The Politics of Plato and His Objection to Democracy

A N N A L E S

8 1 , 9 ( 5 6 , 7$7 , 6   0 $ 5 , $ (   & 8 5 , (  6 . à 2 ' 2 : 6 . $ /8%/,1±32/21,$ 92/;;, 6(&7,2.  0D\LV8QLYHUVLW\,VWDQEXO7XUNH\ $<',1723$/2ö/8

The Politics of Plato and His Objection to Democracy

ABSTRACT $QFLHQW*UHHNSKLORVRSKHU3ODWRKDGQRWRQO\KDGSROLWLFDOGHVLUHVEXWKDGDOVRWULHGWRHQJDJH LQDFWLYHSROLWLFV%XWDIWHUDELJIUXVWUDWLRQHVSHFLDOO\ZLWKWKHWULDORI6RFUDWHVKHWXUQHGDZD\IURP SROLWLFVDQGFULWLFL]HGWKHSROLWLFDOSKHQRPHQDRIKLVRZQWLPHXQGHUWKHQDPHRIGHPRFUDF\,QKLV IDVFLQDWLQJZRUNVZHILQGKLVSROLWLFDOLGHDVDPELWLRQVDGYHQWXUHVDSSURYDOVDQGGLVDSSURYDOV)RU 3ODWRVRFLHW\RUDQLGHDOVWDWHPXVWEHRUJDQL]HGDQGFRQWUROOHGQRWE\PDVVHVEXWE\SHUVRQVZKR UHDOO\NQRZZKDWWKHQRUPVDUH7KHWURXEOHVRIPDQNLQGZLOOQHYHUFHDVHXQWLOHLWKHUWUXHJHQXLQH SKLORVRSKHUVDWWDLQSROLWLFDOSRZHURUWKHUXOHUVRIVWDWHVE\VRPHGLVSHQVDWLRQRISURYLGHQFHEHFRPH JHQXLQHSKLORVRSKHUV

Key words: 3ODWRSROLWLFVLGHDOVWDWHMXVWLFHW\SHVRIJRYHUQPHQWVDQGGHPRFUDF\

3ODWR*UHHNFODVVLFDOSKLORVRSKHUUHPDUNVLQKLVSeventh LetterWKDW³«3HR-SOHZHUHGLVVDWLVILHGZLWKWKHH[LVWLQJFRQVWLWXWLRQDQGDUHYROXWLRQWRRNSODFH$V DUHVXOWRIZKLFKSRZHUZDVFRQFHQWUDWHGLQWKHKDQGVRIILIW\RQHPHQ«´ $ULV-WRWOHDWHDFKHURI$OH[DQGHUWKH*UHDWDQG3ODWR¶VWHDFKHUUHPDUNVLQKLV3ROLWLFV ³$GHPRFUDF\H[LVWVZKHQHYHUWKRVHZKRDUHIUHHDQGDUHQRWZHOORIIEHLQJLQWKH PDMRULW\DUHLQVRYHUHLJQFRQWURORIJRYHUQPHQWDQROLJDUFK\ZKHQFRQWUROOLHVZLWK _{ 3ODWRPhaedrus and Letters VII and VIII,WUDQVOE\:DOWHU+DPLOWRQ3HQJXLQ%RRNV}

/RQGRQ S  (OHYHQ RI WKHVH ILIW\RQH PHQ ZHUH LQ FKDUJH LQ WKH FLW\ DQG WHQ LQ 3LUDHXV WKLUW\ DVVXPHGVXSUHPHFRQWURORIWKHZKROHVWDWHDFFRUGLQJWR3ODWR

 $<',1723$/2ö/8 WKHULFKDQGEHWWHUERUQWKHVHEHLQJIHZ´_{%RWK3ODWR¶VRZQDFFRXQWH[SODLQVZK\} KHWXUQHGDZD\IURPSXEOLFOLIHHYHQKHKDGGHVLUHVLQKLV\RXWKDQG$ULVWRWOH¶VODWHU GLVWLQJXLVKLQJWKHIRUPVRIUXOLQJE\RQHPRQDUFK\DIHZROLJDUFK\DULVWRFUDF\ RUPDQ\GHPRFUDF\LQKLVPoliticsJLYHXVHQRXJKLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWWKHSUREOHPDWLF DVSHFWVRI$WKHQLDQGHPRFUDF\RIDQFLHQW*UHHNVDQG3ODWR¶VUHDVRQVIRUGLVDSSURYDO ,QWKLVSDSHU,ZRXOGOLNHWRGHDOZLWK3ODWR¶VDSSURDFKWRWKHSROLF\ILUVWDQGWR VWUHVVRQKLVLGHDVDERXWVWDWHVW\SHVRIJRYHUQPHQWVLGHDOVWDWHMXVWLFHGHPRFUDF\ FULWLFVDQGVKLSDQDORJ\3ODWR%&%&KDGQRWRQO\KDGSROLWLFDOGH-VLUHVEXWKDGDOVRWULHGWRHQJDJHLQDFWLYHSROLWLFV,QKLVRepublic, Laws, Letters DQG

Politicus,ZHILQGKLVSROLWLFDOGLDJQRVHVDQGSUHVFULSWLRQVLGHDOVDQGDQWLSDWKLHV_+H ZDVERUQLQWRDQDULVWRFUDWLF$WKHQLDQIDPLO\DQGJUHZXSGXULQJWKHJUHDW3HORSRQ-QHVLDQ:DUWR%&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¶VWKRXJKWIURPILUVWWRODVWZDVFKLHIO\EHQWRQWKHTXHVWLRQKRZ VRFLHW\FRXOGEHUHVKDSHGVRWKDWPDQPLJKWUHDOL]HWKHEHVWLVLQKLP_ $VPDQ\SHRSOHH[SHFWWRHPEDUNRQDSROLWLFDOFDUHHULQWKHLU\RXWK3ODWRGLG VDPHWKLQJ+HZDVDERXWWZHQW\WKUHHZKHQWKHWKLUW\W\UDQWVZLWKKLVXQFOH&ULWLDV DVWKHLUOHDGHUFDPHWRSRZHULQ%&+HGUHDPHGWRVROYHWKHVRFLDOSUREOHPV EHFDXVHSHRSOHZHUHXQKDSS\ZLWKWKHH[LVWLQJFRQVWLWXWLRQ$FWXDOO\KHZDVFDOOHG XSRQWRGRVRXQGHUWKHLUUHJLPH+LVUHODWLYHVDQGIULHQGVLQWKHJRYHUQPHQWKLV XQFOH&ULWLDVDQGKLVFRXVLQ&KDUPLGHV5_{LQYLWHGKLPWRMRLQDQGKHOSWKHP,WZDVDQ} REYLRXVFDUHHUIRUKLP

$W WKH EHJLQQLQJ 3ODWR ZDV KRSHIXO DERXW VRPH FKDQJHV IURP FRUUXSWLRQV LQ DGPLQLVWUDWLRQDQGKHZDVHDJHUWREHOLHYHWKHPDERXWWKHLUDLPIRUFRUUHFWLQJWKH HYLOVRIGHPRFUDF\%XWVRRQKHZDVYHU\GLVDSSRLQWHGZLWKZKDWKHH[SHULHQFHG _{ $ULVWRWOHThe PoliticsWUDQVOE\7$6LQFODLU3HQJXLQ%RRNV/RQGRQES} _{ 5\OH *  ³3ODWR´ The Encyclopedia of Philosophy 3 (GZDUGV HG 0DFPLOODQ 1HZ}

<RUNYROS

_{ /DHUWLXV'LRJHQHVLives of Eminent Philosophers³3ODWR´%RRN,,,WUDQVOE\5'+LFNV}

+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV/RQGRQ9RO,SS±'HVPRQG/HH¶VLQWURGXFWLRQIRUThe Republic 3ODWR3HQJXLQ%RRNV/RQGRQSS[L±OYL)0&RUQIRUG¶VLQWURGXFWLRQIRUThe Republic3ODWR 2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV/RQGRQSS[Y±[[L[

7KH\WULHGWRLQYROYH6RFUDWHVLQWKHLUDFWLRQV6RFUDWHVLQVWHDGRIREH\LQJUHIXVHG WRSDUWLFLSDWHLQWKHLULQIDPRXVGHHGVZLWKULVNLQJHYHU\WKLQJDV3ODWRZDVZDLWLQJWR ZDWFKWKHP%XWKHZDVVRRQGLVJXVWHGE\WKHLUUHSUHVVLYHPHDVXUHVDQGHVSHFLDOO\E\ WKHLUDWWHPSWWRLPSOLFDWH6RFUDWHVLQWKHLUPXUGHURXVGHVLJQV_{6RFUDWHVZLWKGUDZV} KLPVHOIIURPWKHSUHYDLOLQJZLFNHGQHVV%XWDWRWDOUHYROXWLRQSXWDQHQGWRWKHUXOH RIWKH7KLUW\DQGRQFHDJDLQ3ODWREHJDQWRIHHODGHVLUHWRWDNHSDUWLQSROLWLFVDQG LQ SXEOLF OLIH EHFDXVH GHPRFUDWV VKRZHG FRPPHQGDEOH UHVWUDLQW LQ GHDOLQJ ZLWK WKHLUODWHHQHPLHVDQG3ODWRVHHPHGWRKDYHEHHQRQWKHSRLQWRIHQWHULQJSROLWLFV RQFHPRUH%XWVRRQWKH\EURXJKW6RFUDWHVEHIRUHWKHFRXUWVRQDZLFNHGFKDUJHE\ 3ODWR¶VZRUGVZLWKWKHDFFXVDWLRQRIEHLQJLPSLRXVDQGWKHFRXUWFRQGHPQHGDQG SXWKLPWRGHDWK7KHWULDORI6RFUDWHVDQGKLVGHDWKDWWKHHQGSOXQJHGWKH\RXQJ 3ODWR LQWR GHVSDLU %HFDXVH WKHUH ZDV QR KRSH VDQLW\ RU PRGHUDWLRQ HLWKHU IURP ROLJDUFKRUGHPRFUDW7_

3ODWRGLVLOOXVLRQHGE\6RFUDWHV¶FRQGHPQDWLRQWRGHDWKDWWKHKDQGVRIWKHDV-VHPEO\ DEDQGRQHG KLV SROLWLFDO GHVLUH DQG VWDUWHG WR ODXQFK D GHYDVWDWLQJ DWWDFN $VZHZLOOVHHODWHUKHSXWVLQWRTXHVWLRQWKHSHRSOHV¶DELOLW\WRUXOHMXVWO\+HZLOO GHQRXQFHWKHXVHRIORWWRVHOHFWRIILFLDOVDVJLYLQJXQGXHSRZHUWRWKHOHVVDEOHDQG NQRZOHGJHDEOH $IWHUZDWFKLQJWKHWULDORI6RFUDWHV3ODWRORVWDJDLQKLVEHOLHIIRUGHPRFUDF\DQG KHVWDUWHGWRTXHVWLRQHYHU\WKLQJUHODWHGWRVWDWHDQGVRFLDOOLIH+HXQGHUVWRRGWKDW LWZDVGLIILFXOWWRWDNHSDUWLQSXEOLFOLIHDQGUHWDLQRQH¶VLQWHJULW\DQGWKHPRUHKH REVHUYHGWKHROGHUKHEHFDPH1RWKLQJFRXOGEHGRQHZLWKRXWIULHQGVDQGOR\DODV-VRFLDWHVEXWVXFKPHQZHUHQRWHDV\WRILQG%HFDXVHRIWKHFRUUXSWLRQVKHHQGHGE\ JURZLQJGL]]\DWWKHVSHFWDFOHRIXQLYHUVDOFRQIXVLRQ+HWKRXJKWWKDWQRWKLQJFRXOG FXUHWKHLUFRQVWLWXWLRQVEXWDPLUDFXORXVUHIRUPDVVLVWHGE\JRRGOXFN$QGDIWHUWKLV VDGQHVV3ODWRWROGKLVIDPRXVVHQWHQFH³7KHWURXEOHVRIPDQNLQGZLOOQHYHUFHDVH XQWLOHLWKHUWUXHJHQXLQHSKLORVRSKHUVDWWDLQSROLWLFDOSRZHURUWKHUXOHUVRIVWDWHVE\ VRPHGLVSHQVDWLRQRISURYLGHQFHEHFRPHJHQXLQHSKLORVRSKHUV´8_ )RU3ODWRWRNQRZVRPHWKLQJJRRGZDVQRWHQRXJKEXWWKHUHZDVDQHHGWRSUDF-WLFHWKHJRRGQHVVRQDOODVSHFWVRIVRFLDOOLIH3KLORVRSK\ZDVQRWRQO\DWKHRUHWLFDO LVVXHEXWDOVRDSUDFWLFDOYDOXH,WZDVZLVGRPZKHQSUDFWLFHDQGWKHRU\FRPELQHG HDFKRWKHU3ODWR¶VLQWHUHVWDQGSXUVXHRQUXOLQJVWDWHHWKLFODZDQGSROLF\PDGH KLPRQHRIWKHJUHDWHVWV\VWHPDWLFSKLORVRSKHUVRIKLVWRU\+HZDVRIWHQGHVFULEHG DVWKHJUHDWHVWZHVWHUQSKLORVRSKHUDV:KLWHKHDGSRLQWHGRXWWKDWWKHVDIHVWJHQHUDO FKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQRIWKH(XURSHDQSKLORVRSKLFDOWUDGLWLRQLVWKDWLWFRQVLVWVRIDVHULHV RIIRRWQRWHVWR3ODWR9_ _{ *UXEH*0$Plato’s Thought+DFNHWW3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\,QF,QGLDQDSROLVS} 7 _{Ibid.S}

8_{ 3ODWRPhaedrus and Letters VII and VIII3HQJXLQ%RRNV/RQGRQS}

9_{ :KLWHKHDG$1Process and Reality in Essays in Cosmology':6KHUEXUQH'5*ULIILQ}

 $<',1723$/2ö/8 3ODWRWHOOVXVKLPVHOIWKDWKLVFKLHIUHDVRQZDVDQLQWHQVLYHIHHOLQJRIVKDPHOHVW KHVKRXOGILQGKLPVHOIWREHDPHUHEXLOGHURIWKHRULHVZKHQKHZDVFDOOHGXSRQE\ KLVIULHQG'LRQIRUHGXFDWLRQRIWKH\RXQJ'LRQ\VXV$QGVHFRQGWLPHKHVWDUWHGWR LQYROYHZLWKSROLF\ZLWKKRSLQJWRWHDFKJRRGQHVVDQGSKLORVRSK\WR'LRQ\VXVE\ HQFRXUDJLQJ'LRQ%HFDXVHSROLWLFVZDVDVFLHQFHDLPLQJDWPDNLQJWKHFLWL]HQVEHWWHU PHQDQGKHZRXOGQRWKDYHHVFDSHGIURPKLVUHVSRQVLELOLW\$IWHUDOLWWOHELWKHVLWDWLRQ 3ODWRDFFHSWHGWKHLQYLWDWLRQRI'LRQOHIWKLVODQGVDQGZHQWWR6\UDFXVH%\GRLQJ VRKHGLVFKDUJHGWKHFODLPVRIKRVSLWDOLW\DQGSUHVHUYHGKLPVHOIIURPDQ\UHSURDFK IURPSKLORVRSK\ZKLFKZRXOGKDYHVXIIHUHGVKDPHLIKHKDGSOD\HGWKHFRZDUGDQG LQFXUUHG GLVJUDFH E\ VKLUNLQJ KLV GXW\_{ 8QIRUWXQDWHO\ KLV VHFRQG DWWHPSW IDLOHG}

WRR%HFDXVHKHXQGHUVWRRGWKDWSHRSOHOLVWHQRQO\WRZKDWSOHDVHVWKHP3HRSOHZKR FRQVXOWKLPKDYHFRPSOHWHO\DEDQGRQHGWKHWUXHSULQFLSOHVRIJRYHUQPHQWDQGILUPO\ UHIXVHWRUHWXUQWRWKHULJKWWUDFNDQGWHOOWKHLUDGYLVHUWROHWWKHFRQVWLWXWLRQDORQH RQSDLQRIGHDWKDQGWRFRQILQHKLPVHOIWRDGYLVLQJRQWKHTXLFNHVWDQGHDVLHVWZD\ IRUWKHPWRREWDLQWKHSHUPDQHQWVDWLVIDFWLRQRIWKHLUZLVKHVDQGGHVLUHV3ODWRFDOOV WKHSHUVRQZKRJDYHDGYLFHRQWKHVHWHUPVDFRZDUGDQGWKHSHUVRQZKRUHIXVHGLW DEUDYHPDQ_{$IWHUWKLVIDLOXUHEDGSROLWLFDOH[SHULHQFH3ODWRTXHVWLRQHGWKHV\VWHP}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{)RUH[DPSOHRUGLQDU\SHRSOH} GRQRWNQRZZKDWµSLHW\¶RUµMXVWLFH¶LV7KH\FODLPWRNQRZWKHJRRGLQSROLWLFVEXW DVWKHLURSLQLRQVQHYHUVWDQGXSWRH[DPLQDWLRQWKHLUDFWLRQVDUHOLNHO\WREHZURQJ EHLQJEDVHGRQLJQRUDQFH,PSLHW\DQGXQMXVWQHVVVWHPIURPLJQRUDQFHµ*RRGPDQ¶ LVDVDKDSS\PDQEHFDXVHKHLVWHPSHUDWHDQGMXVWQRPDWWHUKHLVELJDQGVWURQJ RUVPDOODQGZHDNRUULFKRUSRRU,IKHLVXQMXVWKHLVDZUHWFKDQGOLYHVDOLIHRI PLVHU\HYHQLIKHGRHVVRPHWKLQJZKDWSHRSOHFRPPRQO\FDOO³JRRG´%HFDXVHWKLQJV RUGLQDU\SHRSOHXVXDOO\FDOOµJRRG¶DUHPLVQDPHG6RFDOOHGHYLOVDUHJRRGIRUWKH XQMXVWDQGVRFDOOHGµJRRGV¶DUHHYLOVIRUWKHZLFNHG_{+HUHZHVHH6RFUDWHV¶UHIOH[LRQV} RQ3ODWR+HKDVQRIDLWKLQLJQRUDQWPDVVHVDQGSD\VQRDWWHQWLRQWRWKHOLIHZLWKLQ WKHP:KHQ6RFUDWHVZDVH[HFXWHGLQ3ODWROHIW$WKHQVDVDGLVDSSRLQWPHQW PDQIURPSROLWLFDODWWHPSWV+HWKRXJKWWKDWDOOVWDWHVKDGQRWEHHQJRYHUQHGZHOO

_{ 3ODWRThe Republicop. cit.S}  _{Ibid.S}

_{ 3ODWRLawsWUDQVOE\7-6DXQGHUV3HQJXLQ%RRNV/RQGRQSS±}  _{Ibid.SS±}

,WZDVWKHUHDVRQIRU3ODWRWRGHDOZLWKSKLORVRSK\DQGWKHQWRVHHNMXVWLFHLQHYHU\ PLQXWHVRIVRFLDOOLIH%XWLQKLVApology, KHH[SODLQVKLVGLVDSSRLQWPHQWZLWKWKHVH ZRUGV³,WLVQHFHVVDU\WRWKDWRQHZKRUHDOO\DQGWUXO\ILJKWVIRUWKHULJKWLIKHLV WRVXUYLYHHYHQIRUDVKRUWWLPHVKDOODFWDVDSULYDWHPDQQRWDVDSXEOLFPDQ´_ ,QKLVStatesmanDQGKLVRepublic3ODWRGHILQHVWKHLGHDOSHUVRQVLGHDOVWDWHVPHQ DQGJLYHVXVWKHLGHDOIRUPRIJRYHUQPHQWWKHLGHDOIRUPRIPDLQFRQVWLWXWLRQV_

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³SKLORVRSKHUNLQJV´DV³WKRVHZKRORYHWKHVLJKWRIWUXWK´ DQGVXSSRUWVWKHLGHDZLWKWKHDQDORJ\RIDFDSWDLQDQGKLVVKLSRUDGRFWRUDQGKLV PHGLFLQH$FFRUGLQJWRKLPVDLOLQJDQGKHDOWKDUHQRWWKLQJVWKDWHYHU\RQHLVTXDOL-ILHGWRSUDFWLFHE\QDWXUH_ ,QDVWDWHWKHUHDUHWKUHHPDLQJURXSVUXOHUVZRUNHUVDQGZDUULRUV$FWXDOO\ WKHVHJURXSVLQ3ODWR¶VSKLORVRSK\DUHXVHGDVDQLPDJHWRLOOXPLQDWHWKHVWDWHRIRQH¶V VRXORUWKHZLOOUHDVRQDQGGHVLUHVFRPELQHGLQWKHKXPDQERG\5XOHUVJRYHUQLQJ WKHVWDWHDUHLQWHOOLJHQWUDWLRQDOVHOIFRQWUROOHGLQORYHZLWKZLVGRPZHOOVXLWHG WRPDNHGHFLVLRQVIRUWKHFRPPXQLW\7KH\UHSUHVHQWWKHKHDG7KHVHFRUUHVSRQGWR WKH³UHDVRQ´SDUWRIWKHVRXODQGDUHYHU\IHZ:RUNHUVDUHSURGXFWLYHOLNHODERUHUV FDUSHQWHUVSOXPEHUVPDVRQVPHUFKDQWVIDUPHUVUDQFKHUVHWF7KH\UHSUHVHQWWKH DEGRPHQDQGFRUUHVSRQGWRWKH³DSSHWLWH´SDUWRIWKHVRXO:DUULRUVRUJXDUGLDQV DUHSURWHFWLYHZKLFKUHSUHVHQWVWKHFKHVW7KH\DUHVWURQJEUDYHDQGDGYHQWXURXV LQWKHDUPHGIRUFHV7KH\FRUUHVSRQGWRWKH³VSLULW´SDUWRIWKHVRXO7KHSULQFLSOHV RI$WKHQLDQGHPRFUDF\DVLWH[LVWHGLQ3ODWR¶VGD\DUHUHMHFWHGDVRQO\DIHZDUH ILWWRUXOH5HDVRQDQGZLVGRPVKRXOGJRYHUQWKHVWDWHQRWUKHWRULFDQGSHUVXDVLRQ ,QDQLGHDOVWDWHSKLORVRSKHUVRXJKWWREHRXUUXOHUVIRU3ODWR)LUVWRIDOOSHR-SOHKDYHDFOHDUYLHZRIWKHLUFKDUDFWHU7KH\GHVLUHDOOZLVGRPQRWRQO\VRPHSDUW RILW7KH\KDYHSDVVLRQWRVHHWKHWUXWKDQGWKHLUDIIHFWLRQVDUHVHWRQWKHUHDOLW\ 7KH\GHVLUHWRNQRZWKHZKROHUHDOLW\OLNHWRNQRZQRWRQO\EHDXWLIXOWKLQJVEXW DOVRWKHEHDXW\LWVHOI_{7KH\DSSUHKHQGWKHHWHUQDODQGXQFKDQJLQJ$OVRWKH\DUH}

_{ 3ODWRApologyThe Dialogues of Plato$0HQWRU%RRN1HZ<RUNGS} _{ 3ODWRStatesmanWUDQVOE\-%6NHPS+DFNHWW3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\,QF,QGLDQDSROLV}

SS±

_{ 3ODWRThe Republic op. cit.SS±}  _{Ibid.SS}

78 $<',1723$/2ö/8

GLVWLQJXLVKHGE\TXLFNQHVVRIXQGHUVWDQGLQJJRRGPHPRU\FRXUDJHDQGJHQHURV-LW\$QGIRU3ODWRSKLORVRSKHUJHQXLQHORYHURIWKHNQRZOHGJHFDQQRWORYHZLVGRP DQG IDOVHKRRG KH FDQQRW IDLO WR VWULYH DIWHU WKH ZKROH RI WUXWK %HFDXVH MXVWLFH LV VXSHULRUWRLQMXVWLFH_{WKDW¶VWRVD\JRRGQHVVLVVXSHULRUWRHYLO3KLORVRSKHUVVHHN}

MXVWLFHQRWLQMXVWLFH7KH\ZDQWJRRGQHVVQRWHYLO+HUHZHVHHWKDWWKHLGHDOVWDWH LVEDVHGRQMXVWLFH$QGMXVWLFHLVWKHVXPRIDOOYLUWXHDQGSKLORVRSKHUVZKRVHHN DOOYLUWXHVLQHDFKPRPHQWRIOLIH$QGWKHPDLQDLPLQFRQVWUXFWLQJDQLGHDOVWDWH ZDV WR ILQG LQ LW MXVWLFH :LVH EUDYH WHPSHUDWH DQG MXVW DUH WKH YLUWXHV RI WKLV LGHDO VWDWH_{ %XW MXVWLFH LV RQO\ SRVVLEOH FRPSHWLWRU RI WKHVH TXDOLWLHV IRU 3ODWR}_

7KXV FLYLO JRYHUQPHQW LV HLWKHU GHPRFUDWLF DULVWRFUDWLF ROLJDUFK\ RU D PRQDUFK\ RUDW\UDQQ\

8QIRUWXQDWHO\WKHLGHDO6WDWHRI3ODWRZKHUHMXVWLFHIORXULVKHVKDVQHYHUH[LVWHG +HZDVDZDUHRIWKLVIDFW%HFDXVHWKHUHZDVDGHFOLQHRIVRFLHW\$QG3ODWRWULHG WRH[SODLQWKLVJUDGXDOGHFOLQHWKURXJKLQWHUPHGLDWHIRUPVRIFRQVWLWXWLRQDQGIRXU W\SHV JRYHUQPHQWV DIWHU KLV LGHDO V\VWHP 7KLV H[SODQDWLRQ LV DOVR DQ LQWHUHVWLQJ DUJXPHQWWRGLVFXVVZKLFKRQHLVEHWWHU7KHPDLQUHDVRQRIUDQNLQJW\SHVRIJRYHUQ-PHQWVLVDOVRWRVKRZWKHGHILFLHQFLHV$WKHQLDQGHPRFUDF\7KHVHGHILFLHQFLHVFDQ EHGHILQHGDVLQKHUHQWFODVVWHQVLRQEOLQGFRPPLWPHQWWROLEHUW\DQGHTXDOLW\DQG LQFRPSHWHQWJRYHUQDQFH$FFRUGLQJWR3ODWRDIWHUDQLGHDOVWDWHDULVWRFUDF\ILUVW W\SHRIJRYHUQPHQWVLVWLPDUFK\RUWLPRFUDF\WKHFRQVWLWXWLRQRI&UHWHDQG6SDUWD RI 3ODWR¶V RZQ SHULRG VHFRQG RQH LV ROLJDUFK\ SOXWRFUDF\ DFRQVWLWXWLRQ IUDXJKW ZLWKPDQ\HYLOVWKLUGRQHLVDQWDJRQLVWGHPRFUDF\DQGGHVSRWLVPZKLFKLVWKRXJKW VRJORULRXVDQGJRHVEH\RQGWKHPDOODVWKHIRXUWKDQGILQDOGLVHDVHRIVRFLHW\7KHUH LV D WUDQVLWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKHP DQG GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ FULWHULRQ RI WKHVH JRYHUQPHQWV LV SXUHMXVWLFHRUSXUHLQMXVWLFHE\DQRWKHUVD\LQJKDSSLQHVVRUPLVHU\WKH\EULQJWR WKHLUFLWL]HQV

7LPRFUDF\ LV D VWDWH LQ ZKLFK WKH DPELWLRXV PDQ¶V ORYH RI KRQRXU_{ ,W LV WKH}

IRUPRIJRYHUQPHQWUXOHGE\ZDUULRUVVHHNLQJYLUWXHVMXVWDVWKHDULVWRFUDWVEXWDOVR SXUVXLQJSRZHUZKLFKFDQOHDGWKHPWRZDUVDQGFRPEDWV)RU3ODWRWKLVLVDNLQGRI JRYHUQPHQWWKDWDULVHVZKHQDULVWRFUDF\VWDUWVWRGHJHQHUDWH2OLJDUFK\LVEDVHGRQ DSURSHUW\TXDOLILFDWLRQZKHUHWKHULFKDUHLQSRZHUDQGWKHSRRUPDQFDQQRWKROG RIILFH0RQH\LVYDOXHGDERYHHYHU\WKLQJLQROLJDUFK\_{7KHULFKRQHVUXOHDQGWKH} SRRUPXVWREH\7KLVDFFRUGLQJWR3ODWRLVDSUREOHP%HFDXVHULFKSHRSOHDUHQRW QHFHVVDULO\HGXFDWHGRUZLVHDQGZKHQWKHSRZHULVLQWKHKDQGVRIQRQYLUWXRXV SHRSOHWKHULFKZLOODWWHPSWWREHFRPHULFKHUDQGWKHSRRUPLJKWEHFRPHHYHQSRRUHU 7KLVLVJHQHUDWLQJUHYROXWLRQV7KHDLPRIOLIHLQDQROLJDUFK\LVWREHFRPHULFKDV SRVVLEOH7KHSRZHURIWKHUXOLQJFODVVLVGXHWRLWVZHDOWK%XWIRU3ODWRDVRFLHW\  _{Ibid.S}  _{Ibid.S}  _{Ibid.S}  _{Ibid.S}  _{Ibid.S}

FDQQRWKROGZHDOWKLQKRQRXUDQGDWWKHVDPHWLPHHVWDEOLVKDSURSHUVHOIFRQWUROLQ LWVFLWL]HQV2QHRUWKHRWKHUPXVWEHVDFULILFHG+DWLQJWKHPHQZKRKDYHDFTXLUHG WKHLU SURSHUW\ DQG FRQVSLULQJ DJDLQVW WKHP DOVR FDXVHV UHYROXWLRQ 7KLV VWDWH IDOOV VLFN DQG VRPHWLPHV FLYLO ZDU EHJLQV ZLWK QR KHOS IURP ZLWKRXW_{ :KHQ WKH SRRU}

ZLQWKHUHVXOWLVDGHPRFUDF\3ODWRERWKGHFULHVWKHUXOHRIWKHPDVVHVDQGUHIXWHV SROLWLFLDQVHOHFWHGE\SRSXODUYRWH+HFODLPHGWKDWZLWKLQ$WKHQLDQGHPRFUDF\RUGL-QDU\SHRSOHGRQRWHOHFWWKHZLVHVWDQGDEOHVWWRRIILFHVRISRZHUEXWWKH\YRWHWRWKH GHPDJRJXHVEHVWYHUVHGLQRUDWLRQDQGUKHWRULF$OVRIRUKLPLWLVEHWWHUWREHUXOHG E\DEDGW\UDQWWKDQEHDEDGGHPRFUDF\,QGHPRFUDF\HYHU\ERG\LVUHVSRQVLEOH IRUDFWLRQVUDWKHUWKDQRQHLQGLYLGXDOFRPPLWWLQJPDQ\EDGGHHGVLQW\UDQQ\7KLV LGHDLVHPSKDVL]HGZLWKLQThe Republic DVDVKLSDQDORJ\

,QVKLSDQDORJ\3ODWROLNHQVWKHVWDWHWRDVKLS$FFRUGLQJWRKLPWKHVKLSRI VWDWHQHHGVH[SHUWJRYHUQRUVDWWKHKHOP7KHVHJRYHUQRUVVKRXOGEHZHOOLQIRUPHG DERXWMXVWLFHPRUDOLW\HFRQRP\ODZHWF,JQRUDQWJRYHUQRUVFDQEHGLVDVWHUVVWDWHV $WWKHVDPHWLPHRUGLQDU\SHRSOHFDQQRWUXQWKHVKLSEHFDXVHRIWKHLULJQRUDQFH 7KH\GRQRWNQRZKRZWRUXQWKHVKLSRIVWDWH7KH\DUHQRWIDPLOLDUHQRXJKZLWK SROLWLFVODZHFRQRPLFVHWF7KH\DUHYHU\DPELWLRXVWRUXQEXWWKH\DUHQRWFDSDEOH RILW$OVRLQWKHLULJQRUDQFHWKH\WHQGWRYRWHIRUSROLWLFLDQVZKRGHFHLYHWKHPZLWK XQWUXWKIXOWDON ,Q3ODWR¶VVKLSDQDORJ\GHPRFUDF\WKHUXOHRIWKHSHRSOHLVUHSUHVHQWHGE\WKH FDSWDLQRIWKHVKLS7KHGHPRFUDWLFSROLWLFLDQVDUHWKHFUHZ7KHWUXHSKLORVRSKHU LV WKH VKLS¶V H[SHUW QDYLJDWRU DQG GHPRFUDWLF SROLWLFLDQV DUH GHFULHG DV GLVKRQHVW ³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{Ibid.S}

 $<',1723$/2ö/8

SUDFWLFHWKHVNLOOWRNHHSFRQWURORIWKHKHOPZKHWKHUVRPHRIWKHPOLNHLWRUQRW ,IDVKLSZHUHPDQDJHGLQWKDWZD\ZRXOGQRWWKRVHRQERDUGEHOLNHO\WRFDOOWKH H[SHUWLQQDYLJDWLRQDPHUHVWDUJD]HUZKRVSHQWKLVWLPHLQLGOHWDONDQGZDVXVHOHVV WRWKHP´_

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 RIROLJDUFK\EURXJKWXSXQGHUKLVIDWKHU¶VH\HDQGKLVIDWKHU¶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{$QGWKLVLVWKHVHHGIURPZKLFKVSULQJVGHVSRWLVP)RU3ODWRWKH} VDPHGLVHDVHWKDWGHVWUR\HGROLJDUFK\HQVODYHVGHPRFUDF\%HFDXVHDQ\H[FHVVEULQJV DERXWDQHTXDOO\YLROHQWUHDFWLRQ7KHRQO\RXWFRPHRIWRRPXFKIUHHGRPLVOLNHO\WR EHH[FHVVLYHVXEMHFWLRQ'HPRFUDWLFVWDWHIDOOVXQGHUWKHLQIOXHQFHRIXQSULQFLSOHG  _{Ibid.±S}  _{Ibid.S}  _{Ibid.S}

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{7KHWKLUGFODVVLVµSHRSOH¶FRPSULVLQJ} DOOWKHSHDVDQWU\ZKRZRUNRQWKHLURZQIDUPVZLWKIHZSRVVHVVLRQVDQGQRLQWHUHVW LQSROLWLFV7KLVFODVVLVWKHODUJHVWRQHLQGHPRFUDF\DQGZKHQRQFHDVVHPEOHGLWV SRZHULVVXSUHPH7KHUHLVFRQVWDQWFRQIOLFWEHWZHHQRUGLQDU\SHRSOHDQGULFKSHRSOH $QGIURPWKLVFRQIOLFWDFFRUGLQJWR3ODWRWKHSHRSOH¶VFKDPSLRQWUDQVIRUPVLQWR DGHVSRW,QWKHHDUO\GD\VGHVSRWKDVDVPLOHDQGDJUHHWLQJIRUHYHU\RQHKHPHHWV GLVFODLPVDQ\DEVROXWHSRZHUPDNHVODUJHSURPLVHVWRKLVIULHQGVDQGWRWKHSXEOLF %XWDVVRRQDVKHKDVGLVHPEDUUDVVHGKLPVHOIRIKLVH[LOHGHQHPLHVE\FRPLQJWR WHUPVZLWKVRPHDQGGHVWUR\LQJRWKHUVKHEHJLQVVWLUULQJXSSURYRNHVRQHZDUDIWHU DQRWKHULQRUGHUWKDWWKHSHRSOHPD\IHHOWKHLUQHHGRIDOHDGHU_ 7KHWHUPRIGHPRFUDF\LVDOLWWOHELWDPELJXRXV,WFRYHUVDZLGHYDULHW\RIPHDQ-LQJV %HFDXVH RI 3ODWR¶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±WKDWLVWRVD\LQPRVWFDVHVQRWDW DOO$QG3RSSHUVXJJHVWVWKHWHUP³GHPRFUDF\´DVDVKRUWKDQGODEHOIRUDJRYHUQ-PHQW RI WKH ILUVW W\SH $QG WKH WHUP ³W\UDQQ\´ RU ³GLFWDWRUVKLS´ IRU WKH VHFRQG_

2QWKHRWKHUKDQGZHNQRZWKDW3ODWRH[SHULHQFHGGHPRFUDF\DW$WKHQVLQWKHODVW \HDUVRI*UHDW3HORSRQQHVLDQ:DU7KHUXWKOHVVLPSHULDOLVPRI$WKHQLDQZDUSROLF\ DQGWKHFXOWXUDOGHFD\ZKLFKIDOORZHGWKHZDUPXVWEHWUDFHGEDFNWRFHUWDLQVR-SKLVWLFPRYHPHQWVZKLFKEHJDQLQWKHDJHRI3HULFOHV3ODWRLGHQWLILHGWKLVIRUPRI GHPRFUDF\ZLWKLUUHVSRQVLEOHDQDUFK\DQGFRQGHPQHGLWERWKLQLWVHOIDQGLQEHLQJ  _{Ibid.S}  _{Ibid.SS±}  _{Ibid.S}

 $<',1723$/2ö/8 WKHPRWKHURIW\UDQQ\_{+HKHOGWKDWWKHVNHSWLFDOPDWHULDOLVWLFYLHZVRIWKHVRSKLVWV} DQGUKHWRULFLDQVRIWKH3HULFOHDQ$JHVRZHGWKHVHHGVRI$WKHQLDQGHJHQHUDWLRQ$OO H[LVWLQJVWDWHVDQGSDUWLHVZHUHGHJHQHUDWH+HZDVELWWHUO\RSSRVHGWRWKHUXWKOHVV LPSHULDOLVPDQGPLOLWDULVPRIODWHU$WKHQLDQSROLF\_{,QIDFWKHZDVWU\LQJWRPDNH} FOHDUWKHLQMXVWLFHDQGLQHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIGHPRFUDF\+HFODLPHGWKDWRXWULJKWOLEHUW\ DQGSROLWLFDOHTXDOLW\GLGQRWJXDUDQWHHWUXHKDSSLQHVVDQGMXVWLFHERWKIRUWKHPDMRU-LW\RIFLWL]HQVDQGIRUWKHVWDWHLWVHOI %HVLGHWKHUHDVRQVRIVHHNLQJMXVWLFHDQGKDSSLQHVVIRUDOOIRUSRRURUULFKZH FDQVD\WKDWVRPHRI3ODWR¶VDUJXPHQWVGRQRWDSSO\YHU\ZHOOWRGHPRFUDF\WRGD\ )RUH[DPSOHKLVVHYHUHDFFXVDWLRQVDJDLQVWSROLWLFLDQVDQGPDVVHVRIKLVRZQWLPH DUHQRWYDOLGIRUWRGD\ :HFDQQRWVD\WKDWSROLWLFLDQVDUHGHPDJRJXHVRUPDVVHVDUHLJQRUDQWWRGD\$QG ZHFDQQRWSXWIRUZDUGWKDWWKH\GRQRWNQRZZKDWMXVWLFHRULQMXVWLFHLV$OVRKLV DUJXPHQWWKDWRUGLQDU\SHRSOHWKHGHPRVZLOOFRQWUROHYHU\WKLQJRULPSRVHWKHLU YLHZVRQWRRWKHUVLVDOVRGLVSXWDEOH7KHUHDUHVRPDQ\GLIIHUHQWYLHZSRLQWVRQVR PDQ\ GLIIHUHQW LVVXHV WKDW PRVW SHRSOH¶V RSLQLRQV WRGD\ DUH VKDSHG E\ WKHLU FORVH UHODWLYHVDQGIULHQGVDQGQRWWKHGHPRVEHFDXVHWKHUHDUHWRRPDQ\GLIIHUHQWYLHZ SRLQWV ,I GHPRFUDF\ LV GHILQHG H[FOXVLYHO\ LQ WHUPV RI PDMRULW\ DVVHQW QR PDWWHU ZKDWLVDVVHQWHGWRWKHQPDVVW\UDQQ\WKHPRVWDZIXONLQGPXVWEHUHJDUGHGDV HVVHQWLDOO\GHPRFUDWLF%XWWKLVLVDQLPSRVVLEOHFRQFOXVLRQ_

%,%/,2*5$3+<

$ULVWRWOHThe PoliticsWUDQVOE\7$6LQFODLU3HQJXLQ%RRNV/RQGRQ *UXEH*0$Plato’s Thought+DFNHWW3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\,QGLDQDSROLV

/DHUWLXV'LRJHQHVLives of Eminent Philosophers³3ODWR´%RRN,,,WUDQVOE\5'+LFNV +DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV/RQGRQ

3ODWRThe RepublicWUDQVOE\'HVPRQG/HH3HQJXLQ%RRNV/RQGRQ 3ODWRApologyThe Dialogues of Plato$0HQWRU%RRN1HZ<RUN 3ODWR LawsWUDQVOE\7-6DXQGHUV3HQJXLQ%RRNV/RQGRQ

3ODWRPhaedrus and Letters VII and VIIIWUDQVOE\:+DPLOWRQ3HQJXLQ%RRNV/RQGRQ 3ODWRThe RepublicWUDQVOE\)&&RUQIRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV/RQGRQ

3ODWRStatesmanWUDQVOE\-%6NHPS+DFNHWW3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\,QF,QGLDQDSROLV 3RSSHU.5The Open Society and Its Enemies5RXWOHGJH .HJDQ3DXO/RQGRQ 5\OH*³3ODWR´The Encyclopedia of Philosophy3(GZDUGVHG0DFPLOODQ1HZ<RUN :KLWHKHDG$1Process and Reality in Essays in Cosmology':6KHUEXUQH'5*ULIILQ

HG7KH)UHH3UHVV1HZ<RUN

:LOG -  Plato as an Enemy of Democracy: A Rejoinder Plato: Totalitarian or Democrat? 3UHQWLFH+DOO,QF(QJOHZRRG&OLIIV1-86$

_{ :LOG-Plato as an Enemy of Democracy: A RejoinderPlato: Totalitarian or Democrat?,}

3UHQWLFH+DOO,QF(QJOHZRRG&OLIIV1-86$S

 _{Ibid.S}  _{Ibid.S}

%,2*5$3+<

Aydin Topaloglu ±DVVRFLDWHSURIHVVRUERUQLQ0DODW\D±7XUNH\VWXG-LHGWKHRORJ\DQGSKLORVRSK\DW(\OO8QLYHUVLW\,]PLU±7XUNH\±JRW 0$RQAl-Farabi’s and St. Thomas Aquinas’s God3K'RQ the Problem of

Atheism in the Contemporary British Philosophy EHFDPHDVVRFLDWHSURIHVVRU

ZLWKWKHWKHVLVHQWLWOHGTheism: a Conceptual Analysis+HPDGHUHVHDUFKLQ (J\SW&DLUR8QLY±DQGLQ(QJODQG/RQGRQ8QLY±LQ5XVVLD 0RVFRZ8QLYZRUNHGDVD9LFH5HFWRURIWKH+LJKHU,VODPLF,QVWLWXWHRI6RILD %XOJDULD±+HZDVDUHVHDUFKIHOORZIRUWKH&HQWUHIRU,VODPLF6WXGLHV ,6$0,VWDQEXO±7XUNH\DWWKH3KLORVRSK\ (WKLFV'HSDUWPHQW±+H KDVEHHQZRUNLQJDVDSKLORVRSK\OHFWXUHUDW,VWDQEXO0D\LV8QLYHUVLW\IRUWKUHH \HDUV+LVWRU\RI3KLORVRSK\3KLORVRSK\RI5HOLJLRQ,VODPLF3KLORVRSK\3ROLWLFVDQG (WKLFVDUHDPRQJKLVPDLQLQWHUHVWV(PDLODGGUHVVD\GLQ#\DKRRFRP