Obrona protofizyki i fundamentalizmu

A N N A L E S

81,9(56,7$7,60$5,$(&85,(6.à2'2:6.$

/8%/,1±32/21,$

92/;;;9,,, 6(&7,2, 

2EURQDSURWR¿]\NLLIXQGDPHQWDOL]PX

-$1&=(51,$:6.,

$'HIHQVHRI3URWRSK\VLFVDQG)RXQGDWLRQDOLVP

:67ĉ3

.DĪG\DXWRUFLHV]\VLĊJG\MHVWF]\WDQ\ DW\PEDUG]LHMJG\Z]EXG]DUH- DNFMĊ = ]DSDáHP ]DEUDáHP VLĊ ZLĊF GR OHNWXU\ DUW\NXáX .D]LPLHU]D -RGNRZ- VNLHJRQDWHPDWNRQFHSFMLSURWR¿]\NLUR]ZLMDQHMUyZQLHĪZV]HUHJXPRLFKSX- blikacji^ 2ND]DáR VLĊ ĪH VSRWNDá\ PQLH VURJLH FLĊJL 3U]\MąáE\P MH ] SRNRUą

JG\E\ QLH WR ĪH QLH MHVWHP SHZLHQ F]\ QD QLH ]DVáXJXMĊ 1LHNWyUH ] QLFK ER- ZLHPZ\GDMąVLĊRSLHUDüQDQLHSRUR]XPLHQLDFKLQQH]DĞXSRGVWDZPDMąUyĪQH

SRJOąG\ZPRLPSU]HNRQDQLXGRĞüG\VNXV\MQHSU]HGVWDZLDQHMHGQDNMDNRQLH- NRQWURZHUV\MQHXVWDOHQLD]NWyU\PLNDĪG\SRZLQLHQVLĊ]JRG]Lü&]XMĊVLĊZR- EHF WHJR Z RERZLą]NX Z\MDĞQLü SDUĊ SXQNWyZ: FHOX XáDWZLHQLD NRQIURQWDFML

PRLFKZ\MDĞQLHĔ]NRPHQWRZDQ\PWHNVWHPSR]ZROĊVRELHSRQLĪHMQDĞODGRZDü

MHJRVWUXNWXUĊ

32'67$:2:(7(=<35272),=<.,

7U]HEDSU]\]QDüĪHDXWRUDUW\NXáXGRáRĪ\áZV]HONLFKVWDUDĔDE\DGHNZDWQLH

SU]HGVWDZLüJáyZQąNRQFHSFMĊSU]HGVWDZLRQąZNVLąĪFH']LĊNLWHPXZWHMF]ĊĞFL

NRQLHF]QHVąW\ONRSHZQHGUREQHFKRüF]DVHP]XZDJLQDF]ĊĞüNU\W\F]QąLVWRW- QHXĞFLĞOHQLD'RW\F]ąRQHVDPHMSURWR¿]\NLRGQLHVLHĔGRQLHMLQQ\FKNRQFHSFML

 . -RGNRZVNL Filozoficzny i metodologiczny fundament koncepcji protofizyki Jana Czer- niawskiegoÄ$QQDOHV8QLYHUVLWDWLV0DULDH&XULH6NáRGRZVND´WV±

Y

 Jan Czerniawski

]DNWyU\PLVLĊRSRZLDGDPMDNUyZQLHĪFRZDĪQLHMV]HPRMHJRVWRVXQNXGRUyĪ- Q\FKV]F]HJyáRZ\FKSRJOąGyZLQQ\FKMHM]ZROHQQLNyZ

:UDPDFKW\FKXĞFLĞOHĔZDUWR]DXZDĪ\üĪHSU]HSURZDG]RQąSU]H]+'LQ- JOHUDNU\W\NĊSRGVWDZWHRULLZ]JOĊGQRĞFLPRĪQDRNUHĞOLüMDNRSURWR¿]\F]Qą jedy- QLHUHWURVSHNW\ZQLHJG\ĪSURJUDPSURWR¿]\NLVIRUPXáRZDáGRSLHUR3/RUHQ]HQ

:W\PVHQVLHSURWR¿]\F]QHUR]ZDĪDQLDSURZDG]LáRZF]HĞQLHMZLHOXLQQ\FKP\- ĞOLFLHOLZW\PQS,1HZWRQNWyUHJRDEVROXWQ\F]DVMHVWMXĪJRWRZ\PSRMĊFLHP

SURWR¿]\F]Q\P'LQJOHUMHVW]DWHPQLHW\OHDXWRUHPSURWR¿]\NLFRUDF]HMMHMSUH- NXUVRUHP 1DZLDVHP PyZLąF FKRFLDĪ MHJR JáRV ZVSyáEU]PLDá ] DWDNDPL QD]L- VWyZQDWHRULĊZ]JOĊGQRĞFL]DOLF]HQLHJRGRSU]HGVWDZLFLHOLÄ¿]\NLDU\MVNLHM´² VWDQRZLPRLP]GDQLHPQLHMDNąSU]HVDGĊ

)DNWHP MHVW ĪH WR 'LQJOHU VIRUPXáRZDá ]DVDGĊ SRU]ąGNX SUDJPDW\F]QHJR

Z SLVPDFK SU]HGVWDZLFLHOL V]NRá\ HUODQJHĔVNLHM RNUHĞODQHM WHĪ MDNR zasada po- U]ąGNXPHWRG\F]QHJR-HGQDNMDRGZQLRVNyZZ\FLąJDQ\FK]WHM]DVDG\Z\UDĨ- QLH VLĊ ]G\VWDQVRZDáHP^ 7\PF]DVHP -RGNRZVNL EH] ]DVWU]HĪHĔ SU]\SLVXMH PL

DNFHSWDFMĊ WHM ]DVDG\ SRGREQLH ]UHV]Wą MDN V]HUHJX Z\ZRGyZ 'LQJOHUD NWyUH

RVRELĞFLH MHG\QLH UHIHUXMĊ MDN QS RGZRáDQLH GR ]DVDG\ UDFML GRVWDWHF]QHM F]\

GR]DVDG\QLH]DOHĪQRĞFLSU]HELHJX]MDZLVNRGF]DVXLSU]HVWU]HQL%\üPRĪHPLD- áRWRVáXĪ\üXPDFQLDQLXPRMHJRZL]HUXQNXMDNRfundamentalistyFKRFLDĪDNXUDW

ZW\PVHQVLHIXQGDPHQWDOLVWąQLHMHVWHP:DUWRWHĪSRGNUHĞOLüĪHUyZQLHĪWRQLH

MDZ\VXZDPSRGDGUHVHPLQWHUSUHWDFMLGRĞZLDGF]HQLDZUDPDFKWHRULLZ]JOĊGQR- ĞFL]DU]XWEáĊGQHJRNRáD

-DNRNOXF]RZąGODSURWR¿]\NLZROĊQDWRPLDVWZVND]\ZDüSRFKRG]ąFąUyZ- QLHĪRG'LQJOHUDLGHĊSXQNWX]HURZHJRNWyUąXZDĪDP]DMDNQDMEDUG]LHMWUDIQą

-RGNRZVNL]UHV]WąWHĪMąUHIHUXMHQLHZ\PLHQLDMąF]QD]Z\QLHVWHW\QLHGRNRĔFD

ZLHUQLH)DNW\F]QLHZ\UDĪDRQDQLHSU]HNRQDQLHĪHÄGHIRUPDFMDMHVW]DZV]HGH- IRUPDFMąF]HJRĞ´⁴OHF]ĪHMHVWGHIRUPDFMąZ]JOĊGHPF]HJRĞWMSROHJDQDRGFK\- OHQLXRGSRVWDFLQLH]GHIRUPRZDQHM±FR]UHV]WąPRĪQDZ\F]\WDüMXĪZQDVWĊSQ\P

]GDQLXDUW\NXáX1LH]GHIRUPRZDQ\VWDQU]HF]\QLHMHVWERZLHPWUDNWRZDQ\MDNR

FRĞ]F]HJRSRZVWDMHU]HF]\ZLVW\VWDQ]GHIRUPRZDQ\ZZ\QLNXMDNLHJRĞG]LDáD- QLDOHF]MDNRLGHDá]NWyU\PMHVWporównywany1LHMHVWRQE\QDMPQLHMUHL¿NR- ZDQ\FRPRJáRE\VXJHURZDüF\WRZDQHVIRUPXáRZDQLH

.U\W\NPRMHMSUDF\VáXV]QLH]DXZDĪDSHZLHQ]ZLą]HNPLĊG]\reizmem a pro- WR¿]\NąMHGQDNFKDUDNWHU\]XMHJRQLHGRNRĔFDWUDIQLH1LH]DXZDĪDĪHRQWROR- JLD]DNáDGDQDSU]H]RSHUDFMHSRPLDURZHGRNWyU\FKSU]HFLHĪQDZLą]XMHproto-

23RUIbidemV

3RU-&]HUQLDZVNL5XFKSU]HVWU]HĔF]DV3URWRIL]\F]QHLPHWDIL]\F]QHDVSHNW\SRGVWDZIL- zyki relatywistycznej.UDNyZV±*G]LHLQG]LHM]DĞ]G\VWDQVRZDáHPVLĊUyZQLHĪGRVD- PHM]DVDG\3RUIdemFizyka, protofizyka, metafizykaÄ=DJDGQLHQLD1DXNR]QDZVWZD´W

V±]ZáV

4 .-RGNRZVNLop. cit.V

2EURQDSURWR¿]\NLLIXQGDPHQWDOL]PX 

¿]\NDMHVWZáDĞQLHreistyczna1DWRPLDVWSU]\MĊWHZUDPDFKJHRPHWU\F]QHMLQ- WHUSUHWDFMLWHRULLZ]JOĊGQRĞFLÄGRVáRZQHUR]XPLHQLHWHJRĪH]GDU]HQLDQLHVWD- MąVLĊOHF]DF]DVRZRLVWQLHMą´XQLHPRĪOLZLDQLHW\OHUHL]POHF]QDWXUDOQ\ZMHJR

ramach transjentyzm⁵WMSRJOąGĪHF]DVÄSá\QLH´]DNWyU\PPRĪQDRSRZLDGDü

VLĊUyZQLHĪQLH]DOHĪQLHRGUHL]PXQSZUDPDFKHZHQW\]PXOXESURFHVXDOL]PX

1DMEDUG]LHMNRQWURZHUV\MQHPDMąE\üPRMHZ\SRZLHG]LQDWHPDWeteru⁶1DM- Z\UDĨQLHMFKRG]LWXJáyZQLHRNZHVWLRQRZDQLHSU]H]HPQLHRELHJRZHJRSU]HNRQD- QLDMDNRE\]HV]F]HJyOQHMWHRULLZ]JOĊGQRĞFLZ\QLNDáDNRQLHF]QRĞüRGU]XFHQLDLVW- QLHQLDHWHUX7\PF]DVHPQLHMHVWPL]QDQ\ĪDGHQHIHNW\ZQ\GRZyGSUDZG]LZRĞFL

WHJRSU]HNRQDQLDDSU]HFLHĪGRW\F]\RQRUHODFMLORJLF]QHMZLĊFSRZLQQRSRGOHJDü

GRZRGRZL&RZLĊFHMWUHĞüGUXJLHJRSRVWXODWX(LQVWHLQDPRĪQDRWU]\PDüMDNREH]- SRĞUHGQLąNRQVHNZHQFMĊKLSRWH]\HWHUX⁷FKRFLDĪPRĪQDMąWHĪMDNWR]URELá(LQVWHLQ

SRSURVWX]DáRĪ\üDEVWUDKXMąFRGWHMKLSRWH]\DQDZHWMąQHJXMąFDSLHUZV]\SR- VWXODWQLHEDUG]LHMMHVW]WąKLSRWH]ąVSU]HF]Q\QLĪ]DVDGDZ]JOĊGQRĞFL*DOLOHXV]D

RERZLą]XMąFDZPHFKDQLFH1HZWRQD]]DáRĪHQLHPLVWQLHQLDSU]HVWU]HQLDEVROXWQHM

*G\E\]DĞFKRG]LáRRWRĪHZMĊ]\NXWHRULL(LQVWHLQDSRMĊFLHHWHUXQLHPDVHQVX^ FRVNąGLQąGZRJyOQRĞFLQLHMHVWSUDZGąER]DOHĪ\RGMĊ]\NDZNWyU\PWHRULĊWĊ

VLĊZ\UDĪDMHVWRQRMDNQDMEDUG]LHMVHQVRZQH]ZáDV]F]DZMĊ]\NXZVSRPQLDQHMQD

SRF]ąWNXDUW\NXáX-RGNRZVNLHJRG\QDPLF]QHMLQWHUSUHWDFMLWHMWHRULLVIRUPXáRZDQHM

SU]H]+$/RUHQW]D⁹WRUyZQLHĪZWHG\WH]DRQLHLVWQLHQLXHWHUX]WHRULLWHMQLHZ\- QLND1LHSUDZGąMHVWWHĪMDNRE\]RUWRGRNV\MQLHUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHJRSXQNWXZLG]H- QLDÄS\WDQLHRWRGODF]HJRZ\VWĊSXMąWDNLHHIHNW\MDNVNUyFHQLHGáXJRĞFL´QLHPLD- áRVHQVX^&RZLĊFHMMDNVLĊMHV]F]HRNDĪHS\WDQLHWRMHVW]WHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLD

VHQVRZQHLX]\VNXMHZMHJRUDPDFKRNUHĞORQąRGSRZLHGĨ

8:$*,.5<7<&=1(

1LHVWHW\ZF]ĊĞFLNU\W\F]QHMMHVWQLHFRJRU]HM=DUD]QDSRF]ąWNXSRMDZLD

VLĊWH]DR]ZLą]NXUR]ZLMDQHMSU]H]HPQLHSURWR¿]\NL]PRLPSRJOąGHPNWyU\MD

rzekomo nazywam indukcjonizmemVNąGLQąGSRGREQRQLHWUDIQLH:áDĞFLZLHUR- zumiany indukcjonizm to bowiePZHGáXJ-RGNRZVNLHJRVWDQRZLVNRZNZHVWLL

JHQH]\WHRULLQDXNRZ\FK

53RU+(LOVWHLQProf. Shimony on “the transient now”³6\QWKHVH´WV±

63RUIbidemV

73RU-&]HUQLDZVNL5XFKSU]HVWU]HĔF]DV«V

3RU.-RGNRZVNLWspólnoty uczonych, paradygmaty i rewolucje naukowe/XEOLQ

V±PRZDWDPRIORJLVWRQLHDOH]DSHZQHWRVDPRDXWRUQDSLVDáE\RHWHU]H

93RUQS-6%HOOHow to teach special relativity>Z@Speakable and Unspeakable in Quan- tum Mechanics&DPEULGJHV±3RUWDNĪHZ\ZLDG]-6%HOOHP>Z@3&:'DYLHV

-5%URZQDuch w atomie:DUV]DZDV±]ZáV±.53RSSHUQuantum Theory and the Schism In Physics/RQGRQV±

3RU.-RGNRZVNLFilozoficzny i metodologiczny fundament…V

 Jan Czerniawski

0QLHMV]DRWRĪHQLHSU]\SRPLQDPVRELHĪHE\PZPRLFKGRW\FKF]DVRZ\FK

SXEOLNDFMDFKJG]LHNROZLHNWHJRRNUHĞOHQLDXĪ\á*G\E\PERZLHPPLDáJRXĪ\ü

WRU]HF]\ZLĞFLHUR]XPLDáE\PJRMDNRÄSRJOąGĪHZQDXFHLZĪ\FLXZQLRVNR- ZDQLDLQGXNF\MQHVąQLHGR]DVWąSLHQLD´±ZF]\PMHGQDNQLHZLG]ĊQLF]áHJR

JG\ĪLQGXNFMRQL]PWDNZáDĞQLHUyZQLHĪMHĞOLQLHSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPE\ZDUR]X- miany^ &R ZLĊFHM ZREHF FRUD] EDUG]LHM SRZV]HFKQHM ĞZLDGRPRĞFL ĪH Z QD- uce ma zastosowanie metoda hipotetyczno-dedukcyjna D WHRULH Vą SRZRá\ZD- Q\PLGRĪ\FLDZDNWDFKWZyUF]HJRP\ĞOHQLDhipotezamiSRJOąGNWyU\-RGNRZ- VNLMDNRMHG\Q\FKFLDáE\]DLQGXNFMRQL]PXZDĪDüPDG]LĞMHG\QLH]QDF]HQLHKL- VWRU\F]QH:DUWRWHĪ]D]QDF]\üĪHFKRFLDĪQLHMHGQRNURWQLHSRGNUHĞODáHPzawod- QRĞüZQLRVNRZDĔLQGXNF\MQ\FKSU]H]ZQLRVNRZDQLDWHJRURG]DMXQLHUR]XPLHP

E\QDMPQLHMZV]HONLFKZQLRVNRZDĔQLHGHGXNF\MQ\FK^OHF]W\ONRZQLRVNRZDQLD

RNUHĞODQH SU]H] SROVNLFK ORJLNyZ MDNR redukcyjne^ GOD NWyU\FK SRGVWDZą MHVW

VNLHURZDQHZSU]HFLZQąVWURQĊZ\QLNDQLHORJLF]QH=SHZQRĞFLąMHVWWRGRĞüV]H- URNLHLFKUR]XPLHQLHMHGQDNVWDQRZLąFHQDWXUDOQHXRJyOQLHQLHZQLRVNRZDQLDQD

NWyU\PRSLHUDVLĊÄ]Z\NáD´indukcja enumeracyjna

1LH]DOHĪQLHRGWHJR]SHZQRĞFLąLQGXNFMRQL]PXZSU]\MĊW\PSU]H]HPQLH

UR]XPLHQLX QLH P\OĊ ] SU]\SLVDQ\P PL IXQGDPHQWDOL]PHP MXVW\¿NDFMRQLVW\F]- nymNWyUHJRVNąGLQąGMHVWQLH]E\ZDOQ\PVNáDGQLNLHP'RWDNRNUHĞORQHJRSR- JOąGXUyZQLHĪ±SRGSHZQ\PL]DVWU]HĪHQLDPLRNWyU\FKQLĪHM±JRWyZMHVWHPVLĊ

SU]\]QDü3U]\SLVDQLHPLJRWUDNWRZDQHMHVWMHGQDNMDNRQDMSRZDĪQLHMV]\]DU]XW

JG\ĪNRQFHSFMDWDPDE\üÄZDGOLZDZZLHOXDVSHNWDFK´Z]ZLą]NX]F]\PÄNRQ- FHSFMDSURWR¿]\NLWUDFLUDFMĊE\WX´0RĪQD]DXZDĪ\üĪHQLHW\OHUDFMĊE\WXOHF]

FRQDMZ\ĪHMRGZRáXMąFHVLĊGRQLHMX]DVDGQLHQLH=REDF]P\MHGQDNF]\ZVSR- PQLDQDNRQFHSFMDPHWRGRORJLF]QD]DVáXJXMHQDWDNVXURZąRFHQĊ

-HGQą]UDFMLQDU]HF]WHMRFHQ\PDE\üVWZLHUG]HQLHÄ:QDXFHQLHLVWQLH- MHKLHUDUFKLDWZLHUG]HĔLSR]LRPyZX]DVDGQLHĔ´:V]F]HJyOQRĞFLQLHLVWQLHüPD

KLHUDUFKLDQDNWyUHMGROH]QDMGRZDá\E\VLĊSU]\MĊWHSU]H]HPQLHMDNRDEVROXWQ\

fundament wiedzy empirycznej zdania fenomenologiczne7H]DWDVDPDZVRELH

QLHMHVWE\QDMPQLHMRF]\ZLVWDZLĊF-RGNRZVNLSUyEXMHMąQLHFRQDFK\ELáWUD-

¿á X]DVDGQLü1D SU]\NáDG SRZRáXMH VLĊ QD VWZLHUG]HQLHÄ: QDXFHZLĊNV]RĞü

]GDĔPRĪHZ\VWĊSRZDüZGZyFKURODFKZSHZQ\FKSU]\SDGNDFKMDNRSU]HVáDQ- NDZLQQ\FKMDNRZQLRVHN´1DZHWMHGQDNDEVWUDKXMąFRGWHJRĪHZLĊNV]RĞüWR

QLHWRVDPRFRZV]\VWNLHWU]HED]DXZDĪ\üLĪwywnioskowanieWRQLHWRVDPR

co uzasadnienieZLĊFVWZLHUG]HQLHWRQLHVWDQRZLSRGVWDZ\GODQHJDFMLLVWQLHQLD

SR]LRPyZX]DVDGQLHĔ

=REQS$*UREOHUMetodologia nauk.UDNyZV±

3RU.-RGNRZVNLFilozoficzny i metodologiczny fundament…V

3RU-&]HUQLDZVNL5XFKSU]HVWU]HĔF]DV«V=RE.$MGXNLHZLF]Zarys logiki:DU- V]DZDV±

2EURQDSURWR¿]\NLLIXQGDPHQWDOL]PX 

1LH]E\WFHOQHZ\GDMHVLĊWHĪSRZRáDQLHVLĊQDIDNWĪHZUHDOQHMSUDNW\FHQD- XNLWHRULHQDRJyáQLHVWDQRZLąsystemów zaksjomatyzowanych3U]HFLHĪUyZQLHĪ

WDNLV\VWHPPRĪQD]DNVMRPDW\]RZDüQDZLHOHVSRVREyZD]PLDQDDNVMRPDW\NL

SROHJDZáDĞQLHQDW\PĪHQLHNWyUHGRW\FKF]DVRZHtwierdzeniaSU]HMPXMąIXQNFMĊ

aksjomatów]DĞGRW\FKF]DVRZHDNVMRPDW\VWDMąVLĊWZLHUG]HQLDPL:ĪDGHQVSR- VyEMHGQDNQLHX]DVDGQLDWRHNVWUDZDJDQFNLHMWH]\MDNRE\ZQDXFHGRSXV]F]DOQH

E\á\X]DVDGQLHQLDREDUF]RQHEáĊGQ\PNRáHP

:ĞZLHWOHG]LVLHMV]HMZLHG]\DNVMRPDW\WHRULLVąpostulatamiZVSRVyEuwi- NáDQ\ZVSyáGH¿QLXMąF\PLSRMĊFLDSLHUZRWQHWHRULL-DNQDMEDUG]LHMWUDIQDZ\GD- MHVLĊZLĊFU]HNRPRÄU\]\NRZQD´WH]D.\EXUJD^LĪÄZV]\VWNLHRJyOQHSUDZG\

ZW\PWHRULHQDXNRZHPDMąDQDOLW\F]Q\FKDUDNWHU´=WHJRMHGQDNE\QDMPQLHMQLH

Z\QLNDĪHÄGRX]DVDGQLHQLDMDNLHJRĞWZLHUG]HQLDZ\PDJDQHMHVW]DáRĪHQLHSUDZ- G]LZRĞFLFDáHMWHRULL´ZW\PX]DVDGQLDQHJRWZLHUG]HQLD^3U]\WRF]RQ\SU]\NáDG

X]DOHĪQLHQLDZ\QLNXSRPLDUXPDV\RG]DáRĪHQLDGUXJLHM]DVDG\G\QDPLNL1HZWR- QDZVND]XMHW\ONRQDIXQNFMĊWHM]DVDG\MDNRSRVWXODWXGH¿QLXMąFHJRPDVĊ]NWy- UHJRZ\QLNDMHGQDNMHG\QLHWRczymZĞZLHWOHWHMWHRULLMHVWPDVDLMDNZREHFWHJR

QDOHĪ\MąPLHU]\üQDWRPLDVWE\QDMPQLHMQLHZ\QLNDĪHZĞZLHFLHLVWQLHMąRELHNW\

REGDU]RQHWDNUR]XPLDQąPDVąDQLMDNLHIDNW\F]QLHEĊGąwyniki takiego pomia- UX-HĞOLZLĊFSUDZG]LZRĞü]DVDG\G\QDPLNLMHVWWX]DNáDGDQDWRMHG\QLHZIXQN- FMLGH¿QLRZDQLDSRMĊFLDPDV\ZUR]XPLHQLXWHMWHRULLDQLHZIXQNFMLRSLVXU]H- F]\ZLVWRĞFL

:\QLNL]DSODQRZDQ\FKQDSRGVWDZLHWHRULLSRPLDUyZQLHPXV]ą]DWHP]JD- G]Dü VLĊ ] MHM SU]HZLG\ZDQLDPL D QDZHW VDPH SRPLDU\ PRJą RND]Dü VLĊ QLH- Z\NRQDOQH1DSU]\NáDGQLHPRĪOLZ\RND]DáVLĊSRPLDUSUĊGNRĞFLODERUDWRULXP

]LHPVNLHJRZ]JOĊGHPHWHUXNWyU\PPLDáVLĊVWDü]DSODQRZDQ\QDSRGVWDZLH¿- ]\NLQLHUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHMHNVSHU\PHQW0LFKHOVRQD0RUOH\D6DPDWH]D.\EXUJD

MHVW NRQWURZHUV\MQD MHG\QLH Z NRQWHNĞFLH RG]LHG]LF]RQHJR SR .DQFLH SRJOąGX

ĪHÄZV]\VWNLH]GDQLDDQDOLW\F]QHVąVąGDPLa priori´^$QDOLW\F]Q\VWDWXVWZLHU- G]HĔWHRULLQLH]DSHZQLDDGHNZDWQRĞFLHPSLU\F]QHMMHMSU]HZLG\ZDQLRPNWyUHVą

zdaniami warunkowymi (implikacje testoweLPRĪHVLĊ]GDU]\üĪHZG]LHG]LQLH

GRĞZLDGF]HQLDEąGĨZDUXQHNMHVWQLHVSHáQLDOQ\SU]HZLG\ZDQLHMHVWZWHG\W\ONR

SXVWRVSHáQLRQHEąGĨWHĪSU]\VSHáQLRQ\PZDUXQNXSU]HZLG\ZDQLHVLĊQLHSR- WZLHUG]L$E\WDNQLHPRJáRE\üWHRULDPXVLDáDE\E\üWDXWRORJLF]QD

-RGNRZVNLXZDĪDQDVWĊSQLHĪHIXQGDPHQWDOL]PMHVWQLHGRXWU]\PDQLDER

ZHGáXJQLHJRÄ1LHLVWQLHMHQLHKLSRWHW\F]Q\IXQGDPHQWZLHG]\´3U]HGVWDZLDMąF

MHGQDN]DVWRVRZDQLHMDNLH]D(=DKDUHPZLG]ĊGODredukcji fenomenologicznej

 3RU +( .\EXUJ All acceptable generalizations are analytic ³$PHULFDQ 3KLORVRSKLFDO

4XDUWHUO\´WV±

3RU.-RGNRZVNLFilozoficzny i metodologiczny fundament…V

,.DQW3UROHJRPHQDGRZV]HONLHMSU]\V]áHMPHWDIL]\NLNWyUDEĊG]LHPRJáDZ\VWąSLüMDNRQD- uka:DUV]DZDV

 Jan Czerniawski

Z]ZLą]NX]SRV]XNLZDQLHPWDNLHJRIXQGDPHQWX^ZVSRVyESá\QQ\SU]HFKRG]L

GRRPyZLHQLD]DVWRVRZDQLDMDNLHZHGáXJPQLH]QDMGXMHmetoda fenomenologicz- naZSHáQ\P]DNUHVLHGRX]DVDGQLDQLDDSULRU\F]Q\FKWZLHUG]HĔRQWRORJLF]Q\FK

Z W\P PLQ QHJDW\ZQ\FK WH] UHL]PX: WHQ VSRVyE VXJHUXMH NRQLHF]Q\ ]ZLą- ]HNWHJRSLHUZV]HJR]W\PGUXJLP)DNW\F]QLHMHGQDN]ZLą]HNWDNLQLH]DFKRG]L

LZVSRPQLDQH]DVWRVRZDQLHGODUHGXNFMLIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHMPRĪQDX]QDüQLHDQ- JDĪXMąFVLĊZDNFHSWDFMĊLQQ\FKVNáDGQLNyZPHWRG\IHQRPHQRORJLF]QHM

1LH]DOHĪQLHRGWHJRPRĪHZWHQVSRVyESRZVWDüP\OQHZUDĪHQLHMDNRE\P

FKFLDáPHWRGąIHQRPHQRORJLF]Qą]DVWąSLüPHWRGĊKLSRWHW\F]QRGHGXNF\MQą7\P- F]DVHPMD]DVWRVRZDQLHWHJRHOHPHQWXPHWRG\IHQRPHQRORJLF]QHMZLG]ĊZáDĞQLH

Z]ZLą]NX]RSDUW\PQDGHGXNFMLVSUDZG]DQLHPKLSRWH]QDXNRZ\FK2WU]\PDQH

G]LĊNLUHGXNFMLIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHM]GDQLDWHJRURG]DMXVąQLH]EĊGQHE\]DUDG]Lü

bynajmniej nie EáĊGQHPXNRáXFRZHGáXJ-RGNRZVNLHJRPDPRW\ZRZDüPRMHRG- ZRáDQLHGRWHMNRQFHSFML^OHF]QLHVNRĔF]RQHPXUHJUHVRZLNWyU\E\áE\QLHXQLN- QLRQ\JG\E\KLSRWH]\PRĪQDE\áRVSUDZG]DüMHG\QLHSU]H]NRQIURQWDFMĊ]LQQ\- PLKLSRWH]DPL±RF]\ZLĞFLH]DNáDGDMąFĪHdogmatyzmMDNLPE\áRE\SU]HUZDQLH

VSUDZG]DQLDMDNFKFLDá3RSSHU^QDPRF\DUELWUDOQHMGHF\]MLQLHZFKRG]LZJUĊ

3U]HFLZNRQLHKLSRWHW\F]QHPXFKDUDNWHURZL]GDĔIHQRPHQRORJLF]Q\FKSU]H- PDZLDüPDVSRVWU]HĪHQLHĪHÄ-Ċ]\NSRWRF]Q\MHVWRJyOQąWHRULąU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL´

DWRZW\PMĊ]\NXIRUPXáRZDQHVąWDNLH]GDQLD0RMHSU]HNRQDQLHĪHPDMąRQH

WDNLFKDUDNWHUPDSU]\SXV]F]DOQLHZ\QLNDü]QLH]QDMRPRĞFLSRJOąGyZ+DQVRQD

.XKQDF]\)H\HUDEHQGDQDFRZVND]\ZDüPDIDNWĪHLFKQLHF\WXMĊSRGREQLH

jak Poppera – w przypadku tego ostatniego Jodkowski jednak uprzejmie przyzna- MHĪH]DSHZQHRQLPVá\V]DáHPFRMHVWRW\OH¿JODUQHĪHVDPF\WXMHPyMDUW\NXá

JG]LHF\WXMĊQLHW\ONR3RSSHUDDOHL)H\HUDEHQGD²⁰

7RĪHMĊ]\NZSá\ZDQDSRVWU]HJDQLHĞZLDWDPLHOLRGNU\ü6DSLUL:KRUI=H

VIRUPXáRZDQąSU]H]W\FKMĊ]\NR]QDZFyZKLSRWH]ąZ\GDMHVLĊ]ELHĪQDRSDUWDQD

analizie semantycznej teza RQWRORJLF]QHJR ]DDQJDĪRZDQLD MĊ]\ND VIRUPXáRZD- QD SU]H] ORJLND 4XLQH¶D^ NWyUD EDUG]LHM GR PQLH SU]HPDZLD MDNR NODURZQLHM- V]DLQLHRGZRáXMąFDVLĊGRPĊWQ\FKLQWXLFMLOHF]GRZ\QLNyZDQDOL]ORJLF]Q\FK

0DP\WXMHGQDNMDNVLĊ]GDMHNODV\F]Q\SUREOHPNXU\LMDMD:]DVDG]LHPRĪ- QD]JRG]LüVLĊĪHMĊ]\NMDNLHJRXĪ\ZDP\GRRSLVX]MDZLVNRNUHĞODLFKNDWHJR- U\]DFMĊPRĪQDMHGQDN]DS\WDüGODF]HJRRQVDPMHVWWDNLMDNLMHVW1DMSURVWV]D

]DĞZ\GDMHVLĊRGSRZLHGĨĪHHZROXF\MQLHGRVWRVRZDáVLĊGRG]LHG]LQ\QDV]HJR

3RU-&]HUQLDZVNL)HQRPHQRORJLF]QHUR]ZLą]DQLHSUREOHPXED]\HPSLU\F]QHMÄ.ZDUWDO- QLN)LOR]RILF]Q\´WQUV±(*=DKDUThe problem of the empirical basis>Z@

$2¶+HDUHGKarl Popper: Philosophy and Problems&DPEULGJHV±

3RU.-RGNRZVNLFilozoficzny i metodologiczny fundament…V

3RU.53RSSHULogika odkrycia naukowego:DUV]DZDV±

203RU-&]HUQLDZVNL)HQRPHQRORJLF]QHUR]ZLą]DQLHSUREOHPX«V

:924XLQHO tym, co istnieje>Z@=SXQNWXZLG]HQLDORJLNLG]LHZLĊüHVHMyZORJLF]QRIL- lozoficznych:DUV]DZDV±

2EURQDSURWR¿]\NLLIXQGDPHQWDOL]PX 

GRĞZLDGF]HQLD&KRFLDĪNRQNUHWQ\MĊ]\NMHVW]DZV]HZ\WZRUHPMDNLHMĞSRSXODFML

OXG]NLHMQDSU]HVWU]HQLG]LHMyZQLHMHVWWRE\QDMPQLHMZ\WZyUFDáNRZLFLHGRZRO- Q\OHF]QLHVLHZVRELHRJyOQąLQIRUPDFMĊRRQWRORJLLV]HURNRUR]XPLDQHJRĞURGR- ZLVNDZNWyU\PWDSRSXODFMDĪ\MH

,QQ\DUJXPHQWSU]HFLZNRQLHKLSRWHW\F]QHPXFKDUDNWHURZL]GDĔIHQRPHQR- ORJLF]Q\FKRGZRáXMHVLĊGRIDNWXĪHÄ3HUFHSFMD]P\VáRZDMHVWNRĔFRZ\PZ\- QLNLHP VNRPSOLNRZDQHM DNW\ZQRĞFL Py]JX´ &]\ĪE\ MHGQDN IHQRPHQRORJRZLH

R W\P QLH ZLHG]LHOL" 0RĪQD ZąWSLü 5DF]HM SR SURVWX ĞZLDGRPLH DEVWUDKRZD- OLRGV]F]HJyáyZWHMDNW\ZQRĞFLLQWHUHVXMąFVLĊW\ONRZ\QLNLHPNRĔFRZ\PNWy- U\SRMDZLDVLĊZSROXĞZLDGRPRĞFL3RGREQLH]UHV]WąXĪ\WNRZQLNNRPSXWHUDQD

RJyáQLHPXVLVLĊNáRSRWDüRV]F]HJyá\MHJRIXQNFMRQRZDQLDMDNRVNRPSOLNRZD- QHJRXNáDGXHOHNWURQLF]QHJR&DáNRZLFLHZ\VWDUF]DPXZLHG]DFRGRWHJRMDNLH

IXQNFMHWHQNRPSXWHUUHDOL]XMHZUHDNFMLQDGDQHNRPHQG\OXEV\JQDá\RGXU]ą- G]HĔSHU\IHU\MQ\FK

2F]\ZLĞFLHGODIHQRPHQRORJDLVWRWQHMHVWE\REUD]\SHUFHSF\MQHXUyĪQ\FK

OXG]LE\á\]JRGQH1LHFKRG]LMHGQDNRLFKWRĪVDPRĞüOHF]R]JRGQRĞüZ\VWDUF]D- MąFąGR]JRG\FRGRFHFKGDQHJRREUD]XLVWRWQ\FK]HZ]JOĊGXQDX]QDQLHGDQHJR

]GDQLDIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHJRSU]H]UyĪQ\FKXĪ\WNRZQLNyZGDQHJRMĊ]\ND7DND

]JRGQRĞü]D]Z\F]DM]DFKRG]L3RZRá\ZDQLHVLĊZFHOXSRGZDĪHQLDWHJRIDNWXQD

przypadki dysfunkcji neurologicznych²²PDGRQLRVáRĞüQLHZLĊNV]ąQLĪNU\W\NR- ZDQLHSURJUDPXNRPSXWHURZHJRQDWHMSRGVWDZLHĪHĨOHIXQNFMRQXMHQD]HSVX- W\PNRPSXWHU]H

-RGNRZVNLVáXV]QLHSRGNUHĞODĪHREUD]\SHUFHSF\MQHVąMHG\QLHKLSRWH]DPL

QDV]HJRPy]JXQDWHPDWU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL6WDWXVKLSRWH]\PDZLĊFNDĪG\RSDUW\

QDQLFKUDSRUWRGQLHVLRQ\GRU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFL7DNLUDSRUWMHGQDNQLHPDFKDUDNWH- UX]GDQLDIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHJR)XQNFMąUHGXNFMLIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHMMHVWZáDĞQLH

Ä]DZLHV]HQLH´WHJRRGQLHVLHQLDG]LĊNLF]HPX]UHGXNRZDQH]GDQLHFKRFLDĪPRĪH

EU]PLHüMDNVWZLHUG]HQLH]DFKRG]HQLDWUDQVFHQGHQWQHJRZ]JOĊGHPSRGPLRWXVWD- QX U]HF]\ IDNW\F]QLH GRW\F]\ MHG\QLH PHQWDOQHJR REUD]X D QLH WHJR FR REUD- ]RZDQH7HQ]DĞMHVWSRGPLRWRZLGDQ\EH]SRĞUHGQLRMDNRWUHĞüMHJRĞZLDGRPR- ĞFLZLĊFQLHPXVLE\üSU]HGPLRWHPGRPQLHPDQLD1SVHQV]UHGXNRZDQHJRIH- QRPHQRORJLF]QLH]GDQLDÄ1DPDFLHVLHG]LNRW´Z\UDĪD]GDQLHNWyUH.RWDUELĔVNL

]DSHZQHVIRUPXáRZDáE\QDVWĊSXMąFRÄ'R]QDMĊSHUFHSF\MQLHWDN©1DPDFLHVLH- G]LNRWª´±NWyUHZRJyOHQLFQLHPyZLRNRFLHOHF]MHG\QLHRPQLH:W\PVHQ- sie jest ono autopsychologiczne:DUWRQDGPLHQLüĪHG]LĊNLWDNLHPXUR]ZLą]DQLX

WDNRQFHSFMDIXQGDPHQWXNWyUDZSHZQ\PVHQVLHVWDQRZLSRZUyWGRNRQFHSFML

]GDĔSURWRNRODUQ\FKXQLNDVWDZLDQHJRWDPWHMNRQFHSFML]DU]XWXRGZRá\ZDQLDVLĊ

GR¿NFMLÄMĊ]\NDGDQ\FK]P\VáRZ\FK´^

223RU.-RGNRZVNLFilozoficzny i metodologiczny fundament…V±

=RE-&]HUQLDZVNL)HQRPHQRORJLF]QHUR]ZLą]DQLHSUREOHPX«V

 Jan Czerniawski

1LHNDĪGHMHGQDN]GDQLHIHQRPHQRORJLF]QHMHVWUDSRUWHP]WUHĞFLMHGQRVWNR- ZHJRSU]HGVWDZLHQLDQDRF]QHJR:V]F]HJyOQRĞFLQLHMHVWQLPĪDGQH]GDQLHRJyO- QHNWyUHMDNZ\UDĨQLHVWZLHUG]DPPDFKDUDNWHUKLSRWH]\7DNLP]GDQLHPMHVW

]DĞNDĪG\Z\QLNZJOąGXZLVWRWĊ²⁴&DáNRZLFLH]JDG]DPVLĊSU]\W\PĪHÄ1LH

PD>«@SRZRGXE\MHGQąWHRULĊ]DNáDGDQąSU]H]Py]JSUHIHURZDüSU]HGLQQ\- PLIRUPXáRZDQ\PLSU]H]XF]RQ\FK]ZáDV]F]D>«@ĪHVSHF\¿F]Q\GODJDWXQ- NXOXG]NLHJRVSRVyEZ\REUDĪDQLDVRELHU]HF]\ZLVWRĞFLGRW\F]\ĞZLDWDZĞUHGQLHM

VNDOLLRQLHZLHONLP]DNUHVLHUyĪQ\FKSDUDPHWUyZ¿]\F]Q\FK´1LH]JDG]DPVLĊ

MHG\QLHE\WąSLHUZV]ąG\VNU\PLQRZDüZ]DNUHVLHMHMVWRVRZDOQRĞFL]ZáDV]F]D

ĪHSU]HPDZLD]DQLąHZROXF\MQ\VXNFHVJDWXQNXOXG]NLHJR

1LJG]LH QLH WZLHUG]Ċ ĪH NDĪGD WHRULD PXVL E\ü ]JRGQD ] LQWXLFMDPL NWy- UHXZDĪDP]DIXQGDPHQWDOQH-HĞOLMHGQDNSRMDZLDVLĊWHRULDNWyUDZ\JOąGDQD

VSU]HF]Qą]QLPLSU]HGUH]\JQDFMą]QLFK]DZV]HSRVWXORZDáE\PVSUDZG]LüF]\

WD VSU]HF]QRĞü QDSUDZGĊ ]DFKRG]L 0RMH GRĞZLDGF]HQLH ] WHRULą Z]JOĊGQRĞFL

PyZL ERZLHP ĪH ] LQWXLFMDPL W\PL PRĪH E\ü VSU]HF]QD QLH W\OH XJUXQWRZDQD

HPSLU\F]QLHFHQWUDOQDF]ĊĞüWUHĞFLWHRULLFRUDF]HMSHZQDMHMQDGZ\ĪNDLQWHUSUH- tacyjnaNWyUąEH]QDUXV]HQLD]JRGQRĞFLWHRULL]GRĞZLDGF]HQLHPPRĪQDZ\PLH- QLüQDLQQą]JRGQą]QLPL

: SU]\SDGNX ZVSRPQLDQHM WHRULL RZą QDGZ\ĪNą LQWHUSUHWDF\MQą Z MHM RU- WRGRNV\MQHM LQWHUSUHWDFML 0LQNRZVNLHJR MHVW QHJDW\ZQH UR]VWU]\JQLĊFLH PHWD-

¿]\F]Q\FK Z ĞZLHWOH WHM WHRULL NZHVWLL LVWQLHQLD HWHUX L DEVROXWQHJR F]DVX ]DĞ

DOWHUQDW\Zą MHVW LQWHUSUHWDFMD /RUHQW]D Z UDPDFK NWyUHM Vą RQH UR]VWU]\JQLĊ- WHSR]\W\ZQLH:HGáXJ-RGNRZVNLHJRWHGZLHLQWHUSUHWDFMHVąQLHZVSyáPLHUQ\- PLWHRULDPLRF]\PPDĞZLDGF]\üLVWQLHQLHSUREOHPyZVHQVRZQ\FKZUDPDFK

LQWHUSUHWDFML /RUHQW]D D SR]EDZLRQ\FK VHQVX Z UDPDFK LQWHUSUHWDFML 0LQNRZ- skiego²⁵3U]\NáDG\WDNLFKSUREOHPyZZ\UDĪDMąS\WDQLDGODF]HJRLVWQLHMHNODVD

Z\UyĪQLRQ\FKXNáDGyZRGQLHVLHQLDMDNLPLVąXNáDG\LQHUFMDOQHGODF]HJRSUĊGNRĞü

UR]SU]HVWU]HQLDQLDVLĊĞZLDWáDQLH]DOHĪ\RGUXFKXĨUyGáDLGODF]HJRRERZLą]XMą

SU]HNV]WDáFHQLD/RUHQW]DDQLH*DOLOHXV]DMDNUyZQLHĪSUREOHPUHDOQRĞFLHIHN- WyZUHODW\ZLVW\F]Q\FK

.áRSRW Z W\P ĪH SRGREQLH MDN ZVSRPQLDQ\ ZF]HĞQLHM SUREOHP Z\MDĞQLH- QLDHIHNWyZZURG]DMXUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHJRVNUyFHQLDGáXJRĞFLZV]\VWNLHWHSUR- EOHP\ Vą MDN QDMEDUG]LHM VHQVRZQH QD JUXQFLH LQWHUSUHWDFML 0LQNRZVNLHJR FR

ZLĊFHM]QDMGXMąQDW\PJUXQFLHUR]ZLą]DQLDW\OHĪHQDRJyáLQQHQLĪZUDPDFK

LQWHUSUHWDFML/RUHQW]DJG\ĪRGZRáXMąFHVLĊQLHGRHWHUXOHF]GRJHRPHWULLF]D- VRSU]HVWU]HQL:V]F]HJyOQRĞFLXNáDG\LQHUFMDOQHZ\UyĪQLRQHVąSU]H]WRĪHRG- SRZLDGDMą LP F]DVRSRGREQH OLQLH JHRGH]\MQH Z F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL ]DĞ ĞZLDWáR

]DZV]HZ\ELHUDJHRGH]\MQH]HURZHNWyUHUHSUH]HQWXMąZáDĞQLHUXFKZXNáDGDFK

24=REIdem5XFKSU]HVWU]HĔF]DV«V

253RU.-RGNRZVNLFilozoficzny i metodologiczny fundament…V

2EURQDSURWR¿]\NLLIXQGDPHQWDOL]PX 

LQHUFMDOQ\FK]V]\ENRĞFLąUyZQąVWDáHMc²⁶3UREOHPUHDOQRĞFLHIHNWyZUHODW\ZL- VW\F]Q\FKMHVWMDNQDMEDUG]LHMVHQVRZQ\QLH]DOHĪQLHRGLQWHUSUHWDFMLWHRULLZ]JOĊG- QRĞFLRF]\PĞZLDGF]\GHEDWDZOLWHUDWXU]H¿]\F]QHML¿OR]R¿F]QHMNWyUHMXF]HVW- QLF\ZSU]\WáDF]DMąFHMZLĊNV]RĞFLVą]ZROHQQLNDPLLQWHUSUHWDFML0LQNRZVNLHJR²⁷

&R GR LFK JHQH]\ WR QS VNUyFHQLH GáXJRĞFL Z ĞZLHWOH WHM LQWHUSUHWDFML Z\QLND

]WHJRĪHGáXJRĞüFLDáDZUXFKXNWyUąVWDQRZLGáXJRĞüSU]HFLĊFLDUHSUH]HQWXMąFHM

WRFLDáRF]WHURZ\PLDURZHMÄNLV]NL´]KLSHUSRZLHU]FKQLą]GDU]HĔUyZQRF]HVQ\FK

Z GDQ\P XNáDG]LH LQHUFMDOQ\P Z JHRPHWULL SU]\SLV\ZDQHM F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL SU]H]V]F]HJyOQąWHRULĊZ]JOĊGQRĞFLMHVWPQLHMV]DQLĪMHJRGáXJRĞüVSRF]\QNR- ZD NWyUą VWDQRZL GáXJRĞü SU]HFLĊFLD ] KLSHUSRZLHU]FKQLą ]GDU]HĔ UyZQRF]H- VQ\FKZXNáDG]LHZVSyáSRUXV]DMąF\PVLĊ]FLDáHP^1DWRPLDVWSU]HNV]WDáFHQLD

/RUHQW]DDQLHSU]HNV]WDáFHQLD*DOLOHXV]DVWDQRZLąV\PHWULHWHMJHRPHWULLLGOD- WHJRWRRQHRERZLą]XMąMDNRSU]HNV]WDáFHQLDNLQHPDW\F]QH

&R ZLĊFHM UR]ZLą]DQLD WH Z ]DVDG]LH PRĪH X]QDü ]ZROHQQLN LQWHUSUHWDFML

/RUHQW]D%ĊG]LHMHG\QLHWZLHUG]LáĪHG\VSRQXMHUR]ZLą]DQLDPLEDUG]LHMIXQGD- PHQWDOQ\PL]DWHPWDPWHVąQLHZ\VWDUF]DMąFH7XIDNW\F]QLHPRĪQDVLĊGRV]XNDü

SHZQHMQLHZVSyáPLHUQRĞFLJG\ĪMHJRDGZHUVDU]]DNZHVWLRQXMHLVWQLHQLHSRGVWD- Z\W\FKEDUG]LHMIXQGDPHQWDOQ\FKUR]ZLą]DĔ2EDMMHGQDNPRJąVLĊ]JRG]LüĪH

FDáąHPSLU\F]QLHXJUXQWRZDQąF]ĊĞüWUHĞFLWHRULLPRĪQDVIRUPXáRZDüZWDNLVSR- VyEE\QLHUR]VWU]\JDüNRQWURZHUV\MQ\FKNZHVWLLSU]HVXZDMąFMHGRG]LHG]LQ\¿- OR]R¿F]Q\FKLQWHUSUHWDFML-HĞOLZLĊFQLHZVSyáPLHUQRĞüXWU]\PXMHVLĊZUDPDFK

QDXNLWRFRQDMPQLHMZW\PSU]\SDGNXZ\QLNDWR]QLHZ\VWDUF]DMąFHMUDFMRQDOQR- ĞFLXF]HVWQLNyZWHJRVSRUXNWyU]\FKFLHOLE\VZRLPVWDQRZLVNRPZW\P¿OR]R-

¿F]Q\PVSRU]HQDGDüUDQJĊRELHNW\ZQHMZLHG]\QDXNRZHM

Najdziwniejszy zarzut pod adresem fundamentalizmu w reprezentowanej SU]H]HPQLHSRVWDFLZ\UDĪDVLĊZUR]SR]QDQLXĪHÄ:\NOXF]DQLHQLHZVSyáPLHU- QRĞFLWHRULLQDXNRZ\FKKDPXMHUR]ZyMQDXNL´+DPRZDüPLDáRE\JRGąĪHQLHGR

HOLPLQDFMLQLHZVSyáPLHUQRĞFLWHRULLU]HNRPRSU]HV]NDG]DMąFZZ\P\ĞODQLXUD- G\NDOQLHRGPLHQQ\FKWHRULL1LHZLDGRPRMHGQDNGODF]HJRPLDáRE\WDNE\ü

:VSyáPLHUQRĞüUyĪQ\FKWHRULLSROHJDZHGáXJPQLHQDW\PĪHPRJąE\üNRQ- IURQWRZDQH]W\PLVDP\PLIDNWDPLFRPRĪQDX]\VNDüG]LĊNLRGZRáDQLXVLĊGR

IHQRPHQRORJLF]QHJR RSLVX Z\QLNyZ REVHUZDFML : ĪDGHQ VSRVyE MHGQDN QLH

RJUDQLF]DWRUyĪQRURGQRĞFLVSUDZG]DQ\FKZWHQVSRVyEWHRULL1DSU]\NáDGWHR-

263RU&]HUQLDZVNL5XFKSU]HVWU]HĔF]DV«V:.RSF]\ĔVNL$7UDXWPDQCzasoprze- VWU]HĔLJUDZLWDFMD:DUV]DZDV±

273RUQS''LHNVThe “reality” of the Lorentz contraction³=HLWVFKULIWIUDOOJHPHLQH:LV- VHQVFKDIWVWKHRULH´WQUV±

3RU<%DODVKRY0-DQVVHQPresentism and relativity³%ULWLVK-RXUQDOIRUWKH3KLORVRSK\

RI6FLHQFH´WV±3RUWDNĪHQS%)6FKXW]:VWĊSGRRJyOQHMWHRULLZ]JOĊGQRĞFL

Z\G:DUV]DZDV±()7D\ORU-$:KHHOHUFizyka czasoprzestrzeniZ\GSRSU

:DUV]DZDV±

 Jan Czerniawski

ULHWDNUyĪQHMDNV]F]HJyOQDWHRULDZ]JOĊGQRĞFLWHRULDHPLV\MQD5LW]DLUyĪQHZD- ULDQW\WHRULLHWHUX]DNáDGDMąFHKLSRWH]\HWHUXVWDW\F]QHJROXEXQRV]RQHJR]KL- SRWH]ą VNUyFHQLD /RUHQW]D OXE EH] LWS PRĪQD NRQIURQWRZDü ] Z\QLNDPL W\FK

VDP\FKHNVSHU\PHQWyZMDNQSHNVSHU\PHQW0LFKHOVRQD0RUOH\D

7RĪHSU]HZLG\ZDQLDMHGQ\FK]JDG]DMąVLĊ]Z\QLNLHPGDQHJRHNVSHU\PHQ- WX MDNLP Z SU]\SDGNX ZVSRPQLDQHJR HNVSHU\PHQWX E\á EUDN VSRG]LHZDQHJR

SU]HVXQLĊFLDSUąĪNyZLQWHUIHUHQF\MQ\FKE\áZVWDQLHXVWDOLüNDĪG\NRPSHWHQWQ\

EDGDF]EH]Z]JOĊGXQDSUHIHURZDQąSU]H]VLHELHWHRULĊ:V]F]HJyOQRĞFLNDĪG\

]QLFKPyJáXVWDOLüĪHZ\QLNWHQE\á]JRGQ\]67:]WHRULą5LW]DWHRULąHWHUXFDá- NRZLFLHXQRV]RQHJRLWHRULąHWHUXVWDW\F]QHJR]KLSRWH]ąVNUyFHQLDQDWRPLDVWQLH- ]JRGQ\]WHRULąHWHUXVWDW\F]QHJREH]KLSRWH]\VNUyFHQLD²⁹=ZROHQQLNWHMRVWDWQLHM

PyJáE\ZSUDZG]LHXSLHUDüVLĊĪHE\üPRĪHMHJRWHRULĊPRĪQDWDN]PRG\¿NRZDü

E\MąX]JRGQLü]W\PZ\QLNLHPQLNWMHGQDNQLHSRWUDNWRZDáE\WHJRSRZDĪQLHGR- SyNLNRQNUHWQDPRG\¿NDFMDWHJRURG]DMXQLH]RVWDáDE\]DSURSRQRZDQDDZWHG\

]PRG\¿NRZDQDWHRULDPRJáDE\E\üNRQIURQWRZDQD]Z\QLNDPLWHJRLLQQ\FKHNV- SHU\PHQWyZGRNáDGQLHWDNVDPRMDNMHMQLH]PRG\¿NRZDQDZHUVMD

2F]\ZLĞFLHQLHZSHáQLNRPSHWHQWQL]ZROHQQLF\UyĪQ\FKWHRULLPRJOLE\QS

VSLHUDüVLĊF]\]DREVHUZRZDQRĪHHWHUQLHLVWQLHMHF]\WHĪĪHHWHULVWQLHMHW\ONR

SU]\U]ąGXOHJáVNUyFHQLX-DNMXĪMHGQDNZF]HĞQLHM]DXZDĪ\áHPZDUWRĞFLSURJUD- PXQLHSRGZDĪDIDNWĪHĨOHIXQNFMRQXMHQD]HSVXW\PNRPSXWHU]H7RVDPRGRW\- F]\SUHIHURZDQHMSU]H]HPQLHNRQFHSFMLPHWRG\QDXNRZHM

0RĪHZLĊFW\PFRPLDáRE\KDPRZDüUR]ZyMQDXNLE\áDE\Z\UDĪDQDSU]H- ]HPQLHSUHIHUHQFMDWHRULLNRQVWUXNF\MQ\FKSU]HGWHRULDPL]DVDG"-DNMHGQDN]D- XZDĪ\áHPZ\ĪHMZRF]DFKNRPSHWHQWQ\FKEDGDF]\WRF]\MDNDĞWHRULDNRPXĞVLĊ

SRGREDF]\QLHQLHPDĪDGQHJR]QDF]HQLD]HZ]JOĊGXQDMHMNRQIURQWDFMĊ]Z\- QLNDPL REVHUZDFML 1LJG]LH ]UHV]Wą QLH QDZRá\ZDáHP E\ WHRULL ]DVDG XQLNDü

]D ZV]HONą FHQĊ 5R]ZLą]DQLH QLHGRVNRQDáH MHVW OHSV]H QLĪ ĪDGQH -HĞOL MHGQDN

PRĪQDG\VSRQRZDüWHRULą]DUD]HPDGHNZDWQąHPSLU\F]QLHL]UR]XPLDáąZVHQ- VLH Z MDNLP ]UR]XPLDáH Vą WHRULH NRQVWUXNF\MQH D WHRULH ]DVDG QLH WR QLH ZL- G]ĊĪDGQ\FKSU]HFLZZVND]DĔZREHFWDNLHMSUHIHUHQFML3RXF]DMąF\MHVWSU]\NáDG

V]F]HJyOQHMWHRULLZ]JOĊGQRĞFLNWyUą(LQVWHLQVIRUPXáRZDáMDNRWHRULĊ]DVDGDOH

SRWHPQLHQDUXV]DMąFQLF]MHMQDMLVWRWQLHMV]\FKWUHĞFL0LQNRZVNLQDGDáMHMSRVWDü

teorii konstrukcyjnej^0\ĞOĊĪHPDáRNWRFKFLDáE\G]LĞ]WHJRZ\QLNX]UH]\JQR- ZDüQDU]HF]VIRUPXáRZDQLDWHRULL]URNX

-RGNRZVNLSU]\WDF]DRSLQLĊ.XKQDĪH]DGDZDQLHZREHFSHZQHMWHRULLS\- WDĔNWyUHQDMHMJUXQFLHQLHPDMąVHQVXPRĪHSURZDG]LüGRSRMDZLHQLDVLĊWHRULL

QDJUXQFLHNWyUHMVąMXĪVHQVRZQH1LHZLHPMHGQDNF]\ZRJyOHPRĪQDZVND]Dü

SU]\NáDGNLHG\WDNE\áR3U]\WRF]RQHGODLOXVWUDFMLWHMWH]\S\WDQLHGODF]HJRLVW-

293RU-&]HUQLDZVNLStruktura empirycznego testu teorii.UDNyZV±

3RU<%DODVKRY0-DQVVHQop. cit

2EURQDSURWR¿]\NLLIXQGDPHQWDOL]PX 

QLHMHVLáDJUDZLWDFML^QLHMHVWE\QDMPQLHMQDJUXQFLH¿]\NLQHZWRQRZVNLHMEH]- VHQVRZQHOHF]MHG\QLHWHRULDWDQLHSR]ZDODQDQLHXG]LHOLü]DGRZDODMąFHMRGSR- ZLHG]L-HĞOL]DĞQDJUXQFLHMDNLHMĞWHRULLPLDáRE\RQRE\üEH]VHQVRZQHWRE\áDE\

WRRJyOQDWHRULDZ]JOĊGQRĞFLU]HNRPRQDGDMąFDPXVHQV:VZRMHMJHRPHWU\F]- QHMLQWHUSUHWDFMLERZLHPZRJyOHQLHSRVWXOXMHRQDLVWQLHQLDVLá\JUDZLWDF\MQHM

WUDNWXMąFJUDZLWDFMĊMDNRZáDVQRĞüJHRPHWULLF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL^

:1,26(.

:ĞZLHWOHSRZ\ĪV]HMDUJXPHQWDFMLE\QDMPQLHMQLHZ\ND]DQRMDNRE\¿OR]R-

¿F]QHLPHWRGRORJLF]QHSRGVWDZ\SURWR¿]\NLE\á\EáĊGQH-HMPHWRGRORJLF]QH]D- SOHF]HMDNLPMHVWSHZQDIRUPDIXQGDPHQWDOL]PXHSLVWHPRORJLF]QHJRQLHSRSDGD

ZVSU]HF]QRĞü]ĪDGQ\PLXVWDORQ\PLIDNWDPLOHF]MHG\QLH]SHZQ\PLSRJOąGDPL

EH]SRGVWDZQLHSUHWHQGXMąF\PLGRVWDWXVXRELHNW\ZQ\FKXVWDOHĔ:EUHZRSLQLL

-RGNRZVNLHJRQLHRSLHUDVLĊRQDQDQDGPLHUQ\P]DXIDQLXGRIHQRPHQRORJLLOHF]

Z\NRU]\VWXMHMHG\QLHSHZLHQHOHPHQWPHWRG\IHQRPHQRORJLF]QHMGODUR]ZLą]D- QLDRNUHĞORQHJRSUREOHPXPHWRG\KLSRWHW\F]QRGHGXNF\MQHM=DU]XW]DĞMDNRE\

XSRZV]HFKQLHQLHVLĊRGSRZLDGDMąFHMMHMZL]MLQDXNLPRJáR]DV]NRG]LüUR]ZRMRZL

QDXNLRND]DáVLĊ]XSHáQLHEH]SRGVWDZQ\

6DPą SURWR¿]\NĊ MHGQDN PRĪQD UR]ZLMDü QLH]DOHĪQLH RG WHJR ]DSOHF]D

:SHZQ\P]QDF]HQLXVWDQRZLRQDXRJyOQLHQLHRSHUDFMRQLVW\F]Q\FKDQDOL]MDNLH

(LQVWHLQSRáRĪ\áXSRGVWDZWHRULLZ]JOĊGQRĞFL-HMRJyOQLHMV]\FKDUDNWHUZ\UDĪD

VLĊPLQZSRVáXJLZDQLXVLĊDSDUDWHPSRMĊFLRZ\PERJDWV]\PQLĪ]DVWRVRZDQ\

SU]H](LQVWHLQDOHF]Z]DNUHVLH]DVWRVRZDĔWHJRRVWDWQLHJRSR]RVWDMHRQDZFDá- NRZLWHM]JRG]LH]Z\QLNDPLX]\VNDQ\PLSU]H]QLHJR:]DNUHVLH]DĞZ\NUDF]DMą- F\PSR]D]DVLĊJWHJRDSDUDWXVWDQRZLKLSRWH]ĊQDWHPDWJHRPHWULLF]DVRSU]HVWU]H- QLZĞZLHWOHREHFQHMZLHG]\QDXNRZHMQLHUR]VWU]\JDOQąHPSLU\F]QLH:V]F]H- JyOQRĞFLQLHMHVWRQDVSU]HF]QD]ĪDGQ\PLIDNWDPLZLĊFZW\PVHQVLHQLHZ\PDJD

ĪDGQHMÄUHKDELOLWDFML´0RĪQDMHGQDN]JRG]LüVLĊĪHZSU]\V]áRĞFLUyĪQHMHMVNáDG- QLNLPRJą]RVWDüÄ]UHKDELOLWRZDQH´ZQLHFRLQQ\PVHQVLHPLDQRZLFLHPRJąX]\- VNDüVWDWXVKLSRWH]VSUDZG]DOQ\FKHPSLU\F]QLH

3RU.-RGNRZVNLFilozoficzny i metodologiczny fundament…V

 3RU QS ' 'LHNV Another look at general covariance and the equivalence of reference frames³6WXGLHVLQ+LVWRU\DQG3KLORVRSK\RI0RGHUQ3K\VLFV´WV±]ZáV