,9:63£É&=(61(1$5=Õ'=,$=$5=Ë'=$1,$25*$1,=$&-$0, KOMERCYJNYMI I NIEKOMERCYJNYMI Andrzej Kozina* 7<32/2*,$1(*2&-$&-,:35=('6,%,2567:,( %86,1(661(*27,$7,2167<32/2*< 6XPPDU\ 7KHREMHFWLYHRIWKHSDSHULVWRSUHVHQWWKHW\SRORJ\RIEXVLQHVVQHJRWLD-WLRQVWUHDWHGDVPDQDJHULDOWRRO6XFKDW\SRORJ\FRQVWLWXWHVDFUXFLDODVSHFW of complex and multidimensional model of business negotiations.
)LUVWO\JHQHUDOFRQFHSWRIWKRVHQHJRWLDWLRQVLVGHVFULEHG6HFRQGO\WKHLU W\SRORJ\ LV VXJJHVWHG LQFOXGLQJ ERWK JHQHULF DQG VXSSOHPHQWDU\ FULWHULD 7KLUGO\ VRPH SDUWLFXODU W\SHV RI EXVLQHVV QHJRWLDWLRQV DUH FRQVLGHUHG UH-IOHFWLQJWKHLUVSHFLILFIHDWXUHV6XPPLQJXSWKHSDSHUWKHVXEVHTXHQWDUHDV of research are pointed out.
8ZDJLZVWÌSQH
-HGQ\P]LVWRWQ\FKDVSHNW¿ZNRPSOHNVRZHJRLZLHORZ\PLDURZHJRPRGH OXQHJRFMDFMLZSU]HGVLÖELRUVWZLHWUDNWRZDQ\FKMDNRLQVWUXPHQW]DU]ÌG]DQLD MHVW Z\RGUÖEQLHQLH LFK SRGVWDZRZ\FK URG]DM¿Z >.R]LQD @ 8PRÔOLZLD WRERZLHPVSUHF\]RZDQLHXQLZHUVDOQ\FKLVSHF\ILF]Q\FKFHFKW\FKQHJRFMDFML RUD]LFK]DNUHVXLFHO¿ZDFR]DW\PLG]LHZ\SUDFRZDQLHDGHNZDWQ\FKQDU]Ö G]LPHWRG\F]Q\FK]ZÊDV]F]DZSURFHVLHLFKSODQRZDQLD
&HOHP QLQLHMV]HJR UHIHUDWX MHVW ]DWHP SU]HGVWDZLHQLH ZÊDVQHM SURSR]\FML W\SRORJLL UR]ZDÔDQ\FK QHJRFMDFML 1DOHÔ\ SRGNUHÎOLÐ LÔ QLH MHVW WR ÊDWZH ]D GDQLH]HZ]JOÖGXQD]QDF]QH]U¿ÔQLFRZDQLHW\FKQHJRFMDFMLRUD]EUDNNRP SOHNVRZ\FKLVS¿MQ\FKSURSR]\FMLLFKW\SRORJLLZOLWHUDWXU]HSU]HGPLRWX=D SUH]HQWRZDQDZUHIHUDFLHNRQFHSFMDXMPXMHQDMZDÔQLHMV]HNU\WHULDWHJRURG]DMX W\SRORJLL]HÎZLDGRPRÎFLÌLÔQLHMHVWRQDZ\F]HUSXMÌFDDZV]HONLHVFKHPDW\ NODV\ILNDF\MQHZRPDZLDQHMG]LHG]LQLHVÌZ]JOÖGQH GU.DWHGUD3URFHVX=DU]ÌG]DQLD8QLZHUV\WHW(NRQRPLF]Q\Z.UDNRZLH
,VWRWDQHJRFMDFMLZSU]HGVLÌELRUVWZLH :UR]ZDÔDQ\PSU]\SDGNXPDMÌ]DVWRVRZDQLHZV]HONLHRJ¿OQHLQWHUSUHWD FMH SRMÖFLD QHJRFMDFML W]Q MDNR LQWHUDNF\MQHJR SURFHVX GHF\]\MQHJR PHWRG\ NLHURZDQLDNRQIOLNWHPLRVLÌJDQLDSRUR]XPLHQLDZ]DMHPQHM]DOHÔQRÎFLSDUWQH U¿ZSURFHV¿Z NRPXQLNRZDQLDVLÖZ\PLDQ\LWZRU]HQLDZDUWRÎFL]REPLQ >/HZLFNLLLQVLQ@>1HJRFMDFMHVLQ@>0HVMDV] V @ >5]ÌGFD V L Q@ : UR]ZDÔDQ\P REV]DU]H QDMLVWRWQLHMV]D MHVWSLHUZV]D]W\FKLQWHUSUHWDFML£ZSURFHVGHF\]\MQ\MHVW ZID]LHSU]\JRWR ZDZF]HM UHDOL]RZDQ\SU]H]VWURQ\QLH]DOHÔQLHRGVLHELH ]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDLFK FHO¿Z QDVWÖSQLH ZFKRG]L Z ID]Ö Z]DMHPQ\FK X]JRGQLHØ Z ]DNUHVLH GZ¿FK SDU]ELRU¿Z DOWHUQDW\ZUR]ZLÌ]DØLNU\WHUL¿ZRFHQ\RNUHÎORQ\FKZVWÖSQLHGOD NDÔGHJR]QHJRFMDWRU¿Z]RVREQD:UHV]FLHVWURQ\Z\ELHUDMÌNU\WHULD]SXQNWX ZLG]HQLDLFKLQWHUHV¿ZLXVWDODMÌ]EL¿UDOWHUQDW\Z MDNRF]ÖÎÐZVS¿OQÌZ\MÎFLR Z\FKRSFML 6NU¿WRZ\PRNUHÎOHQLHPcQHJRFMDFMHZSU]HGVLÖELRUVWZLHoRNUHÎODVLÖ]D U¿ZQRWHVSRÎU¿GQLFKNW¿UHPDMÌFKDUDNWHUZHZQÌWU]RUJDQL]DF\MQ\W]QVÌ SURZDG]RQHSRPLÖG]\U¿ÔQ\PLJUXSDPLLQWHUHVXZSU]HGVLÖELRUVWZLHQSSUD FRGDZFDPLLSUDFRELRUFDPLZÊDÎFLFLHODPLLPHQHGÔHUDPLLWSMDNLWHQHJR FMDFMH NW¿UH UHSUH]HQWDQFL SU]HGVLÖELRUVWZD SURZDG]Ì ] LQWHUHVDULXV]DPL ]H ZQÖWU]Q\PLQSNRRSHUDQWDPLGRVWDZFDPLRGELRUFDPLLWS 5R]ZDÔDQHQHJRFMDFMHVÌ]DWHPÎFLÎOHSRGSRU]ÌGNRZDQHUHDOL]DFMLU¿ÔQR URGQ\FKFHO¿ZSU]HGVLÖELRUVWZDZ\QLNDMÌF\FK]MHJRLVWRW\MDNRV]F]HJ¿OQH JRURG]DMXRUJDQL]DFMLWMQLH]EÖGQHGRUHDOL]DFMLMHJRFHO¿ZMDNRÎURGRZLVND OXEVWURQ\QHJRFMDFML6WDQRZLÌWDNÔHVSRV¿ENV]WDÊWRZDQLDUHODFMLILUP\]RWR F]HQLHPLZHZQÖWU]Q\FKZDUXQN¿ZZVS¿ÊG]LDÊDQLD3U]\WRF]RQHVSRVRE\LQ WHUSUHWDFMLQHJRFMDFML]ZÊDV]F]DMDNRSURFHVXSRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]MLZVND]XMÌ SRQDGWRQDÎFLVÊ\LFK]ZLÌ]HN]SURFHVHP]DU]ÌG]DQLD'ODNDÔGHMV\WXDFMLQH JRFMDF\MQHMZILUPLHLFK]OHFHQLRGDZFÌMHVWNLHURZQLNOXEGHOHJRZDQ\SU]H]HØ SUDFRZQLNZ\NRQDZF]\ RGSRZLHG]LDOQLWDNÔH]DLFKSURZDG]HQLH ]DU¿ZQR ]GDQHJR]HVSRÊXIXQNFMRQDOQHJROXESURMHNWRZHJR QDMF]ÖÎFLHMZQHJRFMDFMDFK ZHZQÌWU]RUJDQL]DF\MQ\FK MDNL]HVSRÊXQHJRFMDF\MQHJR ]DGDQLRZHJR UHSUH ]HQWXMÌFHJRILUPÖ ]Z\NOHZQHJRFMDFMDFKPLÖG]\RUJDQL]DF\MQ\FK 1DMZDÔQLHMV]ÌFHFKÌZVS¿OQÌUR]ZDÔDQ\FKQHJRFMDFML QLH]DOHÔQLHRGLFK XZDUXQNRZDØLURG]DM¿Z MHVWLFKFKDUDNWHUW]QZV]\VWNLHRQHVÌcJRVSRGDU F]\PLoZV]HUV]\P]QDF]HQLXWHJRVÊRZDXZ]JOÖGQLDMÌFSRGVWDZRZHFHOHHNR QRPLF]QHSU]HGVLÖELRUVWZDLMHJRLVWRWÖMDNRV]F]HJ¿OQHJRURG]DMXRUJDQL]DFML 7HVSRÎU¿GSU]\SDGN¿ZQHJRFMDF\MQ\FKZQLPZ\VWÖSXMÌF\FKNW¿UHQLHGRW\ F]ÌEH]SRÎUHGQLRMHJRG]LDÊDOQRÎFLJRVSRGDUF]HMPDMÌFVZRMHÒU¿GÊRZLQQH JR URG]DMX SURFHVDFK QS VSRÊHF]Q\FK NXOWXURZ\FK F]\ F]\QQLNDFK RVRER ZRÎFLRZ\FK ZRVWDWHF]Q\PHIHNFLHSRZLQQ\E\Ð ERZLHP SRGSRU]ÌGNRZDQH
UHDOL]DFML ]DVDGQLF]\FK MHJR FHO¿Z 'RW\F]\ WR ]ZÊDV]F]D V\WXDFML NRQIOLNWR Z\FKQSZV]HONLHJRURG]DMXSUREOHP¿ZZHZVS¿ÊG]LDÊDQLXF]\VSRU¿Z]ELR URZ\FKSRPLÖG]\SUDFRGDZFDPLLSUDFRELRUFDPL
1HJRFMDFMHJRVSRGDUF]HZÎFLVÊ\P ZÖÔV]\P ]QDF]HQLXGRW\F]ÌWUDQVDNFML KDQGORZ\FKOXEILQDQVRZ\FK5R]XPLHVLÖSU]H]QLHZV]HONLHJRURG]DMXURNR ZDQLD QLH]EÖGQH GOD GRNRQDQLD VSU]HGDÔ\ EÌGÒ ]DNXSX U¿ÔQHJR URG]DMX ]D VRE¿ZU]HF]RZ\FKLILQDQVRZ\FKWMSURGXNW¿ZOXEXVÊXJÎURGN¿ZWUZDÊ\FK Z\SRVDÔHQLDLLQQ\FKHOHPHQW¿ZPDMÌWNXZW\PQLHPDWHULDOQ\FK1HJRFMDFMH WDNLHZZ\PLDU]HILUP\MDNRLFKVWURQ\REHMPXMÌZLÖFZV]HONLHWUDQVDNFMHWHJR URG]DMXUHDOL]RZDQH]LQQ\PLSRGPLRWDPLDWDNÔHZUDPDFKSURFHV¿ZZH ZQÖWU]QHMNRRSHUDFMLLZ\PLDQ\'RW\SRZ\FKURG]DM¿ZW\FKQHJRFMDFMLQDOH ÔÌVSU]HGDÔ ]DNXS SURGXNW¿ZOXEXVÊXJSR]\VNLZDQLHNUHG\W¿ZRSHUDFMHOH DVLQJRZHLWUDQVDNFMHXEH]SLHF]HQLRZHIX]MHSU]HMÖFLDLDOLDQVHVWUDWHJLF]QH 3URSRQRZDQDW\SRORJLDQHJRFMDFMLZSU]HGVLÌELRUVWZLH
2SUDFRZDQD SU]H] DXWRUD NRPSOHNVRZD ZLHORDVSHNWRZD W\SRORJLD UR] ZDÔDQ\FKQHJRFMDFMLRSLHUDVLÖQDGZ¿FKURG]DMDFKNU\WHUL¿Z SRGVWDZRZ\FK Z\QLNDMÌF\FK]HVSHF\ILNLSU]HGVLÖELRUVWZDMDNRREV]DUX VWURQ\ QHJRFMDFML RUD]SRPRFQLF]\FKWMW\FKVSRÎU¿GRJ¿OQ\FKNU\WHUL¿ZSRG]LDÊXQHJRFMDFML NW¿UHPDMÌLVWRWQH]QDF]HQLH]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDFHOXEDGDØ]REWDEHOHL
-HÎOL FKRG]L R SLHUZV]Ì F]ÖÎÐ UR]ZDÔDQHM W\SRORJLL WR GZD SLHUZV]H SR G]LDÊ\VÌQDMZDÔQLHMV]HJG\ÔÊÌF]QHLFKXZ]JOÖGQLHQLHSR]ZDODQDZVND]DQLH QDMLVWRWQLHMV]\FKDWU\EXW¿ZQHJRFMDFMLWMLFKSDUWQHU¿ZFHO¿ZL]DNUHVXSUREOH PRZHJR3RG]LDÊ\QHJRFMDFML]HZ]JOÖGXQD]QDF]HQLHLF]ÖVWRWOLZRÎÐSR]ZDOD MÌQDXFKZ\FHQLHLFKVSHF\ILNLQDSRV]F]HJ¿OQ\FKV]F]HEODFK]DU]ÌG]DQLDDGH NZDWQ\FKGRUR]ZLÌ]\ZDQ\FKSUREOHP¿ZLSRGHMPRZDQ\FKGHF\]ML =NROHL]DVWRVRZDQLHSRPRFQLF]\FKNU\WHUL¿ZSRG]LDÊXUR]ZDÔDQ\FKQH JRFMDFMLSR]ZDODQDRGQLHVLHQLHGRQLFKRJ¿OQ\FKXQLZHUVDOQ\FK]DVDGSURSR QRZDQ\FKZOLWHUDWXU]HSU]HGPLRWXQSXZ]JOÖGQLDMÌF\FKVSHF\ILNÖQHJRFMD FMLZLHORVWURQQ\FKW\SRZ\FKZHZVS¿ÊF]HVQ\FKZDUXQNDFKIXQNFMRQRZDQLD SU]HGVLÖELRUVWZ VLHFLRZ\FK ZRGU¿ÔQLHQLXRGVWDQGDUGRZ\FKQHJRFMDFMLGZX VWURQQ\FK
Tabela 1. 7\SRORJLDQHJRFMDFMLZSU]HGVLÖELRUVWZLH NU\WHULDSRGVWDZRZH .U\WHULD 7\S\QHJRFMDFML &KDUDNWHU\VW\ND SRGW\S\SU]\NÊDG\LWS ÍU RG RZ LV NR L SD UW QH U] \ L QW HU HV DU LX V] H :HZQÌWU]RUJDQL]DF\MQH ZHZQÖWU]QH 3RPLÖG]\MHGQRVWNDPLLVWDQRZLVNDPLRUJDQL]DF\MQ\PLZILUPLHqZH ZQÌWU]ZÊDVQHMVWURQ\>:DOWRQ0F.HUVLH @QS]ELRURZH SUDFR GDZF¿Z]SUDFRELRUFDPL UR]ZLÌ]\ZDQLHNRQIOLNW¿ZZHZVS¿ÊSUDF\SR PLÖG]\Z\G]LDÊDPLXVWDODQLHEXGÔHWXLWS VW\PXORZDQH]MHGQHMVWURQ\ ZVS¿OQ\PLFHODPLLQWHJUXMÌF\PLSUDFRZQLN¿Z]GUXJLHMqNRQIOLNWDPL ZHZQÖWU]Q\PLLV\WXDFMÌSU]\PXVX 0LÖG]\RUJD QL]DF\MQH ]H ZQÖWU]QH =SDUWQHUDPLVSR]DILUP\QSSU]\IX]MDFKZ]DNUHVLHXP¿Z]NRQWUDKHQ WDPL GRVWDZFDPLLRGELRUFDPL SURZDG]RQHZV\WXDFMLSU]\PXVX QS ]PRQRSROLVWDPL OXEZ\ERUX LFKSRGW\S\VÌZ\RGUÖEQLDQH]HZ]JOÖGXQD URG]DMLQWHUHVDULXV]\]HZQÖWU]Q\FK QSDJHQG\U]ÌGRZHMHGQRVWNLJRVSR GDUF]H LIRUP\ZVS¿ÊG]LDÊDQLD QSDOLDQVIUDQFKLVLQJRXWVRXUFLQJ )X QN FM H G ]L HG ]L Q\ G] LD ÊD OQ RÎ FL I LU P \ W] Q S UR Z DG ]R QH Z ] DN UH VL H ']LDÊDOQRÎFL SRGVWDZRZHM 'RW\F]ÌSURFHV¿ZSRGVWDZRZ\FK QSSURGXNF\MQ\FK LSRPRFQLF]\FK EH]SRÎUHGQLHMREVÊXJLQSWHFKQLF]QHMWUDQVSRUWRZHMORJLVW\F]QHMLWS *Ê¿ZQLHZ]DNUHVLHNRRUG\QDFMLG]LDÊDØZID]DFKSURFHV¿ZRUD]ZVS¿Ê G]LDÊDQLD]NRRSHUDQWDPLLSRGZ\NRQDZFDPLZ]DNUHVLHREVÊXJLWHFKQROR JLF]QHMSURFHV¿ZRXWVRXUFLQJXLWS =DU]ÌG]DQLD ]DVREDPLOXG] NLPL 6]HUHJSU]\SDGN¿ZGRW\F]ÌF\FKSRV]F]HJ¿OQ\FKIXQNFMLSHUVRQDO Q\FKQSZSURFHVLHUHNUXWDFML ]DJHQFMDPLGRUDG]WZDSHUVRQDOQHJROXE ZXNÊDG]LHSU]HÊRÔRQ\SRGZÊDGQ\GODFHO¿ZNRRUG\QDFMLG]LDÊDØ +DQGOX LPDUNHWLQ JX VSU]HGDÔ\ L]DRSDWU]HQLD 3URZDG]RQH]NRQWUDKHQWDPL RGELRUFDPLLGRVWDZFDPL ZFHOX]DZDUFLD XP¿ZRZVS¿ÊSUDFÖZ]DNUHVLH]DNXSX VSU]HGDÔ\ SURGXNW¿ZLOXEXVÊXJ RUD]LQQ\FKVNÊDGQLN¿ZPDMÌWNXILUP\DWDNÔHZUDPDFKDQDORJLF]Q\FK WUDQVDNFMLZUDPDFKZHZQÖWU]Q\FKUR]OLF]HØ 5DFKXQNRZR ÎFLLILQDQV¿Z *Ê¿ZQLH]ZLÌ]DQH]SR]\VNLZDQLHPLWUDQVIHUHPÎURGN¿ZILQDQVRZ\FK QSNUHG\WRZHLOHDVLQJRZH ]DEH]SLHF]HQLHP XEH]SLHF]HQLRZH RUD] SODQRZDQLHPLNRQWUROÌ]DVRE¿Z ZHZQÖWU]Q\UDFKXQHNHNRQRPLF]Q\ FRQWUROOLQJEXGÔHWRZDQLH %DGDØLUR] ZRMX 'OD]DSHZQLHQLDZDUXQN¿ZGRUR]ZRMXILUP\QSSU]\]DNXSLHOLFHQFMLZGUDÔDQLXQRZ\FKWHFKQRORJLLLQQ\FKLQZHVW\FMDFK 2UJDQL]DFML SUDF\ :UDPDFKSU]HGVLÖZ]LÖÐXNLHUXQNRZDQ\FKQDGRVNRQDOHQLHRUJDQL]DFML L]DU]ÌG]DQLDQS]ILUPDPLGRUDGF]\PLSU]\SRG]LDOH]DVRE¿ZLZ\G]LH ODQLXVS¿ÊHNZUDPDFKUHVWUXNWXU\]DFMLWZRU]HQLX]HVSRÊ¿ZSU]\ZGUDÔD QLX]PLDQRUJDQL]DF\MQ\FKLWS 0LHV]DQH NRPELQRZDQH ]ÊRÔRQH D GRW\F]ÌFHSUREOHP¿Z]]DNUHVXZLÖFHMQLÔMHGQHJRREV]DUXIXQNFMRQDO QHJRQSZUDPDFKIX]MLLSU]HMÖÐUHVWUXNWXU\]DFML E U¿ÔQLFRZDQH]HZ]JOÖGXQDVSHFMDOL]DFMÖRGPLHQQÌRGIXQNFMRQDO QHMZ]DU]ÌG]DQLXSURMHNWDPL SURFHVDPL q]H]OHFHQLRGDZFDPLSU]\ ]DNXSDFKZVS¿ÊG]LDÊDQLX]HVSRÊ¿ZUR]ZLÌ]\ZDQLXNRQIOLNW¿Z V]HUHJ SU]\SDGN¿Z = QD F] HQ LH U DQ JD
6WUDWHJLF]QH 'RW\F]ÌFHUHDOL]DFMLNOXF]RZ\FKFHO¿ZILUP\QS]NOXF]RZ\PLQZHVWRUHPZDOLDQVDFKVWUDWHJLF]Q\FKLWS 7DNW\F]QH 6WZDU]DMÌFHZDUXQNLGRUHDOL]DFML]DGDØQSGRW\F]ÌFHXP¿Z]GRVWDZFDPLNRRSHUDQWDPLLWS & ]ÖV WR WO LZ RÎ Ð Z \V WÖ SR Z DQ LD
2SHUDF\MQH %H]SRÎUHGQLRSU]\UHDOL]DFMLSURFHV¿ZJÊRZQLHZHZVS¿ÊG]LDÊDQLXLSU]\HOLPLQRZDQLX]DNÊ¿FHØLNRQIOLNW¿ZZHZQÖWU]Q\FK 3RZWDU]DOQH UXW\QRZH 5HDOL]RZDQHZLHORNURWQLH ILUPDSRVLDGDV]HUHJGRÎZLDGF]HØ QSW\SRZH WUDQVDNFMHNXSQDVSU]HGDÔ\PDWHULDÊ¿Z SURGXNW¿Z ]LFKGRVWDZFDPL RGELRUFDPL PDMÌZZLÖNV]RÎFLFKDUDNWHURSHUDF\MQ\QLHNLHG\WDNW\F]Q\ SU]\GXÔ\FKPRÔOLZRÎFLDFKZVSRPDJDQLDRUJDQL]DF\MQHJRVWRVRZDQLH VWDQGDUGRZ\FKSURFHGXU]DVDGLWS 6SRUDG\F]QH EH]SUHFHGHQ VRZH :\VWÖSXMÌFHRNUHVRZR QDZHWMHGQRUD]RZR QSGRW\F]ÌFHIX]ML]LQQ\PL SRGPLRWDPLF]\ZUDPDFKUHVWUXNWXU\]DFMLILUP\ ]Z\NOHVWUDWHJLF]QH SU]\]QDF]QHMSRWU]HELHQLH]EÖGQHJRZVSDUFLDRUJDQL]DF\MQHJR EUDN]D VDGSURFHGXULWS ÑU¿GÊR 2SUDFRZDQLHZÊDVQH
Tabela 2.7\SRORJLDQHJRFMDFMLZSU]HGVLÖELRUVWZLH NU\WHULDSRPRFQLF]H .U\WHULD 7\S\QHJRFMDFML &KDUDNWHU\VW\ND SRGW\S\SU]\NÊDG\LWS 1 DV WD Z LH QL H GR QH JR FM DF ML >: DO WR Q 0 F. HU VL H @ 5R]G]LHODMÌFH G\VWU\EXW\ZQH 1DVWDZLRQHQDU\ZDOL]DFMÖLLQG\ZLGXDOQÌUHDOL]DFMÖFHO¿ZÔÌGDQLH NRU]\ÎFLSU]\NRQLHF]QRÎFLSRG]LDÊXRJUDQLF]RQ\FK]DVRE¿Z,QDF]HM SR]\F\MQHZ\JUDQDSU]HJUDQDWDUJRZDQLHSR]\F\MQH JUDRVXPLH ]HURZHM ,QWHJUXMÌFH LQWHJUDW\ZQH =RULHQWRZDQHQDZVS¿ÊG]LDÊDQLHLZVS¿OQHUR]ZLÌ]\ZDQLHSUREOHP¿Z WZRU]HQLHNRU]\ÎFLSU]\PRÔOLZRÎFL]ZLÖNV]HQLD]DVRE¿Z,QDF]HM SUREOHPRZHZ\JUDQDZ\JUDQDWDUJRZDQLHRSDUWHRLQWHUHV\ JUDRVX PLHQLH]HURZHM ,O RÎ Ð XF ]H VW QL N¿ Z > . DP LØ VN L V @ 'ZXVWURQQH pZ]DMHPQH]DOHÔQRÎFLLUHODFMHVWURQVÌMHGQR]QDF]QHLSURVWH VWRVXQNRZRÊDWZHGR]LGHQW\ILNRZDQLDLDQDOL]\ pSU]\SRGHMPRZDQLXGHF\]MLGOD]DZDUFLDSRUR]XPLHQLDZ\PDJDQD MHVWDNFHSWDFMDREXVWURQ pZ\VWÖSXMÌZ]DMHPQHUHDNFMHVWURQQDVZRMH]DFKRZDQLD pSURFHV\NRPXQLNDFMLZ\PLDQ\LWZRU]HQLDZDUWRÎFLRGE\ZDMÌVLÖ ZUDPDFKUHODFMLGZXVWURQQ\FK pZ\VWÖSXMÌGZLHSRGVWDZRZHVWUDWHJLHQHJRFMDFML ZVS¿ÊG]LDÊDQLD LZVS¿Ê]DZRGQLFWZD HZHQWXDOQLHLFKPRG\ILNDFMH :LHORVWURQQH pZ]DMHPQH]DOHÔQRÎFLLUHODFMHVWURQVÌQLHMHGQR]QDF]QH LVNRPSOLNRZDQHWUXGQHGRRSLVDQLDLDQDOL]\ pSU]\GRFKRG]HQLXGRSRUR]XPLHQLDDNFHSWDFMDSU]H]ZV]\VWNLFK XF]HVWQLN¿ZQLH]DZV]HMHVWQLH]EÖGQDL?OXEPRÔOLZD p]DFKRZDQLDVWURQRGQRV]ÌVLÖGR]QDF]QLHV]HUV]HJR LZLHORZ\PLDURZHJRNRQWHNVWX pPDPLHMVFHZ\VRND]ÊRÔRQRÎÐSURFHV¿ZNRPXQLNDFMLZ\PLDQ\ LWZRU]HQLDZDUWRÎFLZQHJRFMDFMDFK pZ\VWÖSXMHZLÖNV]DOLF]EDPRÔOLZ\FKVWUDWHJLLVWURQ & HO Q HJ RF MD FM L LF KD UD NW HU N RQ IO LN WX >0 HV MD V] @ :ZDUXQNDFK SU]\PXVX :\VWÖSXMHNRQIOLNWRGXÔ\PQDWÖÔHQLXPLHU]RQ\PLVWRWQÌUR]ELHÔQR ÎFLÌLQWHUHV¿ZVWDQRZLVNF]\WHÔQRUP ZDUWRÎFL ZLQQ\PXMÖFLX SURZDG]RQHJG\QLHPDPRÔOLZRÎFLZ\ERUXSDUWQHUD >'ÌEURZVNL V@ :ZDUXQNDFK GREURZROQRÎFL &HOHPQHJRFMDFMLMHVW]DZDUFLHWUDQVDNFMLSRSU]H]SU]\JRWRZDQLHNRQ WUDNWX XPRZ\ LQDF]HM SURZDG]RQHJG\LVWQLHMHPRÔOLZRÎÐZ\ERUXSDUWQHUD 8]JRGQLHQLD 1LHPDNRQIOLNWXLQWHUHV¿ZVWURQDUR]ELHÔQRÎFLGRW\F]ÌDVSHNW¿ZWHFKQLF]Q\FKQSNRRUG\QDFMLWHUPLQ¿Z 3 U] HG P LR W ] DN UH V
3URVWH 2GQRV]ÌFHVLÖGRMHGQHMNZHVWLL MHGQRNU\WHULDOQH QSZ\VRNRÎFLZ\QDJURG]HØZQHJRFMDFMDFKSÊDFRZ\FKOXESU]\FHORZ\P X]JRGQLR Q\P ]DZÖÔHQLX]DNUHVXQHJRFMDFML Z\VWÖSXMÌU]DGNR =ÊRÔRQH 'RW\F]ÌFHZLHOX]DJDGQLHØ ZLHORNU\WHULDOQH]REVFKHPDWZ>0H VMDV]V@ QSSU]\WUDQVDNFMDFKKDQGORZ\FKqFHQ\DVRU W\PHQWXWHUPLQXSÊDWQRÎFLLWSqZ\VWÖSXMÌZ]GHF\GRZDQHMZLÖNV]R ÎFLSU]\SDGN¿ZZILUPLH ÑU¿GÊR 2SUDFRZDQLHZÊDVQH
6SHF\ILF]QHFHFK\LURG]DMHQHJRFMDFML 3U]\UR]ZLÌ]\ZDQLXSUDNW\F]Q\FKSUREOHP¿ZZUR]ZDÔDQ\PREV]DU]HQLH ]EÖGQ\PX]XSHÊQLHQLHPSU]HGVWDZLRQHMW\SRORJLLMHVW]MHGQHMVWURQ\GRNRQDQLH SRJÊÖELRQHMFKDUDNWHU\VW\NLSRV]F]HJ¿OQ\FKSU]\SDGN¿ZUR]ZDÔDQ\FKQHJRFMDFML D]GUXJLHMZ\RGUÖEQLHQLHLFKEDUG]LHMV]F]HJ¿ÊRZ\FKW\S¿Z 3RSLHUZV]HZLÖNV]RÎÐSU]\SDGN¿ZQHJRFMDF\MQ\FKPDVSHF\ILF]Q\FKDUDN WHUZ\PDJDUR]ZLÌ]DQLDV]HUHJXV]F]HJ¿ÊRZ\FKSUREOHP¿ZZNRQWHNÎFLHGDQHM G]LHG]LQ\G]LDÊDOQRÎFL'RW\F]\WR]ZÊDV]F]DQHJRFMDFML]HZQÖWU]Q\FKR]QDF]H QLXVWUDWHJLF]Q\PQS]SRWHQFMDOQ\PNOXF]RZ\PLQZHVWRUHPZSURFHVLHUHVWUXN WXU\]DFMLILUP\DWDNÔHQLHNW¿U\FKQHJRFMDFMLZHZQÖWU]Q\FKQS]ELRURZ\FK2WR SU]\NÊDG\RSUDFRZDØGRW\F]ÌF\FKZ\EUDQ\FKURG]DM¿ZQHJRFMDFML p ]ELRURZ\FK>:DOWRQ0F.HUVLH @L>%RUNRZVND @ p Z]DNUHVLHDOLDQV¿ZVWUDWHJLF]Q\FK>&KZLVWHFND'XGHN6URNDV @
p GRW\F]ÌF\FK IX]ML L SU]HMÖÐ >&KZLVWHFND'XGHN @ >)UHXQG @ L>.R]LQD@ p Z]DNUHVLHUHVWUXNWXU\]DFMLILUP\q>.R]LQD'UDXV@ p ZSURFHVLHWZRU]HQLDEXGÔHWX>'UXU\ V @>)LVKHULLQQL @ p ZG]LHG]LQLH]DU]ÌG]DQLD]DVREDPLOXG]NLPL>7\UDØVND.R]LQD@ p NUHG\WRZ\FK>0HVMDV]@ p ]DRSDWU]HQLRZ\FK>3HUURWLQ+HXVFKHQ @ 1HJRFMDFMHZHZQÌWU]RUJDQL]DF\MQHRP¿ZLRQRZ>%D]HUPDQ/HZLFNL @L>6KHSSDUGLLQQL @DZ>1DXWD6DQGHUV@SU]HGVWDZLRQRLFKQDM EDUG]LHMW\SRZ\SU]\SDGHNWMPLÖG]\Z\G]LDÊDPL1LHNW¿UHSU]\SDGNLUR]ZD ÔDQ\FKQHJRFMDFMLQLH]RVWDÊ\ZGRVWDWHF]Q\PVWRSQLXSRGGDQHNRQFHSWXDOL]DFML QSGRW\F]ÌFHXEH]SLHF]HØDOLDQV¿ZVWUDWHJLF]Q\FKF]\]DU]ÌG]DQLDSURMHNWD PL 3RGUXJLHX]XSHÊQLHQLHPW\SRORJLLQHJRFMDFML]HZQÖWU]Q\FKMHVWSU]\NÊDGR ZHUR]U¿ÔQLHQLHSRG]LDÊIRUPZVS¿ÊG]LDÊDQLD NRRSHUDFMLLNRQFHQWUDFML ILUP\ ]SRGPLRWDPLRWRF]HQLD p EH]XPRZQHZ\PLDQDZ]DMHPQLHGRVWRVRZDQ\FKÎZLDGF]HØQD]DVDGDFK KDQGORZ\FKZ]DMHPQLH]JRGQH]DFKRZDQLDU\QNRZH ZV\WXDFMDFKNRQ NXUHQF\MQRÎFL p XPRZQHNXSQDVSU]HGDÔ\NRRSHUDF\MQH NRRSHUDFMDSURGXNF\MQD LQQH QSNDUWHORZH NRQVRUFMXPG]LHUÔDZDOHDVLQJLZVS¿OQHSU]HGVLÖZ]LÖFLD ZW\PVS¿ÊNL
p NRRUG\QDF\MQH ]U]HV]HQLH GREURZROQH L]ED JRVSRGDUF]D V\QG\NDW FHFK
p NRQFHQWUDF\MQH ]ZDUWH SU]HGVLÖELRUVWZR ZLHOR]DNÊDGRZH >/LFKWDUVNL
V@ 0QRJRÎÐLU¿ÔQRURGQRÎÐZVS¿ÊF]HVQ\FKIRUPNRRSHUDFMLLLQWHJUDFMLSU]HGVLÖ ELRUVWZWDNLFKMDNQSIX]MHLSU]HMÖFLDDOLDQVHVWUDWHJLF]QHNRQFHUQ\LKROGLQJL VLHFLLJURQDRUD]LFKG\QDPLNDLZ]DMHPQHSU]HQLNDQLHVLÖ]QDF]QLHXWUXGQLDLFK W\SRORJLÖQSZ>*UXG]HZVNL+HMGXNV @Z\PLHQLDVLÖNLOND QDÎFLHHOHPHQW¿ZVWUXNWXUDOQ\FKSRZLÌ]DØNRQWUDNWRZ\FKXF]HVWQLN¿Z]JUXSR ZDQLD QSZVS¿OQHSU]HGVLÖZ]LÖFLDOLFHQFMHSRUR]XPLHQLDNRQWUDNW\LWS L W\S¿ZDOLDQV¿Z>@ . :FHOXX]XSHÊQLHQLDSRZ\ÔV]HMW\SRORJLLQDOHÔ\Z]LÌÐSRGXZDJÖGZLHNODV\ ILNDFMHNRQIOLNW¿ZQDMZDÔQLHMV]HGODRSLVXQHJRFMDFMLZILUPLHq]HZ]JOÖGXQD p SRGPLRW\ XF]HVWQLN¿Z NRQIOLNWX >5DKLP @ ZHZQÖWU]Q\ X GDQHM RVRE\ PLÖG]\SRV]F]HJ¿OQ\PLRVREDPLMHGQRVWNÌDJUXSÌJUXSDPLRU JDQL]DFMDPL p QDWXUÖLSU]\F]\Q\NRQIOLNWX>0RRUH V@ QLHSRWU]HEQHZDUWR ÎFLUHODFMLGDQ\FK VXELHNW\ZQH LSUDZG]LZHGDQ\FK RELHNW\ZQH LQWH UHV¿ZVWUXNWXUDOQ\ 8ZDJLNRÎFRZH 5HDVXPXMÌFSURSRQRZDQDW\SRORJLDZVND]XMHQDZ\VWÖSRZDQLHZLHOXV\WX DFMLQHJRFMDF\MQ\FK]U¿ÔQLFRZDQ\FKFRGRVWURQFHO¿ZL]DNUHVXVWRSQLD]ÊRÔR QRÎFL3URZDG]HQLHQHJRFMDFMLMHVWERZLHPLPPDQHQWQÌFHFKÌILUP\VÌRQHQD WXUDOQÌNRQVHNZHQFMÌMHMIXQNFMRQRZDQLDMDNRV]F]HJ¿OQHJRURG]DMXRUJDQL]DFML =GUXJLHMVWURQ\cRUJDQL]DFMDQHJRFMXMHFKRFLDÔQLHZV]\VWNRQLH]HZV]\VWNLPL LQLHZHZV]\VWNLFKV\WXDFMDFKPRÔH FKRÐQLHPXVL QHJRFMRZDÐo>5]ÌGFD V@ -DNVLÖZ\GDMHSU]HGVWDZLRQDSURSR]\FMDVWDQRZLXÔ\WHF]QHQDU]ÖG]LHSODQR ZDQLDUR]ZDÔDQ\FKQHJRFMDFML1DMLVWRWQLHMV]HMHM]DOHW\WRXQLZHUVDOQRÎÐLZLHOR Z\PLDURZRÎÐSRGHMÎFLD=GUXJLHMMHGQDNVWURQ\QLH]EÖGQHMHVWMHMGRVNRQDOHQLH ZUDPDFKGDOV]\FKEDGDØDXWRUD JÊ¿ZQLHSRGNÌWHP NRQNUHW\]DFMLLRSHUDFMRQL]DFMLSDUDPHWU¿ZRSLVXMÌF\FKSRV]F]HJ¿OQHW\S\ QHJRFMDFML
Z]ERJDFHQLD V]F]HJ¿ÊRZ\FK QDU]ÖG]L PHWRG\F]Q\FK LFK LGHQW\ILNDFML LDQDOL]\ :\PDJDQDMHVWWDNÔHHPSLU\F]QDZHU\ILNDFMDSURSRQRZDQHMNRQFHSFMLZED GDQLDFKSRU¿ZQDZF]\FKGRW\F]ÌF\FKU¿ÔQRURGQ\FKQHJRFMDFMLZSU]HGVLÖELRU VWZLH]DU¿ZQRW\SRZ\FK SRZWDU]DOQ\FK MDNLEH]SUHFHGHQVRZ\FKR]QDF]H QLXVWUDWHJLF]Q\P =RELQQHW\SRORJLHQSZ >%ULOPDQVLQ@>&KZLVWHFND'XGHN6URNDV@>&\JOHUV LQ@>'XUDMVLQ@L>6WUDWHJRU V LQ@
/LWHUDWXUD
%D]HUPDQ 0+ /HZLFNL 5- UHG 1HJRWLDWLQJ LQ 2UJDQL]DWLRQV Sage Publications%HYHUO\+LOOV
%D]HUPDQ0+/HZLFNL5-Contemporary Research Directions in WKH6WXG\RI1HJRWLDWLRQVLQ2UJDQL]DWLRQV $6HOHFWLYH2YHUYLHZn-R XUQDORI2FFXSDWLRQDO%HKDYLRXUo YRO %RUNRZVND61HJRFMDFMH]ELRURZH3:(:DUV]DZD %ULOPDQ-1RZRF]HVQHNRQFHSFMHLPHWRG\]DU]ÌG]DQLD3:(:DU V]DZD &KZLVWHFND'XGHN+)X]MHLSU]HM§FLDxID]DQHJRFMDF\MQDo3U]HJOÌG 2UJDQL]DFMLoQU
&KZLVWHFND'XGHN + 6URND : $OLDQVH VWUDWHJLF]QH 3UREOHP\ WHR-rii i dylematy praktyki:\GDZQLFWZR3URIHVMRQDOQHM6]NRÊ\%L]QHVX .UDN¿Z
&\JOHU-$OLDQVHVWUDWHJLF]QH'LILQ:DUV]DZD
'ÌEURZVNL3-3UDNW\F]QDWHRULDQHJRFMDFML6RUERJ:DUV]DZD 'UXU\&5DFKXQHNNRV]WÕZ:SURZDG]HQLH:\GDZQLFWZR1DXNRZH
3:1:DUV]DZD
'XUDM - 3RGVWDZ\ HNRQRPLNL SU]HGVL§ELRUVWZD 3:( :DUV]DZD
)LVKHU-*)UHGHULFNVRQ-53HIIHU6$%XGJHWLQJ $Q([SHULPHQ-tal Investigation of the Effects of Negotiation n7KH $FFRXQWLQJ 5H YLHZoYROQU )UHXQG-&0HUJHU1HJRWLDWLRQV Z 0/5RFN UHG 7KH0HUJHUV $FTXLVLWLRQV+DQGERRN0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ<RUN *UXG]HZVNL0+HMGXN,. UHG 3U]HGVL§ELRUVWZRSU]\V]ãR¢FL'LILQ :DUV]DZD .DPLØVNL - 1HJRFMRZDQLH 7HFKQLNL UR]ZLc]\ZDQLD NRQIOLNWÕZ 3R OWH[W:DUV]DZD .R]LQD$1HJRFMDFMHZSURFHVDFKIX]MLLSU]HM¢éc=DU]ÌG]DQLH=DVR EDPL/XG]NLPLoQU .R]LQD$0RGHOQHJRFMDFMLMDNRLQVWUXPHQWX]DU]cG]DQLDILUPc Z ,QVWUXPHQW\]DU]cG]DQLDZHZVSÕãF]HVQ\PSU]HGVL§ELRUVWZLH$QDOL]D krytycznaUHG.=LPQLHZLF]:\GDZQLFWZR$NDGHPLL(NRQRPLF] QHMZ3R]QDQLXc=HV]\W\1DXNRZHoQU3R]QDØ .R]LQD$'UDXV01HJRFMDFMHZSURFHVLHUHVWUXNWXU\]DFMLILUP\ Z =PLDQDZDUXQNLHPVXNFHVX7UDQVIRUPDFMDSU]HGVL§ELRUVWZxSUREOH-P\PHWRG\HIHNW\UHG-6NDOLNc3UDFH1DXNRZH$(ZH:URFÊDZLXo QU
/HZLFNL5-6DXQGHUV'0%DUU\%0LQWRQ-:=DVDG\QHJRFMDFML
.RPSHQGLXP ZLHG]\ GOD WUHQHUÕZ L PHQHGHUÕZ 'RP :\GDZQLF]\ 5HELV3R]QDØ /LFKWDUVNL- UHG 3RGVWDZ\QDXNLRSU]HGVL§ELRUVWZLH:\GDZQLFWZR $(ZH:URFÊDZLX:URFÊDZ 0HVMDV]&'HWHUPLQDQW\LPRGHOHSURFHVÕZQHJRFMDFMLNUHG\WRZ\FK SRPL§G]\EDQNLHPDSU]HGVL§ELRUVWZHP:\GDZQLFWZR$(Z.UDNR ZLH.UDN¿Z
0RRUH&:The Mediation Process: Practical Strategies for Resolving Conflicts-RVVH\%DVV3XEOLFDWLRQV6DQ)UDQFLVFR
1DXWD$6DQGHUV.Interdepartamental Negotiation Behavior in Ma-QXIDFWXULQJ2UJDQL]DWLRQVn7KH,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI&RQIOLFW0D QDJHPHQWoYROQU
1HJRFMDFMHHarvard Business Essentials07%L]QHV/WG.RQVWDQFLQ -H]LRUQD 3HUURWLQ5+HXVFKHQ3.XSLé]]\VNLHP1HJRFMDFMHKDQGORZH3R OWH[W:DUV]DZD 5DKLP0$0DQDJLQJ&RQIOLFWLQ2UJDQL]DWLRQV3UDHJHU3XEOLVKHUV 1HZ<RUN 5]ÌGFD51HJRFMDFMHZLQWHUHVDFK3:(:DUV]DZD 6KHSSDUG%+%D]HUPDQ0+/HZLFNL5- UHG Research on Nego-WLDWLRQLQ2UJDQL]DWLRQV$%LDQQXDO5HVHDUFK6HULHV-$,3UHVV,QF 9ROXPH*UHHQZLFK 6WUDWHJRU=DU]cG]DQLHILUPc6WUDWHJLH6WUXNWXU\'HF\]MH7RVDPR¢é. 3:(:DUV]DZD 7\UDØVND0.R]LQD$1HJRFMDFMHZ]DU]cG]DQLX]DVREDPLOXG]NLPL >Z @,QQRZDF\MQR¢éZHZVSÕãF]HVQ\FKRUJDQL]DFMDFKSRGUHG$6WD EU\Ê\:\GDZQLFWZR$(Z.UDNRZLH.UDN¿Z :DOWRQ5(0F.HUVLH5%$%HKDYLRUDO7KHRU\2I/DERU1HJRWLD-WLRQV $Q$QDO\VLV2I$6RFLDO,QWHUDFWLRQ6\VWHP0F*UDZ+LOO%RRN &RPSDQ\1HZ<RUN
