5\VXQHN ,, 7HRUHW\F]QH SDVPD DEVRUSFML FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QH GOD VWUXNWXU DONRKROL
LIHQROL
(WDS6SUDZG]HQLHREHFQRĞFLJUXS]DZLHUDMąF\FKD]RWJUXS\DPLQRZHM1+
L QLWURZHM 12
*UXSD DPLQRZD 1+
FKDUDNWHU\]XMH VLĊ Z\VWĊSRZDQLHP GZyFK
FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\FKSDVPZUHMRQLHRNRáRFP
±U\VXQHN,,$&KDUDNWHU\
VW\F]QH GOD JUXS\ QLWURZHM 12
Vą GZD LQWHQV\ZQH SDVPD SRFKRG]ąFH RG GUJDĔ
UR]FLąJDMąF\FKV\PHWU\F]Q\FKLDV\PHWU\F]Q\FK1±2SU]\LFP
±U\
VXQHN,,%
5\VXQHN,,7HRUHW\F]QHSDVPDDEVRUSFMLFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHGODVWUXNWXUDPLQDOLID
W\F]Q\FKSLHUZV]RU]ĊGRZ\FK5±&+±1+$L]ZLą]NyZQLWURZ\FK&±12%
,QWHUSUHWDFMĊZLGP,5XáDWZLDSRVáXĪHQLHVLĊRGSRZLHGQLPLSURJUDPDPL3U]\
NáDGHPSURJUDPXVáXĪąFHJRGRWHJRFHOXMHVW%LR5DG,50HQWRU3URU\VXQHN,,
3URJUDP]DZLHUDLQIRUPDFMHQDWHPDWFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\FKDEVRUSFMLJUXSIXQNF\M
Q\FK NWyUH PRĪQD Z\NRU]\VWDü Z LQWHUSUHWDFML ZLGPD 3RQDGWR GOD Z\EUDQHJR
DXWRPDW\F]QLH OXE ZVND]DQHJR SU]H] DQDOLW\ND SDVPD Z DQDOL]RZDQ\P ZLGPLH
Z\ĞZLHWODQDMHVWOLVWDJUXSIXQNF\MQ\FKRGNWyU\FKGDQHSDVPRPRĪHSRFKRG]Lü
0RĪOLZHMHVWWDNĪHX]\VNDQLHWHRUHW\F]QHJRZLGPDZ]DNUHVLH,5GOD]DSURSRQR
ZDQHMVWUXNWXU\
$ %
5\VXQHN,,2NQRSURJUDPX%LR5DG,50HQWRU3URVáXĪąFHJRGRLQWHUSUHWDFML
ZLGP,5
3U]\NáDGLQWHUSUHWDFMLZLGPD,5
1DU\VXQNX,,SU]HGVWDZLRQRZLGPRVXEVWUDWXVWRVRZDQHJRGRSURGXNFMLĪ\ZLF
IHQRORZRIRUPDOGHK\GRZ\FK :LGPR VXEVWDQFML ]RVWDáR RWU]\PDQH WHFKQLNą SD
VW\ONL ] .%U NWyU\ MHVW SU]HSXV]F]DOQ\ Z ]DNUHVLH ±FP
±SDVPD REVHU
ZRZDQHZZLGPLHSRFKRG]ąZ\áąF]QLHRGEDGDQHMVXEVWDQFML,QWHQV\ZQHSDVPD
Z]DNUHVLHSRQLĪHMFP
±ZVND]XMąQDDURPDW\F]Q\FKDUDNWHU]ZLą]NXSDVPDWH
SRFKRG]ąRGGUJDĔ]JLQDMąF\FK&±+SR]DSáDV]F]\]QĊSLHUĞFLHQLD3RWZLHUG]HQLHP
VWUXNWXU\DURPDW\F]QHMVąLQWHQV\ZQHSDVPDLFP
±SRFKRG]ąFH
RG GUJDĔ UR]FLąJDMąF\FK & & SLHUĞFLHQLD : ]DNUHVLH JUXS IXQNF\MQ\FK ±
FP
±REVHUZXMHVLĊEDUG]RLQWHQV\ZQHV]HURNLHSDVPRZ]DNUHVLHFP
±ZVND]XMąFH QD REHFQRĞü JUXS\ K\GURNV\ORZHM SRFKRG]ąFH RG GUJDĔ UR]FLąJDMą
F\FK JUXS\ 2±+ 3RWZLHUG]HQLHP Z\VWĊSRZDQLD JUXS\ K\GURNV\ORZHM Vą SDVPD
L FP
±SRFKRG]ąFHRGSRZLHGQLR RG GUJDĔ ]JLQDMąF\FK 2±+ Z SáDV]
F]\ĨQLHLGUJDQLDUR]FLąJDMąFHJR&±2%UDNZZLGPLHLQWHQV\ZQHJRSDVPDZ]D
NUHVLH ± FP
±ZVND]XMH QD EUDN JUXS\ NDUERQ\ORZHM QLH REVHUZXMH VLĊ
UyZQLHĪ GZyFK SDVP Z UHMRQLH RNRáR FP
±FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\FK GOD JUXS\
DPLQRZHM1+
5\VXQHN ,, :LGPR VXEVWUDWX VWRVRZDQHJR GR SURGXNFML Ī\ZLF IHQRORZR
IRUPDOGHK\GRZ\FKZ\NRQDQHWHFKQLNąSDVW\ONL].%U
2PyZLRQHHOHPHQW\LQWHUSUHWDFMLZLGPDSU]HGVWDZLRQRZWDEHOL,,1DSRG
VWDZLHDQDOL]\ZLGPDPRĪQDVWZLHUG]LüĪHEDGDQ\]ZLą]HNSRVLDGDSLHUĞFLHĔDUR
PDW\F]Q\ RUD] JUXSĊ K\GURNV\ORZą :\NRU]\VWDQLH GRGDWNRZ\FK LQIRUPDFML
R]ZLą]NXQS]QDMRPRĞüZ]RUXVXPDU\F]QHJRXPRĪOLZLDRNUHĞOHQLHVWUXNWXU\±
EDGDQ\P]ZLą]NLHPMHVWIHQRO3RWZLHUG]HQLHPSRSUDZQRĞFLLGHQW\ILNDFML]ZLą]NX
MHVW SRUyZQDQLH ZLGPD EDGDQHM SUyENL ] ZLGPHP UHIHUHQF\MQ\P :LGPD WDNLH
GRVWĊSQH Vą Z UyĪQ\FK DWODVDFK L NDWDORJDFK RUD] ELEOLRWHNDFK ZLGP UyZQLHĪ
ZZHUVMLHOHNWURQLF]QHM2JyOQRGRVWĊSQHELEOLRWHNLZLGP,5]QDMGXMąVLĊPLQQD
VWURQDFKLQWHUQHWRZ\FK6SHFWUDO'DWDEDVHIRU2UJDQLF&RPSRXQGV6'%61DWLRQ
DO ,QVWLWXWH RI $GYDQFHG ,QGXVWULDO 6FLHQFH DQG 7HFKQRORJ\ $,67 -DSDQ UL
RGELEDVHDLVWJRMSVGEVRUD]7KH1DWLRQDO,QVWLWXWHRI6WDQGDUGVDQG7HFKQROR
J\1,67&KHPLVWU\:HE%RRNZHEERRNQLVWJRYFKHPLVWU\
7DEHOD,,,QWHUSUHWDFMDZLGPD]ZLą]NXSU]HGVWDZLRQHJRQDU\VXQNX,,
3RáRĪHQLHSDVPD
ZZLGPLH>FP±@ ,QWHUSUHWDFMD
'UJDQLDUR]FLąJDMąFHJUXS\2+]ZLą]DQHMPLĊG]\F]ąVWHF]NRZ\P
ZLą]DQLHPZRGRURZ\P
'UJDQLDUR]FLąJDMąFH&±+DURPDW\F]QH
'UJDQLDUR]FLąJDMąFH& &SLHUĞFLHQLD
'UJDQLD]JLQDMąFH2±+ZSáDV]F]\ĨQLH
'UJDQLDUR]FLąJDMąFH&±2
'UJDQLD]JLQDMąFH&±+SR]DSáDV]F]\]QĊ
'UJDQLD]JLQDMąFHSR]DSáDV]F]\]QĊSLHUĞFLHQLD
'UJDQLD]JLQDMąFHSR]DSáDV]F]\]QĊJUXS\]ZLą]DQHMZHZQĊWU]Q\P
ZLą]DQLHPZRGRURZ\P
1D ]DNRĔF]HQLH ]HEUDQR NLOND SUDNW\F]Q\FK ZVND]yZHN 3U]\ LQWHUSUHWDFML
ZLGPZ]DNUHVLHSRGVWDZRZHMSRGF]HUZLHQLSRPRFQHMHVW
x
Z\NOXF]HQLHSDVPSRFKRG]ąF\FKRGUR]SXV]F]DOQLND
x
RNUHĞOHQLH SRáRĪHQLD LQWHQV\ZQ\FK SDVP Z ]DNUHVLH F]ĊVWRĞFL FKDUDNWHU\
VW\F]Q\FKGODGUJDĔJUXSIXQNF\MQ\FK!FP
±x
SU]\SLVDQLHJáyZQ\PSDVPRPGUJDĔRNUHĞORQ\FKJUXSIXQNF\MQ\FKNRU]\VWD
MąF]WDEOLFNRUHODF\MQ\FKWDEHOSURJUDPyZNRPSXWHURZ\FK
x
SRWZLHUG]HQLH REHFQRĞFL ]LGHQW\ILNRZDQ\FK JUXS IXQNF\MQ\FK Z LQQ\FK ]D
NUHVDFKZLGPDFP
±,QIRUPDFMą MHVW ]DUyZQR REHFQRĞü MDN L EUDN RNUHĞORQHJR SDVPD Z ZLGPLH
:]DOHĪQRĞFLRGZDUXQNyZSRPLDUXLQWHQV\ZQRĞüRUD]SRáRĪHQLHSDVPPRJąVLĊ
]PLHQLDüZQLHZLHONLP]DNUHVLH1LHMHVWNRQLHF]QHLPRĪOLZH]LGHQW\ILNRZDQLH
NDĪGHJR SDVPD Z ZLGPLH 3RWZLHUG]HQLHP RNUHĞORQHM VWUXNWXU\ MHVW SRUyZQDQLH
ZLGPDEDGDQHJR]ZLą]NX]ZLGPHPZ]RUFRZ\P
=DVWRVRZDQLDVSHNWURVNRSLLZ]DNUHVLHSRGF]HUZLHQL
$QDOL]D MDNRĞFLRZD. 6SHNWURVNRSLD Z SRGF]HUZLHQL MHVW SRZV]HFKQLH VWRVRZDQD
GRLGHQW\ILNDFML]ZLą]NyZFKHPLF]Q\FKJáyZQLHRUJDQLF]Q\FK3RGVWDZĊLGHQW\IL
NDFMLVWDQRZLSRUyZQDQLHZLGPDEDGDQHMSUyENL]ZLGPHP]ZLą]NXR]QDQHMVWUXN
WXU]H 'RVWĊSQH Vą REV]HUQH ELEOLRWHNL ]DZLHUDMąFH ZLGPD SUDZLH GOD ZV]\VWNLFK
JUXS]ZLą]NyZRUJDQLF]Q\FK1DSRGVWDZLHDQDOL]\ZLGPD,5 PRĪOLZHVąRNUH
ĞOHQLH JUXS IXQNF\MQ\FK Z ]ZLą]NX RNUHĞOHQLH VWUXNWXU\ LGHQW\ILNDFMD ]ZLą]NX
RUD]EDGDQLDRGG]LDá\ZDĔPLĊG]\F]ąVWHF]NRZ\FK
$QDOL]D LORĞFLRZD =DVWRVRZDQLD VSHNWURVNRSLL Z ]DNUHVLH ,5 Z DQDOL]LH LOR
ĞFLRZHM Vą RJUDQLF]RQH Z SRUyZQDQLX ] PHWRGDPL VSHNWURVNRSLL Z ]DNUHVLH 89
L9,6QDFRZSá\ZDNLONDF]\QQLNyZPQLHMV]DF]XáRĞüGXĪHRGVWĊSVWZDRGSUDZ
DEVRUSFML PQLHMV]D SUHF\]MD SRPLDUyZ =H Z]JOĊGX QD GXĪH VWĊĪHQLD EDGDQ\FK
VXEVWDQFML PRJą Z\VWĊSRZDü RGFK\OHQLD RG SUDZD /DPEHUWD%HHUD LFK NRPSHQ
VRZDQLHZ\PDJDVWDUDQQHJRSU]\JRWRZDQLDNU]\ZHMZ]RUFRZHM
0LPR W\FK RJUDQLF]HĔ PHWRGĊ ,5 Z ]DNUHVLH SRGVWDZRZ\P Z\NRU]\VWXMH VLĊ
WDNĪHZDQDOL]LHLORĞFLRZHMPLQGRR]QDF]HĔ]DQLHF]\V]F]HĔSRZLHWU]D
=DNUHV]DVWRVRZDĔVSHNWURVNRSLL,5MHVWEDUG]RV]HURNL:FKHPLLLELRFKHPLL
PHWRGDWDZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQDMHVWSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPGREDGDQLDVWUXNWXU\LZáDĞFLZR
ĞFL]ZLą]NyZFKHPLF]Q\FK]DUyZQRRUJDQLF]Q\FKMDNLQLHRUJDQLF]Q\FKRUD]RG
G]LDá\ZDĔPLĊG]\F]ąVWHF]NRZ\FK
6SHNWURVNRSLD ,5 MHVW V]HURNR Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQD Z WRZDUR]QDZVWZLH GR RFHQ\
MDNRĞFLWRZDUyZ-HVWSRQDGWRZDĪQąPHWRGąNRQWUROLSURFHVyZWHFKQRORJLF]Q\FK
6WRVXMHVLĊMąPLQGR
x
LGHQW\ILNDFMLLNODV\ILNDFMLSROLPHUyZ
x
EDGDQLD MDNRĞFL SDOLZ R]QDF]DQLD ]DZDUWRĞFL EHQ]HQX Z EHQ]\QLH HVWUyZ
PHW\ORZ\FKNZDVyZWáXV]F]RZ\FKZSURGXNWDFKQDIWRZ\FK
x
R]QDF]DQLD]DZDUWRĞFLWOHQXVLDUNLZĊJODZPHWDODFKLVWRSDFK
x
EDGDQLD ROHMyZ L WáXV]F]yZ URĞOLQQ\FK R]QDF]DQLD L]RORZDQ\FK L]RPHUyZ
WUDQV
x
DQDOL]\POHNDR]QDF]DQLD]DZDUWRĞFLWáXV]F]XPOHF]QHJRELDáNDLODNWR]\
x
DQDOL]\MDNRĞFLSRZLHWU]D
x
RFKURQ\ JOHE\ SU]HG ]DQLHF]\V]F]HQLHP EDGDQLD ]DZDUWRĞFL URS\ QDIWRZHM
LMHMVNáDGQLNyZ
=DJDGQLHQLDSRPRFQLF]H
=DVWRVRZDQLHVSHNWURVNRSLL,5
=DNUHV\SRPLDURZHEOLVNLHMSRGVWDZRZHMLGDOHNLHMSRGF]HUZLHQL
5RG]DMH L OLF]ED GUJDĔ F]ąVWHF]NRZ\FK GHILQLFMD GUJDQLD GUJDQLD ZáDVQH
GUJDQLDQRUPDOQHW\S\LHQHUJLDGUJDĔ
$QDOL]DGUJDĔF]ąVWHF]HNSURVW\FK
%XGRZDLG]LDáDQLHVSHNWURIRWRPHWUyZ,5
3U]\JRWRZ\ZDQLHSUyENLGRUHMHVWUDFMLZLGPD
,QWHUSUHWDFMDZLGPD,5Z]DNUHVLHSRGF]HUZLHQLSRGVWDZRZHMRJyOQH]DVDG\
DQDOL]\ZLGPD
,QWHQV\ZQRĞüSDVPZ,5
7HRUHW\F]QHF]ĊVWRĞFLSDVPRGSRZLDGDMąF\FKJUXSRPIXQNF\MQ\P
&]\QQLNLZSá\ZDMąFHQDOLF]EĊSRáRĪHQLHLNV]WDáWSDVPZZLGPLH,5
3DUDPHWU\EDUZ\
%DUZĊRNUHĞODMąWU]\SDUDPHWU\ WRQRGFLHĔQDV\FHQLHLQWHQV\ZQRĞüLMDVQRĞü
MDVNUDZRĞü7RQMHVWFHFKąFKURPDW\F]QąEDUZ\LRNUHĞODMHMURG]DMF]\OLF]\MHVW
WREDUZDF]HUZRQD]LHORQDĪyáWDLWG:WHUPLQDFKIL]\F]Q\FKWRQRNUHĞODQ\MHVW
MDNRW]ZGRPLQXMąFDGáXJRĞüIDOL 1DV\FHQLHRNUHĞODXG]LDáELHOLZGDQHMEDUZLH
%LRUąFSRGXZDJĊQDV\FHQLHPRĪHP\SRWRF]QLHREDUZLHSRZLHG]LHüĪHMHVWQS
PDWRZDOXEZ\UDĨQD%DUZDMHVWW\PEDUG]LHMZ\UDĨQDQDV\FRQDLPGDOHMOHĪ\RG
SXQNWXELHOLGDQHMSU]HVWU]HQLEDUZLMHVWW\PEDUG]LHMPDWRZDQLHQDV\FRQDLP
EOLĪHMSXQNWXELHOLOHĪ\ZSU]HVWU]HQLEDUZ)L]\F]QLHSDUDPHWUWHQRNUHĞODQ\MHVW
MDNRW]ZF]\VWRĞüSREXG]HQLD-DVQRĞüMHVW]ZLą]DQD]LORĞFLąĞZLDWáDRGELWHJRGOD
FLDá QLHSU]H]URF]\VW\FK OXE SU]HSXV]F]RQHJR GOD FLDá SU]H]URF]\VW\FK SU]H]
SU]HGPLRW%DUZDMHVW]DWHPSRVWU]HJDQDMDNRMDVQDOXEFLHPQD
%DUZ\FKURPDW\F]QHFKDUDNWHU\]XMąFHVLĊWRQHPPRJąVLĊUyĪQLüPLĊG]\VREą
ZV]\VWNLPLSDUDPHWUDPLEDUZ\QDWRPLDVWEDUZ\DFKURPDW\F]QHSR]EDZLRQHWR
QXUyĪQLąVLĊW\ONRMDVQRĞFLą
3RGVWDZRZHV\VWHP\SU]HGVWDZLDQLDEDUZ&,(
=DVDG\SRPLDUXEDUZ\RSDUWRQDZUDĪOLZRĞFLRNDW]Z]QRUPDOL]RZDQHJRREVHUZD
WRUDQDWU]\SRGVWDZRZHEDUZ\F]HUZRQą]LHORQąLQLHELHVNąRUD]QD]QRUPDOL]R
ZDQ\FKĨUyGáDFKĞZLDWáDELDáHJR
8NáDG&,(5*%
0DWHPDW\F]QH SU]HGVWDZLHQLH EDUZ\ MHVW RSDUWH QD WU]HFK SUDZDFK VIRUPXáRZD
Q\FKZ;,;ZLHNXSU]H]+*UDVVPDQQD=JRGQLH]SUDZDPL*UDVVPDQQDZFHOX
RGWZRU]HQLD NDĪGHM EDUZ\ Z\VWDUF]\ ]PLHV]Dü]HVREą Z RGSRZLHGQLP VWRVXQNX
WU]\ EDUZ\ SRGVWDZRZH 0LĊG]\QDURGRZD .RPLVMD 2ĞZLHWOHQLRZD Z GURG]H
XPRZ\SU]\MĊáD]DEDUZ\SRGVWDZRZHEDUZĊF]HUZRQąRRGSRZLDGDMąFąGáX
JRĞFLIDOLQP]LHORQąGRGáXJRĞFLIDOLQPRUD]EDUZĊQLHELHVNąB RûZLF]HQLD]GáXJRĞFLIDOLQP
5
QP
*QP
%
QP
6
5\VXQHN9,7UyMNąWEDUZ5*%
%DUZĊZSU]HVWU]HQLZ\UDĪDZHNWRUNWyUHJRNLHUXQHNRNUHĞODFKURPDW\F]QRĞü
WRQLQDV\FHQLHDGáXJRĞüGHILQLXMHMDVNUDZRĞü7UyMNąWEDUZ5*%SRZVWDáSU]H]
XPLHV]F]HQLHWU]HFKEDUZSRGVWDZRZ\FKZZLHU]FKRáNDFKWUyMNąWDUyZQRERF]QH
JR%RNLWUyMNąWDVWDQRZLąPLHV]DQLQĊGZyFKEDUZSRGVWDZRZ\FKLRGSRZLDGDMą
EDUZRPQDV\FRQ\PQDWRPLDVWSXQNW\OHĪąFHZHZQąWU]WUyMNąWDRGSRZLDGDMąEDU
ZRP QLHQDV\FRQ\P SRZVWDá\P SU]H] ]PLHV]DQLH WU]HFK EDUZ SRGVWDZRZ\FK
=PLHV]DQLH UyZQ\FK LORĞFL EDUZ SRGVWDZRZ\FK R G B Z\]QDF]D Z WUyMNąFLH
SXQNWELHOL6U\VXQHN9,$
8NáDG&,(;<=L<[\
6WZLHUG]RQR GRĞZLDGF]DOQLH ĪHQLH ZV]\VWNLH EDUZ\ QDV\FRQHPRJą E\ü RGWZR
U]RQHSU]H]DGG\W\ZQHPLHV]DQLHWU]HFKEDUZSRGVWDZRZ\FKRGB2ND]DáRVLĊ
ĪHLVWQLHMąEDUZ\EDUG]LHMQDV\FRQHQLĪEDUZ\OHĪąFHQDERNDFKWUyMNąWD5*%2G
WZDU]DMąF ]D SRPRFą EDUZ SRGVWDZRZ\FK ZV]\VWNLH QDV\FRQH EDUZ\ VSHNWUDOQH
LáąF]ąF SXQNW\ UHSUH]HQWXMąFH WH EDUZ\ RWU]\PDQR NU]\Zą EDUZ ZLGPRZ\FK
NWyUąQD]ZDQRspectrum locusU\VXQHN9,%:FHOXRWU]\PDQLDOLF]ERZHMFKD
UDNWHU\VW\NL SDUDPHWUyZ ZV]\VWNLFK EDUZ ZLGPRZ\FK VWZRU]RQR V\VWHP ;<=
ZNWyU\PU]HF]\ZLVW\PEDUZRPRGBRGSRZLDGDMąQLHU]HF]\ZLVWHEDUZ\SRG
VWDZRZH X Y Z 7UyMNąW 5*% ZUD] ]ZSURZDG]RQ\P QD QLHJR spectrum locus
PRĪQD ZSLVDü Z WUyMNąW UyZQRERF]Q\ OXE Z\JRGQLHMV]\ Z XĪ\FLX WUyMNąW SURVWR
NąWQ\U\VXQHN9,
$ %
5\VXQHN9,3URVWRNąWQ\]QRUPDOL]RZDQ\WUyMNąWEDUZ;<=
%DUZ\SRGVWDZRZHXYZZV\VWHPLH;<=VąQLHU]HF]\ZLVWHW]QQLHVąIL ]\F]QLHPRĪOLZHGRUHDOL]DFMLPRJąE\üMHGQDNREOLF]RQH]ZDUWRĞFLU]HF]\ZLVW\FK
RGBLRGZURWQLH]DSRPRFąRGSRZLHGQLFKUyZQDĔ
:V\VWHPLH;<=ZDUWRĞFLXYZRNUHĞODVLĊMDNRVNáDGRZHWUyMFKURPDW\F]
QHDF]ĊĞFLLFKVXP\R]QDF]DQHSU]H]xyz MDNRZVSyáU]ĊGQHWUyMFKURPDW\F]QH
ZVSyáU]ĊGQHWUyMFKURPDW\F]QHxyzRNUHĞODVLĊSRSU]H]QDVWĊSXMąFHUyZQDQLD
.Z Y X z Z Z ,
Y X y Y Z ,
Y X x X
9,
6XPDZVSyáU]ĊGQ\FKWUyMFKURPDW\F]Q\FKx y z WRWHĪZ\VWDUF]\RNUHĞOLü
GZLHZVSyáU]ĊGQHDE\]QDOHĨüWU]HFLą:VSyáU]ĊGQHWUyMFKURPDW\F]QHxLySR]ZD
ODMą XPLHĞFLü EDUZĊ Z SURVWRNąWQ\P WUyMNąFLH EDUZ L RNUHĞOLü MHM WRQ L QDV\FHQLH
SDWU] V\VWHP +HOPKROW]D -DVQRĞü EDUZ\ RNUHĞOD EH]SRĞUHGQLR VNáDGRZD WUyM
FKURPDW\F]QD Y 'R RSLVX SDUDPHWUyZ EDUZ\ Z\VWDUF]D ]DWHP VNáDGRZD Y RUD]
GZLHZVSyáU]ĊGQHWUyMFKURPDW\F]QHxLyV\VWHP<[\
6NáDGRZHWUyMFKURPDW\F]QHXYZ PRJąE\üREOLF]RQHQDSRGVWDZLHZDUWRĞFL
YxLy]]DOHĪQRĞFL
yy Y x
Z Y, , Y
y Y x
X
9,
:FHOXRNUHĞOHQLDUyĪQLF\EDUZGZyFKSUyEHNQDOHĪ\REOLF]\ü'Y'xL'yZH
GáXJQDVWĊSXMąF\FKZ]RUyZ
ǻ
Y YYb,ǻ
x xxb,ǻ
y yyb9, JG]LH
Y x y ± PLHU]RQHZDUWRĞFLEDGDQHMSUyENL
Yb
x
by
b± ZDUWRĞFLGODEDUZ\ED]RZHMEDUZ\]NWyUąSRUyZQXMHP\SUyENL
8NáDGPRQRFKURPDW\F]Q\+HOPKROW]D
: V\VWHPLH +HOPKROW]D WRQ MHVW RNUHĞORQ\ SRSU]H] GRPLQXMąFą GáXJRĞü IDOL O
'DQDV\FHQLHSRSU]H]W]ZF]\VWRĞüSREXG]HQLDP
e ,x x
x P x
y y
y P y
w d
w e
w d
w
e
OXE 9,
JG]LH
x
y ±ZVSyáU]ĊGQHWUyMFKURPDW\F]QHEDUZ\EDGDQHM
xd
y
d±ZVSyáU]ĊGQHWUyMFKURPDW\F]QHĞZLDWáDPRQRFKURPDW\F]QHJRO
'ZLHONRĞFLVWDEHODU\]RZDQH
xw
y
w±ZVSyáU]ĊGQHWUyMFKURPDW\F]QHSXQNWXELHOLĨUyGáDĞZLDWáD
:\EyUUyZQDQLD]DOHĪ\RGWHJRNWyU\OLF]QLNPDZLĊNV]ąZDUWRĞüEH]Z]JOĊGQą
'ODEDUZ\ZLGPRZHMGRPLQXMąFąGáXJRĞüIDOLO
'Z\]QDF]DVLĊSURZDG]ąFSURVWą
RG SXQNWX ELHOL % VWDQGDUGRZHJR ĨUyGáD ĞZLDWáD SRSU]H] SXQNW UHSUH]HQWXMąF\
EDGDQąEDUZĊZLGPRZą:GRSU]HFLĊFLDspectrum locusZSXQNFLHGRPLQXMąFHM
GáXJRĞFLIDOLO
':WHQVSRVyEO
'RNUHĞODWRQEDUZ\DRGOHJáRĞüSXQNWXEDUZ\RG
SXQNWX ELHOL RNUHĞOD F]\VWRĞü SREXG]HQLD P
eF]\OL QDV\FHQLH :DUWRĞü P
ePRĪQD
Z\]QDF]\ü]HZ]RUX9,OXEMDNRVWRVXQHNRGOHJáRĞFLaSXQNWXEDUZ\RGSXQN
WXELHOLGRRGOHJáRĞFLa + bSXQNWXELHOLGRSXQNWXO
'U\VXQHN9,
5\VXQHN9,:\NUHVFKURPDW\F]QRĞFL]GRPLQXMąFąGáXJRĞFLąIDOLO'GRSHáQLDMąFą
GáXJRĞFLąIDOLO&RUD]F]\VWRĞFLąSREXG]HQLDPeEDUZZLGPRZ\FKLQLHZLGPRZ\FK
$E\ Z\]QDF]\ü WRQ EDUZ\ QLHZLGPRZHM Z\]QDF]D VLĊ EDUZĊ GRSHáQLDMąFą
RGáXJRĞFL IDOL O
&GR QLHZLGPRZHM EDUZ\ EDGDQHM =QDMąF SDU\ EDUZ GRSHáQLDMą
F\FK VLĊ SRSU]H] EDUZĊ GRSHáQLDMąFą PRĪQD RNUHĞOLü WRQ EDUZ\ QLHZLGPRZHM
:FHOX Z\]QDF]HQLD O
&QDOHĪ\ SRSURZDG]Lü SURVWą RG SXQNWX UHSUH]HQWXMąFHJR
EDUZĊQLHZLGPRZą1SRSU]H]SXQNWELHOL%SXQNWĨUyGáDĞZLDWáDGRSU]HFLĊFLD
spectrum locusZSXQNFLHGRSHáQLDMąFHMGáXJRĞFLIDOLO'
QSEDUZLHQLHZLGPRZHM
RZVSyáU]ĊGQ\FKx Ly RGSRZLDGDEDUZDZLGPRZDRO
'QP
EDUZD ]LHORQD NWyUD MHVW EDUZą GRSHáQLDMąFą GR EDUZ\ SXUSXURZHM WDEHOD 9,
V &]\VWRĞü SREXG]HQLD P
eQDV\FHQLH EDUZ\ QLHZLGPRZHM 1 MHVW LORUD]HP
RGOHJáRĞFLeSXQNWXEDUZ\QLHZLGPRZHMGRSXQNWXELHOL%LRGOHJáRĞFLe + d SXQNWXELHOLGRQLHZLGPRZHMJUDQLF\spectrum locusU\VXQHN9,
5\VXQHN9,7UyMNąWEDUZ]GRPLQXMąFąGáXJRĞFLąIDOLO'RUD]NU]\Z\PLVWDáHMF]\
VWRĞFLSREXG]HQLDPeSU]\ĨUyGOHĞZLDWáD&
6XEVWDQFMĊ RSW\F]QLH F]\QQą VNUĊFDMąFą SáDV]F]\]QĊ ĞZLDWáD VSRODU\]RZDQHJR
]JRGQLH ] NLHUXQNLHP UXFKX ZVND]yZHN ]HJDUD QD]\ZD VLĊ SUDZRVNUĊWQą Ä´
DVNUĊFDMąFąZNLHUXQNXSU]HFLZQ\P±OHZRVNUĊWQąÄ±´
,GHQW\ILNDFMDLZ\]QDF]DQLHVWĊĪHQLDVXEVWDQFML
RSW\F]QLHF]\QQ\FKQDSRGVWDZLHSRPLDUXNąWD
VNUĊFHQLDSáDV]F]\]Q\SRODU\]DFMLĞZLDWáD
:DUWRĞüNąWDVNUĊFHQLDSáDV]F]\]Q\SRODU\]DFMLĞZLDWáDSU]H]VXEVWDQFMHRSW\F]QLH F]\QQH ]DOHĪ\ RG URG]DMX VXEVWDQFML VWĊĪHQLD EDGDQHJR UR]WZRUX JUXERĞFL ZDU
VWZ\SU]H]NWyUąSU]HFKRG]LĞZLDWáRGáXJRĞFLIDOLĞZLDWáDRUD]WHPSHUDWXU\
.ąW VNUĊFHQLD SáDV]F]\]Q\ SRODU\]DFML PLHU]RQ\ Z RGSRZLHGQLFK ZDUXQNDFK
W]ZVNUĊFDOQRĞüZáDĞFLZD > @ D
DMHVWZLHONRĞFLąFKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QąLVWDáąGODGDQHM
VXEVWDQFMLXPRĪOLZLDMąFąMHMLGHQW\ILNDFMĊWDEHOD9,,,
7DEHOD9,,,6NUĊFDOQRĞüZáDĞFLZD
>
ĮD@
Z\EUDQ\FKVXEVWDQFMLRSW\F]QLHF]\QQ\FK
6XEVWDQFMDRSW\F]QLHF]\QQD 5R]SXV]F]DOQLN
> @
D D*OXNR]D ZRGD
*DODNWR]D ZRGD
)UXNWR]D ZRGD ±
6DFKDUR]D ZRGD
6NUĊFDOQRĞüZáDĞFLZDMHVWWRZLHONRĞüNąWDRMDNLXOHJQLHVNUĊFHQLXSáDV]F]\]QDSR
ODU\]DFMLĞZLDWáDRGáXJRĞFLIDOLRGSRZLDGDMąFHMĪyáWHMOLQLLVRGXOLQLD' QP ZWHPSHUDWXU]H&SRSU]HMĞFLXSU]H]ZDUVWZĊVXEVWDQFMLVWDáHMRJUXERĞFLPPOXE
ZDUVWZĊFLHF]\RJUXERĞFLGP
:SU]\SDGNXUR]WZRUyZZGHILQLFMLVNUĊFDOQRĞFLZáDĞFLZHMXZ]JOĊGQLDVLĊVWĊ
ĪHQLH6NUĊFDOQRĞüZáDĞFLZąRNUHĞODZLHONRĞüNąWDRMDNLZDUVWZDRJUXERĞFLGP
LVWĊĪHQLXJPO
VNUĊFDSáDV]F]\]QĊSRODU\]DFMLĞZLDWáDVRGRZHJROLQLD' QP ZWHPSHUDWXU]H&
> @
»¼
« º
¬ ª
GP J
PO VWRSLHĔ
c
D l
D D
9,,,
JG]LH
D ± ]PLHU]RQ\NąWVNUĊFHQLDSáDV]F]\]Q\SRODU\]DFMLĞZLDWáD
c ± VWĊĪHQLHUR]WZRUX
l
± JUXERĞüZDUVWZ\UR]WZRUXZGHF\PHWUDFK
6NUĊFDOQRĞüPRORZDRNUHĞORQDMHVWZ]RUHP
> @ > @
M
ĮD
M D
9,,,
JG]LHM ± PDVDF]ąVWHF]NRZD
3RGVWDZąR]QDF]HQLDVWĊĪHQLDPHWRGąSRODU\PHWU\F]QąMHVW]DOHĪQRĞüNąWDVNUĊ
FHQLD SáDV]F]\]Q\ SRODU\]DFML ĞZLDWáD RG VWĊĪHQLD VXEVWDQFML RSW\F]QLH F]\QQHM
Z\ZRáXMąFHMWRVNUĊFHQLHZJPOUR]WZRUX
> @
>
JPO@
l c
D
D
D 9,,,
5XUNLSRODU\PHWU\F]QHZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQHZSRODU\PHWUDFKNRáRZ\FKPRĪQDSR
G]LHOLüQDGZDURG]DMHXQLZHUVDOQHLVSHFMDOQHWDEHOD9,,,5XUNLXQLZHUVDOQH
RGáXJRĞFLPPLPPZ\NRU]\VWXMHVLĊGRGRZROQ\FKSRPLDUyZSRODU\PH
WU\F]Q\FKDUXUNLVSHFMDOQH]HZ]JOĊGXQDLFKGáXJRĞüVąSU]H]QDF]RQHGRSRPLD
UyZRNUHĞORQ\FK]ZLą]NyZ
7DEHOD9,,,3U]\NáDG\REOLF]HĔVWĊĪHQLDVXEVWDQFMLRSW\F]QLHF]\QQ\FKQDSRGVWDZLH
SRPLDUyZ]]DVWRVRZDQLHPUXUNLSRODU\PHWU\F]QHMXQLZHUVDOQHMLVSHFMDOQHM
5RG]DM
UXUNL 'áXJRĞü
UXUNL =DVWRVRZDQLH
8QLZHUVDOQD PP
VWĊĪHQLHSUyENLREOLF]DVLĊZHGáXJZ]RUX
ZJPO
> @
lc
D
Į
Į
6SHFMDOQD PP
EDGDQLHVDFKDUR]\SRQLHZDĪGODVDFKDUR]\
Į
DZLĊF
Į Į
, ,
c Į
]DWHPRGF]\W]HVNDOLRGSRZLDGD]DZDUWRĞFLVDFKDUR]\
ZJPO
%XGRZDL]DVDGDG]LDáDQLDSRODU\PHWUyZ
3RODU\PHWU\VWRVRZDQHGRSRPLDUyZNąWDVNUĊFHQLDSáDV]F]\]Q\SRODU\]DFMLĞZLD
WáDG]LHOąVLĊQDGZD]DVDGQLF]HW\S\SRODU\PHWU\NRáRZHLNOLQRZH
3RODU\PHWU\NRáRZH:SRODU\PHWUDFKNRáRZ\FKSRPLDUXVNUĊFHQLDSáDV]F]\
]Q\GUJDĔĞZLDWáDVSRODU\]RZDQHJRGRNRQXMHVLĊSRSU]H]REUyWDQDOL]DWRUDVSU]Ċ
ĪRQHJR ]H VNDOą XPRĪOLZLDMąFą Z\]QDF]HQLH NąWD VNUĊFHQLD ZVWRSQLDFK U\VXQHN
9,,,
5\VXQHN9,,,6FKHPDWEORNRZ\SRODU\PHWUXNRáRZHJR±ĨUyGáRĞZLDWáD±NROLPD
WRU±SRODU\]DWRU±XU]ąG]HQLHSyáFLHQLRZH±UXUNDSRODU\PHWU\F]QD±DQDOL]D
WRU±SRNUĊWáRDQDOL]DWRUD±RNXODU
'RSRPLDUyZZ\NRU]\VWXMHVLĊĞZLDWáRPRQRFKURPDW\F]QHRO QPSR
FKRG]ąFH]ODPS\VRGRZHM:]GáXĪRVLUR]PLHV]F]RQHVąHOHPHQW\XNáDGXRSW\F]
QHJR SRODU\PHWUX ĨUyGáR ĞZLDWáD NROLPDWRU VHOHNW\ZQ\ ILOWU
±SU]HSXV]F]DMąF\
W\ONRĞZLDWáRRO QPSRODU\]DWRUSRODURLGRZ\
±SRODU\]XMąF\OLQLRZRQDWX
UDOQHĞZLDWáR]HĨUyGáDXU]ąG]HQLHSyáFLHQLRZH±]áRĪRQH]GZyFKSá\WHN/DXUHQWD
NRPRUDZNWyUHMXPLHV]F]DVLĊUXUNLSRODU\PHWU\F]QH]EDGDQąSUyENąREURWRZ\
DQDOL]DWRUSRODURLGRZ\RELHNW\ZRNXODULWDUF]DVNDOLNąWRZHM±
=DVDGD G]LDáDQLD SRODU\PHWUX NRáRZHJR VSURZDG]D VLĊ GR Z\JDV]DQLD ĞZLDWáD
VSRODU\]RZDQHJROLQLRZRSU]H]REUyWDQDOL]DWRUDVNU]\ĪRZDQLHSáDV]F]\]Q\SU]H
SXV]F]DQLDDQDOL]DWRUD]SáDV]F]\]QąGUJDĔĞZLDWáDVSRODU\]RZDQHJR
3RODU\PHWU\NOLQRZH :SRODU\PHWUDFKNOLQRZ\FKNąWVNUĊFHQLDSáDV]F]\]Q\
GUJDĔ SURPLHQLRZDQLD Z\ZRáDQ\ REHFQRĞFLą VXEVWDQFML RSW\F]QLHF]\QQHM NRP
SHQVXMH VLĊ SU]H] ZSURZDG]HQLH NOLQD NZDUFRZHJR R VNUĊFDOQRĞFL SU]HFLZQHM
ZVWRVXQNXGR Z\ND]\ZDQHM SU]H]EDGDQą VXEVWDQFMĊ3RODU\PHWU\ NOLQRZH VáXĪą
SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPGREDGDQLDUR]WZRUyZVDFKDUR]\DOHPRĪOLZHMHVWLFK]DVWRVR
ZDQLHGREDGDQLDLQQ\FKVXEVWDQFMLRSW\F]QLHF]\QQ\FK
: VDFKDU\PHWUDFK VWRVXMH VLĊ ĞZLDWáR ELDáH -HVW WR PRĪOLZH ]H Z]JOĊGX QD
]ELHĪQRĞüG\VSHUVMLURWDF\MQHM]DOHĪQRĞFLNąWDVNUĊFHQLDĞZLDWáDVSRODU\]RZDQHJR
OLQLRZR RG GáXJRĞFL IDOL VDFKDUR]\ L NZDUFX )XQNFMĊ SRODU\]DWRUD L DQDOL]DWRUD
SHáQLąGZDVNU]\ĪRZDQHQDVWDáHSU\]PDW\1LFRODĝZLDWáRVSRODU\]RZDQHOLQLRZR
SU]H]SRODU\]DWRUSU]HFKRG]LSU]H]UXUNĊSRODU\PHWU\F]QąSá\WNĊ]NZDUFXSUDZR
VNUĊWQHJRPDá\NRQWUNOLQ]NZDUFXOHZRVNUĊWQHJRPDá\NOLQ]NZDUFXOHZRVNUĊW
QHJR XPRĪOLZLDMąF\ SRPLDU\ VXEVWDQFML OHZRVNUĊWQ\FK L XPRFRZDQ\ QLHUXFKRPR
DQDOL]DWRUU\VXQHN9,,,
5\VXQHN 9,,, 6FKHPDW EORNRZ\ SRODU\PHWUX NOLQRZHJR ± ĨUyGáR ĞZLDWáD
±NROLPDWRU±SRODU\]DWRU±XU]ąG]HQLHSyáFLHQLRZH±UXUNDSRODU\PHWU\F]QD
±EORN]NZDUFXSUDZRVNUĊWQHJR±UXFKRP\NOLQ]NZDUFXOHZRVNUĊWQHJR±QLH
UXFKRP\NOLQ]NZDUFXOHZRVNUĊWQHJR±DQDOL]DWRU±RNXODU
3RPLDUSROHJDQDNRPSHQVDFMLNąWDVNUĊFHQLDF]HJRGRNRQXMHVLĊSU]H]]PLDQĊ
JUXERĞFLZVXZDQLHOXEZ\VXZDQLHZRĞRSW\F]QąNOLQDNZDUFRZHJRRVNUĊFDOQR
ĞFLRGZURWQHMQLĪVNUĊFDOQRĞüVXEVWDQFMLEDGDQHM6NDODMHVWZ\FHFKRZDQDZMHG
QRVWNDFK Ä=´ 0LĊG]\QDURGRZHM 6NDOL &XNURZHM QD SRGVWDZLH W]Z RGZDĪNL QRU
PDOQHM
6NUĊFDOQRĞüUR]WZRUX]DZLHUDMąFHJRJFKHPLF]QLHF]\VWHMEH]ZRGQHMVDFKD
UR]\ Z PO ZRG\ PLHU]RQD Z UXUFH SRODU\PHWU\F]QHM R GáXJRĞFL PP
ZWHPSHUDWXU]H & RGSRZLDGD = 6WąG MHGHQ VWRSLHĔ VNDOL FXNURZHM RGSR
ZLDGDJVDFKDUR]\ZPOUR]WZRUX2GF]\WQDVNDOLFXNURZHMRGSRZLDGD
SURFHQWRZLFXNUXZEDGDQHMSUyEFHZSU]\SDGNXSREUDQLDW]ZRGZDĪNLQRUPDOQHM
JSUyENLZPOZRG\3U]HOLF]HQLDVNDOLFXNURZHMQDNRáRZąZVWRSQLDFK
NąWRZ\FKGRNRQXMHVLĊPQRĪąFZ\QLNZVWRSQLDFKVNDOLÄ=´SU]H]ZVSyáF]\QQLN
3RODU\PHWU\ DXWRPDW\F]QH 6áXĪą GR R]QDF]HĔ SRODU\PHWU\F]Q\FK RSDUW\FK
QD SRPLDU]H NąWD VNUĊFHQLD SáDV]F]\]Q\ SRODU\]DFML ĞZLDWáD :\SRVDĪRQH Vą ]D
]Z\F]DM Z VNDOH NąWRZą RG ± GR RUD] FXNURZą Z ]DNUHVLH QDZHW RG
í= GR = 3RPLDUyZ PRĪQD GRNRQ\ZDü SU]\ UyĪQ\FK GáXJRĞFLDFK IDO
LQP
=DVWRVRZDQLDSRODU\PHWULL
3RODU\PHWULD Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQD MHVW Z DQDOL]LH MDNRĞFLRZHM L LORĞFLRZHM UR]WZRUyZ
VXEVWDQFML RSW\F]QLH F]\QQ\FK WDNLFK MDN FXNU\ VDFKDUR]D JOXNR]D PDOWR]D
ELDáNDDQW\ELRW\NLLDONDORLG\3RGVWDZąLGHQW\ILNDFML]ZLą]NyZFKHPLF]Q\FKMHVW
ZDUWRĞü LFK VNUĊFDOQRĞFL ZáDĞFLZHM 'R R]QDF]HĔ LORĞFLRZ\FK Z\NRU]\VWXMH VLĊ
]DOHĪQRĞü ZDUWRĞFL NąWD VNUĊFHQLD SáDV]F]\]Q\ SRODU\]DFML RG VWĊĪHQLD VXEVWDQFML
RSW\F]QLHF]\QQHM
=DUyZQRSRODU\PHWU\F]QDDQDOL]DMDNRĞFLRZDMDNLLORĞFLRZD]QDMGXMąZLHOH]D
VWRVRZDĔZUyĪQ\FKG]LHG]LQDFKPLQZSU]HP\ĞOHFXNURZQLF]\PVSRĪ\ZF]\P
IDUPDFHXW\F]Q\PNRVPHW\F]Q\PFKHPLF]Q\PLZEDGDQLDFKNOLQLF]Q\FK$QDOL]D