF=G?LHC $BDV9;EDCI4 r9;LDB4 1N

!"#$%"&'!()*+,&

*!"#$#%&%#'+(,$O'$OPO*,'Q'+!0#.-'0O%,+( P%O+' '

[?HEC<>I C9?;DD @?89;9BCBIA8 =D<; ;IJI@< GIxI ?=y>D?B9 > R;<AI !;CJB9; D DBK M6NNNO > F`zADF EC<CIAJBI=K [;J9HEC<>D=I <B<L?PDAJBI =?H9L > R?H9`{ADF HIB<=DAJBI= J AJ<E9= HIE@C;9CBI=K .<RDEJ9=I EC<BH<;H?>9 <@E`?=<CI H9:DBDF`|A9 =D<;I @?89;9BCB9 HIB<=DAJBD9K ,=y>D=I >x<EB?{AD R;J9HEC<>D?B9P? =?H9LF ?;<J R?@<^9=I =?^LD>?{} >I@?;JIEC<BD< =?H9LF H? J<G9JRD9AJ9BD< R?JIA`D :DB<BE?>9` >I@?;JIECF`|A >IG;<B| @L<Ez =D<; ;IJI@<K