Instantaneous Flow Reconstruction from Particle Trajectories with Vortex-in-Cell

Pełen tekst

(1)Delft University of Technology. Instantaneous Flow Reconstruction from Particle Trajectories with Vortex-in-Cell Schneiders, Jan; Singh, P.; Scarano, Fulvio. Publication date 2016 Document Version Final published version Published in Proceedings of the 18th International Symposium on the Application of Laser and Imaging Techniques to Fluid Mechanics. Citation (APA) Schneiders, J., Singh, P., & Scarano, F. (2016). Instantaneous Flow Reconstruction from Particle Trajectories with Vortex-in-Cell. In Proceedings of the 18th International Symposium on the Application of Laser and Imaging Techniques to Fluid Mechanics Springer. Important note To cite this publication, please use the final published version (if applicable). Please check the document version above.. Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons. Takedown policy Please contact us and provide details if you believe this document breaches copyrights. We will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.. This work is downloaded from Delft University of Technology. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to a maximum of 10..

(2) PROCEEDINGS OF THE. 18th INTERNATIONAL. SYMPOSIUM ON APPLICATION OF LASER AND IMAGING. TECHNIQUES TO FLUID MECHANICS.

(3)

(4) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – .

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8) #.$).&*%&23*753)*.()5,6*/$#2#./. &04/'&2/30#$&.(*.&&2*.( &,'4&,'4)&&4)&2,#.%3 /22&30/.%&.4#54)/2 $).&*%&2345%&,'4., #4#33*-*,#4*/.!#24*$,&2#$+*.(!&,/$*-&427&.3&.4&20/,#4*/.. *74 <0=DB2A8?CB ?A4B4=CB C74 F>A:8=6 ?A8=28?;4 >5 0 =>E4; C427=8@D4 C> 8=C4A?>;0C4 B?0AB4 0=3 B20CC4A43 ?0AC82;4 CA02:8=6 E4;>28<4CAH '*, <40BDA4<4=CB >=C> 0 34=B4 6A83 1H DB8=6 C74 E4;>28CH <40BDA4<4=CB 0;>=6 0 5D;; ?0AC82;4CA0942C>AH *74<4C7>3?4A5>A<B8C4A0C8E4;H0E>AC4G8=24;;B8<D;0C8>=)27=4834AB4C0;

(9) 8=G?;D83B

(10) C> <8=8<8I4 C74 38554A4=24 14CF44= C74 B8<D;0C8>= 0=3 C74 B20CC4A43 E4;>28CH <40BDA4<4=CB *74 >?C8<8I0C8>=8BB>;E43DB8=6C74#)0;6>A8C7<F74A46A0384=CB0A44E0;D0C434558284=C;HDB8=6C74039>8=C>5C74 E>AC4G8=24;;2>34 =C74=D<4A820;0BB4BB<4=CC7420B4>50E>AC4G8B2>=B834A43 C068E4=B4438=62>=24=CA0C8>= C74A42>=BCAD2C8>=@D0;8CH>5E4;>28CHF0BB7>F=C>8<?A>E41H F74=05D;;CA02:8BDB438=2><?0A8B>=C>0 38E4A64=24 5A44 A42>=BCAD2C8>= DB8=6 >=;H 8=BC0=C0=4>DB E4;>28CH *74 =D<4A820; 0BB4BB<4=C 34<>=BCA0C4B C74 ?>C4=C80; >5 C74 <4C7>3 C> 8=2A40B4 <40BDA4<4=C @D0;8CH 0=3 B?0C80; A4B>;DC8>= 8= 2><?0A8B>= C> C427=8@D4B C70C 8=C4A?>;0C4E4;>28CHDB8=6>=;H8=BC0=C0=4>DB5;>F8=5>A<0C8>=0=35>A4G0<?;4C7438E4A64=245A442>=BCA08=C . $" %$ *74A424=C;H8=CA>3D243, C427=8@D4)27=4834AB4C0;

(11) 70B144=34<>=BCA0C43C>0;;>F 5>A022DA0C45;>FA42>=BCAD2C8>=5A><C8<4A4B>;E43C><>6A0?782'*,4G?4A8<4=CB0C05A02C8>= >5C74B4438=62>=24=CA0C8>=BA4@D8A435>AB8<8;0A022DA02HF8C7C><>6A0?782' ,1H;4E4A068=6 C74 E4;>28CH <0C4A80; 34A8E0C8E4 <40BDA43 1H 0 ?0AC82;4 CA02:8=6 0;6>A8C7< *78B F0B 20;;43 = ?0AC82D;0A )27=4834AB 4C 0;

(12) 34<>=BCA0C43 C78B DB8=6 C74 B8<8;0C434G?4A8<4=C0;>=605;0C?;0C4CDA1D;4=C1>D=30AH;0H4A DAC74A<>A4C74<4C7>370B 144= DC8;8I43 8= 0 2><?0A0C8E4 BCD3H 10B43 >= 0 B8<D;0C43 4G?4A8<4=C C70C 0BB4BB4B B4E4A0; <4C7>3BC>>1C08=?A4BBDA45A><' ,30C0 *74F>A:2>=3D2C43F8C78=C74DA>?40=% &'#. 2>=B>AC8D<;8=344C0;

(13) B7>F43C70CC74>?C8<8I0C8>=?A>3D243F8C7C74, 0;6>A8C7< H84;3B 0 E4AH 022DA0C4 A42>=BCAD2C8>= >5 C74 8=BC0=C0=4>DB ?A4BBDA4 584;3 F74= 2><?0A43 C> >C74A <4C7>3B 10B43 >= 2A>BB2>AA4;0C8>= 0=0;HB8B *74 BCD3H 1H )27=4834AB 4C 0;

(14) 0 2>=58A<43 8= C74 20B4 >5 0 A40;F>A;3 CDA1D;4=C 1>D=30AH ;0H4A 4G?4A8<4=C 0C

(15) ǉ

(16) C70C , 20=H84;3<>A4022DA0C44BC8<0C4B>5E>AC828CH<06=8CD340=3A<BE>AC828CH5;D2CD0C8>=B8= C741>D=30AH;0H4A .

(17)

(18) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – . . . )274<0C82 >5 0 '*, <40BDA4<4=C A4BD;C #06A0=680= ?0AC82;4 CA0942C>AH <40BDA4<4=CB 6A4H;8=4B0=3E4;>28CHE42C>ABDB435>A34=B4E4;>28CHA42>=BCAD2C8>=A43 *74CA024A?0AC82;4B DB43 5>A E4;>28CH A42>=BCAD2C8>= 0A4 2>;>A43 A43 C74 >C74AB 1;D4 #8=40A 8=C4A?>;0C8>= 0 DB4B 8=BC0=C0=4>DB E4;>28CH >=;H , 1 DB4B 0;B> C74 <0C4A80; 34A8E0C8E4 0=3 , 2 DB4B C74 5D;;?0AC82;4CA0942C>AH *74H4;;>F;8=4BA4?A4B4=CC74A42>=BCAD2C8>=6A83 *74 , <4C7>3 DB4B 0= 8C4A0C8E4 6A0384=C10B43 >?C8<8I0C8>= ?A>243DA4 C> 8=2>A?>A0C4 1>C7 8=BC0=C0=4>DB E4;>28CH 0=3 <0C4A80; 34A8E0C8E4 <40BDA4<4=CB 8=C> C74 8=BC0=C0=4>DB 5;>F A42>=BCAD2C8>= 86 1 *78B 8B 8= 2>=CA0BC C> C427=8@D4B C70C DB4 8=BC0=C0=4>DB E4;>28CH >=;H BD27 0B ;8=40A 8=C4A?>;0C8>= 86 0 *74 DB4 >5 BD27 8C4A0C8E4 A42>=BCAD2C8>= C427=8@D4B 70B A4248E43 8=2A40B43 0CC4=C8>= 8= ;8C4A0CDA4 >E4A C74 ?0BC 342034 4B?4280;;H 8= C74 584;3 >5 >?C820; 5;>F48CI4C0;

(19). 1DC0;B>5>A4G0<?;45>A0=8=E4BC860C8>=8=C741>CC><1>D=30AH;0H4A>5 C74 2>0BC0; >240= <40BDA43 1H BD1<4AB43 C><>6A0?782 '*, ,;0B4=:> 4C 0;

(20) >A ' , <40BDA4<4=CBA>=B:8B4C0;

(21) 0=3/460E80=4C0;

(22) DB40=8C4A0C8E430C00BB8<8;0C8>= ?A>243DA4 B>;E8=6 C74 8=2><?A4BB81;4 %0E84A)C>:4B 4@D0C8>=B C> >1C08= A4B?42C8E4;H 022DA0C4 8=5;>F2>=38C8>=B5>A;0C4A%)B8<8;0C8>=B0=3C>8=2A40B4A4B>;DC8>=>5C74' ,<40BDA4<4=CB )8<8;0A;H#4<:40=3)4BC4A74==

(23) ?A>?>B430=8C4A0C8E430C00BB8<8;0C8>=5A0<4F>A:DB8=6 C74 2><?A4BB81;4 %0E84A)C>:4B 4@D0C8>=B 5>A ?A4BBDA4 4E0;D0C8>= 5A>< ' , <40BDA4<4=CB = E84F >5 2><?8C0C8>=0; 2>BC 0;; C74B4 <4C7>3B DB4 0= 039>8=C 2>34 C> 4E0;D0C4 4558284=C;H C74 6A0384=CB A4@D8A43 5>A C74 6A0384=C10B43 >?C8<8I0C8>= >F4E4A BC8;; 0??;820C8>= >5 C74B4 C427=8@D4BC>A40;E>;D<4CA82E4;>28CH<40BDA4<4=C30C070BB>50A7>F4E4A144=;8<8C433D4C> 2><?4C0C8>=0; 2>BCB 0BB>280C43 F8C7 B>;E8=6 C74 %0E84A)C>:4B 4@D0C8>=B 8C4A0C8E4;H >= C74 2><?DC0C8>=0;6A83 *74 8C4A0C8E4 >?C8<8I0C8>= 5A0<4F>A:B 0;;>F 5>A 8=2;DB8>= >5 <>A4 <40BDA4<4=C 30C0 C70= 8= C74 20B4 >5 , >=;H E4;>28CH 0=3 8CB <0C4A80; 34A8E0C8E4 (424=C 03E0=243 8= C74 584;3 >5 #06A0=680=?0AC82;4CA02:8=60;6>A8C7<B–8=?0AC82D;0A)70:4C74>G)270=I4C0;

(24) –70E4 0;;>F435>A<40BDA4<4=C>5;>=6?0AC82;4CA0942C>A84BB?0==8=6>E4A B=0?B7>CB8=34=B4;H B44343 5;>FB 2><?0A01;4 C> C><>6A0?782 ' , *78B ?A>E834B 022DA0C4 0=3 B20CC4A43 <40BDA4<4=CB>5E4;>28CH>E4AC8<48=0<40BDA4<4=CE>;D<4 *74, <4C7>334<>=BCA0C43 8=2A40B43 A42>=BCAD2C8>= 022DA02H F74= E4;>28CH 0=3 8CB 8=BC0=C0=4>DB <0C4A80; 34A8E0C8E4 0A4.

(25)

(26) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – . DB435>AA42>=BCAD2C8>= -74=0;;C8<48=BC0=CB0A4DB435>AA42>=BCAD2C8>=>5C748=BC0=C0=4>DB 5;>F>A60=8I0C8>=86 2C78B2>D;30;;>F5>A8=2A40B43A42>=BCAD2C8>=@D0;8CH>5A4;4E0=C5;>F @D0=C8C84BBD270BA<BE4;>28CH0=3E>AC828CH5;D2CD0C8>=;4E4;B = C74 ?A4B4=C <0=DB2A8?C 8C 8B ?A>?>B43 C> DB4 5D;; E4;>28CH C8<4 78BC>A84B 5A>< #06A0=680= ?0AC82;4 CA0942C>AH <40BDA4<4=CB F8C7 C74 , 5A0<4F>A: *74 A4BD;C8=6 ‘VIC++’ <4C7>3 A4@D8A4B 0= 4GC4=B8>= >5 C74 5A0<4F>A: C> 8=2;D34 0= 8C4A0C8E4 C8<48=C46A0C8>= ?A>243DA4 420DB4 >5 C74 2><?DC8>=0; 2>BC 0BB>280C43 F8C7 C78B 4GC4=B8>= C74 5>2DB >5 C74 ?A4B4=C <0=DB2A8?C8B>=02>=24?C34<>=BCA0C8>=>=C740=0;HC820;20B4>50CF>38<4=B8>=0;E>AC4GC> 8=E4BC860C4C74?>C4=C80;>5C74<4C7>3 %"$ ! ""! *74 <4C7>3 8B 10B43 >= 8C4A0C8E4 C8<48=C46A0C8>= DB8=6 E>AC4G8=24;; , 0B 0??;843 C> ' , <40BDA4<4=CB 8= )27=4834AB 4C 0;

(27) = 8=8C80; 2>=38C8>= 8B 270=643 0C 4027 8C4A0C8>= C> <8=8<8I4 C74 38554A4=24 14CF44= C74 E4;>28CH 5A>< , C8<48=C46A0C8>= 0=3 C74 '*, E4;>28CH <40BDA4<4=CB 8;;DBCA0C43 8= 86

(28) *78B 8B 0 64=4A0;8I0C8>= >5 C74 , <4C7>3 ?A>?>B43 40A;84A8=)27=4834AB4C0;

(29) 8=F7827C8<48=C46A0C8>=F0B0E>83430=3>=;HE4;>28CH0=3 E4;>28CH <0C4A80; 34A8E0C8E4 8B 2>=B834A43 5>A C74 =>=;8=40A 8C4A0C8E4 >?C8<8I0C8>= *78B 64=4A0;8I0C8>=8B20;;43‘VIC++’8=C74?A4B4=C<0=DB2A8?C . ;>F270AC>5C74?A>?>B43E4;>28CHA42>=BCAD2C8>=C427=8@D4. . *74 <4C7>3 A4;84B >= C74 0E08;018;8CH >5 ?0AC82;4 CA0942C>A84B *78B A4@D8A4B C8<4A4B>;E43 <40BDA4<4=CB F74A4 ?0AC82;4B 20= 14 >1B4AE43 <>E8=6 >= ;>=6 CA02:B B=0?B7>CB 145>A4 4G8C8=6 C74 <40BDA4<4=C 3><08= *74 ?0AC82;4 CA0942C>A84B 20= 14 >1C08=43 5A>< E>G4;10B43 0??A>0274 6 C><>6A0?782'*,>A38A42C;H5A><8C4A0C8E4?0AC82;4A42>=BCAD2C8>= '(-84=4:4

(30) )70:4C74>G)270=I4C0;

(31) .

(32)

(33) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – . ന ࡼࢀࢂ >5 0 ?0AC82;4 *74 <0CA8G 2>=C08=8=6 C74 ;>20C8>=B >5 0;; ?0AC82;4B 0C 4027 C8<48=BC0=C 8B ࢄ ന ࡼࢀࢂ CA0942C>AHF8C7;4=6C7 *742>AA4B?>=38=6?0AC82;4E4;>28C84B0A42>;;42C438=C74<0CA8Gࢂ. *74, C8<48=C46A0C8>=BC0AC8=65A><0=8=8C80;2>=38C8>=20;2D;0C4B0C4027<40BDA4<4=CC8<4 ന ࢂࡵ࡯ 0C C74 ?0AC82;4 ;>20C8>=B ࢄ ന ࡼࢀࢂ %>C4 C74 8=C46A0C8>= C8<4BC4? 8B 8=BC0=C C74 E4;>28C84B ࢂ. CH?820;;H B<0;;4A C70= C74 <40BDA4<4=C C8<48=C4AE0; 0=3 34C4A<8=43 022>A38=6 C> C74 2A8C4A80 3458=43 8= )27=4834AB 4C 0;

(34) *74 2><?DC0C8>=0; 3><08= 8B 27>B4= 4@D0; C> C74 ന ࡼࢀࢂ 5A>< C74 ന ࢂࡵ࡯ 0C ࢄ <40BDA4<4=C E>;D<4 0=3 ;8=40A 8=C4A?>;0C8>= 8B DB43 C> >1C08= ࢂ. 2><?DC0C8>=0;6A83 . =>=;8=40A >?C8<8I0C8>= ?A>1;4< 8B 3458=43 8= F7827 C74 346A44B >5 5A443>< 8 4 8=8C80; 0=3 ന ࢂࡵ࡯ 0=3ࢂ ന ࡼࢀࢂ 1>D=30AH2>=38C8>=B0A48C4A0C8E4;H039DBC43C><8=8<8I4C7438554A4=2414CF44=ࢂ B44 86

(35) <833;4 *78B 38554A4=24 8B @D0=C85843 8= C74 2>BC 5D=2C8>= 5>A C74 >?C8<8I0C8>= ?A>243DA4 . ଶ. ന ࡼࢀࢂ െ ࢂ ന ࢂࡵ࡯ ൧ ‫ ܬ‬ൌ σൣࢂ. 6A0384=C 10B43 >?C8<8I0C8>= C427=8@D4 8B DB43 #) #8D 0=3 %>2430; C> 58=3 C74 346A44B >5 5A443>< <8=8<8I8=6 C74 2>BC 5D=2C8>= *74 346A44B >5 5A443>< 5>A C74 >?C8<8I0C8>= 0A42>;;42C438=0E42C>Aࣈ >AC746A0384=C10B43>?C8<8I0C8>=0C40278C4A0C8>=8C8B=424BB0AHC> 20;2D;0C4C746A0384=CB ࣈ +B8=658=8C438554A4=28=6C78BF>D;32><40CC742>BC>5C74=D<14A >5346A44B>55A443><J=GO=HO=IC8<48=C46A0C8>=B*>0E>83C78BC746A0384=C8B 20;2D;0C434558284=C;H1HC74=D<4A820;039>8=C>5C74, 2>34 *78B8B0<0C74<0C820;‘trick’C> 4E0;D0C4 C74 6A0384=C ࣈ 0C C74 '+ 2>BC >5 0 B8=6;4 C8<48=C46A0C8>= >=;H 1DC 0C C74 2>BC >5 8=2A40B43 <4<>AH DB064 *74 ;0CC4A <4<>AH DB064 A4<08=B 7>F4E4A E4AH ;8<8C43 3D4 C> C74 A4;0C8E4;HB7>AC C8<48=C46A0C8>=BC70C 0A4 ?4A5>A<43 0;>=6?0AC82;4 CA0942C>A84B>5CH?820;;H

(36) B=0?B7>CB >A 8=5>A<0C8>= >= C74 039>8=C C74 A4034A 8B A454AA43 C> *0;06A0=3 0=3 >DAC84A 0<>=6BC >C74AB *74 8C4A0C8E4 ?A>243DA4 8B BC>??43 F74= C74 2>BC 5D=2C8>= 8B >= C74 >A34A>5C74<40BDA4<4=C4AA>A8=C74'*,E4;>28CH<40BDA4<4=CB %"####$ >=B834A 0 CF>38<4=B8>=0; 0DBB80= E>AC4G ?>B8C8>=43 8= C74 24=C4A >5 0 B8<D;0C43 <40BDA4<4=C?;0=4 *7420B4>5BD270E>AC4G1;>170B144=DB43?A4E8>DB;H5>A0BB4BB<4=C>5 C8<4A4B>;E43' ,C427=8@D4B1H0<>=6BC>C74AB34"0C0=3E0=&D374DB34=

(37)

(38) #H=270=3 )20A0=>

(39) 0=3 )27=4834AB 4C 0;

(40) 1 *74 C0=64=C80; E4;>28CH 584;3 8=3D243 1H C74 0DBB80=E>AC4G1;>18B68E4=1H .

(41)

(42) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – .

(43) . ܸఏ ൌ. ୻. ଶగ௥. ቆͳ െ ݁. ೝమ. ି೎. ഇ. ቇ. F74A4ƥ8BC7428A2D;0C8>=0=3ǉ Ǆ 7>>B8=6Ǆ

(44) C74C0=64=C80;E4;>28CH?40:B0CC74 2>A4A038DB >AC74?A4B4=C0BB4BB<4=CȞȀܸ௣ ‫ ܮ‬F74A4 8BC74?40:E4;>28CH0CC742>A4. A038DB 86DA4 0 B7>FB C74 A4BD;C8=6 0=0;HC820; E42C>A 584;3 86DA4B 1 0=3 2 B7>F C74 2><?>=4=C>5E4;>28CH0=3E>AC828CHA4B?42C8E4;H . (454A4=24E42C>A584;302>=C>DAB>5E4;>28CH10=3E>AC828CH2 *74 <40BDA4<4=C ?;0=4 8B 27>B4= C> 14 0 B@D0A4 F8C7 B834B >5

(45) )8<D;0C43 '*, <40BDA4<4=CB 0A4 <034 1H B4438=6 0 2><?DC0C8>=0; ?;0=4 D=85>A<;H F8C7 ?0AC82;4B *74 ?0AC82;4B 0A4 8=C46A0C43 >E4A C8<4 F8C7 C74 (" <4C7>3 F74A4 C74 8=BC0=C0=4>DB E4;>28CH 8B ?A>E8343 1H C74 0=0;HC820; 5;>F 584;3 68E4= 1H

(46) )20CC4A43 E4;>28CH <40BDA4<4=CB 0A4 C0:4= 5A><C740=0;HC820;5;>F584;30CC74?0AC82;4;>20C8>=B0C0C8<4B4?0A0C8>=>5ȟ‫*

(47) ݐ‬74C>C0; <40BDA4<4=C 3DA0C8>= 8B C0:4= C> 14 B=0?B7>CB B 38B2DBB43 8= C74 8=CA>3D2C8>= 4BC01;8B743 C427=8@D4B C> 8=C4A?>;0C4 E4;>28CH 0C 5A>< C74 B20CC4A43 ?0AC82;4 ?>B8C8>=B >=C> 0 34=B4 6A83 DB4 >=;H C74 8=BC0=C0=4>DB E4;>28CH <40BDA4<4=CB = C74 ?A4B4=C BCD3H CA8;8=40A 8=C4A?>;0C8>= 0=3 030?C8E4 0DBB80= F8=3>F8=6 - 6D8 0=3 !8<4=4I 0A4 C0:4= 0B 4G0<?;4B >5 BD27 C427=8@D4B *74 ?A>?>B43 E>AC4G8=24;; C427=8@D4 20= 0;B> 14 0??;843 C> 0 B8=6;4 E4;>28CH <40BDA4<4=C F7827 A4BD;CB 8= 0 38E4A64=24 5A44 8=C4A?>;0C8>= >5 C74 B20CC4A43 E4;>28CH<40BDA4<4=CB >A0;;<4C7>3BE4;>28CH8B8=C4A?>;0C43C>0A46D;0A6A83F8C7

(48) G

(49) E42C>AB >A C74 E>AC4G8=24;; <4C7>3B 7><>64=4>DB ?0338=6 CH?4 1>D=30AH 2>=38C8>=B )27=4834AB4C0;

(50) 10A44<?;>H43 *74A4BD;CB0A458ABC0BB4BB431H2><?0A8B>=>52>=C>DA?;>CB>58=BC0=C0=4>DBE4;>28CH 86DA40 B7>FB C74 8=BC0=C0=4>DB 0=0;HC820; 2><?>=4=C >5 E4;>28CH B4438=6 2>=24=CA0C8>= 0C F7827 CA024A ?0AC82;4B 0A4 ?A4B4=C F8C78= 0C C74 <40BDA4<4=C ?;0=4 8B 2>=B834A43 86DA4 1 B7>FB C74 A4BD;C >5 CA8;8=40A 8=C4A?>;0C8>= >5 C74 B20CC4A43 E4;>28CH <40BDA4<4=CB C> 0 A46D;0A.

(51)

(52) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – . 6A83 *74 8=BC0=C0=4>DB ?0AC82;4 ;>20C8>=B 0A4 E8BD0;8I43 1H C74 A43 2A>BB4B 8= C74 586DA4 *74 ;8=40A 8=C4A?>;0C8>= A4BD;C A4CDA=B 4G02C;H C74 E4;>28CH <40BDA4<4=C 0C C74 ?0AC82;4 ;>20C8>=B = 14CF44=C74<40BDA4<4=CB>=C74>C74A70=3C74A4BD;C8B05542C431HC74;8<8C43CA024A?0AC82;4 2>=24=CA0C8>=0=3C74CF>2>=24=CA0C434GCA4<08=C74E4;>28CH584;386 00A4=>C5>D=31H C74 ;8=40A 8=C4A?>;0C8>= 86 1 *74 030?C8E4 0DBB80= F8=3>F8=6 C427=8@D4 A4CDA=B C74 F4867C430E4A0643E4;>28CH584;30C40276A83=>340=3C74A45>A4058;C4A43A4BD;C8B4G?42C438= 2><?0A8B>=C>C74;8=40A8=C4A?>;0C8>= *78B8B2>=58A<431HC74-A4BD;C8=86 2F78278B B8<8;0AC>C74A4BD;C>5C74;8=40A8=C4A?>;0C8>=86 11DCB7>FB0A43D243E4;>28CH6A0384=C . >=C>DAB>5C742><?>=4=C>5E4;>28CH (454A4=245;>F584;30;8=40A8=C4A?>;0C8>=1. . -20=3C74?A>?>B43<4C7>3F8C7

(53) 0=3 35A4B?42C8E4;H *74 ?A>?>B43 E>AC4G8=24;; C427=8@D4 20= 14 4<?;>H43 5>A 0= 8=BC0=C0=4>DB A42>=BCAD2C8>= DB8=6 >=;H >=4 >A

(54) E4;>28CH <40BDA4<4=C C> H84;3 4BB4=C80;;H 0 38E4A64=24 5A44 A42>=BCAD2C8>= >5 C74 5;>F 420DB4 C78B 8<?>B4B 0 ?7HB82B10B43 A4BCA82C8>= >= C74 5;>F A42>=BCAD2C8>= 8<?A>E43 022DA02H >5 C74 E4;>28CH A42>=BCAD2C8>= 8= 14CF44= ?0AC82;4B 8B 4G?42C43 *78B 8B 2>=58A<43 1H C74 A4BD;C 8= 86 3 F7827 B7>FB C74 E>AC4G8=24;; A42>=BCAD2C8>= DB8=6 9DBC CF> E4;>28CH C8<4 8=BC0=CB

(55) *74A4BD;C B7>FB C74 CF> 38B2A4C4 4GCA4<0 >5 8= C74 A42>=BCAD2C8>= -74= <>A4 <40BDA4<4=C C8<48=BC0=CB 0A4 DB43 5>A C74 8=BC0=C0=4>DBE4;>28CHA42>=BCAD2C8>=05DAC74AA46D;0A8I0C8>=>5C74E4;>28CH8B4G?42C43 86DA4B 40=35B7>FC74A4BD;CBDB8=6 0=3 <40BDA4<4=CC8<48=BC0=CBA4B?42C8E4;H *74A43.

(56)

(57) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – . 2A>BB4B B7>F C74 ?0AC82;4 CA0942C>A84B >E4A C74 A4B?42C8E4 C8<43DA0C8>=B DB43 5>A E4;>28CH A42>=BCAD2C8>= -74= C8<48=BC0=CB 0A4 4<?;>H43 C74 A4BD;C8=6 E4;>28CH 584;3 8B ?A02C820;;H BH<<4CA820=3B7>FBC74B0<42>=C>DA;4E4;B0BC74A454A4=24B>;DC8>=86 0 *74C>F0A3BC74 4364B>5C743><08=C74E4;>28CH342A40B4BF78278B4G?42C430B=>?0AC82;4B0A4?A4B4=C8=C78B A468>= *74A4BD;CB?;>CC438=86 34?4=3>=C74?0AC82;4;>20C8>=B8=?0AC82D;0A5>AC74<4C7>3BC70C DB4>=;H0;8<8C43=D<14A>5C8<48=BC0=CB5>AE4;>28CH8=C4A?>;0C8>= *>8=B?42C<>A42;>B4;HC74 38554A4=24B 14CF44= B7>AC 0=3 ;>=6 CA02: ;4=6C7B DB43 5>A E4;>28CH A42>=BCAD2C8>=86 00=31B7>FC740E4A064?A>58;4B0;>=6C7424=C4A;8=4>5C74<40BDA4<4=C ?;0=48B68E4=5>AC740=32><?>=4=CB>5E4;>28CH *74?A>58;4B0A40E4A06435A><<D;C8?;4 A0=3>< 8=8C80;8I0C8>=B >5 C74 ?0AC82;4 ;>20C8>=B &= 0E4A064 CA024A ?0AC82;4B F4A4 ?A4B4=C 8= C74<40BDA4<4=C?;0=4 *740=0;HC820;?A>58;4B0A4?;>CC438=1;02: *74A4BD;CB5>A

(58) 0=3 0A4B7>F=8=1;D40=3A43A4B?42C8E4;H *74B703430A40A4?A4B4=CBC74BC0=30A334E80C8>=5A>< C74<40=A4BD;CBF7827A4?A4B4=CBC74E0A80C8>=8=C74A42>=BCAD2C8>=@D0;8CH34?4=38=6>=C74 ?0AC82;4 ;>20C8>=B B 4G?42C43 5A>< C74 A4BD;CB 8= 86 F74= 0 ;>=64A CA0942C>AH 8B DB43 5>A A42>=BCAD2C8>= C74 ?40: E4;>28C84B 0A4 0??A>G8<0C43 <>A4 022DA0C4;H – 0C C74 B0<4 B4438=6 2>=24=CA0C8>= . E4A06424=C4A;8=4?A>58;4B>5C74E4;>28CH2><?>=4=CBD00=3E10=3E>AC828CH2 20;2D;0C435A>< A0=3><8=8C80;8I0C8>=B>5C74CA024A?0AC82;4B *74 8<?A>E43 4BC8<0C8>= >5 C74 ?40: E4;>28C84B F74= <>A4 C8<48=BC0=CB 0A4 DB43 5>A A42>=BCAD2C8>= 8B 4G?42C43 C> H84;3 0 <>A4 022DA0C4 4BC8<0C8>= >5 C74 ?40: E>AC828CH ;4E4;B *74 E>AC828CH 2>=C>DA ?;>CB 0A4 ?A4B4=C43 8= 86 *74 586DA4B 5>;;>F C74 ;0H>DC >5 C74 E4;>28CH 2>=C>DA?;>CB86 38B2DBB4301>E40=30608=C74?0AC82;4BCA0942C>A84BDB435>AA42>=BCAD2C8>= 0A4?;>CC431HC74A432A>BB4B .

(59)

(60) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – . . >=C>DAB>5E>AC828CH (454A4=245;>F584;30;8=40A8=C4A?>;0C8>=1-20=3C74 ?A>?>B43<4C7>3F8C7

(61) 0=3 35A4B?42C8E4;H B 20= 14 4G?42C43 5A>< C74 58;C4A43 A4BD;CB >1C08=43 1H C74 ;8=40A 8=C4A?>;0C8>= 0=3 030?C8E4 0DBB80=F8=3>F8=6C427=8@D4B86 10=32A4B?42C8E4;HC74E>AC4G1;>18B=>C834=C858431H C742>=C>DAB?;>CC4386 10=32 *74B8CD0C8>=8B<D278<?A>E43F74=C7438E4A64=245A44 2>=38C8>=8B4=5>A2435>AC74A42>=BCAD2C8>=86 3 *74B70?4>5C74E>AC4G8B7>F4E4A05542C43 1H C74 8=BC0=C0=4>DB ?0AC82;4 ;>20C8>=B 0=3 CF> ?40:B 0A4 E8B81;4 8= C74 A42>=BCAD2C8>= -74= <>A4 C8<48=BC0=CB 0A4 DB43 86 4 C74 A4BD;C 8B 5DAC74A A46D;0A8I43 0=3 ?A02C820;;H 28A2D;0A5>A 86 5 *74BC0C8BC820;;H0E4A0643?A>58;4B5>AE>AC828CH0A4?;>CC438=86 2 F7827 2>=58A<B C70C F8C7 C74 ?40: E>AC828CH E0;D4 8B 14CC4A A4B>;E43 C70= F74= 4BB4=C80;;H>=;H038E4A64=245A44A42>=BCAD2C8>=8B<034F8C7

(62) CB7>D;314A4<0A:43C70C C74B;867C=460C8E4E>AC828CHC>F0A3BC743><08=1>D=30A84B5>;;>FB5A><C7458G437><>64=>DB E4;>28CH1>D=30AH2>=38C8>=BDB435>AC78B0BB4BB<4=C >A0<>A4@D0=C8C0C8E42><?0A8B>=>5C74A4BD;CBC74A<B4AA>A;4E4;>5E4;>28CHF8C7A4B?42CC> C740=0;HC820;B>;DC8>=4@

(63) 8B4E0;D0C438=C743><08=24=C4A C>0=3?;>CC438= 86 F7827 B7>FB C74 A<B 4AA>A E0A80C8>= F8C7 B4438=6 2>=24=CA0C8>= 5>A C74 38554A4=C 8=C4A?>;0C8>=C427=8@D4B2>=B834A43 *744AA>A8B=>A<0;8I431HC74?40:E4;>28CHE0;D4 .

(64)

(65) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – . ,4;>28CHA<B4AA>AE0A80C8>=F8C7=D<14A>5?0AC82;4B0=3A42>=BCAD2C8>=C427=8@D4 -74=C74=D<14A>5?0AC82;4BDB435>AC748=C4A?>;0C8>=8=2A40B4BC74A<B4AA>A342A40B4B $>A4 =>C4F>AC7H5>A0;;B4438=62>=24=CA0C8>=BC744AA>A342A40B4BF74=0;>=64AC8<4B4A84B8BDB43 5>AC74, A42>=BCAD2C8>= *745;0CC4=8=6>5C74 A4BD;C5>A;0A64%?8B0B2A8143C>C74 58=8C40=3A4;0C8E4;H2>0AB46A83B8I4DB435>AC74A42>=BCAD2C8>= *78BB7>FBC74?>C4=C80;>5C74 =>E4; C427=8@D4 C> 8<?A>E4 E4;>28CH 022DA02H 8= 20B4B F74A4 C8<4A4B>;E43 <40BDA4<4=CB 0A4 0E08;01;4

(66) %# # *74=>E4;2>=24?C>5DB8=65D;;?0AC82;4CA0942C>AH<40BDA4<4=CBF8C7E>AC4G8=24;;B8<D;0C8>=B C> 0;;>F 5>A 0 34=B4 8=C4A?>;0C8>= >5 E4;>28CH 8= C74 <40BDA4<4=C A468>= 8B >DC;8=43 0=3 34<>=BCA0C43 >= C74 =D<4A820; 20B4 >5 E>AC4G 1;>1 >A 0;; B4438=6 2>=24=CA0C8>=B 2>=B834A43 C74DB4>5;>=64A?0AC82;4CA0942C>A84BH84;3B0<>A4022DA0C4A42>=BCAD2C8>=>5C74E4;>28CH584;3 *74 BCD3H 34<>=BCA0C4B C74 ?>C4=C80; >5 0BB8<8;0C8>= >5 ;>=6 #06A0=680= ?0AC82;4 CA0942C>AH <40BDA4<4=CB 4 6 5A>< C><>6A0?782'*,>A“ShakeC74Box”F8C7E>AC4G8=24;; B8<D;0C8>=B 5>A8=2A40B43022DA02H>5E4;>28CH0=3E>AC828CH<40BDA4<4=CB &$# *78BA4B40A278B?0AC;H5D=3431H#0,8B8>=<1 "# 6D80=3!8<4=4I ;8=34'$82704;8B E0=&D374DB34= - -48BB' 34"0C( #0B:0A8 !4>=/ ! 0E83# )270=I D7= 4B4<0==) %>E0A0$ $2'7034= %44C4B>=% (8E0; )27=4834AB! )27A894A

(67) ><?0A0C8E4 0BB4BB<4=C >5 ' ,10B43 ?A4BBDA4 4E0;D0C8>= C427=8@D4B 0??;843 C> 0 CA0=B>=82 10B4.

(68)

(69) 4).4&2.#4*/.#,7-0/3*5-/.4)&00,*$#4*/./'#3&2#.%-#(*.(&$).*15&34/,5*%&$)#.*$3࣭8 ࣭ " – . 5;>F = C7 8=C4A=0C8>=0; BH<?>B8D< >= C74 0??;820C8>= >5 ;0B4A C427=8@D4B C> 5;D83 <4270=82B #8B1>= '>ACD60; !D;H 34 "0C ( E0= &D374DB34= -

(70)

(71) =BC0=C0=4>DB ?;0=0A ?A4BBDA4 34C4A<8=0C8>= 5A>< ' , 8= CDA1D;4=C 5;>F G?4A8<4=CB8=;D83B

(72) – A>=B:8B 48CI $K<8=

(73) =5;>F0=38=8C80;2>=38C8>=B5>A38A42C=D<4A820;B8<D;0C8>=10B43>= 039>8=C30C00BB8<8;0C8>= !><?DC'7HB

(74)

(75) – 48CI $4<8= )27=>AA

(76). ,0A80C8>=0;5;D835;>F<40BDA4<4=CB5A><8<064B4@D4=24BBH=>?B8B0=3 ?4AB?42C8E4BG?4A8<4=CB8=;D83B #4<:4$ )4BC4A74==!

(77) 39>8=C10B43?A4BBDA434C4A<8=0C8>=5A><' ,30C0—E0;830C8>=F8C7BH=C74C82 ' ,<40BDA4<4=CB = C78=C4A=0C8>=0;BH<?>B8D<>=' ,4;5C*74%4C74A;0=3B #H=27" )20A0=>

(78) $0C4A80;0224;4A0C8>=4BC8<0C8>=1H5>DA?D;B4C><>' , $40B)28*427=>;

(79) . )270=I 4B4<0==) )27AL34A

(80) )70:4*74>G#06A0=680=?0AC82;4CA02:8=60C7867?0AC82;48<064 34=B8C84B G?4A8<4=CB8=5;D83B )27=4834AB! F867C( ' )20A0=>

(81) *8<4BD?4AB0<?;8=6>5 ' ,<40BDA4<4=CBF8C7E>AC4G 8=24;;B8<D;0C8>= G?4A8<4=CB8=;D83B

(82) )27=4834AB ! I89;8 )20A0=> F867C ( '

(83) '>DA8=6 C8<4 8=C> B?024 = C7 =C4A=0C8>=0; )H<?>B8D<>='0AC82;4 <064,4;>28<4CAH' , )0=C00A10A0+))4?C4<14A

(84) )27=4834AB ! )20A0=> ;B8=60

(85) 0 &= C74 (4B>;E43 )20;4B 8= 0 *DA1D;4=C >D=30AH #0H4A 1H *><>6A0?782 ' , 0=3 '*, 08343 1H , = C7 8=C4A=0C8>=0; BH<?>B8D< >= C74 0??;820C8>= >5 ;0B4A C427=8@D4BC>5;D83<4270=82B #8B1>='>ACD60; !D;H )27=4834AB! 'AL1BC8=6) F867C( ' E0=&D374DB34= - )20A0=>

(86) 1 'A4BBDA44BC8<0C8>= 5A><B8=6;4B=0?B7>CC><>6A0?782' ,8=0CDA1D;4=C1>D=30AH;0H4A G?4A8<4=CB8=;D83B ,;0B4=:> )C44;4 %8<<>)<8C7 - $

(87) ?7HB82B4=01;43 5;>F A4BC>A0C8>= 0;6>A8C7< 5>A B?0AB4' ,0=3'*,<40BDA4<4=CB $40B)28*427=>;

(88) /460E80= ( #42;08A4 70<?06=0C $0A@D4C &

(89) '4A5>A<0=24 0BB4BB<4=C >5 ' , BD?4AA4B>;DC8>= F8C7 039>8=C10B43 30C0 0BB8<8;0C8>= = C7 8=C4A=0C8>=0; BH<?>B8D< >= ' , )0=C0 0A010A0 +) )4?C4<14A

(90) -84=4:4

(91) C4A0C8E4 A42>=BCAD2C8>= >5 E>;D<4CA82 ?0AC82;4 38BCA81DC8>= $40BDA4<4=C )284=24 0=3 *427=>;>6H

(92)

(93) . .

(94)