Delft University of Technology
Economically efficient flood protection levels
Effects of system interdepencies
Dupuits, Guy
Publication date
2017
Document Version
Final published version
Published in
Integral Design of Multifunctional Flood Defenses
Citation (APA)
Dupuits, E. J. C. (2017). Economically efficient flood protection levels: Effects of system interdepencies. In
B. Kothuis, & M. Kok (Eds.), Integral Design of Multifunctional Flood Defenses: Multidisciplinary Approaches
and Examples (pp. 26-29). Delft University Publishers.
Important note
To cite this publication, please use the final published version (if applicable).
Please check the document version above.
Copyright
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent
of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.
Takedown policy
Please contact us and provide details if you believe this document breaches copyrights.
We will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.
This work is downloaded from Delft University of Technology.
"& "' 1&23b*53-*C*"/93"93'3F:-3E'.!"!'/+3".3/:+3VW=\ UJJ-3C&?%&'B3'/3!+C'&/B+./3?(345!&'*7"E3 T.%".++&".%A3('E*7/53?(3M"8"73T.%".++&".%3g3 b+?9E"+.E+9A3-+7(/3I."8+&9"/53?(3W+E:.?7?%523 4+3"93C'&/3?(3/:+3C&?#+E/3;V'(+/53'.!3&+7"'H"7"/53 '99+99B+./3?(3B*7/"(*.E/"?.'73(7??!3!+(+.9+9<23 b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a.6A5B.5B.BA@SP.KJ;IA5M;NN9.5P.C5K<J7.EU. 0@S7O7JX.SA7P.M@P4565@PB.MA;PK7.@O7J.65L7X. 4<7.6@.R@J.7V;LIN7.7M@P@L5M.KJ@S6AX.6A7. @I65L;N.B;R769.N7O7NB.MA;PK7.;B.S7NNU.$A5B.5B. 5NN<B6J;674.5P.C5K<J7.eU.+P.5P^47I6A.47BMJ5I65@P. @R.6A7.M<JJ7P6.<B7.@R.M@B6^87P7R56.;P;N9B7B.5P. 6A7.*76A7JN;P4B.M;P.87.R@<P4.5P.?5P4.[EFG\]U 'I7M5R5M;NN9X.7M@P@L5M.M@B6^87P7R56.;P;N9B7B. M;P.@RR7J.B<II@J6.5P.47M5B5@PB.J7K;J45PK.6@. SA7J7X.SA7P.;P4.A@S.L<MA.6@.5PO7B6U.QA7J7. 6@.5PO7B6.M;P.87.547P65R574.89.B7N7M65PK.N@M;^ 65@PB.SA7J7.87P7R56B.@<6S75KA.6A7.M@B6BU.C@J. 6A7B7.N@M;65@PBX.47M545PK.@P.SA7P.;P4.A@S. L<MA.6@.5PO7B6.M;P.87.B<II@J674.89.J7B<N6B. B<MA.;B.BA@SP.5P.C5K<J7.eU.+44565@P;NN9X.6A7. J7B<N6B.@R.;.M@B6^87P7R56.;P;N9B5B.M;P.87.<B74. 6@.MN;J5R9.6A7.B7JO5M7.N7O7NB.IJ7B7P674.89.6A7. K@O7JPL7P6.6@.6A7.I<8N5MU $A7.87P7R56.I;J6.5P.;P.7M@P@L5M.M@B6^87P7R56. ;P;N9B5B.5B.6A7.J74<M65@P.5P.RN@@4.J5B=U.$A7. RN@@4.J5B=.;BB@M5;674.S56A.;.RN@@4.47R7PB7.5B. @R67P.47R5P74.;B.6A7.RN@@4.IJ@8;85N569.65L7B. 6A7.RN@@4.4;L;K7U.QA7P.RN@@4.47R7PB7B.;J7. ;P;N9d74.B7I;J;67N9X.7;MA.RN@@4.47R7PB7.M;P. A;O7.56B.@SPX.5B@N;674.M@B6^87P7R56.;P;N9B5BU. 0@S7O7JX.@PM7.RN@@4.47R7PB7B.;J7.O57S74.;B. 47I7P47P6.@P.7;MA.@6A7JX.R@J.7V;LIN7.5R.6A79. R@JL.;.B9B67L.S56A.L<N65IN7.N5P7B.@R.RN@@4.47^ R7PB7BX.6A7.5P67J47I7P47PM57B.876S77P.RN@@4. 47R7PB7B.;NB@.P774B.6@.87.6;=7P.5P6@.;MM@<P6. 5P.6A7.M@B6^87P7R56.;P;N9B5BU. "./+&!+C+.!+.E"+93(?&3(7??!3!+(+.9+9 QA7P.47;N5PK.S56A.RN@@4.47R7PB7BX.6A7. J7N7O;P6.5P67J47I7P47PM57B.;J7.6A@B7.6A;6.
c<9.&<I<56B
$0,",.!0'((4)$--!0!$"#)-(,,*)5&,#$0#!,")($M$(+
1CC1($'./C.'-'$1!.%*$1,&1)1*(%1'
J"%*&+3K3L/?C3&"%:/P23 T]'BC7+3?(3'.3+E?\ .?B"E3E?9/\H+.+("/3 '.'759"93(?&3'3(7??!3 !+(+.9+2 A;O7.;P.5LI;M6.@P.6A7.A94J;<N5M.N@;4BU.C@J. 7V;LIN7X.M@PB547J.;.J5O7J.S56A.;.P<L87J.@R. 45=7.J5PKBX.;B.BA@SP.5P.C5K<J7.GU.%R.45=7.J5PK.G. A;B.;.8J7;MA.4<J5PK.;.RN@@4.7O7P6X.;.M7J6;5P. ;L@<P6.@R.S;67J.S@<N4.87.45O7J674.RJ@L.6A7. L;5P.J5O7J.5P6@.6A7.N@S7J^N95PK.N;P4.IJ@67M674. 89.6A7.45=7.J5PKU.1O7P.6A@<KA.6A5B.S5NN.IJ@8^ ;8N9.N7;4.6@.4;L;K7.87A5P4.45=7.J5PK.GX.N7BB. S;67J.S5NN.J7;MA.45=7.J5PKB.E.6@.\U.%P.@6A7J. S@J4BX.;.8J7;MA.<IB6J7;L.;6.45=7.J5PK.G.S5NN. J74<M7.6A7.J5B=.R@J.6A7.J7L;5P5PK.45=7.J5PKBU. CN@@4.47R7PB7B.6A;6.5P67J;M6.S56A.7;MA.@6A7JX. N5=7.6A7.@P7.47BMJ5874.5P.C5K<J7.GX.6A7J7R@J7. P@6.@PN9.IJ@67M6.6A75J.@SP.;J7;X.8<6.M;P.;NB@. 5PRN<7PM7.6A7.B;R769.N7O7NB.@R.@6A7J.;4>;M7P6. RN@@4.47R7PB7BU J7??!3!+(+.9+9A3"./+&!+C+.!+.E"+93'.!3&"9$ %P.6A7.IJ7O5@<B.7V;LIN7.;.I@B565O7.5P67J47^ I7P47PM9.7RR7M6.S5NN.@MM<J.5P.6A7.M;B7.@R.;. 8J7;MAU.0@S7O7JX.;.8J7;MA.M;P.;NB@.A;O7.;. P7K;65O7.7RR7M6X.R@J.7V;LIN7.5R.7V6J;.S;67J. 7P67JB.;P@6A7J.J5O7J.4<7.6@.6A7.8J7;MAU.$A5B. 7V6J;.S;67J.5PMJ7;B7B.6A7.RN@@4.J5B=.R@J.;J7;B. ;N@PKB547.6A;6.@6A7J.J5O7JU.$A7.M@PB7W<7PM7B. @R.5P67J47I7P47PM57B.M;P.6A7J7R@J7.87.756A7J. I@B565O7.@J.P7K;65O7U %P.L9.J7B7;JMAX.6A7.M@PB7W<7PM7.@R.5P67J47^ I7P47PM57B.A;B.877P.7VIJ7BB74.5P.67JLB.@R. MA;PK7B.5P.6A7.A94J;<N5M.N@;4BU.%P.@J47J.6@. W<;P65R9.6A5BX.6A7.O;J5@<B.A94J;<N5M.N@;4B.P774. 6@.87.L@47N74X.;B.S7NN.;B.I@67P65;N.8J7;MA7B. ;P4.I@67P65;N.RN@@4.4;L;K7.J7B<N65PK.RJ@L. B<MA.;.8J7;MAU.+B.6A7.87A;O5@J.@R.;.J5O7J.;P4. 56B.A94J;<N5M.N@;4B.;J7.5LI@J6;P6.SA7P.7B65^ L;65PK.RN@@4.IJ@8;85N569X.;B.S7NN.;B.I@BB58N7. 4;L;K7BX.5PMN<45PK.5P67J47I7P47PM57B.5P.6A7. M@B6^87P7R56.;P;N9B5B.5LIJ@O7B.6A7.RN@@4.J5B=. I;J6.@R.6A7.M@B6^87P7R56.;P;N9B5BU %P.@J47J.6@.W<;P65R9.6A7.RN@@4.J5B=.;BB@M5;674. S56A.;.RN@@4.47R7PB7X.6A7.5P67J47I7P47P^ M57B.P774.6@.87.5PM@JI@J;674.5P.IJ@8;85N569. J"%*&+3Q3L/?C37+(/P23 W?C38"+03?(3'3&"8+&3 0"/:3(?*&3!"$+3&".%923 W:+3'&&?093".!"E'/+3 C?99"H7+3H&+'E:+92 J"%*&+3f3L@?//?B3 7+(/P23T]'BC7+3?(3'3 E:'.%".%3+E?.?B"\ E'7753?C/"B'739'(+/53 7+8+73?8+&3/"B+3!*+3 /?3(?&3+]'BC7+3+E?\ .?B"E3%&?0/:23W:+3 <".8+9/B+./3".39'(+/5<3 7".+93".!"E'/+3/:+3 ?C/"B'73B?B+./93 L'.!3:?03B*E:P3/?3 ".8+9/2 J"%*&+3`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a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kt\uEF.M@L85^ P;65@PB.;J7.I@BB58N7U.Q56A.5P67J47I7P47PM57BX. 0$!*1)!.+"+)%*0%+*/.%/!/0+ĆŲœćĂĆċ $A5B.P<L87J.5PMJ7;B7B.R<J6A7J.5R.6A7.65L5PK.@R. 5PO7B6L7P6B.5B.5PMN<474U.C@J.7V;LIN7X.5P.M;B7. @R.;.65L7.BI;P.@R.GFF.97;JB.S56A.97;JN9.5PMJ7^ L7P6BX.6A7.P<L87J.@R.M@L85P;65@PB.J5B7B.6@. EFFF.;P4._EXkFFX.J7BI7M65O7N9U.$A7.MA;NN7PK7X. 6A7J7R@J7X.5B.P@6.@PN9.6@.R5P4.6A7.@I65L;N.B@N<^ 65@P.;L@PK.L;P9.45RR7J7P6.@I65@PBX.8<6.;NB@. 6@.M;NM<N;67.6A7B7.45RR7J7P6.@I65@PB.7RR5M57P6N9X. 5P.@J47J.6@.J74<M7.M@LI<6;65@P.65L7U J"%*&+3Y23T]'BC7+3 ?(3B*7/"C7+37".+93?(3 !+(+.9+3\34?*/&"H!"#$3 ".3O'$+31G99+7A3W:+3 R+/:+&7'.!93LF:?/?3 E?*&/+953G+99+3>77+.A3 R>V>3"B'%+9P