5. Ceny w łańcuchu marketingowym żywności
5.1. Relacje i rozstępy cenowe – istota i kierunki zmian w świetle literatury
5. Ceny w łańcuchu marketingowym żywności
5R]G]LDá WHQ SRĞZLĊFRQR RFHQLH ZVSyá]DOHĪQRĞFL PLĊG]\ FHQDPL Z áDĔ
FXFKXPDUNHWLQJRZ\PĪ\ZQRĞFL1DSRGVWDZLHSU]HJOąGXOLWHUDWXU\LZ\QLNyZ
EDGDĔZáDVQ\FKRGQLHVLRQRVLĊGR]PLDQUR]VWĊSyZFHQRZ\FKPLĊG]\FHQąGH
WDOLF]Qą D FHQą VXURZFyZ UROQ\FK Z 3ROVFH 3U]HGVWDZLRQR G\QDPLNĊ FHQ
ZáDĔFXFKXPDUNHWLQJRZ\PGODQDMZDĪQLHMV]\FKNRV]\NyZFHQRZ\FKRUD]Z\
EUDQ\FKSURGXNWyZZ3ROVFHZODWDFK$QDOL]RZDQR]DUyZQR]DOHĪ
QRĞFLGáXJRRNUHVRZHLSU]\F]\QRZHPLĊG]\W\PLFHQDPLMDNLPQRĪQLNLREUD
]XMąFHZSá\ZFHQUROQ\FKLNRV]WyZPDUNHWLQJRZ\FKQDFHQ\GHWDOLF]QH
5.1. Relacje i rozstępy cenowe – istota i kierunki zmian w świetle literatury
Istota rozstępów cenowych
.OXF]RZ\SUREOHPSRGQRV]RQ\SRGF]DVEDGDĔRGQRĞQLHFHQGHWDOLF]Q\FK
Ī\ZQRĞFLGRW\F]\]ZLą]NXPLĊG]\FHQąGHWDOLF]QąSURGXNWXDZDUWRĞFLąZ\NR
U]\VWDQHJRGRMHMSURGXNFMLVXURZFDUROQHJR2LOHUR]VWU]\JQLĊFLHWHJRSUREOH
PX Z SU]\SDGNX SURGXNWyZ QLHSU]HWZRU]RQ\FK OXE VáDER SU]HWZRU]RQ\FK QLH
QDVWUĊF]DZLHOXWUXGQRĞFLRGSRZLHGĨQDWRS\WDQLHZSU]\SDGNXSURGXNWXSU]H
WZRU]RQHJROXEVNáDGDMąFHJRVLĊ]ZLHOXNRPSRQHQWyZVXURZFRZ\FKZ\PDJD
QLHW\ONR]QDMRPRĞFLWHFKQRORJLLSURGXNFMLQLHU]DGNRKHWHURJHQLF]QHMLXOHJDMą
FHM]PLDQRPZF]DVLHDOHWDNĪHZ\FHQ\SRV]F]HJyOQ\FKNRPSRQHQWyZVXURZ
FD Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQHJR Z SURFHVLH SURGXNFML : HIHNFLH Z SUDNW\FH DQDOL]\
RJUDQLF]DMąVLĊGREDGDQLDUHODFMLOXEW]ZUR]VWĊSyZFHQRZ\FK
5R]VWĊSFHQRZ\ܴܥZXMĊFLXZ]JOĊGQ\PGHILQLXMHVLĊMDNRVWRVXQHNUyĪ
QLF\FHQ\GHWDOLF]QHMSURGXNWXĪ\ZQRĞFLRZHJRܥLFHQ\VXURZFDUROQHJRܥܴ
GRFHQ\VXURZFDUROQHJRܴܥ ൌିோ
ோ 3RSRPQRĪHQLXSU]H]SR]ZDODRQQD
RNUHĞOHQLHLOHSURFHQWFHQ\VXURZFDUROQHJRVWDQRZLUyĪQLFDPLĊG]\FHQąILQDO
QąDFHQąVXURZFD-HJRSRGVWDZąMHVWUHODFMDFHQ\GHWDOLF]QHMGRFHQ\VXURZFD
UROQHJRZ\UDĪDMąFDVLĊZ]RUHPܴ ൌோ.RQVHNZHQWQLH]ZLą]HNPLĊG]\UR]
VWĊSHP Z]JOĊGQ\P D SRZ\ĪV]ą UHODFMą FHQRZą SU]\ELHUD QDVWĊSXMąFą SRVWDü
ܴܥ ൌ ܴ െ ͳ >*DUGQHU )LJLHO L 5HPELV] @ 2GQRV]ąF VLĊ GR EDGDĔ
LLFKLQWHUSUHWDFML]DZDUW\FKZGDOV]HMF]ĊĞFLRSUDFRZDQLDZDUWRSRGNUHĞOLüĪH
Z]JOĊGQ\UR]VWĊSFHQRZ\LUHODFMDFHQGHWDOLF]Q\FKGRFHQUROQ\FKVąXMHPQLH
VNRUHORZDQH$EVROXWQHUR]VWĊS\FHQRZHGHILQLRZDQHVąQDWRPLDVWMDNRUyĪQLFD
PLĊG]\FHQąGHWDOLF]QąDFHQąZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQHJRVXURZFD
3RGNUHĞOLüQDOHĪ\ĪHSU]\VSHáQLHQLXSU]\MPRZDQHJR]DáRĪHQLDRVWDáRĞFL
WHFKQRORJLL Z\QLNL WHJR W\SX DQDOL] GRVWDUF]DMą ZLHOX LQIRUPDFML QD WHPDW
]PLDQFHQGHWDOLF]Q\FKĪ\ZQRĞFLZF]DVLH1DMZLĊNV]\PPLQXVHPWHMPHWRG\
MHVWMHGQDNWRĪHXG]LDáGDQHJRVXURZFDZFHQLHSURGXNWXSR]RVWDMH]D]Z\F]DM
QLH]QDQ\LPRĪHXOHJDü]PLDQRPZF]DVLH
Przegląd literatury światowej
$QDOL]ą UR]VWĊSyZ FHQRZ\FK Z ĞZLHFLH ]DMPRZDOL VLĊ PLQ 3LHWROD
>@ GOD )LQODQGLL F]\ WHĪ 6FKOXWHU L LQ >@ GOD 86$ $XWRUHP MHGQHJR
]QDMQRZV]\FKRSUDFRZDĔRGQRĞQLHUR]VWĊSyZPLĊG]\FHQDPLUROQ\PLDGHWD
OLF]Q\PLZ86$MHVW6FKQHSI>@3RGNUHĞOLáRQĪHFKDUDNWHUWUDQVPLVMLFHQ
PLĊG]\ SR]LRPHP UROQLND D GHWDOLVW\ ]DOHĪ\ RG UR]PLDUX XG]LDáX FHQ\ UROQHM
ZFHQLHGHWDOLVW\LVWRSQLDNRQNXUHQFMLU\QNRZHMQDNDĪG\P]SR]LRPyZáDĔFX
FKD GRVWDZ 3U]\NáDGRZR XG]LDá UROQLND Z FHQLH GHWDOLF]QHM WX]LQD MDM VLĊJD
ZSU]\SDGNXFHQGHWDOLF]Q\FKZLĊNV]RĞFLĞZLHĪ\FK PLĊVMHVWWR
1DWRPLDVWZSU]\SDGNXFHQSáDWNyZĞQLDGDQLRZ\FKLSLHF]\ZDMHVWWR]DOHGZLH
$XWRU]DXZDĪ\áWDNĪHĪHXG]LDáFHQ\VXURZFDZFHQLHGHWDOLF]QHM]PQLHM
V]DVLĊQDNDĪG\PHWDSLHáDĔFXFKDGRVWDZSRUXV]DMąFVLĊZNLHUXQNXNRQVXPHQ
WDĝUHGQLDZLHONRĞüWHJRXG]LDáXZFDáNRZLW\FKZ\GDWNyZNRQVXPHQWDVSDGáD
]ZURNXGRZURNX7RZDU]\V]\áWHPXVáDEQąF\ZSá\Z
]PLDQFHQVXURZFDQDFHQĊGHWDOLF]Qą
3RND]DQRSRQDGWRĪHSU]\F]\QRZRĞüELHJQLHRG]PLDQZFHQLHVXURZFDGR
]PLDQZFHQLHGHWDOLF]QHMRUD]ĪHRSyĨQLHQLDZRGSRZLHG]LFHQ\GHWDOLF]QHMQD
]PLDQ\FHQVXURZFyZVLĊJDMą]D]Z\F]DMNLONXPLHVLĊF\QDZHWZSU]\SDGNXSUR
GXNWyZV]\ENRSVXMąF\FKVLĊMDNPOHNRPLĊVDĞZLHĪHRZRFHF]\ZDU]\ZD2ND
]DáRVLĊWDNĪHĪHFHQ\GHWDOLF]QHRGSRZLDGDMąDV\PHWU\F]QLH±GRVWRVRZDQLDGR
Z]URVWyZZFHQLHVXURZFD]DFKRG]ąV]\EFLHML]Z\ĪV]\Ppass-throughQLĪGR
VWRVRZDQLDZSU]\SDGNXVSDGNyZFHQVXURZFDFRĞZLDGF]\RV]W\ZQRĞFLFHQGH
WDOLF]Q\FK ± URVQą RQH Z HIHNFLH Z]URVWX FHQ VXURZFD OHF] VSDGDMą SRZROL
LW\ONRF]ĊĞFLRZRJG\FHQ\VXURZFyZVSDGDMą$XWRU]DXZDĪ\áSU]\W\PLĪPL
PR GRZRGyZ HPSLU\F]Q\FK QD V]W\ZQRĞü FHQ GHWDOLF]Q\FK EUDNXMH WHRULL HNR
QRPLF]QHMGRNáDGQLHWáXPDF]ąFHMWDNRZH]DFKRZDQLH=DXZDĪDVLĊĪHRJUDQLF]H
QLX GRVWRVRZDĔ FHQ GHWDOLF]Q\FK PRJą VSU]\MDü ]DFKRZDQLD NRQVXPHQWyZ
]DU]ąG]DQLH]DSDVDPLVWUDWHJLHGHWDOLVWyZZHIHNFLHF]HJRDV\PHWU\F]QDWUDQVPL
VMDFHQQLHPXVLR]QDF]DüZ\ZLHUDQLDQDGPLHUQHMVLá\U\QNRZHM>6FKQHSI@
:V]F]HJyOQRĞFLDXWRUWHQGRNRQDáSRUyZQDĔPLHVLĊF]Q\FKĞUHGQLFKFHQ
VNXSXVXURZFyZSR]LRPJRVSRGDUVWZDRUD]LQGHNVyZFHQSURGXFHQWDSR]LRP
KXUWRZQL ] LQGHNVDPL FHQ NRQVXPHQFNLFK GOD JáyZQ\FK JUXS SURGXNWRZ\FK
SR]LRPGHWDOLVW\EH]SU]HOLF]DQLDQDNLORJUDP\'RGDWNRZR]HVWDZLHQLHFHQ
VXURZFD]FHQDPLGHWDOLF]Q\PLZ\EUDQ\FKSURGXNWyZĪ\ZQRĞFLRZ\FKUyZQLHĪ
EH]SU]HOLF]DQDQDWHVDPHMHGQRVWNLXPRĪOLZLáRVWZLHUG]HQLHUyĪQLFZNLHUXQ
NDFKLZLHONRĞFLDFKRGSRZLHG]LQD]PLDQ\REXURG]DMyZFHQ1DOHĪ\GRGDüĪH
EUDN SU]HOLF]DQLD QD WDNLH VDPH MHGQRVWNL PDV\ XQLHPRĪOLZLD XVWRVXQNRZDQLH
VLĊGRZLHONRĞFLPDUĪPDUNHWLQJRZ\FK0LPREUDNXWHJRNURNXRND]DáRVLĊĪH
FHQ\GHWDOLF]QHDQDOL]RZDQ\FKSURGXNWyZVąZ\VRFHVNRUHORZDQH]FHQDPLVX
URZFyZLZZLĊNV]RĞFLSU]\SDGNyZUHDJXMą]SHZQ\PRSyĨQLHQLHP
Przegląd literatury krajowej
$QDOL]ą UR]VWĊSyZ L UHODFML FHQRZ\FK QD SROVNLP U\QNX UROQR
Ī\ZQRĞFLRZ\P]DMPRZDOLVLĊPLQ)LJLHOL3RSLRáHN>@5HPEH]DL6HUH
PDN%XOJH >@ +DPXOF]XN L 6WDĔNR > @ F]\ +DPXOF]XN L LQ
>@:ZLĊNV]RĞFLSU]\SDGNyZDQDOL]RZDQRUR]VWĊS\ZXMĊFLXZ]JOĊGQ\P
'DOHMSU]\EOLĪ\P\QDMZDĪQLHMV]HZQLRVNL]LFKEDGDĔ
)LJLHOL3RSLRáHN>@ZRSDUFLXRGDQH]ODWGRNRQDOLQDMV]HU
V]HMDQDOL]\UR]VWĊSyZFHQRZ\FK-HMSU]HGPLRWHPE\á\DEVROXWQHUR]VWĊS\FHQR
ZHZXMĊFLXQRPLQDOQ\PLUHDOQ\PLFK]PLHQQRĞüVWUXNWXUDFHQZáDĔFXFKDFK
PDUNHWLQJRZ\FK SURGXNWyZ L ]ZLą]NL UR]VWĊSyZ FHQRZ\FK PLĊG]\ JáyZQ\PL
RJQLZDPLáDĔFXFKDPDUNHWLQJRZHJRVNXSSU]HWZyUVWZRLGHWDOGODZ\EUDQ\FK
SURGXNWyZ Ī\ZQRĞFLRZ\FK MDN UyZQLHĪ ZLHONRĞü UR]VWĊSyZ FHQRZ\FK QD WOH
ZLHONRĞFL SURGXNFML VXURZFD UROQHJR L SU]HWZRU]RQ\FK SURGXNWyZ Ī\ZQRĞFLR
Z\FK SRGDĪ RUD] LFK VSRĪ\FLD SRS\W $QDOL]RZDQR QDVWĊSXMąF\FK U\QNyZ
]ERĪDLSURGXNW\]ERĪRZHU]HSDNLNRQVXPSF\MQHSURGXNW\ROHMDUVNLHZLHSU]R
ZLQDLSURGXNW\ZLHSU]RZHZRáRZLQDLSURGXNW\ZRáRZHGUyELSURGXNW\GUR
ELRZHPOHNRLSURGXNW\POHF]DUVNLHZVXPLHáDĔFXFKyZPDUNHWLQJRZ\FK
=ZUyFRQR XZDJĊ QD LVWQLHQLH VLOQ\FK ZDKDĔ UR]VWĊSyZ FHQRZ\FK
± Z DQDOL]RZDQ\P RNUHVLH PDNV\PDOQH Z]JOĊGQH VSDGNLZ]URVW\ QLHU]DGNR
SU]HNUDF]Dá\LVWDZDá\VLĊFRUD]VLOQLHMV]HZUD]]SU]HFKRG]HQLHPRGSR
F]ąWNRZHJRGRNRĔFRZHJRRJQLZD2ND]DáRVLĊWDNĪHĪHUXFK\FHQSU]HQRV]R
QHVąDV\PHWU\F]QLH±VNDODPDNV\PDOQ\FKZ]URVWyZUR]VWĊSyZE\áD]D]Z\F]DM
Z\ĪV]DQLĪVNDODLFKPDNV\PDOQ\FKVSDGNyZ&RFLHNDZHRLOHQRPLQDOQHUR]
VWĊS\FHQRZHFKDUDNWHU\]RZDá\WHQGHQFMHZ]URVWRZHSRXZ]JOĊGQLHQLXLQIODFML
REVHUZRZDQRF]ĊVW\WUHQGVSDGNRZ\OXEEUDNWUHQGXSU]\F]\PZ\MąWNLF]\OL
ZLĊNV]\ RG LQIODFML Z]URVW UR]VWĊSyZ PLDá\ PLHMVFH Z SU]\SDGNX ZLĊNV]RĞFL
RJQLZZáDĔFXFKDFKPDUNHWLQJRZ\FKSURGXNWyZ]ERĪRZ\FKROHMDUVNLFKZLH
SU]RZ\FK L ZRáRZ\FK F]HJR SU]\F]\Q XSDWU\ZDQR Z QLHSURSRUFMRQDOQ\FK
]PLDQDFKFHQGHWDOXLSU]HWZyUVWZDZUHDNFMLQDVSDGHNFHQVNXSX2ND]DáRVLĊ
WDNĪH ĪH ZDUWRĞü UR]VWĊSyZ URĞQLH ZUD] ]H VWRSQLHP WUDQVIRUPDFML SURGXNWX
=ZUyFRQRXZDJĊĪHQDU\QNXĪ\ZQRĞFLRZ\PSURFHV\WUDQVIRUPDFMLPDMąPLHM
VFH QD HWDSDFK SU]HWZyUVWZD L KDQGOX NWyU\FK FHOHP MHVW QDGDQLH SURGXNWRP
QRZ\FKFHFKXĪ\WNRZ\FKLZ]URVWLFKZDUWRĞFLF]HPXWRZDU]\V]\XVWDZLF]QH
XVWDODQLH FHQ QD NDĪG\P HWDSLH áDĔFXFKD PDUNHWLQJRZHJR 6WZLHUG]RQR GXĪ\
ZSá\ZF\NOLF]QRĞFLLVH]RQRZRĞFLFHFKXMąF\FKSURGXNFMĊUROQLF]ąQD]PLHQ
QRĞüUR]VWĊSyZ
)LJLHOL3RSLRáHN>@SRGNUHĞOLOLĪHQDFHQ\Ī\ZQRĞFLZSá\ZDMąSRS\W
SUHIHUHQFMHNRQVXPHQWDLSRGDĪNRV]W\PDUNHWLQJRZH.RQVHNZHQWQLHPRĪ
QDSRZLHG]LHüĪHUR]VWĊSFHQRZ\UHSUH]HQWXMHZDUWRĞüGRGDQąQDELHUDQLHZDU
WRĞFLSU]H]SURGXNWZNROHMQ\FKRJQLZDFKáDĔFXFKDLPDUĪĊPDUNHWLQJRZąSR
NU\ZDMąFą NRV]W WUDQVIRUPDFML L GRVWDUF]DQLD SURGXNWX NRQVXPHQWRZL RUD]
]DSHZQLDMąFą ]\VNL = MHGQHM VWURQ\ ERZLHP NRQVXPHQW SRĪąGD SURGXNWyZ
R MDN QDMZLĊNV]HM ZDUWRĞFL GRGDQHM ] GUXJLHM ± QDMOHSLHM DE\ WRZDU]\V]\á PX
MDN QDMQLĪV]\ NRV]W WUDQVIRUPDFML L GRVWDUF]HQLD :]URVW UR]VWĊSX ZLąĪH VLĊ ]H
Z]URVWHP NRV]WyZ RUD] ]\VNyZ QD SRV]F]HJyOQ\FK RJQLZDFK áDĔFXFKD 1D
Z]URVW WHQ ZSá\ZD Z]URVW GRFKRGyZ NRQVXPHQWyZ SRS\WX QD QRZH IRUP\ L
SURGXNW\RZ\VRNLHMMDNRĞFLVWRSQLDSU]HWZRU]HQLDNRV]WyZUHNODP\>0RUULVRQ
@MDNUyZQLHĪQRZHWUHQG\QDU\QNDFKĪ\ZQRĞFLRZ\FK&RMHGQDNFLHND
ZHZ\QLNLEDGDĔ)LJLHODL3RSLRáND>@ĞZLDGF]ąREUDNX]DOHĪQRĞFL]PLDQ
UR]VWĊSyZRGSRS\WXLSRGDĪ\-DNRZ\WáXPDF]HQLHZVND]DOLRQLQLVNąNUyWNRR
NUHVRZą HODVW\F]QRĞü FHQRZą QD U\NDFK UROQRĪ\ZQRĞFLRZ\FK RUD] UR]ZyM
SU]HGáXĪDMąF\FK RNUHV SU]\GDWQRĞFL GR VSRĪ\FLD WHFKQRORJLL SU]HWZyUVWZD
LSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLDNWyUHXPRĪOLZLDMąOHSV]HGRSDVRZDQLHSRGDĪ\GRZ]JOĊGQLH
VWDáHJRSRS\WXQLH]DOHĪQLHRG]PLHQQ\FKFHQVXURZFyZLZLHONRĞFLUR]VWĊSyZ
3U]HGPLRWHP RSUDFRZDQLD 5HPEH]\ L 6HUHPDN%XOJH >@ E\á\ QDWR
PLDVW ]PLDQ\ QD U\QNX POHND ]EyĪ PLĊVD ]LHPQLDNyZ L U\E Z ODWDFK
LLFKZSá\ZQDNV]WDáWRZDQLHVLĊFHQEDGDQ\FKSURGXNWyZLFKZ]DMHPQH
UHODFMHFHQRZHRUD]SURFHVWUDQVPLVMLPLĊG]\SRV]F]HJyOQ\PLHWDSDPLáDĔFX
FKDGRVWDZ:V]F]HJyOQRĞFLQDU\QNDFKPLĊVQ\FKDQDOL]RZDQRZSá\ZVXURZ
FyZQDNRV]\NZLHSU]RZ\VFKDELERF]HNZRáRZ\V]SRQGHUURVWEHIZRáR
ZLQD EH] NRĞFL RUD] NRV]\N SU]HWZRUyZ NLHáEDVD ]Z\F]DMQD WRUXĔVND
SDUyZNLEDOHURQV]\QNDVDOFHVRQ1DZLĊNV]RĞFLDQDOL]RZDQ\FKU\QNyZ]D
REVHUZRZDQRURVQąF\XG]LDáFHQVNXSXZFHQDFKGHWDOLF]Q\FK7\ONRQDU\QNX
]EyĪRND]DáVLĊRQPDOHüQDMVLOQLHMZSU]\SDGNXSLHF]\ZD:SU]\SDGNXU\Q
NyZPLĊVQ\FKVWZLHUG]RQREUDN]PLDQRGSRáRZ\ODW]Z\MąWNLHPZRáRZL
Q\QDWRPLDVWZSU]\SDGNXU\QNXPOHNDXG]LDáWHQUyVáGRURNX]HZ]JOĊ
GX QD ]DNáyFDQLH PHFKDQL]PX U\QNRZHJR SU]H] SROLW\NĊ FHQRZą :35
$QDOL]RZDQRUyĪQLFHORJDU\WPyZFHQSURGXNWyZVSU]HGDZDQ\FKSU]H]]DNáDG\SU]HWZyU
F]H L ]EyĪ PDUĪH SU]HWZyUF]H RUD] UyĪQLFH PLĊG]\ ORJDU\WPDPL FHQ GHWDOLF]Q\PL L FHQ
Z]DNáDGDFKSU]HWZyUF]\FKPDUĪHGHWDOLF]QH
L ZVSDUFLH SURFHVyZ UHVWUXNWXU\]DF\MQ\FK SR F]\P VSDGá Z ]ZLą]NX ] SURFH
VDPL UHVWUXNWXU\]DF\MQ\PL ]ZLą]DQ\PL ] SODQRZDQ\P RGHMĞFLHP RG ZVSDUFLD
U\QNRZHJR
5HPEH]DL6HUHPDN%XOJH>@RGQLHĞOLVLĊWDNĪHGRSRUXV]DQHJRSU]H]
)LJLHODL3RSLRáND>@SUREOHPXURVQąFHMUROLKDQGOXD]ZáDV]F]DVLHFLKDQ
GORZ\FK6WZLHUG]LOLĪH ]MDZLVNRWRMHVWHIHNWHP]E\WZROQ\FK]PLDQVWUXNWXU
SURGXNFML L SU]HWZyUVWZD FR RVáDELD SR]\FMĊ SURGXFHQWyZ L SU]HWZyUFyZ
:ODWDFKSURFHV\NRQFHQWUDFMLLLQWHJUDFMLRND]Dá\VLĊERZLHPZ\VR
FH ]DDZDQVRZDQH MHG\QLH Z SU]\SDGNX U\QNX GURELX SU]HP\VáX SDV]RZHJR
L SU]HWZyUVWZD ]LHPQLDNyZ QD FHOH VSRĪ\ZF]H 0QLHM ]DDZDQVRZDQH SURFHV\
PLDá\ PLHMVFH Z SU]\SDGNX SURGXNFML POHND ]ZáDV]F]D SU]HWZyUVWZR SU]H
WZyUVWZD ]ERĪRZRPá\QDUVNLHJR L PDNDURQRZHJR RUD] SU]HWZyUVWZD PLĊVD
F]HUZRQHJRLU\E1DMZROQLHM]DFKRG]Lá\RQHZSU]\SDGNXSURGXNFML]EyĪWU]R
G\FKOHZQHMLE\GáDPLĊVQHJR$XWRU]\SU]\]QDOLĪHGRSRNRQDQLDMHVWMHV]F]H
GXĪ\G\VWDQVRUJDQL]DF\MQ\LWHFKQRORJLF]Q\DJáyZQ\PSUREOHPHPMHVWQDG
PLDU PRF\ SURGXNF\MQ\FK SU]HWZyUVWZD Z\VRNLH REFLąĪHQLH NRV]WDPL PDMąW
NRZ\PLZ\VRNDSUDFRFKáRQQRĞüMDNUyZQLHĪZ\VRNLHNRV]W\VSU]HGDĪ\Z\QL
NDMąFH ] FKĊFL XWU]\PDQLD V]HURNLHJR DVRUW\PHQWX D ]DWHP ZLHOX NDQDáyZ
G\VWU\EXFMLUyZQRF]HĞQLH=GUXJLHMVWURQ\VLHFLKDQGORZHGRNRQDá\V]\ENLHJR
SRVWĊSXZRUJDQL]DFMLKDQGOXZHIHNFLHF]HJRLFKXG]LDáZVSU]HGDĪ\GHWDOLF]
QHMVWDOHURĞQLH
: QDMQRZV]\P ] Z\PLHQLRQ\FK EDGDĔ +DPXOF]XN L LQ >@ DQDOL]R
ZDOLQDWRPLDVWZ]JOĊGQHUR]VWĊS\FHQRZHZODWDFKGODSURGXN
WyZSRFKRG]ąF\FK]QDVWĊSXMąF\FKU\QNyZ]ERĪDLSURGXNW\]ERĪRZHPLĊVR
ZRáRZH PLĊVR ZLHSU]RZH PLĊVR GURELRZH POHNR L SURGXNW\ POHF]QH MDMD
U]HSDNLWáXV]F]HURĞOLQQHFXNLHU3U]HGPLRWHPSRJáĊELRQHMDQDOL]\E\á\WHQ
GHQFMH ZDKDQLD F\NOLF]QH ZDKDQLD VH]RQRZH RUD] REVHUZDFMH QLHW\SRZH
:]JOĊGQH UR]VWĊS\ FHQRZH SU]\MPRZDá\ ZDUWRĞFL QDMZ\ĪV]H GOD VHUD *RXGD
PDVáDFKOHEDĪ\WQLHJRLPDUJDU\Q\SRZ\ĪHMF]\OLUR]VWĊSFHQRZ\VWDQRZL
SRQDGNURWQRĞüFHQ\NLORJUDPDVXURZFDQDWRPLDVWQDMQLĪV]H ±GODMDMFX
NUXLSDWURV]RQ\FKWXV]HNNXUF]ĊF\FKSRQLĪHMF]\OLUR]VWĊSFHQRZ\VWDQRZL
PQLHM QLĪ FHQ\ NLORJUDPD VXURZFD -DN ZLGDü UR]ELHĪQRĞFL WH RND]Dá\
VLĊE\üJáyZQLHHIHNWHPUyĪQLFZPRĪOLZRĞFLDFKWUDQVIRUPDFMLSURGXNWyZSU]H]
$QDOL]RZDQRQDVWĊSXMąFHUR]VWĊS\PąNDSV]HQQDSV]HQLFDFKOHEĪ\WQLĪ\WRV]SRQGHUZR
áRZ\ ] NRĞFLąĪ\ZLHF ZRáRZ\ PLĊVR ZRáRZH EH] NRĞFL ] XGĨFDĪ\ZLHF ZRáRZ\ ĪHEHUND
ZLHSU]RZHĪ\ZLHF ZLHSU]RZ\ V]\QND ZLHSU]RZD JRWRZDQDĪ\ZLHF ZLHSU]RZ\ WXV]NL NXU
F]ĊFH SDWURV]RQHĪ\ZLHF GURELRZ\ SROĊGZLFD GURELRZDĪ\ZLHF GURELRZ\ POHNR
8+7POHNRPDVáRPOHNRVHU*RXGDPOHNRMDMDZGHWDOXMDMDZ]DNáDG]LHSDNXMąF\PROHM
U]HSDNRZ\U]HSDNPDUJDU\QDU]HSDNFXNLHUZGHWDOXFXNLHUQDJLHáG]LHZ/RQG\QLH
SU]HWZyUFyZSU]HWZRU]HQLH]PLDQDIRUP\SU]HFKRZ\ZDQLH]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHP
VSHFMDOQ\FKWHFKQRORJLL:PQLHMV]\PVWRSQLX]DOHĪDá\RQHQDWRPLDVWRGNRQ
NUHWQHJRU\QNXQSQDU\QNXPOHNDLSURGXNWyZPOHF]Q\FKUR]VWĊSZSU]\SDG
NXPOHND8+7ZDQDOL]RZDQ\PRNUHVLHZDKDáVLĊZJUDQLFDFKQDWRPLDVW
ZSU]\SDGNXPDVáDZJUDQLFDFK
:]JOĊGQHUR]VWĊS\FHQRZHGODDQDOL]RZDQ\FKSURGXNWyZSRGOHJDá\SU]\
W\PPQLHMV]\POXEZLĊNV]\PZDKDQLRP1DMZLĊNV]ąDPSOLWXGą]PLDQPDNVL
PXP PLQXV PLQLPXP ZDUWRĞFL UR]VWĊSyZ FHFKRZDá\ VLĊ UR]VWĊS\ GOD FKOHED
Ī\WQLHJRRNVHUD*RXGDRNRUD]PDVáDLPDUJDU\Q\RNQDMPQLHM
V]ą±SDWURV]RQ\FKWXV]HNNXUF]ĊF\FKLV]SRQGUDZRáRZHJR]NRĞFLąSRQLĪHM
&RFLHNDZHZLĊNV]RĞüER]V]HUHJyZF]DVRZ\FKDQDOL]RZDQ\FK
Z]JOĊGQ\FKUR]VWĊSyZFHQRZ\FKFHFKRZDáRVLĊLVWQLHQLHP SHZQ\FKWUHQGyZ
5R]VWĊS WHQ XWU]\P\ZDá VLĊ QD VWDELOQ\P SR]LRPLH Z SU]\SDGNX SURGXNWyZ
] U\QNX ]ERĪD L SURGXNWyZ ]ERĪRZ\FK RUD] PLĊVD ZLHSU]RZHJR MDN UyZQLHĪ
PDVáD7UHQGPDOHMąF\PLDáPLHMVFHZSU]\SDGNXSURGXNWyZ]U\QNXPLĊVDZR
áRZHJR MDM D WDNĪH SDWURV]RQ\FK WXV]HN NXUF]ĊF\FK QDWRPLDVW URVQąF\ ±
ZSU]\SDGNXSROĊGZLF\GURELRZHMVHUD*RXGDFXNUXRUD]SURGXNWyZ]U\QNX
ROHMyZLWáXV]F]yZURĞOLQQ\FK1LHPRĪQD]DWHPPyZLüRMHGQHMSDQXMąFHMQD
U\QNXSROVNLHMĪ\ZQRĞFLWHQGHQFMLRGQRĞQLHNLHUXQNyZ]PLDQZ]JOĊGQ\FKUR]
VWĊSyZFHQRZ\FK
3RQDGWRZNDĪG\P]DQDOL]RZDQ\FKV]HUHJyZGRVWU]HĪRQRLVWQLHQLHUyĪQHM
GáXJRĞFL ZDKDĔ F\NOLF]Q\FK NWyUH Z\QLNDMą ] ZLĊNV]HM ]PLHQQRĞFL FHQ UROQL
F]\FKQLĪFHQGHWDOLF]Q\FK)DNWLĪFHQ\GHWDOLF]QHSRGOHJDMąPQLHMV]\PZDKD
QLRPR]QDF]DUyZQLHĪĪH]PLHQQRĞüFHQUROQ\FKQLHMHVWFDáNRZLFLHSU]HQRV]R
QDQDFHQ\GHWDOLF]QHFRPRĪHZ\QLNDü]Z\VRNLHJRSR]LRPXNRQNXUHQF\MQRĞFL
U\QNyZ GHWDOLF]Q\FK :DKDQLD FHQ GHWDOLF]Q\FK Vą W\P PQLHMV]H LP ZLĊNV]\
VWRSLHĔSU]HWZRU]HQLDSURGXNWXFRPRĪHUyZQLHĪR]QDF]DüLĪSURGXFHQFLZUH
DNFMLQDZ]URVWFHQVXURZFyZVLĊJDMąSRGRVWRVRZDQLDGRW\F]ąFHWHFKQRORJLL
: DQDOL]RZDQ\FK RNUHVDFK GRFKRG]LáR UyZQLHĪ GR ]PLDQ R FKDUDNWHU]H
VWUXNWXUDOQ\PSU]HMDZLDMąF\FKVLĊZSRVWDFLVNRNRZ\FK]PLDQUR]VWĊSyZ0R
Ją RQH Z\QLNDü ]DUyZQR ]H ]PLDQ FHQ UROQ\FK MDN L FHQ HQHUJLL Z\VRNRĞFL
VWDZHNSRGDWNRZ\FKF]\WHĪLQQ\FKNRV]WyZ1DU\QNXUROQRĪ\ZQRĞFLRZ\P
NWyU\ MHVW U\QNLHP JOREDOQ\P GRFKRG]L GR QLFK GRV\ü F]ĊVWR -DN ]DXZDĪ\OL
+DPXOF]XNLLQ>@QDZ\VWĊSRZDQLHREVHUZDFMLQLHW\SRZ\FKZSU]\SDGNX
V]HUHJX Z]JOĊGQ\FK UR]VWĊSyZ FHQRZ\FK QD U\QNX ]EyĪ L SURGXNWyZ ]ERĪR
Z\FK Z RNUHVLH ZSá\Z PLDá\ WUZDáH ]PLDQ\ V\WXDFML SRS\WRZR
SRGDĪRZHM RUD] ]PLDQD Z RSRGDWNRZDQLX Ī\ZQRĞFL L VXURZFyZ UROQ\FK
9$71DU\QNXPLĊVDZRáRZHJRGRQDJáHJRVSDGNXUR]VWĊSyZGRV]áRQDVNX
WHNFKRURE\ %6( GR QDJáHJR Z]URVWX ± QD VNXWHN ]PLDQ UHODFML FHQRZ\FK SR
ZVWąSLHQLX GR 8( : SU]\SDGNX POHND 8+7 ]H Z]JOĊGX QD GXĪą V]W\ZQRĞü
FHQ WHJR SURGXNWX GR QLHW\SRZ\FK ]PLDQ UR]VWĊSyZ GRFKRG]LáR JáyZQLH QD
VNXWHN JZDáWRZQ\FK ]PLDQ FHQ POHND QDWRPLDVW Z SU]\SDGNX VHUD L PDVáD
]PLDQ\QLHW\SRZH]ZLą]DQHE\á\]ZVWąSLHQLHPGR8(RUD]Z]URVWHPFHQĞZLD
WRZ\FKSRGNRQLHFURNX