678',$5266,&$3261$1,(16,$YRO;;;9,,,SS,6%1,661 $GDP0LFNLHZLF]8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV3R]QDę
:63Ðâ&=(61(1$=:,6.$526<-6.,(32&+2'=(1,$32/6.,(*2 5866,$16851$0(62)32/,6+25,*,17+$7$5(86(' 12:$'$<6 0$5,$1:Ð-72:,&=$%675$&77KH DUWLFOH SUHVHQWV DQ DQDO\VLV RI VXUQDPHV REWDLQHG IURP 5XVVLDQ WHOHSKRQHGLUHFWRULHV7KHDXWKRUGLVFXVVHVWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWSKRQHWLFDQGPRUSKRORJLFDO IHDWXUHVRI5XVVLDQVXUQDPHVRI3ROLVKRULJLQLGHQWLILHVWKHLUW\SHVDQGGUDZVXSDOLVW RIPRVWIUHTXHQWO\XVHGVXUQDPHV 0DULDQ:yMWRZLF]8QLZHUV\WHWLP$GDPD0LFNLHZLF]DZ3R]QDQLX3R]QDę²3ROVND
:]DVRELHZVSyãF]HVQ\FKQD]ZLVNXİ\ZDQ\FKZ5RVMLPRİQDZ\Uyİ QLþ SRG Z]JOčGHP JHQHW\F]Q\P GZLH JUXS\ SLHUZV]Ĉ WZRU]Ĉ QD]ZLVND URG]LPHGUXJĈ²QD]ZLVNDREFHJRSRFKRG]HQLD1D]ZLVNDSLHUZV]HMJUX S\]QDF]QLHSU]HZDİDMĈLORĤFLRZRQDGQD]ZLVNDPLGUXJLHMJUXS\LGHF\GX MĈRMč]\NRZ\PFKDUDNWHU]HRUD]RGUčEQRĤFLHWQLF]QHMWHMNDWHJRULLQD]HZ QLF]HM %DGDQLD QDG VWDW\VW\NĈ QD]ZLVN URV\MVNLFK QLH RVLĈJQčã\ MHV]F]H WDNLHJR SR]LRPX UR]ZRMRZHJR NWyU\ SR]ZROLãE\ QD GRNãDGQH RNUHĤOHQLH SURSRUFMLZMDNLHMSR]RVWDMĈQD]ZLVNDURG]LPHGRQD]ZLVNREF\FKLXVWDOH QLH OLF]E\ QD]ZLVN SU]HMčW\FK ]LQQ\FKV\VWHPyZDQWURSRQLPLF]Q\FK3H ZLHQSRJOĈGQDWčNZHVWLčGDMĈ]HVWDZLHQLDOLF]ERZH]DPLHV]F]RQHZSUDF\ :LNWRUD :DVF]HQNL SRĤZLčFRQHM VWUXNWXU]H PRUIHPRZHM QD]ZLVN URV\M VNLFK:HGãXJWHJREDGDF]DQD]ZLVND]URV\MVNLPLZ\NãDGQLNDPLPRUIROR JLF]Q\PLZW\PIRUPDFMHK\EU\GDOQHRGSRGVWDZREFRMč]\F]Q\FKVWDQRZLĈ MHGQRVWHNEDGDQHJR]ELRUXDQD]ZLVNDREFHEH]Z\NãDGQL NyZPRUIRORJLF]Q\FK²MHGQRVWHN:ĤUyGQD]ZLVNVWUXNWXUDO QLHURV\MVNLFKURG]LP\FKLK\EU\GDOQ\FKSU]HZDİDMĈIRUPDFMH]DNRęF]RQH QD ȜȐɠȓȐ MHGQRVWNLF]\OLLQDȖțɠȩțF]\OL ________________ ǰǰȎȟȥȓțȘȜǼȚȜȞȢȓȚțȜȗȟȠȞȡȘȠȡȞȓȞȡȟȟȘȖȣȢȎȚȖșȖȗÅ5RPDQRVODYLFDµ %XFXUHüWLQU;9,V²$UW\NXã]DZLHUDDQDOL]čRNRãRQD]ZLVN]HVãRZ QLND 0RUWRQD %HQVRQD 'LFWLRQDU\ RI 5XVVLDQ 3HUVRQDO 1DPHV :LWK D *XLGH WR 6WUHVV DQG 0RUSKRORJ\3KLODGHOSKLD: REOLF]HQLDFK SURFHQWRZ\FK Z\NRU]\VWDQR SRGDQH Z Z\PLHQLRQ\P DUW\NXOH
OLF]E\MHGQRVWHNQD]ZLVNSURFHQWREOLF]RQRRGRJyOQHMOLF]E\QD]ZLVN]Z\NãDGQLND PLPRUIRORJLF]Q\PL
Ǻ:yMWRZLF] =QDF]QLH PQLHM MHVW QD]ZLVN URG]LP\FK SRFKRG]ĈF\FK RG SU]\PLRWQLNyZ MDNRĤFLRZ\FKLZ]JOčGQ\FK1D]ZLVNDQDȟȘȖȗɠȤȘȖȗȟȘȜȗɠȤȘȜȗVWDQR ZLĈQDWRPLDVWSR]RVWDãH]DNRęF]RQHQDȩȗȖȗȜȗLU]DGNLH IRUPDFMHQDȖȣɠȩȣȎȑȜȜȐȜ²MHGQRVWHN-HĤOL]DãRİ\þİHDQDOL ]RZDQ\ ]ELyU QLH]E\W GXİ\ L Z ]QDF]Q\P VWRSQLX SU]\SDGNRZ\ RG ]ZLHUFLHGODZPLDUčGRNãDGQLHVWRVXQNLZ]DNUHVLHW\SyZVWUXNWXUDOQ\FK ZFDã\P]ELRU]HQD]ZLVNURV\MVNLFKLİHQD]ZLVNDEH]Z\NãDGQLNyZPRU IRORJLF]Q\FKVĈQD]ZLVNDPLREFHJRSRFKRG]HQLDWR]DUD]HPQDOHİ\SU]\ MĈþİH]DVyEW\FKRVWDWQLFKQLHSU]HNUDF]DFDãHJR]ELRUX
1D]ZLVNRPREF\PVSRURXZDJLSRĤZLčFLãZVZRMHMNVLĈİFH%RU\V8Q EHJDXQ $XWRU ]DQDOL]RZDã RNRãR QD]ZLVN SRFKRG]HQLD SROVNLHJR
SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP SRG NĈWHP W\SRZ\FK FHFK IRQHW\F]Q\FK Z\UyİQLDMĈ F\FKMHVSRĤUyGLQQ\FKQD]ZLVNVãRZLDęVNLFK-HVWWRMHG\QHV]HUV]HRSUD FRZDQLHRPDZLDQ\FKWXQD]ZLVNZOLWHUDWXU]HRQRPDVW\F]QHM 0DWHULDãGREDGDęQDGQD]ZLVNDPLSROVNLHJRSRFKRG]HQLD]DF]HUSQLč WR]GZyFKOLVWIUHNZHQF\MQ\FKLVSLVXQD]ZLVNDERQHQWyZWHOHIRQLF]Q\FK GZyFKPLDVWURV\MVNLFK3LHUZV]ĈOLVWčIUHNZHQF\MQĈVSRU]ĈG]RQRQDSRG VWDZLHLQWHUQHWRZHMNVLĈİNLWHOHIRQLF]QHM]DZLHUDMĈFHMQD]ZLVNDDERQHQWyZ ]SRQDGZLHONLFKPLDVWURV\MVNLFK3RRGSRZLHGQLPRSUDFRZDQLXX]\ VNDQR ]ELyU QDMF]čVWV]\FK QD]ZLVN R RNXUHQFML RG GR MHGQRVWHN 'UXJĈ OLVWč REHMPXMĈFĈ UyZQLHİ QDMF]čVWV]\FK QD]ZLVN SREUDQR]]DVREyZLQWHUQHWRZ\FK1D]ZLVNDSROVNLHJRSRFKRG]HQLDHNV FHUSRZDQRWDNİH]NVLĈİNLWHOHIRQLF]QHM-DURVãDZLDQDG:RãJĈ]DZLHUDMĈFHM RNRãR QD]ZLVN L RGOHJãHJR RG WHJR PLDVWD R NP 7RPVND ZNWyUHM]QDMGXMHVLčRNRãRQD]ZLVN3LHUZV]ĈOLVWčSRWUDNWRZDQRMD NRSRGVWDZRZHĮUyGãRQDWRPLDVWSR]RVWDãHPDWHULDã\MDNRMHJRX]XSHãQLH QLH:\EUDQRãĈF]QLHQD]ZLVN7HVDPHQD]ZLVNDPčİF]\]QLNRELHWVX PRZDQRDRELHIRUP\UHSUH]HQWXMHZ]HEUDQ\PPDWHULDOHQD]ZLVNRPčVNLH 'R QD]ZLVN URV\MVNLFK SRFKRG]HQLD SROVNLHJR ]DOLF]RQR MH QD SRGVWDZLH
________________ %28QEHJDXQ5XVVLDQ6XUQDPHV2[IRUGV²WãXPURVǯǼȁțȏȓ ȑȎȡțǾȡȟȟȘȖȓȢȎȚȖșȖȖǺȜȟȘȐȎV² ȁțȖȐȓȞȟȎșȪțȩȗȠȓșȓȢȜțțȩȗȟȝȞȎȐȜȥțȖȘǿǻDZ0HJD&RQWDFWVȐȓȞȟȖȭȜȠ /LVWčÅȟȎȚȩȣȥȎȟȠȜȠțȩȣȞȡȟȟȘȖȣȢȎȚȖșȖȗµVSRU]ĈG]RQĈZUDPDFKSUR
MHNWX EDGDZF]HJR ÅǾȡȟȟȘȖȗ ȑȓțȜȢȜțȒµ ]DPLHV]F]RQR QD VWURQLH ZZZJHQRIRQGUX 3U]\ QD]ZLVNX QLH SRGDQR F]čVWRĤFL ZVND]DQR MHG\QLH MHJR NROHMQH PLHMVFH QD OLĤFLH %UDNXMHLQIRUPDFMLGRW\F]ĈFHM]ELRUXNWyU\VWDãVLčSRGVWDZĈWHMOLVW\ ǿȝȖȟȜȘȎȏȜțȓțȠȜȐȍȞȜȟșȎȐȟȘȜȗȑȜȞȜȒȟȘȜȗȠȓșȓȢȜțțȜȗȟȓȠȖȝȜȟȜȟȠȜȭțȖȬțȎȭțȐȎ Ȟȭ ȑ ǾȎȕȒȓș ,,, ǸȐȎȞȠȖȞțȩȓ ȠȓșȓȢȜțȩ ȖțȒȖȐȖȒȡȎșȪțȜȑȜ ȝȜșȪȕȜȐȎțȖȭ ȍȞȜȟșȎȐșȪ V²ȀȓșȓȢȜțțȩȗȟȝȞȎȐȜȥțȖȘȑȀȜȚȟȘǿȝȖȟȜȘȎȏȜțȓțȠȜȐȝȜȟȜȟȠȜȭțȖȬțȎȚȎȞ ȠȎ ȑ ǿȝȖȟȜȘ ȘȐȎȞȠȖȞțȩȣ ȠȓșȓȢȜțȜȐ ȖțȒȖȐȖȒȡȎșȪțȜȑȜ ȝȜșȪȕȜȐȎțȖȭ ȀȜȚȟȘ V²
:VSyãF]HVQHQD]ZLVNDURV\MVNLHSRFKRG]HQLDSROVNLHJR
FHFK IRQHW\F]Q\FK ZãDĤFLZ\FK QD]ZLVNRP SROVNLP VSRVREX RGGDZDQLD LFK Z Mč]\NX URV\MVNLP W\SRZ\FK FHFK PRUIRORJLF]Q\FK L NU\WHULXP OHN V\NDOQHJRSR]ZDODMĈFHJRRGQLHĤþNRQNUHWQHQD]ZLVNRGR]ELRUXQD]ZLVN SROVNLFK &HFKĈZ\UyİQLDMĈFĈQD]ZLVNDSROVNLHVĈVDPRJãRVNLQRVRZH]DVWčSR ZDQHZMč]\NXURV\MVNLPSU]H]SRãĈF]HQLHVDPRJãRVNLXVWQHM]HVSyãJãRVNĈ QRVRZĈ6DPRJãRVNDčMHVW]DVWčSRZDQDSU]H]ȓȚSU]HGVSyãJãRVNĈZDUJR ZĈZQDZLDVDFKSRGDQRRGSRZLHGQLHQD]ZLVNRSROVNLHQSDZȓȚȏȖȤȘȖȗ *čELFNLDZșȓȚȏȖȤȘȖȗ*ãčELFNLDzȓȚȏțȜȐȓȤȘȖȗ'čEQRZLHFNLDzȓȚȏȜȐȟȘȖȗ 'čERZVNL ǵȓȚȏșȓȐȟȘȖȗ =LčEOHZVNL ǿȠȓȚȝȓțȪ 6WčSLHę ȀȞȓȚȏȎȥ 7Uč EDF]dzȟȠȞȓȚȟȘȖȗȍȟȠȞȓȚȟȘȖȗ]]DQLNLHPPLčG]\VSyãJãRVNRZHJRȏ-DVWU]čE VNL3U]HGLQQ\PLVSyãJãRVNDPLMHVW]DVWčSRZDQDSU]H]SRãĈF]HQLHȓțQS ǰȓțȔȖȘ:čİ\N²WDNİHQD]ZDKHUERZDDZȓțȦșȖȤȘȖȗ*čĤOLFNLǿȐȓțȠȖȤ ȘȖȗģZLčFLFNLǿȓțȒȓȤȘȖȗ6čGHFNL6DPRJãRVNDĈMHVW]DVWčSRZDQDSU]H] ȜțQSǯȜțȘ%ĈNǽȖȜțȠȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ3LĈWNRZVNLȆșȮțȟȘȖȗģOĈVNLOXEWHİ SU]H]ȜȚSU]HGVSyãJãRVNĈZDUJRZĈQSDzȜȚȏȞȜȐȟȘȖȗ'ĈEURZVNL :QD]ZLVNDFKSRFKRG]HQLDSROVNLHJRU]MHVWRGGDZDQH]Z\NOHSU]H] URV\MVNLHSRãĈF]HQLHVSyãJãRVHNȞȔQSǰȓȞȔȏȖȤȘȖȗ:LHU]ELFNLDZȞȔȖȏȜȐ ȟȘȖȗ *U]\ERZVNL ǵȎȘȞȔȓȐȟȘȖȗ =DNU]HZVNL ǸȜȏȞȔȖȤȘȖȗ .REU]\FNL ǸȜțȎȞȔȓȐȟȘȖȗ .RQDU]HZVNL ǼȞȔȓȣȜȐȟȘȖȗ 2U]HFKRZVNL ǽȞȔȓȐȎșȪȟȘȖȗ 3U]HZDOVNLǽȞȔȖȏȜȞȟȘȖȗ3U]\ERUVNLȃȞȔȎțȜȐȟȘȖȗ&KU]DQRZVNL5]D G]LHM VSRW\ND VLč QD PLHMVFX U] VSyãJãRVNč Ȕ OXE MHM EH]GĮZLčF]Q\ RGSR ZLHGQLNȦQSDzȜȏȔȖțȟȘȖȗ'REU]\ęVNLǵȎȘȦȓȐȟȘȖȗ=DNU]HZVNL
1D SROVNLH SRFKRG]HQLH QD]ZLVND ZVND]XMĈ QLHNWyUH SRãĈF]HQLD JãR VHNNWyUHZRGUčEQ\VSRVyEUR]ZLQčã\VLčZURV\MVNLPQSUyyUǰȞȡȏ șȓȐȖȥ:UyEOHZLF]ǰȞȡȏșȓȐȟȘȖȗ:UyEOHZVNLDZȡȞȎ*yUDDZȡȞȎșȪ*yUDO DZȡȞȟȘȖȗ*yUVNL ǹȖȟȜȑȡȞȟȘȖȗ /LVRJyUVNL ǸȞȡșȖȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ .UyOLNRZVNL SRãĈF]HQLHGOȆȖȒșȜȐȟȘȖȗ6]\GãRZVNLãXDzșȡȑȜȏȜȞȟȘȖȗ'ãXJRERUVNL -HĤOLFKRG]LRFHFK\PRUIRORJLF]QHWRQDSROVNLHSRFKRG]HQLHQD]ZLVND URV\MVNLHJRPRJĈZVND]\ZDþW\SRZHVXILNV\QSVNLFNLG]NLǴȎȏȟȘȖȗ įDEVNLǵȎȐȎȤȘȖȗ=DZDG]NLǿȠȎȐȖȤȘȖȗ6WDZLFNLǼȟȖțȟȘȖȗ2VLęVNL ǽȡȣȎșȪȟȘȖȗ3XFKDOVNLRZLF]ɠHZLF]ǹȡȘȎȦȓȐȖȥâXNV]HZLF]ȌȕȓȢȜȐȖȥ -y]HIRZLF]DNɠ·DNǰȜȕțȭȘ:RĮQLDNȍȘȡȏȥȎȘ-DNXEF]DNLNɠ\Nǰȓț ȔȖȘ:čİ\NǽȎȐșȖȘ3DZOLNLWS .U\WHULXPOHNV\NDOQHRGJU\ZDLVWRWQĈUROčSU]\LGHQW\ILNDFMLQD]ZLVN SROVNLHJRSRFKRG]HQLDUyZQ\FKZVZHMEXGRZLHZ\UD]RPSRVSROLW\POXE QD]ZRPZãDVQ\PLQQ\FKNDWHJRULLQSLPLRQRPRVRERZ\POXEQD]ZRP JHRJUDILF]Q\P 8PRİOLZLD RQR ]DOLF]HQLH GR RPDZLDQHM JUXS\ QD]ZLVN WDNLFKSROVNLFKQD]ZLVNRGDSHODW\ZQ\FKMDNQSǸșȓȝȎȥ.OHSDF]ǸȜȑȡȠ .RJXWǸȞȡȘ.UXNǽȖȟȎȞȓȘ3LVDUHNǿșȓȒȪ6OHGĮǿȠȓșȪȚȎȣ6WHOPDFK OXEQD]ZLVNSRFKRG]ĈF\FKRGLPLRQQSǹȡȘȎȦâXNDV]ǯȎșȪȤȓȞ%DOFHU %DOWD]DUȁȞȏȎț8UEDQLWS3RVãXJLZDQLHVLčZ\ãĈF]QLHMHGQ\PNU\WHULXP
Ǻ:yMWRZLF]
QLH]DZV]HSU]\QRVLZãDĤFLZ\UH]XOWDW=QDF]QLHOHSV]HZ\QLNLGDMH]DVWR VRZDQLH ]HVSRãX Z\PLHQLRQ\FKNU\WHULyZ3HZQHWUXGQRĤFLSRMDZLDMĈVLč Z Z\SDGNX QD]ZLVN R SRGREQHM VWUXNWXU]H L ] W\P VDP\P IRUPDQWHP IXQNFMRQXMĈF\FK Z SROVNLP ELDãRUXVNLP L XNUDLęVNLP %LRUĈF SRG XZDJč KLVWRU\F]QH]ZLĈ]NLVĈVLDGXMĈF\FK]HVREĈQDURGyZQLHãDWZRUR]VWU]\JQĈþ F]\ QD]ZLVNR ǹȡȘȎȦȓȐȖȥ PD SROVNLH F]\ XNUDLęVNLHSRFKRG]HQLHDȀȜȚȎ ȦȓȐȖȥMHVWJHQHW\F]QLHQD]ZLVNLHPSROVNLPF]\WHİELDãRUXVNLP'RQD]ZLVN SROVNLFK PRİQD MH ]DOLF]\þ ]H Z]JOčGX QD SRGVWDZč RG NWyUHM MH XWZR U]RQR ,PLRQD âXNDV] L 7RPDV] QDOHİĈ ERZLHP GR ]DVREX SROVNLFK LPLRQ FKU]HĤFLMDęVNLFK 7HQ VDP SUREOHP GRW\F]\ VSRUHM OLF]E\ QD]ZLVN ] IRU PDQWHPȟȘȖȗɠȤȘȖȗUR]V]HU]RQ\PQLHNLHG\PRUIHPDPLȜȐɠȓȐOXEȖț NWyUHPDMĈZSRGVWDZLHZ\UD]Z\VWčSXMĈF\ZMč]\NXSROVNLPLURV\MVNLP QS ǯȜȏȞȜȐȟȘȖȗ %REURZVNL ǯȩȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ %\NRZVNL ǺȎșȖțȜȐȟȘȖȗ 0DOL QRZVNLǺȎȟșȜȐȟȘȖȗ0DVãRZVNLǿȜȟțȜȐȟȘȖȗ6RVQRZVNLǿșȖȐȖțȟȘȖȗģOL ZLęVNLȅȎȗȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ&]DMNRZVNLLWS:ZLčNV]RĤFLVĈWRQD]ZLVNDNWyU\FK SRGVWDZRPPRİQDSU]\SRU]ĈGNRZDþQD]Z\PLHMVFRZHDVDPHQD]ZLVND RGSRZLHGQLPSU]\PLRWQLNRPRGPLHMVFRZ\PQSǰȩȟȜȤȘȖȗǰȩȟȜȤȘǰȩ ȟȜȘȜȓ²:\VRFNL:\VRND:\VRNLHǸȜȕșȜȐȟȘȖȗǸȜȕșȜȐǸȜȕșȜȐȜ².R] ãRZVNL .R]ãRZR .R]ãyZ ǼȞșȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǼȞȓș ² 2UãRZVNL 2UãRZR 2UãyZ ǿȜȘȜșȜȐȟȘȖȗǿȜȘȜșǿȜȘȜșȜȐǿȜȘȜșȜȐȜ²6RNRãRZVNL6RNRãRZR6RNRãyZ 6RNRã\LWS1LHFRPQLHMV]ĈJUXSčVWDQRZLĈQD]ZLVNDPDMĈFHZSRGVWDZLH WRVDPRLPLčZREXMč]\NDFKQSǺȖșȜȟșȎȐȟȘȖȗǺȖșȜȟșȎȐ²0LãRVãDZVNL 0LãRVãDZǿȠȎțȖȟșȎȐȟȘȖȗǿȠȎțȖȟșȎȐ²6WDQLVãDZVNL6WDQLVãDZǺȎȞȘȜȐ ȟȘȖȗǺȎȞȘ²0DUNRZVNL0DUHNǽȎȐșȜȐȟȘȖȗǽȎȐȓș²3DZãRZVNL3DZHãLWS :DQWURSRQLPLLSROVNLHMQD]ZLVND]SU]\URVWNLHPVNLLMHJR]ãRİRQ\PL ZDULDQWDPL RZVNLɠHZVNL LęVNL VĈ Z GXİ\P VWRSQLX IRUPDFMDPL RGPLHM VFRZ\PL QRWRZDQ\PL MXİ Z ;,9 ZLHNX /LF]QĈ JUXSč ZĤUyG QLFK VWDQR ZLĈ QD]ZLVND XWZRU]RQH RG QD]Z Z\NRQDZFyZ ]DZRGX W\SX 0ã\QDUVNL 3LHNDUVNL6]NODUVNLRUD]QD]ZLVNDRGSU]H]ZLVNQD]ZLVNNWyUHQLHXWUDFLã\ IXQNFMLFKDUDNWHU\]XMĈFHM7HRVWDWQLH]QDQHMXİE\ã\Z;9,ZLHNXD]DF]čã\ VLčV]HU]\þZ;9,,L;9,,,ZLHNXNLHG\UR]SRF]ĈãVLčSURFHVÅXV]ODFKFDQLDµ QD]ZLVNPLHV]F]DęVNLFKLXOHSV]DQLDFKãRSVNLFK1D]ZLVNRPRGSU]H]ZLVNR Z\P QDGDZDQR QRZĈ SRVWDþ QD VNL :LON ]PLHQLDQR QD :LOF]\ęVNL 6RVQD QD6RVQRZVNLįXNQDįXNRZVNL:Mč]\NXURV\MVNLPQD]ZLVNDRGPLHMVFRZH QD ȟȘȖȗɠȤȘȖȗ W\SX ǰȭȕȓȚȟȘȖȗ dzșȓȤȘȖȗ ǿȠȎȞȜȒȡȏȟȘȖȗ E\ã\ Xİ\ZDQH ZNUčJDFKDU\VWRNUDW\F]Q\FKQDWRPLDVWQD]ZLVNDǰȜȕțȓȟȓțȟȘȖȗǽȜȘȞȜȐȟȘȖȗ ________________ =REWHİ%.UHMD3UREOHPSROVNLFKQD]ZLVNW\SXÅ5\ELFNLµÅ'XOVNLµ>Z@92JyO QRSROVND.RQIHUHQFMD2QRPDVW\F]QD.VLčJDUHIHUDWyZSRGUHG.=LHUKRIIHUD3R]QDę V² /LF]QHSU]\NãDG\]PLDQ\QD]ZLVNSRGDMH-6%\VWURę1D]ZLVNDSROVNLH:DU V]DZDV²
:VSyãF]HVQHQD]ZLVNDURV\MVNLHSRFKRG]HQLDSROVNLHJR
ǾȜȔȒȓȟȠȐȓțȟȘȖȗǼȏțȜȞȟȘȖȗǿȝȓȞȎțȟȘȖȗRGSRGVWDZ]QDF]HQLRZR]ZLĈ]D Q\FK]WHPDW\NĈUHOLJLMQĈWUDG\FMĈFKU]HĤFLMDęVNĈLDQW\F]QĈZĤUyGGXFKR ZLHęVWZDSUDZRVãDZQHJR1D]ZLVNDRGLQQ\FKSRGVWDZE\ã\U]DGNLH'OD WHJRWHİQD]ZLVNDURV\MVNLH]SU]\URVWNLHPȟȘȖȗQSǴȡȘȜȐȟȘȖȗǸȜȕșȜȐ ȟȘȖȗǺȎȟșȜȐȟȘȖȗǼȞșȜȐȟȘȖȗǿȜȏȜșȓȐȟȘȖȗǿȜȘȜșȜȐȟȘȖȗǿșȖȐȖțȟȘȖȗȍȐȜȞ ȟȘȖȗLWS]DOLF]RQRGRQD]ZLVNRGDSHODW\ZQ\FKSROVNLHJRSRFKRG]HQLD = XSã\ZHP F]DVX QD]ZLVND SROVNLH VĈ DGDSWRZDQH GR V\VWHPX IRQH W\F]QHJRLPRUIRORJLF]QHJRMč]\NDURV\MVNLHJR$GDSWDFMDIRQHW\F]QD]QDM GXMH QLHNLHG\ VZyM Z\UD] Z SRVWDFL W]Z DNDQLD XWUZDORQHJR Z SLVRZQL QD]ZLVND QS ǯȞȎȐȎȞțȖȘ%URZDUQLNǯȎȑȡȤȘȖȗ%RJXFNLDZȎȒȓȠȟȘȖȗDZȎ ȒȓȤȘȖȗ*RGHFNLDZșȎȐȎȤȘȖȗ*ãRZDFNLǺȎțȥȖțȟȘȖȗ0ĈF]\ęVNLǺȎȦȖț ȟȘȖȗ0RV]\ęVNLǽȎȝȟȡȗ3RSVXMVXEVW\WXFMLVDPRJãRVHNQSǯȓșȜȟȠȜȤȘȖȗ %LDãRVWRFNL]PLDQLHVDPRJãRVNLOXE]DQLNXVSyãJãRVNLMDNQSZQD]ZLVNX dzȟȠȞȓȚȟȘȖȗ ȍȟȠȞȓȚȟȘȖȗ-DVWU]čEVNLLWG$GDSWDFMDPRUIRORJLF]QDSROH JDMĈFD QD GRGDQLX PRUIHPX W\SRZHJR GOD QD]ZLVN URV\MVNLFK Z\VWčSXMH VSRUDG\F]QLH2GQRWRZDQRMHG\QLHGZDSU]\NãDG\ǺȡȟȭșȜȐ0XVLDãLǻȜ ȐȎȘȜȐ1RZDN : QD]ZLVNDFK SU]\PLRWQLNRZ\FK ] NRęFyZNĈ Lɠ\ W\SX 1DURİQ\6WDQLV]HZVNLIOHNVMDSROVNDXOHJDZ\PLDQLHQDURV\MVNĈRGSRZLHG QLRZQD]ZLVNDFKPčİF]\]QLNRELHWǻȎȞȜȔțȩȗǻȎȞȜȔțȎȭǿȠȎțȖȦȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǿȠȎțȖȦȓȐȟȘȎȭ:QD]ZLVNDFKǯȜȞȜȐȟȘȖȣDZșȎȐȎȤȘȖȣǽȜșȭțȟȘȖȣIOHNVMčPLD QRZQLNDOSRM]DVWĈSLRQRNRęFyZNĈGRSHãQLDF]DOPQW\SRZĈGODW]Z QD]ZLVN ÅV\EHU\MVNLFKµ : Z\QLNX WHM VXEVW\WXFML VWDã\ VLč RQH QLHRG PLHQQH: ]HEUDQ\P PDWHULDOH VĈ UHSUH]HQWRZDQH RGSRZLHGQLNL ZV]\VWNLFK ZDİQLHMV]\FKW\SyZQD]ZLVNSROVNLFK1DMOLF]QLHMV]ĈJUXSčQD]ZLVNJHQH W\F]QLH SROVNLFK VNãDGDMĈFĈ VLč ] QD]ZLVN VWDQRZLĈ IRUPDFMH ]SU]\URVWNLHPȟȘȖȗLMHJRZDULDQWDPLȜȐȟȘȖȗɠȓȐȟȘȖȗȖțȟȘȖȗ3U]HZD İDMĈZĤUyGQLFKQD]ZLVNDRGSU]H]ZLVNRZHQD]ZLVNDQSǯȎȞȎțȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǯȡȞȎȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ DZșȖțȟȘȖȗ DZȞȎȏȜȐȟȘȖȗ dzȔȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǴȡȞȎȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǵȓșȖțȟȘȖȗ ǸȎȐȓȤȘȖȗǸȎșȖțȜȐȟȘȖȗǸșȓȝȎȤȘȖȗǸȜȟȖțȟȘȖȗǸȜȠȓȤȘȖȗǸȡȞȥȓȐȟȘȖȗǸȡ ȥȖțȟȘȖȗǹȓȐȎțȒȜȐȟȘȖȗǹȓȐȖțȟȘȖȗǹȓȐȖȤȘȖȗǹȖȟȜȐȟȘȖȗǹȜȕȖțȟȘȖȗǺȎȓȐ ȟȘȖȗ ǺȎȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǺȡȦȖțȟȘȖȗ ǻȓȒȕȐȓȒȟȘȖȗ ǻȜȐȖȤȘȖȗ ǻȜȐȖțȟȘȖȗ ǼȕȖȚ ȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǼșȪȣȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǼșȪȦȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǼȟȖțȟȘȖȗ ǽȓȥȖțȟȘȖȗ ǽșȎȣȠȖțȟȘȖȗ ǿȐȖȒȓȞȟȘȖȗȅȎȝșȖțȟȘȖȗȅȓȞțȭȘȜȐȟȘȖȗȆȎȢȞȎțȟȘȖȗȇȎȐȖțȟȘȖȗLWS ________________
1D]ZLVND QD ȟȘȖȗ RG GDZQD E\ã\ WUDNWRZDQH MDNR SROVNLH &KDUDNWHU\VW\F]QD
MHVWQDVWčSXMĈFDRSLQLD >@ ȞȡȟȟȘȡȬ ȢȎȚȖșȖȬ ǼȟȠȞȜȐȟȘȖȗ ȜȥȓțȪ ȡȝȜȠȞȓȏȖȠȓșȪțȡȬ Ȑ țȎȦȓȚ ȒȡȣȜȐȓțȟȠȐȓ ȒȜșȔțȜȝȖȟȎȠȪȖȝȞȜȖȕțȜȟȖȠȪ²ǼȟȠȞȜȐȟȘȜȗȎțȓǼȟȠȞȜȐȟȘȖȗȁțȎȟȠȎȘȚțȜȑȜȘȞȖȥȎȠȜȏȜȏ ȞȡȟȓțȖȖȎȚȓȔȒȡȠȓȚȜȝȜșȭȥȖȐȎȬȠȘȜȞȓțțȩȣȞȡȟȟȘȖȣșȬȒȓȗȝȜȜȒțȜȚȡȖȕȑșȎȐțȩȣȝȞȖȕțȎ ȘȜȐ²ȝȜȞȜȒȜȐȩȚȝȞȜȕȐȎțȖȭȚ>@ =RE dzǽ Ǹ Ȏ ȞțȜȐȖȥǾȜȒȜȐȩȓȝȞȜȕȐȎțȖȭȖȠȖȠȡșȩȐǾȜȟȟȖȖȖȟșȖȭțȖȓȖțȜȕȓȚȤȓȐ ȟȞȡȟȟȘȖȚȖǿǽȓȠȓȞȏȡȞȑǾȓȝȞȖțȠǺȜȟȘȐȎV
Ǻ:yMWRZLF] 1DGUXJLPPLHMVFXSRGZ]JOčGHPLORĤFL]QDMGXMĈVLčQD]ZLVNDRGPLHM VFRZH QD]ZLVN QS ǮȞȦȎȐȟȘȖȗ ǰȎȞȦȎȐȟȘȖȗ ǸȜțȎȞȔȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǸȜțȖț ȟȘȖȗ ǸȜțȜȠȜȝȟȘȖȗ ǹȓȧȖțȟȘȖȗ ǹȖȑȜȠȟȘȖȗ ǹȖȝțȖȤȘȖȗ ǼȟȠȞȜȚȓȤȘȖȗ ǽȜȕțȎțȟȘȖȗǾȎȒȜȚȟȘȖȗǾȜȑȜȕȖțȟȘȖȗǾȡȟȓȤȘȖȗǿȓȞȝȓȤȘȖȗȀȎȞțȜȐȟȘȖȗȄȓ ȣȎțȜȐȟȘȖȗȅȎȝȟȘȖȗLWS 'RWU]HFLHMJUXS\QD]ZLVNQDȟȘȖȗQDOHİĈIRUPDFMHRGLPLHQQHQD] ZLVND XWZRU]RQH RG LPLRQ FKU]HĤFLMDęVNLFK L WUDG\F\MQ\FK LPLRQ VWDUR SROVNLFK LFK SRVWDFL SHãQ\FK L GHU\ZDWyZ QS ǮȒȎȚȟȘȖȗ ǯȜȑȡȟșȎȐȟȘȖȗ ǯȡȒȕȭțȜȐȟȘȖȗǰȖȠȘȜȐȟȘȖȗǰȜȗȠȓȣȜȐȟȘȖȗǰȜȗȤȓȣȜȐȟȘȖȗǰȜȗȠȘȜȐȟȘȖȗDZȜȒ șȓȐȟȘȖȗ DzȜȚȎȣȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǺȎȘȎȞȟȘȖȗ ǺȖȣȎșȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǽȎȐșȖȤȘȖȗ ǽȎȦȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǿȠȓȢȎțȜȐȟȘȖȗȂȎșȪȘȜȐȟȘȖȗȄȓȣȎțȟȘȖȗȆȖȚȎțȟȘȖȗȍȘȡȏȜȐȟȘȖȗȍțȖȤȘȖȗ ȍțȘȜȐȟȘȖȗȍțȜȐȟȘȖȗȍțȡȦȓȐȟȘȖȗȍȞȜȦȖțȟȘȖȗȍȟȖțȟȘȖȗLWS :JUXSLHQD]ZLVN]SU]\URVWNLHPȟȘȖȗ]QDMGXMĈVLčWDNİHSU]\PLRWQL NLXWZRU]RQHRGQD]ZZ\NRQDZFyZ]DZRGXZ\VWčSXMĈFHZIXQNFMLQD] ZLVNQSǯȞȜȐȎȞȟȘȖȗǸȎȞȏȜȐȟȘȖȗǸȜȠșȭȞȟȘȖȗǸȞȎȐȥȖțȟȘȖȗǺșȩțȎȞȟȘȖȗ ǽȓȘȎȞȟȘȖȗǾȩȚȎȦȓȐȟȘȖȗȀȜȘȎȞȟȘȖȗȆȘșȭȞȟȘȖȗ .ROHMQĈGXİĈJUXSčOLF]ĈFĈQD]ZLVNDVWDQRZLĈIRUPDFMHSDWUR QLPLF]QH]SU]\URVWNDPLȜȐȖȥɠȓȐȖȥȖȤ:ZLčNV]RĤFLVĈWRQD]ZLVNDRG SRGVWDZSHãQ\FKLGHU\ZDWyZLPLRQFKU]HĤFLMDęVNLFKQSǮȒȎȚȜȐȖȥǯșȎȔȓ ȐȖȥǯȞȜȔȓȐȖȥǹȓțȎȞȠȜȐȖȥǺȎȞȤȖțȘȓȐȖȥǺȎȤȘȓȐȖȥǺȖȤȘȓȐȖȥǽȎȐșȜȐȖȥ ǿȠȎțȘȓȐȖȥ ǿȠȎȦȘȓȐȖȥ ȍȘȡȏȜȐȖȥ ȍțȜȐȖȥ ȍțȡȦȘȓȐȖȥ ȍȤȘȜȐȖȥ -HVW Z WHM JUXSLH NLOND QD]ZLVN RG GHU\ZDWyZ LPLRQ VWDURSROVNLFK QS ǯȜȑȡȦȓȐȖȥ ǰȖȠȘȓȐȖȥ DzȕȭȠȘȜȐȖȥ ȂȎșȪȘȜȐȖȥ ȄȓȣȎțȜȐȖȥ D WDNİH SDUč QD]ZLVN XWZR U]RQ\FKRGSU]H]ZLVNLDSHODW\ZyZQSǰȞȡȏșȓȐȖȥǸȜȐȎșȓȐȖȥǺȎȕȡȞȘȓȐȖȥ ȄȓȝȓșȓȐȖȥ : QD]ZLVNX ȅȎȝșȖȤ &]DSOLF Z\VWčSXMH VXILNV LF ² URG]LPD SRVWDþSU]\URVWNDLF]
1D]ZLVNSROVNLHJRSRFKRG]HQLD]LQQ\PLIRUPDQWDPLRGQRWRZDQRQLH ZLHOH QD]ZLVN F]\OL 6Ĉ WR SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP QD]ZLVND ] SU]\ URVWNDPL ȎȘ ȭȘ QS ǰȎȐȞȡȦȎȘ ǺȎȞȥȎȘ dzȔȎȘ DzȕȬȏȎȘ dzȒȖțȎȘ ǹȓȟțȭȘ ǻȜȐȎȘǿȠȎȞȥȎȘȅȓȞțȭȘ]SU]\URVWNLHPȖȘǻȜȐȖȘǽȎȐșȖȘǾȡȒȕȖȘ]SU]\ URVWNLHPȥȖȘǸȞȎȐȥȖȘLȓȘDZșȜȒȫȘ
6SRUĈJUXSčWZRU]ĈQD]ZLVNDEH]Z\NãDGQLNyZVãRZRWZyUF]\FKZMč ]\NXSROVNLP/LF]\RQDQD]ZLVN6ĈWRQD]ZLVNDUyZQHZVZHM EXGRZLH LPLRQRP L DSHODW\ZRP 'R QD]ZLVN UyZQ\FK SHãQ\P IRUPRP OXE GHU\ZDWRP RG LPLRQ FKU]HĤFLMDęVNLFK L VWDURSROVNLFK RERN NLONX MXİ Z\PLHQLRQ\FKQDOHİĈQSǯȎțȎȣ%DQDFK%DQDG\N%HQHG\NWȍȞȜȦȍȞȜ ȦȓȘ ȍȞȜțȪ -DURVãDZ -DURPLU ǽȎȟȪ 3DĤ 3DZHã ǸȜȣȎț ǿȡșȖȚ 6XOLPLU 6XOLVãDZ 1D]ZLVND UyZQH DSHODW\ZRP WR GDZQH SU]H]ZLVND 6Ĉ ZĤUyG QLFKQD]Z\SWDNyZ]ZLHU]ĈWU\EURĤOLQQSǯȎȞȎțDzȞȜȕȒǸȎȞȎȟȪǹȜȏȜȒȎ ǹȡȧǺȜȠȩșȪǾȩȏȘȎȅȎȗȘȎȆȝȎȘQD]Z\Z\NRQDZFyZ]DZRGyZL]DMčþ ǯȡȒțȖȘ ǰȜȕțȩȗ ǸȜȐȎșȪ ǸȞȎȐȓȤ ǸȡȣȠȎ ǼșȓȗțȖȘ ǾȩȏȎȘ ǿȝȓȐȎȘ ǿȠȞȎȔ ȀȞȓȚȏȎȥǺȩȠțȖȘǺȩȟșȖȐȓȤQD]Z\PLHV]NDęFyZQD]Z\HWQLF]QHDZȡȞȎșȪ
:VSyãF]HVQHQD]ZLVNDURV\MVNLHSRFKRG]HQLDSROVNLHJR
ǸȎȦȡȏȎ ǺȎȕȡȞ ǽȜșȭȘ QD]Z\ UR]PDLW\FK SU]HGPLRWyZ QD]Z\ DEVWUDN F\MQHDZȡȕȖȘDzȡȣǵȎȗȒȎǻȎșȓȟțȖȘǽȎȚȝȡȣǿȘȖȏȎǿȘȜȞȡȝȎȀȡȞȘȜȠȆȘȜȒȎ LWS:JUXSLHWHMMHVWUyZQLHİNLONDQD]ZLVNNWyU\FKSROVNLHRGSRZLHGQLNL VĈ UyZQH SU]\PLRWQLNRP]NRęFyZNĈLɠ\QSǻȓȟȚȎȥțȩȗǻȎȘȜțȓȥțȩȗ ǻȎȞȜȔțȩȗ ǽȜȐȦȓȒțȩȗ L MHGQR QD]ZLVNR Z SRVWDFL UR]NDĮQLND ² ǽȎȝȟȡȗ 1D]ZLVND GRSHãQLDF]RZH VĈ UHSUH]HQWRZDQH SU]H] GZLH IRUP\ GRSHãQLD F]DOSRMDzȕȬȏȎLǿȡșȖȚȎWDNİHQD]ZDKHUERZD6XOLP6XOLPLU6XOLVãDZ 1D]ZLVNDSROVNLHJRSRFKRG]HQLDNRQFHQWUXMĈVLčZGROQHMVWUHILHF]čVWR ĤFL SLHUZV]HM OLVW\ QDMF]čVWV]\FK QD]ZLVN URV\MVNLFK =QDMGXMH VLč WX QD]ZLVNDOLF]EDLFKQRVLFLHOL]DZLHUDVLčZSU]HG]LDOHRGGR : GROQHM VWUHILH PRİQD Z\UyİQLþ QD]ZLVND R GXİHM F]čVWRĤFL ² QRVLFLHOL GR NWyUHM QDOHİ\ QD]ZLVN L JUXSč QD]ZLVN PQLHM F]čVW\FK ²QRVLFLHOLOLF]ĈFĈQD]ZLVN1DGUXJLHMOLĤFLHQDMF]čVWV]\FK QD]ZLVN URV\MVNLFK RGQRWRZDQR QD]ZLVN JHQHW\F]QLH SROVNLFK =DPLH V]F]RQ\SRQLİHMZ\ND]]DZLHUDQD]ZLVND]SLHUZV]HMOLVW\XãRİRQHZHGãXJ PDOHMĈFHM OLF]E\ QRVLFLHOL 7H VDPH QD]ZLVND Z\VWčSXMĈFH QD REX OLVWDFK Z\UyİQLRQR NXUV\ZĈ &\IUD SU]HG QD]ZLVNLHP R]QDF]D NROHMQ\ QXPHU F\IUDSRQD]ZLVNX²OLF]EčQRVLFLHOL ǽȜșȭțȟȘȖȗ ǸȜȕșȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǸȜȐȎșȪ ǼșȓȗțȖȘ ǼȟȠȞȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǽȎȐșȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǯȩȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǰȩȟȜȤȘȖȗ ǻȜȐȖȤȘȖȗ ǾȜȚȎțȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǯȎȞȎțȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǸȜȐȎșȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǿȜȘȜșȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǺȎȕȡȞ ǴȡȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǯȓșȪȟȘȖȗ ǸȎȚȖțȟȘȖȗ ȅȎȗȘȎ ǯȜȏȞȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǹȖȟȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǿȠȎțȘȓȐȖȥ ǿȎȒȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǸȞȎȐȓȤ ȅȓȞțȭȘ ǻȜȐȖȘ ȍțȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ DzȕȬȏȎ ǼȞșȜȐȟȘȖ ȆȝȎȘ ǸȜȐȎșȪȟȘȖȗ ǯȓșȭȐȟȘȖȗ ǺȎșȖțȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǹȡȘȎȦȓȐȖȥ ȃȚȓșȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǯȓșȓȤȘȖȗ ȍțȜȐȟȘȖȗ DzȜȚȏȞȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǻȜȐȎȘ ȅȎȗȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǯȓșȖțȟȘȖȗ ǺȎȤȘȓȐȖȥ ǸȎșȖțȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǵȎȐȎȒȟȘȖȗ ǿȜȏȜșȓȐȟȘȖȗ DzȞȜȕȒ ǸȡȥȖțȟȘȖȗ ȍȘȡȏȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǼșȪȣȜȐȟȘȖȗ DzȜȏȞȜȐȜșȪȟȘȖȗ ǺȎȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǺȎȞȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǾȩȏȎȘ ȍȐȜȞȟȘȖȗ ǴȡȞȎȐȟȘȖȗ ǺȎȟșȜȐȟȘȖȗ ȍȏșȜțȟȘȖȗ DZȡȞȟȘȖȗ ǵȓșȖțȟȘȖȗ ǯȜȞȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǿȘȖȏȎ ǽȎȐșȜȐȖȥ ȍȟȖțȟȘȖȗ ǾȡȒțȖȤȘȖȗ ȄȩȏȡșȪȟȘȖȗ ǰȜȗȤȓȣȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǼșȪȦȓȐȟȘȖȗ ȁȞȏȎț ȆȖȒșȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǯȜȑȡȟșȎȐȟȘȖȗ ȆȖȚȎțȟȘȖȗ ǺȎȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǽȎȦȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ
Ǻ:yMWRZLF] ȍȞȜȦ DZȎȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǿȜȟțȜȐȟȘȖȗ ȍȘȡȏȜȐȖȥ ǮȒȎȚȜȐȖȥ ǯȡȒțȖȘ ǾȡȟȓȤȘȖȗ ǺȖȤȘȓȐȖȥ ǿȠȓșȪȚȎȣ ǰȎȐȞȡȦȎȘ ǿȠȎȐȖȤȘȖȗ ǽȜșȭȘ ǸȜȑȡȠ ȍȟȘȓȐȖȥ ǸȜȐȎșȓȐȖȥ ǹȡȘȎȦ ǸȜȣȎț ǹȓȐȎțȒȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǰȖȠȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǽȜȠȜȤȘȖȗ ǹȓȟțȭȘ ȍȤȘȓȐȖȥ ǵȎșȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǹȓȧȖțȟȘȖȗ ǰȞȡȏșȓȐȟȘȖȗ ǾȡȠȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǿȠȎȟȓȐȖȥ ǹȎȝȖȤȘȖȗ ȍȞȜȦȓȐȖȥ ȍțȜȐȖȥ DZȞȎȏȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǾȡȒȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǿȖȘȜȞȟȘȖȗ ȀȡȞȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǰȜșȪȟȘȖȗ ȅȖȔȓȐȟȘȖȗ ȆȝȎȘȜȐȟȘȖȗ ǺȎȞȤȖțȘȓȐȖȥ ǽȎȐșȖȘ ȍțȘȜȐȖȥ ǸȎȦȡȏȎ ǸȎȞȝȖțȟȘȖȗ ǿȡșȖȚȎ DZȡȞȎ
1D REX OLVWDFK IUHNZHQF\MQ\FK ]QDMGXMH VLč W\FK VDP\FK QD]ZLVN SROVNLHJR SRFKRG]HQLD D ZLčF ]JRGQRĤþ OLVW SRG W\P Z]JOčGHP Z\QRVL :\ND]QDMF]čVWV]\FKQD]ZLVN]DZLHUDQD]ZLVND]IRUPDQWHPȟȘȖȗ L MHJR ZDULDQWDPL FR VWDQRZL 7DN GXİD SU]HZDJD Z\PLHQLRQHJR W\SX QD]ZLVN ZLĈİH VLč ] W\P İH Z V\VWHPLH QD]ZLVN SROVNLFK IRUPDFMH QDVNL]DMPXMĈSRGZ]JOčGHPOLF]ERZ\PSLHUZV]HPLHMVFH:V\VWHPLH QD]ZLVNURV\MVNLFKVWDQRZLĈRQH]DWHPZ\UyİQLNQD]ZLVNSROVNLHJRSRFKR G]HQLD:SRZ\İV]\PZ\ND]LHMHVWQD]ZLVN]SU]\URVWNLHPȜȐȖȥɠȓȐȖȥ LQD]ZLVNLQQ\FKW\SyZ=SRUyZQDQLDWHJRZ\ND]X]OLVWĈQDMF]čĤFLHM Xİ\ZDQ\FK QD]ZLVN SROVNLFK Z\QLND İH ]QDMGXMH VLč Z QLP QD]ZLVN URV\MVNLFKF]\OLPDMĈF\FKVZRMHSROVNLHRGSRZLHGQLNL=WHMOLF]E\ QD]ZLVNPDRGSRZLHGQLNLZĤUyGSLHUZV]\FKQDMF]čVWV]\FKQD]ZLVN 1LH PD Z Z\ND]LH QDMF]čVWV]\FK URV\MVNLFK QD]ZLVN RGSRZLHGQLNyZ ]DM PXMĈF\FKZ\VRNLHPLHMVFDQDOLĤFLHUDQJRZHMQD]ZLVNSROVNLFKWDNLFKMDN QS :LĤQLHZVNL :yMFLN .RZDOF]\N .ZLDWNRZVNL .DF]PDUHN .UDZF]\N3LRWURZVNL0LFKDOVNLLWG 3U]HGVWDZLRQHZ\İHM]DJDGQLHQLHZ\PDJDQLHZĈWSOLZLHV]HUV]\FKED GDęNWyUH]F]DVHPSR]ZROĈPRİHX]\VNDþEDUG]LHMSHãQ\REUD]WHMJUXS\ QD]ZLVNEčGĈF\FKQLHW\ONRLQWHJUDOQĈF]čĤFLĈURV\MVNLHJRV\VWHPXDQWUR SRQLPLF]QHJRDOHWDNİHZDİQ\PĤZLDGHFWZHPMHJR]ZLĈ]NyZ]DQWURSR QLPLĈSROVNĈ ________________ =RE.6NRZURQHN:VSyãF]HVQHQD]ZLVNRSROVNLH6WXGLXPVWDW\VW\F]QRNRJ QLW\ZQH.UDNyZVLWDEQDV$XWRUNDSRGDMHİHQD]ZLVNQDVNLMHVW RNRãRW\VF]\OLZV]\VWNLFKSROVNLFKQD]ZLVN /LVWčIUHNZHQF\MQĈSROVNLFKQD]ZLVN]RE.6NRZURQHNRSFLWV²