On Reynolds Number Dependence of Micro-ramp-Induced Transition

Pełen tekst

(1)Delft University of Technology. On Reynolds Number Dependence of Micro-ramp-Induced Transition Ye, Qingqing; Schrijer, Ferdinand; Scarano, Fulvio. Publication date 2016 Document Version Final published version Published in Proceedings of the 18th International Symposium on the Application of Laser and Imaging Techniques to Fluid Mechanics. Citation (APA) Ye, Q., Schrijer, F., & Scarano, F. (2016). On Reynolds Number Dependence of Micro-ramp-Induced Transition. In Proceedings of the 18th International Symposium on the Application of Laser and Imaging Techniques to Fluid Mechanics Lisbon, Portugal: Springer. Important note To cite this publication, please use the final published version (if applicable). Please check the document version above.. Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons. Takedown policy Please contact us and provide details if you believe this document breaches copyrights. We will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.. This work is downloaded from Delft University of Technology. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to a maximum of 10..

(2) PROCEEDINGS OF THE. 18th INTERNATIONAL. SYMPOSIUM ON APPLICATION OF LASER AND IMAGING. TECHNIQUES TO FLUID MECHANICS.

(3)

(4) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . .

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

(6) E4 @C ; 8<:; G FGE84@J<F8 +;8 <AFG4AG4A8BHF 4A7 G<@84I8E4 :87 9?BJ GBCB?B:L 4E8 6;4E46G8E<M87 <A 78G4<? 9B6HF<A: BA G; 8 <A9?H8A68B9)8LA B?7FAH@58E@4<A7<998E8A68<FG;8?BA:8EFGE84@J<F8CE8F8A68E4A:8B9CE<@4ELIBEG8K C4<E<A G;8 G<@84I8E4 :87 9?BJ GBCB?B:L 4 G 6E<G<64? %( 6B@C4E87 J<G; FHC8E6E<G<64? 6BA7<G<BA E8FH?G<A: <A 7<998E8AG GLC8 @B7<9<64G<BAGBG;8 @84A9?BJ+;8 GE4AF<G<BACEB68FF<FF<:A<9<64AG?L78?4L87 J;8A786E84F<A:%( LC8E9BE@<A : 'EBC8E&EG;B:BA4?86B@CBF<G<BA'&4A4?LF<FGJB@4=BEGLC8F B98<:8A @B78FJ<G; FL@@8GE<6 4A74FL@@8GE<6 FC4G<4? 7<FGE<5HG<BA B9 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF <A G;8 A84E J4>8 4E8 B5F8EI87 6BEE8FCBA7<A: GB G;8 CE8F8A68 IBEG8K F;877<A: 4A7 F<AHBHF J<::?<A: @BG<BA E8FC86G<I8?L +;8 6BEE8?4G<BA 58GJ88A G; 8 9BE@8E '& @B78F 4A7 G; 8 GE4AF<G<BACEB68FFFGEBA:?L78C8A7FBA%( . !"! +;8EB?8B9FHE9468EBH:;A8FFBA5BHA74EL?4L8EGE4AF<G<BA<FB9F<:A<9<64AG<@CBEG4A687H8GB<GF <@C46G <A 48EB7LA4@<6 4A7 48EBG;8E@B7LA4@<6 CEB5?8@F +LC<64??L G;8 89986G B9 EBH:;A8FF 8?8@8AGF <A CEB@BG<A: 5BHA74EL ?4L8E GE4AF<G<BA <F 8FG<@4G87 5L G;8 EBH:;A8FF;8<:;G 54F87 )8LAB?7F AH@58E 789<A87 4F %( 2( 8(ȣ J;8E8 ( <F G;8 EBH:;A8FF ;8<:;G 4A7 2( <F G;8 FGE84@J<F8 I8?B6<GL 4G G;4G ;8<:;G +4A< I4A E<8FG 4A7 $64H?8L BE 4 GJB 7<@8AF<BA4?EBH:;A8FF8?8@8AGJ<G;BHGFC4AJ<F8I4E<4G<BA8:FG8C:4CBEE<55BAG;8A4GHE4? GE4AF<G<BA CEB68FF <F CEB@BG87 5L 4@C?<9<64G<BA B9 +B??@<8A*6;?<6;G<A: +* J4I8F 4G G;8 7BJAFGE84@ F8C4E4G<BA E8:<BAB9 G;8 EBH:;A8FF "?854AB99 4A7 +<7FGEB@ A6E84F<A: %( G;8 GE4AF<G<BA ?B64G<BA :E47H4??L @BI8F HCFGE84@ 6?BF8E GB G;8 EBH:;A8FF 8?8@8AG BE G;E88 7<@8AF<BA4? 7<FGE<5HG87 BE <FB?4G87 EBH:;A8FF 4 6E<G<64? I4?H8 B9 %( J4F B5G4<A87 5L 8KC8E<@8AGF +4A< 8G 4? .;8A 8K6887<A: G;<F I4?H8 GE4AF<G<BA J<?? E4C<7?L @BI8 HCFGE84@ AFG84758?BJG;86E<G<64?%( G;89?BJ<AG;8J4>8B9G;8EBH:;A8FF8?8@8AGE8@4<AF.

(7)

(8) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . FG45?8 "?854AB99 8G 4? CEBCBF87 4A 8@C<E<64? 8FG<@4G8 B9 G;8 6E<G<64? %( 9BE G;E88 7<@8AF<BA4?<FB?4G87EBH:;A8FFJ<G;4FC86GE4G<B(#B9HA<GL4F87BA8K<FG<A:8KC8E<@8AG4? E8FH?GFG;8LCEBCBF87G;4G%(#/)1?<8F<AG;8E4A:858GJ88A 4A7 9BE<A6B@CE8FF<5?89?BJF +;8 8@C<E<64? 6BEE8?4G<BA B998EF 4 54F<6 :H<78?<A8 9BECE87<6G<BA B9 9BE687 GE4AF<G<BA BJ8I8E G;8 6E<G<64? )8LAB?7F AH@58E <F FG<?? <A9?H8A687 5L @4AL 946GBEF FH6; 4F EBH:;A8FFF;4C8 4A7 9E88FGE84@ 7<FGHE54A68 ?8I8? DH8FG<BA<A: G;8 :8A8E4?<GL B9 G;8 CEBCBF87 I4?H8 $BE8BI8E G;8 C;LF<64? @86;4A<F@ B9 EBH:;A8FF <A7H687 GE4AF<G<BA 58;<A7 G;E887<@8AF<BA4? EBH:;A8FF 8?8@8AGF 4G 7<998E8AG )8LAB?7F AH@58EF <F 94E 9EB@ 58<A: 9H??L HA78EFGBB7 4A7 A887F GB 58 9HEG;8E 6BAFB?<74G87 A BE78E GB <ADH<E8 G;8 9<78?<GL B9 AH@8E<64? F<@H?4G<BAF GB CE87<6G GE4AF<G<BA 4 @BE8 466HE4G8 4A7 78G4<?87 8KC8E<@8AG4? 6;4E46G8E<M4G<BA B9 G;8 9?BJ 58;4I<BHE<F A868FF4EL A 4 ?4@<A4E 5BHA74EL ?4L8E 4 G;E887<@8AF<BA4? <FB?4G87 EBH:;A8FF 8?8@8AG <AGEB7H68F 4 FC4AJ<F8789?86G<BAB9G;8I8?B6<GL9<8?76<E6H?4GBEL@BG<BA<F<A7H687<A5BG;HCFGE84@4A7 7BJAFGE84@ F8C4E4G<BA E8:<BA ?847<A: GB G;8 9BE@4G<BA B9 FGE84@J<F8 IBEG<68F <A G;8 J4>8 E4AFFBA 8G 4? +;8 FGE84@J<F8 IBEG<68F <A7H68 4A HCJ4F; @BG<BA BA BA8 F<78 GE4AFCBEG<A:?BJ@B@8AGH@9?H<74J4L9EB@G;8J4??4A7BAG;8BG;8EF<78G;8LFJ88C;<:; @B@8AGH@ 9?H<7 GBJ4E7F G;8 J4?? E8FH?G<A: <A G;8 9BE@4G<BA B9 ?BJ 4A7 ;<:;FC887 FGE84>F J;<6; @B7H?4G8 G;8FHE9468 F;84E<A G;8 FC4AJ<F8 7<E86G<BA *<@<?4E?L <A G;8 5LC4FF GE4AF<G<BA CEB68FFG;89BE@4G<BAB9I8?B6<GLFGE84>FG;EBH:;G;8‘liftup’@86;4A<F@G4>8FBI8EG;8EB?8B9 +* J4I8F <A G;8 CEB68FF B9 G;8 :EBJG; B9 G;8 C8EGHE54G<BAF #4A74;? &A68 G;8 FGE84> 4@C?<GH78 8K6887F 4 6E<G<64? I4?H8 G;8 FGE84> J<?? 58 FH5=86G GB 4 F86BA74EL <AFG45<?<GL J<G; 8<G;8EF<AHBHFBEI4E<6BF8@B7H?4G<BA4A79<A4??L5E84>F7BJA<AGBGHE5H?8A68A78EFFBA8G4? +;8 GE4AF<G<BA CEB68FF F;BJF FGEBA: 78C8A78A68 BA %( J;<6; 49986GF G;8 FGE84> 4@C?<GH78 ?8A:G;F64?8F4A7C8EGHE54G<BA:EBJG;E4G8E:<A4A7.;<G8 FGH7<87G;8GE4AF<G<BA4?9?BJ BI8E4FC4AJ<F84EE4LB96L?<A78EF;4C8EBH:;A8FF5LHF<A:;BGJ<E84A8@B@8GEL4GI4E<BHF%( E4A:<A: 9EB@ FH56E<G<64? GB FHC8E6E<G<64? 6BA7<G<BAF +;8 CE8F8A68 B9 ;<:; I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF ?B64G87 4G G;8 <A9?86G<BA CB<AG B9 G;8 I8?B6<GL CEB9<?8 <A7<64G8F 4 CBFF<5?8 89986G B9 "8?I<A 8?@;B?GM <AFG45<?<GL BA GE4AF<G<BA +;8L 4?FB 9BHA7 G;4G G;8 :EBJG; E4G8 B9 G;8 7<FGHE54A68F <A6E84F8F E4C<7?L J<G; G;8 <A6E84F8 B9 %( F 4 E8FH?G 4G FHC8E6E<G<64? 6BA7<G<BAF G;8 7<FGHE54A68F FCE847?4G8E4??L 4?BA: G;8 J4>8 FC4A 4A7 ?847 GB GE4AF<G<BA GB GHE5H?8A68 &A G;8 BG;8E ;4A7 <A G;8 FH56E<G<64? 6BA7<G<BA G;8 7<FGHE54A68F 4E8 FG45<?<M87 589BE8 GE4AF<G<BA 64A B66HE A G;8 E868AG 7<E86G AH@8E<64? F<@H?4G<BA 6BA7H6G87 5L #B<F84H 8G 4? I8?B6<GL.

(9)

(10) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . FGE84>F 4E8 B5F8EI87<A G;8 J4>8 A6E84F<A: %( ?847F GB 4?BA:8E FGE84@J<F8 C8EF<FG8A68 B94 ?BJ FC887 E8:<BA 6?BF8 GB G;8 FC4AJ<F8 FL@@8GEL C?4A8 +;8 <A6E84F87 4@C?<GH78 B9 FGE84>F @4>8FG;8J4>89?BJ@BE8CEBA8GB?B64?FGE84><AFG45<?<GL 8FC<G8 G;8 <AG8AF<I8 E8F84E6; BA G;8 89986G B9 )8LAB?7F AH@58E BA EBH:;A8FF <A7H687 GE4AF<G<BA @BFG 4GG8AG<BA ;4F 588A C4<7 GB G;8 FG4G<FG<64? 4A4?LF<F B9 C8EGHE54G<BA :EBJG; 4A7 @B74?4A4?LF<F<A<A6B@CE8FF<5?89?BJ8G4<?874A4?LF<FB9G;8<AFG4AG4A8BHF9?BJBE:4A<M4G<BA 78C8A7<A:HCBAG;8)8LAB?7FAH@58E<FA868FF4EL088G4? 4 5@84FHE87G;8G;E88 7<@8AF<BA4? IBEG<64? FGEH6GHE8F <A G;8 J4>8 B9 <FB?4G87 EBH:;A8FF 8?8@8AGF ;4I<A: 7<998E8AG :8B@8GE<8F 6L?<A78E FDH4E8 ;8@<FC;8E8 4A7 @<6EBE4@C 4G FHC8E6E<G<64? %( HF<A: GB@B:E4C;<6' -+;89?BJC4GG8EA<FJ8??64CGHE87J<G;4FLFG8@B9@H?G<C?86BHAG8EEBG4G<A: IBEG8K C4<EF <A G;8 A84E J4>8 E8:<BA+;8 <AFG4AG4A8BHF 9?BJ BE:4A<M4G<BA E8I84?F G;8BAF8G B9 ;4<EC<A IBEG<68F 9B??BJ<A: 7<998E8AG 8IB?HG<BA CEB68FF8F GBJ4E7F GE4AF<G<BA <A G;8 J4>8 B9 I4E<BHF8?8@8AGFFG;89BE@8EFGH7LBA?L784?GJ<G;G;8FHC8E6E<G<64?6BA7<G<BAG;8HAFG847L 9?BJ58;4I<BHE6?BF8EGB6E<G<64?%( A887FGB588KC?BE87HEG;8E@BE8<G<FC4EG<6H?4E?L78F<E87 GB<78AG<9LG;8IBEG<64?FGEH6GHE8FG;4G@4L6BAGE<5HG8GBG;8<AFG45<?<GL@86;4A<F@?847<A:GBG;8 <AG8E8FG<A'EBC8E&EG;B:BA4?86B@CBF<G<BA'&J;<6;<F4A899<6<8AGGBB?9BE74G4E87H6G<BA <A G;8 9<8?7 B9 9?H<7 @86;4A<6F *<EBI<6; +;8 B5G4<A87 8<:8A@B78 64A F;87 ?<:;G BA G;8 7B@<A4AG9?BJ984GHE8F4A7946<?<G4G8G;8E87H687BE78E78F6E<CG<BAB9G;89?BJ9<8?7 +;8CE8F8AG<AI8FG<:4G<BA8@C?BLFGB@B:E4C;<6' -GB64CGHE8G;8G;E887<@8AF<BA4?4FC86GFB9 G;88IB?HG<BACEB68FFGBJ4E7FGE4AF<G<BA<AG;8J4>858;<A74@<6EBE4@C+;88KC8E<@8AGF4E8 6BA7H6G876BI8E<A:5BG;6E<G<64?4A7FHC8E6E<G<64?%( 9?BJ6BA7<G<BAF+;8FLFG8@B9FGE84@J<F8 IBEG<68F 4F J8?? 4F G;8 <A7H687 I8?B6<GL 7<FGE<5HG<BA <F <78AG<9<87 <A G;8 G<@84I8E4:87 9?BJ GBCB?B:L +;8<A9?H8A68 B9%( BA G;8 <AFG4AG4A8BHF 9?BJBE:4A<M4G<BA <F I<FH4?<M87 5L G;8<FB FHE9468B9Ȝ 6E<G8E<BA+;89H??4EG<6?86BEEB5BE4G8FG;84A4?LF<FJ<G;4FG4G<FG<64?6;4E46G8E<M4G<BA B9 G;8 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF +;8'& 4A4?LF<F E8GHEAF G;8 @BFG 8A8E:8G<6 FC4G<4? @B78F J;<6; 4E8 4FFB6<4G87 GB G;8 FL@@8GE<6 4A7 4FL@@8GE<6 6B@CBA8AGF B9 G;8 :EBJ<A: I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF %! !"!"!. ),$12,,%*&*-4#-,$)1)-,0!,$+)#/-/!+. '%-+%1/6 +;8 8KC8E<@8AGF 4E8 6BA7H6G87 <A G;8 BC8A =8G ?BJFC887 J<A7 GHAA8? 4G G;8 8EB7LA4@<6 #45BE4GBE<8F B9 8?9G ,A<I8EF<GL B9 +86;AB?B:L +;8 J<A7 GHAA8? ;4F 4A 8K<G B9 P @ .

(11)

(12) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . 9B??BJ<A: 4 6BAGE46G<BA E4G<B B9 A 4?H@<AH@ 9?4GC?4G8 J<G; 4 ?8A:G; B9 @@ J<7G; B9 @@4A74G;<6>A8FFB9 @@<FC?46874GG;8@<7C?4A8B9G;8G8FGF86G<BA+;8@<6EBE4@C J<G; @@;8<:;G (4A7 @@FC4A#<FC?46874?BA:G;868AGE8?<A84G @@7BJAFGE84@B9 G;8C?4G8?847<A:87:8+;8?8A:G;*B9@<6EBE4@C<F @@E8FH?G<A:<A4A<A6<78A684A:?8ȕ 4A7;4?9FJ88C4A:?8ĮB9 Û4FF;BJA<A<: +;85674K8FB9G;86BBE7<A4G8FLFG8@<F 789<A87 J<G; E8FC86G GB G;8 FGE84@J<F8 J4??ABE@4? 4A7 FC4AJ<F87<E86G<BA +;8BE<:<A B9 G;8 6BBE7<A4G84K<F-<F?B64G87BAG;8FL@@8GELC?4A84GG;8J4??;4?9J4LG;8@<6EBE4@C6;BE7. <: $<6EBE4@C :8B@8GEL 4A76BBE7<A4G8789<A<G<BA GBC4A7F<78I<8J. +;8 8KC8E<@8AGF 4E8 64EE<87 BHG 4G 4 9E88FGE84@ I8?B6<GL 2 4A7 @F +;8 6BEE8FCBA7<A: E4@C;8<:;G54F87)8LAB?7FAH@58E%( <F 4A7. E8FC86G<I8?L4F87BAG;8EBH:;A8FF 4FC86GE4G<B(#B9 G;86E<G<64?%( E4A:8F9EB@ GB <A7<64G<A:6E<G<64?4A7FHC8E6E<G<64? 6BA7<G<BAF9BEG;86HEE8AG8KC8E<@8AGF"?854AB998G4? -BAB8A;B994A7E4F?BJ +;8 HA7<FGHE587 ?4@<A4E 5BHA74EL ?4L8E G;<6>A8FF ǅ J<G;BHG G;8 EBH:;A8FF 8?8@8AG <F @84FHE87GB58 4A7

(13) @@E8FC86G<I8?L+;8E8FH?G<A:E4G<B58GJ88AEBH:;A8FF;8<:;G4A7 5BHA74EL ?4L8E G;<6>A8FF <F Kǅ 4A7 +;8 F;4C8 946GBE B9 G;8 HA7<FGHE587 5BHA74EL ?4L8E<F <A7<64G<A:4?4@<A4EE8:<@8B9G;89?BJ . -+-'/!.()# +;8 GB@B:E4C;<6 ' - FLFG8@ 984GHE8F 9BHE #4-<F<BA +!'%/ /- <AG8E?<A8 64@8E4F P

(14) C<K8?F O@C<K8?4EE4A:874?BA:4A4E6J<G;4@4K<@H@4C8EGHE84A:?8B9ǃÝ 4FF;BJA<A<: +;864@8E4F4E88DH<CC87J<G;B5=86G<I8FB9 @@9B64??8A:G;4A7G<?G87GB 6B@C?LJ<G;G;8*6;8<@C9?H:6BA7<G<BA+;84C8EGHE8J4FF8G4G&. E8FH?G<A:<A49B64?78CG; B9 @@+;89?BJJ4FF88787J<G;4*/9B:@46;<A8G;4G:8A8E4G8FJ4G8E:?L6B?7EBC?8GF B9 4CCEBK<@4G8?L O@ 7<4@8G8E +;8 F887<A: 6BA68AGE4G<BA <F 64E89H??L 47=HFG87 4G 4CCEBK<@4G8?L C4EG<6?8F@@

(15) +;8 @84FHE8@8AG E8:<BA J4F <??H@<A4G87 J<G; 4 (H4AG8? %70 ?4F8E @!CH?F8

(16) A@ J4I8?8A:G; AF CH?F8 7HE4G<BA +;8 CH?F8 F8C4E4G<BA G<@8 J4F F8G GB 4A7

(17) OF L<8?7<A: 4 C4EG<6?8 7<FC?468@8AG B9 C<K8?F<A G;8 9E88.

(18)

(19) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . FGE84@+;8E8:<BAB9<AG8E8FGB9G;864@8E4J4F6EBCC87<AG;8I8EG<64?7<E86G<BAE8FH?G<A:<A4A 46G<I8F8AFBEF<M8B9 P C<K8?F+;86BEE8FCBA7<A:@84FHE8@8AGIB?H@8F<M8<F 5P 6P 7@@

(20) (P

(21) (P (E8FH?G<A:<A47<:<G4?<@4:8E8FB?HG<BAB9

(22)

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

(24) F8?964?<5E4G<BA G86;A<DH8 .<8A8>8 +;8 E4J <@4:8F 4E8 CE8 CEB68FF875LG;8FH5GE46G<BAB9C<K8?G<@8@<A<@H@4A7B9G;8FC4G<4?@<A<@H@9EB@4>8EA8? B9

(25) P

(26) C<K8?F @4:8 <AG8AF<GL J4F ;B@B:8A<M87 5L ABE@4?<M4G<BA 4:4<AFG G;8 ?B64? 4I8E4:8 >8EA8? B9 P C<K8?F +;8 @84FHE8@8AG IB?H@8 <F E86BAFGEH6G87 HF<A: G;8 *$)+ 4?:BE<G;@ G><AFBA 4A7 *BE<4 *C4G<4? 6EBFF6BEE8?4G<BA 4A4?LF<F <F C8E9BE@87 J<G; 4 6HFGB@ FB9GJ4E8 #,) #LA6; C8E9BE@<A: @H?G<:E<7 4A7 IB?H@8 789BE@4G<BA <AG8EEB:4G<BA HF<A: 4 9<A4? <AG8EEB:4G<BA IB?H@8 B9 P P IBK8?F

(27) P P

(28) @@

(29) J<G; 4ABI8E?4CB958GJ88AA8<:;5BHE<A:<AG8EEB:4G<BAJ<A7BJF+;8E8FH?G<A:FC4G<4?E8FB?HG<BA 8A45?8FG;878G86G<BAB9IBEG8KFGEH6GHE87BJAGB;4?94EBH:;A8FF;8<:;G&HG?<8EF4E878G86G87 HF<A: G;8 ABE@4?<M87 @87<4A 9<?G8E CEBCBF87 5L .8FG8EJ88? 4A7 *64E4AB 4A7 E8C?4687 J<G;<AG8ECB?4G87A8<:;5BHE<A:I4?H8F .

(30)

(31) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . /-.%//1(-'-,!*%#-+.-0)1)-, 'EBC8E BEG;B:BA4? 786B@CBF<G<BA '& <F 4 J8??8FG45?<F;87 CEB687HE8 <AGEB7H687<AGB 9?H<7 @86;4A<6FGBFG4G<FG<64??L<78AG<9L7B@<A4AG6B;8E8AGFGEH6GHE8F<A6B@C?8K9?BJF#H@?8L +;8 '& @8G;B7 786B@CBF8F G;8 9?H6GH4G<A: 6B@CBA8AG B9 G;8 I8?B6<GL 9<8?7 <AGB ?<@<G87 AH@58E B9 G<@8<A78C8A78AG BEG;B:BA4? @B78F ĳ,567 4A7 G<@878C8A78AG BEG;BABE@4? 4@C?<GH786B899<6<8AGFĮ,14F8KCE8FF87<A8DH4G<BA . ¦D M. u '( x, y, z, ti ). n. (ti )Mn ( x, y, z ) . n 1. '&;4F588AJ<78?L4CC?<874F74G4E87H6G<BA@8G;B79BE' -8KC8E<@8AGFL<8?7<A:8<G;8E4 F<@C?<9<87 E8CE8F8AG4G<BA B9 G;8 FGEH6GHE8 B9 7B@<A4AG 9?H6GH4G<BAF BE FHCCBEG<A: 4 E87H687 BE78E E86BAFGEH6G87 @B78?F 54F87 BA 4 ?<@<G87 AH@58E B9 @B78F #8:E4A7 8G 4? . -4A &H7;8HF78A8G4? +;8FA4CF;BG'&@8G;B7J;<6;J4FCEBCBF875L*<EBI<6; <F 4CC?<87 GB G;8 6HEE8AG GB@B:E4C;<6 ' - 8KC8E<@8AG +;8 FH<G45<?<GLB9 '& GB G;8 GE84G@8AG B9

(32) 74G4 <FFH87 9EB@ GB@B:E4C;<6 ' - ;4F 588A 4?E847L F;BJA <A C4FG JBE>F -<B?4GB 4A7 *64E4AB

(33) GF9<EFG4CC?<64G<BAGB<AI8FG<:4G8G;8G;E887<@8AF<BA4?C4GG8EAE8FH?G<A:9EB@G;8 9BE687 GE4AF<G<BA <F :<I8A <A G;8 CE8F8AG FGH7L +;8 G;E88 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BA 6B@CBA8AGF 4E8 4EE4A:87<AG;8@4GE<K58?BJ8DH4G<BA <ABE78EGBG4><A:G;8<E6BEE8?4G<BA<AGB466BHAG . U. ª u11 « 1 « v1 « w11 « « « « 1 « uN « v1 « N «¬ w1N. u12 v12 w12. u N2 vN2 wN2. u1M º » v1M » w1M » » » » » u NM » vNM » » wNM »¼. 46;'&@B78<FJE<GG8A4F4?<A84E6B@5<A4G<BAB9FA4CF;BGF4F 1 M M x y z ( , , ) n ¦D n (ti )u '( x, y, z, ti )

(34) M On i 1 $ <F G;8 AH@58E B9 FA4CF;BGF +;8 6BEE8FCBA7<A: 8<:8AI4?H8 B9 846; @B78F Ȝ, E8CE8F8AGF <GF 6BAGE<5HG<BAGBG;8GBG4?7<FGHE54A688A8E:L #$$!& .

(35)

(36) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . +;8 @84A 9?BJ GBCB?B:L <F 8K4@<A87 J<G; G;8 <FBFHE9468F B9 ABA7<@8AF<BA4? FGE84@J<F8 IBEG<6<GL Ȧ5 Ȧ5 P(2 4G%( . 4A7 4F F;BJA <A <:

(37) +;8 @4=BE 984GHE8 B9 4 C4<E 6BHAG8EEBG4G<A: IBEG8K C4<E 64A 58 B5F8EI87 8@4A4G<A: 9EB@ G;8 @<6EBE4@C EB@ G;8 F<78 I<8JBA864AB5F8EI8G;4GG;<FCE<@4ELC4<EB9IBEG<68F<F?<9G87HCJ;8A@BI<A:7BJAFGE84@ 5LG;8F8?9<A7H687I8?B6<GL G %( . <:

(38) 4 4F 7<F6HFF87 5L 08 8G 4? 4 49G8E G;8 E4C<7 ?<9GHC 4A7 786E84F87 <AG8AF<GLG;8CE<@4ELIBEG8KC4<E64AAB?BA:8E587<FG<A:H<F;879EB@5( F88<:

(39) 4F<78 I<8J+;8F86BA74ELIBEG8KC4<E<F9BE@8758A84G;G;8CE<@4ELC4<EJ ;<6;<F4?E847LCE8F8AG4G G;8@BFGHCFGE84@E8:<BAB9G;8@84FHE8@8AG7B@4<A 5( G5( 4G8EG<4ELIBEG8KC4<E <FCEB7H687GB:8G;8EJ<G;9HEG;8EIBEG8KC4<EFG;4G4CC84EBAG;8BHGF<78J;8A@BI<A:9HEG;8E 7BJAFGE84@ 8KC4A7<A: FC4AJ<F8 G;8 FGE84>L I8?B6<GL 7<FGE<5HG<BA +;8 :?B54? G<@84I8E4:87 IBEG<64?FGEH6GHE8E8F8@5?8F4J87:8F;4C8 .;8A 786E84F<A: %( GB <:

(40) 5 <AFG847 B9 HA78E:B<A: 4 94FG 7864L G;8 CE<@4EL IBEG8K C4<E4CC84EFGB58<A<G<4??L?<9G87HC4A7G;8A6BAG<AH8F7BJAFGE84@J<G;ABF<:A<9<64AG7864LB9 <GF<AG8AF<GL*G4EG<A:9EB@5( 846;IBEG8KB9G;8CE<@4ELC4<E5<9HE64G8F<AGBGJB5E4A6;8F 7<FGE<5HG87 I8EG<64??L J;<6; ?4G8E E86BAA86G <AGB 4F<A:?8 C4<E 4:4<A 4A7C8EF<FG HAG<? G;8 @BFG 7BJAFGE84@ @84FHE8@8AG ?B64G<BA F86BA74EL C4<E B9 6BHAG8EEBG4G<A: IBEG8K 4CC84EF 9EB@ 5( 4GG;8FC4AJ<F8F<78B9G;8CE<@4ELC4<E<AFG847B958A84G;4A7J<G;BCCBF<G8EBG4G<A: 7<E86G<BA+;89BE@4G<BAB94G8EG<4ELIBEG8KC4<EBHGJ4E7FB9G;8F86BA74ELBA8<FF<:A<9<64AG?L 78?4L87J<G;E8FC86GGBG;864F84G;<:;8E %( 4FG;8L4CC84E9EB@5( +;8BI8E4??IBEG<64? FGEH6GHE8 4?G;BH:; F<@<?4E GB G;8 CE8I<BHF 64F8 ;4F 4A <AI8EG87 F<:A 9BE G;8 IBEG<6<GL <A G;8 7BJAFGE84@ E8:<BA J;<6; <F 7H8 GB G;8 C8EF<FG8A68 B9 G;8 CE<@4EL IBEG8K C4<E 4F BCCBF87 GB G;8@ ?<9G87 4J4L 9EB@ G;8 J4?? 4G %( . +;8 9BE@4G<BA B9 4 J87:8 F;4C8 E8:<BA <F 4?FB 78?4L874A7BA?L4G8EG<4ELC4<E<FB5F8EI87J<G;<AG;8CE8F8AG@84FHE8@8AG7B@4<A +;8 FC4AJ<F8 @B7H?4G<BA B9 @B@8AGH@ 64HF87 5L G;8 46G<BA B9 G;8 FGE84@J<F8 IBEG<68F 78G8E@<A8FG;8FC4G<4?7<FGE<5HG<BAB9G;8?BJ4A7;<:;FC887E8:<BAF<AG;8J4>8B9G;8@<6EB E4@C+;8I8?B6<GL789<6<G58GJ88AG;84I8E4:87FGE84@J<F8I8?B6<GL224A7G;8HA7<FGHE587 5BHA74EL ?4L8E 2"*2 <F 6BAF<78E87 ;8E8 4F2$ 222"*2 49G8E G;8 CEB687HE8<AGEB7H687 5L <F;8E 4A7 ;BH7;4E< 4G G;E88 67 6EBFF C?4A8F ?B64G87 4G 5( <: +;8 6BAGBHE?<A8FB9FGE84@J<F8I8?B6<GL4A7F8?86G87CEB=86G87FGE84@?<A8F4E8FHC8E<@CBF87BAG;8 6B?BHE6BAGBHEFB9G;8ABA7<@8AF<BA4?FGE84@J<F8I8?B6<GL789<6<G2$ 2 .

(41)

(42) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . 4. 5 . <:

(43) +;E887<@8AF<BA4? E8A78E<A:B9G<@84I8E4:87 FGE84@J<F8IBEG<6<GL E874A75?H89BE 6?B6>J<F84A7 4AG<6?B6>J<F8EBG4G<BA IBEG<68F Ȧ5 N 4%(. 5%( +BCGBC 4A7F<785BGGB@ I<8J. ?BF8 GB G;8 @<6EBE4@C 5( 9BE 5BG; %( 4 CEBABHA687 ?BJFC887 E8:<BA 6?BF8 GB G;8 FL@@8GEL C?4A8 5BHA7<A: 5L GJB ;<:;FC887 E8:<BAF 6?BF8 GB G;8 J4?? <F CEB7H687 5L G;8 68AGE4?HCJ4F;4A7?4G8E4?7BJAJ4F;@BG<BAB9G;8CE<@4ELIBEG<68FB@C4E45?8@4:A<GH78B9 G;8?BJ4A7;<:;FC887E8:<BAF4E8CEB7H687B92$

(44) 24A7 24G%( . 4A72$ 24A7 24G%( E4C<778684F8<A@4:A<GH78B9G;868AGE4??BJFC887E8:<BA<F B5F8EI874G%( . <: 4J;<6;?<9GFHC4A764AABG5878G86G874AL@BE8 4G5( 6BAA86G<BAB9G;8 ;<:;FC887E8:<BAFB66HEF4GG;8@BFGHCFGE84@E8:<BA7H8GBG;894FG?<9GHC CEB68FF B9 G;8 CE<@4EL IBEG<68F 4A7 G;8 84E?L 4CC84E4A68 B9 G;8 F86BA74EL C4<E +;8 9BE@8E E8:<BAF @8E:8F 4G 5( ?847<A: GB 4A <A6E84F87 @4:A<GH78 B9 2 +JB A8J?L 9BE@87 F<78J4E7 ?BJFC887 E8:<BAF 64A 58 B5F8EI87 4G G;<F FGE84@J<F8?B64G<BA 7H8 GB G;8 F<78J4E7 HCJ4F; @BG<BA CEB7H687 5L G;8 F86BA74EL IBEG<68F G 5( G;8 9?BJ 78@BAFGE4G8F 4 E8?4G<I8?L;B@B:8ABHF7<FGE<5HG<BAB9G;8;<:;FC887E8:<BA6?BF8GBG;8J4??%8I8EG;8?8FFGJB ?BJFC887 E8:<BAF 64A FG<?? 58 78G86G87 BA GBC B9 <G J<G; ?BJ8E @4:A<GH78 <A7<64G<A: G;8 C8EF<FG8A68B9F<78J4E7HCJ4F;@BG<BA&AG;8BG;8E;4A7G;868AGE4??BJFC887E8:<BAC8EF<FG G<??G;8@BFG7BJAFGE84@@84FHE8@8AG?B64G<BA9BE%( 4FJ8??4FG;8<A7H687<A9?86G<BA4? I8?B6<GL CEB9<?8 <A 94IBHE B9 G;8 4@C?<9<64G<BA B9 GHE5H?8AG 9?H6GH4G<BAF +;8 <A6E84F8 <A @4:A<GH78 B9 G;8 ;<:;FC887 E8:<BAF GB 2$+!5

(45)

(46) 2 4G 5( <F F?BJ8E 7H8 GB G;8 ?4G8 <A68CG<BAB9F86BA74ELIBEG8KC4<E4A7J84>8E7BJAJ4F;@BG<BA+;86BAA86G<BAB9;<:; FC887.

(47)

(48) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . E8:<BA <F CBFGCBA87 7BJAFGE84@ GB 5( F<78 B9 G;8 ;<:;FC887 E8:<BAF GJB ?BJFC887 E8:<BA J<G; E4G;8E J84> <AG8AF<GL 64A 4?FB 58B5F8EI87 7H8 GB G;8HCJ4F; @BG<BA<A7H687 5L G;8=B<AG46G<BAF86BA74EL4A7G8EG<4ELIBEG8KC4<E. . . . 4%( . 5 %( . . <: *GE84@J<F8 I8?B6<GL 789<6<G2$ 2 4G6²76EBFFC?4A8FJ<G;6BAGBHE?<A8FB9. . 22 2 3B9 <AG8EI4?9?BJ GBCB?B:L F;BJAJ<G;F8?86G87 FGE84@?<A8F. #"!#!&"!"! A BE78E GB DH4AG<G4G<I8?L 6;4E46G8E<M8 G;8 8IB?HG<BA B9 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF<AGEB7H687 5L G;8 @<6EBE4@CG;8<AG8:E4G877<FGHE54A688A8E:L<FGE46>87<AG;8EBH:;A8FFJ4>89B??BJ<A:G;8 789<A<G<BAB9E:<A4A7.;<G8 4F erms ( x) ³³ u '( x, y, z) ! /ufd ( y / h)d ( z / h) *C86<4?4GG8AG<BA<FC4<7GBG;87<998E8A68B9G;87<FGHE54A688A8E:LCEB7H6875LG;86;4A:8B9 %( +;8 FGE84@J<F8 8IB?HG<BA B9 %/+0 4G FHC8E6E<G<64? 4A7 6E<G<64? %( <F F;BJA <A <: +;8 8IB?HG<BAFG4:8F4E8F8C4E4G87J<G;E874A7@4:8AG4?<A8F9BE%( . 4A7 E8FC86G<I8?L G%( . G;84@C?<GH78B9%/+0786E84F8FE4C<7?L9EB@ GB 9EB@G;8@BFGHCFGE84@ E8:<BA HAG<? 5( FG4:8 8LBA7 5( G;8 <AG8:E4G87 7<FGHE54A68 8A8E:L HA78E:B8F 8KCBA8AG<4? :EBJG; J;8A @BI<A: 7BJAFGE84@ +;8 :EBJG; E4G8 B9 %/+0 <F 64?6H?4G87 5L.

(49)

(50) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . C8E9BE@<A:?<A84E9<GGBG;8F8@<?B:CEB9<?8E846;<A:G;8@4:A<GH78B9 <AG;8E4A:8B95( 2 3 FG4:8 9B??BJ<A: 5L 4 9HEG;8E <AG8AF<9<64G<BA GB <A 5( 2 3 FG4:8. +;8. FGE84@J<F8 ?B64G<BA B9 G;8 GHEA<A: CB<AG B9 G;8 :EBJG; E4G8 6B<A6<78F J<G; G;8 <A68CG<BA B9 G8EG<4ELIBEG8KC4<E<AG;8@84A 9?BJ9<8?7HEG;8E7BJAFGE84@5( FG4:8 -G;8:EBJG; B9 %/+0<F E8G4E787 GB 4 E4G8B9 <A7<64G<A: G;4G G;8 9?BJ 586B@8F GHE5H?8AG<A G;<F E4A:8 F CEBCBF87 5L 08 8G 4? 4 G;8 GE4AF<G<BA @86;4A<F@ <F E8?4G87 GB G;8 I8?B6<GL FGE84> 7<FGE<5HG<BA CEB7H687 5L G;8 F86BA74EL 4A7 G8EG<4EL IBEG8K C4<E ?847<A: GB ?B64? <A9?86G<BA4? <AFG45<?<GL.;8A8IB?I<A:7BJAFGE84@G;84@C?<GH78B9G;8I8?B6<GLFGE84>F786E84F8FJ;<6;<F ?8FF FHF68CG<5?8 GB G;8 :EBJG; B9 <AFG45<?<GL ?847<A: GB ?BJ8E :EBJG; E4G8 B9 9?H6GH4G<BAF F<@<?4E74@C<A:58;4I<BEB9:EBJG;E4G8<AG;8 J4>8EBH:;A8FF8?8@8AGJ4F4?FBB5F8EI875L E:<A 4A7 .;<G8 4A7 8EA4E7<A< 8G 4? E:<A 4A7 .;<G8 FG4G87 G;4G G;8 GE4AF<G<BA CEB68FF <F 4 6B@C8G<G<BA 58GJ88A G;8 :EBJG; B9 HAFG847L 9?H6GH4G<BA 4A7 G;8 E8?4K4G<BAB9FC4AJ<F8ABAC4E4??8?9?BJGBJ4E7F?4F<HF6BA7<G<BAFG;8<A<G<4?:EBJG;B9G;8 HAFG847L 9?H6GH4G<BAF <F FH99<6<8AG?L ?4E:8 4?G;BH:; 7864LF <A G;8 7BJAFGE84@ E8:<BA G;8 GE4AF<G<BA4A75E84>7BJAGBGHE5H?8A68FG<??B66HEF589BE8G;89?BJ<FE8FG45<?<M87 Reh = 1170. IV. Reh = 465. 10-1. IV. III erms. III II. I 10-2. I 0. II 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. 60. 70. 80. x/h. . <:*GE84@J<F8 8IB?HG<BAB9<AG8:E4G87 7<FGHE54A688A8E:L . 86E84F<A: G;8 %( GB G;8 %/+0 4?FB 4@C?<9<8F 5HG F;BJ<A: ?BJ8E @4:A<GH78 <A G;8 8AG<E8 FGE84@J<F8E4A:86B@C4E87J<G;%( . E8I84?<A:G;4GG;8@<6EBE4@CJ4>8<F?8FFHAFG45?8 4G ?BJ8E %( +;8 58;4I<BHE B9 F;4EC 786E84F8 9B??BJ<A: 5L 4 FG88C <A6E84F8 <F 4?FB B5F8EI87 6?BF8GBG;8@<6EBE4@C<AG;8E4A:8B95(2

(51) 3FG4:8 4A72 3FG4:8 E8FC86G<I8?L+;8 :EBJG;E4G8<AG;8F86BA7FG4:8 <FF<:A<9<64AG?L;<:;8EG;4AG;4GB9;<:;8E%( EB@5( G;8<AG8:E4G877<FGHE54A688A8E:L<A6E84F8F8KCBA8AG<4??LHAG<?5(FG4:8. J<G;4?BJ8E. :EBJG; E4G8 B9 J<G; E8FC86G GBFHC8E6E<G<64? 6BA7<G<BA 9G8E G;<F FG4:8 G;8 %/+0 8KC8E<8A68.

(52)

(53) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . F4GHE4G<BA 4F G;8 9?BJ 4CCEB46;8F GHE5H?8AG 6BA7<G<BA FG4:8 - +;8 7<FC4E<GL B9 %/+0 58GJ88A 7<998E8AG %( I4A<F;8F +;8 ?4G8 <A68CG<BA B9 G;8 C?4G84H FG4:8 - E8@4E>F G;8 BAF8G B9 GHE5H?8A684FJ8??4FGE4AF<G<BA<FF<:A<9<64AG?L78?4L874G?BJ%( . <:+;8<AFG4AG4A8BHF9?BJC4GG8EA4G%( . C8EFC86G<I8I<8J4A745 78G86G87 5Lǌ 6E<G8E<BA 6B?BE6B787 5L22 F<78I<8J FGE84@J<F8IBEG<6<GL E874A75?H89BE6?B6>J<F84A74AG<6?B6>J<F8EBG4G<BA IBEG<68F ǚ5 N

(54) . !!" $!& +;8<AG8E46G<BA58GJ88A@<6EBE4@C4A7G;8?4@<A4E5BHA74EL?4L8ECEB7H68F4F8C4E4G87F;84E ?4L8E J;8E8 G;8 I8?B6<GL 8K;<5<GF 4A <A9?86G<BA4? CEB9<?8 FHF68CG<5?8 GB "8?I<A8?@;B?GM " <AFG45<?<GL+;8?4GG8E<AFG45<?<GL?847FGBG;89BE@4G<BAB9HAFG45?8J4I8F<AG;89BE@B9;4<EC<A ?<>8 IBEG<68F +;8 <@CBEG4A68 B9 " <AFG45<?<GL BA GE4AF<G<BA CEB68FF ;<:;?L 78C8A7F BA.

(55)

(56) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . )8LAB?7FAH@58EE:<A4A7.;<G8 #B<F84H8G4? A4E868AGFGH7L088G4? 4 6?4<@87 G;4G 4G FHC8E6E<G<64? %( " IBEG<68F ?BF8 G;8 FC4G<4? 6BAA86G<BA J<G; G;8 BAF8G B9 GHE5H?8AG J87:8<A G;8 J4>8 B9 @<6EBE4@C <A7<64G<A: " <AFG45<?<GL 7B8F ABG C?4L 4 EB?8 <A GE4AF<G<BA A G;8 6HEE8AG 8KC8E<@8AG G;8 C4GG8EA 4A7 8IB?HG<BA CEB68FF B9 " IBEG<68F <A G;8 J4>8 9?BJ 4G 7<998E8AG %( <F I<FH4?<M87 5L G;8 <FBFHE9468 B9 4 IBEG8K 78G86G<BA 6E<G8E<BA 5L ǌ !8BA: 4A7 HFF4<A 4A7 <AFG4AG4A8BHFFGE84@J<F8 IBEG<6<GL ǚ5 4FF;BJA <A <: 4A7 <: G FHC8E6E<G<64? %( G;8 " IBEG<68F FG4EG GB 58 46G<I8 9EB@ 5( <: J<G; <A<G<4? J4I8?8A:G; B9 ǌK 8F<78F FHFG4<A87 :EBJG; <A F<M8 G;8 F;4C8 B9 " IBEG<68F 6;4A:8F 9EB@4E6;GB;4<EC<A<:4J;BF8?8:F?4G8E6BAA86G4GG;85BGGB@7BJAFGE84@F;BJ<A:4F4 E<A:F;4C8<:5*HA8G4? 04A8G4? +;8FH778A<A6E84F8<AJ4I8?8A:G;4G5( <A7<64G8FG;8B66HEE8A68B9IBEG8KC4<E<A:+;8IBEG<68FE4C<7?L5E84>7BJA49G8EG;8C4<E<A: E8:<BA ?BF<A: 6B;8E8A68 4A7 C8E<B7<6<GL 7BJAFGE84@ B9 5( G 5(

(57) A8J?L 9BE@87 IBEG8KFGEH6GHE8FF;BJHC<AG;8A84EJ4??E8:<BAJ<G;;4<EC<AF;4C8+;8A8J;4<EC<AIBEG<68F 78I8?BC 7BJAFGE84@ J<G; 4 FC4AJ<F8 FCE847<A: E8F8@5?<A: 4 J87:8 F;4C8 :?B54??L +;8 J87:8 F;4C8 IBEG8K C4GG8EA <F 6BA9<E@87 GB 58 G;8 GHE5H?8AG J87:8 <A7<64G<A: G;8 BAF8G B9 GE4AF<G<BA088G4? 4 G%( G;8F;84E?4L8E4GG;8<AG8E9468B9G;8J4>84A7G;89E88FGE84@8K;<5<GF4E8?4G<I8?L FG847L FG4G8 <A G;8 A84E J4>8 B9 @<6EBE4@C 5( 2 3 J<G; BA?L G;8 CE<@4EL FGE84@J<F8 IBEG8KC4<ECE8F8AG<A:BJAFGE84@4GE4<AB9"IBEG<68F64A5878G86G87<A4;4<EC<AF;4C8 +;8IBEG<68F4E8FC46874GE8:H?4E<AG8EI4?FJ<G;4?BA:8E<A<G<4?J4I8?8A:G;B94CCEBK<@4G8?LǌK

(58) +;8 " IBEG<68F 6BAI86G 7BJAFGE84@ J;<?8 F<:A<9<64AG?L :EBJ<A: <A F<M8 4A7 58<A: FGE8G6;87+;8?8:CBEG<BAB9G;8"<F8?BA:4G874A7G8A7FGB@BI86?BF8GBG;8J4??J;<?8G;8 ;847 CBEG<BA ?<9GF HC 4A7 ?4G8E 78G46;8F 9EB@ G;8 ?8:F C?4G84H C4EG <F 9BE@87 <A G;8 ?8: 4F F;BJA<AG;8F<78I<8J<A<:64E?4E4A7*@<G; 8KC?4<A87G;<FC?4G84HCBEG<BA4FG;8 8DH<?<5E<H@B9G;8<AG8E46G<BA58GJ88AGJBBCCBF<A:89986GFJ;<6;4E8G;8F;84E89986GG;4GG8A7F GBEBG4G8G;8;4<EC<AGBJ4E7FG;8J4??4A7G;8<A7H687I8?B6<GLB9G;8GJB?8:F A58GJ88AB9GJB A8<:;5BHE<A:;4<EC<AF?8:F45H998EIBEG8KFGEH6GHE8<F9BE@87J<G;BCCBF<G8EBG4G<BA7<E86G<BA 7H8GBG;8@HGH4?<A7H6G<BA89986GB9G;8?8:F4FF;BJA5LG;8<FBFHE9468B9FGE84@J<F8IBEG<6<GL ǚ5 <A<:5+;8?8:5H998EIBEG<68F7E4JIBEG<6<GL9EB@G;85<9HE64G87F;84E?4L8E4A7:EBJ <A F<M8 +;8L @BI8 4J4L 9EB@ G;8 FL@@8GEL C?4A8 4A7 G8A7 GB 6BAA86G 58GJ88A F8DH8AG<4? IBEG<68F 6BEE8FCBA7<A: GB G;8 F86BA74EL IBEG8K FGEH6GHE8 <A G;8 @84A 9?BJ BE:4A<F4G<BA +;8 9HEG;8E<A6E84F8<A<AG8AF<GLB9G;8?8:5H998EIBEG<68F:<I8FE<F8GB4ABG;8EHA<DH8?4E:8?8:F;4C8.

(59)

(60) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . IBEG8KFGEH6GHE8BHGJ4E7F+;8FGEBA:F<78J4E78=86G<BA8I8AGGE4AFCBEGF?BJ@B@8AGH@9?BJ GB G;8 BHG8E 5BHA74EL?4L8E J;<6; <F FHF68CG<5?8 GB G;8 :EBJG; B9 C8EGHE54G<BA +;8 6B@5<A87 IBEG8KC46>8GFG4EGF9EB@5( <A<:5E8F8@5?8G;8984GHE8B9,F;4C8IBEG8K<A7<64G<A: G;8 78?4L87 BAF8G B9 GE4AF<G<BA *<A:8E 4A7 !BF?<A +;8 GHE5H?8AG J87:8 <F ABG 78G86G87 ,A?<>8 G;8 C4E<A: 4A7 E4C<7 7<FGBEG<BA CEB68FF 4G %( . G;8 " IBEG<68F ;8E8 4CC84E GB C8EF<FG BI8E 4 F<:A<9<64AG?L ?BA:8E FGE84@J<F8 7<FG4A68 +;8L 4?FB F88@ GB C4EG<6<C4G8 <A G;8 9BE@4G<BAB9,F;4C8IBEG8KC46>8G4FFB6<4G8GBG;8BAF8GB9GE4AF<G<BA+;8?4GG8E<A7<64G8FG;4G 6?BF8GBG;86E<G<64?E8:<@8B9%( "<AFG45<?<GLC?4LF4EB?8<AG;8EBHG8GB9BE687GE4AF<G<BA9BE G;8@<6EBE4@C:8B@8GEL . <:+;8<AFG4AG4A8BHF9?BJC4GG8EA 4G%( C8EFC86G<I8 I<8J78G86G875Lǌ 6E<G8E<BA6B?BE6B787 5L22 F<78I<8J 4A745 FGE84@J<F8 IBEG<6<GL E874A75?H89BE 6?B6>J<F84A74AG<6?B6>J<F8EBG4G<BAIBEG<68F ǚ5 N

(61) .

(62)

(63) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . AFH@@4EL4G%( G;8CE<@4ELIBEG<68FB9G<@84I8E4:879?BJ4FJ8??4FG;8"EB??8EF <A G;8 <AFG4AG4A8BHF 9?BJ C8EF<FG BI8E 4 ?BA:8E FGE84@J<F8 E4A:8 BJ8I8E G;8 BAF8G B9 F86BA74EL 4A7 G8EG<4EL IBEG8K C4<E <F CBFGCBA87 7BJAFGE84@ +;8 GE4AF<G<BA CEB68FF <F F<:A<9<64AG?L 78?4L87 4F G;8 GHE5H?8AG J87:8 7B8F ABG 4CC84E <A G;8 6HEE8AG @84FHE8@8AG 7B@4<A+;8BAF8G?B64G<BA4A7E8?8I4AGCEBC8EG<8FB9G;849BE8@8AG<BA87IBEG<64?FGEH6GHE8F4G 5BG;%( 4E8FH@@4E<M87<A+45 +45 B@C4E<FBA58GJ88AIBEG<64?FGEH6GHE8F4G7<998E8AG%( %( . . . *GE84@J<F8E4A:8B9CE<@4ELIBEG<68F. . . . . &AF8GB9G;8G8EG<4ELIBEG<68F. . . .4I8?8A:G;B9"IBEG<68F. .

(64) . 2 3. 2 3. &AF8GB9G;8F86BA74ELIBEG<68F. *GE84@J<F8E4A:8B9"IBEG<68F & . AG;8CE8F8AGFGH7LG;8FA4CF;BG'&@8G;B7<F4CC?<87GBG;E887<@8AF<BA4?I8?B6<GL9<8?7GB E8I84? G;8 @BFG 8A8E:8G<6 9?BJ FGEH6GHE8F 4F J8?? 4F G;8<E 6BAGE<5HG<BA GB G;8 :EBJG; B9 GBG4? 7<FGHE54A688A8E:LJ;<6;CBFF<5?L?847GBG;8BAF8GB9GE4AF<G<BA+;84A4?LF<F<FC8E9BE@87<A4 FH57B@4<A 589BE8 G;8 FG4EG B9 9H??L GHE5H?8AG 9?BJ 4G 5BG; FHC8E6E<G<64? 4A7 6E<G<64? %( 4F G;8 ?4G8E6BAG4<AF;<:;GHE5H?8AG><A8G<68A8E:LJ;<6;JBH?7@4F>G;8984GHE8F<AG;8 ?4@<A4E4A7 GE4AF<G<BA4?FG4G8BAF8DH8AG?LG;87B@4<A<FE87H687GB5( 4A7 9BE%(. 4A7 E8FC86G<I8?L+;86BAGE<5HG<BAB9 @B78FGBG;8GBG4?7<FGHE54A688A8E:L<F78@BAFGE4G87<A<: <998E8AG9EB@ G;8'&4A4?LF<FB9G;8J4>8 9?BJB9G;85?HAG5B7L-4A&H7;8HF78A8G4? BE=8G9?BJF"<E5L8G4? <AJ;<6;G;8?4E:84@BHAGB98A8E:L<F64CGHE875L4F@4?? AH@58EB98<:8A@B78FHFH4??L9<EFGGJB@B78FF@4??8A8E:LI4E<4G<BA58GJ88A?BJ4A7;<:; BE78E@B78F<FB5F8EI87<AG;86HEE8AG4A4?LF<F+;87<FG<A6G<BA64A4GGE<5HG8GBG;8946GG;4GG;8 B5F8EI87 9?BJ FGEH6GHE8F <A G;8 GE4AF<G<BA4? 5BHA74EL ?4L8E 9BE687 5L FHE9468 EBH:;A8FF 4E8 ;<:;?L@H?G<F64?84A7ABA?<A84E4??B64G<A:8A8E:LGB;<:;BE78E@B78F$BE8BI8EG;8E8?4G<I8 7<FGHE54A68 8A8E:L B9 846; F<A:?8 @B78 7B8F ABG 7<E86G?L E8CE8F8AG <GF <@CBEG4A68 <A G;8 GE4AF<G<BACEB68FF&AG;8BG;8E;4A7G;86BEE8FCBA78A6858GJ88AG;8GBCB?B:LB9'&@B78F 4A7G;878I8?BC@8AGB9FC86<9<69?BJ<AFG45<?<GL586B@8F6E<G<64?<A <78AG<9L<A:G;86BAGE<5HG<BA B9 G;8 @B78F GB GE4AF<G<BA F 4G %( . G;8 ?4E:8F64?8 "8?I<A8?@;B?GM GLC8 IBEG<68F.

(65)

(66) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . 586B@8F?8FFCE87B@<A4AG4A7FHEI<I8F<AF;BEG8EFGE84@J<F8E4A:8G;88A8E:L7<FGE<5HG<BA<F 9HEG;8E 9?4GG8A87 J<G; B9 G;8 GBG4? 8A8E:L 64CGHE875L G;8 9<EFG 8<:8A@B78F?BJ8E G;4A

(67) 4G%( . Reh = 1170. . Reh = 465. On¦On(%). . . 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. Mode. . <:)8?4G<I88A8E:L 7<FGE<5HG<BAB99<EFG '&@B78F.

(68) 2.%/#/)1)#!*#-,$)1)-,%( +;8 9<EFG G;E88 '& @B78F 4E8 F8?86G87 GB 78C<6G G;8 9?BJ 984GHE8F 4F G;8L 6BAG4<A87 ;<:;8FG 4@BHAGB98A8E:L58<A:6BAF<78E874F:BB7E8CE8F8AG4G<BAB9G;87B@<A4AGHAFG847L58;4I<B HE B9G;89?BJ+;8E8FG@B78FF;BJF<@<?4E7<FGE<5HG<BAB9I8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BAF6BEE8FCBA7<A:GB G;8F4@8984GHE8FG;HFABG58<A:7<F6HFF87<A78G4<?+;8<FBFHE9468B9ABE@4?<M87FGE84@J<F8 I8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BA6B@CBA8AG<FF;BJA<A<: A G;8 A84E J4>8 B9 @<6EBE4@C 5( G;8 9?BJ <F 7B@<A4G87 5L G;8 " IBEG<68F <A G;8 <AFG4AG4A8BHF9?BJ G<F8KC86G87G;4GG;8 9BE@8EFGEH6GHE86BAGE<5HG8FGB;<:;?8I8?B9I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF J<G;<A G;<F FGE84@J<F8 E4A:8 A @B78 4A7 G;8 7<FGE<5HG<BA B9 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF<FGBCB?B:<64??LF<@<?4E+;8546>946<A:F8C4E4G8CEB7H6875LG;8@6<EBE4@C?847F GBI8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BAC4G6;8F4G5(*BBA49G8EG;4G5(2 3G;8F;4C8B9G;8<FBFHE9468 B9;<:;I8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BAFF;BJF<AG;89BE@B97<FG<A6GC4G6;8FB94?G8EA4G<A:F<:ADH4EG8E J4I8?8A:G;FC4G<4?F;<9GB9G;8GJB@B78F64A58<78AG<9<87J<G;G;8I86GBE@4C4GG;8FL@@8GEL C?4A84FF;BJA<A<: +;8FC4G<4?6BEE8?4G<BA58GJ88AG;8GJB@B78FE8I84?FG;8CE8F8A68B9 6BAI86G<I8 " EB??8EF <A G;8 J4>8 #8A:4A< 8G 4? +;8 FG4EG<A: B9 G;8 F;877<A: C;8AB@8ABA <F 78G86G87 5L G;8 9<EFG I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BA @4K<@4 4G 5( J<G; 4A <A<G<4? J4I8?8A:G;B9Ȝ0 ( E846;<A::BB74:E88@8AGJ<G;G;8 J4I8?8A:G;B9"IBEG<68F9EB@.

(69)

(70) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . <AFG4AG4A8BHF 9?BJ GBCB?B:L HEG;8E@BE8 G;8 C4G6;8F 8K;<5<G :BB7 FC4AJ<F8 FL@@8GEL J<G; E8FC86G GB G;8 FL@@8GEL C?4A8 +;8 F68A4E<B <F F<@<?4E GB G;8 I4E<6BF8 @B78 B5G4<A87 9EB@ FG45<?<GL4A4?LF<F#B<F84H8G4? 6BAGE<5HG<A:GBG;89BE@4G<BAB9;4<EC<AIBEG<68F?G;BH:; <A<G<4??L4CC84EF4GG;8J4>868AGE8G;8I4E<6BF8@B78CEBC4:4G8F4A7B66HC<8FG;8J;B?8FC4A 589BE89478F4J4LBJ8I8EG;8I8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BAC4G6;8F<A'&@B78 4A7 <F6BA9<A87 J<G;<A 4 ?<@<G87 FC4AJ<F8 E4A:8 +;8<AG8AF<GL B9 G;8 C4G6;8F FG4EG GB 4GG8AH4G8 9EB@ 5( 586B@<A:A8:?<:<5?858LBA75( $BI<A:7BJAFGE84@GB5( <A@B78 A8JC4G6;8F 4CC84E6?BF8GBG;8J4??F;<9G<A:4J4L 9EB@G;8FL@@8GELC?4A8J<G;4?G8EA4G<I8CBF<G<I84A7 A8:4G<I8 F<:A 4F J8?? +;8 C4G6;8F 4E8 B5?<DH8 GB G;8 FGE84@J<F8 7<E86G<BA <A<G<4G<A: G;8 4@C?<9<64G<BA B9 GHE5H?8AG 9?H6GH4G<BAF A @B78 G;8 A8J C4G6;8F 4E8 C4E4??8?87 GB G;8 FGE84@J<F87<E86G<BA<AG;858:<AA<A:5( GHEA<A:<AGBG;8B5?<DH8C4GG8EA9EB@5( +;8B5?<DH8C4G6;8FFCE847<AG;8FC4AJ<F87<E86G<BA4A7E8F8@5?84J87:8F;4C8:?B54??L 6BAG4@<A4G<A: G;8 ?4@<A4E 9?BJ +;8 9BE@8E C4G6;8F 4E8 E8:4E787 4F G;8 CE86HEFBE B9 G;8 GHE5H?8AG J87:8 <A G;8 7BJAFGE84@ E8:<BA A 477<G<BA G;8 6B8K<FG8A68 B9 G;8 C4G6;8F 6BEE8FCBA7<A: GB G;8 " IBEG<68F 4A7 G;8 A84EJ4?? C4G6;8F <A G;8 F4@8 @B78<A7<64G8F G;8<E 6BEE8?4G<BA 4$B78 . . 5 $B78 . .

(71)

(72) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . 6$B78

(73) . <:*GE84@J<F8 I8?B6<GL 6B@CBA8AGB9 '&@B78F4G%(. X·X P . . <: 566EBFFF86G<BA4?I86GBE @4CFB9@B78 4A7 4G7( 6B?BE6B787 5LG;8FGE84@J<F8I8?B6<GL 6B@CBA8AG X·X . <998E8AGI8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BAFGEH6GHE8F4E8CE8F8AG87<A@B78

(74) <AG;8A84EJ4>84FG;8C4G6;8F B94?G8EA4G<A:F<:AG8A7GB7<FGE<5HG8<A4FG4::8E87C4GG8EA?BF<A:G;8FC4AJ<F8FL@@8GEL <: 6+;8<A68CG<BAB9G;8I8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BAC4G6;8FCBFGCBA8FGB5(J<G;4?4E:8E<A<G<4? J4I8?8A:G; ǌ! ( B9 7H8 GB ;<:;8E 6BAI86G<I8 I8?B6<GL 4G G;8 9BE@8E ?B64G<BA %B C4<E B9 8<:8A@B78 4E<F8F <A G;<F 64F8 <A7<64G<A: <GF FG4G<BA4EL A4GHE8 +;8 @4:A<GH78 B9 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF <F F<:A<9<64AG ?BJ8E 6B@C4E<A: J<G; FL@@8GE<6 @B78F 4A7 *<@<?4E GB J;4G B5F8EI87<AG;8F<AHBHF<AFG45<?<GL@B78 #B<F84H8G4? G;84FL@@8GE<6@B78<F4FFH@87 GB @B7H?4G8 G;8 9?BJ 9<8?7 <AGB F<AHBHF J<::?<A: C4GG8EA BAF8DH8AG?L G;8 F;4C8 B9 ;4<EC<A.

(75)

(76) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . IBEG<68F64HF875LG;84FL@@8GE<6@B78?BF8FG;8I4E<6BF8FL@@8GEL78@BAFGE4G<A:4CH?F4G<A: @BG<BA *G4EG<A: 9EB@ 5( G;8 B5?<DH8 C4G6;8F 6?BF8 GB G;8 J4?? 64A 4?FB 58 78G86G87 E8F8@5?<A:G;8FC4G<4?7<FGE<5HG<BA4FG;4G<A@B78 4A7 *<@<?4E?LG;84FL@@8GE<6C4G6;8F4E8 6BEE8?4G87GBG;8B5?<DH8C4G6;8F4FJ8?? +;8 45BI8 4A4?LF<F FH::8FGF G;4G G;8 IBEG<64? 7LA4@<6F 6?BF8 GB G;8 @<6EBE4@C F;BH?7 58 4 6B@5<A4G<BAB9F;877<A:4A7J<::?<A:@BG<BA4F5BG;FL@@8GE<64A74FL@@8GE<6@B784E<F8F BJ8I8E 4F G;8 @4:A<GH78 B9 G;8 4FL@@8GE<6 @B78<F 6B@C4E45?L ?BJ8E G;4A G;8 FL@@8GE<6 @B78G;8F<AHBHF@B7H?4G<BAGBG;8"IBEG<68F<FABGB5I<BHF<AG;8<AFG4AG4A8BHF9?BJ DH4AG<G4G<I84FF8FF@8AGB9G;86BEE8?4G<BA 58GJ88AG;8HCFGE84@FL@@8GE<64FL@@8GE<64A7 7BJAFGE84@ B5?<DH8 C4G6;8F 4E8 C8E9BE@87 5L 6B@C4E<A: G;8 8IB?HG<BA B9 <AG8:E4G87 7<FGHE54A68 8A8E:L %/+0 CEB7H687 5L @B78 4A7 <A 6B@5<A4G<BA FL@@8GE<6 4A7 @B78

(77) 4FL@@8GE<64FF;BJA<A<:. +;8FGE84@J<F8I8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BAF4E8E86BAFGEH6G87HF<A: 8DH4G<BA +;8 )$* B9 G;8 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF <F 6B@CHG87 BI8E <AFG4AG4A8BHF FA4CF;BGF AG;8A84E J4>85( G;8FL@@8GE<6@B78F7B@<A4G8G;87<FGHE54A688A8E:L J;<?8 G;8 6BAGE<5HG<BA B9 4FL@@8GE<6 @B78 <F BA8BE78E ?BJ8E BE G;8 FL@@8GE<6 @B78F G;8 7<FGHE54A68 :EBJF DH<6>?L 49G8E G;8 5<EG; B9 " IBEG<68F 4G 5( E846;<A: G;8 @4K<@H@ 4@C?<GH784G5(. 9B??BJ<A:5L4 E4C<7786E84F88KG8A7<A:HCGB5( +;87<FGHE54A68 8A8E:L FG4LF E8?4G<I8?L 6BAFG4AG @BI<A: 7BJAFGE84@ *G4EG<A: 9EB@ 5( G;8 %/+0 B9 4FL@@8GE<6 @B78 HA78E:B8FFG88C <A6E84F8 7H8 GB G;8 9BE@4G<BA B9 B5?<DH8C4G6;8F E<F<A:HC 58LBA7 G;8 ?8I8? B9 FL@@8GE<6 @B78F 4G 5(

(78)

(79) .;8E84F G;8 F86BA7 4F68A7<A: B9 G;8 ?4G8E @B78F B66HEF 7BJAFGE84@ 4G 5(

(80) E846;<A: ?BJ8E @4K<@H@ @4:A<GH78 6B@C4E<A: J<G; 4FL@@8GE<6@B78 symmetry asymmetry. erms. 10-2. 10-3. 10-4 0. 10. 20. 30 x/h. 40. 50. . <:. *GE84@J<F8 8IB?HG<BA B9%/+0 B9FL@@8GE<6 4A7 4A74FL@@8GE<6

(81) @B78F 4G%( . .

(82)

(83) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . HEG;8E E86BAFGEH6G<BA B9 G;8 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF ;4F 588A @478 HC GB '& @B78F G4><A: <AGB466BHAG B9 G;8GBG4?7<FGHE54A688A8E:L'4EG<6H?4E?LG;8I8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BAF<A7H687 5L G;8 @B78F F;BJ<A: FL@@8GE<6 4A7 4FL@@8GE<6 FC4G<4? 7<FGE<5HG<BA 4E8 C<6>87 BHG 4A7 FH@@87HCF8C4E4G8?L+;8FGE84@J<F88IB?HG<BAB9<AG8:E4G877<FGHE54A688A8E:L<F6B@C4E87 <A<: +;88A8E:L7<FC4E<GL58GJ88AG;8FL@@8GE<64A74FL@@8GE<6@B78F786E84F8F<AG;8 A84E J4>8 5( +;8 8A8E:L B9 5BG; @B78F F4GHE4G8F E846;<A: 4 C?4G84H B9 G;8 F4@8 7<FGHE54A68 8A8E:L @4:A<GH78 <A 5( 2

(84) 3 8LBA7 5(

(85) G;8 :EBJG; E4G8 B9 G;8 4FL@@8GE<6@B78F<A6E84F8FJ<G;E8FC86GGB@B78

(86) J;<?8G;4GB9FL@@8GE<6@B78E8@4<AFG;8 F4@8 4F @B78 4A7 ?847<A: GB 4 ?4E:8E 8A8E:L 7<998E8A68 <A G;8 7BJAFGE84@ E8:<BA F 4 E8FH?G 4?G;BH:; G;8 4FL@@8GE<6 C4G6;8F 6BAG4<A<A: ?BJ8E 7<FGHE54A68 8A8E:L <A G;8 HCFGE84@ E8:<BA <GF E8?4G87 B5?<DH8 C4G6;8F 64CGHE8F ?4E:8E 4@BHAG B9 8A8E:L 6B@C4E<A: GB G;4G B9 FL@@8GE<6C4G6;8F<A7<64G<A:<GF?4E:8E6BAGE<5HG<BAGBG;8<A68CG<BAB9GHE5H?8AGJ87:84FJ8?? 4FGE4AF<G<BA Total Symmetry Asymmetry. erms. 10-2. 10-3. 10-4 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. x/h. . <: *GE84@J<F8 8IB?HG<BA B9%/+0 B9 @B78F4G%( . .

(87) /)1)#!*#-,$)1)-,%(

(88) G6E<G<64?%( G;8C4G6;8FB9G;8@BFG8A8E:8G<6'&@B786BAI8EG<AGB4A4FL@@8GE<6FC4G<4? 7<FGE<5HG<BA 4F F;BJA <A <:

(89) 4 B@C4E87 J<G; @B78

(90) 4G FHC8E6E<G<64? 6BA7<G<BA 4 @BE8 CEBABHA687 FC4AJ<F8 F;<9G B9 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BA C4G6;8F B9 4?G8EA4G<A: F<:A 64A 58 B5F8EI87 4EBHA7G;8FL@@8GELC?4A8<A7<64G<A:4FGEBA:8EF<AHBHF@B7H?4G<BAGBG;868AGE4??BJFC887 E8:<BA5LG;<F@B78+;84FL@@8GE<6@B78FG4EGF9EB@G;8@BFGHCFGE84@B9G ;8@84FHE8@8AG 7B@4<AJ;<?8G;8<A68CG<BAB9G;8FG4::8E877<FGE<5HG87C4G6;8F@BI8F7BJAFGE84@GB5( +;8 <A<G<4? J4I8?8A:G; B9 G;8 C4G6;8F B9 G;8 F4@8 F<:A <F Ȝa0 /h

(91) ?BJ8E G;4A G;4G B9 G;8 " IBEG<68F <A G;8 <AFG4AG4A8BHF 9?BJ AFG847 B9 ?<@<G<A: 6?BF8 GB G;8 FL@@8GEL C?4A8 G;8.

(92)

(93) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . 4FL@@8GE<6@B78FCE847F<AG;8FC4AJ<F87<E86G<BA5L<A7H6<A:CBF<G<I84A7A8:4G<I8I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BA FGE84>F 4G G;8 F<78 6BAGE<5HG<A: GB G;8 HAFG847<A8FF B9 G;8 FC4AJ<F8 F;84E ?4L8E 58GJ88A A8<:;5BHE<A: ?BJ 4A7 ;<:;FC887 E8:<BAF <A G;8 @84A 9?BJ F88

(94) +;8 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAFGE84>FC8EF<FGG<??G;87BJAFGE84@8A7B9G;87B@4<A@4<AG4<A<A:;<:;4@C?<GH78 +;8 FGEH6GHE8F E8F8@5?8 4 J87:8 F;4C8 :?B54??L +;8 B5?<DH8 C4G6;8F 7B ABG 8@8E:8 <A G;<F @B78 *<@<?4E GB G;8 B5F8EI4G<BA 4G FHC8E6E<G<64? 6BA7<G<BA C4<E<A: B9 @B78 4A7

(95) B66HEF <A C;4F8 DH47E4GHE8F88<:

(96) 564A7<: L<8?7<A:G;8B66HEE8A68B9F;877<A:C;8AB@8ABAB9G;8 "IBEG<68F#BA:8EFGE84@J<F87<FG4A689EB@G;8@<6EBE4@C<FE8DH<E879BEG;8BAF8GB9@B78 4A7

(97) +;8<A<G<4?J4I8?8A:G;Ȝs0 /hB9G;89BE@8E@B78F<F

(98) J;<6;<F<78AG<64?GB G;4GB9" IBEG<68F<AG;8<AFG4AG4A8BHF9?BJ+;8C4G6;8F4E8FGE8G6;874A78KG8A7GBJ4E7FG;8 J4??+;8 FC4AJ<F8 CEBC4:4G<BA B9 G;8 C4G6;8F <F <A<G<4G87 5L G;8 :8A8E4G<BA B9 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BA 9<?4@8AGF 6?BF8 GB G;8 J4?? +;8 C4G6;8F 6BEE8FCBA7 GB IBEG8K F;877<A: FHEI<I8 9BE ?BA:8E FGE84@J<F87<FG4A686B@C4E<A:J<G;FHC8E6E<G<64?6BA7<G<BA7BJAFGE84@GB 5( 4A7 9BE @B78 4A7

(99) E8FC86G<I8?LEB@G;<F?B64G<BABA B5?<DH8C4G6;8FB9?4E:8EF<M8<AFC4G<4?8KG8AG 64A 58 78G86G87 F;BJ<A: :BB7 FC4AJ<F8 FL@@8GEL ?G;BH:; G;8 <A68CG<BA <F 78?4L87 G;8 GBCB?B:LB9G;8A8JC4G6;8F6B<A6<78FJ<G;G;4G4GFHC8E6E<G<64?%( 4$B78 . . 5 $B78 . .

(100)

(101) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . 6$B78

(102) . . <:

(103) *GE84@J<F8 I8?B6<GL 6B@CBA8AG B9'&@B78F 4G%( X·X. P . <: 566EBFFF86G<BA4?I86GBE @4CFB9@B78 4A7

(104) 4G7( 6B?BE6B787 5LG;8FGE84@J<F8I8?B6<GL 6B@CBA8AG X·X . +;8FGE84@J<F88IB?HG<BAB9G;8<AG8:E4G877<FGHE54A688A8E:L4G6E<G<64? %( <FF;BJA<A <: BEG;84FL@@8GE<6@B78%/+0HA78E:B8F8KCBA8AG<4?:EBJG;FG4EG<A:9EB@ G;8HC@BFG E8:<BAB9G;8@84FHE8@8AG7B@4<A4A7F4GHE4G8F9EB@5( ?G;BH:;G;8FL@@8GEL@B78F 64CGHE8F ?4E:8E CBEG<BA B9 G;8 7<FGHE54A68 8A8E:L <A G;8 HCFGE84@ E8:<BA 5(

(105) ;<:;8E @4:A<GH78B9%/+0<FB5F8EI879BE4FL@@8GE<6@B78<AG;8E4A:8B9 5(2

(106) 37H8GB<GFE4C<7 <AG8AF<9<64G<BA +;8 <A68CG<BA B9 G;8 B5?<DH8 C4G6;8F <A G;8 FL@@8GEL @B78 ?847 GB G;8F86BA7 <A6E84F8B9GHE5H?8AG9?H6GH4G<BA8A8E:L4G5( E846;<A:F4GHE4G<BAB9G;8F<@<?4E@4:A<GH78 4FG;84FL@@8GEL@B784G5( . LG4><A:G;89<EFG'&@B78F<AGB466BHAGJ;<6;4?FB6BAG4<A B9GBG4?7<FGHE54A688A8E:L <G<F9BHA7G;4GBA?LG;89<EFG@B78F;BJF4FL@@8GE<67<FGE<5HG<BAJ;8E84F@BE8@B78C4<EFB9.

(107)

(108) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . FL@@8GELGLC88@8E:8+;8BI8E4??<AG8:E4G877<FGHE54A688A8E:LB94??G;8FL@@8GE<6@B78F<F ;<:;8E G;4A G;4G B9 G;8 4FL@@8GEL @B78 <A G;8 J;B?8 <AI8FG<:4G87 7B@4<A F G;8 B5?<DH8 C4G6;8F<AG;8FL@@8GE<6@B78<AGEB7H68;<:;8E4@C?<GH78B9I8?B6<GL9?H6GH4G<BAF<A 5(2 3<GF4@C?<9<64G<BACBFF<5?L?847GBGE4AF<G<BA symmetry asymmetry. erms. 10-2. 10-3. 10-4 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. 60. . x/h. <: *GE84@J<F8 8IB?HG<BA B9%/+0B9FL@@8GE<6 4A7

(109) 4A74FL@@8GE<6 @B78 4G%( . Total Symmetry Asymmetry. erms. 10-2. 10-3. 10-4 0. 10. 20. 30. x/h. 40. 50. 60. <: *GE84@J<F8 8IB?HG<BA B9%/+0 B9@B78F 4G%( . . " +B@B:E4C;<6 ' - @84FHE8@8AGF BA @<6EBE4@C <A7H687 5BHA74EL ?4L8E GE4AF<G<BA <A <A6B@CE8FF<5?8 9?BJ 4E8 C8E9BE@87 4G 5BG; 6E<G<64? 4A7 FHC8E6E<G<64? %( *GEBA: 78C8A78A68 B9.

(110)

(111) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . IBEG<64?7LA4@<6F<AG;8@<6EBE4@CJ4>8BA)8LAB?7FAH@58E;4F588A9BHA7J;<6;<A9?H8A68 G;88IB?HG<BACEB68FFGBJ4E7FGE4AF<G<BA +;8 G<@84I8E4:87 J4>8 9?BJ GBCB?B:L 984GHE8F @H?G<C?8 C4<EF B9 FGE84@J<F8 IBEG8K C4<EF 4G 5BG; %( G FHC8E6E<G<64? %( B9. 4F E8CBEG87 5L08 8G 4? 4 G;8 F<78J4E7 ?BJFC887 E8:<BAF<A7H6875LG;8HCJ4F;@BG<BA7H8GBF86BA74EL4A7G8EG<4ELIBEG8KC4<EF<F FHF68CG<5?8 GB?B64?<A9?86G<BA4?<AFG45<?<G<8F?847<A:GBG;8CEB7H6G<BAB9GHE5H?8AG9?H6GH4G<BAF4A7G;8BAF8G B9 GE4AF<G<BA G 6E<G<64? 6BA7<G<BA %( G;8 CE<@4EL IBEG<68F C8EF<FG G<?? G;8 @BFG 7BJAFGE84@ E8:<BA B9 G;8 @84FHE8@8AG 7B@4<A <A7H6<A: 68AGE4? ?BJFC887 E8:<BA B9 ;<:; 4@C?<GH78 B9 I8?B6<GL 789<6<G +;8 68AGE4? <A9?86G<BA4? I8?B6<GL CEB9<?8 ?847F GB G;8 :EBJG; B9 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF 7H8 GB"8?I<A8?@;B?GM <AFG45<?<GL +;8 GE4AF<G<BA CEB68FF<FF<:A<9<64AG?L 78?4L874G?BJ%( 'EBC8E &EG;B:BA4? 86B@CBF<G<BA <F CEBI87 GB 58 4 984F<5?8 74G4 E87H6G<BA G86;A<DH8 GB ;<:;?<:;GG;87B@<A4AG9?BJ984GHE8F<AG;8G;E887<@8AF<BA4?GE4AF<G<BA4?5BHA74EL?4L8E+JB 7B@<A4AG GLC8F B9 @B78F 4E8 B5G4<A87 9EB@ G;8 '& 4A4?LF<F +;8 FL@@8GE<6 @B78 C4<E 6BEE8FCBA7FGBG;8F;877<A:C;8AB@8ABAB9"IBEG<68FJ;<?8G;84FL@@8GE<6@B78?847FGB 4 F<AHBHF J<::?<A: 4EBHA7 G;8 J4>8 68AGE8?<A8 A G;8 7BJAFGE84@ E8:<BA B5?<DH8 C4G6;8F B9 I8?B6<GL 9?H6GH4G<BAF 64A 58 78G86G87 :<I<A: E<F8 GB G;8 4@C?<9<64G<BA B9 GHE5H?8AG 9?H6GH4G<BA 8A8E:LJ;<6;?847FGBG;8BAF8GB9GE4AF<G<BA+;86BEE8?4G<BAB9G;89BE@8E'&@B78FJ<G;G;8 GE4AF<G<BA CEB68FF FGEBA:?L 78C8A7F BA %( G FHC8E6E<G<64? %( G;8 4FL@@8GE<6 @B78 6BAGE<5HG8F;<:;8E4@C?<GH78B97<FGHE54A688A8E:LGBG;8B5?<DH8C4G6;8FC?4L<A:G;87B@<A4AG EB?8BAGE4AF<G<BA.;8E84F4G6E<G<64?%( G;8FL@@8GE<6@B78G4>8FBI8EG;8CBF<G<BA78ABG<A: :E84G8E6BAGE<5HG<BA 64E?4E$**@<G;) FGH7LB9;4<EC<AIBEG<68F<A4?4@<A4E5BHA74EL?4L8E'4EG 4<EC<AIBEG<68F:8A8E4G875L4;8@<FC;8E8CEBGH58E4A68!?H<7$86; . A78EFFBA ' E4A7G # BGG4EB 8AA<A:FBA * &A G;8 5E84>7BJA B9 5BHA74EL ?4L8EFGE84>F!?H<7$86; . G><AFBA *BE<4 ! A 899<6<8AG F<@H?G4A8BHF E86BAFGEH6G<BA G86;A<DH8 9BE GB@B:E4C;<6C4EG<6?8<@4:8I8?B6<@8GELKC?H<7F

(112) . 8EA4E7<A< $ '<EBMMB?< * &E?4A7< ' #8?8 *" '4E4@8G8E<M4G<BA B9 5BHA74EL?4L8E GE4AF<G<BA<A7H6875L<FB?4G87EBH:;A8FF8?8@8AGF ! .

(113)

(114) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . E:<A .;<G8 ,AFG847L 4A7 GE4AF<G<BA4? 9?BJF 58;<A7 EBH:;A8FF 8?8@8AGF ! . E4AFFBA !$ E4A7G # +4?4@8??< BFFH KC8E<@8AG4? 4A7 G;8BE8G<64? <AI8FG<:4G<BAB9G;8ABA@B74?:EBJG;B9FG847LFGE84>F<A4 9?4GC?4G85BHA74EL?4L8E';LF ?H<7F

(115)

(116)

(117) !8BA:!HFF4<A &AG;8<78AG<9<64G<BAB94IBEG8K!?H<7$86; . "<E5L $ BE<F ! *<EBI<6; # A 8<:8A9HA6G<BA 4A4?LF<F B9 4K<FL@@8GE<6 =8G 9?BJ ! B@CHG';LF . "?854AB99'*?8I8?4A7.+<7FGEB@" &AG;88IB?HG<BAB94GHE5H?8AG5BHA74EL ?4L8E<A7H6875L4G;E887<@8AF<BA4?EBH:;A8FF8?8@8AG!?H<7$86;

(118) . . "?854AB99 '* *6;H54H8E4A7 +<7FGEB@ " $84FHE8@8AGF B9 G;8 89986G B9 GJB . 7<@8AF<BA4? 4A7 G;E887<@8AF<BA4? EBH:;A8FF 8?8@8AGF BA 5BHA74EL?4L8E GE4AF<G<BA. !BHEA4?B9G;88EBA4HG<64?*6<8A68F

(119) "?854AB99 '* +<7FGEB@ " $86;4A<F@ 5L J;<6; 4 GJBǦ7<@8AF<BA4? EBH:;A8FF 8?8@8AG<A7H68F5BHA74ELǦ?4L8EGE4AF<G<BA';LF?H<7F .

(120) . . #4A74;?$+ &AFH5?4L8EFGE84>F!?H<7$86;

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

(122)

(123)

(124) . *<EBI<6;# +HE5H?8A684A7G;87LA4@<6FB96B;8E8AGFGEH6GHE8FC4EG<<*L@@8GE<8F4A7 GE4AF9BE@4G<BAF(H4EG8E?LB9CC?<87@4G;8@4G<6F

(125) . *HA 1 *64EG<AB -4A &H7;8HF78A . *6;E<=8E ! 04A 0 #<H %H@8E<64? 4A7 8KC8E<@8AG4?<AI8FG<:4G<BAFB9G;8FHC8EFBA<6@<6EBE4@CJ4>8 ! . +4A< BHA74EL?4L8EGE4AF<G<BAAAH4?)8I<8JB9?H<7$86;4A<6F .

(126)

(127) 6+ 06(40$6,10$. 9 /215,7/106+(22.,&$6,101)$5(4$0'/$*,0* (&+0,37(561.7,'(&+$0,&5 ࣭ : ! ࣭ !# – . . +4A< "B@B74 "B@4GFH 0 H6;< $ BHA74EL?4L8E GE4AF<G<BA 5L <FB?4G87 EBH:;A8FF)8C

(128) 8EBA4HG<64?)8F84E6; AFG<GHG8,B+. I4AE<8FG)$64H?8L. +;889986GB96BAGEB??87G;E887<@8AF<BA4?EBH:;A8FFBA 5BHA74EL?4L8EGE4AF<G<BA4GFHC8EFBA<6FC887F!BHEA4?B9G;88EBFC468*6<8A68F . -4A &H7;8HF78A . *64E4AB -4A <AF58E: %' .4GG . ';4F8E8FB?I87. 6;4E46G8E<M4G<BA B9 IBEG8K F;877<A: <A G;8 A84E J4>8 B9 4 FDH4E8 F86G<BA 6L?<A78E 4G. <A6<78A68KC?H<7F

(129) -<B?4GB *64E4AB

(130) +;E887<@8AF<BA4? IBEG8K 4A4?LF<F 4A7 48EB46BHFG<6 FBHE68 6;4E46G8E<M4G<BAB9=8G6BE85E84>7BJA';LF?H<7F . . -BAB8A;B99E4F?BJ# +;889986GB97<FGE<5HG87FHE9468EBH:;A8FFBA?4@<A4E 9?BJ A#46;@4AA-87BHA74EL#4L8E4A7?BJBAGEB?'8E:4@BACC . .8FG8EJ88? ! *64E4AB ,A<I8EF4? BHG?<8E 78G86G<BA 9BE C<I74G4 KC?H<7F

(131) . . .<8A8>8 -B?H@8 F8?964?<5E4G<BA 9BE

(132) 7 C4EG<6?8 <@4:8 I8?B6<@8GEL KC ?H<7F . 04A 0 ;8A .4A: / #<H #8F 4A7 4A4?LF8F BA G;8 IBEG8K FGEH6GHE8 58;<A7 FHC8EFBA<6@I:J<G;GHE5H?8AG<A9?BJCC?$4G;$B78?

(133) . . 08(*6;E<=8E!*64E4AB 4BHA74EL?4L8EGE4AF<G<BA@86;4A<F@F58;<A74@<6EB E4@C!?H<7$86;

(134)

(135) . 08 ( *6;E<=8E ! *64E4AB 5 8B@8GEL 89986G B9 <FB?4G87 EBH:;A8FF BA 5BHA74EL ?4L8EGE4AF<G<BA<AI8FG<:4G875LGB@B:E4C;<6C<I AG!84G?H<7?BJ4668CG87. .

(136)