View of Analysis of Operational Availability of Public City Buses in Selected Periods of Use

HNVSORDWDFMDLWHVW\

-RDQQD5\PDU]$QGU]HM1LHZF]DV(ZD'ĘELFND

$QDOL]DJRWRZRĘFLDXWREXVµZPLHMVNLFKZZ\EUDQ\FK

RNUHVDFKXķ\WNRZDQLD

-(/ O18. '2, 10.24136/atest.2018.347. 'DWD]JâRV]HQLD 7.10.2018. 'DWDDNFHSWDFML 30.11.2018. &HOHPDUW\NXâXMHVWSRUyZQDQLHJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMDXWREXVyZ PLHMVNLFK3U]HSURZDG]RQREDGDQLDSRSXODUQ\FKPDUHNDXWREXVyZ ZIXQNFMLF]DVXXŮ\WNRZDQLDZRNUHVLHODWHNVSORDWDFMLZ0LHMVNLP 3U]HGVLĘELRUVWZLH.RPXQLNDF\MQ\PZ/XEOLQLH=DSUH]HQWRZDQRQRZ\ SRG]LDâF]DVXHNVSORDWDFMLQDRNUHVSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\M- QHMLRNUHVRJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMSRMD]GyZ:\ND-]DQRŮHŒUHGQLHZDUWRŒFLJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMEDGDQ\FKDXWREXVyZ UyŮQLâ\VLĘLVWRWQLHPLĘG]\VREĉ]HZ]JOĘGXQDPDUNĘSRMD]GXDWDNŮH ]HZ]JOĘGXQDRNUHVHNVSORDWDFML'RRFHQ\LVWRWQRŒFLUyŮQLFZ\NRU]\-VWDQRPHWRGĘDQDOL]\ZDULDQFML$129$ 6âRZDNOXF]RZHJRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDDXWREXV\NRPXQLNDFMLPLHM-VNLHMRNUHVSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLRNUHVRJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFL

:VWĘS

:DŮQ\PVNâDGQLNLHPVSRâHF]Q\FKSRWU]HEWUDQVSRUWRZ\FKVĉ SU]HZR]\OXG]LZGXŮ\FKDJORPHUDFMDFKPLHMVNLFK=DGDQLDWH UHDOL]RZDQHVĉSU]H]Z\VSHFMDOL]RZDQHV\VWHP\WUDQVSRUWXPLHM- VNLHJR:W\PREV]DU]HV]F]HJyOQLHZDŮQHVĉZâDŒFLZH]DU]ĉ- G]DQLHUHDOL]DFMĉ]DGDĽSU]HZR]RZ\FKRUD]]DSHZQLHQLHQLH]D-ZRGQRŒFLŒURGNyZWUDQVSRUWX :\VRNLHVWDQGDUG\QLH]DZRGQRŒFLŒURGNyZWUDQVSRUWXVĉ RF]HNLZDQHQLHW\ONRSU]H]SDVDŮHUyZDOHLSU]H]SU]HZRŬQLNyZ SRQLHZDŮXPRŮOLZLDMĉ]PQLHMV]HQLHNRV]WyZG]LDâDQLDSU]HGVLĘ-ELRUVWZD>@DMHGQRF]HŒQLHVĉZDUXQNLHPSUHVWLŮXL]DXIDQLD ]HVWURQ\XŮ\WNRZQLNyZ 0RŮOLZRŒýSUDZLGâRZHMLHIHNW\ZQHMUHDOL]DFML]DGDĽSU]HZR-]RZ\FKZLVWRWQ\VSRVyE]DOHŮ\RGSR]LRPXJRWRZRŒFLŒURGNyZ WUDQVSRUWXLLFKQDSUDZLDOQRŒFL:]URVWMDNRŒFLZ\NRQ\ZDQ\FK QDSUDZRUD]VNUyFHQLHF]DVXQDSUDZ\SRZRGXMĉ]ZLĘNV]HQLH SU]HELHJyZPLĘG]\XV]NRG]HQLDPLRUD]Z]URVWJRWRZRŒFLWHFK- QLF]QHM>@:NRQVHNZHQFMLSURZDG]LWRGRZLĘNV]HJRZ\NRU]\- VWDQLD]GROQRŒFLSU]HZR]RZHMSU]HGVLĘELRUVWZDWUDQVSRUWRZH-JR>@%DGDQLDHPSLU\F]QHSRWZLHUG]DMĉŮHSR]LRPJRWRZRŒFL WHFKQLF]QHMMHVWIXQNFMĉLFKVWDQXWHFKQLF]QHJRGHWHUPLQRZDQH-JRSU]HELHJLHPLF]DVHPHNVSORDWDFML>@ 8Z]JOĘGQLDMĉFSU]HGVWDZLRQHSU]HVâDQNLZQLQLHMV]\PDUW\NX-OHSU]HGVWDZLRQRZ\EUDQHDVSHNW\DQDOL]\JRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHM DXWREXVyZ0RGHORFHQ\JRWRZRŒFLRSUDFRZDQRQDSRGVWDZLH GDQ\FKSR]\VNDQ\FK]0LHMVNLHJR3U]HGVLĘELRUVWZD.RPXQLND-F\MQHJRZ/XEOLQLH

*RWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDDXWREXVyZ

*RWRZRŒýRELHNWXWHFKQLF]QHJRGHILQLXMHVLĘMDNRSUDZGRSR-GRELHĽVWZR]QDMGRZDQLDVLĘRELHNWXZVWDQLH]GDWQRŒFL>@ :VNDŬQLNWHQLQWHUSUHWRZDQ\MHVWMDNRSUDZGRSRGRELHĽVWZR ]GROQRŒFLGRSRGMĘFLDSUDF\ZRNUHŒORQ\PF]DVLH>@*RWR-ZRŒý]DOHŮ\QLHW\ONRRGSU]HVWRMyZ]ZLĉ]DQ\FK]XWU]\PDQLHP WHFKQLF]Q\PSRMD]GyZDOHUyZQLHŮRGSUDZGRSRGRELHĽVWZDQLH-Z\NRQDQLDSU]H]V\VWHPSU]\SLVDQ\FKPXIXQNFML>@1D SRGVWDZLHOLWHUDWXU\>@RUD]GRNXPHQWDFMLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM 03.Z/XEOLQLHSU]\MĘWRZQLQLHMV]HMSUDF\LŮJRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]-QDEĘG]LHGHÀQLRZDQDZHGâXJQDVWĘSXMĉFHJRZ]RUX>@ _୥ሺ–ሻ ൌ୸_െ୬ ୸ ή ͳͲͲ ) gdzie: Nz²OLF]EDDXWREXVyZ]GDWQ\FKZGDQ\PRNUHVLHHNVSORDWDFML

w rozpatrywanym systemie transportowym;

Nn²OLF]EDDXWREXVyZQLH]GDWQ\FKZGDQ\PRNUHVLHHNVSORDWDFML

w rozpatrywanym systemie transportowym.

&HOHPRFHQ\JRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMDXWREXVXMHVWQDMF]ĘŒFLHM Z\]QDF]HQLHSURJQR]\F]\GDQ\RELHNWWHFKQLF]Q\EĘG]LH]QDM- GRZDâVLĘZVWDQLH]GDWQRŒFLZSU]\V]âRŒFLLF]\XPRŮOLZLWRUHDOL-]DFMĘ]DGDQLDSU]HZR]RZHJR 'RVWDW\VW\F]QHJRSRUyZQDQLDJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMEDGD-Q\FKPDUHNDXWREXVyZZ\NRU]\VWDQRPHWRGĘDQDOL]\ZDULDQFML >²@

3U]HELHJEDGDĽ

2ELHNWHPEDGDĽE\â\DXWREXV\PDUHNSRMD]GyZ'SURGXFHQW NUDMRZ\L,SURGXFHQW]DJUDQLF]Q\XŮ\WNRZDQ\FKZ0LHMVNLP 3U]HGVLĘELRUVWZLH.RPXQLNDF\MQ\PZ/XEOLQLH$XWREXV\WHQD-OHŮĉGRNODV\SRMD]GyZPD[L%DGDQLDSURZDG]RQHE\â\PHWRGĉ SUyE\FLĉJâHM$XWREXV\E\â\HNVSORDWRZDQHZSRGREQ\FKZD-UXQNDFK3RMD]G\SRFKRG]Lâ\]SDUWLLSURGXNF\MQHMDXWREXV\ SRVLDGDâ\NROHMQHQXPHU\SRGZR]LDLE\â\ZSURZDG]RQHGRHNV-ploatacji w jednakowym czasie.

/LF]QRŒýSUyENLZ\QRVLâDRELHNWyZPDUNL'RUD]RELHN-W\PDUNL,'DQHUHMHVWURZDQRZRNUHVLHPLHVLĘF\őUHGQLH G]LHQQHSU]HELHJLDXWREXVyZZ\QRVLâ\RNRâRNPZDKDQLD VNUDMQHQLHSU]HNUDF]Dâ\NPőUHGQLPLHVLĘF]Q\SU]HELHJZ\-QLyVâNPGODDXWREXVyZ'LNPGODDXWREXVyZ, %DGDQHDXWREXV\REVâXJLZDâ\UHJXODUQHOLQLHNRPXQLNDF\MQH w ruchu miejskim.

:\QLNLEDGDĽHPSLU\F]Q\FK

:VNDŬQLNLJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMDXWREXVyZPDUNL'L,SU]HGVWD- ZLRQRZ]DOHŮQRŒFLRGF]DVXXŮ\WNRZDQLD1DU\V]DSUH]HQWR-ZDQRZ\NUHVJRWRZRŒFLZXMĘFLXURF]Q\PDVWDW\VW\NLRSLVRZH SRGDQRZWDE :SU]\SDGNXDXWREXVyZPDUNL'PRŮQD]DXZDŮ\ýVSDGHN JRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMZFDâ\POHWQLPRNUHVLHXŮ\WNRZDQLD SU]\ZVSyâF]\QQLNX]PLHQQRŒFLUyZQ\P:SU]\SDGNXDX-WREXVyZPDUNL,ŒUHGQLDJRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDPDOHMHGRSLHUR SRXSâ\ZLHODW:VSyâF]\QQLN]PLHQQRŒFLE\âWXUyZQ\ ZFDâ\PRNUHVLHODWHNVSORDWDFML :GDOV]HMF]ĘŒFLDQDOL]\Z\QLNyZEDGDĽZFDâNRZLW\PREVHU-ZRZDQ\PRNUHVLHODWXŮ\WNRZDQLDZ\UyŮQLRQRÅRNUHVSHâQHM SU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMµREHMPXMĉF\SLHUZV]HODWDXŮ\W-

NRZDQLDSRMD]GyZRUD]ÅRNUHVRJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNV-HNVSORDWDFMDLWHVW\

SORDWDF\MQHMµREHMPXMĉF\NROHMQHODWDXŮ\WNRZDQLD²ODW 3RG]LDâQDRNUHV\SHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMLRJUDQL-F]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMZ\QLND]IDNWXVNRNRZHJR Z]URVWXLQWHQV\ZQRŒFLXV]NRG]HĽSRMD]GyZZGUXJLPRNUHVLHLFK XŮ\WNRZDQLD>@ :\QLNLREOLF]HĽŒUHGQLHMJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMDXWREXVyZ ZZ\UyŮQLRQ\FKSU]HG]LDâDFKF]DVXXŮ\WNRZDQLDSU]HGVWDZLRQR QDU\VRUD]ZWDE0RŮQDWX]DXZDŮ\ý]QDF]ĉFĉUyŮQLFĘ JRWRZRŒFLPLĘG]\RNUHVDPL33(L23(:ÅRNUHVLHRJUDQLF]RQHM SU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMµF]\OLZRNUHVLH²ODWHNVSORDWD-FMLJRWRZRŒýDXWREXVyZ'VSDGâDRZVWRVXQNXGRÅRNUHVX SHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMµDGODDXWREXVyZ,²RSR-QDGU\V :DUWRŒFLŒUHGQLHJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMSRUyZQDQR]DSRPR-FĉW\SRZ\FKWHVWyZVWDW\VW\F]Q\FKSUH]HQWRZDQ\FKZOLWHUDWXU]H SU]HGPLRWX3U]HSURZDG]RQRMHGQRF]\QQLNRZĉDQDOL]ĘZDULDQ-FML]SRG]LDâHPQDÅRNUHVSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMµ LÅRNUHVRJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMµ'RREOLF]HĽ Z\NRU]\VWDQRSDNLHW67$7,67,&$:SU]HSURZDG]RQ\PWH-ŒFLHF]\QQLNLHPNODV\ÀNXMĉF\PE\âDÅPDUNDSRMD]GXµQDWRPLDVW ]PLHQQĉ]DOHŮQĉREMDŒQLDQĉE\âDJRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDZGD-Q\PRNUHVLHHNVSORDWDFML6SUDZG]RQRF]\LVWQLHMĉREVHUZDFMH RGVWDMĉFHZSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKRNUHVDFKXŮ\WNRZDQLDSRMD]GyZ LZ\âĉF]RQRMH]GDOV]\FKREOLF]HĽ:\NUHVUDPND²ZĉV\SR XVXQLĘFLXREVHUZDFMLRGVWDMĉF\FKZRNUHVLHRJUDQLF]RQHMLSHâQHM SU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMSU]HGVWDZLRQRQDU\V 7DE6WDW\VW\NLRSLVRZHJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMDXWREXVyZPDUNL'L,ZIXQNFML F]DVXXŮ\WNRZDQLDZXMĘFLXURF]Q\P *RWRZRğýWHFKQLF]QD.JğU>@ /DWD PDUND' PDUND, ğUHGQLD RGFK\OHQLH  VWDQGDUGRZH ZVSyâF]\QQLN  ]PLHQQRğFL ZDUWRğý  minimalna ZDUWRğý 

PDNV\PDOQD ğUHGQLD RGFK\OHQLH

 VWDQGDUGRZH ZVSyâF]\QQLN  ]PLHQQRğFL ZDUWRğý  minimalna ZDUWRğý  PDNV\PDOQD 1 0,910 0,04 0,049 0,807 0,968 0,900 0,086 0,095 0,677 1,000 2 0,882 0,05 0,052 0,813 0,950 0,903 0,078 0,087 0,690 0,984 3 0,888 0,06 0,064 0,769 0,967 0,944 0,025 0,026 0,908 0,981 4 0,849 0,06 0,068 0,764 0,944 0,890 0,037 0,042 0,819 0,960 5 0,845 0,04 0,046 0,772 0,920 0,874 0,081 0,093 0,649 0,968 6 0,847 0,07 0,087 0,700 0,962 0,921 0,032 0,034 0,864 0,966 ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH     _{ }                       *RWRZRĜÈ WHFKQLF]QD .J ĜU 5>@ 5RNHNVSORDWDFML 0DUND' 0DUND, 5\VőUHGQLDJRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDDXWREXVyZZIXQNFMLF]DVXXŮ\WNRZDQLDZXMĘFLX URF]Q\P ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH             33( 23( *RWRZRĜÈ WHFKQLF]QD .JĜU 33(23( >@ 0DUND' 0DUND, 5\VőUHGQLDJRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDDXWREXVyZZRNUH- VLHSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM33(RUD]RJUD-QLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM23( ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH 7DE6WDW\VW\NLRSLVRZHJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMDXWREXVyZPDUNL'L,ZIXQNFML F]DVXXŮ\WNRZDQLDZXMĘFLXURF]Q\P 2NUHV 0DUND *RWRZRğýWHFKQLF]QD.JğU>@ ğUHGQLD RGFK\OHQLH  VWDQGDUGRZH ZVSyâF]\QQLN  ]PLHQQRğFL ZDUWRğý  minimalna ZDUWRğý  PDNV\PDOQD PPE D 0,894 0,051 0,057 0,769 0,968 OPE 0,847 0,058 0,069 0,700 0,962 PPE _I 0,916 0,071 0,078 0,677 1,000 OPE 0,895 0,058 0,065 0,649 0,968 ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH 5\V:\NUHVUDPND²ZĉV\]PLHQQHM]DOHŮQHM²JRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QD GODF]\QQLNDÅPDUNDSRMD]GXµZRNUHVLHSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWD- F\MQHMRUD]RJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMSRXVXQLĘ-FLXREVHUZDFMLRGVWDMĉF\FK ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH

HNVSORDWDFMDLWHVW\

=DâRŮHQLDQLH]DOHŮQRŒFLRUD]PLHU]DOQRŒFL]PLHQQ\FK]RVWDâ\ VSHâQLRQH1RUPDOQRŒýUR]NâDGX]PLHQQ\FKVSUDZG]RQRWZRU]ĉF VNDWHJRU\]RZDQHZ\NUHV\QRUPDOQRŒFLGODNDŮGHM]PDUHNSR-MD]GXLSU]HGVWDZLRQRMHQDU\V:WHŒFLH:6KDSLUR²:LOND SR]LRPLVWRWQRŒFLZHZV]\VWNLFKSU]\SDGNDFKMHVWZLĘNV]\RG ]DâRŮRQHJRS!Ơ =DWHPQLHPDSRGVWDZGRRGU]XFHQLD KLSRWH]\]HURZHMRMHGQRURGQRŒFLZDULDQFML 'UXJLPVSUDZG]RQ\P]DâRŮHQLHPE\âSRVWXODWRMHGQRURGQRŒFL ZDULDQFML7DELSU]HGVWDZLDZDUWRŒýSUDZGRSRGRELHĽVWZ GRW\F]ĉF\FKW\FKWHVWyZGODHIHNWXNODV\ÀNXMĉFHJRÅPDUNDSRMD]-GXµ$QDOL]XMĉFRWU]\PDQHGDQHPRŮQD]DXZDŮ\ýLŮZWHVWDFK QRUPDOQRŒFLQLHPDSRGVWDZGRRGU]XFHQLDKLSRWH]\]HURZHM 0RŮQD]DWHPVWZLHUG]LýŮH]DâRŮHQLDMHGQRURGQRŒFLZDULDQFMLVĉ VSHâQLRQHZHZV]\VWNLFKDQDOL]RZDQ\FKSU]\SDGNDFK 3U]HSURZDG]RQRMHGQRF]\QQLNRZĉDQDOL]ĘZDULDQFMLEDGDMĉF ZSâ\ZF]\QQLNDÅPDUNDSRMD]GXµQDZ\QLNJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHM SRMD]GyZZRNUHVDFKF]DVXXŮ\WNRZDQLDRJUDQLF]RQHMLSHâQHM SU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM=WDEZ\QLNDŮHSR]LRPLVWRWQR- ŒFLSGODPDUNLSRMD]GXZREXDQDOL]RZDQ\FKRNUHVDFKHNVSOR-DWDFMLZ\QRVLS =DWHP]JRGQLH]]DâRŮHQLDPLPHWRG\ VXJHUXMHWRRGU]XFHQLHKLSRWH]\]HURZHMRUyZQRŒFLŒUHGQLFKQD NRU]\ŒýKLSRWH]\DOWHUQDW\ZQHMŒZLDGF]ĉFHMRLVWRWQHMUyŮQLF\JR-WRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMREXPDUHNDXWREXVyZ:\QLNLWHSRWZLHUG]D UyZQLHŮZ\NUHVLQWHUDNFMLU\V :NROHMQ\PHWDSLHSUDF\SU]HSURZDG]RQRDQDOL]ĘZDULDQFMLGOD F]\QQLNDÅRNUHVHNVSORDWDFMLµXZ]JOĘGQLDMĉFRNUHVRJUDQLF]RQHM SU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM23(LRNUHVSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFL HNVSORDWDF\MQHM33(=PLHQQĉ]DOHŮQĉE\âDWXJRWRZRŒýWHFK-QLF]QDGODDQDOL]RZDQ\FKPDUHNDXWREXVyZ 5\V:\NUHVLQWHUDNFMLJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMGODF]\QQLNDÅPDUNDSRMD]GXµZRNUHVLHDSHâQHMERJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM DXWREXVyZ'L, ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH 7DE:\QLNLWHVWX/HYHQH·D]PLHQQHM]DOHŮQHM²JRWRZRŒýWHFK-QLF]QDGODF]\QQLNDÅPDUNDSRMD]GXµZRNUHVLHSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFL HNVSORDWDF\MQHM33(RUD]RJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM 23(

2NUHV HNVSORDWDFML =PLHQQD (IHNW

7HVW/HYHQH·DMHGQRURGQRğFLZDULDQFML =D]QDF]RQHHIHNW\VĆLVWRWQH]S

06

(IHNW 06%âĆG F S

PPE _JRWRZRĞü techniczna pojazdu marka

0,002 0,001 2,268 0,137 OPE 0,000 0,001 0,008 0,929 ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH 5\V6NDWHJRU\]RZDQHZ\NUHV\QRUPDOQRŒFL]PLHQQHM]DOHŮQHM²JRWRZRŒýWHFK- QLF]QDGODF]\QQLNDÅPDUNDSRMD]GXµZRNUHVLHSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\M-QHMRUD]RJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH 7DE:\QLNLWHVWX+DUWOH\D%DUWOHWWDL&RFKUDQD]PLHQQHM]DOHŮQHM ²JRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDGODF]\QQLNDÅPDUNDSRMD]GXµZRNUHVLHSHâ-QHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM33(RUD]RJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFL HNVSORDWDF\MQHM23(

2NUHV HNVSORDWDFML =PLHQQD (IHNW

7HVW\MHGQRURGQRğFLZDULDQFML

+DUWOH\D &RFKUDQD %DUWOHWWD df S

PPE _JRWRZRĞü techniczna pojazdu marka

1,611 0,617 1,874 1 0,171

OPE 1,032 0,508 0,008 1 0,930

ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH

HNVSORDWDFMDLWHVW\

6SUDZG]RQRŮHSLHUZV]H]DâRŮHQLDDQDOL]\ZDULDQFML]RVWDâ\ VSHâQLRQHFRR]QDF]DŮH]PLHQQHVĉPLHU]DOQHLQLH]DOHŮQH :\QLNLWHVWXQRUPDOQRŒFLSRWZLHUG]RQR]JRGQLH]U\V:DUWR- ŒFLSUDZGRSRGRELHĽVWZGRW\F]ĉFH]DâRŮHQLDMHGQRURGQRŒFLZD-ULDQFMLGODHIHNWXNODV\ÀNXMĉFHJRÅRNUHVHNVSORDWDFMLµSRGDQR ZWDEL$QDOL]XMĉFRWU]\PDQHGDQHPRŮQD]DXZDŮ\ýLŮGOD ZV]\VWNLFKWHVWyZQRUPDOQRŒFLQLHPDSRGVWDZGRRGU]XFHQLD KLSRWH]\]HURZHMS!=DâRŮHQLHMHGQRURGQRŒFLZDULDQFML ]RVWDâR]DWHPVSHâQLRQH 3U]HSURZDG]RQRMHGQRF]\QQLNRZĉDQDOL]ĘZDULDQFMLEDGDMĉF ZSâ\ZF]\QQLNDÅRNUHVHNVSORDWDFMLµQDZ\QLNJRWRZRŒFLWHFK- QLF]QHMSRMD]GyZPDUNL'RUD],=WDEZ\QLNDŮHSR]LRPLVWRW-QRŒFLSGODPDUNL'RUD]PDUNL,MHVWPQLHMV]\RG]DâRŮRQHJR 5\V:\NUHVLQWHUDNFMLJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMGODF]\QQLNDÅRNUHVHNVSORDWDFMLµ²SHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM33(LRJUDQLF]RQHM SU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM23(DXWREXVyZPDUNLD'E, ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH E a) 7DE:\QLNLREOLF]HĽMHGQRF]\QQLNRZHMDQDOL]\ZDULDQFML]PLHQQHM]DOHŮQHM² JRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDGODF]\QQLNDÅPDUNDSRMD]GXµZRNUHVLHSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFL HNVSORDWDF\MQHM33(RUD]RJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM23(

2NUHV HNVSORDWDFML (IHNW

-HGQRZ\PLDURZHWHVW\LVWRWQRğFL GOD]PLHQQHM]DOHīQHMJRWRZRğýWHFKQLF]QD 3DUDPHWU\]DFMD]VLJPDRJUDQLF]HQLDPL 'HNRPSR]\FMDHIHNW\ZQ\FKKLSRWH] 66 _VZRERG\6WRSQLH 06 F S PPE wyraz wolny 58,32 1 58,32 26956,3 0,000 marka pojazdu 0,027 1 0,027 12,38 0,001 EáąG 0,147 68 0,002 OPE wyraz wolny 50,09 1 50,09 28571,9 0,000 marka pojazdu 0,049 1 0,049 28,18 0,000 EáąG 0,112 64 0,002 ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH 7DE:\QLNLWHVWX/HYHQH·D]PLHQQHM]DOHŮQHM²JRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDGOD F]\QQLNDÅRNUHVHNVSORDWDFMLµRJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM23( LSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM33( 0DUND  SRMD]GX =PLHQQD (IHNW 7HVW/HYHQH·DMHGQRURGQRğFLZDULDQFML =D]QDF]RQHHIHNW\VĆLVWRWQH]S 06 (IHNW 06%âĆG F S D _JRWRZRĞü

techniczna i PPEOPE

0,000 0,001 0,058 0,811 I 0,000 0,002 0,008 0,929 ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH 7DE:\QLNLWHVWX+DUWOH\D%DUWOHWWDL&RFKUDQD]PLHQQHM]DOHŮQHM²JRWRZRŒý WHFKQLF]QDGODF]\QQLNDÅRNUHVHNVSORDWDFMLµRJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSOR-DWDF\MQHM23(LSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM33( 0DUND  SRMD]GX =PLHQQD (IHNW 7HVW\MHGQRURGQRğFLZDULDQFML

+DUWOH\D &RFKUDQD %DUWOHWWD df S

D _JRWRZRĞü

techniczna pojazdu marka

1,319 0,569 0,662 1 0,416 I 1,034 0,508 0,009 1 0,921 ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH 7DE:\QLNLREOLF]HĽMHGQRF]\QQLNRZHMDQDOL]\ZDULDQFML]PLHQQHM]DOHŮQHM² JRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDGODF]\QQLNDÅRNUHVHNVSORDWDFMLµRJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFL HNVSORDWDF\MQHM23(LSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM33( 0DUNDSRMD]GX (IHNW -HGQRZ\PLDURZHWHVW\LVWRWQRğFLGOD]PLHQQHM]DOHīQHM JRWRZRğýWHFKQLF]QD 3DUDPHWU\]DFMD]VLJPDRJUDQLF]HQLDPL 'HNRPSR]\FMDHIHNW\ZQ\FKKLSRWH] 66 _VZRERG\6WRSQLH 06 F S D wyraz wolny 54,52 1 54,52 17793,30 0,000 OPE i PPE 0,039 1 0,039 12,86 0,001 EáąG 0,215 70 0,003 I wyraz wolny 59,38 1 59,38 17622,55 0,000 OPE i PPE 0,016 1 0,016 4,74 0,033 EáąG 0,236 70 0,003 ūUyGâRRSUDFZâDVQH

HNVSORDWDFMDLWHVW\

RGSRZLHGQLRS RUD]S =DWHPQDOHŮ\RGU]XFLý KLSRWH]Ę]HURZĉRUyZQRŒFLŒUHGQLFK2]QDF]DWRLVWRWQĉUyŮQL-FĘZJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMSRPLĘG]\DQDOL]RZDQ\PLRNUHVDPL HNVSORDWDFMLGODDXWREXVyZPDUNL'RUD],:\QLNLWHVWyZDQDOL]\ ZDULDQFMLSRWZLHUG]DMĉUyZQLHŮZ\NUHV\LQWHUDNFMLU\V

3RGVXPRZDQLH

2SLHUDMĉFVLĘQDZ\QLNDFKSU]HSURZDG]RQ\FKEDGDĽGRŒZLDG- F]DOQ\FKJRWRZRŒFLWHFKQLF]QHMDXWREXVyZVIRUPXâRZDQRQDVWĘ-SXMĉFHZQLRVNL ¡ EDGDMĉFZSâ\ZF]\QQLNDÅRNUHVHNVSORDWDFMLµVWZLHUG]RQRŮH ]DUyZQRZSU]\SDGNXDXWREXVyZPDUNL'MDNLDXWREXVyZ PDUNL,JRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDSRPLĘG]\RNUHVDPLRJUDQLF]RQHM LSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMUyŮQLâDVLĘLVWRWQLH ¡ ZRNUHVLHSHâQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMŒUHGQLDJRWR-ZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDDXWREXVyZ'Z\QLRVâD.JŒU

DDX-WREXVyZ,.JŒU :]JOĘGQDUyŮQLFDŒUHGQLFKZ\QLRVâD

:RNUHVLHRJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDWQRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHM ŒUHGQLDJRWRZRŒýWHFKQLF]QDDXWREXVyZ'Z\QLRVâD.JŒU  DDXWREXVyZ,.JŒU :]JOĘGQDUyŮQLFDŒUHGQLFK

Z\QLRVâD ¡ ]DSUH]HQWRZDQDZDUW\NXOHPHWRGDDQDOL]\JRWRZRŒFLWHFK- QLF]QHM]Z\UyŮQLHQLHPRNUHVXSHâQHMLRJUDQLF]RQHMSU]\GDW-QRŒFLHNVSORDWDF\MQHMPRŮHE\ýZ\NRU]\VWDQDGRZ\]QDF]HQLD UDFMRQDOQHMJUDQLF\XŮ\WNRZDQLDSRMD]GX]HZ]JOĘGXQDNU\-WHULXPQLH]DZRGQRŒFL0DWHŮ]QDF]HQLHSU]\Z\ERU]HPDUNL SRMD]GXZSU]\SDGNXUR]EXGRZ\OXERGQRZ\ÁRW\

%LEOLRJUDÀD

 Apeland S., Aven T., Nilsen T., 4XDQWLI\LQJXQFHUWDLQW\XQGHU

DSUHGLFWLYHHSLVWHPLFDSSURDFKWRULVNDQDO\VLV, „Reliability (QJLQHHULQJ 6\VWHP6DIHW\µ9RO  '\U70LVLXUVNL33URJQR]RZDQLHNRV]WyZXWU]\PDQLDLHNV- SORDWDFMLWDERUXDXWREXVRZHJRÅ3UREOHP\7UDQVSRUWXL/RJL-VW\NLµQU  '\U75DPD36WUDWHJLDRGQRZ\WDERUX0=.Z7RUXQLX, Å$XWREXV\²7HFKQLND(NVSORDWDFMD6\VWHP\7UDQVSRUWRZHµ QU  *XLKDLUH9+DR-.+7UDQVLWQHWZRUNGHVLJQDQGVFKHGX-OLQJ$JOREDOUHYLHZÅ7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ5HVHDUFK3DUW$3ROLF\ DQG3UDFWLFHµ1R  .XEDOVNL-0DâHN30URF]HN..RPXQLNDFMDDXWREXVRZD HNRQRPLNDLHNVSORDWDFMD:\GDZQLFWZD.RPXQLNDFMLLáĉF]-QRŒFL:DUV]DZD  /HJXWNR63RGVWDZ\HNVSORDWDFMLPDV]\QLXU]ĉG]HĽ, Wy-GDZQLFWZR6]NROQHL3HGDJRJLF]QH:DUV]DZD  0LVLXUVNL3.RV]W\HNVSORDWDFMLWDERUXDXWREXVRZHJR ZSU]HGVLĘELRUVWZDFKNRPXQLNDFMLVDPRFKRGRZHM, „Autobusy ²7HFKQLND(NVSORDWDFMD6\VWHP\7UDQVSRUWRZHµQU  0LVUD.%+DQGERRNRI5HOLDELOLW\(QJLQHHULQJ, Springer 9HUODJ/RQGRQ  1LHZF]DV$5\PDU]-'ĘELFND(6WDJHVRIRSHUDWLQJYH-KLFOHVZLWKUHVSHFWWRRSHUDWLRQDOHIÀFLHQF\XVLQJFLW\EXVHV DVDQH[DPSOHÅ(NVSORDWDFMDL1LH]DZRGQRŒý²0DLQWDLQDQ-FHDQG5HOLDELOLW\µ9RO1R 3KDP++DQGERRNRI5HOLDELOLW\(QJLQHHULQJ6SULQJHU9HU-ODJ/RQGRQ 3LDVHFNL6=DJDGQLHQLDXŮ\WNRZDQLDPDV]\QLŒURGNyZWUDQV-SRUWRZ\FK/XEHOVNLH7RZDU]\VWZR1DXNRZH/XEOLQ 5\PDU]-1LHZF]DV$.U]\ŮDN$&RPSDULVRQRIRSHUDWLR-QDODYDLODELOLW\RISXEOLFFLW\EXVHVE\DQDO\VLVRIYDULDQFH, Å(NVSORDWDFMDL1LH]DZRGQRŒý²0DLQWDLQDQFHDQG5HOLDELOL-W\µ9RO1R 5\PDU]-6WRNâRVD-1LHZF]DV$:\EUDQHSUREOHP\HIHN- W\ZQRŒFLIXQNFMRQRZDQLDSXEOLF]QHJRWUDQVSRUWX]ELRURZH-JRÅ/RJLVW\NDµQU 6WDSHOEHUJ5)+DQGERRNRIUHOLDELOLW\DYDLODELOLW\PDLQWD-LQDELOLW\DQGVDIHW\LQHQJLQHHULQJGHVLJQ6SULQJHU9HUODJ /RQGRQ Szkoda M., $VVHVVPHQWRI5HOLDELOLW\$YDLODELOLW\DQG0D-LQWDLQDELOLW\RI5DLO*DXJH&KDQJH6\VWHPV, „Eksploatacja L1LH]DZRGQRŒý²0DLQWDLQDQFHDQG5HOLDELOLW\µ9RO 1R :RURSD\06]XEDUWRZVNL00LJDZD.0RGHORFHQ\ LNV]WDâWRZDQLDJRWRZRŒFLRSHUDF\MQHMSRGV\VWHPXZ\NR-QDZF]HJRZV\VWHPLHWUDQVSRUWRZ\P, Wydawnictwo Instytutu

7HFKQRORJLL(NVSORDWDFML5DGRP

Zio E.,

5HOLDELOLW\HQJLQHHULQJ2OGSUREOHPVDQGQHZFKDO-OHQJHVÅ5HOLDELOLW\(QJLQHHULQJ 6\VWHP6DIHW\µ9RO 1R $QDO\VLVRIRSHUDWLRQDODYDLODELOLW\ RISXEOLFFLW\EXVHVLQVHOHFWHGSHULRGVRIXVH 7KHDLPRIWKHDUWLFOHLVWRFRPSDUHWKHRSHUDWLRQDODYDLODELOLW\RIWKH FLW\EXVHV7ZRSRSXODUPDNHVRIEXVHVZHUHDQDO\VHGLQWKHIXQF-WLRQRIWLPHRIXVHGXULQJWKHVL[\HDUVRIRSHUDWLRQLQWKH0XQLFLSDO 7UDQVSRUW&RPSDQ\03.LQ/XEOLQ$QHZGLYLVLRQRIRSHUDWLQJWLPH IRUWKHSHULRGRIIXOORSHUDWLRQDOXVHIXOQHVVDQGSHULRGRIOLPLWHGRS-HUDWLRQDOXVHIXOQHVVRIYHKLFOHVZDVSUHVHQWHG ,WZDVVKRZQWKDWWKHDYHUDJHRSHUDWLRQDODYDLODELOLW\RIWKHDQDO\VHG EXVHVGLIIHUHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\GXHWRWKHYHKLFOH·VPDNHDQGDOVRGXHWR WKHVHUYLFHOLIH7KH$129$DQDO\VLVPHWKRGZDVXVHGWRDVVHVVWKH VLJQLÀFDQFHRIGLIIHUHQFHV

.HZRUGVoperational availability, public city buses, period of full operational usefulness, period of limited operational usefulness.

$XWRU]\

GULQŮ-RDQQD5\PDU]²,QVW\WXW7UDQVSRUWX6LOQLNyZ6SDOLQRZ\FK L(NRORJLL3ROLWHFKQLND/XEHOVND SURIGUKDELQŮ$QGU]HM1LHZF]DV²,QVW\WXW7UDQVSRUWX Samochodowego dr (ZD'ĘELFND²,QVW\WXW7UDQVSRUWX6DPRFKRGRZHJR Andrzej Krzyszkowski :\]QDF]DQLHF\NOL SU]HJOĉGRZRQDSUDZF]\FK GODRELHNWyZQHOHPHQWRZ\FKZWUDQVSRUFLH ,6%1 /LF]EDVWURQ )RUPDW% 2SUDZDWZDUGD 5RNZ\GDQLD &HQD]âZW\P9$7

3HâQDRIHUWDZ\GDZQLF]D





ZZZLQZVSDWLXPSO

$QGU]HM.U]\V]NRZVNL :\]QDF]DQLHF\NOL SU]HJOąGRZRQDSUDZF]\FK GODRELHNWyZQHOHPHQWRZ\FK ZWUDQVSRUFLH