Proceedings of The 1st Workshop
on
"DEVELOPMENT OF ADVANCED SHIP
SUPPORT SYSTEM
USING INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY"
February 5, 2009
Etchujima Hall, Etchujima
Campus,
Tokyo University of Marine
Science and Technology
Tokyo, Japan
P2009-14
Delft University of Technology
Ship Hydromechanics laboratory
Library
Mekelweg 2 26282 CD Delft
Phone: +31 (0)15 2786873
Closing 17:20-17:30
Program
Opening 13:00-13:10Sessionl: Maritime Broadband Communication System 13:10-14:10
»- Development of Maritime Broadband Communication / Kohei Ohtsu and Ruri Shoji, Tokyo University of Marine Science and Technology
An Estimation Tool of Long Term Benefits of Auxiliar Wind Propulsion by Means of a Traction Kite Including the Effect of Route Optimization / Peter Naaijen, Wei Shi,
Delft University of Technology, and Jean-Gregoire Kherian, Gusto MSC
Session2: Electronic Navigation System 14:10-15:10
Development of an e-Navigation Strategy in IMO and Study on Navigational Intention Exchange Support System / Yasuyuki Niwa, National Maritime Research
Institute
A Scaled-down version of the Integrated Navigational InformationSystem on Seascape Image for the training ship SHIOJIMARU / Takahiko Fujisaka , Tokyo University of Marine Science and Technology
Coffee Break 15:10-15:20
Session3: Advanced Operation Control System 15:20-16:20
)0. Practical Education for Marine Control Engineering Using an Actual Training Ship /
Jun Kayano, Tadatsugi Okazaki, Hayato Kondo, Hitoi Tamaru and Kohei Ohtsu, Tokyo University of Marine Science and Technology
On the Development of Decision-support and Guidance System for Ships Operating in Close Proximity / [gil Pedersen, Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Session4: Advanced Management System for Marine Engineer 16:20-17:20
'fr Knowledge Bank System for Marine Engineering Operation / Sachiyo Horiki and
Masahiro Osakabe, Tokyo University of Marine Science and Technology
>. Recording System of Seamless Work-log With a Wearable device and its Application to an Education Support System / Katsunori Matsuoka, National Institute of
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Foreword to the Textbook 3
Maritime Broadband Communication System 5
Development of Maritime Broadband Communication 7
An Estimation Tool of Long Term Benefits of Auxiliar Wind Propulsion
by Means of a Traction Kite Including the Effect of Route Optimization. 21
Electronic Navigation System 35
Development of an e-Navigation Strategy in IMO and Study on Navigational
Intention Exchange Support System 37
A Scaled-down version of the Integrated Navigational Information System
on Seascape Image for the training ship SHIOJIMARU 47
Advanced Operation Control System 57
Practical Education for Marine Control Engineering
Using an Actual Training Ship 59
On the Development of Decision-support and Guidance System
for Ships Operating in Close Proximity 69
Advanced Management System for Marine Engineer 75
Knowledge Bank System for Marine Engineering Operation 77
Recording System of Seamless Work-log With a Wearable device
Foreword to the Textbook
The Information Technology (IT) has found its way into shipping to achieve safe and efficient marine transportation as is exemplified by the IMO e-Navigation Strategy. In order to lead the way in this new field, the Tokyo University of Marine Science and Technology (TUMSAT) launched a new research and development project in 2008 on advanced IT-based ship operation technologies such as Maritime Broadband Communication System, Electronic Navigation System, Advanced Ship Operation and Control System and Advanced Management System for Marine Engineering. The TUMSAT also intends to integrate the outcome of this project into its curriculum to provide young professionals with sufficient knowledge in advanced
marine-related IT technologies to the broad maritime community including the maritime
industry, maritime education and training institutions and maritime authorities.
The project is run by the following 4 groups:
The Maritime Broadband Communication System Group attempts to develop a maritime
broadband communication system, which enables ships at sea and land-based personnel to share ship operation information.
The Electronic Navigation System Group aims at developing a navigation assistance system following the E-Navigation Strategy proposed by the IMO.
The Advanced Ship Operation and Control System Group focuses on ship control
technologies such as ship to ship operation, tracking control, and automatic berthing.
The Advanced Management System for Marine Engineering Group endeavors to develop a knowledge bank system for marine engineering operation.
We hope that this workshop will become a milestone in the development of advanced ship support systems for safe and efficient ship operation.
Hideo Yabuki
Project manager Professor
MARITIME BROADBAND
Development of Maritime Broadband Communication
Kohei Ohtsu
Emeritus Prof TLTMSAT
Ruri Shoji
Associate Prof. .TITMSAT
Introduction
We might say that the first generation of navigation style had continued until 19
century when G.Marconi developed a wireless communication technique in 1987.
During the first generation, a ship was navigating in standing alone, in other word, not
depending on land support except for a light house and manual signal using hand flag
and so on. A ship could receive on board some information from land for the first time
Marconi developed a wireless communication technique. However, the information
which the ship could receive was extremely few as the signals were exchanged by Morse
signal code. Until this generation, however, the gap in remote communication technique
between sea and land were small. The gap has abruptly expanded since G.Bell
developed a remote telephone technique. And nowadays, the gap becomes decisive by
development of internet and satellite communication system. Inversely considering this,
the innovation of communication technique in navigation will yield a break-through in
order to reduce the gap between sea and land and realize safety eco navigation which is
the urgent problem for navigation, by co-operation between ship and land.
In this paper, we will review the real state of the communication technique at
seaand introduce the actual experimental projects which has be carried out in TUMSAT
and discuss a new world in navigation which will been derived by realization of a high
speed and a large capacity broad band (Maritime Broad Band Network; MBB)
communication network at sea.
2
Sea Infrastructure of Communication Technique
2.1 Infrastructure of Communication System at Land
Fig1 shows transition of the communication speed in LAN
system. This figure
shows that the communication speed has become faster at the rate of 4.3db/year. The
middle line of Fig2 shows transition of the communication speed in cellular
phone. Theupper line is the one of the LAN copied from Fig. 1. We can know that the incline of these
two lines are almost parallel. In any case, transition of the communication speed in land
g 80 ,11111 140 60 40 20 o 1G 100M: -10MbPs 1 00 o 100 10 1 0. Transmission Spee Mbps -1?m-f 4ADSL1.5M .57.6k 136N 128k 24delay 384kbps(FOMA) 4-- \--32kbps(PHS) 9.8kbps(PDC) 1990 1995 2000 2005
Fig.2 Speed Up of Cellular Phone
2.2 Infrastructure of Communication System at Sea
2.2.1 Gap of communication speed between land and sea
On the other hand, the communication speed at sea is surprisingly slow. Fig 3
showsthe gap between them (Japanese Ministry of Internal Affairs and
Communications).Seeing this figure, we might perceive that overtaking at sea communication to
developing at land communication services is too late.
Ultra High Speed Wir AN
Phone
Avtate e
ration ". Ku
.
IrirrAfi SAT NStar----
Band1995 2000 2005 2010
Fig.3 Communication Speed Gap between Land and Sea
Gap!!
2 4Mbp (EV-DO 64kbps(PHS)
1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
Fig.1 Speed Up of LAN
2 -
#.-t74') 140 120 c,s, 100 80 60 40 20 O2.2.2 Coastal Navigation
In coastal navigation, most popular communication method in Japan is to utilize a
cellular phone. However, the cover area of cellular phone at sea is extremely narrow
because the antennas for cellular phone direct to inland. Navigating out of the range,
the satellite communication systems called by N-Star ( DoCoMo Mobile Coltd) are
popularly utilized. It covers about 200 NM with max 64kbps.
According to the questionnaire to crews of inland ship carried out by Ministry of Land,
Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, large claims on the present communication at
sea, are that the communication speed is slow and the cover range, narrow, considering
high cost
2.2.3 Ocean Navigation
There is no method except for a satellite communication system from ship to land
because the radio operator has not got on board in many recent ships. The most typical
communication service in the satellite communication is the INMARSAT satellite
services operated by International Maritime Satellite Organization whose band is L
band (1.6/1.5GHz). Table 1 shows the recent services in the INMARSAT. A frequently
used one among them is the INMARSAT-F (the communication speed is 64kbps).We can
understand that the communication speed is extremely slow comparing with land
communication because this communication speed was equivalent to the one in the first
generation in land service.
Conclusively speaking, the most urgent problem in the communication services at sea
to be grappled with, is realization of higher (at least over 1Mbps in up link speed,Ku
Band) speed low cost services as much as possible.
Table 1 Feature of INMARSAT Services
Type Voice Telex Fax Data A Analog Yes 4.8kbps 4.8kbps B Digital Yes 9.6kbps 9.6kbps C Yes 600bps M Digital 2.4 kbps 2.4kbps miniM Digital 2.4 kbps 64kbps Aviate Digital 4.8 kbps 4.8kbps F Digital 9.6 kbps 64kbps D 32kbps Bgan Digital 14.4kbps 492kbps Aviate Digital 2.4kbps 64kbps
2.3 The effects obtained by realization of High Speed Large Capacity Communication
Table 2 demonstrates some effects induced by realization of broadband communication
service between sea and land. Most expected field of the contents in the last
questionnaire is information support to ship from land.
Table 2 Applications of High Speed Large Capacity
Communication at Sea
3 Marine Broad Band Project
3.1 Introduction
TUMSAT began a projects called by Marine Broad Band Network in 2005
aiming realization of a new world of navigational technique which is derived by a high
speed and a large capacity communication network system. This project is supported by
co-working team between TUMSAT and 7 companies, NTT communication system , Sky Perfect JSAT and DoCoMo Mobile treat
with network, Ube Kaiun, Mitsui Zosen
,Mitsui Akishima, JRC..This project aims that
Realization of communication services
between sea and land in coastal and
Field Item Form
Contents
Welfares Welfares for crew
Image, Data
TV phone,Internet,
Mail,TV
Medical Remote MedicalService
Image, Data
Diagnosis to patient
Safety
Navigation
Outside
and
Inside
Lookout
Image,Voice Lookout by camera etc
Monitoring
Hull Monitoring
Engine Monitoring
Cargo Monitoring
Data
Monitoring of Hull stress,
ship's
motions, rpm, FO.
Thrust ,Cargo
Information
Support
to ShipEnvironmental
Information
Data
Weather , Wave Forecasting
Weather Routing
Route Information
Guidance Way
Point
Trackingand Control
Data
Guiidance and Control of
Ship
in Ocean and Port
Ship
Management
Damage Control Ship Performance
Data, Image
Damage Control,Long Term
Performance
Management
Risk
Management
Hazard at sea
Data, Image
Real TimeInformation
ocean navigation and development of useful contents for safety and eco and energy
saving navigation
In this chapter, we introduce the activity of the marine broad band network project.
3.2
Maritime Broad Band Network for Ocean Going Ship
The marine broad band network project began with a satellite communication
between land and sea using the JSAT's satellite and the service of NTT communications.
Fig.4 shows the feature of the satellite maritime broad band system developed by the
project. The communication speed of the network realized 1 Mbps in up link and 1.2
Mbps in
down linkbetween
the
training
shipShioji Maru in TUMSAT.
Witt - )1
a
i
aita3- 5,, 'MIMI JD'1-41#3II
7,0 1 RF I Ammon K25--BER2D00 I mares1-1sp
S/Gt4'44*
IIIIIP 7-0 EM45111''5 [77(Ilg) I7-0 --1 e ,.. F. A"RIM=
11E71)-5- tRiil ciFtOft SW-1-11-16 GSM=Fig.4 Feature of Maritime Broad Band Network
3.3 Coastal Marine Broad Band Network
On the other hand, as the coastal navigation project, a wireless LAN network system
using many light houses, in which many ones has already be operated without human
operations(Fig.5). In Japan, there are now 3315 lighthouses and 1251 buoys. All of them
are unmanned. Except for the light house of entrance of port and so on, they are located
at high places in tips of peninsula. Their light arriving range are 20-30 NM.
We beganit in the entrance of Tokyo Bay. Fig 6 shows one of the light house to be installed and
antenna and transmitter.
Light House and
Fig.5 Concept of Coastal Broad Band Project Utilizing Light Houses
Fig.7 shows one example of the wireless LAN bases in the entrance of Tokyo Bay.
According to Fig.7 we need at least over 5 light houses in order to cover the entrance of
Tokyo Bay when the range of wireless output is 3 nm whose value is maximum range
permitted by law.
In near future, this project will become a national project.
- '12. 4.
Tokyo_ Báy
5Miles
Fig.7 Light Houses Alignment at Entrance of Tokyo Bay (The Doted Circles are not permitted by Law)
3.4 On-board Local Area Network (LAN) System
In order to realize the broad band communication between land and
sea, we need realtime observing system and data transmission technique through
on board LAN systemand finally, establishment of unified standard of signal communication.
Especially, anestablishment and standardization of on board LAN system is urgent problem.
Our
project has technically supported the project supported by Japan
Marine Equipment
Association.
4 Applications
4.1 Example of Image Data Communication
In this chapter, we describe some examples carried by the project using the satellite
network
system. Most powerful
effectgained by realization
of broad band
communication network is to be possible to exchange
many image data. The people
living on land and the people on board
can receive or send the real and clear image data.
Effective application of the image data exchange
between ship and land is damage
time image using a head mounted camera in an engine room. The image data can are
sent to land through the established network. Not only seafarers on board but also the
staff on land can monitor the state of engine and find the place of damage.
Engine
Monitoring
MEM =NM EMI *LI MO-MNFig.8 Engine Room Monitoring using Images
Nowadays, important information on navigation, for example on prediction of weather,
wave, and tide are gained through
INTERNET. The crews on board can gain such a
comfortable internet environment by the broad band
communication system. Fig.9
shows one example of the navigation information view. In this example, the people on
land can monitor ship's motions in real time.
Fig.10 shows a lookout view from a flyingbridge through a Skype camera system.
Another feasible important application is a remote
medical services. Using a clear
picture through the network system, a patient on
board can receive effective medical
examination by doctor in a hospital on land. This project will be actually tested by
National Institute for Sea Training.
Navigation
Information
Views
.
8, -111,1.1 II e ria ..1.,. El ...um, OPRAnnrail_a__a_
- rrniT2----114,,,,. imir Igor mi., 'Arms. loom
Fig.9 Navigation Information Views on Land
L.-INV a 111
M
r . 1 "B. ,i1V77.114.3,0 4-1R4 12011 ..tsakom ibwro .4.S. 4 LI EA (.00Fig.10 View from Flying Bridge through
a Skype Camera
100 200 210 220 '0 2*
MliM=1 ;i00% I 8 ?;
4.2 Example of Ship's Monitoring System
Nowadays, concerns having the highest priority in earth level are saving energy and
the realization of eco-society. The navigation of ship is also not exceptionable. In ship's
navigation, most energy loss is given by strong ship's motions at rough sea, the
movement of main engine and other machineries. Therefore the monitoring of ship's
state is important for realization of safety, eco and energy saving navigation
However,the number of crews are now reduced and resultantly, they have no room to monitor all
states of ship. Thus, it is important to support the crews from land.
Fig. 11 are heading, rudder, true wind direction, wind force, drift angle, rolling,
pitching and thrust of a large ocean going ship sampled at 1 sec ,their spectra so on. Fig.
12 shows the change of their spectra. By monitoring such a data by staff on land in
stead of busy crews on board, we can realize energy saving and eco
navigation.
I FF
-
---Data Inspection v,., E. A A r E.Fig.11 Time Series Records of Ship's Motion Fig.12 Analyzing of Ship Motion
4.3 Example of
Ship's Long Span Management
Received data from ship are stored on land at each ship and then we can make own
data base of each ship. For examples, by analyzing such a data, we can gain information
on trend, seasonal trend
and prediction of sea margin in each ship. Fig.13 shows the
change of sea margin in long span. We can decompose such long span data of trend,
seasonal
element and aging effect. Based on this information, we can judge the timing
J
Fouling+Aging+Seasonal =Se SI Slargin Slodel
1982 Actual Nlargin ¡OW fi014101: Strike!
/
I 4#P10 : : n a II-.. Hal" AgingFffctSea Nlargin Model
Fig.13 Analysis of Sea Margin in one middle class container ship
4.4 Example of Radar Information Exchange
RADAR gives precious information to navigator in order to know own and other ship's
positions. By acknowledgement of other ship's positions, the ship can determine her
next course and speed in order to avoid collision with other ships. Moreover, recently
an AIS (automatic identification system) became compulsory in large ship. If other
ship's position not only near own ship but also out of range of own radar get, safety of
navigation would increase. Our project team is now creating radar information
exchange system between many ships. Fig.14 shows example of the radar information
to be sent from ship to other ship or to traffic control center through the broad band net
work system. 1981 1 e 1983 J n n 4181 6410 Dap. in 'cr. ice 8110 Fouling Effect 200
i
Fig.14 RADAR Information of Tokyo Bay in TUMSAT
4.5 Example of Ship's Weather Routing
System
A ship builds navigation plan before leaving, considering change of weather during
sailing to destination port. However, the weather condition during sailing often
changes from the expected one. Thus, the ship need demand rerouting based on
updated weather conditions to land. The staff in land rebuild an energy saving or
minimum time navigation plan, considering the updated ship's states received through
satellite network. The marine broad band
project has carried out the actual
experiments of weather routing and re-routing
using inland sailing ship. In this
experiment, the way points are given to the ship, the ship tracks along the given route
Information_ 40_
O
38
Give an Optimal Route
From land
42 36 ... ... ... 34 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 LONGITUDE o o 5444 Wind 13044110n Y5.31 /1441 34444 V/ 144 5,445 07 1. 4.31Optimal Route
Tracking
Fig.15
Optimal Weather Routing Navigation in an Inland Ship
5
Conclusion
This paper described about the necessity of innovation in its speed and capacity
ofcommunication between ship and land and introduced the recent projects on the marine
broad band. in TUMSAT. We hope that the marine broad band network fixes
to and
realize safety and energy saving echo navigation system through the network.
We thank for the contribution to our project to NTT Communication
Co.LtdSkyperfect JSAT Co.Ltd, Ube Shipping Co.Ltd, Mitsui Ship Building
Co.Ltd JRC CoLtd ,Mitsui,
Akishima Co.Ltd and Toyo Engineering Co.LtdAn Estimation Tool of Long Term Benefits of Auxiliar Wind
Propulsion by Means of a Traction Kite Including the Effect of
Route Optimization
Peter Naaijen, Wei Shi, Delft University of Technology, the Netherlands Jean-Gregoire Kherian, GustoMSC, the Netherlands
SUMMARY
This paper describes an estimation tool to assess long-term benefits of auxiliary wind propulsion means
of traction kites. Methods are described to estimate kite propulsion force, ship and resistance and
propulsion performance without using any specific experimental data of the considered ship and kite
system. A voyage optimization/simulation tool is presented that has been developed in order to
assessthe effect of route optimization. Results of the performance prediction for the 52560 tons displacement
bulk carrier Jin Hui is presented.
INTRODUCTION
Although the recent drop in oil price
dramatically
decreases the direct financialbenefit for ship owners of reducing fossil fuel
consumption, there is
still enough reason to
search for sustainable alternatives if the long
term is considered: sooner or later, the oil price
will increase again. Besides, there is an ongoing
process to regulate emissions in the UN-based
International Maritime Organization (IMO).
which is based on Art. 2.2 of the Kyoto Protocol.
EU has stated that international shipping to the
EU region may be regulated by EU by linking it
to EU ETS from 2012 unless a global regulation
is established [1]. Either way, polluting will
have to be paid for in the near future.
Shipping is the most energy-efficient mode of
transport which is probably why the sector has
got away with doing very
littleto reduce
emissions until now. The fact that shipping
(responsible for transporting more than 90 % of
world trade) accounts for approx. 3-5 % of
global CO2 emissions
ismore and more
considered to be a good reason to change this.
One way to achieve this is to reintroduce wind
power. Having some advantages compared to
conventional sails, a traction kite propulsion
system for commercial ships is an interesting
concept which is being worked on by various
parties in industry
This paper describes an accurate method to
assess the long term benefit of wind assisted
propulsion, applied on the specific concept of
ahigh performance (high lift to drag ratio)
kitefor traction force generation.
Attached to a single tow line via a steering
gondola, these kites can be actively controlled in
order to create high flying speeds resulting in
high traction force. Figure 1 depicts such
aFigure 1, Ship with kite (courtesy: Skysails)
Compared
to more conventional windpropulsion by sails, there are some benefits
involved with applying kites:
a kite can be actively controlled in order
to create
its own flying speed thus
increasing its apparent wind speed and
the traction force: more traction power
can be created with less 'sail' area this
way.
due to the fact that a kite can fly at
higher altitudes it is exposed to higher
wind speed
due to the low attachment point of the
tow line the roll heeling moment is
considerably smaller
there are no masts taking deck space
A logical
firststep when quantifying the
benefits of such a system is to analyze its
performance for
a range of environmental
conditions. A detailed description of such an
analysis can be found in Naaijen et.al. [8].
When considering the area of operation of the
specific
ship of which the performance
isknown, average long-term wind and wave data
can be used to estimate the long term fuel
saving potential. This kind of analysis has been
presented by Jdger [2].
However, since the environmental conditions
play such an important role in the case of wind
propulsion, it can be expected that the efficiency
increase that can be obtained by applying
weather routing is even more pronounced than
is the case for conventional propulsed ships, and
therefore should be taken into account to come
towards a fair and accurate estimate of
long-term fuel saving.
In the following, the estimation
of
theperformance of a kite equipped ship, based on
some general input parameters
is brieflydescribed. Results for case study are presented.
Next, the
tool isdescribed that has been
developed to include the effect
of route
optimization of long-term fuel saving.
Performance analysis
Introduction
This section describes how the performance of
the ship
kite system is analyzed. First the kite
traction force calculation is explained followed
by a description of how kite, hull, propeller and
engine interact finally
resulting
in fuelconsumption and forward speed that can be
obtained in prescribed wind conditions.
Kite traction
A kite can be considered as a wing surface
which enables the application
of existing
aerodynamic concepts: the resulting force acting
on a kite is determined by
calculating lift and
drag on a 3D wing surface being governed by
relative wind speed and angle of attack. The
main assumption for the model is instantaneous
equilibrium between the direction of the tow
line and the direction
of
theresultant
aerodynamic force on the kite. For a kite, this
equilibrium is depending on its position in space
which will be described using the so-called
flight envelope (FE). The apparent wind speed,
experienced by the kite is a combination of true
wind, ship speed and the kite's own flying
speed. Depending on the position, the kite
willdevelop its flying speed in such a way that
theresulting force is parallel to the tow line. It's
thecalculation to determine this equilibrium speed
and the resulting towing force.
Flight Envelope
The set of possible positions in space of a kite,
attached to a tow line with length r, is described
by a quarter sphere with radius r, which is called
the flight envelope (FE). See Figure 2 where the
direction of the true wind is indicated. True
wind speed is defined by W. Point F is the
attachment point of the tow line. The half circle
LUR is called the edge of the FE. P is the centre
of the so-called power zone. When assuming
uniform inflow over the altitude in the FE, P is
the point where the highest speed and traction of
the kite are obtained. The boundary layer for the
wind speed in which wind speed increases with
altitude will result in an maximum speed and
traction force occurring at a certain altitude
above the mentioned point P.
All half circles parallel to LUR are called
iso-power lines: kite speed and traction are constant
on these lines. All circle segments from P to the
edge are iso-gradient lines: the gradient of speed
and power has a constant maximum value on
these lines.
The position of the kite within the FE, indicated
by K is described by two angles (See Figure 2):
O is the inclination of the tow line FK with
respect to the line FP
(1)
is the inclination of the plane FKP with
respect to the horizontal plane
In order to describe the flying direction of the
kite, a kite reference system xic, YK, zK is defined
having its origin at K. The xi( axis is tangential
to the iso-power line through K pointing from L
to R, while the yK axis is tangential to the
iso-gradient line through K pointing towards P. The
zK axis is parallel to the tow line, pointing
outwards the FE.
y is the angle between the flying direction of the
kite and the positive xK axis. See Figure 3
showing a top view (looking in negative
zK direction) on the kite.Figure 2, Flight Envelope (FE)
YK
v,
XK
V.
Figure 3, Kite in projected plane of FE
Having defined how the kite's position and
flying direction are described, this definition is
used now to
formulate the apparent wind
experienced by the kite.
First, the apparent wind is split up into a part
tangential to the FE (vt) which is a combination
of tangential velocities vt_x and lit, in xK and yK
direction respectively, and a radial part parallel
The tangential
velocity
is caused by acombination of true wind and kite speed. The
part due to the kite speed can be split up into a
part tangential to the iso-power lines in the
direction of xK (vx_k) and a part tangential to the iso-gradient lines in the direction of yK (vy_k). In
YK direction, there is a contribution by the true
wind (v) as well. With the above mentioned
definitions, the following formulae for these
velocities can be found:
= -rd + Wsin(0) = v y_k+v),_, (1)
i 43= vx, (2)
Combining these two contributions to the total
tangential velocity yields:
(3)
For the flying speed vk and direction y of the kite follows:
Vk=NIVy_k2 + V k_k2
,Vk_k
The radial velocity is caused by true wind only:
= Wcos(0) (6)
With the above defined velocities, a formula
forthe total relative velocity vrei and the angle
of
attack a experienced by the kite can be derived:
(See Figure 4 which depicts a cross section of
the kite and the involved angle of attack.)
Figure 4, Kite Angle of Attack
v a =
arctanH
v,
a, = a -;
kPerpendicular to tow line
ChorNd line Re l edative wind' N
a
ow line Vt e %v,
(8)To find the effective angle of attack, ae, the
angle at which the kite is attached to the tow
line, ak, has to be subtracted from a. (Figure 4)
(9)
Lift and Drag
To determine the resulting force on the kite, first
lift and drag of the 2D airfoil are determined.
Corrections to this 2D lift and drag coefficients
are made in order to take into account
3Dinduced drag and the curvature of the kite.
Furthermore some additional
contributions to
the drag are considered which take into account
line drag, inlet drag, and drag due to
irregularities and surface roughness.
2D lift and drag coefficients are calculated
bythe free available panel method program XFOIL
by Drela & Youngren [3]. The inviscid
flowcalculated by the program is constructed by a
superposition of three potential flows being the
free stream, a flow created by a vortex sheet on
the airfoil surface and a source sheet on
the
airfoil surface and wake. y = arctan v v_k
The viscous part of the solution resulting in
frictional resistance is described by boundary
layer shape parameter equations. For a detailed
description of XFOIL reference
is made to
Drela & Youngren [3] and Drela [4].
The obtained 2D lift and drag coefficients have
to be corrected in order to include 3D effects.
This is done based on Prandtl's lifting line
theory assuming elliptical lift distribution over
the wing span.
The fact that a kite has a certain span wise
curvature will also effect the lift of the whole
kite. Resolving the lift force perpendicular to the
curved kite into the ZK direction results in the
following formulation for the lift on the curved
kite according to Lingard [6]: (See Figure 5).
CL = C COS' (4) (10)
where:
CL= 3D Lift coefficient of straight wing CL, = 3D Lift coefficient of curved wing
= angle of curvature (See Figure 5.)
.-kite
4 controlling gondola
Figure 5, lines between gondola and kite
The lines between steering gondola and kite,
where the speed is assumed to equal the speed
of the
kite itself,appear
to generate aconsiderable amount
of
drag. The dragcoefficient of all these lines together can be
determined using the formulation of Prakash
[7]:
CD, =n Rdcos3(a,)
S (11)
where:
Cal = drag
coefficientsof lines
between gondola and kiten = number of lines
R= length of lines between gondola and kite
d = diameter of individual lines
= angle of attack between relative speed and
kite line S = kite area
According to Prakash [7] the number of lines
depends on the kite aspect ratio as follows:
n=8+16AR
(12)The diameter of the individual lines between
gondola and kite is chosen such that their total
cross sectional area equals that of the tow line
between gondola and ship.
For determining the line drag the part of the tow
line underneath the
gondola and the
partbetween gondola
and kite are consideredseparately. For the lower part it appeared that
even when taking into account a line drag
coefficient of 3, the drag of the tow line did not
exceed 1% of the total drag (partly because the
speed of the tow line itself is low). Therefore the
lower tow line drag is neglected. (It must be
noted however that an increase in line drag can
be expected due to vortex induced vibrations
which is not taken into account here.)
Other additional drag coefficients come from
the air
inlet, and surface irregularities and
surface roughness. The air inlet is an opening at
the nose of the kite enabling air flow into the
inflatable kite. Approximations
for
drag coefficientsof these components given by
Prakash [7] have been used.
As mentioned,
the key assumption of the
presented approach to calculate the kite traction
is the resultant force on the kite being parallel to
the tow line. When assuming that the Reynolds
number (based on which the 2D lift and drag
coefficients are calculated) is independent of the
instantaneous relative kite velocity v
I and as a
consequence independent of the position of the
kite in the FE, the Lift to Drag ratio (LID) is
also independent of the kite
position. Thismeans that the direction of the resultant kite
force depends on the angle of attack only. With
a known L/D, the required angle of attack for
which the resultant kite force is parallel to the
tow line is easily determined and also
independent of the kite position. Equation (8)
gives the relation between angle of attack and
radial and tangential relative velocity of the kite.
The radial velocity vr_, is a result of true wind
only (equation (6)) and depends on the position
of the kite on the FE. The tangential velocities
12,, and 1/1_,,
however are strongly dependent of
the kite's own speed in terms of (i5 and Ò. So fora given flying direction y and a given
position
on the FE (defined by 0 and t9), the
requiredangle of attack for which the resultant force on
the kite is indeed parallel to the tow line can be
obtained by tuning the kite's own speed in terms
of
and d:
By combining equations (1), (2) and (5) é can
be expressed as follows:
sin(9) 0 tan(y)
(13)By substituting equation (13) and equations (1)
and (2) in the expression for the angle of attack
(8), a quadratic equation for 0 can be obtained:
2(1-2sin2(61).(1+ tan2(y))) (2rsin(19)tan(y))- Wsin(61)
=
'sin2(0)+(Wc°s(e)
pvtan(a) (14)
Having solved q3 from equation (14), é follows
from equation (13).
Knowing the kite velocities the instantaneous
relative velocity v,/ of the kite is known which
enables the calculation of the resultant force on
the kite from the lift and drag force:
L=Y2pv,.2SCL (15)
D=Y2pv,2S-C (16)
As mentioned calculation of lift and drag
coefficients is based on a constant Reynolds
number (independent of location in the FE
and)independent
of
the instantaneousrelative
velocity of the kite. Therefore the lift to drag
ratio is also independent of the location on the
FE and only depending on the angle of attack.
The angle ak between kite cord line and tow line
has been chosen such that the angle of attack for
which the resultant force is parallel to the tow
line is giving the maximum lift to drag ratio. For
the kite considered during the case study that
will be described in the last paragraph, this L to
D ratio amounts to 3.5.
As mentioned, one of the benefits of a kite is
that its relative velocity can be increased by
actively maneuvering it on a desired track on the
FE.
Such a track could be an orbit shaped as
depicted in Figure 6.
O
-300 -200 -100 0
Figure 6, possible kite track on FE
When a certain track is prescribed, total relative
kite velocity and traction force at a finite
number of points on the track can be
determined. The average traction force and its
direction can be calculated by a time integration
over the chosen orbit. In the present study an
orbital shape as depicted in Figure 6 is
considered. The mathematical expression of the
selected type of orbit is presented in Wellicome
[9].
In case of a kite towing a ship, the wind that
enters the FE (being called 'true'
wind until
now) is in fact a combination of true wind and
wind created by the ship's own speed. In
general the direction of these two will not
coincide. The FE is positioned on the ship
insuch a way that its edge is perpendicular to the
direction of combined true wind and ship speed
at the average flying altitude of the kite. As the
kite's flying altitude is supposed to be within the
so-called surface layer of the atmosphere, where
the occurring wind is dominated by pressure
differences and no geotropic winds occur, the
variation of wind speed with altitude can be
expressed by a logarithmic profile (Troen [5]):
W (z)= Cbg
H-
(17)z,
where:
W(z) = Wind speed at altitude z above (sea) surface
Ctog where:
uf= known wind speed at reference level
zf= reference level (10 m)
zo = surface roughness (depending on wave height)
Figure 7 depicts a top view on ship and FE for
astern quartering wind condition. The hatched
area represents a likely area for positioning the
kite track.
App. wind direction at kite's altitude
Figure 7, FE on ship for bow quartering wind
For a given ship course and wind direction,
arange
of tracks
having similar horizontalamplitude as shown in Figure 6 are tested. The
track generating the highest force in the
shipdirection is selected. The horizontal and vertical
amplitudes of the kite track are kept
constant
and were chosen so as to represent a realistic
kite flying behavior.
Concerning the vertical position of the kite
orbit, an optimum can be found resulting in the
highest mean traction force in the ship's sailing
direction.
This optimum flying altitude is governed by:
the variation of traction force over the
FE
the variation
of wind velocity over
altitude
variation of horizontal
traction forcewith inclination of tow line
To assess the effect of the flying altitude on the
kite force in the direction of the forward speed
Xkite, and to find the optimum flying altitude in
terms of maximum Xkite,
simulations of the kite,
flying along an orbital track, have been made
for various flying altitudes during a case study.
(Details about this case study are presented later
on.) For three different towing line lengths, 150
m, 350 m and 550 m and three different wind
speeds, the traction force in the direction of the
forward ship speed (time-averaged over one
revolution on the orbit) has been calculated for
various flying altitudes.
It appears that the altitude at which maximum
forward towing force occurs amounts to 27
to33 % of the towing
line length, slightly decreasing with increasing wind speed.Above presented results are for a wind direction
of 0 degrees off the stern. Similar calculations
have been made for different wind directions
resulting in optimum flying altitudes in the
samerange.
The properties of the kite that has been applied
for the current case study are as follows: Kite area:
Lift coefficient: Drag coefficient: LID ratio:
Line length:
Average flying altitude:
S = 400 m2 CL=0.73 CD=0.21 L/D=3.5 r=300 m
100m
The lift and drag coefficients determined as
described above have been used. Wind tunnel
measurements reported by Gernez [10] resulted
in lift and drag coefficients of 0.70 and 0.18
showing that
the calculated values can be
considered to be realistic.
For a constant ship speed of 15 kn the resulting
kite force in the direction of the forward speed
of the ship is presented in Figure 8
o 5 10 16 a, o_ 4 20 25 a) f-'1 30 35
:700
600 500 400 300 200 100 oparagraph, only the longitudinal drag is relevant
for the current study.
The input parameters that govern the drag force
coefficient
G given by Isherwood for the
longitudinal force are given in Table 1.
Coefficient
G
and corresponding force are
related as follows:c =
Xpc,V2A,
2
I"
Where V, indicates the
experienced by the ship. The
dependent of the
apparent
relative to the ship.
(18)
apparent
wind
coefficient G is
wind direction
Table 1, parameters used for Bulk Carier to determine
C, wind coefficient
Calculation of Fuel Consumption
and
ship speed
In this section the method used to determine the
performance of the existing propulsion system.
As will be explained in the next section, the ship
operation scenario
to be considered
is theconstant propeller revolutions scenario: given a
certain fixed propeller speed, ship speed and
fuel costs engine are to be determined.
Sinceships hull resistance, provided thrust
by the
propeller and kite force are all
depending on
LOA, Length o.a. [m] 189.99
B, Breadth [m] 32.26
AT, Transverse projected wind
area[m2]
756
AL, Lateral projected wind area
[m2] 3570
S, Length of perimeter of lateral
projection [m]
(Excluding waterline and slender
bodies)
300.00
C, Distance from bow to centroid
of lateral projected area [m]
115.00
M, Number of distinct groups of
masts or king posts [-]
2
o 50 100 150
True wind direction [deg]
Figure 8, Kite force 1kNi] against true wind speed [kill and direction [deg] for ship forward speed of 15.0 kn
An operational limit in terms of a maximum
wind speed at which the kite can be applied has
been assumed. Both apparent wind speed
andtrue wind speed are capped at 20 m/s for kite
application.
Wind drag
Apart from the wind driven force generated
bythe kite a second wind force has to be taken into
account that results from the air flow around the
hull
part
above the water line and thesuperstructure. To approximate this force the
method of Isherwood [11] is applied, which is
based on regression analysis of
wind tunnel
measurements.
This method provides drag
force coefficients in longitudinal and transverse
direction and a yaw moment coefficient that can
be obtained
by
substituting some maincharacteristics concerning the ship' s
forward speed, the determination of the forward
speed is an iterative process. Once the ship
speed has been solved, corresponding engine
power and fuel consumption can be determined.
A detailed
descriptionof
the calculation methods can also be found in Shi [12]In this section the
following nomenclature is
used:
diameter of the propeller, m
advanced ratio
engine brake power, kW
effective towing power, kW thrust power, kW
transmission power, kW
torque of propeller, Nm
model-ship correlation resistance, kN resistance of appendages, N
additional pressure resistance of bulbous
bow near the water surface, kN
frictional resistance according to the
ITTC-1957 friction formula, 1(1\1
total ship resistance, kN
additional pressure resistance of immersed transom stern, kN
wave-making and wave-breaking resistance,
kN
thrust of propeller, N ship speed, m/s relative quality
form factor describing the viscous resistance
of the hull form in relation of R1 propeller speed, rad/s
thrust deduction factor wake factor
hull efficiency open water efficiency relative rotative efficiency transmission efficiency
seawater density, kg/m3
Power Transmission
From the propulsion system point of view, the
main engine generates amount of power, known
as the engine brake power, transferred by the
transmission system, (gearbox and shaft), the
power propels the propeller, generating amount
of thrust to overcome the ship resistance. See
Figure 9 for the power transmission through the
propulsion system and the consequent
efficiencies. b P, P th
P
Q prop RA R4 RB RE Rtotal RTR Rw TB, Vship 0* I +k prop tin loFigure 9, Propulsion chain
Ship Resistance
In general, the ship resistance is determined by
the sailing speed, the shape of the hull and the
wave conditions. In the ship design phase, there
are different kinds of methods to predict ship
resistance and other factors, such as the thrust
deduction factor (t) and the wake factor (w), on
the basis of ship dimensional parameters. The
Holtrop and Mennen method, presented
inHoltrop [12] & [13], has been implemented to
calculate ship resistance.
According to the Holtrop and Mennen method,
the total ship resistance is divided into six parts,
as shown in (20):
R1010, = (1+ k,)R, + R4 +R + RB + RTR +R,
In Holtrop [12] & [13], a statistical method,
which resulted into a set of prediction formulas,
was presented for the determination of each
component of the resistance. This method was
based on regression analysis of random model
and full-scale test data. By running this part of
simulation program with the input of ship
design data and ship speed, an accurate value of
ship resistance, as well as the thrust deduction
factor (t) and the wake factor (w), are generated.
Thus, the effective towing power and the hull
efficiency are calculated:
D
Hull Hydromechanics
As was concluded by Naaijen et. al. [8], the drift angle of the hull and required rudder angles
resulting from the transverse force and
yawmoment caused by applying a kite as auxiliary
propulsion are very small. The effects
on thePe fotalVship
(1 t)
H
1 w)
4-overall efficiency appeared to be negligible. For
this reason, in the current study only the
longitudinal force balance is considered. No
additional resistance components due to drift and rudder are taken into account.
Propeller
In order to balance the moving force acted on
the ship body, an estimate of the performances
of the propeller is required. The Wageningen
B-Screw Series are used to predict the thrust, the
delivered torque and the open water efficiency
of the propeller.
Concerning with the steady-state shipping
operation conditions, the ship speed remains
constant, by means of the balance of the ship
resistance, the wind force and the propeller
thrust.
The thrust and torque performance of propeller
of
the
Wageningen B-Screw Series arerepresented by the standard open water curves
using J, KT and KQ. On the basis of experimental
data, refer to Kuiper ,
the Maritime Research
Institute Netherlands (MARIN) developed KT ,
K Q versus J diagram to describe open water
diagram of propellers within Wageningen
B-Screw Series, see Eq. (21), (22) and (23) Also,
fig. 2 illustrates the KT, K Q versus J diagram of
the reference bulk carrier.
j
n D K =TP"P (21)(22)
0.0 0.4 go; 02 0.1 OpenWater DagrernFigure 10. open water propeller diagram of the considered bulk carrier
When calculating VA from ship speed,
theeffective wake factor (w) according to Holtrop
[13] is used. The same source gives values for
the thrust deduction factor
(t)and relative
rotative efficiency (17,) are used to correct the
open water
thrust
Tpro,and torque Qpp.
Afterward, the demanded power in propelling
the propeller is:
p P
(77,77 0)
(8)
Transmission system & Main Diesel Engine
With the assumption of ?it, = 0.97, the demanded
engine brake power at specific ship speed is
achieved:
(9)
Concerning with the fuel
consumption,
asimplified calculation method, based on engine
brake power and engine rotation speed,
isimplemented. As a shown in Brussen [15], the
algorithm can be expressed as:
FC* = (a + bl),* + c(Pb* )2)(d + eneng* + f (,I; )2) (25)
According to Eq. (26), there are 6 parameters
which determine the
trendof engine
fuelconsumption. By combining typical operation
conditions, Table. 1 illustrate a f coefficients
of the main diesel engine of the reference bulk
carrier.
KQ=
P"/
(pnpr,2D5)(23)
Since the open water diagram is based on
the open water test, during which the flow in
front of the propeller is uniform, the open water
propeller efficiency is introduced, as shown
in(24),
as well as the
rioversus J diagram
illustrated in Fig. 2: TV /
=Kr. 1/ (24) / (27z- Qpropn prv) (271- KQ)Iop
0.1 02 0.3 0.4 07 0 &Man. RM. JTable 2, typical engine operation point and coefficients
Table 3, main particulars, engine and propeller characteristics of considered bulk carrier
Overall propulsion performance Bulk
Carrier
The overall performance of the bulk carrier due
to kite application and wind drag is presented
here. For an appropriate range of wind
conditions the force balance of propeller thrust,
kite force and wind drag and hull resistance (all
speed dependent) is solved iteratively. The
resulting ship speed and fuel consumption
arestored in two dimensional lookup tables in order
to avoid time consuming iterative calculations
during the route optimization / simulation
described in the next section. These lookup
tables are visualized in Figure 11 and Figure 12.
In both figures the nominal operation
performance (without wind influence) is shown
by the single contour line and indicated value of
fuel consumption and forward speed.
500
Figure 11, Fuel consumption for given true wind speed
and direction o 10 20 30 40
Fuel consumption
[ton/1;2470r--Effect kite -81
Effect kite
'4
50 100
True wind direction [deg]
150
50
50 100 150
True wind direction [deg]
:1
52 1.5 1.48 1.46 1.44 1.42 1.4 1.30 1 36 17.5 17 16.5 16 15.5 15 14.5 14 13.5Figure 12, Ship speed at constant propeller rate for
given true wind speed and direction
Route optimization
As mentioned, the added value of the developed
tool above existing estimation methods is to
include the effect of route optimization which
might be of significant impact in
case the
performance strongly depends on environmental
conditions.
Route optimization Algorithm
The method used for the actual route
optimization is the so-called modified isochrone
method that was developed at Delft University
of Technology by Hagiwara [16].
Instead of a spatial grid, a time grid is applied in
this method. See Figure 13 : from the starting
Sulzer 6RTA48TB Op. point 1 2 3 4 5 Pi, (kW) 8203 o o 6152 4102 no,0(11m1) 118 118 35 107 94 FC (gis) 389.7 31.1 23.3 283.1 188.1 a 0.0908200 b 1.0532000 c -0.0045346 d 0.6783600 e -0.1477300
f
0.3463700 Bulk carrier General Name: Jin Hui Classification: ABS Al DWT, ton: 44579 Displacement, rn3: 52559 Design speed, knot: 14.8 Principal dimensions Length o.a., m: 189.99 Length p.p., m: 182 Beam mld, m: 32.26 Draught, m : 10.75 Depth, m : 16.69 Cb: 0.802 Cw: 0.84 Cp: 0.818 Engine Main engine: Sulzer Type: 6RTA48TB No: I Power, kW: 8203 Speed, rpm: 118 Fuel type: HFO Propeller No: 1 Diameter, m: 6.35 Type: fixed pitch P/D: 0.59 AE/AO: 0.55 No. of blades: 4 Speed, rpm: 118 D 10 20 co 30 40point the ship is navigated for a preset time
interval At with a certain heading.
X_o
Departure point
Sub-sector angle AS2
tl
fi
tl
Sub-sector S2(k)
Great circle route from X0 to X
- -f
Great circles departing from X.0
Figure 13, Construction of isochrones (Source:
Hagiwara 11611)
This is done for a range of n headings. Doing so,
a number of positions is obtained that can be
reached by the ship at t. From each of these
reached positions, the procedure is repeated
resulting in possible arrival points after 2At.
Form these n arrival points a selection is made
by choosing in every sub-sector (as depicted
inFigure 13) that one having the largest great
circle distance from the starting point. This
selection
of
points defines the so-calledisochrone at t2. The points on the previous
isochrone from which the new found isochrone
points can be reached are memorised.
By repeating
this procedure,a number of
isochrones and the possible tracks between them
are constructed between starting point and final
destination. As soon as the minimum distance
from the latest constructed isochrone is less than
the expected distance that can be covered
duringAt hours, the ship is navigated from each of the
points on the final isochrone to the
destination
along a rhumb line. This method is particularly
suitable for minimum passage time
optimizations.
When it comes to minimum fuel optimization
there are
some restrictions
to the applied operational scenario:For several reasons, an interesting scenario for
kite application is that of constant speed with
varying
thnist
(andcorresponding
varying propeller speed):increasing the ship speed by auxiliary
kite propulsion will decrease the
operability and efficiency of the kite: a
'slow'
ship benefits more from kite
propulsion than a fast one due to the
more favourable apparent wind direction
for slower ships
varying speed may result
in earlierarrival but since arrival time remains
uncertain due to uncertainty in predicted
wind conditions, the question is how
favourable this possible early arrival will
be
For these reasons, the constant speed scenario is
an attractive one which unfortunately cannot be
dealt
with by
the isochrone method: the isochronesare known in
advance for
this
problem and the resulting possible tracks will
diverge from the great circle track until the final
isochrone and then converge to the destination.
The minimum time route is per definition the
shortest route between departure and destination
location. The minimum fuel route however may
not be found this way.
However, the scenario of constant propeller
speed is likely to benefit significantly from kite
propulsion as well. Both ship speed and fuel
consumption will be affected in a similar way
by kite application as was shown in the previous
section: the kite's driving force results in
both
increased speed and as a consequence earlier
arrival and less overall fuel consumption due to
less engine operation hours. Besides, the
fuelconsumption per hour decreases due to the kite
in this scenario as can be seen in Figure 11.
Environmental data
The environmental data to be used in
combination with the developed tool is provided
in so-called ww3-type grib files by the National
Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration
of various environmental quantities such as
wind speed and wind direction, significant wave
height, period and direction. Records for 0 hours
forecast up to 180 hours forecast with 3 hours
intervals are provided in the grib files that are
updated with the latest forecasts every 6 hours.
Optimization vs. Simulation
The developed tool provides the possibility to
both optimize and simulate voyages in a
realistic way: when analyzing a certain voyage
the first step is to find the optimal route between
departure location and destination. This is done
as described above using only the latest grib file
available at the entered departure date and time.
Once the optimal route is found, simulation of
the journey for At hours (the time between the
isochrones) along the optimal course is carried
out, using only the 0 hours forecast values of
several grib files.
Considering the
locationreached after At hours as a new departure point,
the optimization process is repeated to find the
updated optimal route from the reached location
to the destination. This process can be repeated
until the destination is reached.
This way, the minimum At that can be applied
using the described grib files, is 6 hours.
An example of the graphical output of the first
optimization step
for an east bound North
Atlantic crossing from New York to the English
Channel is shown. Isochrones and
interconnecting tracks are depicted in black. The
wind field shown by the blue arrows
corresponds with the forecast for the last part of
the voyage.
The minimum
distance routedeviates from the great circle since the great
circle crosses some pieces of land (Nova Scotia
and New Foundland) in this example. As can be
seen the minimum fuel route hardly deviates
from the minimum distance route in this
case.However this
willstrongly depend on the
predicted wind conditions.
6 4
\\\\\A
\\\\\\\
.Nm,\\\,,
\i"\\\\\,
\\''
\\\\\\% \\\,,4""\"1
\\\ //J.' \\\4' 4j. 11,
Figure 14, example of optimization of east bound North Atlantic crossing
Future work
Added resistance in waves has not been taken
into account in any of the presented results. It
will
be implemented by means of using
quadratic RAO's for the added resistance in
waves resulting from calculations with existing
strip theory software.
Having developed the described tool, it will be
used to optimize and simulate
a sufficientnumber of voyages for different ocean areas and
seasons, with and without kite propulsion and
compare those
to great circle (or shortestdistance) crossings in order to obtain statistics
on the long term benefits of applying kite
propulsion and the effect of route optimization
on it.
Acknowledgements
Ashish Jha and Anoop Mohan contributed to the
development of the presented simulation tool for
which they are gratefully acknowledged.
3
The authors thank Prof. Hideki Hagiwara for
providing parts of the original code of the
modified isochrone method.
REFERENCES
[li
Torvanger, A. What happens in sectors
outside of the EU ETS: Shipping and Aviation, CLIPORE seminar on
Critical Aspects of the Post 2012 EU
Climate Policy, Gothenburg 25th June
2008
Jager, D. A tool to estimate the economical effects of kite propulsion technology Bsc. Thesis work
commissioned by "Stichting de
Noordzee", the Netherlands 2008
Drela, M., Youngren, H., XFOIL 6.94
User Guide, MIT Dept. of
Aerodynamica and & Astrodynamics, Aerocraft, Inc, 2001
(http://raphael.mit.edu/xfoil/xfoil doc.t
xt)
Drela, M.,An analysis and design
system for low Reynold's number
airfoils, MIT Dept. of Aerodynamica
and & Astrodynamics,1989
Troen, I. and Petersen, E.L., European
Wind Atlas, Riso National Laboratory,
1989
Lingard, J. S., Ram-air Parachute
Design, Precision Aerial Delivery
Seminar, 13th AIAA Aerodynamic
Decelerator Systems Technology
Conference, Clearwater Beach,1995
Prakash, O., Aerodynamics and
Longitudinal Stability of
Parafoil/Payload System, Department
of Aerospace Engineering, Indian
Institute of Technology, Bombay, 2004
[8]
Naaijen P., Koster V., Dallinga R.P. On
the Power Savings by an Auxiliary
KitePropulsion System, ISP Volume 53
No.4 2006
[7]
Wellicome J.F., Wilkinson S., Ship
Propulsion Kites An Initial Study. Ship Science dept. report SSSU 19,
1984
Gernez E., Experimental and numerical
investigation of the Performance of a
Kite, MSc Report, Ship Science dept,
University of Southampton, 2006
Isherwood, R.M., Wind Resistance of
Merchant Ships, Trans. of the Royal
Institution of Naval Architects, 1973 W. Shi, D. Stapersma and H.
Grimmelius, "Simulation of the
influence of ship voyage profiles on
exhaust emissions", in Proc. IMECE
08, ASME Conference
J. Holtrop, G.G.J. Mennen, 1978, "A
statistical power prediction method",
International Shipbuilding Progress,
Vol. 25.
J. Holtrop, G.G.J. Mennen, 1982, "An
approximate power prediction
method", International Shipbuilding
Progress, Vol. 29.,
P. Brussen, 2006, "CO2-emissions of
various ship types, simulated in an
operational year profile", TNO report,
2006-D-R0262.