Baire measurability in C (2
𝜅)
Grzegorz Plebanek (Uniwersytet Wroc̷lawski)
joint work with A. Avil´es and J. Rodr´ıguez (Universidad de Murcia)
Integration, Vector Measures and Related Topics IV March 2011
Terminology and notation
For any family 𝒜 ⊆ 𝒫(X ) we write 𝜎(𝒜) for the 𝜎-algebra generated by 𝒜.
If ℱ ⊆ ℝX is a family of functions ten 𝜎(ℱ ) denotes the 𝜎-algebra generated by ℱ , i.e. the least 𝜎-algebra making all f ∈ ℱ measurable.
Baire and Borel sets
In every completely regular topological space X there are two natural 𝜎-algebras:
Bor (X ) generated by all open sets, and
Baire(X ) generated by all continuous functions X → ℝ.
Baire(X ) = Bor (X ) whenever X is a metric space, in general
Banach spaces C (K )
For a compact space K we can equipp C (K ) with three natural topologies
(C (K ), ∣∣ ⋅ ∣∣);
(C (K ), weak);
(C (K ), 𝜏p).
We can discuss five 𝜎-algebras on C (K ). Recall that Baire(C (K ), 𝜏p) = 𝜎(𝛿x : x ∈ K ), where 𝛿x(g ) = g (x ) Baire(C (K ), weak) = 𝜎(𝜇 : 𝜇 ∈ C (K )∗), where 𝜇(g ) =∫ g d𝜇.
Borel structures in C (2𝜅)
Bor (C (2𝜅), 𝜏p) = Bor (C (2𝜅), weak) = Bor (C (2𝜅)),
for every 𝜅 because C (2𝜅) has a 𝜏p-Kadec renorming (Edgar).
Baire structures in C (2𝜅) for 𝜅 ≤ 𝔠 Baire(C (2𝜅), 𝜏p) = Baire(C (2𝜅), weak),
for 𝜅 ≤ 𝔠 because every probability measure 𝜇 on 2𝔠 is a weak∗-limit 𝜇 = limn(1/n)∑
i ≤n𝛿xi for some sequence xi ∈ 2𝜅 (Fremlin).
For 𝜅 ≤ 𝔠 we have thus the Baire 𝜎-algebra on C (2𝜅) and its Borel 𝜎-algebra.
Theorem
Baire(C (2𝜔1), 𝜏 ) = Bor (C (2𝜔1), 𝜏 ) and, consequently, all the five
Why Baire(C (2𝜔1), 𝜏p) = Bor (C (2𝜔1), 𝜏p)?
Lemma
Suppose that K is such a compact space that for every n ∈ ℕ and every closed F ⊆ Kn, F is a decreasing intersection of a sequence (Fp)p∈ℕ of closed separable subspaces Fp ⊆ Kn.
Then Baire(C (K ), 𝜏p) = Bor (C (K ), 𝜏p).
Lemma
Every closed F ⊆ 2𝜔1 is a decreasing intersection of a sequence (Fp)p∈ℕ of closed separable subspaces Fp ⊆ 2𝜔1.
Kunen cardinals
𝜅 is a Kunen cardinal if 𝒫(𝜅) ⊗ 𝒫(𝜅) = 𝒫(𝜅 × 𝜅), i.e.
𝜎({A × B : A, B ⊆ 𝜅}) contains all subsets of 𝜅 × 𝜅.
If 𝜅 is Kunen then 𝜅 ≤ 𝔠.
𝜔1 is a Kunen cardinal.
𝔠 is Kunen cardinal under MA + non CH, but, consistently, 𝔠= 𝜔2 is not Kunen.
If 𝜅 is a Kunen cardinal then there is no universal measure on 𝒫(𝜅).
Fremlin’s result and a corollary
Baire(l1(𝜅), weak) = Bor (l1(𝜅), weak) iff 𝜅 is a Kunen cardinal.
If Baire(C (2𝜅), 𝜏p) = Bor (C (2𝜅), 𝜏p) then 𝜅 is a Kunen cardinal.
Theorem - the main result
Baire(C (2𝜅), 𝜏p) = Bor (C (2𝜅), 𝜏p) iff 𝜅 is a Kunen cardinal.
Corollary
C (2𝜅) is measure-compact whenever 𝜅 is a Kunen cardinal.
A Banach space E is measure compact if for every weakly measurable f : Ω → E there is a Bochner measurable g : Ω → E such that x∗g = x∗f 𝜇-a.e. (for any probability space (Ω, Σ, 𝜇)).
Equivalently, for every finite measure 𝜈 on Baire(E , weak) there is a separable subspace E0 such that 𝜇∗(E0) = 𝜇(E ).
Remark
Assuming the absence of weakly inaccessible cardinals, C (2𝜅) is measure-compact for any 𝜅. (Plebanek [1991])
Corollary
Under MA + non CH, Bor (2𝜔1) is countable generated.