Sztuka w ujęciu Jose Ortegi y Gasseta

A N N A L E S

81,9(56,7$7,60$5,$(&85,(6.à2'2:6.$

/8%/,1±32/21,$

92/;;;9,,, 6(&7,2, 

-RVp2UWHJD\*DVVHW±MHVWMHGQ\P]QDMZ\ELWQLHMV]\FKSU]HG- VWDZLFLHOLP\ĞOLKLV]SDĔVNLHM3URIHVRU8QLZHUV\WHWXZ0DGU\FLHP\ĞOLFLHOSR- OLW\F]Q\DOHSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPVRFMRORJ¿OR]RILDXWRUZLHOXG]LHá±VSRUDLFK

F]ĊĞü]RVWDáDSU]HWáXPDF]RQDQDMĊ]\NSROVNL-HGQDNMDN]DXZDĪD'RURWD/HV]- F]\QDWHQWDNFHQLRQ\Z]DFKRGQLHM(XURSLHL6WDQDFK=MHGQRF]RQ\FKXF]RQ\

Z QDV]\P NUDMX ZFLąĪ SR]RVWDMH Ä¿OR]RIHP GUXJRU]ĊGQ\P´ R F]\P ĞZLDGF]\

GRĞüXERJDOLF]EDRSUDFRZDĔ^SRĞZLĊFRQ\FKMHJRP\ĞOL²'RQDMEDUG]LHMSRSX- ODUQ\FKG]LHáKLV]SDĔVNLHJRP\ĞOLFLHOD]GDMHVLĊZFLąĪQDOHĪHüSUDFDBunt mas

ZNWyUHMDXWRUGRNRQDáGLDJQR]\VSRáHF]HĔVWZDLNXOWXU\-HVWRQDSXQNWHPZ\M- ĞFLDQLHW\ONRGODMHJRP\ĞOLVRFMRORJLF]QHMDOHWDNĪHNXOWXUR]QDZF]HMLHVWHW\F]- QHMRUD]NRQFHSFMLV]WXNLNWyUąSUDJQĊSU]\EOLĪ\üZQLQLHMV]\PWHNĞFLH6WDZLDP

S\WDQLHF]\PMHVWV]WXNDGOD-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWD"=DVDGQLF]HSRJOąG\QDWHPDW

V]WXNL2UWHJD]DZDUáZSUDFDFKDehumanizacja sztukiSztuka w czasie te- UDĨQLHMV]\PLSU]HV]á\PDWDNĪHZLQQ\FKHVHMDFKHVWHW\F]Q\FKNWyUHF]\- QLĊSU]HGPLRWHPPRLFKDQDOL]

8SRGVWDZP\ĞOLHVWHW\F]QHM2UWHJLWNZLNRQFHSFMDNXOWXU\.XOWXUDGODKLV]- SDĔVNLHJRP\ĞOLFLHODPDSURZHQLHQFMĊZLWDOQąMHVWHIHNWHPWZyUF]HMSRWHQFMLJak SLV]H.U]\V]WRI3ROLWZHGáXJ2UWHJLÄF]áRZLHNLQVW\QNWRZQLHZ\NRQXMHMHG\Qą

 : 3ROVFH SRZVWDá\ WU]\ PRQRJUDILH SRĞZLĊFRQH KLV]SDĔVNLHPX ILOR]RIRZL L MHJR P\ĞOL

(*yUVNL-RVp2UWHJD\*DVVHWLNU\]\VLGHRORJLLKLV]SDĔVNLHM:URFáDZ.3ROLWKryzys cywi- OL]DFML=DFKRGXZP\ĞOL-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWD/XEOLQ5*DMOrtega y Gasset :DUV]DZD

25*DMOrtega y Gasset:DUV]DZDUHF'/HV]F]\QD2Ī\ZRWQRĞFLP\ĞOL-RVp2UWH- gi y Gasseta Ä'LDPHWURV´ QUV

6]WXNDZXMĊFLX-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWD

$*1,(6=.$6.52%$6

7KH$UWLQWKH&RQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQRI-RVp2UWHJD\*DVVHW

Y

 Agnieszka Skrobas

PRĪOLZąF]\QQRĞüVWDUDVLĊXSRU]ąGNRZDüWRFRMDZLPXVLĊMDNRFKDRVLGRNR- QXMHNROHMQ\FKSUyELQWHUSUHWDFMLĞZLDWD´^.XOWXUDWR]HVSyáLGHLNWyUHSRU]ąGNX- MąU]HF]\ZLVWRĞüRWDF]DMąFąF]áRZLHNDF]\QLąMąSU]\VWĊSQąL]UR]XPLDáą7RVSR- VyEZLG]HQLDU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL.XOWXUĊVWDQRZLZV]\VWNRFRSRVLDGDMDNLĞVHQVGOD

F]áRZLHND,GHDPLNXOWXURZ\PLVąWHLGHHNWyUHX]QDMHRQ]DSUDZG]LZHDNXOWX- URZ\PLLQVW\WXFMDPLWHNWyUHX]QDMH]DVáXV]QH.XOWXUDWR]HVSyáLQWHOHNWXDOQ\FK

LSUDNW\F]Q\FKUHDNFMLGąĪąF\FKGRUHDOL]DFMLQRUPNWyU\PF]áRZLHNQDGDMHZDU- WRĞüDEVROXWQą⁴.XOWXUD]DZLHUDZVRELHSRMĊFLHSUDZG\GREUDSLĊNQDVSUDZLH- GOLZRĞFL-DNSLV]H2UWHJDÄSRF]XFLHVSUDZLHGOLZRĞFLSR]QDQLHLP\ĞOHQLHSUDZ- G\WZyUF]RĞüL]DGRZROHQLHDUW\VW\PLPRĪHZ\UDVWDMą]SU]\GDWQRĞFLĪ\FLRZHM

PDMąVZyMZáDVQ\VHQVLZDUWRĞü6WDQRZLąZLĊFĪ\FLHGXFKRZHF]\OLNXOWXUĊ´⁵

7UHĞüW\FKZ\SRZLHG]LVXJHUXMHRELHNW\ZQ\VWDWXVZDUWRĞFLNXOWXU\ZV\VWHPLH

autora Buntu masFRMHGQDNQLH]JDG]DVLĊ]MHJRJáyZQ\PLWH]DPL:DUWRĞFLZH- GáXJKLV]SDĔVNLHJRXF]RQHJRVąVXELHNW\ZQHLZWyUQHZREHFĪ\FLD,FKDXWRQRPLD

MHVWZ]JOĊGQD=DJDGQLHQLHWRZ\PDJDMHGQDNRGUĊEQ\FKVWXGLyZ⁶

2UWHJD\*DVVHWSRVWXOXMHNRQFHSFMĊNXOWXU\HOLWDUQHM8MHMSRGVWDZWNZL]D- WHP QLHW]VFKHDĔVNLHM SURZHQLHQFML SRODU\]DFMD VSRáHF]HĔVWZD L SRG]LDá QD HOLWĊ

RUD]PDVĊ(OLWĊVWDQRZLąZ\ELWQHMHGQRVWNLWZyUF]HNUHDW\ZQHRZ\VRNLPSR- WHQFMDOHXP\VáRZ\PNWyUHZDUXQNXMąSRVWĊSNXOWXU\8WU]\PXMąMąQDZ\VRNLP

SR]LRPLHMDNRĞFLRZ\PQLHXVWDQQLHUR]ZLMDMąFLGĨZLJDMąFFLĊĪDURGSRZLHG]LDO- QRĞFL]DSRGMĊW\WUXG-DNSLV]H2UWHJDÄF]áRZLHNZ\ELWQ\W\PVLĊUyĪQLRGF]áR- ZLHNDSRVSROLWHJRĪHWHQSLHUZV]\PDGXĪHZ\PDJDQLDZREHFVLHELHVDPHJRQD- WRPLDVWWHQGUXJL]DFKZ\FRQ\ZáDVQąRVREąQLF]HJRRGVLHELHQLHZ\PDJDEĊGąF

]XSHáQLH]DGRZRORQ\]WHJRNLPMHVW´⁷$XWRUBuntu masHOLWDUQRĞüXWRĪVDPLD]H

V]ODFKHWQRĞFLąNWyUąRNUHĞODMDNRÄZWUXG]LHZ\SUDFRZDQą´ÄGRVNRQDáą´^&]áR- ZLHNDPDVRZHJRFHFKXMHQDWRPLDVWKHUPHW\]PQLHVIRUQRĞüLSU]HFLĊWQDXP\VáR- ZRĞüNWyUDQLHMHVWZVWDQLHZ\WZRU]\üSUDZG]LZHMNXOWXU\RSDUWHMQD]DVDGDFK

SUDZRU]ąGQRĞFLLQRUPDFKVWDQRZLąF\FKMHMSRGVWDZĊ-DNSLV]HÄ>«@QLHPDNXO-

.3ROLWop. citV

43RUIbidemV

5-2UWHJD\*DVVHWZadanie naszych czasów>Z@Po co wracamy do filozofiiSU]Há0,ZLĔ- VND:DUV]DZDV

6.U]\V]WRI3ROLW]DXZDĪDSHZQąQLHNRQVHNZHQFMĊ2UWHJL\*DVVHWDJG\SLV]HÄZDUWRĞüQLHGODWH- JRMHVWZDUWRĞFLąĪHQDPVLĊSRGREDF]\EXG]LQDV]HSRĪąGDQLHOHF]RGZURWQLHGODWHJRQDPVLĊSRGR- EDF]\EXG]LQDV]HSRĪąGDQLHLĪMHVWZDUWRĞFLą$]DWHPZDUWRĞFLVąZDUWRĞFLDPLZF]HĞQLHMLQLH]DOHĪQLH

RGWHJRF]\VWDQRZLąRELHNWQDV]HJR]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDLXF]Xü´-2UWHJD\*DVVHWWprowadzenie do estymatyki>Z@Dehumanizacja sztuki i inne esejeSU]Há31LNOHZLF]:DUV]DZDV6áRZD

WHVXJHUXMąRELHNW\ZQ\VWDWXVZDUWRĞFL1LH]JRGQRĞüWĊDXWRU.U\]\VXF\ZLOL]DFML=DFKRGXZP\ĞOL-RVp

Ortegi y GassetaSUyEXMHZ\MDĞQLüQDJUXQFLHNRQFHSFMLDU\VWRWHOHVRZVNLHMZyZF]DVZDUWRĞFLLVWQLD- á\E\MDNRF]\VWHSRWHQFMHRGF]\W\ZDQHSU]H]F]áRZLHNDZSURFHVLHĪ\FLD=RE.3ROLW op. citV

=DJDGQLHQLHZDUWRĞFLZP\ĞOLKLV]SDĔVNLHJRILOR]RIDSRUXV]DWDNĪH5\V]DUG*DMop. citV±

7-2UWHJD\*DVVHWBunt masSU]Há31LNOHZLF]:DUV]DZDV

 IbidemV

6]WXNDZXMĊFLX-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWD 

WXU\JG]LHQLHPDQRUPGRNWyU\FKPRJOLE\VLĊRGZRá\ZDüQDVLEOLĨQL1LHPD

NXOWXU\JG]LHQLHPD]DVDGSUDZRU]ąGQRĞFLGRNWyU\FKPRĪQDE\VLĊRGZRáDü1LH

PDNXOWXU\JG]LHQLHPDV]DFXQNXGODSHZQ\FKRVWDWHF]Q\FKVWDQRZLVNLQWHOHNWX- DOQ\FKGRNWyU\FKPRJá\E\VLĊRGQLHĞüVWURQ\ZG\VNXVML1LHPDNXOWXU\JG]LH

VWRVXQNDPL HNRQRPLF]Q\PL QLH NLHUXMą MDNLHĞ XVWDORQH ]DVDG\ 1LH PD NXOWXU\

JG]LHZSROHPLNDFKHVWHW\F]Q\FKQLHX]QDMHVLĊSRWU]HE\X]DVDGQLDQLDG]LHáV]WX- NL´⁹,FKEUDNMHVW]GDQLHP2UWHJLWRĪVDP\]EDUEDU]\ĔVWZHP

.XOWXUDMHVWZ\UD]HPĪ\FLDDZLĊFMHVWIRUPąVXELHNW\ZQą2UWHJDX]QDZDá

SLHUZLDVWHN Ī\FLRZ\ ]D FHQQą HQHUJLĊ ZLWDOL]XMąFą NXOWXUĊ ]DEH]SLHF]DMąFą MHM

Ī\ZRWQRĞüÄ.XOWXUDQLHLVWQLHMHEH]Ī\FLD±WZLHUG]LDXWRUZadania naszych cza- sów±WDNMDNQLHPDGXFKRZRĞFLEH]ZLWDOQRĞFL´^.XOWXUDZ\UDĪDĪ\FLHDNW\Z- QHLWZyUF]HNWyUHQLHXVWDQQLHSUDJQLHSU]HNUDF]DüZáDVQHKRU\]RQW\Z\FKRG]L

SR]DVLHELHSRV]XNXMHQRZ\FKSHUVSHNW\ZVDPRUHDOL]DFMLLZLG]HQLDĞZLDWD-DN

SLV]H2UWHJDÄWDNGáXJRĪ\MHP\QDSUDZGĊMDNGáXJRSUDJQLHP\MHV]F]HZLĊNV]HM

LQWHQV\ZQRĞFLĪ\FLD3R]RVWDZDQLH]Z\WUZDá\PXSRUHPZUDPDFKFLąJOHW\FK

VDP\FK]QDQ\FKKRU\]RQWyZR]QDF]DVáDERĞüL]DQLNHQHUJLLĪ\FLRZHM´^

:NRQFHSFMĊNXOWXU\-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWDZSLVXMHVLĊGH¿QLFMDV]WXNL6]WX- ND GOD 2UWHJL WR MHGHQ ] NXOWXURZ\FK ERJDW\FK Z\WZRUyZ Ī\FLD RZRF HJ]\- VWHQFMLNUHDW\ZQHMNWyUDĪąGDRGVLHELHZFLąĪZLĊFHM-DNSLV]HDXWRUQDMQRZV]HM

SROVNLHMPRQRJUD¿LR2UWHG]H5\V]DUG*DMÄ>«@V]WXNDQDMEDUG]LHM]HZV]\VW- NLFKSR]DWHRUHW\F]Q\FKVIHUG]LDáDOQRĞFLF]áRZLHNDZ\UDĪDZROQRĞFLRZ\SURMHN- W\ZQ\LWZyUF]\FKDUDNWHUĪ\FLDOXG]NLHJR´^-HVWZLĊFLQWHJUDOQąF]ĊĞFLąĪ\FLD

SURELHU]HP ]PDJDĔ ] ORVHP RVRELVW\P VSRáHF]Q\P L G]LHMRZ\P^ 3U]HVWU]HĔ

DUW\VW\F]QD]GDMHVLĊE\üSHZQąNRQVHNZHQFMąF]\WHĪNRQNUHWQąIRUPąQDMJáĊE- V]HJR XF]XFLD ZREHF Ī\FLD 6]WXND WR SLHUZRWQH G]LDáDQLD ZLWDOQH +LV]SDĔVNL

P\ĞOLFLHO VWZLHUG]D LĪ ÄV]WXND MHVW V]ODFKHWQ\P VXEVW\WXWHP Ī\FLD *G\E\ĞP\

ZV]\VF\PRJOLSURZDG]LüĪ\FLHWDNLQWHQV\ZQHSHáQHZLHONLHMQDPLĊWQRĞFLV]OD- FKHWQ\FK PHODQFKROLL L ZV]\VWNLFK W\FK XF]Xü L ZUDĪHĔ MDNLPL Vą SU]HV\FRQH

GUDPDW\6]HNVSLUDWRE\üPRĪHPRJOLE\ĞP\REHMĞüVLĊEH]V]WXNL>«@ZPR- PHQWDFKNLHG\©]HZV]\VWNLFK]DNDPDUNyZZ\]LHUDQXGDL]QLHFKĊFHQLHªVąF]ąF

ZGXV]ĊEyOLVPXWHNZV]HFKĞZLDWDVWZLHUG]DP\QDJOHSXVWNĊQDV]HMHJ]\VWHQFML

LZWHG\ZáDĞQLHRGF]XZDP\SRWU]HEĊVLĊJQLĊFLDSRZLQR]FXG]\FKZLQQLFF]X- MHP\FKĊü]DJáĊELHQLDVLĊZWUDJLF]Q\FKVFHQDFKV]WXN>«@6]WXNDMHVWZLĊFZ\- ]ZROHQLHP2GF]HJRQDVZ\]ZDOD"±RGSRZV]HFKQRĞFL´^

9 IbidemV

 IdemZadanie naszych czasówV

 IdemDehumanizacja sztuki>Z@Dehumanizacja sztuki i inne esejeV

5*DMop. citV

3RU=&KRPLF]&]HNDMąFQDDUF\G]LHáRÄ.XOWXUDL7\´QUV

-2UWHJD\*DVVHWPoezja nowa – poezja stara>Z@Dehumanizacja sztuki i inne eseje

V±

 Agnieszka Skrobas

6]WXNDGOD2UWHJLMHVWSHZQ\PV]ODFKHWQ\P]P\VáHPáąF]ąF\PĞZLDWSU]\UR- G\LĞZLDWGXFKD-DNVWZLHUG]D5\V]DUG*DMÄJG\QDXNDG]LHOLSUREOHPĪ\FLDQDGX- FKDLSU]\URGĊLQLHMHVWZVWDQLHZ\FKZ\FLüZV]\VWNLFKUHODFML]ZLą]DQ\FK]U]HF]ą

ERU]HF]WRFDáRĞüLVWQLHMąF\FKUHODFML]UHV]WąZV]HFKĞZLDWDV]WXNDVWDUDVLĊZ\- MDĞQLüWHUHODFMHWZRU]ąF¿NFMĊMHMFDáRĞFL´^7RURG]DMHVWHW\]DFMLU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL

6WDQRZLDSRJHXPSUDF\LQWHOHNWXXRVRELHQLHMDVQRĞFL3U]HVWU]HĔDUW\VW\F]QDMHVW

Z\UD]HPVZHJRF]DVXEĊGąFX]DOHĪQLRQąRGMHMGXFKRZ\FKXZDUXQNRZDĔ']LH- áDV]WXNLZ\UDĪDMąLGHHVąQRĞQLNDPLLV\PERODPLZDUWRĞFL6]WXNDMHVWRG]ZLHU- FLHGOHQLHPXF]XüGDQHMHSRNLMHVWVSRVREHPLFKV\PEROL]DFMLDW\PVDP\PLFK

utrwalania^-HVW]ZLą]DQD]V\VWHPDPL¿OR]R¿F]Q\PLLPRUDOQ\PLNWyUHMHGQDN

]QLNDMąZODPXVLHHSRNL2UWHJDSRVWXOXMHERZLHPV]WXNĊQRZąNWyUD]U\ZD

]WUDG\FMą:LHONDV]WXNDF]DVXSU]HV]áHJRWR]GDQLHP¿OR]RID]DE\WHNDUFKHROR- JLF]Q\IDNWKLVWRU\F]Q\Ä:\SDURZDá\MXĪUHV]WNLGXFKDWUDG\FML'DZQHPRGHOH

QRUP\Z]RU\QLHPDMąMXĪ]DVWRVRZDQLD´^,FKZDĪQRĞüSU]HPLQĊáDZUD]]ZDUWR- ĞFLąHVWHW\F]Qą1LHPDERZLHPZLHF]Q\FKQLHSU]HPLMDMąF\FKZDUWRĞFLV]WXNL-DN

pisze autor 6]WXNLZF]DVLHWHUDĨQLHMV]\PLSU]HV]á\PÄZLHF]QDWUZDáRĞüV]WXNLQLH

MHVWSUDZGąUD]QD]DZV]HXVWDORQąGRNWyUHMPRĪQDVLĊ]DZV]HRGZRáDüMHVWWRSR

SURVWXEDUG]RVXEWHOQ\SUREOHP´^2UWHJDQLHGHSUHFMRQXMHV]WXNLZLHNyZSRSU]HG- QLFKDOH]ZUDFDXZDJĊQDMHMSU]HV]á\FKDUDNWHUÄVąRQHZFDáRĞFL]DNRQVHUZRZD- QHDOHPLHV]F]ąVLĊZZ\PLDU]HZLGPRZ\P>«@´^3U]\MHPQRĞüMDNąF]HUSLHP\

]REFRZDQLD]HV]WXNąSU]HV]áRĞFLZ\Sá\ZD]DWHPEDUG]LHM]Ī\ZRWQRĞFLWUDG\FML

ZNWyUHMMHVWRQDXV\WXRZDQDQLĪ]MHMZDUWRĞFLHVWHW\F]Q\FK,VWRWąV]WXNLZVSyá- F]HVQHMVąQDWRPLDVWGR]QDQLDHVWHW\F]QH1RZDV]WXNDZ\QRVLF]áRZLHNDSRQDG

MHJROXG]NLZ\PLDURGU\ZDJRRGU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLĞZLDGRPLHMąGHIRUPXMąF

2UWHJDZ\PLHQLDSRVWXODW\QRZHMV]WXNL8ZDĪDĪHGąĪ\RQDGRGHKX- PDQL]DFMLXQLNDQLDIRUPPDMąF\FKVZHRGELFLHZĪ\FLXVSRZRGRZDQLD

E\G]LHáRV]WXNLE\áRZ\áąF]QLHG]LHáHPV]WXNLWUDNWRZDQLDV]WXNLMDNR]DED- Z\LQLF]HJRZLĊFHMSRVWDZ\]]DVDG\LURQLF]QHMZ\VWU]HJDQLDVLĊIDáV]X

LVNUXSXODWQHMUHDOL]DFMLG]LHáD3RQDGWRGRGDMHLĪQRZDV]WXNDQLHPDĪDGQHJR

transcendentnego znaczenia²⁰

$NW GHKXPDQL]DFML R]QDF]D GHIRUPDFMĊ U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL ]QLV]F]HQLH MHM

DVSHNWyZ ÄOXG]NLFK´^ 'HKXPDQL]DFMD WR Z\UXJRZDQLH ]H V]WXNL WUHĞFL Ī\FLR- Z\FK2UWHJDSLV]HÄVPXWHNOXEUDGRĞü]OXG]NLFKORVyZRNWyU\FKRSRZLDGD

V]WXNDQLHPDQLFZVSyOQHJR]SUDZG]LZąSU]\MHPQRĞFLąHVWHW\F]Qą&RZLĊFHM

5*DMop. citV±

3RU0*RONDOdczytywanie sztukiÄ1XUW´QUV

-2UWHJD\*DVVHW6]WXNDZF]DVLHWHUDĨQLHMV]\PLSU]HV]á\P>Z@Dehumanizacja sztuki i inne esejeV

 IbidemV

 Ibidem

20=REIdemDehumanizacja sztukiV

 IbidemV

6]WXNDZXMĊFLX-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWD 

]DDEVRUERZDQLHOXG]NąWUHĞFLąG]LHáDMHVW]DVDGQLF]RQLH]JRGQH]ZáDĞFLZ\P]D- GRZROHQLHPHVWHW\F]Q\P´²²1RZDV]WXNDLG]LHZNLHUXQNXVSU]HF]Q\P]ÄOXG]- Ną´ U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLą 3U]\ĞZLHFD MHM SRWU]HED REUD]REXUVWZD ± RGUD]D GR IRUP

LLVWQLHĔWZRU]RQ\FKSU]H]VDPRĪ\FLH=QRZąV]WXNąQLHPRĪQDREFRZDüQLH

MHVWRQDSRZURWHPGRFRG]LHQQRĞFLOHF]RGHUZDQLHPRGQLHM=PXV]DGRLPSUR- ZL]RZDQLDQRZ\FKIRUPRGELRUXNRPSOHWQLHUyĪQ\FKRGQDV]HJR]Z\NáHJRSR- VWĊSRZDQLD]SU]HGPLRWDPL'ODZVSyáF]HVQHJRDUW\VW\WULXPIQDGPDWHULąOXG]- NąMHVWĨUyGáHPSU]\MHPQRĞFLHVWHW\F]QHM-HJRG]LHáRMHVWSR]EDZLRQHDVSHNWyZ

QDWXUDOLVW\F]Q\FKLUHDOLVW\F]Q\FKMHVWRGHUZDQLHPRGU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLF]áRZLHND

LQ¿OWUDFMąWUHĞFLOXG]NLFKPLPRWRSRVLDGDMHGQDNVHQV-DNSLV]H2UWHJDÄVWZR- U]HQLH F]HJRĞ FR QLH MHVW QDĞODGRZDQLHP ©QDWXU\ª D PLPR WR SRVLDGD SHZQą

WUHĞü PRĪH E\ü MHG\QLH G]LHáHP WDOHQWX´^ 6WąG RUWHJLDĔVND NU\W\ND V]WXNL UR- mantyzmu²⁴ L QDWXUDOL]PX NWyUHM LVWRWĊ VWDQRZLáD UHDOQD U]HF]\ZLVWRĞü EĊGąFD

MDNE\SLV]H2UWHJD\*DVVHWÄHVWHW\F]QąVXEVWDQFMąFLHOHVQą´²⁵6]WXND;,;ZLH- NXE\áDÄRGELFLHPĪ\FLDRGELFLHPQDWXU\ZLG]LDQHMSRSU]H]WHPSHUDPHQWMHG- QRVWNLSU]HGVWDZLHQLHPOXG]NLFKORVyZ´²⁶%\áDZLĊFáDWZDLSU]\VWĊSQD

1RZD V]WXND ]U\ZD ] NDWHJRULą mimesis QLH SUDJQLH E\ü RGWZyUF]D QLH

QDĞODGXMH UHDOQHJR ĞZLDWD 8SUDZLDQLH V]WXNL QLH MHVW XVSUDZLHGOLZLRQH MH- ĞOL PD VLĊ RJUDQLF]Dü GR UHSURGXNFML U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL GR EH]SáRGQHJR MHM NR- SLRZDQLD =DGDQLHP V]WXNL MHVW SRZRá\ZDQLH GR Ī\FLD ĞZLDWyZ XURMRQ\FK²⁷

6]WXND ZVSyáF]HVQD WZRU]\ QRZH QLH]QDQH NRPELQDFMH 6NáDQLD VLĊ Z VWUR- QĊ VWUXNWXU IRUPDOQ\FK Z NLHUXQNX V]WXNL F]\VWR DUW\VW\F]QHM Ä=DPLDVW PD- ORZDQLD SU]HGPLRWyZ MDNLPL VLĊ MH ZLG]L PDOXMH VLĊ VDPR ZLG]HQLH´^ – pi- VDá 2UWHJD R PDODUVWZLH LPSUHVMRQLVWyZ 2UWHJD SRVWXOXMH V]WXNĊ F]\VWą DX- WRWHOLF]Qą EĊGąFą FHOHP VDP\P Z VRELH QLHZ\SHáQLDMąFą ĪDGQ\FK IXQNFML

poza stricte HVWHW\F]Q\PL 6]WXNĊ QLHLQVWUXPHQWDOQą L QLHSUDNW\F]Qą :V]HO- NL LQVWUXPHQWDOL]P QLV]F]\ ERZLHP V]WXNĊ SUDZG]LZą -DN ]DXZDĪD KLV]SDĔ- VNL ¿OR]RI Ä>«@ RGFLVND VLĊ Z JRGQ\ SRĪDáRZDQLD VSRVyE QD NXOWXU]H HVWH- W\F]QHM SU]HNV]WDáFDMąF V]WXNĊ Z U]HF] XĪ\WNRZą ]Z\F]DMQą GRVWRVRZDQą

GR RNUHĞORQHM SRU\ : WHQ VSRVyE WUDFLP\ SRF]XFLH G\VWDQVX D WDNĪH V]DFX- QHN L OĊN ZREHF V]WXNL ]EOLĪDP\ VLĊ GR QLHM Z E\OH MDNLP XEUDQLX PRPHQ- FLHLXRVRELHQLXNWyUHQDVRWĊSLDMąLSU]HVWDMHP\MąUR]XPLHü´²⁹'ODWHJRWHĪ

2UWHJDSRVWXOXMHXZROQLHQLHZDUWRĞFLHVWHW\F]Q\FKDSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPSLĊNQD

22 IbidemV

 IbidemV

24-DN]DXZDĪD5\V]DUG*DMop. citVZURPDQW\]PLH2UWHJDGRVWU]HJDWDNĪHSHZQHSR- ]\W\ZQHZDUWRĞFLQSF]\VWąPLáRĞüURPDQW\F]QąNWyUDZ\NUDF]DSRQDGSRVSROLWRĞü

25-2UWHJD\*DVVHWDehumanizacja sztukiV

26 Ibidem

27 IbidemV

 IdemO punkcie widzenia w sztuce>Z@Dehumanizacja sztuki i inne esejeV

29 IdemEsej o estetyce zamiast prologu>Z@5*DMop. citV

 Agnieszka Skrobas

RG]Z\F]DMXZ\JRG\F]\GHNRUDFML3LĊNQRQLHMHVWERZLHPVFKOXGQRĞFLąSUR- VWRWąF]\XSRU]ąGNRZDQLHP^'OD2UWHJLQLHPDMHGQHJRLGHDáXSLĊNQD

']LHáRV]WXNLQLHSRZLQQRWHĪZ\UDĪDüUHDOQ\FKXF]Xü8F]XFLHZV]WXFHMHVW

]QDNLHPĞURGNLHPHNVSUHVMLDQLHW\PFRZ\UDĪDQHVZRLVW\PPDWHULDáHPGODQR- wej materii sui generis6]WXNDNUHXMHQRZ\RELHNWNWyU\Ī\MHZSU]HVWU]HQLĞZLDWD

HVWHW\F]QHJRUyĪQHJRRGU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL¿]\F]QHMF]\ĞZLDWDSV\FKRORJLF]QHJR

:HGáXJ2UWHJLV]WXNDMHVWHVHQFMDOQLHLUUHDOL]DFMą-DNSLV]HÄLVWRWąV]WXNLMHVWWZR- U]HQLHQRZHMRELHNW\ZQRĞFL]URG]RQHMSU]H]XSU]HGQLHUR]ELFLHL]QLV]F]HQLHUHDO- Q\FKSU]HGPLRWyZ=WHJRSRZRGXV]WXNDMHVWSRGZyMQLHLUUHDOQDSRSLHUZV]HSR- QLHZDĪQLHMHVWUHDOQDJG\ĪMHVWQRZąLUyĪQąRGWHJRU]HF]ąFRUHDOQHSRGUXJLH

SRQLHZDĪWDU]HF]RGPLHQQDLQRZDNWyUąMHVWSU]HGPLRWHVWHW\F]Q\QRVLZVRELH

MDNR MHGHQ ]H VZ\FK HOHPHQWyZ ]GROQRĞü UR]NUXV]HQLD U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL´^ 2UWH- JD]ZUDFDXZDJĊLĪWZRU]HQLXVLĊSU]HGPLRWXHVWHW\F]QHJRWRZDU]\V]\V]F]HJyO- Q\VWDQXF]XFLRZ\OHF]]D]QDF]DLĪQLHMHVWRQWRĪVDP\]SV\FKRORJLF]QLHSRMPR- ZDQ\PXF]XFLHPMDNRVWDQHP]DGRZROHQLDF]\MHJREUDNLHPUDGRĞFLąF]\VPXW- NLHP3RGZ\ĪV]HQLHOXEUR]ELFLHUHDOQHMVWUXNWXU\U]HF]\WZRU]\QRZąNRQVWUXN- FMĊOXESHZQąXF]XFLRZąVHQW\PHQWDOQąLQWHUSUHWDFMĊ+LV]SDĔVNL¿OR]RIXWRĪVD- PLD SU]HGPLRW HVWHW\F]Q\ ] SU]HGPLRWHP PHWDIRU\F]Q\P -DN SLV]H ÄPHWDIRUD

MHVWHOHPHQWDUQ\PSU]HGPLRWHPHVWHW\F]Q\PSLĊNQąNRPyUNą´^

6]WXNDMHVWZLĊFPHWDIRUąZNWyUHMZHGáXJ2UWHJLNU\MąVLĊQDMZLĊN- V]HPRĪOLZRĞFLF]áRZLHND-HMVNXWHF]QRĞüJUDQLF]\]PDJLąWRÄQDU]ĊG]LHWZR- U]HQLDNWyUH%yJSU]H]SRP\áNĊ]RVWDZLáZHZQĊWU]XF]áRZLHND´^7RIRUPDLQ- WHOHNWXDOQHMDNW\ZQRĞFLLRELHNWG]LĊNLQLHMRVLąJQLĊW\0HWDIRUDRGUHDOQLDÄĪ\MH

MDVQąĞZLDGRPRĞFLąQLHLGHQW\F]QRĞFL´^-HVWUHDOL]DFMąGHKXPDQL]DFML-HVWSU]H- NURF]HQLHPU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLLQDWXUDOQHMÄQRUPDOQHM´SHUVSHNW\Z\0HWDIRUDMHVW

ÄSU]HGáXĪHQLHPUĊNL´OXG]NLHJRXP\VáX-DNSLV]H2UWHJDÄMHVWPHWRGąLQWHOHNWX- DOQHJRG]LDáDQLDSR]ZDODMąFąQDPQDXFKZ\FHQLHL]UR]XPLHQLHWHJRFR]QDMGX- MHVLĊSR]DREUĊEHPQDV]\FKPRĪOLZRĞFLSRMĊFLRZ\FK´^)RUPąGHKXPDQL]DFML

V]WXNLMHVWWHĪ]PLDQDSHUVSHNW\Z\+LV]SDĔVNL¿OR]RI]DXZDĪDERZLHPLĪÄZ\- VWDUF]\RGZUyFLüKLHUDUFKLĊZDUWRĞFLLVWZRU]\üG]LHáRV]WXNLZNWyU\PGUREQH

Z\GDU]HQLD]Ī\FLDXND]DQH]RVWDQąQDSLHUZV]\PSODQLHLZPRQXPHQWDOQ\FK

Z\PLDUDFK´^=DELHJWHQ2UWHJDRNUHĞODMDNRÄSRGUHDOL]PPHWDIRU\´7RWHĪ]D- UyZQRQDGUHDOL]PPHWDIRU\MDNMHMSRGUHDOL]P]DVSRNDMDMąDUW\VW\F]QąSRWU]HEĊ

ÄXFLHF]NLRGU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL´

3RUIbidemV

 IbidemV

 IbidemV

 IdemDehumanizacja sztukiV

 IdemEsej o estetyce zamiast prologuV

 IdemDwie wielkie metafory>Z@Dehumanizacja sztukiV

 IdemDehumanizacja sztukiV

6]WXNDZXMĊFLX-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWD 

1DU]ĊG]LHP QRZHM V]WXNL MHVW ]DWHP Z\REUDĨQLD WZRU]ąFD ĞZLDW SU]HQRĞQL

6]WXNDPDZ\UDĪDüWRFRQLHZ\UDĪDOQHWRF]HJRQLHGDVLĊXFKZ\FLüZLQQ\VSR- VyE:Eseju o estetyce zamiast prologuF]\WDP\ÄV]WXNDMHVWQLHW\ONRDNW\ZQR- ĞFLąZ\UDĪDQLDF]HJRĞPRĪOLZHJRGRZ\UDĪHQLDDOHEDUG]LHMMHV]F]HWHJRFRQLH- Z\UDĪDOQHLLVWQLDáRZF]HĞQLHMMDNRU]HF]\ZLVWRĞü´^6]WXNDXU]HF]\ZLVWQLDZLĊF

LGHHXUHDOQLDLUUHDOQRĞüRELHNW\ZL]XMHLQDGDMH]LHPVNLNV]WDáWWHPXFRVXELHNW\Z- QHLLPPDQHQWQH1RZDV]WXND]ZUDFDVLĊNXPDORZDQLXVDPHMLGHLNXZáDVQ\PVX- ELHNW\ZQ\PZ\REUDĪHQLRP7ZRU]\QRZ\SU]HGPLRWHVWHW\F]Q\NWyU\SU]HNV]WDá- FDVLĊZZ\REUDĪHQLHSRMĊFLHLGHĊSU]HVWDMHE\üW\PF]\PMHVWÄDE\]PLHQLüVLĊ

ZFLHĔOXEVFKHPDWVLHELHVDPHJR´^3UDZG]LZ\PSU]HGPLRWHPHVWHW\F]Q\PMHVW

ZLĊFZHZQĊWU]QRĞüMDNRWDND-DN]DXZDĪD2UWHJDÄG]LHáRV]WXNLSRGREDVLĊ

QDP]HZ]JOĊGXQDWĊV]F]HJyOQąUR]NRV]NWyUąQD]\ZDP\HVWHW\F]QąSU]H]WRĪH

Z\GDMHVLĊQDPLĪXZLGDF]QLDZHZQĊWU]QRĞüU]HF]\LFKGRNRQXMąFąVLĊU]HF]\ZL- VWRĞü±ZREHFNWyUHMLQQHLQIRUPDFMH]HVIHU\QDXNLZ\GDMąVLĊ]Z\Ná\PLVFKHPDWD- PLGDZQ\PLDOX]MDPLFLHQLDPLLV\PERODPL´^3U]HGPLRWHVWHW\F]Q\VWDMHVLĊIH- nomenologicznym momentem ja RGELRUF\MHJRE\FLDLZLG]HQLD:LG]HQLHU]HF]\

SU]HNV]WDáFDVLĊZSU]HGPLRWSHUFHSFMLJG\E\FLHLDNW\ZQRĞüRGELRUF\XV\WXXMą

VLĊQLHMDNR]W\áXWHMU]HF]\LVWDPWąGSDWU]ąGRZHZQąWU]VLHELH-DNVWZLHUG]D2U- WHJDE\RJOąGDüU]HF]NWyUDÄRGUHDOQLDMąFVLĊSU]HNV]WDáFDVLĊZPRMąDNW\ZQRĞü

w moje ja´⁴⁰(VWHW\ND2UWHJLPDZLĊFFKDUDNWHUIHQRPHQRORJLF]Q\JG\ĪED]XMHQD

]DáRĪHQLXĪHSR]QDQLHSU]HGPLRWyZDUW\VW\F]Q\FKMHVWLQWXLF\MQHLFDáRĞFLRZH^ 3RVWXORZDQHSU]H]2UWHJĊRGUHDOQLHQLHV]WXNLMHVWZLĊFWUXGQH:\PDJDZ\- VLáNXLQWHOHNWXDOQHJRERURG]LSRPLHV]DQLHSRMĊü$UW\VWDWZRU]\WRFRQLHLVW- QLHMH]DF]\QDVLĊWDPÄJG]LHNRĔF]\F]áRZLHN´⁴²6\WXDFMĊWĊRSLVXMH2UWHJDQD

SU]\NáDG]LHSRHW\NWyU\ÄUR]V]HU]DĞZLDWGRGDMąFGRLVWQLHMąFHMU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL

QRZHNRQW\QHQW\Z\REUDĨQL´^+LV]SDĔVNL¿OR]RI]DZ\]ZROLFLHODSRH]MLSRGDá

0DOODUPpJR⁴⁴X]QDMąFJR]DÄSLHUZV]HJRF]áRZLHNDZ;,;ZLHNXNWyU\FKFLDá

E\üMHG\QLHSRHWą´⁴⁵2GU]XFDáQDWXUĊMHJRG]LHáDSR]EDZLRQHE\á\ÄOXG]NLHMIDX- Q\LÀRU\´Ä3RH]MLWHM±SLV]H2UWHJD±QLHWU]HEDE\áR©F]FLüªQLHE\áRZQLHMQLF

OXG]NLHJRD]DWHPQLHE\áRZQLHMWHĪQLF]SDWRVX-HĞOLPyZLVLĊZQLHMRNRELH- FLHWRMHVWWR©NRELHWDĪDGQDªMHĞOLELMHMDNDĞJRG]LQDWRMHVWWR©JRG]LQDQLHR]QD- F]RQDQDWDUF]\ª2GG]LDáXMąFSRSU]H]QHJDFMHZLHUV]0DOODUPpJRWáXPLZV]HO-

 IdemEsej o estetyce zamiast prologuV

 IbidemV

 IbidemV

40 IbidemV

=RE5*DMop. citV±

42-2UWHJD\*DVVHWDehumanizacja sztukiV

 Ibidem

446WpSKDQH0DOODUPp±±IUDQFXVNLSRHWDWHRUHW\NV]WXNLNU\W\NOLWHUDFNLZ\ELWQ\

UHSUH]HQWDQWG]LHZLĊWQDVWRZLHF]QHJRV\PEROL]PXNRQVWUXNWRUÄSRH]MLF]\VWHM´

45-2UWHJD\*DVVHWDehumanizacja sztukiV

 Agnieszka Skrobas

NLHRGELFLDU]HF]\ZLVWHJRĪ\FLDPDOXMHRQSRVWDFLHGRWHJRVWRSQLD©QLH]WHJR

ĞZLDWDªĪHVDPRLFKRJOąGDQLHMHVWF]\VWąUR]NRV]ą´

3RVWXORZDQD V]WXND JHQHUXMH WDNĪH QRZą ZUDĪOLZRĞü HVWHW\F]Qą RUD] NDWH- JRULĊQRZHJRRGELRUF\NWyU\ZLG]LW\ONRZ\REUDĪHQLHL¿NFMĊSU]\]DFKRZDQLX

PLQLPXP]DDQJDĪRZDQLDHPRFMRQDOQHJR6NXSLDXZDJĊQDVDP\PG]LHOHV]WX- NL-HJRZUDĪOLZRĞüHVWHW\F]QDQLHMHVWWRĪVDPD]OXG]NąJRWRZRĞFLąZF]XZDQLD

VLĊZUDGRĞFLLVPXWNLF]áRZLHND'XFKRZ\G\VWDQVSR]ZDODPXREVHUZRZDüQLH

]DĞSU]HĪ\ZDü-HJRSRVWDZDMHVWF]\VWRSHUFHSF\MQD:HGáXJ2UWHJLR]QDF]DWR

LĪÄXNU\W\WUDJLF]Q\VHQV]GDU]HQLDXP\NDMHJRXZDJLQDVWDZLRQHMZ\áąF]QLHQD

VWURQĊZL]XDOQąFDáHMVFHQ\±QDNRORU\ĞZLDWáDLFLHQLH´⁴⁶1RZ\RGELRUFDMHVW

Ä]DDQJDĪRZDQ\QLHSUDNW\F]QLH´-DNSLV]H2UWHJDÄ]UR]XPLHQLHF]\UR]NRV]RZD- QLHVLĊV]WXNąMHVWQRZ\PZ\P\ĞORQ\PVSRVREHPĪ\FLDSU]HNUHĞODMąF\PZV]HO- NąVSRQWDQLF]QRĞü1LHMHVWRQRSR]EDZLRQHXF]XüLQDPLĊWQRĞFLDOHQDOHĪąRQH

QDMZLGRF]QLHMGRLQQHMÀRU\SV\FKLF]QHMQLĪWDNWyUąSRUDVWD]Z\F]DMQ\NUDMREUD]

OXG]NLHJRĪ\FLD2ZHXOWUDSU]HGPLRW\⁴⁷ EXG]ąZ©VLHG]ąF\PZQDVªDUW\ĞFLHQD- PLĊWQRĞFLZWyUQHV]F]HJyOQHJRURG]DMXXF]XFLDHVWHW\F]QH´^3U]\MHPQRĞüHVWH- W\F]QDQLHMHVWZLĊFVWDQHPXP\VáX]DVDGQLF]RWRĪVDP\P]FRG]LHQQ\P]DFKRZD- QLHP2GELRUFDQRZHMV]WXNLVWRLQLHMDNR]ERNXSU]\SDWUXMąFVLĊÄZLG]ąFVDPR

ZLG]HQLH´MHVWRERMĊWQ\QDORV\OXG]NLHREVHUZXMHJUĊIRUPEDUZLFLHQL,QWH- UHVXMHJRVSRVyE]RUJDQL]RZDQLDGĨZLĊNyZZPX]\FHF]\F]\VWD¿NFMDZOLWHUD- WXU]H.RQWHPSOXMHHVWHW\F]QąFDáRĞü1LHDEVRUEXMHJRQDWRPLDVWVHQVRGELHUDQHM

VFHQ\MHMWUHĞü3U]\MHPQRĞüHVWHW\F]QDZHGáXJ2UWHJLZLQQDE\üĞZLDGRPąSU]\- MHPQRĞFLąJG\ĪZV]\VWNRFRPDE\üGXFKRZHDQLHPHFKDQLF]QHPDĞZLDGRP\

charakter zrozumienia i motywacji⁴⁹6WąGWHĪRUWHJLDĔVNDNU\W\NDV]WXNLWUDG\F\M- QHMNWyUDGRVWDUF]DSU]HĪ\FLDHVWHW\F]QHJRQLHPDMąFHJRQLFZVSyOQHJR]SUDZG]L- ZąUR]NRV]ąHVWHW\F]QąDEĊGąFHJRMHG\QLHÄEODGąSU]\MHPQRĞFLą´XF]XFLHPVáD- E\PLSá\WNLPQLHGDMąF\PZUDĪHQLDEOLVNLHJRNRQWDNWX]SLĊNQ\PG]LHáHP-DN

VWZLHUG]D6\OZHVWHU-DEáRĔVNLÄQRZDV]WXNDMHVWZLĊFZHGáXJ2UWHJLSHZQHJRUR- G]DMXJUąWZRU]RQąSU]H]DUW\VWyZJUąQLHPDMąFąQLFZVSyOQHJR]HVIHUąOXG]NLFK

HPRFML*UDWDWZRU]\RF]\ZLĞFLHSHZQHZDUWRĞFLHVWHW\F]QHDOHGRVWU]HFMHVąMH- G\QLHZVWDQLHOXG]LHZ\EUDQLLV]F]HJyOQLHZUDĪOLZL±DU\VWRNUDFMDGXFKRZD´⁵⁰

:DĪQ\P V\PSWRPHP V]WXNL ZVSyáF]HVQHM U\VHP QRZHM ZUDĪOLZRĞFL HVWH- W\F]QHMMHVWMHMDWUDQVFHQGHQWQRĞüNWyUąDXWRUVSURZDG]DGR]PLDQ\

miejsca sztuki w hierarchii ludzkich]DLQWHUHVRZDĔ±V]WXNDQLHMHVWMXĪG]LDáDOQR- ĞFLąÄZLHONLHJRIRUPDWX´QLHREFLąĪDMHMSDWHW\F]QH]DGDQLHRFDOHQLDOXG]NRĞFL

46 IbidemV

47  Ä8OWUDL]P´ WR MHGQD ] QDMEDUG]LHM FHOQ\FK QD]Z MDNą PRĪQD XNXü GOD RNUHĞOHQLD QRZHM

ZUDĪOLZRĞFL

 IbidemV

49 IbidemV

50-2UWHJD\*DVVHWDehumanizacja sztuki:DUV]DZDUHF6-DEáRĔVNLPanorama my- ĞOLÄ3HUVSHNW\Z\´QUV

6]WXNDZXMĊFLX-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWD 

MDNWRVLĊG]LDáRZ;,;ZLHNXJG\UHOLJLDVWUDFLáDVZH]QDF]HQLHDQDXNDXOHJáD

UHODW\ZL]DFMLÄ6]WXNDE\áDWUDQVFHQGHQWQD±SLV]H2UWHJD±ZV]ODFKHWQ\PWHJR

VáRZD]QDF]HQLX±SRSLHUZV]HGODWHJRĪH]DMPRZDáDVLĊQDMSRZDĪQLHMV]\PLSUR- EOHPDPLOXG]NRĞFLDSRGUXJLHGODWHJRĪHVDPDZVRELHUHSUH]HQWRZDáDGU]HPLą- FąZOXG]NRĞFLSRWHQFMDOQąVLáĊQDGDMąFąJDWXQNRZLOXG]NLHPXJRGQRĞüLXVSUD- ZLHGOLZLDMąFą MHJR LVWQLHQLH´^ 6]WXND SR]EDZLRQD OXG]NLHJR SDWRVX WUDFL ZLĊF

MDNąNROZLHN WUDQVFHQGHQWQRĞü ± VWDMH VLĊ SR SURVWX V]WXNą EH] ĪDGQ\FK LQQ\FK

Z\ĪV]\FK DVSLUDFML⁵² 'OD V]WXNL QRZHM QDMZ\ĪV]ą NDWHJRULą HVWHW\F]Qą VWDáD VLĊ

LURQLD1RZDV]WXNDNSLVDPD]VLHELHV]XNDQDWFKQLHQLDZĞPLHV]QRĞFLLGRZ- FLSDFK2GU]XFDZV]HONLSDWRV-DNSLV]H2UWHJDÄWNZLąFDZV]WXFHPDJLF]QDPRF

QLJG\QLHREMDZLáDVLĊWDNZ\UDĨQLHMDNZGUZLQLH]VDPHMVLHELH´^1RZDV]WX- NDSUDJQLHE\ü]DEDZą-DN]DXZDĪD0DULDQ*RONDÄV]WXNDGąĪ\GRZ\VWU]HJDQLD

VLĊIDáV]X±F]\OLX]QDQLDLGHL]DWRF]\PZáDĞFLZLHVąVXELHNW\ZQLHVWZRU]RQ\- PLZ]RUDPLLSURSR]\FMDPL:\UDĪDWRVLĊZV]WXFHSRGNUHĞOHQLHPVXELHNW\ZQR- ĞFLLMHMLUUHDOQRĞFL´⁵⁴$WUDQVFHQGHQWQRĞüV]WXNLZLąĪHVLĊ]MHMEUDNLHP]QDF]HQLD

3RVWXODW\QRZHMV]WXNLF]\QLąMąQLH]UR]XPLDáąGODZV]\VWNLFK2GELyUV]WX- NLVWDMHVLĊ]DWHPGRGDWNRZ\PNU\WHULXPSRODU\]DFMLVSRáHF]HĔVWZDNWyUHG]LH- OLVLĊQDW\FKNWyU]\UR]XPLHMąQRZąV]WXNĊLQDW\FKNWyU]\MHMQLHUR]XPLHMą]H

Z]JOĊGXQDEUDNÄRJyOQROXG]NLHJRFKDUDNWHUX´-DNSLV]HÄQLHMHVWWRV]WXNDGOD

OXG]LZRJyOHOHF]MHG\QLHGODSHZQHMJUXS\OXG]LNWyU]\E\üPRĪHQLHVąOHS- VLDOH]FDáąSHZQRĞFLąVąLQQL´⁵⁵2ZDÄVSHFMDOQLHZ\EUDQDPQLHMV]RĞü´⁵⁶ bu- G]LREXU]HQLHZĞUyGPDVVSRZRGRZDQHQLHPRĪQRĞFLą]UR]XPLHQLDG]LHáDV]WXNL

Ä0DV\±SLV]H±SU]\Z\NáHGRGRPLQDFMLZHZV]\VWNLFKG]LHG]LQDFKĪ\FLDF]X- MąVLĊ]DJURĪRQHZVZ\FK©SUDZDFKF]áRZLHNDªSU]H]QRZąV]WXNĊEĊGąFąGRPH- QąXSU]\ZLOHMRZDQHMDU\VWRNUDFMLGXFKDLGREUHJRVPDNX´⁵⁷6WąGQLHSRSXODUQRĞü

QRZHMV]WXNL3U]HFLĊWQ\F]áRZLHNSUDJQLHV]WXNLSURVWHMRG]ZLHUFLHGODMąFHMU]H- F]\ZLVWRĞüNWyUąVLĊRWDF]DERáDWZRMHVWPXMą]UR]XPLHüLQLHZ\PDJDRQDRG

QLHJR ĪDGQHJR Z\VLáNX -HJR FDáD DNW\ZQRĞü XP\VáRZD MHVW VNXSLRQD QD UHDOL- VW\F]Q\PSU]HGPLRFLHĪ\FLDFRG]LHQQHJR±OXG]LDFKLQDPLĊWQRĞFLDFK2UWHJDSL- V]HLĪÄV]WXNąMHVWGODQLFKFDáDJDPDĞURGNyZ]DSHZQLDMąFDLPNRQWDNW]LQWH- UHVXMąF\PLOXG]NLPLVSUDZDPL:áDĞFLZHIRUP\DUW\VW\F]QHWDNLHMDN¿NFMDF]\

IDQWD]MDWROHURZDQHVąW\ONRRW\OHRLOHQLHSU]HV]NDG]DMąZĞOHG]HQLXOXG]NLFK

SRVWDFLLLFKORVyZ´^

-2UWHJD\*DVVHWDehumanizacja sztukiV

52 IbidemV

 IbidemV

540*RONDOdczytywanie sztukiV

55-2UWHJD\*DVVHWDehumanizacja sztukiV

56 IbidemV

57 Ibidem

 IbidemV

 Agnieszka Skrobas

1RZDV]WXNDMHVW]DWHPV]WXNąGODPQLHMV]RĞFLHOLW\GODDUW\VWyZSU]H]NWy- U\FKKLV]SDĔVNLP\ĞOLFLHOUR]XPLHMHGQDNQLHW\ONRWZRU]ąF\FKV]WXNĊOHF]WDN- ĪHW\FKNWyU]\]GROQLVąGRVWU]HFMHMF]\VWRDUW\VW\F]QHZDUWRĞFLÄQRV]ąF\FKDU- W\VWĊZVZHMGXV]\´

'\VWDQVGRU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLNRQFHQWUDFMDQDSU]\MHPQRĞFLHVWHW\F]QHMDXWR- WHOLF]QRĞüV]WXNL$UW\VWDMHVWW\ONRDUW\VWąQLH]DĞÄSU]HZRGQLNLHPGXV]´6]WXND

WRLURQLDL]DEDZD=GHKXPDQL]RZDQDV]WXNDSU]HFKRG]LRGSU]HĪ\ZDQLDNXRE- VHUZDFML3RVWXODW\QRZHMV]WXNL]DNáDGDMąZLĊFLQZHUVMĊSURFHVXHVWHW\F]QH- JR3URZDG]ąZNLHUXQNXF]\VWHMIRUP\NWyUDVWDMHVLĊQDMZDĪQLHMV]DZDNFLHZ\- ]ZDODQLDRGSRVSROLWRĞFLLXFLHF]NLRGGUDPDW\]PXĪ\FLD2UWHJDQLHRGSRZLDGD

QDS\WDQLHF]\F]\VWDV]WXNDMHVWPRĪOLZD]ZUDFDMHGQDNXZDJĊQDWHQGHQFMĊGR

ÄSXU\¿NDFMLV]WXNLSURZDG]ąFHMGRVWRSQLRZHMHOLPLQDFMLHOHPHQWyZOXG]NLFK´⁵⁹

2UWHJDSRPLMDZLĊFNZHVWLĊLFKUHDOL]DFMLJG\ĪXZDĪDLĪQRZDV]WXNDQLHVWZR- U]\áDMHV]F]HQLFQDSUDZGĊJRGQHJRXZDJL3RGNUHĞODMHGQDNLĪZVSyáF]HVQ\DU- W\VWDSRVWDZLáVRELHZLHONLH]DGDQLHSUDJQLHERZLHPWZRU]\ü]QLF]HJRRGU]X- FDMąFSU]\WáDF]DMąF\JRFLĊĪDUWUDG\FML

RESUMEN

(OWH[WRWLWXODGREl arte según José Ortega y Gasset nos acerca al SHQVDPLHQWRHVWpWLFRGH2U- WHJD\*DVVHW/DWHRUtDGHODUWHGHOSHQVDGRUHVSDxROVHIXQGDPHQWDVREUHODEDVHGHVXSHQVDPLHQ- WR¿ORVy¿FRJHQHUDO\VXWHRUtDGHODFXOWXUD3RUHVRODDXWRUDDSHODDODFRQFHSFLyQGHODFXOWXUDGH

2UWHJD6XHOLWLVPR\VX¿ORVRItDGHODYLGDVRQXQDEDVHGHVXGH¿QLFLyQGHODUWH'HVFULEHODSR- VWXUDGHO¿OyVRIRDQWHODWUDGLFLyQ\VXVSRVWXODGRVUHODFLRQDGRVFRQHOQXHYRDUWHODGHVKXPDQL- ]DFLyQGHODUWHHOUHFKD]RHQHODUWHGHODVIRUPDVTXHVRQODVLPiJHQHVGHODYLGDODWHQGHQ- FLDGHTXHODREUDGHDUWHVHDVRORREUDGHDUWHHOWUDWDPLHQWRGHODUWHFRPRHOMXHJR\QDGDPiV

ODSRVWXUDSULQFLSDOPHQWHLUyQLFDHOUHFKD]RGHORIDOVRODIDOWDGHVLJQL¿FDGRVGHFDUiF- WHUWUDQVFHQGHQWDO

Palabras claves¿ORVRItDHVSDxRODHVWpWLFDDUWHGHVKXPDQL]DFLyQGHODUWHDWUDQVFHQGHQFLD

SUMMARY

The article The Art According to José Ortega y Gasset makes more clear and understandable 2UWHJD\*DVVHW¶VDHVWKHWLFWKRXJKW7KHDUWWKHRU\RIWKH6SDQLVKWKLQNHUGHULYHVIURPWKHJHQHUDO

SKLORVRSKLFDODQGFXOWXUDOH[SHUWWKRXJKW7KXVWKHDXWKRUTXRWHVWKH6SDQLVKWKLQNHU¶VLGHDRIFXOWX- UHKLVHOLWLVPDQGKLVOLIH¶VSKLORVRSK\WKDWGH¿QHWKHGH¿QLWLRQRIDUWDFFRUGLQJWR-2UWHJD\*DV- VHW7KHDXWKRURIWKLVDUWLFOHRXWOLQHVWKH6SDQLVKWKLQNHU¶VDWWLWXGHWRZDUGVWKHWUDGLWLRQDQGWKHSR- VWXODWHVRIWKHQHZDUWGHKXPDQL]DWLRQHVFDSLVPIURPWKHIRUPVWKDWKDYHVRPHWKLQJLQFRP- PRQZLWKWKHUHDOLW\VWULYLQJWRWKHDUWZRUNWREHDSXUHDUWZRUNWUHDWLQJRIDUWDVQRWKLQJPRUH

EXWDPXVHPHQWDQDWWLWXGHRQDQLURQLFEDVLVJXDUGLQJDJDLQVWDQ\IDOVHKRRGDQGVFUXSXOR- XVPDNLQJRIDQDUWZRUNDVZHOODVODFNRIDWUDQVFHQGHQWDOPHDQLQJ

Keywords6SDQLVKSKLORVRSK\DHVWKHWLFVDUWGHKXPDQL]DWLRQRIDUWXQWUDQVFHQGHQF\

59 IbidemV

6]WXNDZXMĊFLX-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWD 

675(6=&=(1,(

Tekst 6]WXNDZXMĊFLX-RVp2UWHJL\*DVVHWDSU]\EOLĪDP\ĞOHVWHW\F]Qą2UWHJL\*DVVHWD7HR- ULD V]WXNL KLV]SDĔVNLHJR P\ĞOLFLHOD Z\UDVWD ] RJyOQHM P\ĞOL ¿OR]R¿F]QHM L NXOWXUR]QDZF]HM WR- WHĪDXWRUNDSU]\WDF]DNRQFHSFMĊNXOWXU\KLV]SDĔVNLHJRP\ĞOLFLHODMHJRHOLWDU\]PL¿OR]R¿ĊĪ\FLD

ZNWyUHZSLVXMHVLĊGH¿QLFMDV]WXNL-2UWHJL\*DVVHWD1DNUHĞODVWRVXQHNKLV]SDĔVNLHJRP\ĞOLFLH- ODGRWUDG\FMLRUD]SRVWXODW\QRZHMV]WXNLWDNLHMDNGHKXPDQL]DFMDXQLNDQLHIRUPPDMąF\FK

VZHRGELFLHZĪ\FLXVSRZRGRZDQLHE\G]LHáRV]WXNLE\áRZ\áąF]QLHG]LHáHPV]WXNLWUDNWR- ZDQLHV]WXNLMDNR]DEDZ\LQLF]HJRZLĊFHMSRVWDZD]]DVDG\LURQLF]QDZ\VWU]HJDQLHVLĊIDáV]X

LVNUXSXODWQDUHDOL]DFMDG]LHáDRUD]EUDNWUDQVFHQGHQWQHJR]QDF]HQLD

6áRZD NOXF]RZH ¿OR]R¿D KLV]SDĔVND HVWHW\ND V]WXND GHKXPDQL]DFMD V]WXNL DWUDQVFHQ- GHQWQRĞü