Charakterystyka sprawców zabójstw lub poważnego uszkodzenia ciała. Na podstawie obserwacji sądowo-psychiatrycznych osób dokonujących przestępstwa w stanie upojenia alkoholowego zwykłego

(1)

228

! "

Charakterystyka sprawców zabójstw lub poważnego uszkodzenia ciała.

Na podstawie obserwacji sądowo-psychiatrycznych osób dokonujących

przestępstwa w stanie upojenia alkoholowego zwykłego

Characteristics of ethanol intoxicated homicide offenders or perpetrators of severe body injury

based on forensic psychiatry observation

D > * +$29,*CCA*ADC*DSA8*$@FG42,*GB%4$#I+2$'9&2 @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @

ORIGINAL CONTRIBUTIONS

(2)

229

@ @ @ G+#.*"&4'4"'%*4%%/$(*B.*+;"*$T&$#+*&%.)14G+#4%+%9*\))"#(4'3*+"*+1$*)"22$)+$(*FG+$#4G2%8*4+*;G%*$%+GB24%1$(*+1G+*F"%+* B$1GJ4"/#%*4'*+1$*&G%+9

0

@ F424"'G*"%PBNDO _@ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ N>@QO₉ @ @ N=O₉ @ @ @ @

**#$%&'()*%#'$**

\

G*F4224"'*&$"&2$*(4$*(/$*+"*4'+$#&$#%"'G2*J4"@ 2$')$NDO _@ @ +G2*)"'(4+4"'9*0/#%/G'+*+"*+1$*)/##$'+*<'";2$(3$8*$+1G'"2* @ 2$G(%*+"*GF'$%4G9* @ +#G+4"'8*GB%+#G)+*+14'<4'38*G'(*;"#<4'3*F$F"#.9*-+*)G/%$%* &%.)1"F"+"#*G34+G+4"'8*4')#$G%$(*G)+4J4+.8*"#*$J$'*G)+4J$* @ @ G'(*)4#)/2G+4"'*N>@QO₉ @ N=O₉ @ %4"'8*$939*1"F4)4($%8*G++$F&+$(*1"F4)4($%8*J4"2$')$*"#*G#@ %"'%8*G#$*G%%")4G+$(*;4+1*$/&1"#4)*&1G%$*G'(*$T)4+G+4J$* @ )$'+#G+4"'*4'*B2""(*B$+;$$'*?9D*G'(*?9R*&$#*)$'+9*M1$%$* &1G%$%*G#$*)1G#G)+$#4H$(*B.*G'*4')#$G%$(*&%.)1"F"@ +"#*(#4J$*;4+1*4'%+4')+4J$*B$1GJ4"/#%8*$/&1"#4G8*4')#$G%$(* @ /G+4"'9*M1$.*&#")$$(*;4+1*)2$G#*&%.)1"F"+"#*G'(*&%.@ )1"%$'%"#.*(4%"#($#%9*\+*G2)"1"2*2$J$2*4'*B2""(*GB"J$* ?9>*&$#*)$'+8*+1$*1431$#*$F"+4"'G24+.*G'(*)#4+4)4%F*(4%G&@ @ N=O₉

(3)

230

>*&#"F424 @ N=O₉ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ NC@EO @ @ ND?8DDO₉ @ @ @ &#"</#G+"#GNA8EO @ @ @ @ @ @ NAO₉ @ @ @ @ @ @ )H.F*&#";G(H"'.F*&#H$H*&#"</#G+"#G*"*)H.'*&#H$)4;<"* @ #$'%4)*&%.)14G+#.*"&4'4"'*+"*$T)2/($*+1$*)4#)/F%+G')$%*#$@ %/2+4'3*4'*+1$*&$#&$+#G+"#K%*24F4+$(*)#4F4'G2*G))"/'+GB424+.9 @ @ NC@EO @ #$'%4)*&%.)14G+#.*"B%$#JG+4"'*%1"/2(*B$*$T&$#+*&%.)14G@ ND?8DDO₉ @ G+#4)*$TGF4'G+4"'*FG.*B$*G2%"*)"FB4'$(*;4+1*G'*"B%$#@ JG+4"'*4'*+1$*&%.)14G+#.*/'4+9*7/)1*G*($)4%4"'*4%*+G<$'*B.* 4'*+1$*&/B24)*&#"%$)/+"#K%*4'J$%+43G+4"'*+1$*)"/#+*($)4($%* G+*+1$*&/B24)*&#"%$)/+"#K%*#$V/$%+NA8EO_{9*0/#%/G'+*+"*+1$*} @ @ @ )"'%4%+%*4'*)"22$)+4'3*+1$*$J4($')$*&"4'+4'3*+"*G*1431*&#"B@ @ %/2+%*4'*G*BG'*"'*"B%$#JG+4"'*;1$'*+1$*)G%$*)4#)/F%+G')@ $%*G22";*+"*$T&$)+*+1G+*+1$*)"/#+*;422*%$'+$')$*+1$*G))/%$(* ;4+1*4F&#4%"'F$'+*;4+1*G*)"'(4+4"'G2*%/%&$'%4"'8*F42(@ $#8*"#*;1$'*+1$*$T&$)+$(*%$'+$')$*;422*B$*%1"#+$#*+1G'*+1$* @ #$'%4)*&%.)14G+#.*"B%$#JG+4"'*#$V/4#$%*+1$*G))/%$(*&$#@ %"'K%*)"'%$'+NAO₉ M1$*%+/(.*4%*G4F$(*G+*+1$*($%)#4&+4"'8*4'*($F"3#G&14)*#$@ @ %/)1*V/G'+4+G+4J$*G'(*V/G24+G+4J$*JG#4GB2$%*G%,*G3$8*3$'@ ($#8*FG#4+G2*%+G+/%8*F424+G#.*%$#J4)$*G++4+/($8*)#4F4'G2*#$@ )"#(%8*G33#$%%4J$*B$1GJ4"/#%9*L$%4($%8*G'*G++$F&+*;G%* @ (4)+4"'*&#")$%%9 G'(*>?*;"F$'O*4'*+1$*&/B24)*&#"%$)/+"#K%*4'J$%+43G+4"'* @ %/G'+*+"*+1$*&$'G2*)"($*G%, Y*1"F4)4($*NG#+9*DQA Y*1"F4)4($*;4+1*&G#+4)/2G#*)#/$2+.*NG#+9*DQA @ 'G2*)"($OW

(4)

231

Y* Y* Y* Y* @ Y* Y* @ @ <"1"2/*;*;.(.)1G'.F*&";4$+#H/*NBG(G'4$*G2<"FG+$F* @ @ @ @ @ @ @ +#"%&$<+.;'.9 @ @ @ @ @ %";G'"*F$+"(.*"&4%";$*"#GH*F$+"(.*;'4"%<";G'4G*%+G+.@ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ Y* @ Y* Y* Y* @ )"1"2*2$J$2*4'*$T1G2$(*G4#*NB#$G+1G2.%$#*+$%+%*FG($*B.*&"@ @ F"'4$%*"#*%/%&$)+%K*%+G+$F$'+%9 @ #$'%4)*&%.)14G+#.*"B%$#JG+4"'*G+*+1$*Z"#$'%4)*0%.)14G+#.* @ +1"%$*;1"*$T14B4+$(*&%.)1"+4)*(4%"#($#%8*G'(*+1"%$*;1"* F$+*+1$*&G+1"2"34)G2*4'+"T4)G+4"'*)#4+$#4G*ND*&$#%"'O8*G%* ;$22*G%*G22*+1$*%/%&$)+%*;1"*&$#&$+#G+$(*G*&/'4%1GB2$*G)+* @ +4)2$%O9*-+*;G%*G*#$+#"%&$)+4J$*%+/(.9 M1$*(G+G*&#$%$'+$(*4'*+1$*%+/(.*G#$*BG%$(*"'*+1$*FG+$#4@ @ @ .%$(*;G%*+1$*F$(4)G2*(")/F$'+G+4"'*)"22$)+$(*(/#4'3*+1$* @ @ M1$*G/+1"#K%*V/$%+4"''G4#$*;G%*/%$(*+"*&#$&G#$*G'(*)"2@ 2$)+*+1$*(G+G*)"'+G4'$(*4'*+1$*(")/F$'+G+4"'9 FG+$#4G29*M"*($%)#4B$*+1$*$TGF4'$(*3#"/&8*%+#/)+/#$*4'@ @ @ JG2/$*4'*#$2G+4"'*+"*+1$*F$G'*JG2/$9 M1$*#$%/2+%*;$#$*G'G2.%$(*/%4'3*%+G+4%+4)G2*&G)<G3$%*7077* @

(5)

232

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

(6)

233

@ @ @ "#GH*B$'H"(4GH$&4'*N+GB$2G*>O9 @ @ @ @ %+G;4$*G<+*%&#G;.*"#GH*;.;4G(/*H$B#G'$3"*&#H$H*&%.)14G@ @ @ @ B.*+1$*&%.)14G+#4%+*4'(4)G+$*+1G+*+1$*%/%&$)+%*1G(*'"+* @ Zmienna

Variable PoziomLevel LiczebnośćSize FrakcjaFraction

ZUA

AD TakYes 65 0,72

Nie

No 25 0,28

Rodzaj spożywanego alkoholu

Type of consumed alcohol Non-consumption alcoholsAlkohole niespożywcze 10 0,11 Piwo Beer 18 0,20 Wódka Vodka 58 0,65 Wino Wine 4 0,04

Pobyty w izbie wytrzeźwień

Detentions in sobering centres TakYes 26 0,30 Nie

No 64 0,70

Leczenie odwykowe

Detoxification TakYes 32 0,36

Nie

No 58 0,64

Występowanie DT

Occurrence of DT TakYes 25 0,28

Nie

No 65 0,72

Padaczka

Epilepsy TakYes 19 0,21

Nie

No 71 0,79

Uzależnienie od substancji psychoaktywnych

Dependence on psychoactive substances TakYes 19 0,21 Nie

No 71 0,79

DT – delirium tremens, majaczenie drżenne; ZUA – zespół uzależnienia od alkoholu. DT – delirium tremens; AD – alcohol dependence.

(7)

234

@ @

',-.#/$#/

@ @ @ @ ND>8DRO₉ @ NDR@D=O_{8*(4G3'"H";G@} @ ND=8DCO₉ @ @ NDSO _@ NDCO₉ @ @ ND=O₉ @ * M1$*GJG42GB2$*(G+G*BG%$*("$%*'"+*)"'+G4'*G'.*#$&"#+%* @ ;$#$*4F&#4%"'$(ND>8DRO₉ @ (4%%")4G+$(*&$#%"'G24+.NDR@D=O_{*(4G3'"%$(*GF"'3*+1$*&"&/@}

@ ND=8DCO₉ @ @ +;$$'*G33#$%%4J$*G)+%*G'(*+1$*&$#&$+#G+"#%K*."/'3*G3$8* FG2$*3$'($#8*2";*%")4"$)"'"F4)*%+G+/%8*G'(*2";*$(/)G@ +4"'G2*2$J$2NDSO &%.)1"G)+4J$*%/B%+G')$%NDCO₉ +1$*F424+G#.*%$#J4)$9*\%*)"F&G#$(*+"*+1$*"+1$#*4'J$%+43G+$(* 3#"/&%8*+1$*G2)"1"2*G((4)+%*%$2("F*1G(*+1$4#*";'*)142(#$'ND=O₉ M1$* %+/(4$%* )G##4$(* "/+* (/#4'3* DEE>@DEE=* G'G2.%$(* @ @ @ @ @ @ NDCO₉ Zmienna

Variable N* Mean valueŚrednia MedianaMedian MinimumMinimum MaksimumMaximum SD

Czas trwania ZUA [lata]

Duration of AD [years] 66 10,38 8 2 36 7,75

Długość trwania ciągów [tygodnie]

Duration of bouts [weeks] 66 10,52 3 0 126 22,34

Zawartość alkoholu [mg/dl]

Alcohol content [mg/dl] 58 1,06 1,04 0,31 1,81 0,32

N – liczebność; * – różnice w liczebnościach wynikają z braku danych; SD – odchylenie standardowe. N – size; * – differences in sizes result from the lack of data; SD – standard deviation.

(8)

235

@ @ @ @ NDCO₉ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ NDO₉ @ HG+#/('4$'4G8*#"H;4$(H$'4*2/B*;*%+G'4$*;"2'.F8*<+P#H.*'4$* @ @ @ @ @ @ @ G'(*+1"%$*;4+1*G)/+$*&%.)1"%4%*%.F&+"F%*;$#$*$T)2/($(* @ @ @ @ G'(*($&$'($')$*"'*G2)"1"2*"#*&%.)1"G)+4J$*%/B%+G')@ @ +"*+1$*&$#&$+#G+"#9 #"BB$#4$%NDO₉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

(9)

236

@ @ @ @ G*)G%$@)#"%%"J$#*%+/(.9*\((4)+4"'*>??CW*D?D,*D??@D?A9 @ @ @ L$1GJ9*>??RW*>E,*R?>@RD=9 @ @ @ @ @ &%.)14G+#.8*&%.)1"2"3G*"#GH*%$<%/"2"3G*;*%&#G;G)1*<G#'.)19* @ @ )#4F4'G2%*;4+1*"#3G'4)*B#G4'*%.'(#"F$,*+;"*(4%+4')+*+.&$%*BG%$(* U"F4)4($8*&%.)1"&G+1.8*G'(*G34'3*[*G*'G+4"';4($*#$34%+$#@ @ @ @ @ @ * * *[*4'($<%";G'$3"*;*-'($T*!"&$#'4)/%** *