Delft University of Technology
Stakeholder value inclusive design
Using the contested issues game structuring approach (CIGAS) in Texas
Kothuis, B.L.M.
Publication date
2017
Document Version
Final published version
Published in
Integral Design of Multifunctional Flood Defenses
Citation (APA)
Kothuis, B. L. M. (2017). Stakeholder value inclusive design: Using the contested issues game structuring
approach (CIGAS) in Texas. In B. Kothuis, & M. Kok (Eds.), Integral Design of Multifunctional Flood
Defenses: Multidisciplinary Approaches and Examples (pp. 154-157). Delft University Publishers.
Important note
To cite this publication, please use the final published version (if applicable).
Please check the document version above.
Copyright
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent
of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.
Takedown policy
Please contact us and provide details if you believe this document breaches copyrights.
We will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.
This work is downloaded from Delft University of Technology.
!%$ !%% ! " # $ " % & '( % ) * ') + , -.* )
:;<=>7.?@6A<5B
+#'6$N,(*$&)M'(/$)!"0(/+!M$)*$+!%")
"'%*c.$01.(/*$1'$1&.%''"1'.c+!1.'$,"($",%*c.+)),/+(0.[(%c+'].%*.$13+'
-&23@'*$#+36?/:*"930'93'3F?9/!?E3".3/:+3VW=\ UJJ-3C&?%&'B3'/3/:+3J'E*7/53?(3W+E:.?7?%5A3 F?7"E53g3U'.'%+B+./A3WI3-+7(/3".3/:+3C&?#+E/3 ;1./+%&'/+!3!+9"%.<23M*&&+./7539:+30?&$93'/3 J'E*7/53?(3M"8"73T.%".++&".%3g3b+?9E"+.E+93'93 '3&+9+'&E:+&3".3/:+3R=S3F&?%&'B3;1./+%&'73 g39*9/'".'H7+3!+9"%.3?(3C?&/93".3>(&"E'<3'.!3 (?&3WI3-+7(/3'.!3W+]'9\H'9+!3*."8+&9"/"+93'93 '.3".!+C+.!+./3E?.9*7/'./3'.!3E?\F13".3/:+3 RVJ\F1DT3&+9+'&E:3'.!3+!*E'/"?.3+]E:'.%+3 C&?%&'B3hM?'9/'73J7??!3D"9$3D+!*E/"?.h3 /?3!+8+7?C3C'&/.+&9:"C93(?&3"./+&.'/"?.'73 &+9+'&E:3'.!3+!*E'/"?.23 W:+3M1b>V\'CC&?'E:30'93("&9/3"./&?!*E+!3".3 KXQQ3".3V?*/:3>(&"E'3".3/:+3b&+'/3@&'$3&+%"?.3 H53G"773V7".%+&A3VE?//3M*..".%:'B3'.!3O+?.3 4+&B'.93L9++3V7".%+&3+/3'723KXQ`P23W:+3B+/:?!3 0'93(*&/:+&3+7'H?&'/+!3(?&3/:+30?&$9:?C3".3 W+]'93".3KXQ`A3'93"./&?!*E+!3:+&+3L(?&3'3(*773 &+C?&/39++36?/:*"93+/3'72A3KXQ`P23W:+3'CC&?'E:3 :'93'79?3H++.3'CC7"+!3".3/:+3R+/:+&7'.!93 LT.+&%+/"E3R?&/:3V+'A3KXQYPA3?.3W+]+73LM?M\ ?M:'..+7A3KXQePA3'.!3".3b:'.'3LV*9/'".'H7+3 F?&/3-+8+7?CB+./A3KXQ[P23F7+'9+3E?./'E/3 #2:297".%+&z/*!+7(/2.73?&3H272B2$?/:*"9z/*!+7(/2 .73(?&3(*&/:+&3".(?&B'/"?.3?.3'CC75".%3"/3".3 5?*&3("+7!2 =+30?*7!37"$+3/?3+]C&+993?*&3%&'/"/*!+3/?3G"B3 @7'E$H*&.A30:?30'93".!"9C+.9'H7+3/?3*93".3 +]+E*/".%3/:"93M1b>V30?&$9:?C23 %R.S7.S;P6.6@.5PM@JI@J;67.L<N65IN7.R<PM65@PB.5P. ;.RN@@4.47R7PB7.B6J<M6<J7X.B9B67L.@J.B6J;67K9X. 56.5B.5LI7J;65O7.6A;6.S7.M@PB547J.6A7.45RR7J^ 7P6.;P4.@R67P.45O7JK5PK.5P67J7B6B.;P4.O;N<7B. @R.5PO@NO74.B6;=7A@N47JBU.'5PM7.6A7B7.5P67J^ 7B6B.;P4.O;N<7B.;J7.P@6.;NS;9B.B7NR^7O547P6X. B6;=7A@N47J.M@PB<N6;65@PB.;J7.;.O56;N.I;J6.@R.;P. 5P67KJ;674.;P4.B<B6;5P;8N7.47B5KP.6J;>7M6@J9. R@J.;.L<N65R<PM65@P;N.RN@@4.47R7PB7.[!CC&]U. 0@S7O7JX.M@PB<N65PK.B6;=7A@N47JB.M;P.87.4@P7. 5P.L;P9.S;9Ba.6A5B.M;P.J;PK7.RJ@L.Z5PR@JL5PKY. B6;=7A@N47JB.6@.;M6<;NN9.R;M5N56;65PK.6A7L.6@. 7VIJ7BB.6A75J.N@M;N.=P@SN74K7.;P4.O;N<7BX.;P4. 47J5O5PK.47B5KP.B6J;67K57B.8;B74.@P.6A5B.5PI<6U. %P.6A7.$7V;B.M;B7X.!CC&.J7B7;JMA7JB.A;4.6A7. @II@J6<P569.6@.M@P65P<7.47O7N@I5PK.;.P7S. 6@@NT.6A7.(@P67B674.%BB<7B.c+L7.'6J<M6<J5PK. ;IIJ@;MA.[(%c+']U %P.6A7.0@<B6@P.c;NO7B6@P.:;9.,7K5@PX.L;P9. 5BB<7B.P774.6@.87.;44J7BB74.SA7P.47B5KP^ 5PK.;.RN@@4.IJ@67M65@P.B6J;67K9T.67MAP@N@K5M;N. ;BI7M6BX.7M@N@K5M;N.;P4.7PO5J@PL7P6;N.R;M^ 6@JBX.;P4.B@M5;N.5BB<7B.[:N;M=8<JP.76.;NUX.EFG\a. '78;B65;P.76.;NUX.EFG\]U.*@6.B<JIJ5B5PKN9X.6A7. B6;=7A@N47JB.J7IJ7B7P6.;.N;JK7.;P4.7V6J7L7N9. 45O7JB7.KJ@<IU.%P.EFGE.^.SA7P.6A7.!CC&. J7B7;JMA.KJ@<I.87M;L7.5PO@NO74.5P.6A5B.M;B7.^. B7O7J;N.B6;=7A@N47JB.S7J7.;NJ7;49.O7A7L7P6N9. ;JK<5PK.;8@<6.6A7.Z87B6.B@N<65@PY.R@J.6A7.J7^ K5@PU.$A5B.A7;674.478;67.S;B.R<J6A7J.5PRN;L74. 89.6A7.N@M;N.IJ7BBX.;P4.J7IJ7B7P6;65O7B.@R.N@M;N. K@O7JPL7P6B.;B.S7NN.;B.I@N565M5;PBU./P.B7O7J;N. @MM;B5@PBX.5P45O54<;N.B6;=7A@N47JB.A7N4.85N;6^ 7J;N.M@PB<N6;65@PBa.;P4.N;JK7J.M@PR5K<J;65@PB. @R.B6;=7A@N47JB.L76.7;MA.@6A7J.;6.A7;J5PKB.@J. 5PR@JL;65O7.L7765PKB.SA7J7.7L@65@PB.@R67P. J;P.A5KAU.$A7.478;67.L;5PN9.R@M<B74.@P.6A7. IJ@B.;P4.M@PB.@R.B6J<M6<J;N.B@N<65@PBX.B<MA.;B. 8<5N45PK.RN@@4.8;JJ57JB.5P.6A7.'A5I.(A;PP7N.;6. 0@<B6@P.)@J6.;P4.:@N5O;J.,@;4BX.@J.MJ7;6^ 5PK.7V67PB5O7.N7O77.B9B67LB.;N@PK.6A7.8;JJ57J. 5BN;P4B.;P4.6A7.Q7B6.:;9.;J7;U.+N6A@<KA.;NN. I;J657B.B77L74.6@.S;P6.6@.R5P4.;.B@N<65@P.6A;6. IJ@67M674.6A7.0@<B6@P.c;NO7B6@P.:;9.J7K5@P. ;P4.IJ@O5474.7V6J;.R<PM65@PB.;P4.87P7R56B.R@J. 6A7.L;>@J569.@R.B6;=7A@N47JB.5PX.;.B@N<65@P.6A;6. B;65BR574.;NN.@J.L@B6.B6;=7A@N47JB.B77L74.R;J. ;S;9U.$A7.47M5B5@P^L;=5PK.IJ@M7BB.S;B.;6.;P. 5LI;BB7U &5BM<BB5PK.6A7B7.5BB<7B.S56A.;M;47L5M. I;J6P7JB.;6.,5M7."P5O7JB569.;P4.$7V;B.+2!. c;NO7B6@PX.6A7.!CC&.J7B7;JMA7JB.B;S.B5L5N;J5^ 657B.6@.@6A7J.L<N65R<PM65@P;N.RN@@4.47R7PB7. 47O7N@IL7P6.IJ@>7M6BU.C@J.;.IJ@>7M6.5P.'@<6A. +RJ5M;X.;.B6;=7A@N47J.M@PB<N6;65@P.;IIJ@;MA. S;B.47O7N@I74.6@.;44J7BB.N@M;N.O;N<7B.;P4.5P^ 67J7B6B.;P4.47;N.S56A.M@P67B674.5BB<7B.@R.RN@@4. L;P;K7L7P6.['N5PK7J.76.;NU.EFG\]U.+MM@J45PK^ N9X.6A7.67;L.IJ@I@B74.M@P4<M65PK.;.S@J=BA@I. ;N@PK.6A7B7.B;L7.N5P7B.5P.6A7.0c:.J7K5@PU.$A7. 5P67P65@P.S;B.6S@^R@N4T.C5JB6X.6@.;IIJ@;MA.6A7. 45BI<674.5BB<7B.5P.$7V;B.RJ@L.;.45RR7J7P6.;PKN7. [O;N<7^8;B74.5PB67;4.@R.B@N<65@P^8;B74]X.S56A. 6A7.5P67P65@P.@R.MJ7;65PK.M@LL56L7P6.R@J.>@5P6. ;M65@PU.+P4.B7M@P4X.6@.7VIN@J7.6A7.8@<P4^ ;J57B.;P4.L7J56B.@R.6A7.(%c+'.B6;=7A@N47J. M@PB<N6;65@P.L76A@4.5P.;.P7S.7PO5J@PL7P6U. $A7.L;5P.B6;=7A@N47JB.S7J7.=5P4.7P@<KA.6@. KJ;P6.6A5B.J7W<7B6X.;P4.K7P7J@<BN9.A7NI74.6@. R;M5N56;67.6A7.7P47;O@JU %P./M6@87J.EFG\X.S7.M@P4<M674.;.(%c+'. S@J=BA@I.5P.0@<B6@P.;P4.'7;8J@@=.(569X. $7V;BU.'5V677P.I;J65M5I;P6B.;667P474U.$A7. (%c+'.;IIJ@;MA.B6J5O7B.6@.M@^MJ7;67.5PB5KA6B. J7K;J45PK.6A7.M@P67B674.7PO5J@PL7P6X.<B5PK. ;M65@P.J7B7;JMAX.K;L7.B6J<M6<J5PKX.;P4.B9B67L. L@47N5PK.67MAP5W<7B.5P.;.6S@^4;9.S@J=BA@IU. '5PM7.I;J65M5I;P6B.;J7.<P47JB6@@4.6@.A;O7.45R^ R7J7P6.5P67J7B6B.;P4.O;N<7BX.6A7.K@;N.5B.P756A7J. 6@.J7;MA.M@PB7PB<B.P@J.6@.B@NO7.M@PRN5M6BX.8<6. 6@.7VIN@J7.6A7.45RR7J7P6.O;N<7B.;P4.5P67J7B6B. A7N4.89.6A7.B6;=7A@N47JBX.;P4.6@.M@PB547J. I@67P65;N.@<6M@L7B.R@J.6A7.M@P67B674.7PO5J@P^ L7P6U.+B.5PI<6X.6A7.S@J=BA@I.<B7B.=P@SN74K7. @R.6A7.N@M;N.85@IA9B5M;N.;P4.B@M5;N.B9B67LBX. J"%*&+3Q23V59/+B93 '.!38'7*+93'/39/'$+3 ".3/:+34?*9?.3 b'78+9/?.3@'53'&+'A3 '93+]C&+99+!3H53C'&\ /"E"C'./93?(3M1b>V3 =?&$9:?C3SE/?H+&3 KXQ`A3W+]'9A3IV>2!%& !%' ! " # $ " % & '( % ) * ') + , -.* ) ;P4.6A7.7RR7M6B.6A;6.6A7.5PRJ;B6J<M6<J7.L7;^ B<J7B.L5KA6.A;O7U. +.8J57R.47BMJ5I65@P.@R.6A7.;IIJ@;MA.<B74.5P.;. (%c+'.S@J=BA@I.5B.IJ@O5474.87N@SU.+P.7V67P^ B5O7.@O7JO57S.@R.6A7.L76A@4.M;P.87.R@<P4.5P. (<PP5PKA;L.76.;NU.[EFG\].;P4.56B.;IIN5M;65@P.5P. $7V;B.5P.?@6A<5B.76.;NU.[EFG\]U. :<5N45PK.KJ@<I.6J<B6.5B.;P.5LI@J6;P6.;BI7M6. @R.;.S@J=BA@I.SA7J7.B7PB565O7.5BB<7B.;J7.;6. B6;=7U.+B=5PK.I;J65M5I;P6B.6@.7VIJ7BB.6A75J. 6J<7.O;N<7B.;P4.5P67J7B6B.5P.;P.7PO5J@PL7P6. SA7J7.Z;4O7JB;J57BY.;J7.7VI7M674X.5B.;.47N5M;67. IJ@M7BBX.;P4.S5NN.P@6.@MM<J.SA7P.6J<B6.5B.;8^ B7P6U.C@J.6A5B.J7;B@PX.6A7.(%c+'.L76A@4.B6;J6B. 89.I7JB@P;N5d5PK.6A7.KJ@<I.6@.6A7.5P45O54<;N. BM;N7U.);J65M5I;P6B.;J7.O57S74.;B.L@J7.6A;P.;. J7IJ7B7P6;65O7.@R.;P.@JK;P5d;65@P.@J.BMA@@N.@R. 6A@<KA6a.6A79.;J7.;NB@.5PA;856;P6BX.O;M;65@P^ 7JBX.A@L7.@SP7JBX.SA@.;J7.M@PP7M674.6@.6A7. 0@<B6@P.c;NO7B6@P.:;9.J7K5@P.89.R;L5N9X.6J;45^ 65@PX.BI@J6X.S@J=X.I;BB5@PX.J7N5K5@PX.M<N6<J;NN9X. 76MU.$A7.S@J=BA@I.R;M5N56;67B.6A5B.I7JB@P;N5d;^ 65@P.89.;B=5PK.I;J65M5I;P6B.6@.5P6J@4<M7.6A7L^ B7NO7B.6@.6A7.KJ@<I.89.4J;S5PK.@P.;.N;JK7. L;I.SA7J7.6A79.N5O7X.SA7J7.6A79.@J5K5P;NN9. M@L7.RJ@LX.;P4.6A75J.;J7;.@R.5P67J7B6.;P4v@J. 7VI7J65B7.['67I.GU.Z!;I^7V7JM5B7YX.B77.C5K<J7.E. P7V6.I;K7]U.$A5B.B67I.@R67P.957N4B.<P7VI7M674. I7JB@P;N.M@PP7M65@PB.;6.6A7.5P45O54<;N.N7O7Na. ;P4.;6.6A7.KJ@<I.N7O7NX.56.MJ7;67B.45B65PM6.O5B<;N. 5PB5KA6B.5P6@.6A7.M@LI@B565@P.@R.6A7.M<JJ7P6. KJ@<IU.%P.6A7.$7V;B.M;B7X.56.87M;L7.5LL745^ ;67N9.MN7;J.6@.6A7.S@J=BA@I.I;J65M5I;P6B.6A;6. 6A7.7;B6.B547.@R.0c:.S;B.P@6.J7IJ7B7P674a.6A5B. S;B.B@L76A5PK.6A79.6@@=.5P6@.;MM@<P6.5P.6A7. J7L;5P47J.@R.6A7.S@J=BA@I.SA7P.;44J7BB5PK. ;P4.J7IJ7B7P65PK.B6;=7A@N47JBU $A7.ZJ7;NY.S@J=.6A7P.M@LL7PM7B.S56A.I;J^ 65M5I;P6B.47M545PK.;B.;.KJ@<I.SA;6.6A7.L;5P. B6;=7A@N47J.M@PR5K<J;65@PB.;J7.['67I.EU.ZQA@. M;J7BbYX.B77.$;8N7.GX.I;K7.Gk_]X.;P4.SA5MA.B9B^ 67LB.;P4.O;N<7B.;J7.;6.B6;=7.['67I.eU.ZQA9.4@. 6A79.M;J7bY.B77.C5K<J7.G]U.:@6A.B67IB.A7NI.I;J^ 65M5I;P6B.87M@L7.R<J6A7J.;S;J7.@R.M@LIN7V5^ 657B.;P4.L<N65IN7.5P67J7B6BX.MJ7;65PK.6A7.47B5KP. BI;M7.P77474.R@J.B67I.\U.%P.6A5B.R@<J6A.B67IX. I;J65M5I;P6B.BIN56.<I.5P.BL;NN7JX.L<N65^7VI7J65B7. KJ@<IB.;P4.;J7.J7W<7B674.6@.7PO5B5@P.;N67JP;^ 65O7.R<6<J7B.R@J.0c:X.SA5MA.J74<M7.RN@@4.J5B=. @J.IJ@67M6.6A7.;J7;U.+6.6A5B.B6;K7X.6A79.;J7. ;B=74..?/.6@.M@PB547J.6A7.47B5KP.@J.67MAP5^ M;N.5LIN7L7P6;65@P.@R.6A7.47R7PB7U.%PB67;4X. I;J65M5I;P6B.;J7.5PO5674.6@.5L;K5P7.6A7.@<6^ M@L7B.R@J.6A7.0c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k.[Z/<6M@L7BY].7;MA.KJ@<I.IJ7B7P6B. 6A75J.@<6M@L7B.6@.;NN.S@J=BA@I.I;J65M5I;P6Ba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a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jU.Z1VIN@J5PK.>@5P6. ;M65@PY]X.I;J65M5I;P6B.45BM<BB.6A7.47B5KP.BI;M7X. R7;B58N7.M@;N565@PB.@R.B6;=7A@N47JBX.;P4.I@67P^ 65;N.MN<B67JB.@R.;M65@PB.8;B74.@P.6A7.S@J=BA@I. ;M65O5657B.5P.'67I.G^_U.$A79.6A<B.7VIN@J7.6A7. BI;M7.R@J.M@LL56L7P6.6@.>@5P6.;M65@PU =?&$9:?C3S*/E?B+3'.!3J?77?03IC $A7.S@J=BA@I.IJ@O5474.5PB5KA6.5P6@.6A7. M@P67B674.B56<;65@P.89.7VIN@J5PK.6A7.R@NN@S5PK. 6AJ77.M7P6J;N.5BB<7BT ^.ZQA@.5B.;RR7M674.89.RN@@45PKbY Q@J=BA@I.I;J65M5I;P6B.547P65R574.7N7O7P. KJ@<IB.@R.B6;=7A@N47JBa.5P.R<J6A7J.45BM<BB5@PX. I;J65M5I;P6B.KJ@<I74.6A7B7.B6;=7A@N47JB.5P6@. 6AJ77.L;>@J.M@;N565@PB.[B77.$;8N7.G]U ^.ZQA;6.4@.6A7.B6;=7A@N47JB.M;J7.;8@<6bY. );J65M5I;P6B.45BM<BB74.;P4.47BMJ5874.6A7.B9B^ 67LB.;P4.O;N<7B.5LI@J6;P6.6@.6A7LX.SA5MA.;J7. BA@SP.5P.C5K<J7.GX.I;K7.Gk\]U.:;B74.<I@P.6A7. B6;=7A@N47JB.;P4.O;N<7B.5PO@NO74X.6A79.B<8B7^ W<7P6N9.47B5KP74.6A7.<6@I5;P.;P4.49B6@I5;P. I@BB58N7.Z@<6M@L7BY.@R.6A7.0@<B6@P.c;NO7B6@P. :;9.J7K5@PU.$A7B7.6@@=.6A7.R@JL.@R.ZJ5MA.I5M^ 6<J7BY.@R.I@BB58N7.RN@@4.M@P6J@N.L7;B<J7B.;P4. 6A75J.5LI;M6.@P.5PRJ;B6J<M6<J7X.6A7.7M@P@L9X. M565d7PBX.;P4.6A7.7PO5J@PL7P6U.C@<J.@R.6A7. B7O7P.BM7P;J5@B.45BM<BB74.5P.6A7.S@J=BA@I. ;J7.@<6N5P74.5P.$;8N7.EU ^.Z0@S.;J7.B6;=7A@N47J.O;N<7B.7L874474.5P. 6A7.@<6M@L7Bb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d74.6A7. 5LI@J6;PM7.@R.47O7N@I5PK.>@5P6.;M65@Pa.5P.6A5B. B7PB7X.6A7.S@J=BA@I.S;B.;.B<MM7BBU.$A79.;NB@. ;KJ774.6A;6.6A7.S@J=BA@I.IJ@O5474.;P.5PM7P^ 65O7.6@.R@JL.;.IN;6R@JL.SA7J7.=79^IN;97JB. M@<N4.45BM<BB.6A7.M@P67B674.5BB<7B.;P4.M@L7. 6@.;P.;KJ77L7P6.6@.M@@I7J;67.5P.6A7.R<6<J7U. C@J.6A7.J7B7;JMA7JBX.;IIN95PK.(%c+'.5P.6A7. 0@<B6@P.c;NO7B6@P.:;9.B56<;65@P.IJ@O5474. R<J6A7J.5PR@JL;65@P.@P.6A7.<B7R<NP7BB.@R.6A7. ;IIJ@;MAU.%6.957N474.5PB5KA6B.@P.A@S.56.M;P.87. ;4;I674.R@J.7O7P6<;N.R<J6A7J.<B7U.*7O7J6A7N7BBX. L<MA.J7L;5PB.6@.87.4@P7T.R@J.7V;LIN7X.;.R@N^ N@S^<I.S@J=BA@I.R@M<B5PK.L@J7.@P.R<PM65@P;N. 7PK5P77J5PK.J7W<5J7L7P6B.6@.R<J6A7J.7VIN@J7. I@67P65;N.RN@@4.J5B=.B6J;67K9.47B5KP.8;B74.@P. 6A7.O;N<7B.;P4.5P67J7B6B.7VIJ7BB74.89.6A7.N@M;N. B6;=7A@N47JB.5P.6A7.(%c+'^$7V;B.S@J=BA@IU W'H7+3Q3LH+7?0P2W:&++3 B'#?&3E?'7"/"?.93?(3 9/'$+:?7!+&93\3M1b>V3 =?&$9:?C3SE/?H+&3 KXQ`A3W+]'9A3IV>2 W'H7+3K3LH+7?03 H+7?0P23J?*&3?*/\ E?B+93?.3/:+3F'&+/?3 SC/"B*B3\3M1b>V3 =?&$9:?C3SE/?H+&3 KXQ`A3W+]'9A3IV>2 `I8.691 'H)$HY=HF?B)=HB) &?cAU?H=@?B)&?D=Q @GEH>YGS)VG@Y)"=@AL? +?DTQ&?DG=H@)0EJQ JAHG@G?> #Y?),U?LQ $HIGH??L?B)+EDA@GEH 7=G@GHI)TEL)@Y?)"?`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d7.A;J4.5PRJ;B6J<M^ 6<J7.@O7J.B@R6U.';R769.5B.;.A5KA.IJ5@J569U. CN@@4.IJ@67M65@P.5B.L5P5L;NX.;P4.IJ5L;J5N9.R@M<B74. @P.5P4<B6J5;N.d@P7B.SA7J7.6A7J7.;J7.@8O5@<B.7M@^ P@L5M.;P4.7PO5J@PL7P6;N.N@BB7B.6@.87.;44J7BB74U. "J8;P.7VI;PB5@P.M@P65P<7B.;I;M7X.S56A.L@J7.;P4. L@J7.M565d7PB.N5O5PK.;P4.S@J=5PK.5P.6A7.RN@@4.d@P7BU. O6I5"6I8.6910"62"8A1"F/5186"`48=9I9";"YHheD"E65S0A64"`.86J15"(,') R6./>"=28151080 ^. .'6;67.;P4.N@M;N. K@O7JPL7P6 ^. .(565d7PB.@P.6A7. S;67J.RJ@P6 ^. .(565d7PB.5P.6A7. B<JK7.d@P7 ^. .1PO5J@PL7P6;N. ;P4.6@<J5BL. . 5P67J7B6B _/8=62/>"=28151080 ^. .C747J;N.K@O7JP^ L7P6 ^. ."U'U.+JL9.(@JIB. @R.1PK5P77JB ^. .%P4<B6J5;N.;P4.I@J6. 5P67J7B6B ^. .CN@@4.5PB<J7JB ^. +L7J5M;P.I7@IN7 H2K5/085I.8I5/>"=28151080 ^. .%PRJ;B6J<M6<J7. . IJ@O5B5@P ^. .1L7JK7PM9. . J7BI@PB7.67;LB. J"%*&+3K23U'C3 +]+&E"9+3'/3M1b>V3 =?&$9:?C3SE/?H+&3 KXQ`A3W+]'9A3IV>2 :A511"9/765".6/>=8=620"6K"08/S1A6><150";"YHheD"E65S0A64"`.86J15"(,')