Filozoficzny i metodologiczny fundament koncepcji protofizyki Jana Czerniawskiego

81,9(56,7$7,60$5,$(&85,(6.à2'2:6.$

/8%/,1±32/21,$

92/;;;9 6(&7,2, 2010

32'67$:2:(7(=<35272),=<.,

-DQ&]HUQLDZVNLVNRĔF]\áQDMSLHUZVWXGLD]¿]\NLDSyĨQLHM]¿OR]R¿L7R

SRGZyMQH SU]\JRWRZDQLH ZLGDü ZH ZV]\VWNLFK MHJR SXEOLNDFMDFK 3RF]ąWNRZR

LQWHUHVRZDáVLĊLQWHUSUHWDF\MQ\PLSUREOHPDPL¿]\NL]ZáDV]F]DWHRULLZ]JOĊGQR- ĞFL -XĪ ZWHG\ XMDZQLá FHFK\ SU]\V]áHJR G\V\GHQWD LQWHOHNWXDOQHJR JG\ ]DVWD- QDZLDá VLĊ F]\ X]DVDGQLRQH E\á\ UHZROXF\MQH ]PLDQ\ Z\REUDĪHĔ GRW\F]ąF\FK

F]DVX L SU]HVWU]HQL ZSURZDG]RQH SU]H] ¿]\NĊ UHODW\ZLVW\F]Qą

 3R]QDá ZyZ- F]DV Z\SUDFRZDQą SU]H] +HQGULND$ /RUHQW]D G\QDPLF]Qą LQWHUSUHWDFMĊ WHRULL

Z]JOĊGQRĞFL NWyUD Z\MDĞQLDáD UHODW\ZLVW\F]QH HIHNW\ G\ODWDFML F]DVX NRQWUDN- FMLRGOHJáRĞFLLSU]\URVWXPDV\MDNRVNXWHNUXFKXZ]JOĊGHPHWHUX

3RU]XFLáMHG- QDN±MDNVLĊRND]DáRW\ONRQDMDNLĞF]DV±SUREOHPDW\NĊRQWRORJLLQDU]HF]PH- WRGRORJLLQDXNNWyUHMSRĞZLĊFLá]DUyZQRSUDFĊPDJLVWHUVNąMDNLGRNWRUVNą3R- ZUyFLáGREDGDĔRQWRORJLF]Q\FK]DVSUDZąUHL]PXNWyU\X]QDá]DNRQFHSFMĊWUDI-

13RU3U]HVąG\ZQDXFHF]\OLGODF]HJRQLHUR]XPLHP\IL]\NLZVSyáF]HVQHMÄ&]áRZLHNLĝZLD- WRSRJOąG´QUV±3U]HVWU]HĔLF]DVZIL]\FHQLHUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHMLZV]F]HJyOQHMWHRULL

Z]JOĊGQRĞFLÄ.ZDUWDOQLN)LOR]RILF]Q\´WQUV±-DN]UR]XPLHüV]F]HJyOQąWHR- ULĊZ]JOĊGQRĞFLÄ3U]HJOąG)LOR]RILF]Q\´QUV±7HRULDZ]JOĊGQRĞFLDXSá\ZF]DVX

Ä)LOR]RILD1DXNL´WQUV±

2 3RU 'ZLH LQWHUSUHWDFMH WHRULL Z]JOĊGQRĞFL Ä=DJDGQLHQLD 1DXNR]QDZVWZD´  W 

V±What is and what is not essential in Lorentz’s relativity>Z@0%DURQH)6HOOHULHGV

)URQWLHUVRI)XQGDPHQWDO3K\VLFV3OHQXP3UHVV1HZ<RUNV±ĥEHU6WlEH8KUHQ

XQG5HODWLYLWlW>Z@)6HOOHUL-%UDQGHV-&]HUQLDZVNL8+R\HU.:RKOUDEHDie Einstein’sche XQGORUHQW]LDQLVFKH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGHUVSH]LHOOHQXQGDOOJHPHLQHQ5HODWLYLWlWVWKHRULH95,.DUOV- EDGV±

)LOR]R¿F]Q\LPHWRGRORJLF]Q\IXQGDPHQWNRQFHSFML

SURWR¿]\NL-DQD&]HUQLDZVNLHJR

.$=,0,(5=-2'.2:6.,

3KLORVRSKLFDODQG0HWKRGRORJLFDO%DVLVRI-DQ&]HUQLDZVNL¶V3URWRSK\VLFV&RQFHSWLRQV

QąRQWRORJLF]QLHLPRĪOLZąGRREURQ\SU]HGUR]PDLW\PL]DU]XWDPL5HL]PMHG- QDNSURZDG]LGREH]SRĞUHGQLHJRNRQÀLNWX]SU]\MĊWąZ¿]\FHUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHM

LQWHUSUHWDFMąWDNSRGVWDZRZ\FKSRMĊüMDNSROHHOHNWURPDJQHW\F]QHIDODHOHNWUR- PDJQHW\F]QDHQHUJLDIRWRQĞZLDWáD]GDU]HQLHSURFHVF]WHURZ\PLDURZDF]DVR- SU]HVWU]HĔħUyGáHPWHJRNRQÀLNWXE\áRRGU]XFHQLHSU]H]$OEHUWD(LQVWHLQDLVWQLH- QLDHWHUX&]HUQLDZVNLXPRFQLáVZyMVFHSW\F\]PGRW\F]ąF\SU]\MĊWHMLQWHUSUHWD- FML¿]\NLUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHMJG\GRZLHG]LDáVLĊRNU\W\F]QHMZREHFWHRULLZ]JOĊG- QRĞFLNRQFHSFMLSURWR¿]\NL+XJR'LQJOHUDSU]HGVWDZLFLHODW]Z¿]\NLDU\MVNLHM

NRQFHSFMLUR]ZLMDQHMSyĨQLHMSU]H]3DXOD/RUHQ]HQD3URWR¿]\NDSR]ZROLáD&]HU- QLDZVNLHPXVWZRU]\üVSyMQąMHJR]GDQLHPLQWHUSUHWDFMĊSRGVWDZ¿]\NLUHODW\- ZLVW\F]QHMNWyUDMHVWDOWHUQDW\ZąGODSRZV]HFKQLHSU]\MPRZDQHMSU]H]¿]\NyZ

L¿OR]RIyZ¿]\NL

3U]HGVWDZLRQDSU]H]HĔNRQFHSFMDPDFKDUDNWHURQWRORJLF]Q\GRW\F]\RQWR- ORJLL¿]\NLUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHMDOHZ\VWĊSXMHZQLHMEDUG]RZDĪQ\LZ\UDĨQ\HOH- PHQWPHWRGRORJLF]Q\DQDZHWPHWRGRORJLF]QRHSLVWHPRORJLF]Q\

6WDQGDUGHP ;;ZLHF]QHM ¿OR]R¿L QDXNL E\áR Z]RUHP QHRSR]\W\ZLVWyZ

G]LHOHQLH]GDĔSUHWHQGXMąF\FKGRRSLVXU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLQD]GDQLDQDXNRZHLPH- WD¿]\F]QH=DVWDQDZLDQRVLĊQDGVHQVRZQRĞFLąW\FKGUXJLFKQDGZ]DMHPQąUH- ODFMąMHGQ\FKGRGUXJLFKDSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPQDGW\PMDNMHRGVLHELHRGG]LHOLü

&]HUQLDZVNLQDPLHMVFHWHJRGZXSRG]LDáXSURSRQXMHWUyMSRG]LDáPLĊG]\¿]\Ną

LPHWD¿]\NąXPLHV]F]DSURWR¿]\NĊ:MHGQ\P]DUW\NXáyZZ\PLHQLDVHQVyZ

VáRZDÄSURWR¿]\ND´

DOHVDPRGZRáXMHVLĊW\ONRGRGZyFK

:SLHUZV]\P]QD- F]HQLXSURWR¿]\NDMHVWG]LHG]LQąEDGDĔGRW\F]ąF\FKRSHUDF\MQHJRVHQVXSRGVWD- ZRZ\FKSRMĊü¿]\F]Q\FKSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPF]DVXSU]HVWU]HQLLUXFKX:GUX- JLP ]QDF]HQLX SURWR¿]\ND MHVW SURJUDPHP ¿OR]R¿F]Q\P SUyEą NRQVWUXNW\ZL- VW\F]QHJR XJUXQWRZDQLD ¿]\NL FR MHVW F]ĊĞFLą SURJUDPX V]NRá\ HUODQJHĔVNLHM

&]HUQLDZVNLUR]ZLMDSURWR¿]\NĊZSLHUZV]\P]QDF]HQLXDOHGRVWU]HJDĪHMHJR

XMĊFLHPDVSRURZVSyOQHJR]SRGHMĞFLHP¿OR]RIyZ]HV]NRá\HUODQJHĔVNLHM

3URWR¿]\ND ZHGáXJ &]HUQLDZVNLHJR SR]ZDOD XVXQąü VSU]HF]QRĞü REUD]X

U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLMDNLVLĊ±MHJR]GDQLHP±Z\áDQLD]¿]\NLUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHM]SHZ- Q\PL±MDNZLHORNURWQLHPyZL±IXQGDPHQWDOQ\PLLQWXLFMDPL-DNLHWRLQWXLFMH"

2MHGQHMMXĪZVSRPQLDáHP±WRUHL]PNWyU\XQLHPRĪOLZLDGRVáRZQHUR]XPLHQLH

WHJRĪH]GDU]HQLDQLH]GDU]DMąVLĊOHF]DF]DVRZRLVWQLHMąSURFHV\QLHG]LHMąVLĊ

OHF]SRGREQLHDF]DVRZRUR]SRĞFLHUDMąVLĊZF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQLĪHĞZLDWMHVWF]WH- URZ\PLDURZąF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQLąLWG,QQHSRGVWDZRZHLQWXLFMHMDNLH&]HUQLDZVNL

SU]HFLZVWDZLDUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHPXREUD]RZLĞZLDWDWR±MDNWZLHUG]L±]DXZDĪRQD

SU]H]'LQJOHUDVSU]HF]QRĞü(LQVWHLQRZVNLHMUHÀHNVMLQDGVWRVXQNLHPSRGVWDZR-

33RU-&]HUQLDZVNL3U]HV]áRĞüLSHUVSHNW\Z\SURWRIL]\NL>Z@-=RQUHG 3RJUDQLF]DQDXNL

3URWRQDXND±SDUDQDXND±SVHXGRQDXND /XEOLQ:\GDZQLFWZR.8/V±>±@

43RU-&]HUQLDZVNL5XFK3U]HVWU]HĔ&]DV3URWRIL]\F]QHLPHWDIL]\F]QHDVSHNW\SRGVWDZIL- zyki relatywistycznej.UDNyZ:\GDZQLFWZR8QLZHUV\WHWX-DJLHOORĔVNLHJRV

Z\FKSRMĊü¿]\F]Q\FKGRSUDNW\NLHNVSHU\PHQWDOQHM]]DVDGąUDFMLGRVWDWHF]QHM

OXE]DVDGąQLH]DOHĪQRĞFLSU]HELHJX]MDZLVNRGF]DVXLSU]HVWU]HQL'LQJOHUPLDá

]DXZDĪ\üĪHZ\QLNLHNVSHU\PHQWyZSRSLHUDMąF\FKWHRULĊZ]JOĊGQRĞFLVąZQLH- XVXZDOQ\ VSRVyE X]DOHĪQLRQH RG ]DáRĪHĔ GRW\F]ąF\FK ]DFKRZDQLD VLĊ VWDQGDU- GyZPHWU\F]Q\FKZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQ\FKZSRPLDUDFK3RQLHZDĪWHRULDZ]JOĊGQR- ĞFLVDPDWDNLH]DáRĪHQLD]DZLHUDWRGRNRQ\ZDQDZMHMUDPDFKLQWHUSUHWDFMDSR- PLDUyZWZRU]\EáĊGQHNRáR

'LQJOHUVIRUPXáRZDá]DVDGĊSRU]ąGNXSUDJPDW\F]QHJRLQQDQD]ZDPHWR- G\F]QHJRZHGáXJNWyUHMLVWQLHMHKLHUDUFKLDWHRULLQDXNRZ\FKLWHRULDQDXNRZD

VWRMąFD Z\ĪHM Z WHM KLHUDUFKLL QLH PRĪH SURZDG]Lü GR NRU\JRZDQLD WHRULL EDU- G]LHMRGQLHMSRGVWDZRZHMWHMNWyUą]DNáDGDZSXQNFLHZ\MĞFLD:]ZLą]NX]W\P

PDP\ ZHGáXJ &]HUQLDZVNLHJR ]D /RUHQ]HQHP NROHMQH SRJZDáFHQLH IXQGD- PHQWDOQHMLQWXLFMLSU]H]¿]\NĊUHODW\ZLVW\F]QąJG\ĪV]F]HJyOQDWHRULDZ]JOĊG- QRĞFLNRU\JXMHPLQNLQHPDW\F]QąF]ĊĞüPHFKDQLNLDNLQHPDW\NDMHVWEDUG]LHM

SRGVWDZRZD3RGREQLHQLHWUDIQDMHVWLQWHUSUHWDFMDRJyOQHMWHRULLZ]JOĊGQRĞFLMDNR

UHZL]MLJHRPHWULLNWyUDMHVWQDZHWMHV]F]HEDUG]LHMSRGVWDZRZDQLĪNLQHPDW\ND

'ODWHJRPHWU\NDF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQLQLHPRĪHRNUHĞODüJHRPHWULLĞZLDWDOHF]MHVWMH- G\QLHZLHONRĞFLąSR]ZDODMąFąRNUHĞOLüZSá\ZUXFKXLJUDZLWDFMLQDZ\PLDU\FLDá

RUD]SU]HELHJSURFHVyZ¿]\F]Q\FK

/RUHQ]HQX]QDáĪHNLQHPDW\NDUD]HP]EDUG]LHMRGQLHMSRGVWDZRZąJHRPH- WULąLFKURQRPHWULąQDOHĪ\ZáDĞQLHGRSURWR¿]\NL7DNUR]XPLDQDSURWR¿]\NDMHVW

RG¿]\NLEDUG]LHMSRGVWDZRZDJG\ĪEH]QLHMSRPLDU\ZLHONRĞFL¿]\F]Q\FKQLH

PDMąRELHNW\ZQHJRVHQVX3URWR¿]\NDIRUPXáXMHLGHDOQHQRUP\GRNWyU\FKVSHá- QLHQLDSRZLQQ\]PLHU]DüSRPLDU\-DNRWDNDPDFKDUDNWHUDSULRU\F]Q\

7HRULD Z]JOĊGQRĞFL SRPLDU\ RGQRVL GR Z]RUFyZ MHGQRVWHN GáXJRĞFL L F]D- VXRNWyU\FKZLDGRPRĪHSRGOHJDMą±SLV]H&]HUQLDZVNL±GHIRUPXMąF\PZSá\- ZRPUXFKXLJUDZLWDFML3URWR¿]\NDQDWRPLDVWSURSRQXMHRGQLHVLHQLHSRPLDUyZ

GRLGHDOQ\FKZ]RUFyZPHWU\F]Q\FKQLHSRGOHJDMąF\FKWDNLPZSá\ZRP7\OHĪH

WDNLFKZ]RUFyZQLHPRĪQDZ\SURGXNRZDü-DNLZLĊFVHQVPDPyZLHQLHRSUR- WR¿]\FH"&]HUQLDZVNLZ\MDĞQLáWRWDNVNRUR¿]\F]QHZ]RUFHPHWU\F]QHSRGOH- JDMąGHIRUPXMąFHPXZSá\ZRZLUXFKXLJUDZLWDFMLWRREUD]]MDZLVNSU]\URG\MHVW

W\PVDP\PUyZQLHĪ]GHIRUPRZDQ\$OHGHIRUPDFMDMHVW]DZV]HGHIRUPDFMąF]H- JRĞ2GHIRUPDFMLREUD]XSU]\URG\PRĪQDVHQVRZQLHPyZLüW\ONRZWHG\MHĞOLLVW- QLHMHMDNLĞREUD]QLH]GHIRUPRZDQ\7DNLREUD]PXVLE\üRNUHĞORQ\ZRGQLHVLHQLX

GRQLH]GHIRUPRZDQ\FKZ]RUFyZPHWU\F]Q\FKF]\OLWDNLMDNLSU]HGVWDZLDSUR- WR¿]\ND7DNLQLH]GHIRUPRZDQ\REUD]QLHMHVWDOWHUQDW\ZąRSLVX¿]\NDOQHJRDOH

MHJRX]XSHáQLHQLHP

&]HUQLDZVNL]GHF\GRZDQLHRGG]LHOD¿]\NĊSURWR¿]\NĊLPHWD¿]\NĊ&KD- UDNWHU\VW\F]Q\ GOD WHM SLHUZV]HM MHVW ]DND] ZSURZDG]DQLD SRMĊü SR]EDZLRQ\FK

MHGQR]QDF]QHJR RSHUDF\MQHJR VHQVX 3URWR¿]\ND GRSXV]F]D MXĪ ZSURZDG]DQLH

WDNLFKSRMĊüDOHW\PUyĪQLVLĊRGPHWD¿]\NLZNWyUHMPLHV]F]ąVLĊSUREOHP\QLH-

UR]VWU]\JDOQHQDXNRZRĪHSRMĊFLDSURWR¿]\F]QHQLHPDMąFVHQVXRSHUDF\MQHJR

PDMą VHQV TXDVLRSHUDF\MQ\ SROHJDMąF\ QD W\P ĪH Vą RNUHĞORQH SU]H] Z\LPD- JLQRZDQHRSHUDFMHSRPLDURZH]DSRPRFąQLH¿]\F]Q\FKLGHDOQ\FKSU]\U]ąGyZ

SRPLDURZ\FKQLHSRGOHJDMąF\FKG]LDáDQLXVLáXQLZHUVDOQ\FK&]HUQLDZVNLXZDĪD

MHGQRF]HĞQLHĪHWHQTXDVLRSHUDF\MQ\VHQVPRĪHVWDüVLĊĞFLVá\PVHQVHPRSHUD- F\MQ\PMHĞOLSRMDZLVLĊZSU]\V]áRĞFLMDNDĞRGSRZLHGQLDWHRULD

:SXEOLNDFMDFK&]HUQLDZVNLHJR]QDMGXMHP\PQyVWZRV]F]HJyáRZ\FKDQD- OL]GRW\F]ąF\FKUXFKXSU]HVWU]HQLLF]DVXZNWyU\FK$XWRUVWDUDVLĊSRND]DüVHQ- VRZQRĞüUR]ZDĪDĔSURWR¿]\F]Q\FK3U]\NáDGHPPRĪHE\üSRMĊFLHJHRPHWULLWáD

NWyUąQDOHĪ\RGUyĪQLüRGJHRPHWULL¿]\F]QHM7ĊGUXJąRNUHĞODVLĊ]DSRPRFą¿- ]\F]Q\FKVNUyFRQ\FKVWDQGDUGyZSLHUZV]ą±]DSRPRFąVWDQGDUGyZLGHDOQ\FK

*HRPHWULD¿]\F]QDPDEH]SRĞUHGQLVHQVRSHUDF\MQ\*HRPHWULDWáDRND]XMHVLĊ

F]\VWRLGHDOQDP\ĞOQDJG\ĪLGHDOQ\QLHSRGOHJDMąF\RGG]LDá\ZDQLRPVWDQGDUG

MHGQRVWNLGáXJRĞFLPDFKDUDNWHUF]\VWRNRQFHSWXDOQ\QLH]ZLą]DQ\EH]SRĞUHGQLR

]PRĪOLZ\PLSRPLDUDPL]DSRPRFąUHDOQ\FKSU]\U]ąGyZ



1DMEDUG]LHMNRQWURZHUV\MQHZ\SRZLHG]L&]HUQLDZVNLHJRGRW\F]ąMHGQDNHWH- UX:SUDZG]LHQLHGDVLĊHPSLU\F]QLHZ\NU\üUXFKXZ]JOĊGHPHWHUXDOHRGU]XFH- QLHLVWQLHQLDHWHUXX]QDáRQ]DSU\ZDWQHXSU]HG]HQLH(LQVWHLQDRUD]]DXSRUF]\ZLH

SRGWU]\P\ZDQ\SU]HVąG

=DQHJRZDQLHSU]H](LQVWHLQDLVWQLHQLDHWHUXRGHJUDáR

MHG\QLHUROĊKHXU\VW\F]QąQLHE\áRNRQLHF]QH&]HUQLDZVNLXZDĪDLQDF]HMQLĪ¿- ]\F\UHODW\ZLVW\F]QLĪHS\WDQLHRWRGODF]HJRZ\VWĊSXMąWDNLHHIHNW\MDNVNUyFH- QLHGáXJRĞFLMHVWVHQVRZQHRGSRZLHG]LQDPRĪQDXG]LHOLüQDJUXQFLHSURWR¿]\- NLNWyUDXĪ\ZDSRMĊFLDQLH¿]\F]QHMJHRPHWULLWáDLSRMĊFLDUXFKXZ]JOĊGHPHWH- UX&]HUQLDZVNLSUyEXMHZLĊF]SRMĊFLHPHWHUX]URELüFRĞSRGREQHJRGRWHJRFR

]K\OHPRU¿]PHP]URELOLZF]DVDFKQRZRĪ\WQ\FKDU\VWRWHOLF\LWRPLĞFL:QD- XFHVWDURĪ\WQHMK\OHPRU¿]PU\ZDOL]RZDá]NRQFHSFMąDWRPLVW\F]QąLSRNRQDáMą

*G\DWRPL]PRGURG]LáVLĊL]RVWDá]DDNFHSWRZDQ\ZQDXFHQRZRĪ\WQHMK\OHPRU-

¿]PXQLHX]QDQR]DEáĊGQ\SRJOąGQLHSRU]XFRQRQDĞPLHWQLNXGDZQ\FKNRQ- FHSFMLDOHSU]HVXQLĊWRJRSR]DQDXNĊZG]LHG]LQĊ¿OR]R¿LGRNáDGQLHMSU]HVX- QĊá\VLĊJUDQLFHWHJRFRQDXNRZHSR]RVWDZLDMąFNRQFHSFMĊK\OHPRU¿]PXSR]D

]DNUHVHPQDXNL

3U]\MĊWD SHUVSHNW\ZD SURWR¿]\F]QD SR]ZROLáD &]HUQLDZVNLHPX X]DVDGQLDü

SRJOąGĪHQLHQDOHĪ\UH]\JQRZDü]Z\REUDĪHQLDÄXSá\ZX´F]DVXDQL]SU]HNRQD- QLDĪHĞZLDWMDNWHJRFKFąUHLĞFLMHVWG]LHG]LQąU]HF]\UR]FLąJáąW\ONRSU]HVWU]HQ- QLHDQLHUR]FLąJáąF]DVRZRG]LHG]LQą]GDU]HĔOXESURFHVyZ6WDUDVLĊUyZQLHĪ

UHKDELOLWRZDü SRMĊFLH JOREDOQHJR DEVROXWQHJR F]DVX NWyU\ RGUyĪQLá RG ¿]\F]- Q\FKF]DVyZZ]JOĊGQ\FKRNUHĞORQ\FKZUyĪQ\FKXNáDGDFKRGQLHVLHQLDLRGF]D- VyZ ZáDVQ\FK SRV]F]HJyOQ\FK FLDá 8ZDĪD ĪH PRĪQD XĪ\ZDü SRMĊFLD DEVROXW-

53RUWDPĪHV±

63RU-&]HUQLDZVNL5HZROXFMDUHODW\ZLVW\F]QDDRQWRORJLDIL]\NLÄ5RF]QLNL)LOR]RILF]QH´

WQUV

QHM(XNOLGHVRZHMJHRPHWULLSU]HVWU]HQLPRPHQWDOQ\FKE\OHMHMQLHXWRĪVDPLDü

] ¿]\F]Qą JHRPHWULą SU]HVWU]HQL Z]JOĊGQ\FK Z UyĪQ\FK XNáDGDFK RGQLHVLHQLD

:V]\VWNLHWHDEVROXWQRĞFLXPLHV]F]DZZDUVWZLHSURWR¿]\F]QHMOXEV]HU]HMPH- WD¿]\F]QHMEDUG]LHMSRGVWDZRZHMQLĪZDUVWZD¿]\NDOQHJRRSLVXU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL

:WHMEDUG]LHMIXQGDPHQWDOQHMZDUVWZLHQDGDOSRVLDGDMąDEVROXWQ\VHQVVWRVXQ- NLGáXJRĞFLFLDáLF]DVXWUZDQLDSURFHVyZ7DNLREUD]U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL±]GDQLHP

&]HUQLDZVNLHJR ± MHVW LQDF]HM QLĪ REUD] Z\QLNDMąF\ ] ¿]\NL UHODW\ZLVW\F]QHM

]JRGQ\]REUD]HP]GURZRUR]VąGNRZ\PXĞFLĞODJRLX]XSHáQLD

8:$*,.5<7<&=1(

.RQFHSFMDSURWR¿]\NLMDNRG]LHG]LQ\PLĊG]\¿]\NąLPHWD¿]\NąMHVWEáĊG- QD]ZLHOXSRZRGyZWDNĪH]]DVDGQLF]HJR±Z\Sá\ZD]QLHZáDĞFLZHJRUR]XPLH- QLD QDXNL L SURFHVyZ SR]QDZF]\FK 2 MHGQ\P ĨUyGOH NRQFHSFML GUD &]HUQLDZ- VNLHJRMXĪZVSRPQLDáHP±WRUHL]PNWyU\VWRLZ]DVDGQLF]HMVSU]HF]QRĞFL]MDNL- PLNROZLHNZąWNDPLHZHQW\VW\F]Q\PLWDNSRSXODUQ\PLZLQWHUSUHWDFMDFKWHRULL

Z]JOĊGQRĞFL2ND]XMHVLĊMHGQDNĪHLVWQLHMHEDUG]LHM]DVDGQLF]HĨUyGáRSRJOąGyZ

SUH]HQWRZDQ\FKZSXEOLNDFMDFK&]HUQLDZVNLHJR2QVDPQD]\ZDMHLQGXNFMRQL- ]PHP1D]ZDWD]SRZRGyZMHVWQLHGREUDE\RNUHĞODüQLąWRFRPDPQDP\ĞOL

3R SLHUZV]H XĪ\ZDQD MHVW SU]H]$XWRUD MDNR SRJOąG ĪH Z QDXFHL Z Ī\- FLXZQLRVNRZDQLDLQGXNF\MQHVąQLHGR]DVWąSLHQLDÄQLHPRĪQDĪ\üEH]LQGXN- FML´

7R]QDF]QLHV]HUV]\VHQVQLĪWHQNWyUHJRVLĊXĪ\ZDZ¿OR]R¿LQDXNL:WHM

RVWDWQLHMLQGXNFMRQL]PLDQW\LQGXNFMRQL]PWRSU]HFLZQHVWDQRZLVNDZVSUDZLH

MDNSRZVWDMąWHRULHQDXNRZH

3R]DW\P$XWRUGRZQLRVNRZDĔLQGXNF\MQ\FK]D- OLF]\á ZV]\VWNLH ZQLRVNRZDQLD QLHGHGXNF\MQH Z W\P WDNĪH QLHNWyUH UHGXNF\M- QH:SUDZG]LHNDĪG\PDSUDZRXĪ\ZDüSRMĊüGRZROQLHMHĞOLMHGH¿QLXMHDOHMD

ZROĊWHUPLQXÄLQGXNFMRQL]P´ZUR]XPLHQLX$XWRUDQLHXĪ\ZDüE\QLHZSURZD- G]Dü]DPLHV]DQLDSRMĊFLRZHJR

3RGUXJLHĨUyGáHPNRQFHSFMLSURWR¿]\NLQLHMHVWVDPRRJyOQHSU]HNRQDQLH

ĪHPRĪQDVWRVRZDüSURFHGXU\LQGXNF\MQH$XWRU]DMąáEDUG]LHMV]F]HJyáRZHVWD- QRZLVNR8]QDáĪHZQDXFHPDP\GRF]\QLHQLD]KLHUDUFKLąWHRULLLWZLHUG]HĔ

7ZLHUG]HQLD]QDMGXMąFHVLĊQLĪHMZWHMKLHUDUFKLLVWDQRZLąX]DVDGQLHQLHGODWZLHU- G]HĔ]QDMGXMąF\FKVLĊZ\ĪHM:ĞUyGW\FKZV]\VWNLFKSR]LRPyZX]DVDGQLDQLDLVW- QLHMHSR]LRPQDMQLĪV]\VWDQRZLąF\ED]ĊHPSLU\F]QąGODQDXNL$XWRUZLHĪH]GD- QLDREVHUZDF\MQHNWyUHWUDG\F\MQLHX]QDZDQR]DIXQGDPHQWQDXNLPDMąFKDUDN-

73RU-&]HUQLDZVNL&]\PRĪQDĪ\üEH]LQGXNFML"Ä3U]HJOąG)LOR]RILF]Q\´WQU

V±

83RUQS-*LHG\PLQIndukcjonizm i antyindukcjonizm>Z@73DZáRZVNLUHGLogiczna teo- ULDQDXNL:\EyUDUW\NXáyZ:DUV]DZD3:1V±RUD].-RGNRZVNL-DNSRZVWDMąWHR- ULHQDXNRZH"Ä$NFHQW´QUV±WHQĪHMetodologiczne aspekty kontrowersji ewo- OXFMRQL]PNUHDFMRQL]P5HDOL]P5DFMRQDOQRĞü5HODW\ZL]P/XEOLQ:\G80&6V±

WHUWHRUHW\F]Q\F]\OL]DNáDGDMąSHZQHRJyOQHLDEVWUDNF\MQHWZLHUG]HQLDRUD]KL- SRWH]\SU]H]SHZLHQF]DV]DMPRZDáVLĊPHWRGRORJLąLMHJRSXEOLNDFMHĞZLDGF]ą

ĪHWURFKĊF]\WDá3RSSHUDDOERUDF]HMVá\V]DáRQLP'ODWHJRSURSRQXMHMHV]F]H

QLĪV]\SR]LRPQLĪ]GDQLDREVHUZDF\MQH-HVWWRSR]LRPIHQRPHQyZGDQ\FKQD- RF]QRĞFLRZRRNWyU\FKPyZLVLĊZIHQRPHQRORJLL&]HUQLDZVNLDNFHSWXMHZW\P

PRPHQFLHSU]HNRQDQLHV]NRá\IHQRPHQRORJLF]QHMĪHLVWQLHMHG]LHG]LQDZLHG]\

EH]]DáRĪHQLRZHMRSDUWHMQDEH]SRĞUHGQLPRJOąG]LHIHQRPHQyZ:LHG]DQDW\P

SRGVWDZRZ\PSR]LRPLHPDPLHüFKDUDNWHUQLHKLSRWHW\F]Q\LPRĪHVWDQRZLüDE- VROXWQ\SRF]ąWHNZSURFHGXUDFKX]DVDGQLDQLD$XWRUMDNZLGDüOXELUyĪQHDEVR- OXWQRĞFLQLHW\ONRZ¿]\FHDOHLZ¿OR]R¿L



7R ĨUyGáR NRQFHSFML SURWR¿]\NL &]HUQLDZVNLHJR OHSLHM ZLĊF QD]\ZDü IXQ- GDPHQWDOL]PHPQLĪLQGXNFMRQL]PHP3RQLHZDĪWHQIXQGDPHQWDOL]PQLHNRQLHF]- QLHGRW\F]\SRZVWDZDQLDWHRULLOHF]SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPLFKX]DVDGQLDQLDPRĪQD

JRQD]ZDüIXQGDPHQWDOL]PHPMXVW\¿NDFMRQLVW\F]Q\P3U]\EOLĪV]\PSU]\MU]HQLX

RND]XMHVLĊĪHUHL]PMHVWNRQVHNZHQFMąWDNUR]XPLDQHJRIXQGDPHQWDOL]PXJG\Ī

$XWRUVWZLHUG]LáĪHSU]\MPXMHUHL]PSRQLHZDĪNDĪG\SU]HGPLRWSU]HGVWDZLHQLD

QDRF]QHJRMHVWU]HF]ą



3U]HGVWDZLRQDZSXEOLNDFMDFK&]HUQLDZVNLHJRNRQFHSFMDIXQGDPHQWDOL]PX

MXVW\¿NDFMRQLVW\F]QHJRMHVWZDGOLZDZZLHOXDVSHNWDFKFRSRZRGXMHĪHNRQFHS- FMDSURWR¿]\NLWUDFLUDFMĊE\WX

:QDXFHQLHLVWQLHMHKLHUDUFKLDWZLHUG]HĔLSR]LRPyZX]DVDGQLHĔ : QDXFH QLH LVWQLHMH QLF WDNLHJR MDN MHGQR]QDF]QD KLHUDUFKLD WZLHUG]HĔ

:SUDZG]LHXF]HQLX]DVDGQLDMąMHGQHWZLHUG]HQLD]DSRPRFąLQQ\FKDOH]GDQLD

NWyUHE\OLE\VNáRQQLX]QDü]DZF]HĞQLHMV]HQS]GDQLDREVHUZDF\MQHZ\PDJD- MąGRVZHJRX]DVDGQLHQLDSRZRáDQLDVLĊQDSUDZG]LZRĞüVNRPSOLNRZDQ\FKWHRULL

LKLSRWH]=ZUDFDáRQDWRXZDJĊZLHOXDXWRUyZMDNNRQZHQFMRQDOLĞFLDZOLWHUD- WXU]HSROVNLHMMHV]F]HSU]HGZRMQąQS(GZDUG3R]QDĔVNLL$OHNVDQGHU:XQGKH- LOHU

3RZRMQLHWHPDWWHQE\áRPDZLDQ\SU]H]3RSSHUDLSU]HGVWDZLFLHOLXKLVWR- U\F]QLRQHM¿OR]R¿LQDXNL

:QDXFHZLĊNV]RĞü]GDĔPRĪHZ\VWĊSRZDüZGZyFK

URODFKZSHZQ\FKSU]\SDGNDFKMDNRSU]HVáDQNDZLQQ\FKMDNRZQLRVHN



93RU-&]HUQLDZVNL)HQRPHQRORJLF]QHUR]ZLą]DQLHSUREOHPXED]\HPSLU\F]QHMÄ.ZDUWDO- QLN)LOR]RILF]Q\´WQUV±

103RU&]HUQLDZVNL5XFK3U]HVWU]HĔ&]DVV

11(3R]QDĔVNL$:XQGKHLOHU3RMĊFLHSUDZG\QDWHUHQLHIL]\NL>Z@3DZáRZVNLUHGdz.

cyt., V  RU\JLQDá Z\GDQ\ Z  U$XWRU]\ F\WXMą WDP DUW\NXá &DUQDSD ] ODW ±

ZNWyU\PWZLHUG]LáĪHQLHPDDEVROXWQ\FK]GDĔSRF]ąWNRZ\FKZEXGRZLHQDXNL

123RUQS.53RSSHU'URJDGRZLHG]\'RP\Vá\LUHIXWDFMH:DUV]DZD:\GDZQLFWZR1D- XNRZH3:1V±

133RU3R]QDĔVNL:XQGKHLOHUdz. cytV±

&]HUQLDZVNLVWZLHUG]LáĪHMHĞOLQLHSU]\MPLHP\MHGQR]QDF]QHMKLHUDUFKLLWHR- ULLLWZLHUG]HĔWRZSDGQLHP\ZEáĊGQHNRáRLZWDNLHEáĊGQHNRáRZSDGOL¿]\- F\UHODW\ZLVW\F]QL

5]HF]\ZLĞFLHPDRQUDFMĊĪHEáĊGQHNRáRZX]DVDGQLDQLX

WZLHUG]HĔMHVWZQDXFH]MDZLVNLHPUHDOQ\P$OHF]\QDJDQQ\P"*G\E\LGHDáHP

WHRULL QDXNRZHM E\áR SU]HGVWDZLHQLH MHM Z SRVWDFL V\VWHPX ]DNVMRPDW\]RZDQH- JRRGSRZLHGĨE\áDE\SR]\W\ZQD3UREOHPZW\PĪHEDUG]RQLHZLHOHZGRGDW- NXPQLHMZDĪQ\FKRQLHZLHONLP]DNUHVLHWHRULLQDXNRZ\FK]\VNDáRWDNąSRVWDü

1DMZ\UDĨQLHMVFKHPDWHP]ELRUXWZLHUG]HĔQDXNRZ\FKQLHMHVWGUDELQDF]\SLUD- PLGDDOHVLDWNDZNWyUHMNDĪGH]GDQLHMHVWPRFQLHMOXEVáDELHMSRZLą]DQH]LQQ\- PL]GDQLDPL:UH]XOWDFLHSRMDZLDMąVLĊV\WXDFMH]DEURQLRQHQDWHUHQLHV\VWHPX

GHGXNF\MQHJR±ZĞUyG]GDĔX]DVDGQLDMąF\FKGDQHWZLHUG]HQLH]QDMGXMHVLĊUyZ- QLHĪLVDPRX]DVDGQLDQHWZLHUG]HQLH(GGLQJWRQMHV]F]HZUX]QDáĪHWDNLH

SRVWĊSRZDQLHZ¿]\FHQLHW\ONRMHVWXSUDZQLRQHDOHFRZLĊFHMVWDQRZLMHGQR

]]DVDGQLF]\FKQDU]ĊG]LQDV]HJRSR]QDQLD

:SyĨQLHMV]HM¿OR]R¿LQDXNLRGNU\- WRZLHOHSU]\SDGNyZJG\GRX]DVDGQLHQLDMDNLHJRĞWZLHUG]HQLDZ\PDJDQHMHVW

]DáRĪHQLHSUDZG]LZRĞFLFDáHMWHRULLNWyUHMWRWZLHUG]HQLHMHVWF]ĊĞFLą

,QLHGR- W\F]\WRW\ONR¿]\NL:\VWDUF]\SU]\SRPQLHüSUDNW\NĊSDOHRQWRORJyZNWyU]\QD

SRGVWDZLHVNDPLHQLDáRĞFLXVWDODMąZLHNZDUVWZZNWyU\FKMH]QDOH]LRQRDOHLQD

SRGVWDZLHZDUVWZXVWDODMąZLHN]QDMGRZDQ\FKZQLFKVNDPLHQLDáRĞFL

7HQKR- OLVW\F]Q\FKDUDNWHUWHRULLQDXNRZ\FKVNáRQLáQDZHW+HQU\HJR(O\¶D.\EXUJDGR

Z\VXQLĊFLDU\]\NRZQHMWH]\ĪHZV]\VWNLHRJyOQHSUDZG\ZW\PWHRULHQDXNRZH

PDMąDQDOLW\F]Q\FKDUDNWHU

=GDQLHP.\EXUJDSRGREQHSRJOąG\JáRVLOL:LOIULG

6HOODUV3DXO.)H\HUDEHQG7KRPDV6.XKQL'RQDOG+RFNQH\

+XJRQD'LQJOHUD]DVDGDSRU]ąGNXSUDJPDW\F]QHJRZQDXFHQLHRERZLą]XMH

]HZ]JOĊGXQDKROLVW\F]Q\FKDUDNWHUWHRULLQDXNRZ\FK$OHSU]HNRQDQLDRKLHUDU- FKLF]QRĞFLX]DVDGQLHĔQLHGDVLĊXWU]\PDüWDNĪH]LQQHJRSRZRGX

1LHLVWQLHMHQLHKLSRWHW\F]Q\IXQGDPHQWZLHG]\

&]HUQLDZVNLSRZWDU]DLDNFHSWXMHSRJOąG\IHQRPHQRORJyZGRW\F]ąFHW]Z

PHWRG\ IHQRPHQRORJLF]QHM 8]QDá ĪH SHUFHSFMĊ ]P\VáRZą PRĪQD SRWUDNWRZDü

143RU&]HUQLDZVNL5XFK3U]HVWU]HĔ&]DVV

15((GGLQJWRQ7KH1DWXUHRIWKH3K\VLFDO:RUOGVF\W]D3R]QDĔVNLL:XQG- KHLOHUG]F\WV

161S-'6QHHG7KH/RJLFDO6WUXFWXUHRI0DWKHPDWLFDO3K\VLFV'5HLGHO'RUGUHFKW

V±WZLHUG]LĪHZDUWRĞFLPDV\LVLá\QLHPRĪQD]PLHU]\üEH]ZF]HĞQLHMV]HJR]DáRĪHQLDGUX- JLHM]DVDG\PHFKDQLNL1HZWRQD

173RU76.HPSA Fresh Look at the Fossil RecordÄ1HZ6FLHQWLVW´'HFHPEHUYRO

V1(OGUHGJH7LPH)UDPHV7KH5HWKLQNLQJRI'DUZLQLDQ(YROXWLRQDQGWKH7KHRU\RI

3XQFWXDWHG(TXLOLEULD1HZ<RUN6LPRQDQG6FKXVWHUV

183RU+(.\EXUJ-UAll Acceptable Generalizations Are AnalyticÄ$PHULFDQ3KLORVRSKLFDO

4XDUWHUO\´YROV±

MDNRV]F]HJyOQ\SU]\SDGHNSU]HGVWDZLHQLDQDRF]QHJRDRGSRZLDGDMąFHMHM]MDZLVNR

MDNRV]F]HJyOQ\SU]\SDGHNIHQRPHQXGDQHJRZQDRF]QRĞFLHPSLU\F]QHM:VNXWHN

UHGXNFMLIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHM]MDZLVNR]RVWDMHXMĊWHMDNRF]\VW\IHQRPHQNWyU\PRĪ- QDEDGDüDEVWUDKXMąFRGNZHVWLLMHJRUHDOQHJRLVWQLHQLD3RQLHZDĪRJOąGGRVWDUF]D

W\ONRVWZLHUG]HĔMHGQRVWNRZ\FKDE\X]\VNDüZLHG]ĊRJyOQąQDWHPDWIHQRPHQyZ

QDOHĪ\GRNRQDüW]ZZJOąGXZLVWRWĊ2VLąJDVLĊWRSU]H]X]PLHQQLDQLHUyĪQ\FKFHFK

EDGDQHJRIHQRPHQXFRSR]ZDODWRUR]SR]QDüNWyUH]W\FKFHFKQLHPRJąXOHF]PLD- QLHEH]Z\NURF]HQLDSU]H]IHQRPHQSR]D]DNUHVGDQHJRSRMĊFLD&HFK\WHRND]XMą

VLĊZWHQVSRVyELVWRWQH]HZ]JOĊGXQDWRSRMĊFLH

:\QLNDPLRVLąJQLĊW\PLQDSáDV]- F]\ĨQLHIHQRPHQyZ&]HUQLDZVNLSURSRQXMHX]DVDGQLDü]GDQLDREVHUZDF\MQHD]D

LFKSRPRFąWZLHUG]HQLDEDUG]LHMXWHRUHW\]RZDQHDĪGRQDMEDUG]LHMDEVWUDNF\MQ\FK

3RV]XNLZDQLHQLHKLSRWHW\F]QHJRIXQGDPHQWXZLHG]\ZZ\QLNDFKPHWRG\IHQR- PHQRORJLF]QHMPDMHGQDNWDNąVDPąZDUWRĞüMDNRZDPHWRGD&]\OLĪDGQą0HWRGĊ

IHQRPHQRORJLF]QąVWRVXMHVLĊXĪ\ZDMąFMĊ]\NDSRWRF]QHJR)HQRPHQRORJLDSRZVWD- áD]DQLPMĊ]\NR]QDZF\L¿OR]RIRZLHMĊ]\NDRGNU\OLRUD]SU]HDQDOL]RZDOLZSá\ZMĊ- ]\NDQDVSRVyEZLG]HQLDĞZLDWD

-Ċ]\NSRWRF]Q\MHVWRJyOQąWHRULąU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL

,VWQLHMą MDN VLĊ Z\GDMH  ]DVDGQLF]R UyĪQH SRMPRZDQLD MĊ]\ND L MHJR IXQN- FMLZHSLVWHPRORJLL3LHUZV]HWUDNWXMHMĊ]\NMDNRQHXWUDOQHQDU]ĊG]LHRSLVXĞZLDWD

LNRPXQLNRZDQLDVLĊQHXWUDOQHZW\PVHQVLHĪHQLHNV]WDáWXMHWUHĞFLRZRWHJRRSLVX

F]\SU]HND]XLQIRUPDF\MQHJR:HGáXJGUXJLHJRUR]XPLHQLDMĊ]\NDMHVWRQQLHW\O- NRQDU]ĊG]LHPDOHWDNĪHEDUG]RRJyOQ\PXMĊFLHPU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL3U]\WDNLPSRM- PRZDQLXUyĪQHMĊ]\NLPRJąSUHVXSRQRZDüRGPLHQQHRQWRORJLHF]\V]HU]HMLGHROR- JLH-Ċ]\NMHVWZLĊFZSHZQ\PVHQVLHWHRULąU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLSU]\MPRZDQą]UHJX- á\EH]UHÀHNV\MQLH



*G\E\&]HUQLDZVNLGáXĪHM]DMPRZDáVLĊPHWRGRORJLąQDWUD¿áE\]SHZQRĞFLą

LUR]ZDĪ\áWDNLHSRJOąG\MDNLHZ\UDĪDáQS3DXO)H\HUDEHQGÄ2GQDMZF]HĞQLHMV]\FK

ODWXF]\P\VLĊUHDJRZDüQDV\WXDFMHSU]\SRPRF\RGSRZLHGQLFKMĊ]\NRZ\FKEąGĨ

LQQ\FKSRVXQLĊü3URFHGXU\QDXF]DQLDNV]WDáWXMą]MDZLVNDLXVWDQDZLDMąQRZ\LFK

]ZLą]HN]HVáRZDPLWDNĪHRVWDWHF]QLH]MDZLVNDZ\GDMąVLĊPyZLüVDPH]DVLHELH

EH]WRZDU]\VWZD]HZQĊWU]QHMZLHG]\3RSURVWXVąRQHW\PFRLPSU]\SLVXMą]ZLą- ]DQH]QLPLVWZLHUG]HQLD-Ċ]\NMDNLPÄPyZLą´]QDMGXMHVLĊRF]\ZLĞFLHSRGZSá\- ZHPSU]HNRQDĔZF]HĞQLHMV]\FKSRNROHĔ±SU]HNRQDĔXWU]\P\ZDQ\FKWDNGáXJRĪH

QLHZ\GDMąVLĊMXĪRQHRGG]LHOQ\PL]DVDGDPLOHF]ZFKRG]ąZ]DNUHVFRG]LHQQHJR

G\VNXUVXLSRRSLVDQ\PWUHQLQJXZ\GDMąVLĊZ\áDQLDü]VDP\FKU]HF]\´



193RU&]HUQLDZVNL5XFK3U]HVWU]HĔ&]DVV±

20 3RU . -RGNRZVNL Wspólnoty uczonych, paradygmaty i rewolucje naukowe, Realizm.

5DFMRQDOQRĞü5HODW\ZL]PW:\G80&6/XEOLQV±

213.)H\HUDEHQG3UREOHPVRI(PSLULFLVP3DUW,,>Z@5&RORGQ\HG The Nature and

:MDNLPVHQVLHMĊ]\NL]DNáDGDMąRQWRORJLĊZMDNLPVHQVLHVąWHRULąU]HF]\ZL- VWRĞFL"1DSHZQRQLHPRĪHWXFKRG]LüREDQDOQ\VHQVĪHZMĊ]\NXIRUPXáXMHVLĊ

WZLHUG]HQLDRU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLRW\PFRLVWQLHMHRIXQNFMRQRZDQLXĞZLDWDLWG:WD- NLFK]GDQLDFKUyZQLHĪIRUPXáXMHVLĊRQWRORJLĊDOHNDĪG\U]HF]\ZLVW\MĊ]\NSRVLDGD

IXQNWRUQHJDFMLSR]ZDODMąF\SU]HNV]WDáFLü]GDQLDREXGRZLHÄ$LVWQLHMH´OXEÄ$MHVW

%´Z]GDQLDÄQLHMHVWWDNĪH$LVWQLHMH´OXEÄQLHMHVWWDNĪH$MHVW%´:W\PVD- P\PMĊ]\NXPRĪQDZLĊFZ\UDĪDüRGPLHQQHRQWRORJLH$OHWHUyĪQHRQWRORJLHZ\- UDĪDQHZW\PVDP\PMĊ]\NXPRJąE\üW\ONRF]ĊĞFLRZRRGPLHQQ\PLRQWRORJLDPL

F]ĊĞFLRZRF]\OLWDNLPLNWyUHSRVLDGDMąZVSyOQHMąGURZVSyOQąSRGVWDZRZąRQWR- ORJLĊ=QDF]\WRĪHQDZHW]GDQLDUyĪQLąFHVLĊW\ONRIXQNWRUHPQHJDFMLMHĞOLW\ONRVą

Z\UDĪRQHZW\PVDP\PMĊ]\NX]DNáDGDMąWĊVDPąSRGVWDZRZąRQWRORJLĊ&KRG]L

RWDNLHV\WXDFMHMDNWDĪHVWUXNWXUDSRGPLRWRZRRU]HF]QLNRZD]GDĔZLĊNV]RĞFLMĊ- ]\NyZHXURSHMVNLFKQDU]XFDRQWRORJLĊVXEVWDQFMDOQRSU]\SDGáRĞFLRZąMDNZ¿OR- ]R¿L$U\VWRWHOHVD

2ZSá\ZLHMĊ]\NDQDSRVWU]HJDQLHĞZLDWDPyZLOLWDF\SRVWSRS- SHURZVF\¿OR]RIRZLHQDXNLMDN+DQVRQ.XKQF]\)H\HUDEHQG$OHĪDGQHJR]QLFK

&]HUQLDZVNLQLHF\WXMHLSUDZGRSRGREQLHQLH]QD1LHF\WXMHQDZHW3RSSHUDFKR- FLDĪ]MHJRSRJOąGDPLSROHPL]XMH

)HQRPHQRORJLDSRZVWDáD]DQLPWDF\MĊ]\NR]QDZF\MDN6DSLUF]\:KRUIXMDZ- QLOLĞZLDWXVZRMHRGNU\FLDLSU]HP\ĞOHQLDQDWHPDWZSá\ZXMĊ]\NDQDVSRVyESR- VWU]HJDQLDĞZLDWD)HQRPHQRORJRZLHPRJOLZLĊFSU]H]SDUĊG]LHVLąWNyZODWV]F]H- U]HZLHU]\üĪHPRĪOLZDMHVWEH]]DáRĪHQLRZDDQDOL]DIHQRPHQyZFKRFLDĪMHVWRQD

SU]HSURZDG]DQD]DZV]HZMDNLPĞMĊ]\NX$OHZ;;,ZWHQSRJOąGMHVWSU]HVWDU]Dá\

3HUFHSFMD]P\VáRZDMHVWNRĔFRZ\PZ\QLNLHPVNRPSOLNRZDQHM

DNW\ZQRĞFLPy]JX

3ROHJDQLH QD IHQRPHQRORJLF]QHM DQDOL]LH SU]HGVWDZLHĔ QDRF]Q\FK PLDáR- E\VHQVJG\E\ZV]\VF\ZWHMVDPHMV\WXDFMLPLHOLWHVDPHSU]HGVWDZLHQLDQDRF]- QH,VWQLHMHVSRURIDNWyZNWyUHMHGQDNWHPXSU]HF]ą2VRE\QLHZLGRPHRGXURG]H- QLDNWyU\PSU]\ZUyFRQRZ]URNSU]H]ZLHOHW\JRGQLQLHZLG]ąSHZQ\FKIUDJPHQ- WyZ ĞZLDWD R NWyU\FK LVWQLHQLX ZF]HĞQLHM QLH ZLHG]LDá\ *UHJRU\ Z NVLąĪFH Oko i mózgSU]HGVWDZLáU\VXQNLDXWREXVXNWyU\PSRUXV]DáDVLĊRVREDNWyUHMSU]\ZUy- FRQRZ]URN3U]H]ZLHOHW\JRGQLDQDZHWPLHVLĊF\QDU\VXQNDFKW\FKEUDNRZDáR

SU]RGXDXWREXVX]NWyU\PMDNRQLHZLGRPDQLHPLDáDZF]HĞQLHMNRQWDNWX7ĊF]ĊĞü

DXWREXVXSDFMHQWPXVLDáVLĊGRSLHURQDXF]\üZLG]LHü

1LHMHVWZLĊFWDNĪHZV]\-

)XQFWLRQRI6FLHQWLILF7KHRU\Ä8QLYHUVLW\RI3LWWVEXUJK6HULHVLQWKH3KLORVRSK\RI6FLHQFH´YRO

3LWWVEXUJK8QLYHUVLW\RI3LWWVEXUJK3UHVVV

223RU%/HH:KRUI-Ċ]\NP\ĞOLU]HF]\ZLVWRĞü%LEOLRWHND0\ĞOL:VSyáF]HVQHM:DUV]DZD

3DĔVWZRZ\,QVW\WXW:\GDZQLF]\ V

232WUXGQRĞFLDFKOXG]LNWyU]\QLHQDXF]\OLVLĊZáDĞFLZLHXĪ\ZDüRND±PLDQRZLFLHW\FKNWy- U]\XURG]LOLVLĊQLHZLGRPLLNWyU\PSU]\ZUyFRQRSyĨQLHMZ]URN±SRU5/*UHJRU\Oko i mózg.

3V\FKRORJLDZLG]HQLD%LEOLRWHND3UREOHPyZ:DUV]DZDV±

VF\OXG]LHQLH]DOHĪQLHRGXĪ\ZDQHJRMĊ]\NDZ\FKRZDQLDZLHG]\LV]HURNRUR- ]XPLDQHMNXOWXU\ZMDNLHMĪ\MąZLG]ąWRVDPRQDSR]LRPLHIHQRPHQyZ,GHQW\F]- QDGODZV]\VWNLFKOXG]LSáDV]F]\]QDIHQRPHQyZMHVWPLWHP

=QDQH MHVW WDNĪH ]MDZLVNR ĞOHSRZ]URF]QRĞFL 7R U]DGNLH ]MDZLVNR SROHJD

QDW\PĪHF]áRZLHNGRWNQLĊW\FKRUREąQLHZLG]LRWDF]DMąFHJRJRĞZLDWD±W]Q

Py]JQLHWZRU]\REUD]XZL]XDOQHJRDOHMHGQDNRULHQWXMHVLĊZSRáRĪHQLXSU]HG- PLRWyZZRNyáVLHELHFKRüVRELHWHJRQLHXĞZLDGDPLD3U]HGPLRW\WHPRĪHQD- ZHWVSUDZQLHZ\PLMDü&KRU\PRĪHWHĪUHDJRZDüQDHPRFMRQDOQ\Z\UD]OXG]- NLFKWZDU]\3U]\F]\QąĞOHSRZ]URF]QRĞFLMHVWXV]NRG]HQLHW]ZSLHUZV]RU]ĊGR- ZHMNRU\Z]URNRZHMREV]DUXZW\OQHMSRW\OLF]QHMF]ĊĞFLPy]JXSRGF]DVJG\

RF]\ Vą FDáNRZLFLH ]GURZH

 : LQWHUQHFLH PRĪQD REHMU]Hü ¿OP MDN QLHZLGR- P\FKRU\QDĞOHSRZ]URF]QRĞüLG]LHNRU\WDU]HP]DJUDFRQ\PSXGáDPLNU]HVáDPL

LLQQ\PLELXURZ\PLVSU]ĊWDPL1LHZLHRQĪHRWDF]DJRW\OHSU]HGPLRWyZPLPR

WHJRMHGQDNZV]\VWNLHMHRPLMD

=MDZLVNRWRGRZRG]LĪHREUD]ZL]XDOQ\NWy- UHJRMHVWHĞP\ĞZLDGRPLMHVWGRSLHURNRĔFRZ\PHWDSHPREUyENLGDQ\FKSU]H]

Py]JNWyU\EH]QLHJRSRWUD¿WHĪZ]JOĊGQLHVSUDZQLH]DU]ąG]DüUXFKHPPLĊĞQL

SRGF]DV SRUXV]DQLD VLĊ F]áRZLHND L WR EH] XG]LDáX ĞZLDGRPRĞFL 7ZRU]ąF RE- UD]ZL]XDOQ\RWDF]DMąFHMU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLPy]JNRU]\VWD]DUyZQR]ÄKDUGZDUH¶X´

VSHF\¿F]QHJRGODJDWXQNXOXG]NLHJRPHFKDQL]PXWZRU]HQLDWDNLFKREUD]yZLQ- QHJRQLĪGODLQQ\FKJDWXQNyZRUD]ÄVRIWZDUH¶X´WDNLFKLQG\ZLGXDOQ\FKXZD- UXQNRZDĔMDNMĊ]\NZ\FKRZDQLHZ\NV]WDáFHQLHZLHG]DLWG

8Z]JOĊGQLDMąF SRZ\ĪV]H IDNW\ QDOHĪ\ X]QDü ĪH WR FR XZDĪDP\ ]D REUD- ]\ ZL]XDOQH RWDF]DMąFHM QDV U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL Z LVWRFLH U]HF]\ Vą WR QLHZHUEDO- QHKLSRWH]\VWDZLDQHSU]H]Py]JQDSRGVWDZLHGDQ\FKGRFLHUDMąF\FKGRQLHJR

SU]H]]P\Vá\)LOR]RIRZLHMĊ]\NDHSLVWHPRORJRZLHLSV\FKRORJRZLHSR]QDQLD

RUD]¿OR]RIRZLHQDXNLE\OLZVWDQLHZ\UyĪQLüNLONDW\SyZWHMDNW\ZQRĞFL,VWQLH- MHZSá\ZZLHG]\WHRULLQDWRFRZLG]LP\1DQLĪV]\PSR]LRPLHLVWQLHMHZSá\Z

MĊ]\NDQDWRFRZLG]LP\WHJRGRW\F]\KLSRWH]D6DSLUD:KRUID$OHLVWQLHMHWHĪ

WU]HFLSR]LRPWHMDNW\ZQRĞFLEDUG]LHMSRGVWDZRZ\QLĪREDZVSRPQLDQHFKDUDN- WHU\VW\F]Q\GODJDWXQNXSR]LRPQHXURQDOQ\QDNWyU\PGRSLHURQDGEXGRZDQHVą

REDSR]RVWDáH

+LSRWH]DXWZRU]RQDSU]H]XNáDGQHUZRZ\FRGRV]F]HJyáyZUyĪQLVLĊRGKL- SRWH]VWDZLDQ\FKZQDXFH7DPWHVąSRMĊFLRZHWDMHVWZL]XDOQD7DPWHSRZVWD- MąSRGáXĪV]\PF]DVLHZVNXWHNĞZLDGRPHJRZ\VLáNXXP\VáRZHJRWDSRZVWDMH

243RU%GH*HOGHU:LG]ąF\QLHZLG]ąF\ÄĝZLDW1DXNL´F]HUZLHFQUV±

25ZZZ6FLHQWLILF$PHULFDQFRPPD\EOLQGVLJKW

26'XĪRRDNW\ZQRĞFLPy]JXPyZLąHNVSHU\PHQW\*06WUDWWRQD]VRF]HZNDPLRGZUDFD- MąF\PLSRU*UHJRU\G]F\WV±76.XKQStruktura rewolucji naukowych )XQGDFMD

$OHWKHLD:DUV]DZDV±RUD]-6%UXQQHUDSRU3R]DGRVWDUF]RQHLQIRUPDFMH6WX- dia z psychologii poznawania:DUV]DZDV±L/-3RVWPDQD]QLHW\SRZ\PLNDUWDPL

.XKQdz. cyt.V±RUD]EDGDQLDSHUFHSFMLW]ZILJXUQLHPRĪOLZ\FK

ZXáDPNXVHNXQG\EH]XG]LDáXĞZLDGRPRĞFL'ODWHJR]áXG]HQLHEH]SRĞUHGQLHJR

REFRZDQLD]U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLąMHVWWDNVLOQH:LVWRFLHREDWHURG]DMHKLSRWH]VąW\P

VDP\P±MHG\QLHGRPQLHPDQLHPVWDQXU]HF]\



&]HUQLDZVNLXZDĪDĪHDQDOL]DWZRU]RQ\FKSU]H]Py]JREUD]yZZL]XDOQ\FK

PXVLE\üSRGVWDZąX]DVDGQLDQLDZV]\VWNLFKEDUG]LHMDEVWUDNF\MQ\FKWZLHUG]HĔ

RU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLQDZHWQDMEDUG]LHMRJyOQ\FKWHRULL-HVW]GDQLDĪHQLH]JRGQRĞü

W\FKRVWDWQLFK]MDNMHQD]\ZDIXQGDPHQWDOQ\PLLQWXLFMDPLF]\OLW\PFRGDQH

QDRF]QRĞFLRZRZ\VWDUF]\E\ZąWSLüZWHRULH1LHPDMHGQDNSRZRGXE\MHGQą

WHRULĊ]DNáDGDQąSU]H]Py]JSUHIHURZDüSU]HGLQQ\PLWHRULDPLIRUPXáRZDQ\- PLSU]H]XF]RQ\FK]ZáDV]F]DMHĞOLXZ]JOĊGQLVLĊIDNWĪHVSHF\¿F]Q\GODJDWXQ- NXOXG]NLHJRVSRVyEZ\REUDĪDQLDVRELHU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLGRW\F]\ĞZLDWDZĞUHGQLHM

VNDOLLRQLHZLHONLP]DNUHVLHUyĪQ\FKSDUDPHWUyZ¿]\F]Q\FK

=]DJDGQLHQLHPW\P]ZLą]DQDMHVWQDVWĊSQDZDGDVWDQRZLVND&]HUQLDZVNLHJR

:\NOXF]DQLHQLHZVSyáPLHUQRĞFLWHRULLQDXNRZ\FK

KDPXMHUR]ZyMQDXNL

-HĞOLZV]\VWNLHWHRULHQDXNRZHPDMąE\ü]JRGQH]IXQGDPHQWDOQ\PLLQWXLFMD- PLSRFKRG]ąF\PL]DQDOL]\WHJRFRGDQHQDRF]QRĞFLRZRWRMDVQHMHVWĪHWHRULH

WHQLHPRJąE\üQLHZVSyáPLHUQH&]HUQLDZVNLZ\UDĨQLHZąWSLZWRE\WHRULHU]H- F]\ZLĞFLHPRJá\E\üQLHZVSyáPLHUQH8ZDĪDQSĪHSUREOHPSRUR]XPLHZDQLD

VLĊRVyEXĪ\ZDMąF\FKUyĪQ\FKMĊ]\NyZMHVWZ\ROEU]\PLRQ\DU]HF]\ZLVWąSU]\- F]\Qą QLHSRUR]XPLHĔ MHVW UDF]HM EUDN ]GHF\GRZDQHM ZROL SRUR]XPLHQLD ZĞUyG

XF]HVWQLNyZVSRUXVSRZRGRZDQ\UyĪQ\PLPRW\ZDPLSR]DPHU\WRU\F]Q\PL



&]HUQLDZVNLPD]D]áHWHRULL(LQVWHLQDWRĪHE\áDW]ZWHRULą]DVDGF]\OLWDNą

WHRULąNWyUDZ\PDJDDE\PRGHOVSHáQLDá]JyU\]DáRĪRQHSUDZD

3U]HFLZVWD- ZLD WHRULRP ]DVDG WHRULH NRQVWUXNF\MQH OXE NRQVWUXNW\ZQH 6ą WR WHRULH NWy- UHIRUPXáXMąSUDZDEĊGąFHNRQVHNZHQFMąZF]HĞQLHM]GH¿QLRZDQ\FKSRMĊüRGQR- V]ąF\FKVLĊGRVWUXNWXU\LZáDVQRĞFLHOHPHQWDUQ\FKRELHNWyZ]NWyU\FK]EXGR- ZDQ\MHVWPRGHOWHRULL:WHRULDFKNRQVWUXNF\MQ\FKQDMSLHUZ]QDP\HOHPHQWDU- QHSU]HGPLRW\LLFKZáDVQRĞFLDGRSLHURSRWHPIRUPXáXMHP\SUDZDRERZLą]XMą- FHZG]LHG]LQLHW\FKSU]HGPLRWyZ1SZG\QDPLF]QHMLQWHUSUHWDFML/RUHQW]DJHR- PHWULDF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQLWUDNWRZDQDMHVWMDNRZWyUQDZ]JOĊGHPZáDVQRĞFLHWHUX

5R]UyĪQLHQLHW\FKURG]DMyZWHRULLĞZLDGF]\ĪHPLĊG]\WHRULą(LQVWHLQDLSUHIHUR- ZDQąSU]H]&]HUQLDZVNLHJRZHUVMąWHRULL/RUHQW]DLVWQLHMHQLHZVSyáPLHUQRĞüPH- WRGRORJLF]QD2W\PĪHLVWQLHMHRQDWDNĪHLQDLQQ\FKSáDV]F]\]QDFKRQWRORJLF]-

273RU.-RGNRZVNL2EVHUZDFMD]P\VáRZDMDNRSRVWU]HJDQLHZLUWXDOQHMU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL>Z@

( .RFKDQ UHG 5]HF]\ZLVWRĞü ZLUWXDOQD ĝZLDW\ SU]HGVWDZLRQH Z QDXFH L V]WXFH 8QLZHUV\WHW

6]F]HFLĔVNL5R]SUDZ\L6WXGLDW6]F]HFLQV±

283RU&]HUQLDZVNL5XFK3U]HVWU]HĔ&]DVV

293RUWDPĪHV

QHMLMĊ]\NRZHMPRĪH]DZ\MąWNLHPSáDV]F]\]Q\REVHUZDF\MQHMĞZLDGF]ąS\WD- QLDMDNLH&]HUQLDZVNLVWDZLDWHRULL(LQVWHLQDLRGSRZLHG]LNWyU\FKQDQLHXG]LH- OD8ZDĪDRQĪHZWHMWHRULLQLH]UR]XPLDáHMHVWLVWQLHQLHNODV\Z\UyĪQLRQ\FKXNáD- GyZRGQLHVLHQLDMDNLPLVąXNáDG\LQHUFMDOQH1LHMHVWWHĪMDVQHGODF]HJRSUĊG- NRĞüUR]SU]HVWU]HQLDQLDVLĊĞZLDWáDQLH]DOHĪ\RGUXFKXĨUyGáDĞZLDWáDRUD]GODF]H- JRMDNRSU]HNV]WDáFHQLDNLQHPDW\F]QHRERZLą]XMąWUDQVIRUPDFMH/RUHQW]DDQLH

*DOLOHXV]D ,VWQLHMH WHĪ SUREOHP UHDOQRĞFL UHODW\ZLVW\F]Q\FK HIHNWyZ VNUyFHQLD

GáXJRĞFLLZ\GáXĪHQLDF]DVX&]HUQLDZVNLXZDĪDĪHSUREOHP\WHGDVLĊ]DGRZD- ODMąFRUR]ZLą]DüQDJUXQFLHDOWHUQDW\ZQHMWHRULL]ÄGROHSLRQą´GRQLHMSURWR¿]\Ną

LPHWD¿]\NąGRW\F]ąFąSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPX]QDQLDĪHLVWQLHMHMHGHQZ\UyĪQLRQ\

XNáDGLQHUFMDOQ\W\OHĪHZ\UyĪQLHQLHWRPDFKDUDNWHUQLHHPSLU\F]Q\



3UREOHPZW\PĪHQDJUXQFLHWHRULL(LQVWHLQDS\WDQLDLSUREOHP\MDNLHZR- EHFQLHMVWDZLD&]HUQLDZVNLQLHPDMąVHQVXSRGREQLHMDNLRGSRZLHGĨRLVWQLHQLX

Z\UyĪQLRQHJRXNáDGXLQHUFMDOQHJRVNRURQLHPRĪQDJRHPSLU\F]QLH]LGHQW\¿NR- ZDü7KRPDV.XKQSRGNUHĞODáĪH]DGDZDQLHRERZLą]XMąFHMWHRULLS\WDĔNWyUHQD

MHMJUXQFLHQLHPDMąVHQVXF]DVDPLPRĪHGRSURZDG]LüGRSRMDZLHQLDVLĊQRZHM

DOWHUQDW\ZQHMWHRULLZUDPDFKNWyUHMZVSRPQLDQHS\WDQLDPDMąMXĪVHQV7DNE\áR

QS]S\WDQLHPGODF]HJRLVWQLHMHVLáDJUDZLWDFML±EH]VHQVRZQ\PQDJUXQFLH¿]\- NLQHZWRQRZVNLHMDOHVHQVRZQ\PZRJyOQHMWHRULLZ]JOĊGQRĞFL=DGDZDQLHZLĊF

EH]VHQVRZQ\FKS\WDĔPRĪHZNRQVHNZHQFMLSU]\QLHĞüNRU]\VWQ\HIHNWĝZLDG- F]\MHGQDNĪHPDP\GRF]\QLHQLD]QLHZVSyáPLHUQRĞFLą-HĞOLVáXV]QHMHVWPRMH

SU]\SXV]F]HQLHĪH¿]\NDUHODW\ZLVW\F]QDLSRSLHUDQDSU]H]&]HUQLDZVNLHJRG\- QDPLF]QDLQWHUSUHWDFMDWHRULL/RUHQW]DVąQLHZVSyáPLHUQHWRQDOHĪ\VLĊVSRG]LH- ZDüĪHFL¿OR]RIRZLHNWyU]\Vą±ĪHE\XĪ\ü]QDQHJRRNUHĞOHQLDNVSURI0LFKDáD

+HOOHUD±ÄSUDZLH¿]\NDPL´

Z\PLHQLąZLHOHEH]VHQVRZQ\FKLQLHSRWU]HEQ\FK

S\WDĔRUD]WZLHUG]HĔ&]HUQLDZVNLHJR

6WDQRZLVNRPHWRGRORJLF]QH&]HUQLDZVNLHJRSUHIHUXMąFHWHRULHNRQVWUXNF\M- QHSU]\MPXMąFHKLHUDUFKLĊWZLHUG]HĔQDXNLLLFKDEVROXWQ\SRF]ąWHNNWyU\PRĪ- QDDQDOL]RZDüPHWRGąIHQRPHQRORJLF]QąZ\NOXF]DSUDZRPRFQHLVWQLHQLHWHRULL

QLHZVSyáPLHUQ\FK=HVWDQRZLVNDWHJRQLHZ\QLNDĪHWDNLFKWHRULLQLHPDDOHĪH

MHĞOLVąWRMHVWWREáąGNWyU\QDOHĪ\XVXZDü7\ONRĪHWDNLHVWDQRZLVNRMHVWV]NR- GOLZH GOD UR]ZRMX QDXNL KDPXMH ERZLHP Z\P\ĞODQLH UDG\NDOQLH RGPLHQQ\FK

WHRULLQDXNRZ\FK=DZĊĪDMHGRW\FKNWyUHZ\ZRG]ąVLĊ]ZL]XDOQHJRREUD]X

U]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLMDNLSURGXNXMHOXG]NLPy]J

303RUWDPĪHV

313RU0+HOOHU2ILOR]RIXMąF\FKIL]\NDFKLIL]\NXMąF\FKILOR]RIDFKF]\OLRILOR]RILF]Q\FKLQ- WHUSUHWDFMDFKIL]\F]Q\FKWHRULLÄ=DJDGQLHQLD)LOR]RILF]QHZ1DXFH´QUV

:1,26(.

)LOR]R¿F]QH L RJyOQRPHWRGRORJLF]QH SRGVWDZ\ NRQFHSFML SURWR¿]\NL MDNą

VIRUPXáRZDá&]HUQLDZVNLVąEáĊGQH3RNáDGDRQQLHVáXV]QLH]E\WZLHONLH]DXID- QLH Z SHZQHM SU]HVWDU]DáHM ¿OR]R¿L IHQRPHQRORJLL D MHJR UR]XPLHQLH QDXNL

JG\E\VWDáRVLĊSRZV]HFKQHVWDáRE\VLĊGODUR]ZRMXWHMQDXNLV]NRGOLZH1LHZ\- QLNDMHGQDN]WHJRĪHNRQFHSFMDSURWR¿]\NLQLHPDĪDGQHMZDUWRĞFL1LHPRĪQD

Z\NOXF]\üWHJRĪH]XSá\ZHPODWWDF]\LQQDWH]DSURWR¿]\NLQSRLVWQLHQLXHWH- UX]RVWDQLH]UHKDELOLWRZDQD

3URWR¿]\NDQLHZąWSOLZLHMHVWSUyEą]DPLHV]DQLD]DVWDáHMRGGDZQDZRG\-HVW

WRNRQWURZHUV\MQDLPDáR]QDQDSUDNW\F]QLHQRZDNRQFHSFMDNWyUDVWZDU]DGR- GDWNRZHPRĪOLZRĞFLG\VNXVMLLVSRUyZQDGNOXF]RZ\PL]DJDGQLHQLDPLRQWRORJLL

RUD]¿OR]R¿L¿]\NL

SUMMARY

,QWKH¿UVWSDUWRIWKHVWXG\WKHDXWKRUGH¿QHVEDVLFWKHVHVRI-DQ&]HUQLDZVNL¶VSURWRSK\VLFV

LQ WKH VHFRQG KH SUHVHQWV QHJDWLYH DWWLWXGH WRZDUGV KLV FRQFHSWLRQ &ULWLFDO UHPDUNV LQ DXWKRU¶V

RSLQLRQLQGLFDWHWKDWSKLORVRSKLFDODQGPHWKRGRORJLFDOIRXQGDWLRQVRISURWRSK\VLFVFRQFHSWLRQVDV

IRUPXODWHGE\&]HUQLDZVNLDUHPLVWDNHQ3URIHVVRU-RGNRZVNLH[SUHVVHVKRSHIRUWKHUHKDELOLWDWLRQ

RIVFLHQFHSXWWLQJDQDUJXPHQWWKDWLWEURDGHQVVLJQL¿FDQWO\WKHDUHDRIGLVFXVVLRQVDQGGLVSXWHV

FRQFHUQLQJWKHPDLQSUREOHPVRIRQWRORJ\DQGSKLORVRSK\RIVFLHQFH